Discharge equation of semi-circular side weirs: An experimental study

Side weirs are diverting structures and usually used for diverting and controlling the water flow into the side open channel. The present study deals with an experimental study regarding the hydraulic performance of side weirs with semi-circular vertical sections along the main channel. As flow depth of the main channel increases the top flow width of the semi-circular side weir (SCSW) increases which is an advantage when high discharge enters the main channel and should be immediately diverted for safety reasons. In this study, the flow discharge of semi-circular sharp-crested side weirs and their affecting parameters are investigated. To investigate the hydraulic behavior and geometric characteristics of the SCSWs, a comprehensive laboratory study including 155 tests (for three weir diameters 0.25, 0.30 and 0.40 m) was conducted in a physical model under subcritical flow conditions. Flow discharge of the SCSW was investigated in relation to height, diameter and flow head of side weir, also approach Froude number (Froude number at upstream end of the side weir) and main channel width. Three different discharge models were developed based on; purely dimensional analysis technique, classical weir equation with linear water surface and classical weir equation with horizontal water surface profile (conventional weir theory along with dimensional analysis technique). The presented mathematical discharge models enable estimation of discharge along the SCSW with acceptable accuracy (best model has an average error of 1.87% with a maximum error of 6.31%) compared with the measured data under subcritical flow conditions. Additionally, a relationship was proposed for computing the limiting flow depth at the downstream end of the SCSW. Experimental results confirm that the proposed relationship well explains the behavior of flow over the SCSW regarding the downstream flow conditions.     

A flow field characterization in a circular channel along a side weir

Side weirs have been used for centuries in urban drainage and flood control for their ability to divert high incoming flow rates. The flow along a side weir may be studied by means of different approaches. However, although the question of side weir has been debating for many decades, there are few studies on the local hydraulic characteristics of the flow along these structures in circular channels.An experimental study of the flow field in a circular channel along a side weir using a commercial TSI Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) system is shown in this paper. Weakly supercritical flows running into different geometric configurations of the weir were investigated, with Froude numbers varying from 1.1 to 1.6. Free surface profiles have been obtained by an image processing technique. An empirical equation has been proposed for their representation. Longitudinal velocity profiles along the side weir can be well predicted by an entropic approach. Local outflow along the side weir may be represented by an asymmetric curve. The peak outflow generally occurs between the 30% and the 50% of the weir length. The elementary discharge coefficient significantly increases from upstream to downstream. An energy head reduction was observed under the investigated configurations. Most of the head variation occurs in the central part of the weir. Finally, the flow power decreases along the weir according to a non-linear function.A thorough knowledge of the flow field features should allow to improve side weir analysis and design, whatever approach is used for the study.     

A review of studies on estimating the discharge coefficient of flow control structures based on the soft computing models

The discharge coefficient (Cd) plays a vital role in the accurate design and safety of weirs, spillways, and dams. In the last decade, Soft Computing(SC) models, which showed excellent capabilities for non-linear mapping between parameters, were widely used to estimate the discharge coefficient of flow control structures. This study provides a comprehensive review of the application of SC models for estimating Cd of different flow control structures such as ogee spillways, orifices, side weirs, etc. In addition, the most common empirical relations which are obtained from laboratory experiments are discussed briefly. The findings revealed that weir length/flow depth ratio, weir length/channel width ratio, weir height/flow depth, and Froude number are widely used to estimate Cd in the side weirs. Besides, the ratio of orifice crest height to height of side orifice, the ratio of main channel width to length of side orifice, ratio of main channel width to height of side orifice, and ratio of the height of side orifice to upstream flow depth were extensively employed to calculate Cd of orifice structures. The common parameters for measuring Cd of labyrinth weirs are, discharge over a labyrinth cycle, weir height, channel width, apex constant, upstream head, discharge over the weir, effective length, convergence constant, sidewall angle, and Froude number. In the weir-gate structure, some factors such as contraction coefficient of the gate, head loss, and weir height are key parameters for the accurate evaluation of Cd. The trends of SC models, features of popular models, and the background of models are discussed briefly in this paper. Also, research gaps and possible directions for new studies are suggested.     

