Clinical evaluation of the Alta hip bolt in peritrochanteric hip fractures

We reviewed the clinical and radiographic results of 58 patients with peritrochanteric fractures treated with the Alta hip bolt (a sliding compression device that inserts a dome plunger in the femoral head instead of a hip screw). This group was compared with a group of 53 patients treated with conventional hip screws. Three patients (5.2%) treated with the Alta hip bolt and three patients (5.7%) treated with conventional hip screw had failure of fixation. Failure of fixation consistently occurred in patients with unstable fracture patterns or significant osteopenia. There were no cases of bolt cut-out in stable intertrochanteric fractures. We conclude that the Alta hip bolt performs as well as sliding hip screws in peritrochanteric fractures, but the additional learning curve and increased cost do not justify its routine use at this point in time.     

Chemical immobilisation of giraffe to facilitate short procedures

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the effects of dynamization of a sliding hip screw plate on the fixation stability for several types of subtrochanteric fractures. Clinical results of treating reverse oblique fractures occasionally show medialization of the femoral shaft. DESIGN: Two types of plate dynamization were compared using the same test protocol in identically prepared groups of uniform, artificial femurs. METHODS: Sawbones composite femurs (Pacific Research Labs, Vashon, WA) having five orientations of simulated subtrochanteric fractures were used with the Medoff plate (Medpac, Inc., Valencia, CA) either fully dynamized or with the sliding lag screw locked. These specimens were physiologically loaded and cycled and displacements of the proximal femur determined. RESULTS: Significantly more shaft medialization occurred with reverse oblique fracture patterns when the Medoff plate was fully dynamized. CONCLUSION: Clinical treatment of reverse oblique fractures with the Medoff plate should be performed using the lag screw locked and only the plate dynamized.     

Operative treatment of hip fractures in patients with renal failure

The conditions of a hip fracture and renal failure cause particularly high mortality. Eight patients (average age, 63 years) who had operative treatment for nine hip fractures were studied retrospectively. Three had intertrochanteric fractures fixed with sliding compression screws, and five had femoral neck fractures (bilateral in one patient): two nondisplaced femoral neck fractures were fixed with percutaneous screws, and four displaced femoral neck fractures were treated with arthroplasties in three and percutaneous screws in one. Operative treatment was done when the patient was in medically stable condition (average, 8 days). Full weightbearing was allowed on the injured limb after surgery. Early morbidity analysis showed no wound infections, thromboembolic events, or hemorrhagic complications. The first year mortality was three (38%). Late morbidity included one nonunion and one sliding screw penetration. Total mortality at 6 years was seven (88%) patients, with an average postoperative survival time of 28 months. Preoperative ambulation was preserved in five of seven (71%) patients. One the basis of this study, it appears that a team approach to operative management including nephrologist and surgeon helps to reduce short term complications and mortality and allows such patients to be mobilized and regain ambulation.     

Modified medial displacement and valgus osteotomy for unstable intertrochanteric fractures

We have described previously a modification of the medial displacement and valgus osteotomy of Dimon and Hughston to manage non-unions of intertrochanteric fractures. In this study, we have used the same modification to manage fresh, unstable intertrochanteric fractures. Eighty-seven patients underwent this procedure. Four died within 4 months. The remaining 83 patients were evaluated over a period ranging from 4 to 49 months. There was a low complication rate with this method. They included one perforation of the femoral head, one post operative infection that recurred as a deep infection, one partial superior migration of the implant, one varus fixation with noticeable shortening and two cases where the trochanteric wire had snapped. In the others, the hip movement, abductor function, functional recovery and rate of union (8-12 weeks) were good. The method permits early weight-bearing and avoids some of the problems seen with anatomical fixation of unstable fractures using the sliding screw plate. We feel that medial displacement and valgus osteotomy with an angled blade plate has a definite role in the treatment of unstable intertrochanteric fractures in some situations.     

