Computed tomography and positron emission tomography in the pre-operative staging of oesophageal carcinoma

Because patients with carcinoma of the oesophagus usually present with advanced disease and surgery has a high mortality with cure in less than 10% of patients, pre-operative staging to select appropriate patients is necessary. Computed tomography (CT) plays an important role in staging but has well recognized limitations. Positron emission tomography (PET) which provides physiological information may therefore be a better alternative. OBJECTIVE: To compare the findings of CT and positron emission tomography (PET) with 2-[18fluorine]-fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose (FDG) in the pre-operative staging of oesophageal carcinoma. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty-five patients with biopsy proven oesophageal cancer had pre-operative staging using CT and FDG-PET. The studies were read independently and full histological confirmation was obtained in 19 patients. Four parameters were studied: the primary tumour, peri-oesophageal lymph nodes, liver metastases and left gastric lymph nodes. RESULTS: PET visualized all primary tumours; CT missed one. CT identified 4/8 patients with involved peri-oesophageal nodes and PET 3/8. CT identified 5/9 patients with left gastric adenopathy and PET 1/9. PET visualized a liver metastasis missed on CT and appeared to be better in assessing residual tumour. PET did identify distant metastases not seen on CT in seven patients. CONCLUSIONS: The two techniques are both effective in showing the primary tumour and about equally sensitive in the demonstration of peri-oesophageal nodes. PET is probably more sensitive than CT for the detection of distant metastases.     

Whole-body 2-[18F]-fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose positron emission tomography (FDG-PET) for accurate staging of Hodgkin's disease

BACKGROUND: Staging of Hodgkin's disease (HD) is accomplished by a variety of invasive and non-invasive modalities. This prospective study was undertaken to investigate the value of whole-body positron emission tomography (PET) with 2-[18F]-fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose (FDG) in defining regions involved by lymphoma compared with conventional staging methods in patients with HD. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Fourty-four newly diagnosed patients with HD underwent FDG-PET as part of their initial staging work-up. PET findings were correlated with findings of conventional staging including computed tomography, ultrasound, bone scanning, bone marrow biopsy, liver biopsy and laparotomy. When results of FDG-PET differed to those obtained by conventional methods reevaluation was performed by biopsy, if possible, or magnetic resonance imaging. RESULTS: The results of FDG-PET were compared with three hundred twenty-one conventional staging procedures performed in 44 patients. FDG-PET was positive in 38 of 44 (86%) patients at sites of documented disease. PET detected additional lesions in five cases previously not identified by conventional staging methods. In another case a nodal lesion suspect on CT was negative at FDG-PET and was settled as true negative by biopsy. As a consequence of PET findings five patients had to be upstaged and one patient had to be downstaged, resulting in changes in treatment strategy in all six cases (14%). FDG-PET failed to visualize sites of HD in four patients. In two of our patients a false positive PET result was obtained. CONCLUSIONS: Our data indicate that FDG-PET provides an imaging technique that appears to visualize involved lesions in most patients with HD and is useful in the management of these patients.     

Lymphoma: role of whole-body 2-deoxy-2-[F-18]fluoro-D-glucose (FDG) PET in nodal staging

PURPOSE: To compare 2-deoxy-2-[fluorine-18]fluoro-D-glucose (FDG) positron emission tomography (PET) with computed tomography (CT) in primary nodal staging of malignant lymphoma. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Sixty consecutive patients with untreated, histopathologically proved malignant lymphoma (aged 7-72 years; 33 with non-Hodgkin lymphoma, 27 with Hodgkin disease) underwent FDG PET and contrast material-enhanced CT for nodal staging. Lymph node regions identified at both CT and PET were regarded as actual locations of disease. Discordant results were verified with biopsy or clinical follow-up whenever possible. RESULTS: One hundred sixty of 740 evaluated lymph node regions were identified as diseased at both CT and PET. Of the 25 additional regions seen with PET, seven were true-positive; two, false-positive; and 16, unresolved. CT showed six additional disease manifestations; three were false-positive, and three were unresolved. Staging was changed in the four patients with the seven confirmed additional PET findings: from stage I to II in one patient and from stage II to III in three patients. Staging was changed from stage II to I in one of the three patients with false-positive CT findings. CONCLUSION: FDG PET may be more accurate for detecting nodal lymphoma than incremental CT.     

