Fabrication & performance study of a palladium on alumina supported membrane reactor: Natural gas steam reforming,a case study

In this work, a synthetic mixture of natural gas is considered in a steam reforming process for generating hydrogen by using a membrane reactor housing a composite membrane constituted of a Pd-layer (13 μm) supported on alumina. The Pd/Al₂O₃ membrane separates part of the produced hydrogen through its selective permeation, although it shows a relatively low H₂/N₂ ideal selectivity (>200 at 0.5 bar of trans-membrane pressure and T = 425 °C).The steam reforming reaction is performed at 420 °C, by varying the gas hourly space velocity between 4400 h^?1 and 6900 h^?1 and by using two different mixtures containing some common impurities found within natural gas pipeline. Specifically, the effect of N₂ and CO₂ as impurities in the feed line is analyzed. The reaction pressure and steam-to-carbon ratio (S/C) are kept constant at 3.0 bar (abs.) and 3.5/1, respectively.The best performance of the Pd-based membrane reactor is obtained at 420 °C, 3.0 bar and 100 mL/min of sweep-gas, yielding a methane conversion of 55% and hydrogen recovery >90%.     

Methane steam reforming using a membrane reactor equipped with a Pd-based composite membrane for effective hydrogen production

Herein, a methane steam reforming (MSR) reaction was carried out using a Pd composite membrane reactor packed with a commercial Ru/Al₂O₃ catalyst under mild operating conditions, to produce hydrogen with CO₂ capture. The Pd composite membrane was fabricated on a tubular stainless steel support by the electroless plating (ELP) method. The membrane exhibited a hydrogen permeance of 2.26 × 10^?3 mol m² s^?1 Pa^?0.5, H₂/N₂ selectivity of 145 at 773 K, and pressure difference of 20.3 kPa. The MSR reaction, which was carried out at steam to carbon ratio (S/C) = 3.0, gas hourly space velocity (GHSV) = 1700 h^?1, and 773 K, showed that methane conversion increased with the pressure difference and reached 79.5% at ΔP = 506 kPa. This value was ～1.9 time higher than the equilibrium value at 773 K and 101 kPa. Comparing with the previous studies which introduced sweeping gas for low hydrogen partial pressure in the permeate stream, very high pressure difference (2500–2900 kPa) for increase of hydrogen recovery and very low GHSV (<150) for increase hydraulic retention time (HRT), our result was worthy of notice. The gas composition monitored during the long-term stability test showed that the permeate side was composed of 97.8 vol% H₂, and the retentate side contained 67.8 vol% CO₂ with 22.2 vol% CH₄. When energy was recovered by CH₄ combustion in the retentate streams, pre-combustion carbon capture was accomplished using the Pd-based composite membrane reactor.     

Hydrogen production by steam methane reforming in a membrane reactor equipped with a Pd composite membrane deposited on a porous stainless steel

With the aim of producing hydrogen at low cost and with a high conversion efficiency, steam methane reforming (SMR) was carried out under moderate operating conditions in a Pd-based composite membrane reactor packed with a commercial Ru/Al₂O₃ catalyst. A Pd-based composite membrane with a thickness of 4–5 μm was prepared on a tubular stainless steel support (diameter of 12.7 mm, length of 450 mm) using electroless plating (ELP). The Pd-based composite membrane had a hydrogen permeance of 2.4 × 10^?3 mol m^?1 s^?1 Pa^?0.5 and an H₂/N₂ selectivity of 618 at a temperature of 823 K and a pressure difference of 10.1 kPa. The SMR test was conducted at 823 K with a steam-to-carbon ratio of 3.0 and gas hourly space velocity of 1000 h^?1; increasing the pressure difference resulted in enhanced methane conversion, which reached 82% at a pressure difference of 912 kPa. To propose a guideline for membrane design, a process simulation was conducted for conversion enhancement as a function of pressure difference using Aspen HYSYS^®. A stability test for SMR was conducted for ～120 h; the methane conversion, hydrogen production rate, and gas composition were monitored. During the SMR test, the carbon monoxide concentration in the total reformed stream was <1%, indicating that a series of water gas shift reactors was not needed in our membrane reactor system.     