Discharging capacity of rectangular side weirs in straight open channels

A side weir is a hydraulic control structure used in irrigation and drainage systems and combined sewer systems. A comprehensive laboratory study, including 843 tests for the discharge coefficient of a sharp-crested rectangular side weir in a straight channel, was conducted in a large physical model under subcritical flow conditions. The discharge coefficient is a function of the upstream Froude number, the ratios of weir length to channel width, weir length to flow depth, and weir height to flow depth. An equation was developed considering all dimensional parameters for discharge coefficient of the sharp-crested rectangular side weir. The average error of the proposed equation is 4.54%. The present study data were compared with ten different discharge coefficient equations developed by several researchers. The study also presents water surface profile and surface velocity streamlines.     

Flow over trapezoidal side weir

In this paper, the hydraulic characteristics of a sharp crested trapezoidal side weir have been experimentally and theoretically investigated. It was found that the DeMarchi coefficient of discharge for a sharp crested trapezoidal side weir in subcritical flow is related to the main channel Froude number, the side slope of weir, ratio of weir height to upstream depth of flow and ratio of weir length to upstream depth of flow. Suitable equations for the discharge coefficient are also obtained.     

Experimental analysis of combined side weir-gate located on a straight channel

Flow measurement and control in open channel system for lateral flow is important to support the system management. The flow characteristics of combined side weir-gate are complicated due to changes in flow conditions along the side weir-gate section. Experimental investigation of the flow characteristics of both weir and sluice gates is crucial for predicting the flow through a combined side weir-gate structure. Although weir-gate structures are widely used for frontal flow in hydraulic structures, the same is not true for lateral flows. In this study, 650 laboratory tests were conducted to determine the flow characteristics of combined side weir-gate for subcritical flow, and the experimental results were analyzed to determine the effect of these characteristics and weir-gate geometry on discharge capacity. Interaction factor of combined side weir-gate is a function of the upstream Froude number, the ratio of gate opening to upstream flow depth, the ratio of distance between the top of the sluice gate and the weir crest to gate opening, the ratio of weir and gate length to upstream flow depth, and the ratio of weir and gate length to main channel width. Consequently, more discharge is passed through combined side weir-gate compared to side weir and sluice gates. The empirically derived equations for the discharge of combined side weir-gate show good compatibility with the experimental data.     

Study of flow at side weir in narrow flume using visualization techniques

The purpose of the research was to quantify characteristics of a subcritical flow at a rectangular sharp-crested side weir in a rectangular main channel using non-invasive measuring techniques based on the visualization of the flow. Experiments were carried out in physical models, including nine different dimensions of the side weir and nine combinations of the inflow and tailwater level for each weir, amounting to 81 test runs. Velocity vector fields were measured in various horizontal planes along the side weir using a high speed digital camera and electrolysis-induced hydrogen bubbles as flow tracers. Recorded films were converted into sequences of images which were used for numerical calculation of local velocities. Components of velocity vectors were determined with great spatial and time resolution. Longitudinal profiles of water surface elevation at each side weir were determined using photos of laser-induced vertical section planes. Measured discharges and flow depths were used to formulate new equation for the side weir discharge coefficient using dimensional analysis. The principal results indicated that velocity distribution along the side weir was distinctly non-uniform, with various velocity ratios increasing along the crest. However, the calculated energy grade line was parallel to the main channel bed, indicating that only friction losses were present. The proposed equations for the side weir discharge coefficient gave results that were in good accordance with two other studies.     

Discharge characteristics and structure of flow in labyrinth weirs with a downstream pool

