The simplest fuzzy PID controllers: mathematical models and stability analysis

This paper reveals mathematical models for the simplest fuzzy PID controllers which employ two fuzzy sets for each of the three input variables and four fuzzy sets for the output variable. Mathematical models are derived via left and right trapezoidal membership functions for each input, singleton or triangular membership functions for output, algebraic product triangular norm, different combinations of triangular co-norms and inference methods, and center of sums (COS) defuzzification method. Properties of these structures are studied to examine their suitability for control application. For the structure which is suitable for control, bounded-input bounded-output (BIBO) stability proof is presented. An approach to design fuzzy PID controllers is given. Finally, some numerical examples along with their simulation results are included to demonstrate the effectiveness of the simplest fuzzy PID controllers.     

A general technique for deriving analytical structure of fuzzy controllers using arbitrary trapezoidal input fuzzy sets and Zadeh AND operator

Deriving the analytical structure of fuzzy controllers is very important as it creates a solid foundation for better understanding, insightful analysis, and more effective design of fuzzy control systems. We previously developed a technique for deriving the analytical structure of the fuzzy controllers that use Zadeh fuzzy AND operator and the symmetric, identical trapezoidal or triangular input fuzzy sets. Many fuzzy controllers use arbitrary trapezoidal/triangular input fuzzy sets that are asymmetric. At present, there exists no technique capable of deriving the analytical structure of these fuzzy controllers. Extending our original technique, we now present a novel method that can accomplish rigorously the structure derivation for any fuzzy controller, Mamdani type or TS type, that employs the arbitrary trapezoidal input fuzzy sets and Zadeh fuzzy AND operator. The new technique contains our original technique as a special case. Given the importance of PID control, we focus on Mamdani fuzzy PI and PD controllers in this paper and show in detail how to use the new technique for different configurations of the fuzzy PI/PD controllers. The controllers use two arbitrary trapezoidal fuzzy sets for each input variable, four arbitrary singleton output fuzzy sets, four fuzzy rules, Zadeh fuzzy AND operator, and the centroid defuzzifier. This configuration is more general and complicated than the Mamdani fuzzy PI/PD controllers in the current literature. It actually contains them as special cases. We call this configuration the generalized fuzzy PI/PD controller.     

模糊控制器的结构化分析及系统化设计方法

对于模糊控制器的输入变量,采用一种新型的不均匀、全交迭、三角形的隶属度函数,推导了两输入（e,△e)－输出（△u）的典型模糊控制器输出的解析表达式,并对最常用的输入变量各取5个模糊变量的情况进行分析。在此基础上提出一种模糊控制系统的系统化设计方法,可根据已有的PI／PD控制器参数设计相应的模糊控制器参数。仿真实验说明了该方法的有效性。     

A simple design method for interval type-2 fuzzy pid controllers

In this study, a design method for single Input interval type-2 fuzzy PID controller has been developed. The most important feature of the proposed type-2 fuzzy controller is its simple structure consisting of a single input variable. The presented simple structure gives an opportunity to the designer to form the type-2 fuzzy controller output in closed form formulation for the first time in literature. This formulation cannot be achieved with present type-2 fuzzy PID controller structures which have employed the Karnik-Mendel type reduction. The closed form solution is derived in terms of the tuning parameters which are chosen as the heights of lower membership functions of the antecedent interval type-2 fuzzy sets. Elaborations are done on the derived closed form output and a simple strategy is presented for a single input type-2 fuzzy PID controller design. The presented interval type-2 fuzzy controller structure still keeps the most preferred features of the PID controller such as simplicity and easy design. We will illustrate how the extra degrees of freedom provided by the antecedent interval type-2 fuzzy sets can be used to enhance the control performance on linear and nonlinear benchmark systems by simulations. Moreover, the type-2 fuzzy controller structure has been implemented on experimental pH neutralization. The simulation and experimental results will illustrate that the proposed type-2 fuzzy controller produces superior control performance and can handle nonlinear dynamics, parameter uncertainties, noise and disturbances better in comparison with the standard PID controllers. Hence, the results and analyses of this study will give the control engineers an opportunity to draw a bridge and connect the type-2 fuzzy logic and control theory.     

Analytical structures and analysis of the simplest fuzzy PDcontrollers

This paper deals with simplest fuzzy PD controllers which employ only two fuzzy sets on the universe of discourse of each input variable, and three fuzzy sets on the universe of discourse of output variable. First, analytical structures of the simplest fuzzy PD controllers are derived via triangular membership functions for fuzzification, intersection T-norm, Lukasiewicz OR and Zadeh (1965) OR T-conorms, Mamdani's minimum, Larsen's product and drastic product inference methods, and center of area method for defuzzification. Properties of such fuzzy PD controllers are investigated. Based on these properties a comparative study is made on fuzzy controllers derived, and also on the fuzzy controllers and their counterpart-conventional linear PD controller. Finally, sufficient conditions for bounded-input bounded-output stability of fuzzy PD control systems are established using the well known small gain theorem.     

