Modelling Environmental Degradation in EA9321-Bonded Joints using a Progressive Damage Failure Model

A progressive cohesive failure model has been proposed to predict the residual strength of adhesively bonded joints using a moisture-dependent critical equivalent plastic strain for the adhesive. Joints bonded with a ductile adhesive (EA9321) were studied for a range of environmental degradations. A single, moisture-dependent failure parameter, the critical strain, was calibrated using an aged, mixed-mode flexure (MMF) test. The mesh dependence of this parameter was also investigated. The parameter was then used without further modification to model failure in aluminum and composite single-lap joints (SLJ) bonded with the same adhesive. The FEA package ABAQUS was used to implement the coupled mechanical-diffusion analyses required. The elastic-plastic response of the adhesive and the substrates, both obtained from the bulk tensile tests, were incorporated. Both two-dimensional and three-dimensional modelling was undertaken and the results compared. The predicted joint residual strengths agreed well with the corresponding experimental data, and the damage propagation pattern in the adhesive was also predicted correctly. This cohesive failure model provides a simple but reliable method to model environmental degradation in ductile adhesive bonded joints, where failure is predominantly within the adhesive layer.     

The effect of residual strains on the progressive damage modelling of environmentally degraded adhesive joints

This work is concerned with developing numerical modelling techniques for predicting the environmental degradation of adhesively-bonded joints. Associated experimental data are also reported. The moisture-dependent mechanical properties of the adhesive were obtained by testing bulk specimens also exposed to various moisture contents. The diffusion parameters for moisture in the adhesive were determined by carrying out gravimetric experiments on bulk adhesive samples. The moisture-dependent interfacial bond strength of the adhesive system investigated has been determined by testing a mixed mode flexure (MMF) specimen, exposed to obtain various levels of moisture content at the interface. Progressive damage in the joints was modelled with a two-parameter cohesive zone model (CZM). The CZM parameters were determined by correlating the experimental data obtained from the MMF test with results from the numerical simulation. The parameters were then used to predict the response of another configuration, the notched coating adhesion (NCA) specimen. When the residual stresses were neglected in the modelling, the predicted NCA response was seen to be in good agreement with the experimental data. However, initial simulations that included the residual stresses resulted in poor predictions of the NCA response. Creep tests on the saturated adhesive, at the ageing temperature, showed large viscoplastic deformations at low loads. Coupled diffusion-stress modelling, including viscoplastic material properties for the adhesive continuum, showed that the residual stresses for the aged specimens decreased significantly and thus did not contribute strongly to the environmental weakening. Good predictions were then obtained for the NCA tests.     

Low-speed bending impact behavior of adhesively bonded single-lap joints

This study addresses the low-speed impact behavior of adhesively bonded single-lap joints. An explicit dynamic finite element analysis was conducted in order to determine the damage initiation and propagation in the adhesive layers of adhesive single-lap joints under a bending impact load. A cohesive zone model was implemented to predict probable failure initiation and propagation along adhesive–adherend interfaces whereas an elasto-plastic material model was used for the adhesive zone between upper and lower adhesive interfaces as well as the adherends. The effect of the plastic deformation ability of adherend material on the damage mechanism of the adhesive layer was also studied for two aluminum materials Al 2024-T3 and Al 5754-0 having different strength and plastic deformation ability. The effects of impact energy (3 and 11 J) and the overlap length (25 and 40 mm) were also investigated. The predicted contact force-time, contact force-central displacement variations, the damage initiation and propagation mechanism were verified with experimental ones. The SEM and macroscope photographs of the adhesive fracture surfaces were similar to those of the explicit dynamic finite element analysis.     

Modeling of cohesive failure processes in structural adhesive bonded joints

This paper presents an approach to predicting the strength of joints bonded by structural adhesives using a finite element method. The material properties of a commercial structural adhesive and the strength of single-lap joints and scarf joints of aluminum bonded by this adhesive were experimentally measured to provide input for and comparison with the finite element model. Criteria based on maximum strain and stress were used to characterize the cohesive failure within the adhesive and adherend failure observed in this study. In addition to its simplicity, the approach described in this paper is capable of analyzing the entire deformation and failure process of adhesive joints in which different fracture modes may dominate and both adhesive and adherends may undergo inelastic deformation. It was shown that the finite element predictions of the joint strength generally agreed well with the experimental measurements.     

