Results of a control programme for the porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome in the French 'Pays de la Loire' region

The porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) virus first entered the Pays de la Loire region in November 1992, with variable effects ranging from sub-clinical seroconversion to severe reproductive failure and piglet mortality, and significant reduction of daily weight gains in finishing pigs. An epidemiological survey was carried out in February 1993. Since the infection prevalence was low (11 infected out of 2310 herds), the pig population was of medium density and the eradication programme of Aujeszky's disease had been successful in the Pays de la Loire region, it was decided (in March 1993) to undertake a control programme for PRRS. In 1993, introduction of infected pigs was known to be the most frequent source by which PRRS virus entered a herd. In the absence of vaccination, this source of virus introduction was reduced by a control programme applied to all members of the regional pig industry, through the impetus of the leaders of the Regional Sanitary Defence Confederation (FRGDS). The control programme was applied on purchased animals (sows, boars, piglets), artificial insemination centres and other environmental factors (people, vehicles, materials, slurry,...). Moreover, pigs from many infected herds were slaughtered. Results showed that in a context of low prevalence and limited spreading to nearby herds, efficient control of animal movements limited the infection spread. At the end of 1993, the PRRS prevalence was 2.7% in the region. Two years after the first outbreak, the PRRS infection could be considered as controlled since 98% of the herds remained free. In order to maintain this low infected status, the control programme was renewed. From this study epidemiological investigations have raised two major initial sources of infection, the use of contaminated semen and the introduction of infected pigs. Around an infected herd, serological screening is still running to detect infection in nearby herds.     

Clinical study on air in epidural hematomas

Twenty 2nd specific pathogen-free pigs were divided into 4 groups: Group A were infected with porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) virus at 6 weeks of age and treated with available swine erysipelas and swine fever combined vaccine (vaccinated) at 7 weeks of age; Group B were vaccinated at 7 weeks of age and infected with PRRS virus at 8 weeks of age; Group C were vaccinated at 7 weeks of age: Group D were neither vaccinated nor infected with PRRS virus. All pigs were challenged to Erysipelothrix rhusiopathiae C42 strain at 10 weeks of age. No clinical signs appeared after vaccination of group A and B pigs, thus confirming that the safety of the vaccine was not influenced by infection with PRRS virus. None of the pigs in Groups A and C developed erysipelas after challenge exposure to E. rhusiopathiae. In contrast, fever and/or urticaria appeared transiently in all pigs of Group B after challenge exposure. At the time of challenge exposure to E. rhusiopathiae, the PRRS virus titer was high in sera of Group B, but was low in those from Group A. However, vaccination of pigs with attenuated E. rhusiopathiae was effective in dual infection with PRRS virus and E. rhusiopathiae, because the clinical signs were milder and the E. rhusiopathiae strain was less recovered from these pigs compared to pigs of group D.     

Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae potentiation of porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus-induced pneumonia

An experimental model that demonstrates a mycoplasma species acting to potentiate a viral pneumonia was developed. Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae, which produces a chronic, lymphohistiocytic bronchopneumonia in pigs, was found to potentiate the severity and the duration of a virus-induced pneumonia in pigs. Pigs were inoculated with M. hyopneumoniae 21 days prior to, simultaneously with, or 10 days after inoculation with porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV), which induces an acute interstitial pneumonia in pigs. PRRSV-induced clinical respiratory disease and macroscopic and microscopic pneumonic lesions were more severe and persistent in M. hyopneumoniae-infected pigs. At 28 or 38 days after PRRSV inoculation, M. hyopneumoniae-infected pigs still exhibited lesions typical of PRRSV-induced pneumonia, whereas the lungs of pigs which had received only PRRSV were essentially normal. On the basis of macroscopic lung lesions, it appears that PRRSV infection did not influence the severity of M. hyopneumoniae infection, although microscopic lesions typical of M. hyopneumoniae were more severe in PRRSV-infected pigs. These results indicate that M. hyopneumoniae infection potentiates PRRSV-induced disease and lesions. Most importantly, M. hyopneumoniae-infected pigs with minimal to nondetectable mycoplasmal pneumonia lesions manifested significantly increased PRRSV-induced pneumonia lesions compared to pigs infected with PRRSV only. This discovery is important with respect to the control of respiratory disease in pigs and has implications in elucidating the potential contribution of mycoplasmas in the pathogenesis of viral infections of other species, including humans.     