Multivariable gain-scheduled fuzzy logic control of an exothermic reactor

Fuzzy logic control frequently exhibits superior performance to classical linear controllers even for ‘hard’, mathematically well defined plants, as described in this paper. The case-study of a highly nonlinear exothermic continuous stirred tank reactor, which poses a multivariable control problem with two interacting loops and open-loop instability, is used. The behaviour of the fuzzy logic controller is compared with that of a PID controller. A smooth, easily tuneable gain-schedule is designed to handle offset-like problems with a fuzzy controller. It is analytically shown that such a gain-schedule is the simpler, intuitive equivalent of a manipulation of the corresponding fuzzy membership functions. The fuzzy controller structure chosen is a parsimonious one, with the choice of Gaussian bell-shaped membership functions generating a smooth input/output surface with nontrivial inferencing spanning the entire input space. This provides a clear, non-heuristic reason to select Gaussian over triangular shapes for membership functions. The gain-scheduled fuzzy controller shows excellent control performance, significantly outperforming the PID controllers in both servo and regulatory modes. The disturbance rejection behaviour of the modified fuzzy controller is observed to be particularly good.     

Analytical Structures for Fuzzy PID Controllers?

In this paper, analytical structures for fuzzy proportional-integral-derivative (PID) controllers are derived by using triangular membership functions for inputs, singletons, or triangular membership functions for output, minimum triangular norm, maximum or drastic sum triangular conorm, Mamdani minimum, drastic or Larsen product inference, nonlinear control rules, and center-of-sum defuzzification. It is shown that these analytical structures are not suitable for control purpose. In this context, it is extremely important to note that the analytical structures reported by Carvajal et al. are also not valid for control.     

模糊控制器的实时精确算法与优化设计

将T-S型模糊控制器与PID控制器相结合,提出了TS-PID模糊控制器模型。推导出了输入采用正规模糊集、三角形全交迭隶属度函数的典型TS-PID模糊控制器的插值解析表达式,揭示了TS-PID模糊控制器本质上是一种非线性PID控制器,为实际应用提供了一种快速精确的控制算法。基于该插值表达式,进一步探讨了利用遗传算法对TS-PID模糊控制器进行优化设计的方法。     

Simplifying the automatic design of a fuzzy logic controller using evolutionary programming

With the availability of a wide range of Evolutionary Algorithms such as Genetic Algorithms, Evolutionary Programming, Evolutionary Strategies and Differential Evolution, every conceivable aspect of the design of a fuzzy logic controller has been optimized and automated. Although there is no doubt that these automated techniques can produce an optimal fuzzy logic controller, the structure of such a controller is often obscure and in many cases these optimizations are simply not needed. We believe that the automatic design of a fuzzy logic controller can be simplified by using a generic rule base such as the MacVicar-Whelan rule base and using an evolutionary algorithm to optimize only the membership functions of the fuzzy sets. Furthermore, by restricting the overlapping of fuzzy sets, using triangular membership functions and singletons, and reducing the number of parameters to represent the membership functions, the design can be further simplified. This paper describes this method of simplifying the design and some experiments performed to ascertain its validity.     

Analytical structures and analysis of the simplest fuzzy PI controllers

This paper deals with simplest fuzzy PI controllers which employ two fuzzy numbers on the universe of discourse (UOD) of each input variable, and three fuzzy numbers on the UOD of output variable. Analytical structures of such controllers are derived using triangular membership functions for fuzzification, different combinations of T-norms and T-conorms, different inference methods, and center of area (COA) method for defuzzification. Properties of these controllers are investigated. A comparative study is made on (i) the fuzzy PI controllers derived, and (ii) on the fuzzy PI controllers and their counterpart—conventional PI controller. Moreover, sufficient conditions for bounded-input bounded-output (BIBO) stability of fuzzy PI control systems are established using the well-known small gain theorem.     

