A 2-D liquid separations/mass mapping method for interlysate comparison of ovarian cancers

A two-dimensional liquid phase separation of proteins from whole cell lysates coupled on-line to an electrospray-ionization time-of-flight (ESI-TOF) mass spectrometer (MS) is used to map the protein content of ovarian surface epithelial cells (OSE) and an ovarian carcinoma-derived cell line (ES2). The two dimensions involve the use of liquid isoelectric focusing as the first phase and nonporous silica reversed-phase HPLC as the second phase of separation. Accurate molecular weight (MW) values are then obtained upon the basis of ESI-TOFMS so that an image of isolectric point (pI) versus MW analogous to 2-D gel electrophoresis is produced. The accurate MW together with the pI fraction and corresponding hydrophobicity (%B) are used to tag each protein so that protein expression can be compared in interlysate studies. Each protein is also identified on the basis of matrix-assisted laser desorption-ionization (MALDI) TOFMS peptide mapping and intact MW so that a standard map is produced against which other cell lines can be compared. Quantitative changes in protein expression are measured in these interlysate comparisons using internal standards in the on-line ESI-TOFMS process. In the ovarian epithelial cell lines under study, it is shown that in the three pI fractions chosen for detailed analysis, over 50 unique proteins can be detected per fraction, of which 40% can be identified from web-based databases. It is also shown that when using an accurate MW to compare proteins in the OSE versus ovarian cancer sample, there are proteins highly expressed in cancer cells but not in normal cells. In addition, many of the proteins in the cancer sample appear to be down-regulated, as compared to the normal cells. This two-dimensional (2-D) liquid/mass mapping method may provide a means of studying proteins in interlysate comparisons not readily available by other methods.     

A comparison of drug-treated and untreated HCT-116 human colon adenocarcinoma cells using a 2-D liquid separation mapping method based upon chromatofocusing PI fractionation

A multidimensional chromatographic 2-D liquid-phase separation method has been developed for differential display of proteins from cell lysates and applied to a comparison of protein expression between Peninsularinone-treated and untreated HCT-116 human colon adenocarcinoma cells. The method involves fractionation according to pI using chromatofocusing with analytical columns in the first dimension followed by separation of the proteins in each pI fraction using nonporous reversed-phase HPLC. A 2-D map of the protein content of each cell line based upon pI versus hydrophobicity as detected by UV absorption was generated and a differential display map indicating the presence of up- or downregulated proteins displayed using ProteoVue and DeltaVue software. Using this method, > 1000 protein bands could be detected in 0.2 pH fractions over a pH range of 4-7. In addition, the liquid eluent from the separation was directed on-line into an electrospray TOF-MS to obtain an accurate molecular weight of the intact proteins. An accurate molecular weight together with the peptide map was used to obtain protein identification using database searching. The method has been shown to have high reproducibility for quantitative differential display analysis of interlysate comparisons, generation of accurate protein identifications, and ease of data interpretation. It has been used herein to identify proteins that change as a function of drug treatment. The relative simplicity of the current procedure and the potential for full automation will make this technique an essential tool in future proteomic studies.     

An automated on-line multidimensional HPLC system for protein and peptide mapping with integrated sample preparation

A comprehensive on-line two-dimensional 2D-HPLC system with integrated sample preparation was developed for the analysis of proteins and peptides with a molecular weight below 20 kDa. The system setup provided fast separations and high resolving power and is considered to be a complementary technique to 2D gel electrophoresis in proteomics. The on-line system reproducibly resolved approximately 1000 peaks within the total analysis time of 96 min and avoided sample losses by off-line sample handling. The low-molecular-weight target analytes were separated from the matrix using novel silica-based restricted access materials (RAM) with ion exchange functionalities. The size-selective sample fractionation step was followed by anion or cation exchange chromatography as the first dimension. The separation mechanism in the subsequent second dimension employed hydrophobic interactions using short reversed-phase (RP) columns. A new column-switching technique, including four parallel reversed-phase columns, was employed in the second dimension for on-line fractionation and separation. Gradient elution and UV detection of two columns were performed simultaneously while loading the third and regenerating the fourth column. The total integrated workstation was operated in an unattended mode. Selected peaks were collected and analyzed off-line by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry. The system was applied to protein mapping of biological samples of human hemofiltrate as well as of cell lysates originating from a human fetal fibroblast cell line, demonstrating it to be a viable alternative to 2D gel electrophoresis for mapping peptides and small proteins.     