A new design of a labyrinth weir is introduced in this study by adding a square pool to the vertex of a one-cycle triangular labyrinth weir with a sidewall angle of 45°. The addition of the square pool increased weir length without causing an excessive nappe interaction, and as a result, reduced the head water over the weir with the same discharge. Laboratory experiments were carried out to investigate the hydraulic performance of the new design with a potential application in pool-weir fishways. Mean and turbulence characteristics of flow for different weir geometries and in both free and submerged flow regimes were measured to be used for prediction of fish behaviour in the upstream of the proposed weir models. Discharge coefficients based on channel width and weir length were calculated. It was found that the new design can significantly increase the capacity of triangular labyrinth weirs and provide financial advantages in construction over triangular labyrinth weirs without pools in low discharges. In submerged flow conditions, the proposed model performed better than sharp-crested linear weirs in low discharges. Contour plots of the three-dimensional velocity components showed a region of strong mean flow around the neck of the new weir model. Turbulent characteristics such as turbulent kinetic energy, power spectra, exuberance ratio, and joint probability distribution functions of velocity fluctuations were extracted from instantaneous three dimensional velocities for different weir depths and flow regimes. Two vertical planes were identified based on the highest turbulent mixing in free and submerged flow regimes. The depths contributing the most to turbulent mixing were identified; active depths decreased as the flow regime changed from free to submerge flow regime.     

Water surface profile along a side weir in a parabolic channel

A side weir is an overflow structure set into the side of a channel. This structure is used for water level control in channels, diverting excess water from a main channel into a side channel and as storm overflows from urban sewage systems. Computation of water surface profile over the side weirs is essential to determine the flow rate of the side weir. Discharge estimation of the side weir is still an important research subject. Most previous research works for the side weir were carried out in main channels with rectangular, triangular, trapezoidal and circular cross sections. Analytical solutions for water surface profile along a rectangular side weir are available only for the special cases of rectangular and trapezoidal main channels on the basis of a constant specific energy. No analytical solution is available for a rectangular side weir located in a parabolic channel. This research presents an elegant analytical solution for establishing the water surface profile along a side weir located in a parabolic channel which involves the use of incomplete elliptic integrals. The solution, which yields a direct computation, should be a useful computational tool for evaluation and design of rectangular side weirs in parabolic channels.     

Experimental analysis of flow characteristics over hydrofoil weirs

The rounded crested weirs are commonly used for discharge measurements and this overflow structures have advantages such as stable overflow pattern and good accuracy. Hydrofoil weirs with streamlined properties are similar to the ogee weirs and can be used as a spillway profile. The hydraulic features of flow over hydrofoil weirs created by the NACA0018, NACA0021 and NACA0024 hydrofoil geometry placed in an open channel are investigated experimentally under free-flow conditions. The velocity field of hydrofoil weir flows are measured by one-dimensional Laser Doppler Anemometer. Experimental velocity profiles are measured along the middle section of the channel, especially around the weir structure, to determine the boundary layer separation. According to the determination of optimum weir structure the free surface profiles, pressure distributions on weir surfaces, experimental discharge coefficients and head losses over weir structures are determined for different structure and flow conditions. Pressure distributions over the hydrofoil weir are presented. In addition, the relationships between discharge coefficient (C_d) and flow rate (Q), specific total head (H/R), relative weir height (P/H), relative total head (H/P) and dimensionless total energy head upstream of the weir (H/L) are investigated.     

Weir velocity formulation for sharp-crested rectangular weirs

Discharge in open channels can be measured by sharp-crested rectangular weirs. Generally, measured head over the weir crest is substituted into an empirical formula derived from energy considerations to calculate the discharge. Assumptions made on the derivation are taken into account by defining a discharge coefficient that fits into the experimental data. In this study, a physical quantity, the average velocity over the weir section defined as ‘weir velocity’ is directly formulated as function of weir geometry and head over the weir. Weir velocity plotted against the weir head has a universal behavior for constant weir width to channel width ratio independent of the weir size. This unique behavior is described in terms of weir parameters to calculate the discharge without involving a discharge coefficient. Combining weir velocity data for variable weir widths provides a basis for direct formulation of discharge. The weir velocity exhibits simpler functional dependency on weir parameters in contrast to the discharge coefficient.     

Cross-sectional void fraction distribution measurements in a vertical annulus two-phase flow by high speed X-ray computed tomography and real-time neutron radiography techniques

A real-time neutron radiography (RTNR) system and a high speed X-ray computed tomography (X-CT) system are compared for measurement of two-phase flow. Each system is used to determine the flow regime, and the void fraction distribution in a vertical annulus flow channel with particular attention on the temporal resolution of the systems and the time behaviour of the two-phase flow. The annulus flow channel is operated as a bubble column and measurements obtained for gas flow rates from 0.0 to 30.0 l/min. Both the RTNR and the X-CT systems show that the two-dimensional void fraction distribution can be obtained. The X-CT system is shown to have a superior temporal resolution capable of resolving the void fraction distribution in an (r,θ) plane in 4.0 ms. The RTNR system is shown to obtain void fraction distribution in a (r,z) plane in 33.0 ms. Void fraction distribution for bubbly flow and slug flow is determined.     