Detection of extrathoracic metastases by positron emission tomography in lung cancer

BACKGROUND: Accurate staging of non-small cell lung cancer is essential for treatment planning. We evaluated in a prospective study the role of whole-body 2-[18F]fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose (FDG) positron emission tomography (PET) in mediastinal nodal staging with a positive predictive value of 96%. The study was continued to further evaluate the value of whole-body FDG PET in detecting unexpected extrathoracic metastases (ETMs) in patients qualifying for surgical treatment by conventional staging. METHODS: One hundred patients underwent clinical evaluation, chest and upper abdominal computed tomography scan, mediastinoscopy (lymph nodes greater than 1 cm on computed tomography), and routine laboratory tests. In 94 patients with stage IIIa or less and 6 with suspected N3 a whole-body FDG PET was performed. If clinical signs of ETMs were present additional diagnostic methods were applied. All findings in the FDG PET were confirmed histologically or radiologically. RESULTS: Unexpected ETMs were detected in 13 (14%) of 94 patients (stage IIIa or less) at 14 sites. In addition 6 of 94 patients were restaged up to N3 after PET. The suspected N3 disease (stage IIIb) on computed tomography was confirmed by PET in all 6 patients. There was no false positive finding of ETM. Weight loss was correlated with the occurrence of ETM: more than 5 kg, 5 of 13 patients (38%); more than 10 kg, 4 of 6 patients (67%). Pathologic laboratory findings were not predictive for ETM. CONCLUSIONS: Whole-body FDG PET improves detection of ETMs in patients with non-small cell lung cancer otherwise elegible for operation. In 14% of patients (stage IIIa or less), ETMs were detected, and in total, 20% of the patients were understaged.     

Cost effectiveness analysis of FDG-PET in the differential diagnosis and staging of lung cancer in Japan

Several studies have shown that FDG-PET is more accurate than CT for the differential diagnosis and for the staging of lung cancer. We have analyzed potential effect of FDG-PET on the medical cost for the management of patients suspected of lung cancer. In the differential diagnosis, chest CT plus FDG-PET protocol reduced the number of bronchofiberscope (BFS) and biopsy by one fourth of that in the conventional protocol using CT alone. PET protocol reduced unnecessary examinations for the patients of benign disease, however, it increased the total cost of examinations by 25% due to the higher cost of PET than that of BFS and biopsy in Japan. In the staging of lung cancer, PET protocol improved accuracy of staging, reduced unnecessary surgery by 67%, and showed a saving of the cost of examination by 5%, and the total medical cost by 2.5% compared to that in the conventional protocol using CT, brain MRI, and bone scan. Conclusion: Use of FDG-PET for the staging may contribute to the improvement of patient management of lung cancer patients also to the saving of the medical cost.     

Imaging of mediastinal lymph nodes: CT, MR, and FDG PET

The evaluation of mediastinal lymph nodes is an important aspect of staging in patients with non-small cell lung cancer. Anatomic imaging of lymph nodes with computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance (MR) imaging has been limited by the relatively low sensitivity and specificity of these techniques. Advances in physiologic imaging of mediastinal lymph nodes with 2-[fluorine-18] fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose (FDG) positron emission tomography (PET) have resulted in improved diagnostic accuracy in the determination of nodal status. Despite the limitations of CT, this technique still plays an important role by aiding in the selection of the most appropriate procedure for staging, by guiding biopsy, and by providing anatomic information for visual correlation with FDG PET images. At present, anatomic MR imaging of lymph nodes is primarily a problem-solving tool for cases with inconclusive CT results. Physiologic MR imaging with iron oxide is an exciting area of investigation, and the accuracy of this technique is being assessed in clinical trials. Anatomic and physiologic imaging techniques should be considered complementary rather than competitive imaging strategies.     

