Carbonation of fly ash in oxy-fuel CFB combustion

Oxy-fuel combustion of fossil fuel is one of the most promising methods to produce a stream of concentrated CO₂ ready for sequestration. Oxy-fuel FBC (fluidized bed combustion) can use limestone as a sorbent for in situ capture of sulphur dioxide. Limestone will not calcine to CaO under typical oxy-fuel circulating FBC (CFBC) operating temperatures because of the high CO₂ partial pressures. However, for some fuels, such as anthracites and petroleum cokes, the typical combustion temperature is above 900 °C. At CO₂ concentrations of 80-85% (typical of oxy-fuel CFBC conditions with flue gas recycle) limestone still calcines, but when the ash cools to the calcination temperature, carbonation of fly ash deposited on cool surfaces may occur. This phenomenon has the potential to cause fouling of the heat transfer surfaces in the back end of the boiler, and to create serious operational difficulties. In this study, fly ash generated in a utility CFBC boiler was carbonated in a thermogravimetric analyzer (TGA) under conditions expected in an oxy-fuel CFBC. The temperature range investigated was from 250 to 800 °C with CO₂ concentration set at 80% and H₂O concentrations at 0%, 8% and 15%, and the rate and the extent of the carbonation reaction were determined. Both temperature and H₂O concentrations played important roles in determining the reaction rate and extent of carbonation. The results also showed that, in different temperature ranges, the carbonation of fly ash displayed different characteristics: in the range 400 °C < T ? 800 °C, the higher the temperature the higher the CaO-to-carbonate conversion ratio. The presence of H₂O in the gas phase always resulted in higher CaO conversion ratio than that obtainable without H₂O. For T ? 400 °C, no fly ash carbonation occurred without the presence of H₂O in the gas phase. However, on water vapour addition, carbonation was observed, even at 250 °C. For T ? 300 °C, small amounts of Ca(OH)₂ were found in the final product alongside CaCO₃. Here, the carbonation mechanism is discussed and the apparent activation energy for the overall reaction determined.     

Sulfation Rates of Particles in Calcium Looping Reactors

The sulfation reaction rate of CaO particles in three reactors comprising a post‐combustion calcium looping system is discussed: a combustion chamber generating flue gases, a carbonator reactor to capture CO₂ and SO₂, and an oxy‐fired calciner to regenerate the CO₂ sorbent. Due to its strong impact on the pore size distribution of CaO particles, the number of carbonation/calcination cycles arises as a new important variable to understand sulfation phenomena. Sulfation patterns change as a result of particle cycling, becoming more homogeneous with higher number of cycles. Experimental results from thermogravimetric tests demonstrate that high sulfation rates can be measured under all conditions tested, indicating that the calcium looping systems will be extremely efficient in SO₂ capture.     

CO2 Capture Using CaO Modified with Ethanol/Water Solution during Cyclic Calcination/Carbonation

The calcium‐based sorbent cyclic calcination/carbonation reaction is an effective technique for capturing CO₂ from combustion processes. The CO₂ capture capacity for CaO modified with ethanol/water solution was investigated over long‐term calcination/carbonation cycles. In addition, the SEM micrographs and pore structure for the calcined sorbents were analyzed. The carbonation conversion for CaO modified with ethanol/water solution is greater than that for CaO hydrated with distilled water and is much higher than that for calcined limestone. Modified CaO achieves the highest conversion for carbonation at the range of 650–700 °C. Higher values of ethanol concentration in solution result in higher carbonation conversion for modified CaO, and lead to better anti‐sintering performance. After calcination, the specific surface area and pore volume for modified CaO are higher than those for hydrated CaO, and are much greater than those for calcined limestone. The ethanol molecule enhances H₂O molecule affinity and penetrability to CaO in the hydration reaction so that the pores in CaO modified are obviously expanded after calcination. CaO modified with ethanol/water solution can act as a new and promising type of calcium‐based regenerable CO₂ sorbent for industrial applications.     