A method of defuzzification based on the approach of areas' ratio

The new method of defuzzification of output parameters from the base of fuzzy rules for a Mamdani fuzzy controller is given in the paper. The peculiarity of the method is the usage of the universal equation for the area computation of the geometric shapes. During the realization of fuzzy inference linguistic terms, the structure changes from the triangular into a trapezoidal shape. That is why the universal equation is used. The method is limited and can be used only for the triangular and trapezoidal membership functions. Gaussian functions can also be used while modifying the proposed method. Traditional defuzzification models such as Middle of Maxima − MoM, First of Maxima − FoM, Last of Maxima − LoM, First of Suppport − FoS, Last of Support − LoS, Middle of Support − MoS, Center of Sums − CoS, Model of Height − MoH have a number of systematic errors: curse of dimensionality, partition of unity condition and absence of additivity. The above-mentioned methods can be seen as Center of Gravity − CoG, which has the same errors. These errors lead to the fact that accuracy of fuzzy systems decreases, because during the training root mean square error increases. One of the reasons that provokes the errors is that some of the activated fuzzy rules are excluded from the fuzzy inference. It is also possible to increase the accuracy of the fuzzy system through properties of continuity. The proposed method guarantees fulfilling of the property of continuity, as the intersection point of the adjustment linguistic terms equals 0.5 when a parametrized membership function is used. The causes of errors and a way to delete them are reviewed in the paper. The proposed method excludes errors which are inherent to the traditional and non- traditional models of defuzzification. Comparative analysis of the proposed method of defuzzification with traditional and non-traditional models shows its effectiveness.     

自适应神经模糊推理结合PID控制的并联机器人控制方法

针对6自由度液压驱动并联机器人的精确控制问题,提出一种结合自适应神经模糊推理系统(ANFIS)和比例积分微分(PID)控制的机器人控制方法。首先,利用浮动坐标系描述法(FFRF)来模拟机器人柔性组件,并构建并联机器人的拉格朗日动力学模型。然后,根据模糊推理中的模糊规则来自适应调整PID控制器参数。最后,利用神经自适应学习算法使模糊逻辑能计算隶属度函数参数,从而使模糊推理系统能追踪给定的输入和输出数据。将该控制器与传统PID控制器、模糊PID控制器进行比较,结果表明,ANFIS自整定PID控制器大大减小了末端器位移误差,能很好的控制并联机器人末端机械手的运动。     

Deriving Analytical Input–Output Relationship for Fuzzy Controllers Using Arbitrary Input Fuzzy Sets and Zadeh Fuzzy AND Operator

A fuzzy controller uses either Zadeh or product fuzzy AND operator, with the former being more frequently used than the latter. We have recently published a novel technique for deriving analytical input–output relation for the fuzzy controllers that use Zadeh AND operator and arbitrary trapezoidal input fuzzy sets, including triangular ones as special cases. In this paper, we have developed a general technique based on that technique to cover arbitrary types of input fuzzy sets. Moreover, we have established some necessary and sufficient conditions to characterize general relationship between shape of input fuzzy sets and shape of input space divisions, an important and integral issue because analytical relationship differs in different regions of input space. The new technique and the shape relations are applicable to any type of fuzzy controllers (e.g., Mamdani type or Takagi–Sugeno type). The analytical structures that we have derived provide an unprecedented opportunity to insightfully and rigorously examine the advantages and shortcomings of different design choices available for various components of the fuzzy controllers. We have focused on type selection for input fuzzy sets of Mamdani fuzzy controllers. Our preliminary analysis indicates that the fuzzy controllers using trapezoidal fuzzy sets may be understood (and possibly analyzed and designed) more sensibly and easily in the context of conventional control theory than the fuzzy controllers using any other types of fuzzy sets. Our proposition is that trapezoidal fuzzy sets should be the first choice and used most of time. Possible implication for automatic learning of input fuzzy sets via neural networks or genetic algorithms is briefly discussed.     

Vague controller: A generalization of fuzzy logic controller

In this research, a vague controller (VC) is synthesized by using the notion of vague sets, which are a generalization of fuzzy sets and characterized by a truth-membership function and a falsity-membership function. The vague sets follow the basic set operations and logic operations defined for fuzzy sets, and are superior to fuzzy sets in that they could deal with the uncertainty encountered in real-world applications in a more natural way. Depending on the vague sets, the VC is developed as a generalization of fuzzy logic controller (FLC). The design procedures of the VC, which allow an arbitrary number of input variables, and each variable could have a distinct number of linguistic values, are outlined in this paper. In order to compensate the effort in constructing two series of membership functions for vague sets and to ease the difficulties in designing VCs, a new means of designating membership functions for VCs is also presented in this article. This method constructs a set of membership functions systematically by using only two parameters: number of linguistic values of a linguistic variable and shrinking factor. The membership functions generated by this method, shrinking-span membership functions (SSMFs), have different spans over the universe of discourse and, therefore, are more rational and more practical from the human expert's point of view.     

