Improved method to extract and concentrate porphyrins from liver tissue for analysis by high-performance liquid chromatography

Metabolic control theory is used to derive conditions under which two deleterious mutations affecting the dynamics of a metabolic pathway act synergistically. It is found that two mutations tend to act mostly synergistically when they reduce the activity of the same enzyme. If the two mutations affect different enzymes, the conclusion depends on the way that fitness is determined by aspects of the pathway. The cases analyzed are: selection for (1) maximal flux, (2) maximal equilibrium concentration (pool size) of an intermediate, (3) optimal flux, (4) optimal pool size. The respective types of epistasis found are: (1) antagonistic, (2) partly synergistic, (3-4) synergism is likely to predominate over antagonism. This results in somewhat different predictions concerning the effect of metabolic mutations on fitness in prokaryotes and eukaryotes. The fact that bacteria are largely clonal but have often a mosaic gene structure is consistent with expectations from the model.     

Bottleneck effect on genetic variance. A theoretical investigation of the role of dominance

The phenomenon that the genetic variance of fitness components increase following a bottleneck or inbreeding is supported by a growing number of experiments and is explained theoretically by either dominance or epistasis. In this article, diffusion approximations under the infinite sites model are used to quantify the effect of dominance, using data on viability in Drosophila melanogaster. The model is based on mutation parameters from mutation accumulation experiments involving balancer chromosomes (set I) or inbred lines (set II). In essence, set I assumes many mutations of small effect, whereas set II assumes fewer mutations of large effect. Compared to empirical estimates from large outbred populations, set I predicts reasonable genetic variances but too low mean viability. In contrast, set II predicts a reasonable mean viability but a low genetic variance. Both sets of parameters predict the changes in mean viability (depression), additive variance, between-line variance and heritability following bottlenecks generally compatible with empirical results, and these changes are mainly caused by lethals and deleterious mutants of large effect. This article suggests that dominance is the main cause for increased genetic variances for fitness components and fitness-related traits after bottlenecks observed in various experiments.     

Somatic mutation favors the evolution of diploidy

Explanation of diploidy have focused on advantages gained from masking deleterious mutations that are inherited. Recent theory has shown that these explanations are flawed. Indeed, we still lack any satisfactory explanation of diploidy in species that are asexual or that recombine only rarely. Here I consider a possibility first suggested by Efroimson in 1932, by Muller in 1964 and by Crow and Kimura in 1965: diploidy may provide protection against somatic, not inherited, mutations. I both compare the mean fitness of haploid and diploid populations that are asexual and investigate the invasion of "diploidy" alleles in sexual populations. When deleterious mutations are partially recessive and somatic mutation is sufficiently common, somatic mutation provides a clear advantage to diploidy in both asexual and sexual species.     

Requisite mutational load, pathway epistasis and deterministic mutation accumulation in sexual versus asexual populations

A measure of the equilibrium load of deleterious mutations is developed that explicitly incorporates the level of genome-wide linkage disequilibrium. This measure, called the requisite mutational load, is based on the minimal net reproductive rate of the least mutated class necessary to prevent the deterministic mutation accumulation. If this minimal net reproductive rate is larger than ecological or physiological constraints allow, then: a) the population is driven to extinction via deterministic mutation accumulation, or b) a mutational Red-Queen ensues with adaptation counterbalancing mutation accumulation. Two population parameters determine the requisite mutational load: a) the equilibrium strength of selection, measured as a selection gradient, and b) the equilibrium opportunity for selection, measured as the variance in number of mutations per genome. The opportunity for selection is decomposed into the accumulation of mutations (average number per genome) and the level of genome-wide linkage disequilibrium. Recombination can substantially reduce the requisite mutational load, compared to clonal reproduction, when there is buffering and/or reinforcing epistasis and also when there is positive assortative mating for fitness. Recombination is advantageous because it reduces the negative (variance reducing) linkage disequilibrium induced by beneficial epistasis. The functional form of the expression for requisite mutational load illustrates why epistasis within pathways, i.e., among closely interacting genes, is a powerful alternative to genome-wide truncation selection, as a means of reducing mutational load.     