Planar coincidence scintigraphy and PET in staging malignant melanoma

This study describes a comparison of simulated planar positron coincidence scintigraphy (PCS) with PET in the whole-body staging of patients with malignant melanoma using 2-18F-fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose (FDG). METHODS: In 55 patients with either known metastatic or newly diagnosed malignant melanoma, whole-body PET scanning was performed on a conventional full-ring dedicated PET tomograph, and multiaxial sections were obtained. Furthermore, anteroposterior projection images simulating images of a dual-head Anger camera operating in coincidence mode were obtained from the PET raw data. Each study was evaluated separately and blindly. Imaging findings were confirmed by biopsy or by at least one imaging modality in addition to PET. RESULTS: A total of 108 lesions were evaluated, of which 76 proved to be melanoma metastases. Whole-body PET correctly demonstrated 68 metastases, 6 lesions were classified as questionable metastases and 2 were missed. Whole-body PCS correctly demonstrated 14 metastases, 22 lesions were classified as questionable metastases and 40 metastases were missed. The sensitivities of whole-body PET and whole-body PCS were 89% and 18%, respectively. In PCS lesions in regions of high background activity, such as in the abdomen, were missed more often than in PET (p < 0.05). The tumor-to-background contrast was generally lower in PCS than in PET. A further decrease in PCS detection was found in lesions of < 22 mm in diameter. CONCLUSION: The lack of sensitivity precludes the clinical use of whole-body PCS in staging malignant melanoma.     

Acute therapy of episodic and chronic cluster headache with sumatriptan s.c. Results of a one-year long-term study

Breast cancer is the commonest malignancy to affect women. The malignant process may present clinicians with problems in establishing the diagnosis expeditiously, accurately staging the disease and assessing tumour response to primary systemic chemotherapy. Considerable recent interest has focused on the application of imaging techniques that utilize tumour-specific gamma-ray-emitting radiopharmaceuticals to resolve these problems. The wide availability of gamma camera systems makes single photon-imaging techniques, using radiopharmaceuticals incorporating conventional isotopes, attractive options. However, results concerning the detection of the primary breast cancer and the staging of axillary lymph nodes suggest that these techniques would appear to offer no significant advantages, when compared with those obtained using standard diagnostic methods. Dual gamma-ray-emission imaging by positron emission tomography (PET) may offer an alternative solution. Studies performed show that PET can accurately detect primary breast cancers, stage locoregional lymph nodes and visualize distant tumour metastases. Furthermore, PET may be able to monitor early tumour response to chemotherapy agents. It would appear, therefore, that dual gamma emission might have an important role to play in the management of patients with breast cancer.     

Neck dissection in the treatment of cancer of major salivary glands

We investigated the use of PET and 2[18F]fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose (FDG) for detection and therapy control of metastatic germ cell cancer in comparison to CT. METHODS: Fifty-four PET studies were performed in addition to CT in 33 patients with histopathologically proven germ cell tumors (14 seminomas, 18 nonseminomas, 1 not classified). The scans were done either after initial diagnosis (Group 1; n = 12), within 2 wk after completion of chemotherapy (Group 2; n = 13) or 14-375 days after chemotherapy (Group 3; n = 29). PET and CT were validated either by histology (n = 19) or clinical follow-up for 182-1704 days (n = 35). Focal pathological uptake with PET was quantified using standardized uptake values (SUVs). RESULTS: PET was significantly more accurate than CT (0.86 versus 0.59; p < 0.025) for detection of residual viable tumor in Group 3. While sensitivities of PET and CT did not differ markedly, PET was significantly more specific than CT. No significant differences between PET and CT were found in Groups 1 and 2. PET scans after therapy resulted in false-negative findings in five of nine cases of Group 2 but only in two of nine cases of Group 3. False-positive PET findings occurred in three inflammatory processes. SUV of seminomas was significantly higher than in nonseminomas (p < 0.01). CONCLUSION: PET using FDG is superior to CT for assessment of residual tumor after chemotherapy of germ cell cancer and may thus have an increased effect on patient management in the future. PET must be performed at least 2 wk after completion of therapy. Further data are necessary to determine the role of FDG PET for initial staging of germ cell cancer.     

