A fuzzy logic and game theory based adaptive approach for securing opportunistic networks against black hole attacks

Opportunistic networks (OppNets) are networks that can be used in situations of sparse network connectivity. Strategies for implementing secure transmission of messages in OppNets offer complex and distinctive problems that are wholly different from traditional networks using TCP/IP protocols for data transmission. In this paper, a security protocol named FuzzyPT is proposed which combats black hole attacks in OppNets. The defense mechanism is based on the information extracted from messages in the buffer, potential threat (PT) messages, and fuzzy logic. Fuzziness aids the system in being adaptive by modeling the character of nodes as either benign or malicious. It provides the network with the ability to judge the character of nodes based on relationships between different parameters instead of basing this decision on fixed conditions. FuzzyPT is observed to reduce erroneous decision‐making and decrease the number of false positives and false negatives in the system. An evolutionary game theoretic model is applied, which analyzes the decision‐making ability of relays in choosing varied strategies while forwarding messages. The evolutionary stable state is computed for the protocol, which verifies the proposition that a majority of the relays will cooperate by forwarding messages. The efficiency of the protocol is judged on various grounds such as delivery probability, network overhead ratio, packets dropped, and transmission latency. It is observed that the proposed game theoretic protocol outperforms an existing acknowledge and evolutionary game theory–based security protocol in terms of all the aforementioned performance characteristics.     

An altruism‐based trust‐dependent message forwarding protocol for opportunistic networks

In opportunistic networks (OppNets), which are characterized by intermittent end‐to‐end connections, the messages are routed in a store‐carry‐and‐forward fashion using the locally inferred knowledge about the behavior of nodes. As such, most OppNets routing protocols use social metrics that are dependent on the nodes' past information. But the participation of nodes in the message forwarding process is not guaranteed without incentivizing them because most nodes are reluctant in sharing their private resources for public uses. In this paper, some socially derived psychological attributes of a node are introduced to ensure their trustworthy participation in the message forwarding process, leading to the design of an altruism‐dependent trust‐based data forwarding mechanism for OppNets (called ATDTN). In this protocol, each node is associated with a dynamically changing altruism value representing its trust in the network, which is used to determine its status with regard to its participation in message forwarding. Through trace‐driven simulations using the ONE simulator, it is shown that ATDTN outperforms IronMan and SimBet protocols for routing in OppNets (respectively, 18% and 48% improvement), in terms of delivery ratio, end‐to‐end delay, overhead count, and average number of hops, under varying buffer size and time‐to‐live.     

Random forest classifier‐based safe and reliable routing for opportunistic IoT networks

Designing a safe and reliable way for communicating the messages among the devices and humans forming the Opportunistic Internet of Things network (OppIoT) has been a challenge since the broadcast mode of message sharing is used. To contribute toward addressing such challenge, this paper proposes a Random Forest Classifier (RFC)‐based safe and reliable routing protocol for OppIoT (called RFCSec) which ensures space efficiency, hash‐based message integrity, and high packet delivery, simultaneously protecting the network against safety threats viz. packet collusion, hypernova, supernova, and wormhole attacks. The proposed RFCSec scheme is composed of two phases. In the first one, the RFC is trained on real data trace, and based on the output of this training, the second phase consists in classifying the encountered nodes of a given node as belonging to one of the output classes of nodes based on their past behavior in the network. This helps in proactively isolating the malicious nodes from participating in the routing process and encourages the participation of the ones with good message forwarding behavior, low packet dropping rate, high buffer availability, and a higher probability of delivering the messages in the past. Simulation results using the ONE simulator show that the proposed RFCSec secure routing scheme is superior to the MLProph, RLProph, and CAML routing protocols, chosen as benchmarks, in terms of legitimate packet delivery, probability of message delivery, count of dropped messages, and latency in packet delivery. The out‐of‐bag error obtained is also minimal     

Neural network‐based routing protocol for opportunistic networks with intelligent water drop optimization