Effect of rice husk ash addition on CO2 capture behavior of calcium-based sorbent during calcium looping cycle

Rice husk ash/CaO was proposed as a CO₂ sorbent which was prepared by rice husk ash and CaO hydration together. The CO₂ capture behavior of rice husk ash/CaO sorbent was investigated in a twin fixed bed reactor system, and its apparent morphology, pore structure characteristics and phase variation during cyclic carbonation/calcination reactions were examined by SEM-EDX, N₂ adsorption and XRD, respectively. The optimum preparation conditions for rice husk ash/CaO sorbent are hydration temperature of 75 °C, hydration time of 8 h, and mole ratio of SiO₂ in rice husk ash to CaO of 1.0. The cyclic carbonation performances of rice husk ash/CaO at these preparation conditions were compared with those of hydrated CaO and original CaO. The temperature at 660 °C–710 °C is beneficial to CO₂ absorption of rice husk ash/CaO, and it exhibits higher carbonation conversions than hydrated CaO and original CaO during multiple cycles at the same reaction conditions. Rice husk ash/CaO possesses better anti-sintering behavior than the other sorbents. Rice husk ash exhibits better effect on improving cyclic carbonation conversion of CaO than pure SiO₂ and diatomite. Rice husk ash/CaO maintains higher surface area and more abundant pores after calcination during the multiple cycles; however, the other sorbents show a sharp decay at the same reaction conditions. Ca₂SiO₄ found by XRD detection after calcination of rice husk ash/CaO is possibly a key factor in determining the cyclic CO₂ capture behavior of rice husk ash/CaO.     

Lime enhanced gasification of solid fuels: Examination of a process for simultaneous hydrogen production and CO2 capture

The lime enhanced gasification (LEGS) process uses CaO as a CO₂ carrier and consists of two coupled reactors: a gasifier in which CO₂ absorption by CaO produces a hydrogen-rich product gas, and a regenerator in which the sorbent is calcined producing a high purity CO₂ gas stream suitable for storage. The LEGS process operates at a pressure of 2.0 MPa and temperatures less than 800 °C and therefore requires a reactive fuel such as brown coal. The brown coal ash and sulfur are purged from the regenerator together with CaO which is replaced by fresh limestone in order to maintain a steady-state CaO carbonation activity (a_ave). Equilibrium calculations show the influence of process conditions and coal sulfur content on the gasifier carbon capture (>95% is possible). Material balance calculations of the core process show that the required solid purge of the sorbent cycle is mainly attributed to the necessary removal of ash and CaSO₄ if the solid purge is used as a pre-calcined feedstock for cement production. The decay in the CaO capture capacity over many calcination–carbonation cycles demands a high sorbent circulation ratio but does not dictate the purge fraction. A thermodynamic analysis of a LEGS-based combined power and cement production process, where the LEGS purge is directly used in the cement industry, results in an electric efficiency of 42% using a state of the art combined cycle.     

Sulfation rates of cycled CaO particles in the carbonator of a Ca‐looping cycle for postcombustion CO2 capture

Calcium looping is an energy‐efficient CO₂ capture technology that uses CaO as a regenerable sorbent. One of the advantages of Ca‐looping compared with other postcombustion technologies is the possibility of operating with flue gases that have a high SO₂ content. However, experimental information on sulfation reaction rates of cycled particles in the conditions typical of a carbonator reactor is scarce. This work aims to define a semiempirical sulfation reaction model at particle level suitable for such reaction conditions. The pore blocking mechanism typically observed during the sulfation reaction of fresh calcined limestones is not observed in the case of highly cycled sorbents (N > 20) and the low values of sulfation conversion characteristic of the sorbent in the Ca‐looping system. The random pore model is able to predict reasonably well, the CaO conversion to CaSO₄ taking into account the evolution of the pore structure during the calcination/carbonation cycles. The intrinsic reaction parameters derived for chemical and diffusion controlled regimes are in agreement with those found in the literature for sulfation in other systems. © 2011 American Institute of Chemical EngineersAIChE J, 2012     

Investigation of sulphation behavior of two fly ash samples produced from combustion of different fuels in a 165 MWe CFB boiler

Emission of sulphur dioxide (SO₂) from combustion of fossil fuel is an important environmental issue. Circulating fluidized bed combustion (CFBC) technology can use limestone sorbent to achieve in situ SO₂ emissions control. This paper presents the chemical and physical analysis results of two fly ash samples derived from a 165 MWe CFBC boiler burning two different fuels with addition of limestone, as they pertain to sulphation behavior. One of the samples in this study was produced from combustion of a bituminous coal with high iron content, the other from firing of blended coal and petroleum coke fuel. The physical examination was conducted by scanning electron microscope (SEM) coupled with an energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) system for analysis of the surface structure or morphology of the sample, as well as the calcium and sulphur distribution. Some large particles derived from high-iron-content fuel were covered by dense iron shells; however, in general such a dense rim was found to not significantly impede the overall desulphurization performance in FBC in terms of the limestone utilization. The large particles (~ 100 μm in diameter) in both samples typically consisted of a CaSO₄ shell and an almost pure CaO core; however, numerous small particles of diameters of 10-20 μm consisted predominantly of CaO without sulphate shells. In particular, the emphasis of this investigation has been focused on the remaining capacity of the fly ash for reaction with sulphur dioxide and to clarify the effects of iron, both samples have been doped with additional iron content, and their sulphation behavior examined, and while both experienced a small reduction in sulphation capacity, the fly ash with the initial low iron content experienced the lowest reduction of sulphation capacity after doping, which is not supportive of the idea that iron has an important effect on sorbent capacity.     