Shear behaviour of structural silicone adhesively bonded steel-glass orthogonal lap joints

This paper outlines an experimental study on the shear behaviour of structural silicone adhesively bonded steel-glass orthogonal lap joints. In the combination of steel plate and glass panel to form a hybrid structural glazing system, bonded joints with structural silicones can provide certain flexibility which relieves stress peaks at critical points of glass panel. The cohesive failure and its related fracture pattern of test joints with varied geometries of adhesives are examined experimentally. It is shown that the presence of two failure modes as discrete voids and macro cracks is closely related to the adhesive thickness. The effects of geometric parameters of adhesives on the joint shear strength are examined. It is demonstrated that the joint shear strengths are increased with increased individual overlap length, reduced adhesive thickness or increased adhesive width while the shear deformation corresponding to maximum shear force is mostly influenced by adhesive thickness. Mechanical contributions for those effects are analyzed accordingly. Finally, an analytical formula allowing for the equilibrium of strain and force on the adhesive and adherend is proposed for the analysis of shear strength. It is demonstrated that calculated normalized shear force ratios predicted by proposed formula agree well with those from experimental results.     

Cohesive Zone Model Characterization of the Adhesive Hysol EA-9394

Abstract

The cohesive zone model approach is attractive for the analysis of failure of adhesively bonded structures. While the numerical implementation of cohesive elements has been well established, there remains a lack of cohesive material data. The present paper contributes to efforts to fill this void. An investigation of crack growth in the widely used structural adhesive Hysol EA-9394 is presented, and the adhesive is characterized by a cohesive zone law. Crack growth experiments were performed on specimens consisting of aluminum adherends bonded by use of the adhesive. Measurements of the surface topography leading reconstruction of fracture processes indicate that plastic deformation is absent during fracture. Thus, the cohesive zone law can directly be determined from the energy release rate and the material separation measured at the initial crack tip. The cohesive zone law is then applied in finite element model to predict crack growth. The predicted strain fields during crack growth are well matched to those obtained by digital image correlation measurements. An independent set of crack growth experiments was performed, and finite element models based on the cohesive law were used to predict the outcome of these experiments. Again good agreement between simulation and experiment was obtained. The results give confidence that the cohesive zone model parameters are transferable to the analysis of structures bonded with the adhesive Hysol EA-9394 in general. A comparison of the cohesive zone law for Hysol EA-9394 demonstrates that this adhesive possesses high strength and moderate toughness. Limits to the transferability regime are discussed.     

Assessments for impact of adhesive properties: modeling strength of metallic single lap joints

Adhesively bonded joints are widely used in a variety of industrial and engineering activities. Their overall strength is dependent on the properties of the adhesives. In the present research, assessments of adhesive properties were performed systematically through defining both strength mixity and energy rate mixity and using them to characterize the overall strength of metallic single lap joints. By means of the cohesive zone model, the adhesive strength mixity was defined as the ratio of the shear and tensile separation strength, and the energy rate mixity was defined as the ratio of the area below the shear cohesive curve and the area below the tensile cohesive curve. For each specified group of mixity parameters, corresponding to the properties of a specified adhesive, the overall strengths and the critical displacements of bonded joints were characterized. A series of strength and energy rate mixities were taken into account in the present calculations. A comparison of the present calculations with some existing experiments was carried out for both brittle and ductile adhesives. Finally, in the calculations presented here, damage initiation and evolution of the adhesive layer were also undertaken. The results showed that the overall strength of the joints was significantly depended on the adhesive properties, which were characterized by the strength and energy rate mixities of the adhesive. Furthermore, the shear adhesive stress components played a dominate role in both the damage initiation and evolution in the adhesives, which were also affected by the overlap length of the joints.     

Single Lap Joints with Rounded Adherend Corners: Experimental Results and Strength Prediction

The objective of the present study was to better understand the effect of the change in the geometry of the adherend corners on the stress distribution in single lap joints and, therefore, on the joint strength. Various degrees of rounding were studied and two different types of adhesives were used: one very brittle and another which had a large plastic deformation. Experimental results on the strength of joints with different degrees of rounding are presented. For joints bonded with brittle adhesives, the effect of the rounded adherend corners is larger than that with ductile adhesives. The strength of joints with brittle adhesives with a large radius adherend corner increases by about 40% compared to that with a sharp adherend corner. It is shown that for joints bonded with brittle adhesives, crack propagation occurs for a short period before it grows into catastrophic failure. However, for ductile adhesives, there is large adhesive yielding and small crack propagation before final failure. Another important feature of joints bonded with ductile adhesives is that there may be more than one crack in the adhesive layer before failure. This makes strength predictions more difficult. The second part of the paper presents an approximate method for predicting the strength of joints bonded with brittle and ductile adhesives, with and without adherend corner rounding. The predictions, based on an average value around the singularity, compare well with the experimental results, especially for joints bonded with ductile adhesives.     