A microtiter plate assay for cytochrome c oxidase in permeabilized whole cells

A new mouse retinal degeneration that appears to be an excellent candidate for modeling human retinitis pigmentosa is reported. In this degeneration, called rd-3, differentiation proceeds postnatally through 2 weeks, and photoreceptor degeneration starts by 3 weeks. The rod photoreceptor loss is essentially complete by 5 weeks, whereas remnant cone cells are seen through 7 weeks. This is the only mouse homozygous retinal degeneration reported to date in which photoreceptors are initially normal. Crosses with known mouse retinal degenerations rd, Rds, nr, and pcd are negative for retinal degeneration in offspring, and linkage analysis places rd-3 on mouse chromosome 1 at 10 +/- 2.5 cM distal to Akp-1. Homology mapping suggests that the homologous human locus should be on chromosome 1q.     

Characterization of deleterious mutations in outcrossing populations

Deng and Lynch recently proposed estimating the rate and effects of deleterious genomic mutations from changes in the mean and genetic variance of fitness upon selfing/outcrossing in outcrossing/highly selfing populations. The utility of our original estimation approach is limited in outcrossing populations, since selfing may not always be feasible. Here we extend the approach to any form of inbreeding in outcrossing populations. By simulations, the statistical properties of the estimation under a common form of inbreeding (sib mating) are investigated under a range of biologically plausible situations. The efficiencies of different degrees of inbreeding and two different experimental designs of estimation are also investigated. We found that estimation using the total genetic variation in the inbred generation is generally more efficient than employing the genetic variation among the mean of inbred families, and that higher degree of inbreeding employed in experiments yields higher power for estimation. The simulation results of the magnitude and direction of estimation bias under variable or epistatic mutation effects may provide a basis for accurate inferences of deleterious mutations. Simulations accounting for environmental variance of fitness suggest that, under full-sib mating, our extension can achieve reasonably well an estimation with sample sizes of only approximately 2000-3000.     

Risk of population extinction from fixation of deleterious and reverse mutations

A model is developed for alternate fixations of mildly deleterious and wild-type alleles arising by forward and reverse mutation in a finite population. For almost all parameter values, this gives an equilibrium load that agrees closely with the general expression derived from diffusion theory. Nearly neutral mutations with selection coefficient a few times larger than 1/(2N(e)) do the most damage by increasing the equilibrium load. The model of alternate fixations facilitates dynamical analysis of the expected load and the mean time to extinction in a population that has been suddenly reduced from a very large size to a small size. Reverse mutation can substantially improve population viability, increasing the mean time to extinction by an order of magnitude or more, but because many mutations are irreversible the effects may not be large. Populations with initially high mean fitness and small effective size, N(e) below a few hundred individuals, may be at serious risk of extinction from fixation of deleterious mutations within 10(3) to 10(4) generations.     

Analysis of germline mutation spectra at the Huntington's disease locus supports a mitotic mutation mechanism

Trinucleotide repeat disease alleles can undergo 'dynamic' mutations in which repeat number may change when a gene is transmitted from parent to offspring. By typing >3500 sperm, we determined the size distribution of Huntington's disease (HD) germline mutations produced by 26 individuals from the Venezuelan cohort with CAG/CTG repeat numbers ranging from 37 to 62. Both the mutation frequency and mean change in allele size increased with increasing somatic repeat number. The mutation frequencies averaged 82% and, for individuals with at least 50 repeats, 98%. The extraordinarily high mutation frequency levels are most consistent with a mutation process that occurs throughout germline mitotic divisions, rather than resulting from a single meiotic event. In several cases, the mean change in repeat number differed significantly among individuals with similar somatic allele sizes. This individual variation could not be attributed to age in a simple way or to ' cis ' sequences, suggesting the influence of genetic background or other factors. A familial effect is suggested in one family where both the father and son gave highly unusual spectra compared with other individuals matched for age and repeat number. A statistical model based on incomplete processing of Okazaki fragments during DNA replication was found to provide an excellent fit to the data but variation in parameter values among individuals suggests that the molecular mechanism might be more complex.     