Effects of rapid calcination on properties of calcium-based sorbents

The calcination process may influence subsequent fragmentation, sintering and swelling when CaO derived from limestone acts as a CO₂ or SO₂-sorbent in combustion, gasification and reforming. Sorbent properties are affected by CO₂ partial pressure, total pressure, temperature, heating rate, impurities and sample size. In this study, the effect of calcination heating rate was investigated based on an electrically heated platinum foil. The effects of heating rate (up to 800 °C/s), calcination temperature (700-950 °C), particle size (90-180 μm) and sweep gas velocity were investigated. Higher initial heating rates led to lower extents of limestone calcination, but the extents of carbonation of the resulting CaO were similar to each other. Calcium utilization declined markedly during carbonation or sulphation of CaO after calcination by rapid heating. Experimental results show that carbonation and calcium utilization were most effective for carbonation temperatures between 503 and 607 °C. Increasing the extent of calcination is not the best way to improve overall calcium utilization due to the vast increase in energy consumption.     

EtOH-H2O对钙基吸收剂分离CO2的影响

采用不同体积浓度的乙醇溶液分别对石灰石和石灰石的煅烧产物CaO进行调质处理,研究它们的碳酸化反应,并与水合调质CaO的碳酸化进行比较。通过SEM和N2吸附法考察吸收剂多次煅烧的微观结构特性,进一步揭示了乙醇溶液促进CaO碳酸化的机理。结果表明：随着循环反应次数的增加,乙醇溶液调质后CaO的碳酸化转化率明显高于石灰石和水合调质的CaO,对于石灰石,乙醇溶液则没有明显的调质效果。CaO经乙醇溶液调质后在650～700℃内有利于碳酸化的进行。乙醇浓度越高,则经调质后CaO的转化率越高,抗烧结性能越好。经乙醇溶液调质的CaO煅烧后比表面积和比孔容均比单纯水合大,远高于煅烧后的石灰石;比孔容分布和孔比表面积分布明显优于煅烧后的水合CaO和石灰石。乙醇溶液调质对CaO的孔有明显的增扩效应。     

Experimental study on CO2 capture conditions of a fluidized bed limestone decomposition reactor

In this study, the decomposition conditions of limestone particles (0.25-0.50 mm) for CO₂ capture in a steam dilution atmosphere (20-100% steam in CO₂) were investigated by using a continuously operating fluidized bed reactor. The results show that the decomposition conversion of limestone increased with the steam dilution percentage in the CO₂ supply gas. At a bed temperature of 920 °C, the conversions were 72% without steam dilution and 98% with 60% steam dilution. The conversion was 99% with 100% steam dilution at 850 °C of the bed temperature. Steam dilution can decrease not only the decomposition temperature of limestone, but also the residence time required for nearly complete decomposition of CaCO₃. The hydration and carbonation reactivities of the CaO produced were also tested and the results show that both the reactivities increased with the steam dilution percentage for decomposing limestone.     

Effect of the CaO sintering on the calcination rate of CaCO3 under atmospheres containing CO2

For the calcination of CaCO₃ under CO₂‐containing atmospheres, a mathematical model taking into account the CO₂‐catalyzed sintering of the CaO product layer is developed. In this model, a modified shrinking core model is coupled with a population balance‐based sintering model. By comparing model predictions with experimental data, it is found that CO₂ strongly affects the overall calcination rate both at high temperature and CO₂ partial pressure, since under these conditions CaO densification considerably reduces the effective diffusivity of CO₂ within product layer. It is observed that for large particles, the CO₂‐catalyzed sintering of CaO can produce the “die off” phenomenon, which takes place when the reaction stops due to the blockage of pores within product layer. Finally, it was determined that limestone impurities do not significantly affect the calcination reaction under atmospheres containing CO₂, because CO₂ causes a much greater increase of the CaO sintering rate than limestone impurities do. © 2018 American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE J, 64: 3638–3648, 2018     