In vivo signal transduction of tetrodotoxin-sensitive nociceptive responses by substance P given into the planta of the mouse hind limb

Diarrhea, sudden death after short duration of diarrhea and sudden death without apparent signs were observed in a herd of breeder pigs. Five pigs that died suddenly with diarrhea (SDD pigs) and 6 pigs that died suddenly without signs (SD pigs) were examined. The average age of the pigs was about 28 days. Twelve pigs of age 10 to 14 days old showing diarrhea (D pigs) were also examined. Eleven of them recovered. Large numbers of Escherichia coli were detected in all organs of every SDD and SD pig and in feces of D pigs. All of the isolates were identified as enterotoxigenic E. coli (ETEC) by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) virus cDNA was also detected from the lung of every SD and SDD pig by the RT-PCR. High and low titers of antibodies to PRRS virus were found in 10-day-old and 1-month-old pigs, respectively. In an experiment, 3 ETEC were isolated from 9 healthy weaning pigs during the quiescent stage in the herd. These data showed that growth of the ETEC was not active in healthy weaning pigs; however, following infection with PRRS virus ETEC infection became systemic and caused peracute death in the weaning pigs. It suggested also that infection with PRRS virus in 10-day-old pigs were protected by the colostral antibodies, and fatal infection by ETEC did not occur as a result.     

Selective breeding of rats for high and low motor activity in a swim test: toward a new animal model of depression

In three successive experiments, the immune functions of pigs persistently infected with the porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) have been evaluated. Non-specific immune responses were analyzed over a period of 12 weeks post-infection (PI). In addition, the capacity of PRRSV-infected pigs to develop an efficient immune response against pseudorabies virus (PRV) glycoproteins and to resist to a subsequent virulent challenge was investigated. Our results demonstrate that PRRSV produced minor effects on the immune system of pigs. The skin delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) in response to phytohemagglutinine injection was slightly diminished one week after challenge, but was restored thereafter. However, three weeks after the infection, the total white blood cell count, and the number of CD2+, CD8+ and IgM+ cells were enhanced. The increase in numbers of CD8+ cells persisted for three consecutive weeks. Serum immunoglobulins in infected pigs also increased by week 3 PI and up to 8 weeks PI. These results show that PRRSV may have stimulating effects on the pig immune system during the phase of long-lasting infection. After immunization with PRV glycoproteins, the production of anti-PRV antibodies and skin DTH response against PRV glycoproteins were not affected. On the contrary, following a virulent PRV challenge, PRRSV-infected pigs developed a better secondary antibody response and their resistance to the infection was as effective as in control pigs. Taken together, our data do not support a systemic immunosuppressive effect of PRRSV, during the persistent phase of infection. Other mechanisms may therefore apply to explain the emergence of secondary infections in endemically infected herds.     

Changes of lymphocyte subpopulations in pigs infected with porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) virus

Abnormal changes of T-cell subpopulation were observed in the peripheral blood lymphocytes of pigs infected with porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) virus. Pigs with naturally occurring PRRS revealed increases in CD2+ and CD8+ cells, and decreases in CD4+ cells and the ratios of CD4+/CD8+ cells. Specific-pathogen-free pigs inoculated with PRRS virus showed remarkable decreases in total lymphocytes, CD4+ and CD2+ cells on Postinoculation Day (PID) 3. The decline of CD4+ cells continued for at least 14 days, while CD2+ cells showed a tendency to increase thereafter. On the other hand,CD8+ cells slightly decreased in number on PID 3, and then increased remarkably; their number was significantly larger on PIDs 28 and 35 than on PID 0. The ratios of CD4+/CD8+ cells were significantly low between PIDs 3 and 28 as compared with PID 0. However, there were no differences in thymocyte subpopulations between infected and non-infected pigs, suggesting that the PRRS virus does not modulate intrathymic T-cell differentiation. In an experiment with peripheral blood mononuclear cell cultures, PRRS virus caused neither alteration of T-cell subpopulations nor cell proliferation, suggesting that the virus is not cytotoxic for CD4+ cells and not mitogenic for CD8+ cells.     