Analysis of high-density lipoprotein apolipoproteins recovered from specific immobilized pH gradient gel pI domains by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry

The proteins associated with the circulating lipoproteins in the blood function not only for mediating lipid metabolism but also for maintaining structural stability of the micellelike structure. Any modifications of these proteins, by mutation or posttranslational modification, could compromise the function of these proteins and contribute to the development of cardiovascular disease. Because of the presence of extensive lipophilic domains, these proteins, when recovered from the lipoprotein particle (apolipoproteins) present an analytical challenge because of low solubility and proclivity toward aggregate formation. Our goal is to characterize these proteins by a combination of high-accuracy pI measurement coupled with MALDI analysis. In this report, we demonstrate the high resolution of immobilized pH gradient isoelectric focusing (IPG-IEF) for the analysis of these apolipoproteins isolated from serum HDL collected from a density gradient ultracentrifugation-based separation. The IPG separation of the HDL apolipoproteins was imaged and combined with digital analysis to produce a detailed pI profile of the apolipoproteins in the high-density lipoprotein (HDL) fraction. This is the first time that a high-resolution pI profile has been obtained for the HDL apolipoproteins. The feasibility of linking the pI profile to a MALDI-based molecular weight determination was achieved by incorporating passive elution of the intact proteins from the IPG gel with a four-component solvent mixture that solved the problem of recovery of the apolipoproteins from the IPG matrix. Twenty-five bands were observed in the pI profile. A survey analysis of 12 of these bands by MALDI indicated that they were associated with the known HDL apolipoproteins. While there is considerable overlap in the pI profiles of the apolipoproteins, linking the analysis with a MALDI-based second dimension in m/z is shown to be an efficient method to characterize this complex mixture of apolipoproteins.     

Protein pI shifts due to posttranslational modifications in the separation and characterization of proteins

Proteins from breast cancer cell lines are characterized using a 2-D liquid separation technique in which protein pI is used as the first-dimension separation parameter. To effect this protein pI separation, chromatofocusing(CF) is employed whereby a pH gradient is generated on-column using a weak anion exchange medium with the intact proteins fractionated and collected every 0.2 pH unit. It is demonstrated that the pI for expressed intact proteins as generated by CF is an important parameter for identification and characterization of the actual protein modifications occurring in the cancer cell. For most proteins, the experimentally determined pI is very close to that predicted by the databases. In other cases, however, where the pI is observed to be shifted from the expected value, it is shown that this shift is often correlated to protein modifications. The modifications that cause such shifts include truncations and deletions often observed in cancer cells or phosphorylations that can shift the pI by several pH units. It is also shown that the effects of phosphorylation on the observed shift can vary depending upon the protein and the amount of phosphorylation. Moreover, large changes in the pI are often observed for proteins with a pI above 7.0 upon phosphorylation, whereas little change is observed for proteins with a pI of approximately 5.0. The expressed protein's pI value thus becomes an important parameter together with the intact MW value, peptide map, and MS/MS results for identification of the presence and type of posttranslational modifications occurring in the cancer cell.     

Rapid profiling of induced proteins in bacteria using MALDI-TOF mass spectrometric detection of nonporous RP HPLC-separated whole cell lysates.

A method for rapid profiling of water-soluble proteins from whole cell lysates has been developed using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) time-of-flight mass spectrometry (TOFMS) following separation by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP HPLC). Rapid separation of proteins from cell lysates was achieved using columns packed with C18 nonporous (NP) silica beads. Using this method, the whole cell lysate water-soluble proteins of E. coli were separated in under 15 min. A method using two columns in series at different temperatures was used in order to provide high loadability without loss of separation efficiency. The nonporous packing in the columns provided for high recovery. Eluting fractions were collected and analyzed by MALDI-TOFMS to determine the molecular weights and peptide maps of the proteins. These methods provided for the rapid screening and identification of proteins from E. coli where the response of E. coli to L-arabinose induction was studied. In this work, it is demonstrated that NP RP HPLC with MALDI-TOFMS detection may serve as a rapid means of detecting and identifying changes in bacterial protein expression due to external stimuli.     