Opportunistic Networks (OppNets) is a system of wirelessly connected nodes in a varying network topology. Routing in OppNets is a challenge. To overcome the problem of routing, an intelligent dynamic strategy to select next best node for forwarding a message is required. This paper proposes an intelligent routing mechanism based on Intelligent Water Drop (IWD) Algorithm which is used in tandem with Neural Networks (NNs) as an optimization technique to solve the problem of routing in such networks. The nature–inspired IWD algorithm provides robustness, whereas the neural network base of the algorithm helps it to make intelligent routing decisions. The weights in the Neural Network model are calculated by IWD Algorithm using training data consisting of inputs that are characteristic parameters of nodes, such as buffer space, number of successful deliveries and energy levels along with transitive parameters such as delivery probabilities. The proposed protocol Intelligent Water Drop Neural Network (IWDNN) is compared with other protocols that use similar ideologies such as MLProph, K‐nearest neighbour classification based routing protocol (KNNR), Cognitive Routing Protocol for Opportunistic Network (CRPO), and Inheritance Inspired Context Aware Routing Protocol (IICAR), as well as the standard protocol Prophet. IWDNN is shown to outperform all other protocols with an average message delivery ratio of 60%, which is a significant improvement of over 10% in comparison to other similarly conceived algorithms. It has one of the lowest latency among the protocols studied, in a range of 3000 to 4000 s, and incurs comparably low overhead costs in the range of 15 to 30. The drop ratios are one of the lowest, staying near six and approaching zero as buffer size is increased. Average amount of time a message stayed in the buffer was the lowest, with a mean of 1600 s.     

基于社会上下文认知的机会路由算法

无线智能设备的普遍使用促进了机会网络的发展.这类网络处于间歇性连接状态,以自组织方式转发数据.路由协议设计时考虑节点携带者的社会特征和日常行为能够提高机会网络的性能.提出了一种基于社会上下文认知的机会路由算法SCOR,该算法利用网络中的社会上下文信息,通过BP神经网络模型预测节点的移动行为.路由决策过程充分考虑移动节点活动的时间和空间属性,当接收节点与发送节点同时处于网络中的同一连通域时,数据转发采用同步方式,否则采用异步方式.仿真分析和实验结果表明,与其它经典算法相比,SCOR算法提高了数据成功转发的比率,减少了网络的开销.     

Poisson's probability‐based Q‐Routing techniques for message forwarding in opportunistic networks

Opportunistic Networks (OppNets) are intermittently connected infrastructure less wireless networks. There is no continuous end‐to‐end connection between the sender and the receiver, and hence nodes follow a store‐carry‐forward mechanism. The routing algorithm is required to be adaptive to the changing topology of the network. In this work, Q‐Routing technique has been used with forwarding probability and incorporated using Poisson's probability for decision making and controlling transmission energy. The algorithm refines the forwarding decision of finding the next suitable hop by exploiting the characteristics of nodes such as daily routines, mobility pattern, etc. In simulations, the performance of PBQ‐Routing is compared with Q‐Routing, Epidemic Routing, PRoPHET (Probabilistic Routing Protocol using History of Encounters and Transitivity), and HBPR (History Based Prediction Routing) for OppNets. The use of Poisson's distribution improves the effectiveness of the probabilistic forwarding decision. The findings show that the delivery probability of PBQ‐Routing almost gets doubled and overhead ratio reduces to half in comparison with that of Q‐Routing when used in OppNets. PBQ‐Routing outperforms other Q‐Routing based algorithms over Poisson's distribution. As there is less replication in case of PBQ‐Routing, it also saves the transmission energy.     

机会网络中基于摆渡节点与簇节点相互协作的路由机制

机会网络是一种不需要在源节点和目的节点之间存在完整路径,利用节点移动带来的相遇机会实现网络通信的延迟容忍自组织网络,它以“存储-携带-处理-转发”的模式进行.为实现互不相交簇间的信息传输,本文设计了一种带阈值的簇移动模型CMMT,并提出了一种基于摆渡（Ferry）节点与簇节点协作的路由算法（CBSW）.该算法减少了冗余的通信和存储开销,以及在Spray阶段簇节点没有遇到目的节点或摆渡节点,进入Wait阶段携带消息的节点采用直接分发方式只向目的节点传输等问题.仿真实验表明,CBSW算法能够增加传输成功率,减少网络开销和传输延迟.     