Positron emission tomography (PET) and (F-18)-fluorodeoxyglucose in (FDG) in cancerology

Positron emission tomography (PET) with 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) is a scintigraphic imaging technique undergoing a rapid growth in the field of oncology. The constant progress of the detectors, either CDET or PET dedicated cameras, allows to obtain in routine conditions images with a 5 mm spatial resolution. Absolute tracer uptake quantification is also possible, which allows to evaluate objectively therapy efficacy. The mechanisms of FDG tissular accumulation are now better understood. Increase of glycolysis and of transmembrane transport of glucose seems to be at the origin of the high tumorous accumulation of FDG. The main current oncologic application of FDG PET is the diagnosis of malignancy of the isolated pulmonary nodules, with a sensitivity of more than 95%, and in the staging of lung cancer where PET shows higher performances than conventional imaging. The same stands in cutaneous melanoma and for malignancies of the digestive tract, either in colorectal, pancreatic or esophageal localizations. In colorectal cancers, the role of PET has for long being recognized in the differential diagnosis between recurrence and postoperative fibrosis. In the head and neck tumors, FDG also allows to differentiate between recurrence and postradiation necrosis. In lymphoma, the most suitable site for biopsy can be identified on a PET scan and therapy efficacy can also be assessed. In breast cancer, the detection of metastases seems to be possible with FDG. In brain and thyroid cancers, the role of FDG PET remains to be further determined. The low uptake of FDG in prostate cancer metastasis is not in favor of its use in this indication. In conclusion, the indications of FDG PET in oncology are now becoming more precise and it can be expected that clinical PET centers will soon appear in France.     

Genetic analysis of protein C deficiency in nineteen Japanese families: five recurrent defects can explain half of the deficiencies

OBJECTIVE: The lack of sensitivity and specificity of conventional imaging techniques based on morphological critera is responsible for considerable limitations in the staging and surveillance of oral cancer. Therefore, this study investigates the contribution of [F18]-2-fluordesoxyglucose (FDG) positron emission tomography (PET) to tumor management with special regard to lymphnode involvement and therapeutic monitoring after radiotherapy. DESIGN: Prospective observational study. PATIENTS: Twenty-one patients with advanced oral cancer, predominantly T3/T4. INTERVENTION: FDG-PET scans before and after preoperative radio(chemo)therapy. Standardized uptake values (SUV) were determined for the tumor site and lymphnode areas. PET scans were correlated to histological findings after ablative tumor surgery. RESULTS: FDG-PET yielded superior sensitivity and specificity for tumor and lymphnode assessment. The effect of radiotherapy was reflected by the metabolic activity of the tumor, which shows a close correlation between the decrease of FDG uptake and histologic tumor regression. PET detected distant metastases and simultaneous tumors. CONCLUSION: FDG-PET is a challenging imaging technique with the potential to improve staging procedures for oral cancer. In the monitoring of metabolic activity of the tumor in the course of radio(chemo)therapy, FDG-PET allows objective measurement of the treatment response.     

FDG-PET in the staging of malignant melanoma

Positron emission tomography (PET scanning) is a useful tool in staging of malignant melanoma. A radiolabelled glucoseanalogue can demonstrate changes in metabolism and thus identify malignancy in macroscopic unchanged structures. It is a non-invasive, fast method to identify especially visceral, still symptomless metastases. The patient can often be spared from mutilating surgery.     