Development of non-gel-based two-dimensional separation of intact proteins by an on-line hyphenation of capillary isoelectric focusing and hollow fiber flow field-flow fractionation

A rapid, non-gel-based, on-line, two-dimensional separation method is introduced for proteome analysis. Protein fractionation was carried out by first exploiting the differences in their respective isoelectric points (pI) in a Teflon capillary using isoelectric focusing (IEF), followed by a molecular weight (MW)-based separation in a hollow fiber by flow field-flow fractionation (FlFFF). The method developed here (CIEF-HFFlFFF) may be a powerful alternative to two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, which is currently used for the separation and purification of proteins. In CIEF-HFFlFFF, proteins can be collected as a fraction of a certain pI and MW interval without being denatured. Additionally, the ampholyte solution is simultaneously removed during separation in the hollow fiber, and the overall process time is significantly reduced. This method was applied to a human urinary proteome sample, leading to the identification of 114 proteins with the subsequent off-line use of nanoflow liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry after the tryptic digestion of each collected protein fraction.     

Comparison of two-dimensional fractionation techniques for shotgun proteomics

Two-dimensional (2D) fractionation is a commonly used tool to increase dynamic range and proteome coverage for bottom-up, shotgun proteomics. However, there are few reports comparing the relative separation efficiencies of 2D methodologies using low-microgram sample quantities. In order to systematically evaluate 2D separation techniques, we fractionated microgram quantities of E. coli protein extract by seven different methods. The first dimension of separation was performed with either reversed-phase high-pressure liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC), gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE), or strong cation exchange (SCX-HPLC). The second dimension consisted of a standard reversed-phase capillary HPLC coupled to an electrospray ionization quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometer for tandem mass spectrometric analysis. The overall performance and relative fractionation efficiencies of each technique were assessed by comparing the total number of proteins identified by each method. The protein-level RP-HPLC and the high-pH RP-HPLC peptide-level separations performed the best, identifying 281 and 266 proteins, respectively. The online pH variance SCX and the SDS-PAGE returned modest performances with 178 and 139 proteins identified, respectively. The offline SCX had the worst performance with 81 proteins identified. We also examined various chromatographic factors that contribute to separation efficiency, including resolving power, orthogonality, and sample loss.     

Objective data alignment and chemometric analysis of comprehensive two-dimensional separations with run-to-run peak shifting on both dimensions.

Data from comprehensive two-dimensional (2-D) separation techniques, such as comprehensive 2-D gas chromatography (GC x GC), liquid chromatography/liquid chromatography (LC x LC) and liquid chromatography/ capillary electrophoresis (LC x CE) can be readily analyzed by various chemometric methods to increase chemical analysis capabilities. A retention time alignment, preprocessing method is presented that objectively corrects for run-to-run retention time variations on both separation dimensions of comprehensive 2-D separations prior to application of chemometric data analysis algorithms. The 2-D alignment method corrects for run-to-run shifting of a sample data matrix relative to a standard data matrix on both separation time axes in an independent, stepwise fashion. After 2-D alignment, the generalized rank annihilation method (GRAM) is successfully applied, substantiating the performance of the alignment method. The alignment method should have important implications, because most 2-D separation techniques exhibit, in the context of chemometric data analysis, considerable run-to-run retention time shifting on both dimensions. Even when there are only three to four points/peak, that is, with three to four separations on the second dimension (column 2) per peak width from the first dimension (column 1), the 2-D alignment coupled with GRAM provides dependable analyte peak identification capabilities and adequate quantitative precision for unresolved analyte peaks. Thus, the 2-D alignment algorithm is applicable to lower data density conditions, which broadens the scope of chemometric analysis to high-speed 2-D separations.     