Optimal mobility control with energy constraint in delay tolerant networks

Owing to the uncertainty of transmission opportunities between mobile nodes, the routing in delay tolerant networks (DTNs) exploits the mechanism of store‐carry‐and‐forward. In this routing mechanism, mobility plays an important role, and we need to control the mobility of nodes around the network to help with carrying messages from the source to the destination. This is a difficult problem because the nodes in the network may move arbitrarily and it is difficult for us to determine when the nodes should move faster to help the data transmission while considering the complicated energy consumption in such a network. At the same time, for most DTNs, the system energy is limited, and energy efficient algorithms are crucial to maximizing the message delivery probability while reducing the delivery cost. In this paper, we investigate the problem of energy efficient mobility speed control in epidemic routing of DTN. We model the message dissemination process under variable mobility speed by a continuous‐time Markov model. With this model, we then formulate the optimization problem of the optimal mobility control for epidemic routing and obtain the optimal policy from the solution of this optimization problem. Furthermore, extensive numerical results demonstrate that the proposed optimal policy significantly outperforms the static policy with constant speed, in terms of energy saving. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Enhanced fuzzy logic‐based spray and wait routing protocol for delay tolerant networks

Delay tolerant networks are a class of ad hoc networks that enable data delivery even in the absence of end‐to‐end connectivity between nodes, which is the basic assumption for routing in ad hoc networks. Nodes in these networks work on store‐carry and forward paradigm. In addition, such networks make use of message replication as a strategy to increase the possibility of messages reaching their destination. As contact opportunities are usually of short duration, it is important to prioritize scheduling of messages. Message replication may also lead to buffer congestion. Hence, buffer management is an important issue that greatly affects the performance of routing protocols in delay tolerant networks. In this paper, Spray and Wait routing protocol, which is a popular controlled replication‐based protocol for delay tolerant networks, has been enhanced using a new fuzzy‐based buffer management strategy Enhanced Fuzzy Spray and Wait Routing, with the aim to achieve increased delivery ratio and reduced overhead ratio. It aggregates three important message properties namely number of replicas of a message, its size, and remaining time‐to‐live, using fuzzy logic to determine the message priority, which denotes its importance with respect to other messages stored in a node's buffer. It then intelligently selects messages to schedule when a contact opportunity occurs. Because determination of number of replicas of a message in the network is a difficult task, a new method for estimation of the same has been proposed. Simulation results show improved performance of enhanced fuzzy spray and wait routing in terms of delivery ratio and resource consumption. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Delay constraint multipath routing for wireless multimedia ad hoc networks

According to the disadvantages of real time and continuity for multimedia services in ad hoc networks, a delay constraint multipath routing protocol for wireless multimedia ad hoc networks, which can satisfy quality of service (QoS) requirement (QoS multipath optimized link state routing [MOLSR]), is proposed. The protocol firstly detects and analyzes the link delay among the nodes and collects the delay information as the routing metric by HELLO message and topology control message. Then, through using the improved multipath Dijkstra algorithm for path selection, the protocol can gain the minimum delay path from the source node to the other nodes. Finally, when the route is launched, several node‐disjoint or link‐disjoint multipaths will be built through the route computation. The simulation and test results show that QoS‐MOLSR is suitable for large and dense networks with heavy traffic. It can improve the real time and reliability for multimedia transmission in wireless multimedia ad hoc networks. The average end‐to‐end delay of QoS‐MOLSR is four times less than the optimized link state routing. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

具有传输成功率保证的概率路由算法的TTL预测模型

概率路由算法是机会网络中一种常用的路由算法,其TTL的设置将直接影响路由的性能.本文首先利用马尔可夫链对概率路由的转发过程进行建模,并从消息的传输成功率和传输延时方面进行性能评估,不仅可以计算出一个消息从源节点到目的节点所需的传输延时,还可以预测出在给定传输成功率下所需要的最短消息生存周期TTL,这对于TTL的设置具有理论上的指导作用.其次,本文建立的预测模型还可以使一些无法到达目的节点的消息及时被删除,从而减少不必要的转发,达到节约网络资源的目的.最后,在两个真实数据集中的实验结果表明,本文提出的模型能够为概率路由中TTL值的准确设置提供有效参考.     