Application of the random pore model to the carbonation cyclic reaction

Calcium oxide has been proved to be a suitable sorbent for high temperature CO₂ capture processes based on the cyclic carbonation‐calcination reaction. It is important to have reaction rate models that are able to describe the behavior of CaO particles with respect to the carbonation reaction. Fresh calcined lime is known to be a reactive solid toward carbonation, but the average sorbent particle in a CaO‐based CO₂ capture system experiences many carbonation‐calcination cycles and the reactivity changes with the number of cycles. This study applies the random pore model (RPM) to estimate the intrinsic rate parameters for the carbonation reaction and develops a simple model to calculate particle conversion with time as a function of the number of cycles, partial pressure of CO₂, and temperature. This version of the RPM model integrates knowledge obtained in earlier works on intrinsic carbonation rates, critical product layer thickness, and pore structure evolution in highly cycled particles. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE J, 2009     

Modified CaO-based sorbent looping cycle for CO2 mitigation

CaO-based sorbent looping cycle, i.e. cyclic calcination/carbonation, is one of the most interesting technologies for CO₂ capture during coal combustion and gasification processes. In order to improve the durability of limestone during the multiple calcination/carbonation cycles, modified limestone with acetic acid solution was proposed as an CO₂ sorbent. The cyclic carbonation conversions of modified limestone and original one were investigated in a twin fixed bed reactor system. The modified limestone shows the optimum carbonation conversion at the carbonation temperature of 650 °C and achieves a conversion of 0.5 after 20 cycles. The original limestone exhibits the maximum carbonation conversion of 0.15 after 20 cycles. Conversion of the modified limestone decreases slightly as the calcination temperature increases from 920 °C to 1100 °C with the number of cycles, while conversion of the original one displays a sharp decay at the same reaction conditions. The durability of the modified limestone is significantly better than the original one during the multiple cycles because mean grain size of CaO derived from the modified limestone is lower than that from the original one at the same reaction conditions. The calcined modified limestone shows higher surface area and pore volume than the calcined original one with the number of cycles, and pore size distribution of the modified limestone is superior to the original one after the same number of calcinations.     

Stabilized Performance of Al‐Decorated and Al/Mg Co‐Decorated Spray‐Dried CaO‐Based CO2 Sorbents

The sharp loss‐in‐capacity in CO₂ capture as a result of sintering is a major drawback for CaO‐based sorbents used in the calcium looping process. The decoration of inert supports effectively stabilizes the cyclic CO₂ capture performance of CaO‐based sorbents via sintering mitigation. A range of Al‐decorated and Al/Mg co‐decorated CaO‐based sorbents were synthesized via an easily scaled‐up spray‐drying route. The decoration of Al‐based and Al/Mg‐based supports efficiently enhanced the cyclic CO₂ capture capability of CaO‐based sorbents under severe testing conditions. The CO₂ capture capacity losses of Al‐decorated and Al/Mg co‐decorated CaO‐based sorbents were alleviated, representing more stable CO₂ capture performance. The stabilized CO₂ capture performance is mainly attributed to the formation of Ca₁₂Al₁₄O₃₃, MgAl₂O₄, and MgO that act as the skeleton structures to mitigate the sintering of CaCO₃ during carbonation/calcination cycles.     

Enhancement of Ca‐Based Sorbent Multicyclic Behavior in Ca Looping Process for CO2 Separation

The Ca‐based sorbent looping cycle represents an innovative way of CO₂ capture for power plants. However, the CO₂ capture capacity of the Ca‐based sorbent decays sharply with calcination/carbonation cycle number increasing. In order to improve the CO₂ capture capacity of the sorbent in the Ca looping cycle, limestone was modified with acetic acid solution. The cyclic carbonation behaviors of the modified and original limestones were investigated in a twin fixed‐bed reactor system. The modified limestone possesses better cyclic carbonation kinetics than the original limestone at each cycle. The modified limestone carbonated at 640–660 °C achieves the optimum carbonation conversion. The acetic acid modification improves the long‐term performance of limestone, resulting in directly measured conversion as high as 0.4 after 100 cycles, while the original limestone remains at a conversion of less than 0.1 at the same reaction conditions. Both the pore volume and pore area distributions of the calcines derived from the modified limestone are better than those derived from the original limestone. The CO₂ partial pressure for carbonation has greater effect on conversion of the original limestone than on that of the modified sorbent because of the difference in their pore structure characteristics. The carbonation conversion of the original limestone decreases with the increase in particle size, while the change in particle size of the modified sorbent has no clear effect on cyclic carbonation behavior.     