Experimental investigation of discharge coefficient over novel kind of sharp-crested V-notch weir

Thin-plate weirs are the simplest and least expensive devices, which frequently have been employed in many water projects. In this research, a unique type of Sharp-Crested V-notch weir, entitled SCVW, has been introduced. The hydraulic characteristics of the present weir were investigated theoretically and experimentally under free aerated and non-aerated flow conditions in an open channel for large physical models. To investigate the variations of the discharge coefficient of SCVW versus weir height and vertex angle, a comprehensive laboratory experiments were conducted by measuring the discharge and the water head over the crest of weir. Possibility of different formulations for the head- discharge relationship of SCVW was examined and suitable analytical equation was proposed. The computed discharge using the suggested equation was within 0–10% of the observed ones. According to the experimental observations, the SCVW showed better performance in comparison with normal wire.     

Prediction of the discharge of side weir in the converge channels using artificial neural networks

Considering the common use of side weirs in irrigation and drainage networks, estimation of the discharge of the side weirs has always given a consideration by water engineering researchers. Another issue about side weirs is the change in flow conditions in the weir and downstream channel. To optimize the flow conditions in the side weir, this structure is established in a converging channel to reduce the channel width and compensate the reduced discharge. The geometrical parameters assumed as variables in this study are: weir length, weir height, convergence angle and downstream channel width. About 248 experiments were performed. Three neural network models were used to estimate the discharge from the side weir. The model was constructed using MATLAB, and the dimensionless variables that were the geometrical and hydraulic ratios of the model were selected as input parameters. Four ratios were selected as inputs to the model to estimate the discharge coefficient and the discharge from the weir. Considering the outputs of the model, the neural-fuzzy networks have the least error compared to the other models, and this model estimates the discharge of side weir overflowing with 99.8% accuracy.     

A new approach to improve the discharging capacity of sharp-crested triangular plan form weirs

Conventional weirs are inherited with afflux and submergence of area upstream of the weir. Various weirs of modified plan form have been suggested in the past to enhance their discharging capacity and to restrict the afflux. Presented in this paper are results of the experimental study carried out to investigate the discharging capacity of a sharp-crested triangular plan form weir under free flow conditions in a rectangular channel. The efficiency of the triangular plan form weirs is better than the normal weir and also high for low vertex angle and decreases with the increase of ratio of head over the crest of the weir and crest height due to interference of the water jets downstream. The computed discharge using the proposed equation is within ±5% of the observed ones. Sensitivity of the weir, i.e., change of discharge due to unit change in head is also carried out which indicates that the weir is more sensitive at the low head and low vertex angle.     

Minimizing the hydraulic side effects of weirs construction by using labyrinth weirs

It is no doubt that weirs are one of the most important hydraulic structures that play a vital role in irrigation project. So, it is necessary to minimize the hydraulic side effects of weirs. Throughout this paper, experiments were conducted to investigate the suitable dimensions and shape of weir's crest to increase head loss, decrease upstream bank level upstream weir and get the most economic structure. Various crest angles of labyrinth weir were tested under different flow conditions. Also back water curve upstream weir was studied according to different weir crest angles. A case of linear weir crest was also included in the test program. The experimental results indicated that labyrinth weirs have lower operating heads and longer crest length compared with a linear weir having the same lateral space and the same discharge. Results showed that the crest weir angle of 60° is the best angle of weir crest. It reduces water level above crested level and the relative jump depth by 18% and 20%, respectively. In addition, it increase the average values of the dissipated energy and the discharge coefficient by 15% and 14%, respectively. It also gave maximum reduction in backwater curve profile by about 17%. Furthermore, the model was verified using CFD numerical model. The numerical results agreed with the experimental results.     