Mathematical simulation of hydrogen production via methanol steam reforming using double-jacketed membrane reactor

The hydrogen production and purification via methanol reforming reaction was studied in a double-jacketed Pd membrane reactor using a 1-D, non-isothermal mathematical model. Both mass and heat transfer behavior were evaluated simultaneously in three parts of the reactor, annular side, permeation tube and the oxidation side. The simulation results exhibited that increasing the volumetric flow rate of hydrogen in permeation side could enhance hydrogen permeation rate across the membrane. The optimum velocity ratio between permeation and annular sides is 10. However, hydrogen removal could lower the temperature in the reformer. The hydrogen production rate increases as temperature increases at a given Damköhler number, but the methanol conversion and hydrogen recovery yield decrease. In addition, the optimum molar ratio of air and methanol was 1.3 with three air inlet temperatures. The performance of a double-jacketed membrane reactor was compared with an autothermal reactor by judging against methanol conversion, hydrogen recovery yield and production rate. Under the same reaction conditions, the double-jacketed reactor can convert more methanol at a given reactor volume than that of an autothermal reactor.     

Co-current and counter-current modes for methanol steam reforming membrane reactor

In this simulation study, methanol steam reforming reaction to produce synthesis gas has been studied in a membrane reactor when shell side and lumen side streams are in co-current mode or in counter-current mode. The simulation results for both co-current and counter-current modes are presented in terms of methanol conversion and molar fraction versus temperature, pressure, _H2O/_CH3OH${\mathrm{H}}_2\mathrm{O}/{\mathrm{CH}}_3\mathrm{OH}$ molar feed flow rate ratio and axial co-ordinate.     

Autothermal steam reforming of glycerol for hydrogen production over packed-bed and Pd/Ag alloy membrane reactors

In this study, glycerol, with its high H/C ratio feature, was steam reformed with oxygen to produce hydrogen in packed-bed and Pd/Ag membrane reactors. The addition of oxygen, which causes the partial oxidation, was to achieve thermal neutral for the energy saving purposes.     

Autothermal reforming of methane for producing high-purity hydrogen in a Pd/Ag membrane reactor

Autothermal reforming of methane includes steam reforming and partial oxidizing methane. Theoretically, the required endothermic heat of steam reforming of methane could be provided by adding oxygen to partially oxidize the methane. Therefore, combining the steam reforming of methane with partial oxidation may help in achieving a heat balance that can obtain better heat efficacy. Membrane reactors offer the possibility of overcoming the equilibrium conversion through selectively removing one of the products from the reaction zone. For instance, only can hydrogen products permeate through a palladium membrane, which shifts the equilibrium toward conversions that are higher than the thermodynamic equilibrium. In this study, autothermal reforming of methane was carried out in a traditional reactor and a Pd/Ag membrane reactor, which were packed with an appropriate amount of commercial Ni/MgO/Al₂O₃ catalyst. A power analyzer was employed to measure the power consumption and to check the autothermicity. The average dense Pd/Ag membrane thickness is 24.3 μm, which was coated on a porous stainless steel tube via the electroless palladium/silver plating procedure. The experimental operating conditions had temperatures that were between 350 °C and 470 °C, pressures that were between 3 atm and 7 atm, and O₂/CH₄ = 0–0.5. The effects of the operating conditions on methane conversion, permeance of hydrogen, H₂/CO, selectivities of CO_x, amount of power supply, and the carbon deposition of the catalyst after the reaction is thoroughly discussed in this paper. The experimental results indicate that an optimum methane conversion of 95%, with a hydrogen production rate of 0.093 mol/m². S, can be obtained from the autothermal reforming of methane at H₂O/CH₄ = 1.3 and O₂/CH₄ near 0.4, at which the reaction does not consume power, and the catalysts are not subject to any carbon deposition.     

Mathematical modeling of hydrogen production using methanol steam reforming in the coupled membrane reactor when the output materials of the reformer section is used as feed for the combustion section

Hydrogen is one of the most abundant elements on Earth's surface. It is not in nature in its pure form, but it can produce by various methods such as methanol steam reforming, partial oxidation, electrolysis, etc. In the present study, using the mass and energy conservation law, hydrogen production in coupled membrane reactors has been modeled using the methanol steam reforming process using two different methods in the coupled membrane reactor. A separate (fresh) methanol is used as feed for the combustion section in the first method. While in the second method, the reformer reactor's output material is used as feed for the combustion section. After simplifying using the required assumptions, the governing equations solved using the ode45 (shooting method) numerical method using MATLAB software. The results of this study show that the conversion of methanol in the coupled membrane reactor when separate methanol is used as feed in the combustion reactor, while in the same reactor, the output material of the reformer section used as feed in the combustion section, is 92% and 88.5% respectively. In this study, the effect of different parameters on the methanol conversion rate is investigated. Finally, it found that with increasing temperature and pressure and decreasing membrane thickness in coupled membrane reactors, methanol conversion rate increases. The percentage of hydrogen recovery in the two coupled membrane reactors is almost equal to 92%.     

