The economics of reburning with cattle manure-based biomass in existing coal-fired power plants for NOx and CO2 emissions control

Coal plants that reburn with catttle biomass (CB) can reduce CO₂ emissions and save on coal purchasing costs while reducing NO_x emissions by 60–90% beyond levels achieved by primary NO_x controllers. Reductions from reburning coal with CB are comparable to those obtained by other secondary NO_x technologies such as selective catalytic reduction (SCR). The objective of this study is to model potential emission and economic savings from reburning coal with CB and compare those savings against competing technologies. A spreadsheet computer program was developed to model capital, operation, and maintenance costs for CB reburning, SCR, and selective non-catalytic reduction (SNCR). A base case run of the economics model, showed that a CB reburn system retrofitted on an existing 500 MW_e coal plant would have a net present worth of −$80.8 million. Comparatively, an SCR system under the same base case input parameters would have a net present worth of +$3.87 million. The greatest increase in overall cost for CB reburning was found to come from biomass drying and processing operations. The profitability of a CB reburning system retrofit on an existing coal-fired plant improved with higher coal prices and higher valued NO_x emission credits. Future CO₂ taxes of $25 tonne⁻¹ could make CB reburning as economically feasible as SCR. Biomass transport distances and the unavailability of suitable, low-ash CB may require future research to concentrate on smaller capacity coal-fired units between 50 and 300 MW_e.     

Experimental study of fuel‐lean reburn system for NOX reduction and CO emission in oxygen‐enhanced combustion

A fuel‐lean reburn system is found here to be able to replace a conventional reburning technique in terms of increasing efficiency. In the fuel‐lean reburn system, the amount of injected reburn fuel into the reburning zone is low enough to maintain the overall fuel‐lean condition in the furnace, so that no additional air system is required, and CO emission can be maintained at almost zero level. In this study, an experimental study has been done to examine the reduction characteristics of NO_X in a lab scale combustor (15 kW) with various oxygen‐enhanced combustion conditions. Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG) was used as a main fuel and reburn fuel. Finally, the current fuel‐lean reburn system, even with only an amount of reburn fuel of 13% of total heat input, was observed to achieve a maximum of 48% in NO_X reduction. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Numerical study on reduction of NOx and unburned carbon in micronized coal reburning

Three dimensional numerical simulation of bituminous coal reburning in a full-scale tangentially fired boiler was conducted with CFD method to study the effects of reburn zone length, the height of reburn nozzles, the stoichiometric ratio in reburn zone, the reburn fuel fraction and the reburn coal fineness on NOx reduction efficiency and unburned carbon in fly ash. The results indicate that the NOx reduction efficiency reaches the largest value when the relative height of reburn nozzles is about 0.21 and the stoichiometric ratio is between 0.8 and 0.9 in reburn zone; NOx reduction efficiency increases with reburn zone length, reburn fuel fraction and the decrease of reburn coal particle size; the smaller the coal particle size is, the better the burnout performance of coal is.     

Experimental study on ash deposition of Zhundong coal in oxy-fuel combustion

To facilitate the large-scale utilization of high-alkali and -alkaline earth metals (AAEMs) coals in power generation, the ash deposition behaviors of a typical Zhundong coal in oxy-fuel combustion were experimentally investigated using a drop tube furnace. A wall-temperature-controlled ash deposition probe by which the bulk gas temperature could be measured simultaneously was designed and employed in the experiments. The deposition tendencies, ash morphologies, chemical compositions of deposited ash particles were studied respectively under various oxygen concentrations, bulk gas temperatures, probe surface temperatures and probe exposure times. The experimental results revealed that the oxygen concentration had a significant influence on the deposition behavior during oxy-fuel combustion of high-alkali coal. Compared with air case, more fine ash particles were generated during the combustion of Zhundong coal in 21% O₂/79% CO₂ atmosphere but the deposition tendency was weaker. However, a higher oxygen concentration could aggravate the tendency of ash deposition. The high contents of iron (Fe), calcium (Ca), sulfur (S), and sodium (Na) in Zhundong coal could result in the generations of low-melting point compounds. Calcium in flue gas existed as CaO and was captured prior to SO₃ by the probe surface during the ash deposition process. At the initial 30 min of the ash deposition process, the dark spherical fine ash particles rich in Fe, Na, oxygen (O), and S were largely produced, while in the range of 60–90 min the light spherical fine ash particles with high contents of Ca, barium (Ba), O, and S were generated on the other hand. The deposition mechanisms at different stages were different and the melted CaO (BaO)/CaSO₄ (BaSO₄) would give rise to a fast growth rate of ash deposit.     