Comparison of cohesive zone elements and smoothed particle hydrodynamics for failure prediction of single lap adhesive joints

This research investigates the use of a meshless smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) method for the prediction of failure in an adhesively bonded single lap joint. A number of issues concerning the SPH based finite element modelling of single lap joints are discussed. The predicted stresses of the SPH finite element model are compared with the results of a cohesive zone based finite element model. Crack initiation and crack propagation in the adhesive layer are also studied. The results show that the peel stresses predicted by the SPH finite element model are higher and the shear stresses are lower than those predicted by the cohesive zone finite element model. The crack initiation and propagation response of the two models is similar, however, the SPH finite element model predicted a lower failure load than the cohesive zone finite element model. It is concluded that the current implementation of SPH method is a promising method for modelling cohesive failure in bonded joins but requires further development to allow for interfacial crack growth and better stress prediction under tensile loading to compete with existing methods.     

Strength Prediction of Adhesively Bonded Single Lap Joints Under Salt Spray Environment Using a Cohesive Zone Model

The aim of this research was to develop an experimental–numerical approach to characterize the effect of salt spray environment on adhesively bonded joints and predict the degradation in joint strength. Experiments were conducted on bulk adhesive specimens and single lap joints (SLJs) under salt spray condition and the corresponding experimental results were reported. The environment degradation factor, Deg, was incorporated into a bilinear cohesive zone model (CZM) to simulate the degradation process of the joints. The degraded CZM parameters, determined from static tests on bulk adhesive, were imported into the CZM using an approximate moisture concentration gradient approach. The reduction in residual strength of SLJ under salt spray environment was successfully predicted through comparing the experimental and numerical results.     

Application of the design of experiments procedure to the behaviour of adhesively bonded joints with plastically deformable adherends to enable further understanding of strain rate sensitivity

The study presented in this paper was carried out to investigate further the effects of strain rate on the strength of adhesively bonded single lap shear joints. Tests were carried out on two different configurations of adhesively bonded joints that were designed to exhibit different behaviours. In one configuration both adherends were made from a relatively low strength grade of aluminium such that both would exhibit significant plastic deformation prior to adhesive failure. The other configuration used one adherend that was significantly stronger such that only elastic deformation was exhibited prior to failure of the adhesive. The joint specimens were tested at several different strain rates using a servo-hydraulic test machine and the results analysed using statistical methods. To further understand the results Finite Element models of the joints were created using a Cohesive Zone Model to predict damage development and failure in the adhesive. The Design of Experiments procedure was used to study the effects of material parameters relating to both the adherends and the adhesive in the Finite Element models. The results of the testing suggested that the strength of joints formed from two adherends that exhibited plastic deformation prior to failure did not show statistically significant sensitivity to strain rate. Interpretation of the results of the Finite Element analyses suggested that the adherend yield was the main factor influencing failure load in the adhesive for joints of this type.     

Metallic multi-material adhesive joint testing and modeling for vehicle lightweighting