Detection of paraneoplastic anti-neuronal autoantibodies on paraffin-embedded tissues

Although the detection of pancreatic carcinoma has been considerably improved by recently developed imaging procedures, differential diagnosis between cancer and benign tumor masses, as well as lymph node staging, is still difficult. In vivo evaluation of regional glucose metabolism by means of positron emission tomography (PET) and fluorine-18-labelled fluorode-oxyglucose (FDG) is a new approach utilizing metabolic instead of morphological tumor properties for diagnosis. PATIENTS AND METHODS. A total of 85 patients with suspected pancreatic carcinoma were investigated by FDG-PET prior to surgery. Static PET scans were evaluated visually as well as quantitatively, taking increased FDG uptake as a sign of malignancy. PET results were correlated with intraoperative findings and histopathology of surgical specimens. RESULTS. Forty-seven out of 55 (85%) malignant tumors and 23 out of 30 (77%) benign lesions were correctly classified by PET. Lymph node metastases were present in 31 patients, 19 of them (61%) positive in PET. In 7 our of 13 (54%) patients with liver metastases, PET detected hypermetabolic lesions. False-negative findings were mainly due to disturbance of glucose metabolism in diabetic patients, while most false-positive results could be attributed to acute inflammatory lesions in chronic pancreatitis. CONCLUSIONS. Our results indicate that classification of pancreatic masses can be improved by use of FDG-PET, which might lead to a reduction of unnecessary laparotomies in patients with benign or incurable disease.     

Current role of positron emission tomography in thoracic oncology

Continuing advances in PET imaging have resulted in an improved ability to evaluate thoracic malignancies. Published reports demonstrate that PET provides accurate, non-invasive detection and staging of thoracic malignancy. Preliminary studies suggest that PET may also be able to assess the therapeutic response accurately. The studies investigating PET have been relatively small but have shown statistically significant advantages over conventional non-invasive techniques in accuracy and possibly even cost/benefit performance in thoracic malignancies.     

Bronchial carcinoma: new radiologic methods

New imaging techniques, technical modifications, and new applications of established imaging techniques are discussed with regard to their cost-effectiveness in improving the end result (cure, survival, quality of life). In detecting lung cancer, two methods seem most likely to overcome the known limits of chest radiography: digital radiography with postprocessing and, for risk groups, low-dose CT. Specific diagnosis depends on detection of tiny calcifications, increased vascularization (CT, MRI) or metabolic activity (PET). Clinical staging will be improved by very short time acquisition (MRI), combination of morphologic and biological information (cross sectional techniques) and by observing metabolic activity (PET).     

Improved retroperitoneal and gastrointestinal sonography using oral contrast agents in a porcine model

PURPOSE: To evaluate use of functional imaging with positron emission tomography (PET) versus computed tomography (CT) for detection of extranodal lymphoma spread. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Eighty-one consecutive and previously untreated patients with malignant non-Hodgkin lymphoma (n = 43) or Hodgkin disease (n = 38) were examined with 2-[fluorine-18]fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose (FDG) PET and contrast material-enhanced CT. Concordant findings at both CT and FDG PET were regarded as actual locations of disease; discordant results were resolved on the basis of biopsy or follow-up results when possible. RESULTS: Forty-two lesions were identified at both PET and CT, and 19 were verified with biopsy results. PET demonstrated a further 24 lesions. Verification was possible in 15 of these lesions with biopsy (n = 10), magnetic resonance imaging (n = 1), scintigraphic (n = 1), or follow-up (n = 3) results. In 14 of these 15 lesions, PET findings were confirmed (bone marrow, nine; spleen, three; other, two). Seven lesions not visualized at FDG PET were identified at CT, six of which were verified with biopsy (n = 2) or follow-up (n = 4) results. Five of these six CT findings were found to be erroneous. In 13 patients, PET findings led to changes in tumor staging. CONCLUSION: PET may provide more information about extranodal lymphoma than does incremental CT.     