Ash deposition and sodium migration behaviors during combustion of Zhundong coals in a drop tube furnace

Zhundong coalfield is one super-large coalfield recently discovered in China. However, the utilization of Zhundong coal in power plants has caused serious ash-related issues mainly due to its high-sodium feature. The ash deposition problem on convection heat exchanger surfaces is still particularly difficult to resolve and its mechanism has yet to be fully understood. This study deals with the ash deposition and alkali metal migration behaviors on convection heat exchanger surfaces between 400 and 800 °C during combustion of Zhundong coal using a lab-scale drop tube reactor. Experimental results show that the sodium content in ash deposit of Zhundong coals increases obviously as the deposition temperature decreases from 800 to 600 °C, while it is almost unchanged below 600 °C. The contents of iron and calcium in ash deposits exhibit nonmonotonic variations as the deposit probe temperature varies between 400 and 800 °C. Quartz and calcium sulfate are main crystalline phases in ash deposit of Zhundong coals. Calcium is inclined to present as calcite and lime at low deposition temperature, while high temperature facilitates calcium sulfation. Sodium of crystalline phase is found as albite and sodium sulfate at low deposition temperature. Both condensation of gaseous alkali metals and formation of low-melting minerals were responsible for the ash deposition phenomenon on convection heat exchanger surfaces involved in combustion of Zhundong coal. The sodium content in ash deposit decreases considerably with the increasing combustion temperature while the case of iron variation is opposite due to its low-volatility. In addition, the Na content in ash deposits increases obviously with the access air ratio reduced from 1.2 to 1.05, but the local weakly reducing atmosphere leads to less iron within ash deposits. Clarification of sodium migration and evaluation of ash deposition behaviors during combustion of Zhundong coal is helpful for a better exploration of the functional mechanism of ash deposit and then large-scale utilization of high-sodium coals.     

Effects of coal characteristics to performance of a highly efficient thermal power generation system based on pressurized oxy‐fuel combustion

Because of its fuel flexibility and high efficiency, pressurized oxy‐fuel combustion has recently emerged as a promising approach for efficient carbon capture and storage. One of the important options to design the pressurized oxy‐combustion is to determine method of coal (or other solid fuels) feeding: dry feeding or wet (coal slurry) feeding as well as grade of coals. The main aim of this research is to investigate effects of coal characteristics including wet or dry feeding on the performance of thermal power plant based on the pressurized oxy‐combustion with CO₂ capture versus atmospheric oxy‐combustion. A commercial process simulation tool (gCCS: the general carbon capture and storage) was used to simulate and analyze an advanced ultra‐supercritical(A‐USC) coal power plant under pressurized and atmospheric oxy‐fuel conditions. The design concept is based on using pure oxygen as an oxidant in a pressurized system to maximize the heat recovery through process integration and to reduce the efficiency penalty because of compression and purification units. The results indicate that the pressurized case efficiency at 30 bars was greater than the atmospheric oxy‐fuel combustion (base line case) by 6.02% when using lignite coal firing. Similarly, efficiency improvements in the case of subbituminous and bituminous coals were around 3% and 2.61%, respectively. The purity of CO₂ increased from 53.4% to 94% after compression and purification. In addition, the study observed the effects of coal‐water slurry using bituminous coal under atmospheric conditions, determining that the net plant efficiency decreased by 3.7% when the water content in the slurry increased from 11.12% to 54%. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Modeling the behavior of selenium in Pulverized-Coal Combustion systems

The behavior of Se during coal combustion is different from other trace metals because of the high degree of vaporization and high vapor pressures of the oxide (SeO₂) in coal flue gas. In a coal-fired boiler, these gaseous oxides are absorbed on the fly ash surface in the convective section by a chemical reaction. The composition of the fly ash (and of the parent coal) as well as the time-temperature history in the boiler therefore influences the formation of selenium compounds on the surface of the fly ash. A model was created for interactions between selenium and fly ash post-combustion. The reaction mechanism assumed that iron reacts with selenium at temperatures above 1200 °C and that calcium reacts with selenium at temperatures less than 800 °C. The model also included competing reactions of SO₂ with calcium and iron in the ash. Predicted selenium distributions in fly ash (concentration versus particle size) were compared against measurements from pilot-scale experiments for combustion of six coals, four bituminous and two low-rank coals. The model predicted the selenium distribution in the fly ash from the pilot-scale experiments reasonably well for six coals of different compositions.     