H2 production via water gas shift in a composite Pd membrane reactor prepared by the pore-plating method

In this work, H₂ production via catalytic water gas shift reaction in a composite Pd membrane reactor prepared by the ELP “pore-plating” method has been carried out. A completely dense membrane with a Pd thickness of about 10.2 μm over oxidized porous stainless steel support has been prepared. Firstly, permeation measurements with pure gases (H₂ and N₂) and mixtures (H₂ with N_2, CO or CO₂) at four different temperatures (ranging from 350 to 450 °C) and trans-membrane pressure differences up to 2.5 bar have been carried out. The hydrogen permeance when feeding pure hydrogen is within the range 2.68–3.96·10⁻⁴ mol m⁻² s⁻¹ Pa^−0.5, while it decreases until 0.66–1.35·10⁻⁴ mol m⁻² s⁻¹ Pa^−0.5 for gas mixtures. Furthermore, the membrane has been also tested in a WGS membrane reactor packed with a commercial oxide Fe–Cr catalyst by using a typical methane reformer outlet (dry basis: 70%H₂–18%CO–12%CO₂) and a stoichiometric H₂O/CO ratio. The performance of the reactor was evaluated in terms of CO conversion at different temperatures (ranging from 350 °C to 400 °C) and trans-membrane pressures (from 2.0 to 3.0 bar), at fixed gas hourly space velocity (GHSV) of 5000 h⁻¹. At these conditions, the membrane maintained its integrity and the membrane reactor was able to achieve up to the 59% of CO conversion as compared with 32% of CO conversion reached with conventional packed-bed reactor at the same operating conditions.     

CFD simulation of methane steam reforming in a membrane reactor: Performance characteristics over range of operating window

Methane steam reforming is the most widely used pathway for hydrogen production. In this context, the use of a fixed bed catalytic reactor with a hydrogen-selective membrane is one of the most promising technologies to produce high purity hydrogen gas. In this work, the membrane reactor three-dimensional computational fluid dynamic (CFD) model was developed to investigate the performance. In this model, methane steam reforming global kinetic model has been coupled with the CFD model using User-Defined Function (UDF). Whereas, hydrogen permeation across the membrane is implemented by introducing source and sink formulation. The CFD simulation results were compared to the experimental data, where the developed model successfully captured the experimentally observed trends. We studied the influence of the various operating parameters, as temperature, steam to carbon ratio, sweep gas flow configuration and space velocity on the overall performance. The main observation and attained optimal operation windows from the study was discussed to provide insight into the factors affecting the overall performance.     

Modeling and simulation of methane steam reforming in a thermally coupled membrane reactor

A distributed mathematical model for thermally coupled membrane reactor that is composed of three channels is developed for methane steam reforming. Methane combustion takes place in the first channel on a Pt/δ–Al₂O₃$\text{Pt}/\delta \text{–}{\text{Al}}_2{\text{O}}_3$ catalyst layer that supplies the necessary heat for the endothermic steam reforming reaction. In the second channel, catalytic steam reforming reactions take place in the presence of Ni/MgO–Al₂O₃ catalyst. The combustion catalyst forms a thin layer next to the reactor wall to minimize the heat transfer resistance. Selective permeation of hydrogen through the palladium membrane is achieved either by co-current or counter-current flow of sweep gas through the third channel. The burner is modeled as a monolith reactor and the reformer is assumed to behave as a pseudo-homogenous reactor. The mass and energy balance equations for the thermally coupled membrane reactor form a set of 22 coupled ordinary differential equations. With the application of appropriate boundary conditions, the distributed reactor model for steady-state operation is solved as a boundary value problem. The model equations are discretized using spline collocation on finite elements. The discretized nonlinear modeling equations, along with the boundary conditions, form a system of algebraic equations that are solved using the trust region dogleg method. The performance of the reactor is numerically investigated for various key operating variables such as inlet fuel concentration, inlet steam/methane ratio, inlet reformer gas temperature and inlet reformer gas velocity. Simulations for both the co-current and the countercurrent flow modes are also performed using different sweep gas flow rates. For each case, the reactor performance is analyzed based on methane conversion and hydrogen recovery yield.     