Online nanoflow reversed phase-strong anion exchange-reversed phase liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry platform for efficient and in-depth proteome sequence analysis of complex organisms

The dynamic range of protein expression in complex organisms coupled with the stochastic nature of discovery-driven tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) analysis continues to impede comprehensive sequence analysis and often provides only limited information for low-abundance proteins. High-performance fractionation of proteins or peptides prior to mass spectrometry analysis can mitigate these effects, though achieving an optimal combination of automation, reproducibility, separation peak capacity, and sample yield remains a significant challenge. Here we demonstrate an automated nanoflow 3-D liquid chromatography (LC)-MS/MS platform based on high-pH reversed phase (RP), strong anion exchange (SAX), and low-pH reversed phase (RP) separation stages for analysis of complex proteomes. We observed that RP-SAX-RP outperformed RP-RP for analysis of tryptic peptides derived from Escherichia coli and enabled identification of proteins present at a level of 50 copies per cell in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, corresponding to an estimated detection limit of 500 amol, from 40 μg of total lysate on a low-resolution 3-D ion trap mass spectrometer. A similar study performed on a LTQ-Orbitrap yielded over 4000 unique proteins from 5 μg of total yeast lysate analyzed in a single, 101 fraction RP-SAX-RP LC-MS/MS acquisition, providing an estimated detection limit of 65 amol for proteins expressed at 50 copies per cell.     

Differential screening and mass mapping of proteins from premalignant and cancer cell lines using nonporous reversed-phase HPLC coupled with mass spectrometric analysis

Nonporous (NPS) RP-HPLC has been used to rapidly separate proteins from whole cell lysates of human breast cell lines. The nonporous separation involves the use of hard-sphere silica beads of 1.5-microm diameter coated with C18, which can be used to separate proteins ranging from 5 to 90 kDa. Using only 30-40 microg of total protein, the protein molecular weights are detectable on-line using an ESI-oaTOF MS. Of hundreds of proteins detected in this mass range, approxinately 75-80 are more highly expressed. The molecular weight profiles can be displayed as a mass map analogous to a virtual "1-D gel" and differentially expressed proteins can be compared by image analysis. The separated proteins can also be detected by UV absorption and differentially expressed proteins quantified. The eluting proteins can be collected in the liquid phase and the molecular weight and peptide maps determined by MALDI-TOF MS for identification. It is demonstrated that the expressed protein profiles change during neoplastic progression and that many oncoproteins are readily detected. It is also shown that the response of premalignant cancer cells to estradiol can be rapidly screened by this method, demonstrating significant changes in response to an external agent. Ultimately, the proteins can be studied by peptide mapping to search for posttranslational modifications of the oncoproteins accompanying progression.     

Proteomic analysis with integrated multiple dimensional liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry based on elution of ion exchange column using pH steps

A novel integrated multidimensional liquid chromatography (IMDL) method is demonstrated for the separation of peptide mixtures by two-dimensional HPLC coupled with ion trap mass spectrometry. The method uses an integrated column, containing both strong cation exchange and reversed-phase sections for two-dimensional liquid chromatography. The peptide mixture was fractionated by a pH step using a series of pH buffers, followed by reversed-phase chromatography. Since no salt was used during separation, the integrated multidimensional liquid chromatography can be directly connected to mass spectrometry for peptide analysis. The pH buffers were injected from an autosampler, and the entire process can be carried out on a one-dimensional liquid chromatography system. In a single analysis, the IMDL system, coupled with linear ion trap mass spectrometry, identified more than 2000 proteins in mouse liver. The peptides were eluted according to their pI distribution. The resolution of the pH fractionation is approximately 0.5 pH unit. The method has low overlapping across pH fractions, good resolution of peptide mixture, and good correlation of peptide pIs with pH steps. This method provides a technique for large-scale protein identification using existing one-dimensional HPLC systems.     