Mineral transformation during combustion of coal blends

Mineral behaviour for two individual coals (I, J) and their two‐component coal blends and 800°C ash blends heating were studied. Ash samples were heated progressively from 800°C to IT (initial deformation temperature) at 100°C intervals under different conditions. Coal samples were heated from room temperature to the corresponding temperature. Mineral transformation at each temperature was determined by X‐ray diffraction and SEM measurements. The results show that Si, Al, Fe and Ca compounds have a great form variation during heating. Their forms at different temperatures depend on the chemical composition of the ash, the blending ratio and the atmosphere. For different coal ashes, the main mineral matters at 800°C were quartz, anhydrite, hematite, calcite and feldspar. As the temperature increased, oxidation, thermal decomposition, transformation and reaction occurred between the components. Comparing a 40% I+60% J ash blend with individual ashes, fayalite was formed at 1100°C for the blend; the reaction product existed in a glassy phase at 1300°C. For a coal blend having the same ash ratio as the ash blend, FeO reacted with amorphous SiO₂ or Al₂O₃ to form fayalite and hercynite at 1000°C. As the temperature increased to 1100°C, fayalite and hercynite increased obviously. At 1200°C, some iron inclusion compounds melted to become glassy phase matter. Compared with the ash blend, iron species undergo a different change during coal blend heating: fayalite and hercynite formed earlier, iron compounds melted to form a glassy phase at lower temperature. This may be caused by early combustion of the more reactive coal (J coal) in the blend inducing local variation in oxygen concentration gradients around the less reactive coal and consequently affecting the reaction atmosphere and Fe mineral behaviour and interaction. That is to say, for coal blends, the mineral transformation was affected by both the mineral species interaction and the combustion behaviour. The calculations were performed to examine the fate of mineral matter under different combustion conditions using a thermodynamic chemical equilibrium calculation program. Calculations from coal blends were comparable with experiments from ash blends, this is because the calculation program only considers the interaction among the mineral species but does not consider the combustion reaction. It indicates that combustion and the relative volatiles also affected the mineral behaviour and slagging during coal blend combustion. Meanwhile, the mineral species evaporations were measured at high temperature: the main evaporated species were Na, K pure species and compounds, Fe, FeO, SiO and SiO₂. The evaporation of Fe has an important effect on initial deposition. Calculations were comparable with the experiments. Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Biomass as a reburning fuel: a specialized cofiring application

Reaction Engineering International has performed a series of combustion tests to evaluate the potential for utilizing wood biomass as a reburn fuel for nitrogen oxides (NO_x) control. Reburning is an effective NO_x reduction technology that utilizes fuel injection above the main burner zone. Studies with other hydrocarbon fuels such as coal and natural gas as reburn fuels have shown that NO_x emissions can be reduced by more than 50–60% with about 15% of the heat input coming from the reburn fuel. Two different biomasses, a hardwood and softwood, were evaluated as reburning fuels and compared to coal and natural gas. The use of wood to reduce NO_x is attractive for several reasons. First, wood contains little nitrogen, as compared with coal which is also used as a reburning fuel. This results in lower NO_x production from fuel nitrogen species for wood. In addition, wood contains virtually no sulfur, so sulfur dioxide (SO₂) emissions are reduced in direct proportion to the coal replacement. Wood is a regenerable biofuel; when a fossil fuel is replaced by a biofuel, there is a net reduction in carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions. Finally, since the reburning fuel is normally 10–20% of the total heat input, large quantities of wood are not necessary. Experimental results showed NO_x reductions of as high as 70% were obtained with approximately 10–15% wood heat input. The stoichiometric ratio in the reburn zone was the single most important variable affecting NO_x reduction. The highest reductions were found at a reburn stoichiometric ratio of 0.85. NO_x reduction fell to about 40–50% at slightly higher stoichiometric ratios (0.9x reduction was strongly dependent on initial NO_x concentration and only slightly dependent upon temperature, where increased temperature increased NO_x reduction. Finally, the experimental results suggest that wood is as effective as natural gas or coal as a reburning fuel. In addition, REI has completed computer simulations of a full-scale boiler to evaluate the conditions that maximize the NO_x reduction efficiency using biomass as the reburn fuel. Computer modeling of the TVA Allen Station Unit 3, a 265 MW_e cyclone-fired boiler, showed that NO_x reductions as high as 50–60% could be achieved within the constraints set by the boiler and operations. The most important parameters affecting final NO_x emissions are the cyclone barrel stoichiometry, residence time in the reburn zone, and mixing in both the reburn and overfire air zones. The combination of computer simulations and experimental programs has provided the engineers with the tools needed to optimize biomass as a reburn fuel to maximize NO_x reduction.     