Multiattribute‐based routing for lifetime maximization in opportunistic mobile social networks

With the advancement in wireless technology and portable devices, smart phones have become one of the belongings of human being. People share their data online, but it has limitations due to transmission range and mobility. Yet opportunistic mobile social network enables users to share data online even if there is no connected path between source and destination. The widespread use of mobile phones equipped with WiFi, Bluetooth, and several other components and contact opportunities among humans bridge the gap between internet available and nonavailable area. In this paper, we have proposed a new routing approach which utilizes both spatial and temporal attributes of user such as probability to meet a particular location and remaining intercontact time between two nodes to select better relay nodes. Generally, users visit different locations such as sports stadium and mall, with varying probability. Users with similar interest form group, and each user has different intercontact time with other users according to their point of interest and visiting pattern. By utilizing multiattributes, different forwarding strategies have been devised for both inter and intragroup routing. The proposed work “point of interest (PoI)‐based routing” is implemented in Opportunistic Network Environment simulator, and the performance is analysed in terms of delivery rate, latency, overhead, goodput, and energy consumed. The simulation results show that PoI diminishes 23% of overhead and yields 24% improvement in goodput over the state‐of‐the‐art protocol. Thus, the simulation results reveal that our proposed work provides the balance between routing performance and resource consumption.     

移动无线传感网能量时延约束的自适应路由及性能评估

 针对间歇性连通的移动无线传感网提出一种能量时延约束的自适应路由协议(EDCA),EDCA由初始化阶段、转发决策阶段、转发阶段和等待阶段组成,传感器节点根据目标时延实时判断是否转发副本,并选择剩余能量多的节点进行副本转发.EDCA对平均时延和网络负载具有控制力,对网络环境变化具有自适应能力,能够有效延长网络生命周期.     

消息内容保护的间断连接移动自组织网络转发机制

移动自组织网络资源有限,且节点之间共享无线信道并以协作的方式完成消息转发,导致所传输消息的机密性较为脆弱。为保护消息内容的机密性,该文提出一种间断连接移动自组织网络中的消息转发机制。各节点对原始消息进行切割,并利用多副本消息转发过程的冗余性和节点相似性控制各片段消息在不相交的路径上进行转发,进而由网络中的摆渡节点收集、检验并还原、加密得到仅目的节点能够解密的完整消息,确保转发过程中消息的机密性、完整性。数值分析表明所提机制在保障网络性能前提下,能有效保护消息的机密性。     

Integrated Routing and Storage for Messaging Applications in Mobile Ad Hoc Networks

This paper is motivated by the observation that traditional ad hoc routing protocols are not an adequate solution for messaging applications (e.g., e-mail) in mobile ad hoc networks. Routing in ad hoc mobile networks is challenging mainly because of node mobility – the more rapid the rate of movement, the greater the fraction of bad routes and undelivered messages. For applications that can tolerate delays beyond conventional forwarding delays, we advocate a relay-based approach to be used in conjunction with traditional ad hoc routing protocols. This approach takes advantage of node mobility to disseminate messages to mobile nodes. The result is the Mobile Relay Protocol (MRP), which integrates message routing and storage in the network; the basic idea is that if a route to a destination is unavailable, a node performs a controlled local broadcast (a relay) to its immediate neighbors. In a network with sufficient mobility – precisely the situation when conventional routes are likely to be non-existent or broken – it is quite likely that one of the relay nodes to which the packet has been relayed will encounter a node that has a valid, short (conventional) route to the eventual destination, thereby increasing the likelihood that the message will be successfully delivered. Our simulation results under a variety of node movement models demonstrate that this idea can work well for applications that prefer reliability over latency.     

Contention aware mobility prediction routing for intermittently connected mobile networks

This paper introduces a novel multi-copy routing protocol, called predict and forward (PF), for delay tolerant networks, which aims to explore the possibility of using mobile nodes as message carriers for end-to-end delivery of the messages. With PF, the message forwarding decision is made by manipulating the probability distribution of future inter-contact and contact durations based on the network status, including wireless link condition and nodal buffer availability. In particular, PF is based on the observations that the node mobility behavior is semi-deterministic and could be predicted once there is sufficient mobility history information. We implemented the proposed protocol and compared it with a number of existing encounter-based routing approaches in terms of delivery delay, delivery ratio, and the number of transmissions required for message delivery. The simulation results show that PF outperforms all the counterpart multi-copy encounter-based routing protocols considered in the study.     