A proteome strategy for fractionating proteins and peptides using continuous free-flow electrophoresis coupled off-line to reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography

Extensive prefractionation is now considered to be a necessary prerequisite for the comprehensive analysis of complex proteomes where the dynamic range of protein abundances can vary from approximately 10(6) for cells to approximately 10(10) for tissues such as blood. Here, we describe a high-resolution 2D protein separation system that uses a continuous free-flow electrophoresis (FFE) device to fractionate complex protein mixtures by solution-phase isoelectric focusing (IEF) into 96 well-defined pools, each separated by approximately 0.02-0.10 pH unit depending on the gradient created, followed by rapid (approximately 6 min per analysis) reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC) of each FFE pool. Fractionated proteins are readily visualized in a virtual 2D format using software that plots protein loci, pI in the first dimension and relative hydrophobicity (i.e., RP-HPLC retention time) in the second dimension. By coupling a diode-array detector in line with a multiwavelength fluorescence detector, separated proteins can be monitored in the RP-HPLC eluent by both UV absorbance and intrinsic fluorescence simultaneously from a single experiment. Triplicate analyses of standard proteins using a pH 3-10 gradient conducted over a 3-day period revealed a high system reproducibility with a SD of 0.57 (0.05 pH unit) within the FFE pools and 0.003 (0.18 s) for protein retention times in the second-dimension RP-HPLC step. In addition, we demonstrate that the FFE-IEF/RP-HPLC separation strategy can also be applied to complex mixtures of low molecular weight compounds such as peptides. With the facile ability to measure the pH of the isoelectric focused pools, peptide pI values can be estimated and used to qualify peptide identifications made using either MS/MS sequencing approaches or pI discriminated peptide mass fingerprinting. The calculated peak capacity of this 2D liquid-based FFE-IEF/RP-HPLC system is 6720.     

Virtual 2-D gel electrophoresis: visualization and analysis of the E. coli proteome by mass spectrometry

Mass spectrometric surface analysis of isoelectric focusing gels provides an ultrasensitive approach to proteome analysis. This "virtual 2-D gel" approach, in which mass spectrometry is substituted for the size-based separation of SDS-PAGE, provides advantages in mass resolution and accuracy over classical 2-D gels and can be readily automated. Protein identities can be postulated from molecular mass (+/-0.1-0.2% for proteins of <50 kDa in size) and pI (+/-0.3 pH unit) and confirmed by MALDI in-source decay of the intact protein (providing sequence spanning up to 43 residues) or by peptide mass mapping following gel-wide chemical cleavage. Additionally, posttranslational modifications such as fatty acid acylation can be detected by the mass-resolved heterogeneity of component hydrocarbon chains. Sensitivity was evaluated by comparing the number of proteins detected by this method to equivalently loaded silver-stained 2-D gels. In the 5.7-6.0 pH range, E. coli is predicted to contain 435 proteins; virtual 2-D gels found 250 proteins ranging from >2 to <120 kDa in size present at levels to tens of femtomoles, as compared to the 100 proteins found by silver-staining 2-D gels. Extrapolating this result to the total theoretical proteome suggests that this technology is capable of detecting over 2500 E. coli proteins.     

Increasing the number of analyzable peaks in comprehensive two-dimensional separations through chemometrics

Comprehensive two-dimensional (2-D) separations are emerging as powerful tools for the analysis of complex samples. The substantially larger peak capacity for a given length of time relative to 1-D separations is a well-known benefit of comprehensive 2-D separation methods. Unfortunately, with complex samples, the probability of peak overlap in 2-D separations is still quite high. This is especially true if one desires to speed up the analysis by reducing the run time and, thus, by reducing the resolving power along the first dimension separation. Chemometric methods hold considerable promise to overcome the limitations brought upon by the likelihood of peak overlap. Thus, chemometric methods should be able to effectively extend the resolving power of 2-D separation methods. In this paper, the theoretical enhancement provided by application of the generalized rank annihilation method (GRAM) for the analysis of unresolved peaks in comprehensive 2-D separations is carefully modeled and critically evaluated. First, Monte Carlo simulations are used to determine the conditions where the use of GRAM results in the successful analysis of unresolved peaks. A wide range of experimental conditions and performance criteria are modeled, typical to many available 2-D separation methods, including analyte/interference peak height ratio, first- and second-dimension resolutions, signal-to noise ratio, injection volume reproducibility, and run-to-run retention time reproducibility. Essentially, a wide range of experimental conditions and performance criteria are found to provide reliable data amenable to GRAM analysis. The information gleaned from this first set of simulations is then used in conjunction with Monte Carlo simulations of comprehensive 2-D separations. For these simulated 2-D separations, the total number of analyzable peaks when using GRAM was determined and found to be substantially better than using only traditional quantitative methods such as peak integration or height. For example, it was determined that the use of GRAM increases the average number of analyzable peaks by a factor of 2 for 2-D separations in which the peak capacity is 67% occupied by randomly distributed peaks. The results of the studies are general, and the use of GRAM should increase the number of analyzable peaks for all forms of comprehensive 2-D separations.     