While adhesive bonding has been shown to be a beneficial technique to join multi-material automotive bodies-in-white, quantitatively assessing the effect of adherend response on the ultimate strength of adhesively bonded joints is necessary for accurate joint design.In the current study, thin adherend single lap shear testing was carried out using three sheet metals used to replace mild steel when lightweighting automotive structures: hot stamped Usibor® 1500 AS ultra-high strength steel (UHSS), aluminum (AA5182), and magnesium (ZEK 100). Six combinations of single and multi-material samples were bonded with a one-part toughed structural epoxy adhesive and experimentally tested to measure the force, displacement across the bond line, and joint rotation during loading. Finite element models of each test were analyzed using LS-DYNA to quantitatively assess the effects of the mode mixity on ultimate joint failure. The adherends were modeled with shell elements and a cohesive zone model was implemented using bulk material properties for the adhesive to allow full three-dimensional analysis of the test, while still being computationally efficient.The UHSS-UHSS joint strength (27.2 MPa; SD 0.6 MPa) was significantly higher than all other material combinations, with joint strengths between 17.9 MPa (SD 0.9 MPa) and 23.9 MPa (SD 1.4 MPa). The models predicted the test response (average R2 of 0.86) including the bending deformation of the adherends, which led to mixed mode loading of the adhesive. The critical cohesive element in the UHSS-UHSS simulation predicted 85% Mode II loading at failure while the other material combinations predicted between 41% and 53% Mode II loading at failure, explaining the higher failure strength in the UHSS-UHSS joint.This study presents a computational method to predict adhesive joint response and failure in multi-material structures, and highlights the importance of the adherend bending stiffness and on joint rotation and ultimate joint strength.     

Taguchi analysis of bonded composite single-lap joints using a combined interface–adhesive damage model

The mechanical behaviour of bonded composite joints depends on several factors, such as the strength of the composite–adhesive interface, the strength of the adhesive and the strength of the composite itself. In this regard, a finite element model was developed using a combined interface–adhesive damage approach. A cohesive zone model is used to represent the composite–adhesive interface and a continuum damage model for the adhesive bondline. The influence of the composite–adhesive interfacial adhesion and the strength of the adhesive on the performance of a bonded composite single-lap joint was investigated numerically. A Taguchi analysis was conducted to rank the influence of material parameters on the static behaviour of the joint. It was found that the composite–adhesive interfacial fracture energy and the mechanical properties of the adhesive predominantly govern the static performance of the joints. A parametric study was performed by varying the most important material parameters, and a response surface equation is proposed to predict the joint strength. It is shown that the influence of experimental parameter variations, e.g. variation in adhesive curing and surface preparation conditions, can be numerically accommodated to investigate the static behaviour of bonded composite joints by combining finite element and statistical techniques. The methods presented could be used by practicing engineers to describe the failure envelope of adhesively bonded composite joints.     

Cohesive and continuum mixed-mode damage models applied to the simulation of the mechanical behaviour of bonded joints

The objective of this work is to discuss the adequacy of cohesive and continuum damage models for the prediction of the mechanical behaviour of bonded joints. A cohesive mixed-mode damage model appropriate for ductile adhesives is presented. The double cantilever beam and the end-notched flexure tests are proposed in order to evaluate the cohesive properties of the adhesive as a thin layer under mode I and mode II, respectively. A new data reduction scheme based on the crack equivalent concept is also proposed to overcome crack-monitoring difficulties during propagation in these fracture characterization tests. An inverse method to determine the cohesive parameters of the trapezoidal softening law is discussed. A continuum mixed-mode damage model is developed in order to better simulate the cases where adhesive thickness plays an important role. The model is applied to evaluate the effect of adhesive thickness on fracture characterization of adhesive joints. Some important conclusions about the advantages and drawbacks of cohesive and continuum damage models are reported.     

Cohesive/adhesive failure interaction in ductile adhesive joints Part II: Quasi-static and fatigue analysis of double lap-joint specimens subjected to through-thickness compressive loading

This paper proposes a new methodology for the finite element (FE) modelling of failure in adhesively bonded joints. Cohesive and adhesive failure are treated separately which allows accurate failure predictions for adhesive joints of different thicknesses using a single set of material parameters. In a companion paper (part I), a new smeared-crack model for adhesive joint cohesive failure was proposed and validated. The present contribution gives an in depth investigation into the interaction among plasticity, cohesive failure and adhesive failure, with application to structural joints. Quasi-static FE analyses of double lap-joint specimens with different thicknesses and under different levels of hydrostatic pressure were performed and compared to experimental results. In all the cases studied, the numerical analysis correctly predicts the driving mechanisms and the specimens’ final failure. Accurate fatigue life predictions are made with the addition of a Paris based damage law to the interface elements used to model the adhesive failure.     