Conversion of probabilistic information into fuzzy sets for engineering decision analysis

To carry out seismic hazard analysis in the framework of fuzzy set theory, it may become necessary to convert probabilistic information regarding some of the variables into triangular or trapezoidal fuzzy sets. In this paper, three approaches for converting probabilistic information, represented by a probability distribution, into an equivalent triangular or trapezoidal fuzzy set are discussed. In all the three approaches, the probability distribution is first converted into a probabilistic fuzzy set, which is then converted into the equivalent triangular or trapezoidal fuzzy set. The first approach is based on the method of least-square curve fitting, the second approach is based on the conservation of uncertainty (represented by the entropy) associated with the probabilistic fuzzy set in a mean square sense, and the third approach is based on the minimisation of Hausdorff distance (HD) between the probabilistic and the equivalent fuzzy sets. The effectiveness of these approaches in preserving the entropy as well as in preserving the elements of the fuzzy set and their corresponding grades of membership are also discussed with the help of a numerical example of obtaining equivalent fuzzy set for peak ground acceleration. It is found that the approach based on minimisation of Hausdorff distance provides a simple and efficient way for converting the probabilistic information into an equivalent fuzzy set.     

A Fuzzy Inverse Model Construction Method for General Monotonic Multi-Input-- Single-Output (MISO) Systems

This paper presents a novel method of systematically constructing a fuzzy inverse model for general multi-input--single-output (MISO) systems represented with triangular input membership functions, singleton output membership function, and fuzzy-mean defuzzification. The fuzzy inverse model construction method has the ability of uniquely determining the inverse relationship for each input–output pair. It is derived in a straightforward way and the required input variables can be simultaneously obtained by the fuzzy inferencing calculation to realize the desired output value. Simulation examples are provided to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method to find the inverse kinematics solutions for complex multiple degree-of-freedom industrial robot manipulators.      

Design of fuzzy PID controllers using modified triangular membership functions

A design method for fuzzy proportional-integral-derivative (PID) controllers is investigated in this study. Based on conventional triangular membership functions used in fuzzy inference systems, the modified triangular membership functions are proposed to improve a system’s performance according to knowledge-based reasonings. The parameters of the considered controllers are tuned by means of genetic algorithms (GAs) using a fitness function associated with the system’s performance indices. The merits of the proposed controllers are illustrated by considering a model of the induction motor control system and a higher-order numerical model.     

采用非线性规则和不均匀分布的输入输出隶属函数时典型模糊控制器的结构分析

针对两输入 (e,Δe)一输出 (Δu)的典型模糊控制器, 其输入变量采用三角形、全交迭、对称、不均匀分布的隶属函数, 输出变量采用对称、不均匀分布的单点隶属函数, 当采用非线性控制规则和Sum Product推理方法时, 推导了输出的解析表达式, 分析了其结构特性和极限特性, 证明了此类模糊控制器具有通用逼近性, 并讨论了典型模糊控制系统的局部稳定性.     

输入采用广义梯形隶属函数的两维最简模糊控制器结构分析

总结了应用最为广泛的三角形和梯形隶属函数的共同特点, 明确定义了一种将以上两种隶属函数作为特例的广义梯形 (Generalized trapezoid-shaped, GTS) 隶属函数, 推导了输入变量采用 GTS 隶属函数的 I 类和 II 类两维最简模糊控制器的解析式. 基于此, 深入研究了模糊控制器的解析结构, 并证明了这两类模糊控制器等价于一种变结构的非线性 (或线性) PI 控制器与相应的非线性 (或定常) 控制偏置之和, 并且在其输入论域上是单调递增、连续且有界的. 最后, 将该类控制器应用于倒立摆控制系统, 通过仿真证明了其有效性, 同时揭示了此类控制器是一种更一般化的模糊控制器.     

On the difference in control performance of interval type-2 fuzzy PI control system with different FOU shapes

Interval type-2 fuzzy logic controllers (IT2-FLCs) have been attracting a lot of attention. However, challenges in designing IT2-FLCs still remain. One of the main challenges is to choose the appropriate FOU shape for interval type-2 fuzzy sets (IT2-FSs). This paper aims to analyse the differences in control performance between three IT2 fuzzy PI controllers (IT2-F-PICs) with different FOU shapes as antecedent sets, namely the triangular top wide IT2 fuzzy set, the triangular bottom wide IT2 fuzzy set and the trapezoidal (also called parallel) IT2 fuzzy set. First, the analytical structures of these IT2-FLCs are derived and the mathematical input–output equations are obtained. Three interesting differences between the analytical structures and input–output relationship of the IT2-F-PICs are then presented. From the differences in the analytical structures of the three IT2-F-PICs and numerical simulation results, it is demonstrated that IT2-F-PICs with trapezoidal (IT2-F-PI-P) and triangular bottom wide (IT2-F-PI-BW) antecedent sets with the potential to provide faster transient response and faster settling time than the IT2-F-PICs with triangular top wide (IT2-F-PI-TW). In addition, IT2-F-PI-P is better able to handle plant uncertainties and disturbances than IT2-F-PI-BW and IT2-F-PI-TW. The contribution of this paper is to provide insights into the performance differences between different FOU shaped controllers, which in turns allowing control designers to select the appropriate FOU shape in order to meet design requirements.