Integration of isoelectric focusing with parallel sodium dodecyl sulfate gel electrophoresis for multidimensional protein separations in a plastic microfluidic [correction of microfludic] network

An integrated protein concentration/separation system, combining non-native isoelectric focusing (IEF) with sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) gel electrophoresis on a polymer microfluidic chip, is reported. The system provides significant analyte concentration and extremely high resolving power for separated protein mixtures. The ability to introduce and isolate multiple separation media in a plastic microfluidic network is one of two key requirements for achieving multidimensional protein separations. The second requirement lies in the quantitative transfer of focused proteins from the first to second separation dimensions without significant loss in the resolution acquired from the first dimension. Rather than sequentially sampling protein analytes eluted from IEF, focused proteins are electrokinetically transferred into an array of orthogonal microchannels and further resolved by SDS gel electrophoresis in a parallel and high-throughput format. Resolved protein analytes are monitored using noncovalent, environment-sensitive, fluorescent probes such as Sypro Red. In comparison with covalently labeling proteins, the use of Sypro staining during electrophoretic separations not only presents a generic detection approach for the analysis of complex protein mixtures such as cell lysates but also avoids additional introduction of protein microheterogeneity as the result of labeling reaction. A comprehensive 2-D protein separation is completed in less than 10 min with an overall peak capacity of approximately 1700 using a chip with planar dimensions of as small as 2 cm x 3 cm. Significant enhancement in the peak capacity can be realized by simply raising the density of microchannels in the array, thereby increasing the number of IEF fractions further analyzed in the size-based separation dimension.     

pH/organic solvent double-gradient reversed-phase HPLC

A new reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatographic (RP HPLC) procedure has been theoretically and experimentally established. The approach consists of the simultaneous development of a gradient of pH and of the organic modifier in the mobile phase. The proposed theoretical model of the pH/organic solvent double-gradient RP HPLC allows determination of both pK(a) and the lipophilicity parameter of the ionized and the nonionized form of the analyte and prediction of the retention times at specific separation conditions as well as bandwidth for all analytes. The model provides a rational basis for optimization of separation of ionizable analytes at any given chromatographic mode and analysis conditions. In addition, in the case of pH/organic solvent double-gradient RP HPLC, a compression of analyte peak and its reduced tailing can be expected.     

Capillary isoelectric focusing-based multidimensional concentration/separation platform for proteome analysis

An integrated proteome concentration/separation approach involving on-line combination of capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) with capillary reversed-phase liquid chromatography (CRPLC) is developed for providing significant analyte concentration and extremely high resolving power toward protein and peptide mixtures. Upon completion of analyte focusing, the self-sharpening effect greatly restricts analyte diffusion and contributes to analyte stacking in narrowly focused bands with a concentration factor of approximately 240. In addition to analyte focusing, CIEF as the first separation dimension resolves proteins/peptides on the basis of their differences in pI and offers greater resolving power than that achieved in strong cation exchange chromatography. The grouping of two highly resolving and completely orthogonal separation techniques of CIEF and CRPLC, together with analyte focusing and concentration, significantly enhances the dynamic range and sensitivity of conventional mass spectrometry toward the identification of low-abundance proteins. The CIEF-based multidimensional separation/concentration platform enables the identification of a greater number of yeast soluble proteins than methods presented in the literature, yet requires a protein loading of only 9.6 microg. This protein loading is 2-3 orders of magnitude lower than those employed by the reported non-gel-based proteome techniques. The distribution of a codon adaptation index value for identified yeast proteins approximates to that predicted for the entire yeast proteome and supports the capability of CIEF-based proteome separation technology for achieving comprehensive proteome analysis. By reducing the inner diameter of chromatography columns from 180 microm to 100 microm, the required protein loading is further decreased from 9.6 microg to 960 ng, illustrating the potential usage of this proteome technology for the analysis of protein profiles within small cell populations or limited tissue samples.     