混煤煤质及燃烧特性研究

针对混煤的煤质特性和燃烧特性开展实验研究,以指导燃煤电站科学合理的燃用混煤。研究结果表明,混煤的元素分析、工业分析及发热量满足质量加权平均,但混煤的可磨性和灰熔融特性不满足加权平均,低灰熔点煤中掺烧高灰熔点煤能显著提高混煤灰熔点,改善锅炉燃烧过程中的结渣问题,混煤灰熔点变化受到单煤灰成分的影响。热重实验分析表明,混煤的剧烈燃烧阶段与单煤存在明显差异,混煤的燃烧特性介于参与掺混的单煤之间,但不满足线性叠加,其燃烧过程存在着不同程度的交互作用。混煤的着火特性接近于易燃煤,而燃尽特性与难燃煤相近。除此以外,随着氧浓度的降低,混煤的燃烧特性明显变差,易燃煤对氧浓度的变化更加敏感。     

Experimental study of the combustion efficiency and formation of NOx in an industrial pulverized coal combustor

With horizontal bias combustion burners, experiments have been carried out on a 670 t h^?1, corner‐fired, pulverized‐coal fired boiler burning bituminous coal. At 200 MWe load, the furnace excess O₂ remains stable. The different horizontal fuel biases are obtained by changing the tilt angle of all the Louvre enrichers' regulating blades. The tilt angles of the blades are 0, 15, 24, 32°; the result is that the enriching ratios of the fuel‐rich primary air increase from 2.2 to 2.6 at No. 2 corner, and from 1.2 to 4.2 at No. 3 corner. The gas temperature increases in the burner region. The application of the horizontal bias combustion burners results in a reduction in NO_x formation from 545.7 mg Nm^?3 (O₂=6%) to 287.9 mg Nm^?3, and a substantial reduction in carbon in ash content from 5.24 to 2.48%. The boiler operated stably at a load of 80 MWe without auxiliary fuel oil. Copyright © 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Evaluation of feasibility of pelletized wood co-firing with high ash Indian coals

To reduce anthropogenic CO₂ emissions from power plants, biomass is an immediate alternative fuel which has similar properties as coal. In this regard, the present study discusses about pelletized wood (PW) co-firing with high ash Indian coal by conducting co-milling and co-firing trials in a 1000 kg/hr of pilot scale test facility. Indian coals are typically high ash content and low calorific value fuels, therefore, its interaction with coal during combustion and ash deposition have studied in detail. Based on co-milling trails of PW and coal, it was observed that as PW proportion in coal increases, the quantity of particles of size below 50 μm and as well above 500 μm were increased. From co-firing studies, it was observed that higher volatile content in PW helping in stabilizing flames while co-firing. At lower proportions, up to 10% weight PW co-firing with coal, the flame temperature and heat flux values are very close to base test of 100% coal firing. However, beyond 10% by weight of PW co-firing with coal, the flame temperature and heat flux values were increased significantly from 100% coal tests. This is because of higher calorific value of PW than coal. The CO emission was decreased with increase in PW proportion in coal but at 30% of PW in coal, CO emission was increased suddenly. However, NO and SO₂ concentrations were decreased up to 8% and 16% respectively with increase in PW proportion in coal due to lower fuel nitrogen and sulphur content in PW than coal. Analytical analysis of slagging indices suggest that the slagging potential for PW co-firing with coal is increasing as the PW proportion in coal increases.     

再燃燃料超细煤粉燃尽特性的实验研究

超细煤粉作为燃料分级燃烧技术中的再燃燃料具有可行性,可有效降低NOx的排放,由于再燃区和燃尽区的反应比较复杂,存在再燃燃料燃尽效果不稳定的现象.从煤种、粒度、过量空气系数、氧浓度、炉膛温度等几个因素分析,认为针对不同的煤种,合适的空气流量和燃尽区炉膛温度是提高再燃燃料燃尽的必要条件.     