The dynamic hip screw with support plate--a reliable osteosynthesis for highly unstable "reverse" trochanteric fractures?

ORIF management of unstable trochanteric fractures of type A3 of the A0 classification is difficult because of lateral dislocation of the proximal fractured segments, particularly when only the sliding hip-screw is used for fixation. A connectable butt-press plate was recently developed in order to prevent this type of dislocation. We review the results with this fixation technique in 22 elderly patients with an average age of 76 years who presented with highly unstable trochanteric fracture of the A3 type. Three patients died of diseases unrelated to the trauma or operation before the fractures had healed. The other 19 were followed prospectively until fracture healing had occurred. Complaints, leg shortening and changes in the CCD angle were recorded. Furthermore, the mobility score was determined. Although the patients were able to bear full weight after the operation, no lateral dislocation of fragments was observed. Only 1 patient had a varus dislocation of 5 degrees until the fracture had consolidated. This was due to severe osteopenia and subsequent dislocation of the screw within the femoral head. No pseudarthrosis, osteitis or rotational malalignment was noted. Five of the surviving patients had a lower mobility score after fracture healing as compared to the status before the fracture was sustained. On the basis of this review, we recommend the use of this new connectable buttress plate with sliding hip screws because it provides sufficient fixation of highly unstable fractures of type A3.     

Use of an intramedullary hip-screw compared with a compression hip-screw with a plate for intertrochanteric femoral fractures. A prospective, randomized study of one hundred patients

One hundred elderly patients who had an intertrochanteric femoral fracture were randomized to treatment with a compression hip-screw with a plate (fifty patients) or a new intramedullary device, the intramedullary hip-screw (fifty patients). All patients were followed prospectively for one year or until death. A detailed assessment of the functional status and the plain radiographs of the hip was performed one, three, six, and twelve months postoperatively. The two treatment groups were strictly comparable. The operative time needed to insert the intramedullary hip-screw was significantly greater than that needed to insert the compression hip-screw with the plate (p = 0.02), but use of the intramedullary hip-screw was associated with less estimated intraoperative blood loss (p = 0.011). The prevalence of perioperative complications, such as bronchopneumonia, cardiac failure, and urinary tract infection, was comparable in the two treatment groups. There were one intraoperative fracture of the femoral shaft and two intraoperative fractures of the greater trochanter in the group managed with the intramedullary hip-screw. One patient had pulling-out of the compression hip-screw on the seventh postoperative day. Four patients had a trochanteric wound hematoma, without infection, after insertion of an intramedullary hip-screw. All but one of the fractures healed. The one non-union, which was in a patient who had a compression hip-screw, was treated with a hemiarthroplasty. The mortality rate was similar in the two treatment groups. The patients who had an intramedullary hip-screw had, on the average, significantly better mobility at one (p < 0.0001) and three months (p = 0.0013) postoperatively. This difference was no longer seen at six and twelve months, although the patients who had an intramedullary hip-screw still had significantly better walking ability outside the home at those time-periods (p = 0.05). The compression hip-screw was removed from two patients because of pain in the mid-portion of the thigh, which had begun after consolidation of the fracture. Fourteen patients who had an intramedullary hip-screw had cortical hypertrophy at the level of the tip of the nail at twelve months postoperatively. Cortical hypertrophy was significantly related to the use of two interlocking screws (p = 0.02). Six of these patients also had pain in the mid-portion of the thigh, and the nail had been locked with two screws in five of them. Three of the six patients had the hardware removed because of the pain, and the symptoms resolved. A seventh patient had pain without cortical hypertrophy. The intramedullary hip-screw device was associated with significantly less sliding of the lag-screw and subsequent shortening of the limb in the region of the thigh (p = 0.012 and 0.019, respectively); these differences were more pronounced when the unstable fractures in the two treatment groups were compared (p < 0.001).     