Mechanisms of transmission of Aujeszky's disease virus originating from feral swine in the USA

To understand the possible mechanisms of transmission of Aujeszky's disease virus (pseudorabies or PRV) from a feral pig reservoir, intranasal infections were initiated in domestic pigs and in pigs from a herd derived from captured feral pigs. Virus strains originating from feral pigs and from domestic pigs were compared. Similar shedding patterns were obtained in both feral-derived and domestic pigs, however, virus strains from feral pigs were markedly attenuated. Virus could be isolated after acute infection from nasal secretions, tonsils and occasionally from genital organs. In studies of transmission of PRV by cannibalism, either latently infected or acutely infected tissue was fed to both domestic and feral-derived pigs. In two similar experiments, latently infected tissue did not transmit virus, but tissues from acutely infected pigs did transmit infection. Cannibalism was observed typically in both types of pigs older than 6 weeks of age. It was concluded that transmission of PRV originating from feral pigs can occur by several mechanisms including the respiratory route and by cannibalism of pigs that die of acute infection. Transmission of PRV from feral swine may, however, result in sub-clinical infection.     

Blood pH in the umbilical artery at birth: an analysis of data from patients delivered in Hesse between 1986 and 1989

A nonradioactive in situ hybridization method is described for the detection of porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) in cell cultures and in formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue sections originating from experimentally infected pigs and from 1 field case. A 174 bp cDNA probe targeting the viral RNA encoding the nucleocapsid protein of a Canadian PRRSV isolate was generated by polymerase chain reaction. The cDNA probe was labeled by random priming with digoxigenin-dUTP using a commercially available kit. The ability of the digoxigenin-labeled probe to specifically detect PRRSV RNA was tested on cultured cells infected with 6 Canadian PRRSV isolates, a US PRRSV isolate and the European Lelystad isolate. The probe detected all Canadian PRRSV isolates tested as well as the US PRRSV isolate but did not detect the Lelystad isolate. In addition, when tested on formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue sections from pigs experimentally infected with several Canadian isolates and from a field case, a strong signal without background staining was obtained. Our results indicate that nonradioactive in situ hybridization could represent a useful tool for the detection of PRRSV in routinely fixed and processed tissues. In situ hybridization could also be used to differentiate infection by North American and European Lelystad-like PRRSV isolates.     

Apoptosis induced in vivo during acute infection by porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus

We studied apoptosis caused by porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) in vivo, focusing on the tissues that constitute the main targets for infection: lung and lymphoid tissues. Previous investigators have shown that the PRRSV glycoprotein p25, encoded by PRRSV open reading frame 5, induces apoptosis when expressed in COS-1 cells. Results of studies conducted in our laboratory indicate the simultaneous occurrence of PRRSV-induced alterations of spermatogenesis and apoptotic death of germinal epithelial cells in the testicle. In this study, the goal was to determine whether virus-induced apoptosis is a direct mechanism of cell death caused by PRRSV in infected pigs. Eight 3-week-old pigs were intranasally inoculated with PRRSV 16244B, a highly virulent field strain. Lung, tonsil, bronchial lymph node, spleen, and heart were assessed histologically at 4 and 7 days postinfection. To characterize PRRSV-infected cells and apoptotic cell death, we used immunohistochemical methods for detection of viral antigen, DNA electrophoresis for detection of DNA fragmentation, the terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated deoxyuridine triphosphate-fluorescein nick end labeling method for in situ detection of DNA strand breaks, and electron microscopy for ultrastructural morphologic studies. PRRSV infection resulted in widespread apoptosis in the lungs and lymphoid tissues of infected pigs. Virus infection-induced apoptotic cells were more abundant than PRRSV-infected cells in all tissues. DNA laddering was detected in lung and lymphoid tissues. However, double-labeling experiments demonstrated that the majority of apoptotic cells did not colocalize with PRRSV-infected cells. Our findings suggest the presence of an indirect mechanism in the induction of apoptosis for PRRSV.     