Further evidence for the presence of mitochondrially encoded subunits in cytochrome c oxidase of the trypanosomatid Crithidia fasciculata

Trimethylaminuria is an autosomal recessive human disorder affecting a small part of the population as an inherited polymorphism. Individuals diagnosed with trimethylaminuria excrete relatively large amounts of trimethylamine in their urine, sweat, and breath, and this results in a fishy odor characteristic of trimethylamine. Activity of the human flavin-containing monooxygenase (FMO) has been proposed to be deficient in trimethylaminuria patients causing a decrease in the metabolism of trimethylamine that results in a fishy body odor. Cohorts of Australian, American, and British individuals suffering from trimethylaminuria have been identified. The human FMO3 cDNA was amplified from lymphocytes of affected patients. We report preliminary evidence of substitutions detected by screening of the cDNA and genomic DNA. The variant human FMO3 cDNA was constructed from wild type human FMO3 cDNA by site-directed mutagenesis as maltose-binding protein fusions. Five distinct human FMO3 mutants were expressed as fusion proteins in Escherichia coli and compared with wild type human FMO3 maltose-binding proteins (FMO3-MBP) for the N-oxygenation of 10-[(N,N-dimethylamino)pentyl]-2-(trifluoromethyl)phenothiazine, tyramine, and trimethylamine. Human Lys158 FMO3-MBP and, to a greater extent, human Glu158 FMO3-MBP efficiently N-oxygenated the three amine substrates. Human Lys158 Ile66 FMO3-MBP, Glu158 Ile66 FMO3-MBP, Lys158 Leu153 FMO3-MBP, and Glu158 Leu153 FMO3-MBP were all constructed as mutants identified as possible FMO3 variants responsible for trimethylaminuria and were found to be inactive as N-oxygenases. The results suggest that mutations at codons 66 and 153 of FMO3 can cause trimethylaminuria in humans. We observed a common polymorphism of Lys to Glu at codon 158 of FMO3 that segregated with almost equal allele frequencies in a number of control Australian and North American samples studied. The Lys158 to Glu158 human FMO3 polymorphism does not decrease trimethylamine N-oxygenation for the cDNA-expressed enzyme and thus does not appear to be causative of trimethyaminuria. The data show that the functional activity of human FMO3 can be significantly altered by amino acid changes that have been observed in individuals with clinically diagnosed trimethylaminuria.     

Experimental demonstration that offspring sex ratio varies with maternal condition

Sex ratio theory predicts that, if prevailing ecological or social circumstances differentially influence the fitness benefits of offspring of each sex, parents should adjust their production accordingly to maximize fitness. For species in which sex is chromosomally determined, such as birds and mammals, a differential effect of maternal condition on the fitness of male and female young is one important route whereby selection is expected to favor a bias in the offspring sex ratio at birth or egg laying. However, despite its central place in sex allocation theory, this hypothesis has rarely been tested in wild populations. We manipulated maternal condition upward and downward in a sexually dimorphic wild bird and examined the effect on offspring survival and on offspring sex ratio. The survival to fledging of male, but not female, young was substantially reduced if they came from less well provisioned eggs produced by females in relatively poor condition. As female condition, and thereby her capacity to produce high quality eggs, declined, she progressively skewed the sex ratio of her eggs toward females; i.e., she produced more of the sex with the higher survival prospects. The decline in the survival of male offspring, and the sex ratio bias, was removed when maternal condition was enhanced. These results provide experimental evidence of an adaptive, facultative adjustment of sex ratio in response to changes in maternal condition in wild birds.     

The effect of overdominance on characterizing deleterious mutations in large natural populations

Alternatives to the mutation-accumulation approach have been developed to characterize deleterious genomic mutations. However, they all depend on the assumption that the standing genetic variation in natural populations is solely due to mutation-selection (M-S) balance and therefore that overdominance does not contribute to heterosis. Despite tremendous efforts, the extent to which this assumption is valid is unknown. With different degrees of violation of the M-S balance assumption in large equilibrium populations, we investigated the statistical properties and the robustness of these alternative methods in the presence of overdominance. We found that for dominant mutations, estimates for U (genomic mutation rate) will be biased upward and those for h (mean dominance coefficient) and s (mean selection coefficient), biased downward when additional overdominant mutations are present. However, the degree of bias is generally moderate and depends largely on the magnitude of the contribution of overdominant mutations to heterosis or genetic variation. This renders the estimates of U and s not always biased under variable mutation effects that, when working alone, cause U and s to be underestimated. The contributions to heterosis and genetic variation from overdominant mutations are monotonic but not linearly proportional to each other. Our results not only provide a basis for the correct inference of deleterious mutation parameters from natural populations, but also alleviate the biggest concern in applying the new approaches, thus paving the way for reliably estimating properties of deleterious mutations.     