Caudascopic experiences and a new patho-anatomic concept for treatment of sciatica

Osteotomy has been used in treatment of unstable intertrochanteric hip fractures in an attempt to increase the stability of the fracture fragments. We have assessed this stability in a randomised prospective study on 138 patients, all having been fixed by dynamic hip screen, comparing anatomical reduction with medialisation osteotomy. The groups were similar in terms of age, gender and fracture configuration. There was no difference in final results in both groups except that operation time was longer in osteotomy group and the blood loss was more. We found no clear benefit from osteotomy and therefore recommend anatomical reduction and fixation by a sliding hip screw in most cases. Rarely, a fracture configuration which does not allow anatomical reduction may benefit from an osteotomy.     

Forces required to initiate sliding in second-generation intramedullary nails

Second-generation intramedullary nails, which allow the fixation screw that is placed in the femoral head to slide distally and thus allow compression of the fracture of the femoral neck, have become a popular option for the treatment of ipsilateral fractures of the femoral neck and shaft. However, the sliding characteristics of the screw within the barrel of the nail or the side-plate have not been assessed biomechanically, to our knowledge. The goal of the current study was to investigate the forces required to initiate sliding of the proximal screw in intramedullary devices and to compare these forces with those required to initiate sliding of hip screws. The loading configuration simulated the typical angle of 135 degrees between the intramedullary nail and the proximal screw. The forces required to initiate sliding of the proximal screw, with the screw extended fifty-one, seventy-six, eighty-six, and 102 millimeters beyond the proximal end of the barrel, were measured for three different types of second-generation intramedullary nails (Recon, ZMS, and Gamma), a sliding compression hip screw, and an intramedullary hip screw, and these forces were then compared. With each amount of extension of the screw, the hip screws required lower forces to initiate sliding than did the second-generation intramedullary devices. Of the second-generation devices, the Gamma nail required the highest forces to initiate sliding; the Recon and ZMS nails required 20 to 40 percent lower forces compared with the Gamma nail. None of the devices jammed in any of the loading configurations that were tested. When the extension of the screw was increased, higher forces were required to initiate sliding.     

Mechanical failure of the intramedullary hip screw in a subtrochanteric femoral fracture

The Gamma nail, an implant specifically designed for intertrochanteric and subtrochanteric femoral fractures, has been criticized for its high risk of secondary shaft fractures. A modified design, the intramedullary hip screw has recently been introduced to correct this complication. We present a case of mechanical failure of this new implant that occurred in a pathological subtrochanteric fracture. The centering sleeve of the implant became loose and migrated while the head screw penetrated the acetabulum. Refixation was successful.     

Interesting case no. 10. Cholesteatoma with destruction of the sigmoid sinus after thrombosis, with epidural abscess and Benzold abscesses

We employed hydroxyapatite (HA) granules to enhance screw fixation in revision surgery of failed osteosynthesis with a compression hip screw system in an 83-year-old woman. After reduction of the fracture, the fracture site with a large bone defect was filled with HA granules, and osteosynthesis was accomplished with a double cannulated lag screw and plate system. We feel that this HA granule augmentation method may also be suitable for osteosynthesis in other osteoporotic fractures.     

Circumstances of falls causing hip fractures in the elderly

A prospective analysis was performed on 832 patients to determine the circumstances surrounding falls leading to hip fracture within a homogeneous, elderly urban population. Special emphasis was placed on the season of year, time of day, location of fall, and other circumstances in which the fracture occurred. All patients were community dwelling, cognitively intact, previously ambulatory elderly who sustained a femoral neck or intertrochanteric fracture. Most fractures occurred at home, particularly in patients who were older, less healthy, and poorer ambulators. More than 75% of fractures resulted from a fall while the patient was standing or walking. Most falls occurred during daylight hours with a peak seen in the afternoon. No seasonal variation in the incidence of hip fractures was observed.     