Experimental infection of maternally immune pigs with porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) virus

To investigate the influence of maternal antibody to porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) virus infection, the following examination was done using conventional and SPF pigs. Ten 17-day-old conventional pigs with maternal antibody against PRRS virus and 6 44-day-old SPF pigs seronegative were inoculated intranasally with 10(5.0) TCID50 of PRRS virus. Two conventional and 4 SPF pigs were served as non-inoculated control. In conventional pigs, coughing and febrile response were observed after inoculation, and mean rate of weight gain reduced. One of the inoculated conventional pigs died on post-inoculation-day (PID) 28 and Haemophilus parasuis was isolated from the lung. Although febrile response was also observed in the inoculated SPF pigs, reduction in weight gain rate was not recognized. Virus was isolated from all the sera of inoculated conventional and SPF pigs except one conventional pig between PID 7 and 49, and between PID 7 and 28, respectively. Onset of viremia in the several conventional pigs delayed. Virus was isolated from the tissues of the 5 conventional pigs on PID 65 and from the tissues of the dead pig. On the other hand, virus was not isolated from the tissues of non-inoculated conventional pigs, and inoculated and non-inoculated SPF pigs. At the virus inoculation, antibodies by the indirect fluorescent antibody (IFA) assay against PRRS virus were detected in the sera of conventional pigs with antibody titers of 1:20. Antibody titers gradually decreased after inoculation and rose from PID 21 or 28 and were between 1:160 and 1:640 on PID 63. Virus neutralization (VN) antibody titers were 1:2 or 1:4 at the inoculation and gradually decreased. Apparent rise in VN antibody titer was not observed after the inoculation. In the sera of control pigs, both antibody titers gradually decreased and did not rise. In the sera of the SPF pigs, antibodies by the IFA assay were first detected on PID 7 or 14. The titers of antibodies rose and reached their maximum with 1:320 to 1:2,560 on PID 21 to 35. VN antibodies were first detected in PID 42 to 56 and thereafter, the titers ranged between 1:1 to 1:4. Control SPF pigs were free of antibody throughout the examination. Antigenic variability was not recognized between the inoculated and recovered viruses by the VN test. The prolonged duration of viremia and virus isolation from the tissues on PID 65 in conventional pigs with low maternal antibody might support the present of antibody-dependent enhancement activity of PRRS virus infection.     

Virus quantification and identification of cellular targets in the lungs and lymphoid tissues of pigs at different time intervals after inoculation with porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV)

Sixteen 6 week old conventional pigs were inoculated by aerosol with a European strain of porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV). Virus replication was followed by virus titration and immunofluorescence in the lungs and in associated and distant lymphoid tissues at 3, 14, 21, 35, 42 and 82 days post-inoculation (DPI). PRRSV replication was detected in alveolar macrophages, lungs, tonsils, spleen, retropharyngeal lymph nodes, bronchial lymph nodes and thoracic aortic lymph nodes at 3 DPI. The same tissues, except retropharyngeal and thoracic aortic lymph nodes, were PRRSV positive at 14 DPI. Lungs and alveolar macrophages were PRRSV positive until 35 DPI. PRRSV was not detected in heart, peripheral blood mononuclear cells and bone marrow cells. Viremia was detected from 3 to 28 DPI. Not more than 2% of alveolar macrophages were PRRSV positive even during the acute stage of infection. 80 to 94% of the PRRSV infected cells in the lungs and in lung lavaged cells were identified as macrophages using a porcine macrophage specific monoclonal antibodies. In the lymph nodes and spleen, 100% of the infected cells were macrophages. Anti-PRRSV antibodies were detected by a blocking ELISA as early as 7 DPI. the antibody titre gradually increased to reach a geometric mean titre (GMT) of 160 at 35 DPI. It remained at that level until the end of the study. These findings clearly demonstrate that PRRSV has a tropism for macrophages. PRRSV mainly replicates in macrophages of the lymphoid tissues and lungs in the acute phase of infection and persists in the lung macrophages.     