The effect of air staged combustion on NOx emissions in dried lignite combustion

Experiments were carried out in a multi-path air inlet one-dimensional furnace to assess NOx emission characteristics of the staged combustion of BRXL lignite and its dried coals. The impact of moisture content, multiple air staging, pulverized coal fineness and burnout air position on NOx emissions under deep, middle and shallow air-staged combustion conditions. Moreover, the impact of blending coals on NOx emissions was investigated in this paper. The unburned carbon concentration in fly ash was also tested. Experimental results based on the combustion of BRXL lignite and its dried coals show that NOx emissions can be reduced drastically by air-staged combustion. NOx emissions reduce with the increase of the air that is staged and the distance between the burner and burnout air position. Dried coal of BRXL lignite emits a smaller amount of NOx than that of BRXL lignite. However, the dried degree of BRXL lignite is closely related to R₉₀ fineness. Dried coal with optimal moisture content yields least NOx emissions. When deep or middle staged combustion was adopted, the application of multi-staged combustion is conducive to NOx reduction. However, when shallow staged combustion was adopted, NOx emissions are higher in multi-staged combustion than that in single-staged combustion with M_S = 0.54. Thus, the existence of a certain concentration of O₂ in reduction zone would significantly reduce NOx emissions. The blending coals that dried coals of BRXL lignite were blended with bituminous coals emit a larger amount of NOx than that of the dried coal alone. NOx emissions decrease with the increase of the proportion of dried coal in the blending coal. Moreover, the unburned carbon concentration in fly ash of dried coal in staged combustion is lower than that of BRXL lignite in staged combustion. On the whole, the dried coal of BRXL lignite is conducive to NOx reduction in staged combustion.     

飞灰回燃对燃烧福建无烟煤CFB锅炉运行影响的研究

利用热天平实验研究了飞灰碳厦其入炉煤的反应性，从理论上分析了飞灰回燃对CFB锅炉燃烧效率的影响，并通过工业试验测试了回燃飞灰量对锅炉返料器运行温度、飞灰的粒度分布及其含碳量、锅炉燃烧效率及其它运行参数的影响。研究表明，燃烧福建无烟煤CFB锅炉飞灰碳的反应性高于其对应入炉煤。回燃飞灰的含碳量、回燃飞灰量与入炉煤量的比值等参数对锅炉燃烧效率有重要影响。采取飞灰回燃技术有利于降低飞灰含碳、降低返料器运行温度和提高锅炉燃烧效率，但当回燃飞灰量较大时会影响锅炉的稳定运行。     

Detailed modeling of hybrid reburn/SNCR processes for NOX reduction in coal-fired furnaces

Mechanism reduction has made the detailed kinetic modeling of combustion problems much easier; it also offers potential improvement of modeling accuracy and flexibility in comparison to global mechanisms. The present work applies mechanism reduction in conjunction with the CHEMKIN library and develops an automatic reduction program code. Regarding the hybrid re-burn/selective non-catalytic reduction (SNCR) (“advanced re-burning”) conditions in coal-fired furnaces and based on a full mechanism “GADM98,” a skeletal mechanism with 39 species, 105 reactions, and further a 10-step/14-species reduced mechanism were established. The reduced mechanism was implemented into a 3D-combustion computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code. The eddy-dissipation-concept model was used to describe the influence of turbulence on the combustion chemistry. A large number of simulations for reburning and hybrid reburn/SNCR processes in a coal-fired reactor were executed; the predicted results were compared with experimental measurements. The reduced mechanism and the comprehensive modeling give quite satisfactory results over a wide range of mole ratios for β = [NH₃]/[NO] and air/fuel equivalence ratios λ₂ in the reburn zone. From the modeling results, it was found that adding ammonia premixed with reburn fuel (CH₄) effects no further reduction of NO_x or even impairs the reduction efficiency compared to pure reburning, and in contrast, staged addition of ammonia downstream of the CH₄ injection in the reburn zone provokes a significant further reduction of NO_x over a wide range of parameters. According to the predictions, NO_x-reduction rates of 50-60% and of 70-80% can be achieved through pure reburning and hybrid reburn/SNCR approaches, respectively, at λ₂ = 0.95 and β = 1.5. Concerning the computational procedure, essential measures were taken to optimize convergence and computing time. The computing time with the present reduced mechanism is ∼2.5 times that with the traditional global mechanism for the same iteration number. Tabulation of the rate constants reduced the computing time of the reaction kinetics by ∼50%.     