The reconstruction locked nail for complex fractures of the proximal femur

Thirty-seven patients with 37 proximal femoral fractures were treated with a reconstruction locked femoral nail. There were four ipsilateral intracapsular femoral neck and shaft fractures, two intertrochanteric fractures, 18 intertrochanteric fractures with diaphyseal extension, eight subtrochanteric fractures with involvement of the lesser trochanter, and five subtrochanteric fractures without involvement of the lesser trochanter. The overall union rate was 92%. Twenty-one complications developed in 13 patients (35%) which included three of the four femoral neck and shaft fractures, and six of 18 intertrochanteric fractures with diaphyseal extension. Of the five intertrochanteric fractures with diaphyseal extension in which anatomic reduction was not achieved, four developed a complication. Of the nine proximal screws in nine fractures, which were placed short (below the subchondral bone of the femoral head), six fractures developed a complication. The complications included three nonunions, one delayed union, two leg-length discrepancies of > 2.5 cm, two cases of varus deformity of > 10 degrees, two varus deformities < 10 degrees, four instances of revision surgery including one broken 13-mm nail, four proximal screws that backed out and required removal, two cases of pudendal nerve palsy, and one case of heterotopic ossification. Seven patients developed more than one complication. Eleven of the 13 patients with complications required a second surgery to treat the complication. We conclude that the reconstruction locked femoral nail is not a good choice for ipsilateral intracapsular neck and shaft fractures. Our recommendation is that anatomic reduction should be achieved for all cases using the reconstruction femoral nail, but it is absolutely required when treating the intertrochanteric fracture with diaphyseal extension. Reconstruction femoral nails have a high rate of complication due to the complex nature of the fractures as well as the device.     

Changing methods of hip fracture osteosynthesis in Sweden. An epidemiological enquiry covering 46,900 cases

An enquiry covering all hospitals in Sweden operating on hip fractures was conducted in 1990. The results were compared with enquiries from 1982 and 1985. In cervical hip fractures the use of single nail has almost disappeared in favor of 2 LIH hook pins and, lately, the Uppsala subchondral screws. Primary hip prosthesis is the ultimate method of choice in Sweden. Among trochanteric hip fracture the Ender nail has almost totally been replaced by a sliding screw and plate device.     

Treatment of cutout of a lag screw of a dynamic hip screw in an intertrochanteric fracture

Sixteen consecutive patients with cutout of a lag screw of a dynamic hip screw fixation in an intertrochanteric fracture were treated with reinsertion of a lag screw, bone cement supplementation in the neck-trochanter, and subtrochanteric valgus osteotomy. Postoperatively, patients were permitted to ambulate with protected weight-bearing. Fourteen patients were followed-up for at least 1 year (median 2 years; range 1-3 years), and all had a solid union. The union period took a median of 5 months, with a range of 3-7 months. Usually, union of an intertrochanteric fracture was faster than that of subtrochanteric osteotomy (P < 0.01). There were no complications of wound infection, loss of reduction, cutout of a lag screw, or osteonecrosis of the femoral head. From clinical and theoretical considerations, we conclude that despite cutout of a lag screw of a dynamic hip screw fixation being difficult to treat, out technique still can provide an excellent outcome. Therefore, we strongly recommend its wide use.     

Intramedullary versus extramedullary fixation of subtrochanteric fractures. A biomechanical study