Discharge coefficient for an inclined side weir crest using a constant energy approach

In this paper, the inclined side weir discharge coefficient was studied using a side weir with three different crest angles (θ=4°,8°,12°) fixed either against and in the flow direction, and the results are compared with those from a horizontal side weir crest (θ=0°). In total there were seven models.The results show that the De Marchi assumption of constant energy for all side weir crested angles is acceptable, and thus that the calculated weir discharge value can therefore be undertaken.An equation for the discharge coefficient was obtained for an inclined side weir, so the value of C_d for crest angle θ=12° increased by 13.6% with respect to the value for θ=8°, by 29% with respect to that for θ=4°, and by 39% with respect to that for the horizontal case (θ=0°), for a crest inclined against the flow direction, while when the crest was inclined in the flow direction all those values exceed, to 14.5%, 31.0%, and 40.7%, respectively. This means that the discharge increases with increasing side weir crest angle, so when we want uniformity in the flow direction and exceed discharge we need to make the side weir crest incline against the flow direction while when we want furthermore discharge we need to make the side weir crest incline in the flow direction.     

Hydraulic jump and energy dissipation downstream stepped weir

Hydraulic jump can be defined as a sudden change or rise of water level because of changing the channel slope from steep to mild combined turbulent flow. This can be used for energy dissipation to reduce flow energy downstream hydraulic structure. Recent studies dealt with energy dissipation downstream hydraulic structures such as stepped weir by changing water level upstream and downstream to reduce flow energy. In this study, the focus was placed on the hydraulic jump formation downstream stepped weir and its characteristics, as well as used it as energy dissipation to reduce the residual energy that will be dissipated on stepped weir. 27 stepped weir models were tested with three different heights, slopes as well as changed number of steps for all models. It was found that the energy dissipation increased by increasing weir slope, the number of steps, and decreasing the height weir, by 20%, 20.6%, 21.8% respectively. It was also found that the energy dissipation increased when the hydraulic jump length increased, but this was not economy. The best model for energy dissipation in this study was that have lower height and greater slope and steps number. This model gives lower value of hydraulic jump length; this is more economy as it reduces the length of stilling basin which is reduces the cost of its construction downstream stepped weir or stepped spillway.     

Sensitivity analysis of the factors affecting the discharge capacity of side weirs in trapezoidal channels using extreme learning machines

Side weirs are installed on the side walls of main channels to control and regulate flow. In this study, sensitivity analysis is planned using Extreme Learning Machines (ELM) to recognize the factors affecting the discharge coefficient in trapezoidal channels. A total of 31 models with 1 to 5 parameters are developed. The input parameters are ratio of side weir length to trapezoidal channel bottom width (L/b), Froude number (Fr), ratio of side weir length to flow depth upstream of the side weir (L/y₁), ratio of flow depth upstream of the side weir to the main channel bottom width (y₁/b) and trapezoid channel side wall slope (m). Among the models with one input parameter, the model including Froude number modeled the discharge coefficient more accurately (MAPE=4.118, R²=0.835). Between models with two input parameters, the model using Fr and L/b produced MAPE and R² values of 2.607 and 0.913 respectively. Moreover, among the models with four input parameters, the model containing Fr, L/b, L/y₁ and y₁/b was the most accurate (MAPE=2.916, R²=0.925).     

Discharge characteristics of a modified oblique side weir in subcritical flow

Side weirs are frequently used in many water projects. Due to their position with respect to the flow direction, side weirs are categorized as plain, oblique and labyrinth. One of the advantages of an oblique side weir is the increase in the effective length of the weir for overflowing and, therefore, diverting more discharge with the same channel opening, weir height and flow properties (i.e., upstream discharge, upstream Froude number and so on). In this paper, an experimental set-up of a new design of an oblique side weir with asymmetric geometry has been studied. The hydraulic behavior of this kind of oblique side weir, with a constant opening length, different weir heights and asymmetric oblique angle, has been investigated in a subcritical situation. The results from over 200 test measurements show that this kind of weir is up to 2.33 times more efficient with respect to the conventional side weir in a rectangular channel among the tested conditions. Finally, the discharge coefficient as a function of geometrical and flow variables are presented for design engineers. In addition, a more precise relation has been obtained for flow with Froude numbers less than 0.4.