A comparative analysis of the existing standards for exposure to ultraviolet radiation

Medical imaging technology is rapidly expanding and the role of each modality is being redefined constantly. PET has been around since the early sixties and gained clinical acceptance in oncology only after an extreme number of scientific publications. Although PET has the unique ability to image biochemical processes in vivo, this ability is not fully used as a clinical imaging tool. In this overview, the role of PET in relation to other tumor imaging modalities will be discussed and the reported results in the literature will be reviewed. In predicting the future of PET, technical improvements of other imaging modalities need to be dealt with. The fundamental physical principles for image formation with computed tomography (CT), ultrasound (US), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), photon-emission tomography (PET), and single photon emission CT (SPECT) will not change. The potential variety of radiopharmaceuticals which may be developed is unlimited, however, and this provides nuclear imaging techniques with a significant advantage and adaptive features for future biologic imaging. The current applications of PET in oncology have been in characterizing tumor lesions, differentiating recurrent disease from treatment effects, staging tumors, evaluating the extent of disease, and monitoring therapy. The future developments in medicine may use the unique capabilities of PET not only in diagnostic imaging but also in molecular medicine and genetics. The articles discussed in this review were selected from a literature search covering the last 3 years, and in which comparisons of PET with conventional imaging were addressed specifically. PET studies with the glucose analogue fluorine-18-labeled deoxyglucose (FDG) have shown the ability of detecting tumor foci in a variety of histological neoplasms such as thyroid cancer, breast cancer, lymphoma, lung cancer, head and neck carcinoma, colorectal cancer, ovarian carcinoma, and musculoskeletal tumors. Also, the contribution of the whole body PET (WBPET) imaging technique in diagnosis will be discussed. In the current health care environment, a successful imaging technology must not only change medical management but also demonstrate that those changes improve patient outcome.     

PET evaluation of therapeutic limb perfusion in Merkel's cell carcinoma

An 87-yr-old woman diagnosed with recurrent Merkel's cell carcinoma was treated with therapeutic limb perfusion and underwent PET scanning with 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG). PET studies were obtained before and after treatment to determine the response to the intervention. A baseline whole-body study was obtained to assess the extent and degree of disease activity. This was followed by a repeat PET scan 2 mo. later after treatment with isolated limb chemotherapy with high-dose melphalan and tumor necrosis factor-alpha. The initial scan demonstrated multiple foci of high FDG uptake in the left calf, a left supraclavicular lesion and also detected concurrent keratinizing squamous cell metastasis in the right axilla. A repeat PET study showed complete metabolic resolution of the lesions in the left calf after treatment. FDG PET may be a useful technique for staging Merkel cell carcinoma and for assessing the tumor response after therapy of this rare tumor.     

Imaging proliferation in vivo with [F-18]FLT and positron emission tomography

Positron emission tomography (PET) is now regularly used in the diagnosis and staging of cancer. These uses and its ability to monitor treatment response would be aided by the development of imaging agents that can be used to measure tissue and tumor proliferation. We have developed and tested [F-18]FLT (3'-deoxy-3'-fluorothymidine); it is resistant to degradation, is retained in proliferating tissues by the action of thymidine kinase 1 (TK), and produces high-contrast images of normal marrow and tumors in canine and human subjects.     

Can dual-headed 18F-FDG SPET imaging reliably supersede PET in clinical oncology? A comparative study in lung and gastrointestinal tract cancer

In this study, we prospectively compared the sensitivity of PET and planar SPET (collimated gamma camera) 18F-FDG imaging in patients with lung and gastrointestinal tract cancer and analysed their respective impact on patient management. Twenty-eight patients with lung cancer and 14 with gastro-intestinal tract tumours were scanned on the same day with a PET and a collimated planar SPET gamma camera. The planar SPET procedure consisted of whole-body planar views and a tomographic acquisition centred over the torso or the abdomen, with the total imaging time within the same range as the whole-body PET procedure. The staging of lung cancer patients was accurate in 86% with PET and 64% with planar SPET. Planar SPET would have led to inappropriate therapeutic decisions in 8 of 28 patients, mainly due to undetected distant metastases. In patients with suspected gastrointestinal tract cancer, planar SPET identified 7 of 15 (47%) proven tumour sites, whereas PET identified 14 of 15 (93%). Our results suggest that collimated planar SPET cameras are not a substitute for dedicated PET scanners. The sensitivity for the detection of tumours is unacceptably low and can impair patient management. The use of multiple tomographic acquisitions could improve the sensitivity but would require a longer scanning time.