CO2 capture from flue gases using a fluidized bed reactor with limestone

The CO₂ capture from flue gases by a small fluidized bed reactor was experimentally investigated with limestone. The results showed that CO₂ in flue gases could be captured by limestone with high efficiency, but the CO₂ capture capacity of limestone decayed with the increasing of carbonation/calcination cycles. From a practical point of view, coal may be required to provide the heat for CaCO₃ calcination, resulting in some potential effect on the sorbent capacity of CO₂ capture. Experiment results indicated that the variation in the capacity of CO₂ capture by using a limestone/coal ash mixture with a cyclic number was qualitatively similar to the variation of the capacity of CO₂ capture using limestone only. Cyclic stability of limestone only undergoing the kinetically controlled stage in the carbonation process had negligible difference with that of the limestone undergoing both the kinetically controlled stage and the product layer diffusion controlled stage. Based on the experimental data, a model for the high-velocity fluidized bed carbonator that consists of a dense bed zone and a riser zone was developed. The model predicted that high CO₂ capture efficiencies (>80%) were achievable for a range of reasonable operating conditions by the high-velocity fluidized bed carbonator in a continuous carbonation and calcination system.     

Synthetic Ca‐based solid sorbents suitable for capturing CO2 in a fluidized bed

Coprecipitation and hydrolysis of CaO have been employed to produce Ca‐based synthetic sorbents suitable for capturing CO₂ in a fluidized bed. Their composition, CO₂ uptake, volume in small pores (2–200 nm) and resistance to attrition were measured and compared to those of limestone and dolomite. Sorbents produced by hydrolysis showed the highest uptake and resistance to attrition. After 20 cycles of carbonation and calcination, two sorbents exceeded the uptake of both limestone and dolomite, when subjected to the same regimes of reaction. A sorbent's uptake of CO₂ was shown to be determined by the volume in pores narrower than ～200 nm.     

Economical assessment of competitive enhanced limestones for CO2 capture cycles in power plants

CO₂ capture systems based on the carbonation/calcination loop have gained rapid interest due to promising carbonator CO₂ capture efficiency, low sorbent cost and no flue gases treatment is required before entering the system. These features together result in a competitively low cost CO₂ capture system. Among the key variables that influence the performance of these systems and their integration with power plants, the carbonation conversion of the sorbent and the heat requirement at calciner are the most relevant. Both variables are mainly influenced by CaO/CO₂ ratio and make-up flow of solids. New sorbents are under development to reduce the decay of their carbonation conversion with cycles. The aim of this study is to assess the competitiveness of new limestones with enhanced sorption behaviour applied to carbonation/calcination cycle integrated with a power plant, compared to raw limestone. The existence of an upper limit for the maximum average capture capacity of CaO has been considered. Above this limit, improving sorbent capture capacity does not lead to the corresponding increase in capture efficiency and, thus, reduction of CO₂ avoided cost is not observed. Simulations calculate the maximum price for enhanced sorbents to achieve a reduction in CO₂ removal cost under different process conditions (solid circulation and make-up flow). The present study may be used as an assessment tool of new sorbents to understand what prices would be competitive compare with raw limestone in the CO₂ looping capture systems.     

CO2 uptake of modified calcium-based sorbents in a pressurized carbonation-calcination looping

This study focuses on enhancing CO₂ uptake by modifying limestone with acetate solutions under pressurized carbonation condition. The multicycle tests were carried out in an atmospheric calcination/pressurized carbonation reactor system at different temperatures and pressures. The pore structure characteristics (BET and BJH) were measured as a supplement to the reaction studies. Compared with the raw limestone, the modified sorbent showed a great improvement in CO₂ uptake at the same reaction condition. The highest CO₂ uptake was obtained at 700 °C and 0.5 MPa, by 88.5% increase over the limestone at 0.1 MPa after 10 cycles. The structure characteristics of the sorbents on N₂ absorption and SEM confirm that compared with the modified sorbent, the effective pores of limestone are greatly driven off by sintering, which hinders the easy access of CO₂ molecules to the unreacted-active sites of CaO. The morphological and structural properties of the modified sorbent did not reveal significant differences after multiple cycles. This would explain its superior performance of CO₂ uptake under pressurized carbonation. Even after 10 cycles, the modified sorbent still achieved a CO₂ uptake of 0.88.