Inferring the fitness effects of DNA mutations from polymorphism and divergence data: statistical power to detect directional selection under stationarity and free recombination

The fitness effects of classes of DNA mutations can be inferred from patterns of nucleotide variation. A number of studies have attributed differences in levels of polymorphism and divergence between silent and replacement mutations to the action of natural selection. Here, I investigate the statistical power to detect directional selection through contrasts of DNA variation among functional categories of mutations. A variety of statistical approaches are applied to DNA data simulated under Sawyer and Hartl's Poisson random field model. Under assumptions of free recombination and stationarity, comparisons that include both the frequency distributions of mutations segregating within populations and the numbers of mutations fixed between populations have substantial power to detect even very weak selection. Frequency distribution and divergence tests are applied to silent and replacement mutations among five alleles of each of eight Drosophila simulans genes. Putatively "preferred" silent mutations segregate at higher frequencies and are more often fixed between species than "unpreferred" silent changes, suggesting fitness differences among synonymous codons. Amino acid changes tend to be either rare polymorphisms or fixed differences, consistent with a combination of deleterious and adaptive protein evolution. In these data, a substantial fraction of both silent and replacement DNA mutations appear to affect fitness.     

Clusters of new identical mutants and the fate of underdominant mutations

Given favorable environmental and demographic conditions, premeiotic clusters of identical mutations can produce a broad distribution of the initial frequency of underdominant alleles. Because of these clusters, new underdominant mutations may not necessarily be as rare in a population as previously assumed. The fixation of underdominant mutations, especially those with low heterozygous fitness, is increased when mutations appear in a cluster due to a genetic change that occurred before germline differentiation. Most restrictions on the fixation of underdominant mutations in a single population, such as strong genetic drift, weak selection against mutant heterozygotes, isolated population structure, inbreeding, meiotic drive, and selection in favor of mutant homozygotes can be relaxed or even dropped. Instead, the fate of strong underdominant mutations is determined mainly by ecological and genetic factors that affect the cluster size distribution of new premeiotic mutations. Accumulation of reproductive isolation by the fixation of underdominant mutations becomes more feasible with clusters, and mutation is not always the weakest force during this evolutionary process. The large mean and variance of reproductive success in many multicellular species make it possible that even underdominant mutations with very low heterozygous fitness could contribute substantially to reproductive isolation.     

Social structure of the mound-building mouse Mus spicilegus revealed by genetic analysis with microsatellites

The Mound-building mouse Mus spicilegus possesses a unique behaviour amongst mice. It constructs large earthen mounds and associated nesting chambers which serve to store food for immature individuals during the winter nesting period. We have used genetic analysis of four autosomal and four X-linked microsatellite loci to determine relationships between individuals inhabiting 40 mounds in Bulgaria. We show that, in almost all cases, individuals in a mound are the product of multiple parentage. We estimate the minimum number of males and female parents contributing offspring to each mound and demonstrate that at least two male and two female parents contribute offspring to a minimum of seven mounds. Analyses of relatedness coefficients and allele sharing values demonstrate that parents of different sibships within mounds are more related than if they had been chosen at random from the population and suggest that it is the female parents that contribute this excess relatedness. These results suggest that the mechanism by which individuals congregate to build mounds is kin-based and that the evolution of mound building and communal nesting in M. spicilegus is due in part to kin selection. This study represents a novel approach to the study of mammalian behavioural ecology. We have used a genetic dataset to construct an outline of social structure in the absence of behavioural data. These inferences can now be used to direct further work on this species.     

Dioxygen activation and bond cleavage by mixed-valence cytochrome c oxidase

Elucidating the structures of intermediates in the reduction of O2 to water by cytochrome c oxidase is crucial to understanding both oxygen activation and proton pumping by the enzyme. In the work here, the reaction of O2 with the mixed-valence enzyme, in which only heme a3 and CuB in the binuclear center are reduced, has been followed by time-resolved resonance Raman spectroscopy. The results show that O==O bond cleavage occurs within the first 200 micros after reaction initiation; the presence of a uniquely stable Fe---O---O(H) peroxy species is not detected. The product of this rapid reaction is a heme a3 oxoferryl (FeIV==O) species, which requires that an electron donor in addition to heme a3 and CuB must be involved. The available evidence suggests that the additional donor is an amino acid side chain. Recent crystallographic data [Yoshikawa, S., Shinzawa-Itoh, K., Nakashima, R., Yaono, R., Yamashita, E., Inoue, N., Yao, M., Fei, M. J., Libeu, C. P., Mizushima, T., et al. Science, in press; Ostermeier, C., Harrenga, A. , Ermler, U. & Michel, H. (1997) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 94, 10547-10553] show that one of the CuB ligands, His240, is cross-linked to Tyr244 and that this cross-linked tyrosyl is ideally positioned to participate in dioxygen activation. We propose a mechanism for O---O bond cleavage that proceeds by concerted hydrogen atom transfer from the cross-linked His---Tyr species to produce the product oxoferryl species, CuB2+---OH-, and the tyrosyl radical. This mechanism provides molecular structures for two key intermediates that drive the proton pump in oxidase; moreover, it has clear analogies to the proposed O---O bond forming chemistry that occurs during O2 evolution in photosynthesis.     