Cohesive/adhesive failure interaction in ductile adhesive joints Part I: A smeared-crack model for cohesive failure

This paper proposes a new methodology for the finite element (FE) modelling of failure in adhesively bonded joint. Unlike current methods, cohesive and adhesive failures are treated separately. Initial results show the method׳s ability to give accurate prediction of failure of adhesive joints subjected to thickness-induced constraint and complex multi-axial loading using a single set of material parameters. The present paper (part I), focuses on the development of a smeared-crack model for cohesive failure. Model verification and validation are performed comparing the model predictions with experimental data from 3 point bending End Notched Flexure (3ENF) and Double Cantilever Beam (DCB) fracture tests conducted on adhesively bonded composite panels of different adhesive thicknesses.     

Strength and bonding characteristics of adhesive joints with surface-treated titanium-alloy substrates

This paper presents a study on the effect of surface treatments on the mechanical behavior of adhesively bonded titanium alloy joints. Several different treatments were selected for the preparation of Ti-6Al-4V alloy faying surfaces, and bonded joints were fabricated using surface-treated titanium alloy substrates and a film adhesive. Tensile tests were performed on single-lap specimens to evaluate the joint strength and to assess the failure mode, i.e. cohesive failure, adhesive (interfacial) failure or a mix of both. Contact angle measurements were also carried out, and the surface free energies of titanium alloys and the thermodynamic works of adhesion for the adhesive/titanium alloy interfaces were obtained. A three-dimensional finite element analysis was used to predict the strength of the specimens exhibiting cohesive failure. In addition, an expression of the relationship between the joint strength corresponding to interfacial failure and the thermodynamic work of adhesion was introduced based on the cohesive zone model (CZM) concept. It is shown that two surface treatments, Itro treatment and Laseridge, lead to cohesive failure and a significant increase in the joint strength, and the numerically predicted strength values are fairly close to the experimental values. These surface treatments are possible replacements for the traditional surface treatment processes. For degreasing, emery paper abrasion, atmospheric plasma treatment, sulfuric acid anodizing, nano adhesion technology and high-power lasershot, the specimens fail at the adhesive/substrate interface and the joint strength increases linearly with the thermodynamic work of adhesion as expected from our CZM-based expression.     

Interfacial Fracture Mechanical Aspects of Adhesive Bonded Joints—A Review

A serious limitation frequently encountered in the use of structural adhesives is the deleterious effect moisture has upon the strength of a bonded component, especially when the component is also subjected to conditions of relatively high stress and temperature. It is generally recognised that while the locus of failure of well prepared joints is invariably by cohesive fracture in the adhesive layer, after environmental attack it is via failure in the interfacial regions. This interfacial locus of failure focuses attention on interfacial fracture mechanical considerations. This paper reviews mechanisms of environmental failure and considers techniques for estimating and increasing the service-lifetimes of bonded components. Particular emphasis is given to the contribution from the application of continuum fracture mechanics concepts to the study of environmental attack on structural adhesive joints.     

Experimental and Numerical Study of Adhesively Bonded CFRP Scarf-Lap Joints Subjected to Tensile Loads

The tensile performance of adhesively bonded CFRP scarf-lap joints was investigated experimentally and numerically. In this study, scarf angle and adherend thickness were chosen as design parameters. The lap shear strength is not directly proportional to scarf angle and adherend thickness for the brittle adhesive studied in the paper. The major failure mode includes cohesive shear failure and adherend delamination failure. The results present a stepped failure morphology along the bondline in the adhesive layer. A finite element model based on cohesive zone model was established to further investigate the stress distribution of scarf-lap joints with different lap parameters. The numerical results were compared with the experiment results, showing a good agreement, thus verifying the validity of the established numerical model.     

Effect of Adhesive Ductility on Cyclic Debond Mechanism in Composite-to-Composite Bonded Joints

An investigation of an adhesively bonded composite joint with a brittle adhesive was conducted to characterize both the static and fatigue debond growth mechanism under mode I and mixed mode I-II loadings. The bonded system consisted of graphite/epoxy adherends bonded with FM-400 adhesive. Two specimen types were tested: (1) a double-cantilever-beam specimen for mode I loading and (2) a cracked-lap-shear specimen for mixed mode I-II loading. In all specimens tested, failure occurred in the form of debond growth either in a cohesive or adhesive manner. The total strain-energy-release rate is not the criterion for cohesive debond growth under static and fatigue loading in the birttle adhesive as observed in previous studies with the ductile adhesives. Furthermore, the relative fatigue resistance and threshold value of cyclic debond growth in terms of its static fracture strength is higher in the brittle adhesive than its counterpart in the ductile adhesive.