An automated orthogonal two-dimensional liquid chromatograph

A simple approach to two-dimensional liquid chromatography has been developed by coupling columns of different selectivity using a 12-port, dual-position valve and a standard HPLC system. The valve at the junction of the two columns enables continuous, periodic sampling (injection) of the primary column eluent onto the secondary column. The separation in the primary dimension is comparable to conventional HPLC, whereas the secondary column separation is fast, lasting several seconds. The high-speed separation in the secondary dimension enables the primary column eluent to be sampled with fidelity onto the secondary column throughout the chromatographic run. One might expect a coupled column liquid chromatography system operating in reverse-phase mode to be strongly correlated and, hence, inefficient. However, by applying a solvent gradient in the primary dimension and by progressively incrementing the solvent strength in the secondary dimension (tuning), the inefficiency or cross correlation between the two dimensions is minimized. In a tuned two-dimensional system, the influence of primary column retention (usually hydrophobicity) is minimal on secondary column retention. This enables subtle differences in component interaction with the two stationary phases to dominate the secondary column retention. The peaks are randomly dispersed over a retention plane rather than along a diagonal, resulting in an orthogonal separation. The peak capacity is multiplicative, and each component has a unique pair of retention times, enabling positive identification. In addition, the location of the component provides two independent measures of molecular properties. The 2D-LC system was evaluated by analyzing a test mixture made of some aromatic amines and non-amines on different secondary columns (ODS-AQ/ODS monolith, ODS/amino, ODS/cyano). The relative location of sample components in the two-dimensional plane varied significantly with change in secondary column. Among the secondary columns, the amino and cyano columns offered the most complementary separation, with the retention order of several components reversed in the secondary dimension. The theoretical peak capacity of the 2D-LC system was around 450 for a separation lasting 30 min. A 2D-LC system involving amino and cyano columns resulted in a high-speed separation of the test mixture, with most of the chemical components resolved within a few minutes.     

Zwitterionic hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (ZIC-HILIC and ZIC-cHILIC) provide high resolution separation and increase sensitivity in proteome analysis

The complexity of peptide mixtures that are analyzed in proteomics necessitates fractionation by multidimensional separation approaches prior to mass spectrometric analysis. In this work, we introduce and evaluate hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) based strategies for the separation of complex peptide mixtures. The two zwitterionic HILIC materials (ZIC-HILIC and ZIC-cHILIC) chosen for this work differ in the spatial orientation of the positive and negative charged groups. Online experiments revealed a pH-independent resolving power for the ZIC-cHILIC resin while ZIC-HILIC showed a decrease in resolving power at an acidic pH. Subsequently, we extensively evaluated the performances of ZIC-HILIC and ZIC-cHILIC as first dimension in an off-line two-dimensional liquid chromatography (2D-LC) strategy in combination with reversed phase (RP), with respect to peptide separation efficiency and how the retention time correlates with a number of peptide physicochemical properties. Both resins allowed the identification of more than 20,000 unique peptides corresponding to over 3500 proteins in each experimental condition from a remarkably low (1.5 μg) amount of starting material of HeLa lysate digestion. The resulting data allows the drawing of a comprehensive picture regarding ZIC- and ZIC-cHILIC peptide separation characteristics. Furthermore, the extent of protein identifications observed from such a level of material demonstrates that HILIC can rival or surpass traditional multidimensional strategies employed in proteomics.