Synergy effects of co-firing wooden biomass with Bosnian coal

The paper presents synergy effects found during the co-firing of wooden biomass with Bosnian coal types in an experimental reactor. The co-firing tests used spruce sawdust in combination with Kakanj brown coal and a lignite blend of Dubrave lignite and Sikulje lignite. Coal/biomass mixtures at 93:7 and 80:20 wt% were fired in a 20 kW pulverized fuel (PF) entrained flow reactor. Over 20 test trials were performed to investigate ash deposition behavior and emissions under different conditions, varying the process temperature, excess air ratio, and air distribution. During the tests, the temperature in the experimental facility varied between 880 and 1550 °C, while the excess air ratio varied between 0.95 and 1.4. There was sufficient combustion efficiency under all co-firing regimes, with burning out at 96.5–99.5% for brown coal–sawdust co-firing. Synergy effects were detected for all co-firing regimes with regard to SO₂ emission, as well for slagging at the process temperature suitable for the slag tap furnace. CO₂ emissions were also calculated for the blends tested and significant reductions of CO₂ found, due to the very low ranking of Bosnian coals.     

Elemental characterization of Nigerian coals and their ashes using particle induced X-ray emission (PIXE) spectrometry for environmental pollution assessment

Nigerian coals and their ashes were investigated using PIXE spectrometry to ascertain their elemental composition, characterize and correlate them, and to determine their environmental risk assessment when combusted. Eleven and 18 elements detected in the raw coals and the ashes, respectively, were subjected to appropriate statistical analyses. Mean elemental summation (%) of the coals and ashes were 8.4 and 39.0, respectively, while average % ash content was 29.6, indicating that they were rich in potential toxic elements which could be emitted into the environment during coal combustion. This was corroborated by t-test results. It is found that pollution index (PI) values for V, Co, Mn, Ni, Cu, and Zn in the coal ash are greater than 1.0. This implies that combustion coal/coal ash may serve as a source of toxic element pollution in environmental media which could produce ill-health. Cross-plot analysis results showed moderate positive correlations, suggesting inter-element correlations among the samples, establishing relationships among the coals. This was validated by the clustering analysis results which indicated three major groups which were also fairly correlated with one another, signifying similar genetic origin. Elemental clustering indicated closest inter-element association among transition metals. This was also confirmed by their Pearson correlation matrices results, indicating chemical affinity and/or similar genetic origin.     

Numerical Investigation of Reburning Flow in a Carbon Monoxide Boiler

This study investigates the combustion and fluid flow in a carbon monoxide boiler from the Formosa Petrochemical Corporation in Taiwan, with emphasis on the effect of reburning on NOx reduction. It is found that NOx reduction occurs mainly behind the DeNOx section where recirculation is strong. A smaller reburn hole yields better NOx reduction while a larger reburn hole yields worse NOx reduction and a localized high temperature region near the reburn hole. NOx reduction is better for a lower primary/reburn fuel ratio and a higher inlet/reburn air ratio. A single-reburn-hole arrangement yields lower NOx concentration and temperature than does a three-reburn-hole arrangement.     

The efficiency of heat transfer through the ash deposits on the heat exchange surfaces by burning coal and coal-water fuels

The results of the numerical simulation of heat transfer from the combustion products of coal and coal-water fuels (CWF) to the internal environment. The mathematical simulation has been carried out on the sample of the pipe surfaces of the combustion chamber of the boiler unit. The change in the characteristics of heat transfer (change of thermochemical characteristics) in the conditions of formation of the ash deposits have been taken into account. According to the results of the numerical simulation, the comparative analysis of the efficiency of heat transfer has been carried out from the furnace environment to the inside pipe coolant (water, air, or water vapor) from the combustion of coal and coal-water fuels. It has been established that, in the initial period of the boiler unit operation during coal fuel combustion the efficiency of heat transfer from the combustion products of the internal environment is higher than when using CWF. The efficiency of heat transfer in CWF combustion conditions is more at large times (t ≥ 1.5 h) of the boiler unit. According to the results the numerical simulation of the temperature distributions in the system “pipeline environment — pipe wall — a layer of ash — the products of combustion” have been obtained. A significant decrease in heat flux from the combustion products to the inside pipe coolant in the case of coal combustion compared to CWF has been found. It has been proved that this is due primarily to the fact that massive and strong ash deposits are formed during coal combustion.