Ethanol steam reforming reaction in a porous stainless steel supported palladium membrane reactor

In this experimental work, the ethanol steam reforming reaction is performed in a porous stainless steel supported palladium membrane reactor with the aim of investigating the influence of the membrane characteristics as well as of the reaction pressure. The membrane is prepared by electroless plating technique with the palladium layer around 25 μm deposited onto a stainless steel tubular macroporous support. The experimental campaign is directed both towards permeation and reaction tests. Firstly, pure He and H₂ are supplied separately between 350 and 400 °C in the MR in permeator modality for calculating the ideal selectivity αH₂/He. Thus, the MR is packed with 3 g of a commercial Co/Al₂O₃ catalyst and reaction tests are performed at 400 °C, by varying the reaction pressure from 3.0 to 8.0 bar. Experimental results in terms of ethanol conversions as well as recovery and purity of hydrogen are given and compared with some results in the same research field from the open literature.As best result of this work, 100% ethanol conversion is reached at 400 °C and 8 bar, recovering a hydrogen-rich stream consisting of more than 50% over the total hydrogen produced from reaction, having a purity around 65%.     

Theoretical evaluation of various configurations of silica membrane reactor in methanol steam reforming using CFD method

The main purposes of this work was to evaluate from a theoretical point of view the performance of silica membrane reactors (MRs) in various configurations for generating hydrogen via methanol steam reforming (MSR) reaction using a two dimensional computational fluid dynamic (CFD) method, presenting details about molar fractions of gas species, velocity and pressure distributions at the simulated conditions. The CFD model was firstly validated and, then, used for the simulations, achieving an acceptable agreement between numerical outcomes and experimental data. The simulations were realized for MSR reaction carried out in three types of silica MRs, namely: 1) silica MR with cocurrent flow pattern (MR1); 2) silica MR with countercurrent flow pattern (MR2); 3) silica MR with countercurrent flow pattern including a water gas shift (WGS) reaction stage in the permeate side (MR3), meanwhile comparing the results with a traditional reactor (TR). The influence of several operating parameters (reaction temperature and pressure, and feed flow rate) on the performance of the aforementioned silica MRs in terms of methanol conversion, hydrogen yield and CO-selectivity was evaluated and the results compared with an equivalent TR. The simulations via CFD method indicated the MR3 results to be the best solution over the other MR proposed configurations and the TR as well, presenting the best simulation results at 10 bar of transmembrane pressure, 513 K, SF = 6, GHSV = 6000 h⁻¹ and feed molar ratio = 3/1 with CO selectivity ≤0.04%, methanol conversion and hydrogen yield >90%.     

A transient study of double-jacketed membrane reactor via methanol steam reforming

A non-isothermal unsteady-state model was established to simulate methanol steam reforming using a double-jacketed Pd membrane reactor. At steady state, a self-sustained membrane reactor was achieved by the oxidation of residual methanol and hydrogen from reformer for endothermic steam reforming. The molar fractions of species and reformer temperature were analyzed under co-current operation between oxidation and reformer sides. The start-up of reformer was simulated under two conditions: (1) The catalyst temperature was lower than the influent temperature and (2) The catalyst temperature was higher than influent temperature. Condition 1 yielded higher methanol conversion and reformer temperature than condition 2 at steady state. Moreover, the instability of species can be minimized on condition 1 during start-up. The fluctuation of membrane reactor at steady state was also studied. Two strategies were compared to analyze the reformer response when temporary extra hydrogen was required. The results showed that increasing inlet methanol outperformed increasing reformer temperature.     

Techno-economic assessment of solar steam reforming of methane in a membrane reactor using molten salts as heat transfer fluid