Mutant alleles of small effect are primarily responsible for the loss of fitness with slow inbreeding in Drosophila melanogaster

Multilocus simulation is used to identify genetic models that can account for the observed rates of inbreeding and fitness decline in laboratory populations of Drosophila melanogaster. The experimental populations were maintained under crowded conditions for approximately 200 generations at a harmonic mean population size of Nh approximately 65-70. With a simulated population size of N = 50, and a mean selective disadvantage of homozygotes at individual loci approximately 1-2% or less, it is demonstrated that the mean effective population size over a 200-generation period may be considerably greater than N, with a ratio matching the experimental estimate of Ne/Nh approximately 1.4. The buildup of associative overdominance at electrophoretic marker loci is largely responsible for the stability of gene frequencies and the observed reduction in the rate of inbreeding, with apparent selection coefficients in favor of the heterozygote at neutral marker loci increasing rapidly over the first N generations of inbreeding to values approximately 5-10%. The observed decline in fitness under competitive conditions in populations of size approximately 50 in D. melanogaster therefore primarily results from mutant alleles with mean effects on fitness as homozygotes of sm < or = 0.02. Models with deleterious recessive mutants at the background loci require that the mean selection coefficient against heterozygotes is at most hsm approximately 0.002, with a minimum mutation rate for a single Drosophila autosome 100 cM in length estimated to be in the range 0.05-0.25, assuming an exponential distribution of s. A typical chromosome would be expected to carry at least 100-200 such mutant alleles contributing to the decline in competitive fitness with slow inbreeding.     

Does the presence of diabetic nephropathy in parents influence the metabolic response in the offspring?

Non-insulin dependent (Type 2) diabetes mellitus (NIDDM) and long-term complications such as nephropathy have a strong genetic predisposition. Insulin resistance is thought to be a pathogenetic factor, predisposing genetically prone individuals to develop the microvascular complications of diabetes. To test these hypotheses, two groups of young individuals were studied: 28 offspring of parents having NIDDM and diabetic nephropathy (group 1) aged 29.5 +/- 6.1 years, BMI 25.2 +/- 4.7 kg m(-2) and 31 offspring of diabetic parents with no history of nephropathy, aged 31.6 +/- 4.1 years and BMI 26.3 +/- 4.9 kg m(-2) (group 2). All underwent a standard oral glucose tolerance test with measurement of serum insulin levels and serum lipid profile. Urine albumin:creatinine ratio (A/C ratio) and blood pressure were also recorded. Diabetes was detected in 2/28 (7.1%) and 3/31 (9.7%) and IGT was detected in 5/28 (25%) and 8/31 (25%) of groups 1 and 2, respectively. These differences were not statistically significant, but were higher than in a group of non-diabetic controls with healthy parents. Comparison of the normoglycaemic subjects (19 and 20 in group 1 and 2, respectively) showed no significant differences between blood pressure readings, fasting and 2 h plasma glucose, and lipid profiles. Plasma insulin values, fasting and 2 h, and the area under the graph were also similar in both groups, indicating an absence of higher insulin response in group 1 in comparison with group 2. These values were also not different from those in the non-diabetic controls. A delay in insulin response to glucose was noted in many of the offspring as indicated by a low deltaI/deltaG at 30'. We conclude that offspring of diabetic parents with nephropathy do not show higher risk of glucose intolerance or insulin resistance compared to those with diabetic parents without nephropathy. The relatively high plasma glucose values in the presence of normal insulin secretion in both groups of offspring of diabetic parents suggest the presence of insulin resistance.     