Hepatitis C virus infection in the elderly. Epidemiology, prophylaxis and optimal treatment

Chronic infection with the hepatitis C virus (HCV) occurs throughout the world and appears to be the main cause of hepatocellular carcinoma. Studies have shown that, in areas of high endemicity, the prevalence of HCV infection is low in children but high in people aged > 60 years. Medical interventions were found to play an important role in the spread of HCV infection, because elderly patients became infected via contaminated blood transfusions or when contaminated syringes and needles were used. Maternal and sexual transmission do not appear to be the main routes of HCV infection. Interferon treatment eliminates HCV in 20 to 30% of patients with chronic HCV infection. The response to interferon therapy is usually complete in 70 to 80% of people with low levels of HCV RNA, HCV of genotype 2 and young women, but poor in elderly patients. Because liver disease can be severe in elderly patients, more effective therapies are clearly needed.     

A case-control questionnaire survey of risk factors for porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) seropositivity in Danish swine herds

Sixty-eight case herds seropositive to porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) were compared to 128 seronegative controls in a double-blinded questionnaire survey. The study indicated no increased risk of PRRS seropositivity for herds using artificial insemination with semen from PRRS seropositive AI-stations. Also the herd-size was non-related to the risk of PRRS seropositivity, indicating that air-borne spread of PRRS may not have been a predominant feature in Denmark. Introduction of replacement breeding animals from seropostive breeding- and multiplying herds significantly increased the risk of a herd being PRRS seropositive, as did introduction of 25 kg pigs for feeding. PRRS seropositivity was in the farmers' opinions associated with abortions in sows, early farrowing, high postweaning mortality and low weight gain in fattening pigs. However, the reported frequencies of probelms were relatively low.     

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus comparison: divergent evolution on two continents

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) is a recently described arterivirus responsible for disease in swine worldwide. Comparative sequence analysis of 3'-terminal structural genes of the single-stranded RNA viral genome revealed the presence of two genotypic classes of PRRSV, represented by the prototype North American and European strains, VR-2332 and Lelystad virus (LV), respectively. To better understand the evolution and pathogenicity of PRRSV, we obtained the 12,066-base 5'-terminal nucleotide sequence of VR-2332, encoding the viral replication activities, and compared it to those of LV and other arteriviruses. VR-2332 and LV differ markedly in the 5' leader and sections of the open reading frame (ORF) 1a region. The ORF 1b sequence was nearly colinear but varied in similarity of proteins encoded in identified regions. Furthermore, molecular and biochemical analysis of subgenomic mRNA (sgmRNA) processing revealed extensive variation in the number of sgmRNAs which may be generated during infection and in the lengths of noncoding sequence between leader-body junctions and the translation-initiating codon AUG. In addition, VR-2332 and LV select different leader-body junction sites from a pool of similar candidate sites to produce sgmRNA 7, encoding the viral nucleocapsid protein. The presence of substantial variations across the entire genome and in sgmRNA processing indicates that PRRSV has evolved independently on separate continents. The near-simultaneous global emergence of a new swine disease caused by divergently evolved viruses suggests that changes in swine husbandry and management may have contributed to the emergence of PRRS.     