This paper reports the results obtained in a techno-economic analysis of the Steam Methane Reforming (SMR) technology aided with solar heat, developed and demonstrated in the European FCH JU project CoMETHy: a compact membrane reformer heated with molten salt up to 550 °C allowed to simultaneously carry out methane steam reforming, water-gas-shift reaction and hydrogen separation. This reactor can be integrated with new generation Concentrating Solar Thermal (CST) systems to supply the process heat. Experimental validation of the technology has been successfully achieved in a pilot scale plant and the results recently published. In this paper, we introduce a fully-integrated scheme and operation strategies of a plant on the 1500 Nm³/h hydrogen production scale. Then, techno-economic analysis of this new solar-driven process is presented to evaluate its competitiveness. Considering a plant capacity of 1500 Nm³/h (pure hydrogen production) and today's costs for the methane feed and the CST technology, obtained Hydrogen Production Cost (HPC) are in the range of 2.8–3.3 €/kg for a “solar-hybrid” system with high capacity factor (8000 h/year operation) and 4.7 €/kg for a “solar-only” case, while HPC≅1.7 €/kg can be obtained with the conventional route under equivalent assumptions. However, a sensitivity analysis shows that the expected drop of the cost of the CST technology will bring the HPC around 2.4 €/kg for the “solar-hybrid” case and close to 3.4 €/kg for the “solar-only” case, thus making the cost of solar reforming closer to conventional SMR with CO₂ capture and with wind/solar electrolysis in the future. In the “solar-hybrid” case total CO₂ production can be reduced by 13–29% with 58–70% of produced CO₂ recovered as pure stream (at 1.3 bar); in the “solar-only” case total CO₂ production can be reduced by 52% and 100% of produced CO₂ recovered as pure stream (at 1.3 bar). However, compared to the conventional route, CO₂ avoidance costs are still relatively high (≥137 €/ton_CO2) and process optimization measures required. Therefore, optimization measures have been outlined to increase the overall process efficiency and further reduce the HPC.     

Steam reforming of heptane in a fluidized bed membrane reactor

n-Heptane served as a model compound to study steam reforming of naphtha as an alternative feedstock to natural gas for production of pure hydrogen in a fluidized bed membrane reactor. Selective removal of hydrogen using Pd₇₇Ag₂₃ membrane panels shifted the equilibrium-limited reactions to greater conversion of the hydrocarbons and lower yields of methane, an intermediate product. Experiments were conducted with no membranes, with one membrane panel, and with six panels along the height of the reactor to understand the performance improvement due to hydrogen removal in a reactor where catalyst particles were fluidized. Results indicate that a fluidized bed membrane reactor (FBMR) can provide a compact reformer for pure hydrogen production from a liquid hydrocarbon feedstock at moderate temperatures (475-550 °C). Under the experimental conditions investigated, the maximum achieved yield of pure hydrogen was 14.7 moles of pure hydrogen per mole of heptane fed.     

Study on a catalytic membrane reactor for hydrogen production from ethanol steam reforming

Ethanol steam reforming in a membrane reactor with catalytic membranes was investigated to achieve important aims in one process, such as improvement in ethanol conversion and hydrogen yield, high hydrogen recovery and CO reduction. In order to confirm the efficiency of reaction and CO reduction, an ethanol reforming-catalytic membrane reactor with water–gas shift reaction (ECRW) in the permeate side was compared with a conventional reactor (CR) and an ethanol reforming-catalytic membrane reactor (ECR). In comparison with the CR, ethanol conversion improvement of 11.9–19% and high hydrogen recovery of 78–87% were observed in the temperature range of 300–600 °C in the ECRW. Compared with CR and ECR, the hydrogen yield of ECRW increased up to 38% and 30%, respectively. Particularly, the ECRW showed higher hydrogen yield at high temperature, because Pt/Degussa P25 loaded in the permeate side showed catalytic activity for the methane steam reforming as well as WGS reaction. Moreover, CO concentration was reduced under 1% by the WGS reaction in the permeate side in the temperature range of 300–500 °C.     

Comparative study of propane steam reforming in vanadium based catalytic membrane reactor with nickel-based catalysts

The performance of catalytic membrane reactor with Pd-coated V membrane was examined for steam reforming of propane. The long term reforming experiment confirmed the stability of the V membrane with high hydrogen selectivity and permeability. The effect of types of hydrogen permeable membranes on the performance of the catalytic membrane reactor was studied by comparing Pd-coated V, Pd–23Ag, and Pd–10Ag membranes. The types of hydrogen separation membranes (i.e. hydrogen removal rates) did not have a marked effect on the propane conversion rates, while the product compositions were largely influenced by the hydrogen removal rate. Varying metal oxide supports of Ni-catalysts resulted in significant differences in the product compositions. Further, the evaluation of various catalyst-support systems (9wt%Ni–1wt%M/CeO₂, M = Co, Pt, Ag, Ru) revealed that hydrogen yield was the highest when 1wt%Ag was added to Ni/CeO₂. However, it was also found that excessive secondary metal additions can have negative impact on the catalytic behaviour of parent catalysts.