Impact of Bloom Filter on Infection Rate in Epidemic Forwarding for ICNs

Mobile ad hoc routing protocols fails in intermittently connected networks (ICN) (i.e. characterized by short-range communication and absence of connected path from source to destination). However, Epidemic routing techniques ensures eventual message delivery from source to destination even where there is never a connected path or when a network partition exists at the origin of message. Epidemic Routing uses random pair-wise messages exchanges between nodes with goals to maximize message delivery rate, minimize message latency, and the total resources consumed in message delivery. Epidemic routing uses summary vector to avoid useless transmission and redundancy. Further,to make summery vector efficient, epidemic routing can use bloom filter to significantly reduce the useless transmissions associated with the summary vector. However, the challenge for epidemic routing remains opens is to optimal design of summary vector size for finite buffer while keeping the benefits of infinite buffer space. This paper proposes an improved scheme of Bloom filter (named it modified bloom filter MBLF), which is tailored according to epidemic routing. We performed simulation to support our clam and observed that delivery ratio of MBLF with epidemic routing is 19 % higher then the traditional bloom filter. In this paper, we have proposed a bloom filter based epidemic forwarding for ICNs.     

ARDEN: Anonymous networking in delay tolerant networks

Delay Tolerant Networks (DTNs) provide a communications infrastructure for environments lacking continuous connectivity. Such networks rely on the mobility of nodes and the resulting opportunistic connections to carry messages from source to destination. Unfortunately, exchanging packets with an arbitrary intermediary node makes privacy difficult to achieve in these systems as any adversary can easily act as an intermediary and determine the sender and receiver of a message. In this paper, we present ARDEN, an anonymous communication mechanism for DTNs based on a modified onion routing architecture. Instead of selecting specific nodes through which messages must pass as is traditionally done in onion routing, ARDEN uses Attribute-Based Encryption (ABE) to specify and manage groups that may decrypt and forward messages. Through simulation, we show that this approach not only increases throughput and reduces end-to-end latency over traditional onion routing techniques, but also adds minimal overhead when compared to DTN routing protocols that do not provide anonymity guarantees. Through this, we show that ARDEN is an effective solution for anonymous communication in intermittently connected networks such as DTNs.     

Selective Message Forwarding in Delay Tolerant Networks

It is challenging to deliver messages in a network where no instant end-to-end path exists, so called delay-tolerant network (DTN). Node encounters are used for message forwarding. In this paper, we propose a DTN routing protocol SMART. SMART utilizes the travel companions of the destinations (i.e. nodes that frequently meet the destination) to increase the delivery opportunities while limiting message overhead to a bounded number. Our approach differs from related work in that it does not propagate node encounter history nor the delivery probabilities derived from the encounter history. In SMART, a message source injects a fixed number of message copies into the network to forward the message to a companion of the destination, which only forwards the message to a fixed number of the destination’s companions. Our analysis and simulation results show that SMART has a higher delivery ratio and a smaller delivery latency than the schemes that only use controlled opportunistically-forwarding mechanism and has a significantly smaller routing overhead than a pure flooding scheme.     

Energy Efficient Forwarding Algorithm in Opportunistic Networks

In opportunistic networks,a successful message transmission between node pairs depends on the message size,the transmission speed and the connection duration time.This paper proposes a new message forwarding algorithm to improve the message delivery ratio and reduce the energy consumption.Previous encounter characteristics between nodes are used to estimate future connection duration time using a three point estimation method.Furthermore,the buffer utilization of nodes is used as a weight for the likelihoods to meet destinations according to the hop count of messages stored in the buffer.The simulation results show that the proposed forwarding algorithm achieves higher delivery ratio and less overhead ratio than the other four popular routing protocols.In addition,the proposed algorithm gains a better average residual energy performance among all the compared protocols.