Summary of the II International Symposium on Cytomegalovirus

Human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) is a highly species-specific DNA virus belonging to the Betaherpesvirinae subfamily of the herpesviridae family. Like other herpesviruses, primary infection with HCMV is followed by persistence of the virus in a latent form. The sites of latency are still largely undefined, but they probably include bone marrow progenitor cells and peripheral blood monocytes. From these sites, the virus can reactivate, resulting in renewed shedding of the virus, or, in immunocompromized persons, development of disease. Humans are the only reservoir of HCMV and transmission occurs by person-to-person contact. Infection with HCMV is common. In most developed countries, HCMV seroprevalence steadily increases after infancy and 10-20% of children are infected before puberty. In adults, the prevalence of antibodies ranges from 40 to 100%. Although HCMV has a world-wide distribution, infection with HCMV is more common in the developing countries and in areas of low socioeconomic conditions, which is predominantly related to the closeness of contacts within these populations. Except for a mononucleosis-like illness in some persons, infection with HCMV rarely causes disease in immunocompetent individuals. However, HCMV can cause severe morbidity and mortality in congenitally infected newborns and immunocompromized patients, most notably transplant-recipients and HIV-infected persons. This article provides a review of the information presented at the Second International Symposium on Cytomegalovirus organized and convened by The Macrae Group (New York City, NY) in Acapulco, Mexico on 24-28 April 1998. During this symposium, the state-of-the-art knowledge on diagnosis, treatment and prophylaxis of HCMV infections were discussed, and, based on this information, attempts to highlight the future directions in basic and clinical research areas that need to be stimulated to facilitate advancement in prevention and treatment of CMV disease.     

Effect of maternally acquired Aujeszky's disease (pseudorabies) virus-specific antibody in pigs on establishment of latency and seroconversion to differential glycoproteins after low dose challenge

This study investigated whether (1) passively immune pigs could become latently infected after challenge with low doses of wild type pseudorabies virus (PRV) and (2) if seroconversion to PRV could be consistently detected using two commercially available differential diagnostic ELISAs. Three litters of piglets with passively acquired PRV serum neutralizing (SN) antibody (geometric mean titers 47.03 to 95.10) were challenged at 6 to 12 days of age with 236 to 500 TCID50 of Shope strain virus; pigs were vaccinated at 11 weeks of age with a commercially available genetically engineered vaccine (TK- gE- gG- Iowa S62 strain PRV). Vaccination was intended to reduce the risk of reactivation of latent infection resulting in spread of virulent PRV infection to previously uninfected pigs during the experiment. Vaccination at this age also approximated common field practices in infected herds. After 15 weeks, all challenged pigs were seropositive on the PRV glycoprotein (g or gp) E differential ELISA but were seronegative on the gG differential ELISA. All three challenge groups had pigs that were latently infected as evidenced by the detection of PRV DNA by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay of their trigeminal ganglia (TG). There was a significant inverse relationship observed for age at challenge and the proportion of PCR positive pigs in the group 15 weeks postchallenge (p = 0.0004). This trend was independent of the passively acquired PRV SN antibody titers at challenge. In this study, passively acquired antibody did not provide protection against establishment of latent infection in piglets after exposure to low doses of virulent PRV. These latent infections were detected serologically by only one of two available differential diagnostic ELISA.     

Congenital infection of pigs with ruminant-type pestiviruses

Congenital infections of pigs were induced with two ruminant-type pestiviruses isolated from pigs. One of the viruses was bovine viral diarrhoea virus-like and the other border disease virus-like. Both produced symptoms similar to those observed with low virulence strains of classical swine fever virus. A striking effect of persistent virus infection in post-natal life was stunting in viraemic animals. It was also shown that a congenitally infected pig shed virus for 2.5 years and in sufficient quantity to infect other pigs, even by indirect contact. Unlike ruminants, congenitally infected pigs sometimes had persistent viraemia but eventually eliminated the virus. Clearance of virus from the blood was related to the appearance of neutralizing antibodies. However, clearance from the tissues sometimes took as much as 5 months longer than from the blood.     

Evaluation of the reinforcing and discriminative stimulus properties of the low-affinity N-methyl-D-aspartate channel blocker memantine

Two experiments were designed to study ultrastructural changes in porcine alveolar macrophages (PAM) inoculated with porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS) virus (experiment 1) and with PRRS virus and Haemophilus parasuis (experiment 2). In both experiments, the viral infectious dose represented a "multiplicity of infection" of 1. Viral infection alone induced minimal ultrastructural changes at this dose, consisting only of an increase in lysosome numbers. Mixed viral and bacterial infection induced the production of greatly increased numbers of phagosomes and phagolysosomes. The PAM were of low efficacy in phagocytizing H. parasuis. PRRS virus infection had only a minimal effect on the phagocytosis of H. parasuis by PAM. It is suggested that the virus induces PAM activation rather than PAM destruction.