A common mechanism for the interaction of nitric oxide with the oxidized binuclear centre and oxygen intermediates of cytochrome c oxidase

The reactions of nitric oxide (NO) with fully oxidized cytochrome c oxidase (O) and the intermediates P and F have been investigated by optical spectroscopy, using both static and kinetic methods. The reaction of NO with O leads to a rapid (approximately 100 s-1) electron ejection from the binuclear center to cytochrome a and CuA. The reaction with the intermediates P and F leads to the depletion of these species in slower reactions, yielding the fully oxidized enzyme. The fastest optical change, however, takes place within the dead time of the stopped-flow apparatus (approximately 1 ms), and corresponds to the formation of the F intermediate (580 nm) upon reaction of NO with a species that we postulate is at the peroxide oxidation level. This species can be formulated as either Fe5+ = O CuB2+ or Fe4+ = O CuB3+, and it is spectrally distinct from the P intermediate (607 nm). All of these reactions have been rationalized through a mechanism in which NO reacts with CuB2+, generating the nitrosonium species CuB1+ NO+, which upon hydration yields nitrous acid and CuB1+. This is followed by redox equilibration of CuB with Fea/CuA or Fea3 (in which Fea and Fea3 are the iron centers of cytochromes a and a3, respectively). In agreement with this hypothesis, our results indicate that nitrite is rapidly formed within the binuclear center following the addition of NO to the three species tested (O, P, and F). This work suggests that nitrosylation at CuB2+ instead of at Fea32+ is a key event in the fast inhibition of cytochrome c oxidase by NO.     

The mutation rate and the distribution of mutational effects of viability and fitness in Drosophila melanogaster

The empirical distributions of the average viability and fitness of mutation accumulation lines of Drosophila melanogaster were analyzed using minimum distance estimation. Data come from two different experimental designs where mutations were allowed to accumulate: 1) in copies of chromosome II protected from natural selection and recombination (viability: Mukai et al., 1972; Ohnishi, 1977; fitness: Houle et al., 1992), 2) in inbred lines derived from the same isogenic stock (viability: Fernández & López-Fanjul, 1996; fitness: this paper). Information from all data sets converged, indicating that the mutational rates were small, about 1% for viability and 3% for fitness. For both traits, the rate of mutational decline appears to be smaller than suggested by previous studies (about one-fifth of the latter), the average mutational effect was neither severe nor very slight, ranging from -0.1 to -0.3, and the distribution of mutant effects was, at most, slightly leptokurtic. Therefore, the mutational load in natural populations is one to two orders of magnitude smaller than previously thought (as based upon analyses conditional to estimates of the mutational decline of viability or fitness that appear to be biased upward). Over 95% of the mutational variance of each trait was contributed by non-slightly deleterious mutations (absolute homozygous effect larger than 0.03 or 0.1, depending on the data set considered) occurring at a rate not higher than 0.025 per haploid genome and generation. Our data suggest that most deleterious mutations affecting fitness act mainly through a single component-trait.     

Variations in the subunit content and catalytic activity of the cytochrome c oxidase complex from different tissues and different cardiac compartments

The objective of this study was to fully characterize normosmic perception of stimuli expected to cause widely varying degrees of olfactory and nasal trigeminal stimulation and to directly evaluate the possible role of olfactory nerve stimulation in nasal irritation sensitivity. During each of four identical test sessions, four anosmic and 31 normosmic participants were presented with a range of concentrations extending from peri-threshold for normosmics to supra-threshold for anosmics. For each session, odor (O) and nasal irritation (NI) sensitivities were summarized in terms of the concentrations required to produce four sensation levels ('iso-response' concentrations). Within-participant variation in these iso-response concentrations was < 10-fold for 95% of normosmics, for both O and NI. For O but not NI, these apparent fluctuations in sensitivity were largely accounted for by the uncertainty surrounding the iso-response concentrations calculated for each session. Anosmics exhibited minimal within- and between-participant variation in NI and required, for all but the highest perceptual level, a higher concentration than almost all normosmics. Between-participant variation, expressed in terms of 90% confidence interval widths, was approximately 0.5 log units for both O and NI for the highest perceptual level, but increased to approximately 0.8 and 1.8 log units, respectively, for the lowest (peri-threshold) level. Our findings suggest that: (i) most apparent variation over time in O sensitivity is actually a reflection of the uncertainty surrounding estimates of sensitivity obtained for each session; (ii) within- and between-participant variation in O sensitivity is far less than is commonly reported; and (iii) low to moderate levels of NI in normosmics are the result of relatively weak trigeminal stimulation combined with much greater olfactory activation.