We compared two different subtrochanteric fracture fixation techniques, an intramedullary hip screw system (IMHS) and an extramedullary, dual sliding screw-plate system (MSP), to determine relative fixation stability. 6 matched pairs of osteosynthesized osteopenic cadaver femurs were axially loaded to 1000 N with concurrent, simulated abductor forces of 0%, 50%, or 86% of the applied head force. The initial loading sequence was made with uniaxial dynamization--the lag screw of the MSP locked and distal locking of the IMHS nail. Femoral head displacement and medial femoral strain were measured for intact femur controls, after fixation of a 2-part reverse oblique subtrochanteric fracture and finally a 3-part reverse oblique subtrochanteric fracture with a lateral wedge defect. The samples were then loaded at 750 N for 10(4) cycles with both devices uniaxially locked, followed by 10(4) cycles with both devices fully biaxially dynamized (unlocked). For the 2-part subtrochanteric fracture pattern, both devices exhibited similar inferior displacements of the femoral head (average 2.0 mm) and medial femoral strain (approximately 70% of intact). Increasing abductor forces decreased medial compressive strain but did not significantly affect head displacement. For the 3-part fracture model, the MSP demonstrated significantly less inferior displacement of the head (1.6 mm vs. 2.1 mm) and both devices demonstrated significantly decreased medial strain. After cycling, head displacement increased approximately 50% in both devices and medial strain increased slightly. After unlocking and cycling, the MSP group showed significant lateral displacement of the proximal fragment. The IMHS and MSP devices provide similar stability for fixation of 2-part and 3-part reverse oblique subtrochanteric fractures. In a biaxially dynamized, 3-part reverse oblique fracture, displacement of the proximal fragment can occur with the MSP.     

Interface pressure measurements of support surfaces with subjects in the supine and 45-degree Fowler positions

The results of treatment of 35 intraarticular distal fractures of the femur are presented. Treatment was performed in 8 cases with a condylar plate, in 8 cases with dynamic compression screw (DCS), in 2 cases with two plates, in 9 cases with screws only, and eight times the fracture was treated with a combination of lag screws and locking nail. Examination took place at an average of 45.5 months after the accident. 19 patients had an isolated fracture, 8 patients one accidental injury and 8 patients had more than one fracture or were polytraumatised. In 75% of the patients treatment lasted for between day 1 and 5. We found 17.1% open fractures and had to face infections in 5.7% (two cases). Bone healing occurred in all fractures, the reported infections could be overcome by early revision and the use of gentamycin-PMMA beds. It is remarkable that locking nails were successfully used in 8 cases of fractures with intraarticular component of the distal femur.     

Outcome of femoral shaft fractures in the elderly

Published literature on fractures of the femoral shaft has reported results of treatment stratified by fracture type or treatment type. The current study analyzes the outcome of fractures of the femoral shaft in elderly patients. One hundred thirty-eight patients older than the age of 65 years sustained femoral shaft fractures. Ten percent of the patients had associated injuries. The majority of the patients had significant prefracture medical problems. Nonsurgical treatment was used in 29 cases. Surgical treatment in 109 patients consisted of cerclage wires in 13 cases, plates and screws in 58 cases, intramedullary nails in 26 cases, and long stem prostheses in 12 cases. Complications of treatment occurred in 46% of patients. The type of treatment did not influence the frequency of complications. Twenty percent of patients died within 6 months of the fracture. There was a significant difference in the age of the patients who survived compared with those who did not survive. The mental status of the patient was also a major determinant of survival. Alert and oriented patients had a much better chance of survival. The outcome of fractures of the femoral shafts cited in the literature is different from the results seen in this population of elderly patients. The observed complication rate of 46% and mortality rate of 20% in this series is similar to those reported for intertrochanteric fractures and femoral neck fractures. Age and mental status are important determinants in the survival of the patient regardless of the treatment administered.     

Bone loss after hip fracture is correlated to the postoperative degree of mobilisation

This study quantifies changes in bone mineral density (BMD) in the opposite hip and in both proximal tibiae and the correlation with the use of walking aids for patients with two types of hip fracture during the 1st year after surgery. In all, 26 women and 15 men aged 42-88 years (median 71 years) were included. Twenty-one patients had an intracapsular hip fracture (ICF) and 20 had an intertrochanteric fracture (ITF). All patients were treated with a dynamic hip screw. BMD was measured by dual X-ray absorptiometry (DXA; LUNAR, Wisconsin) within the 1st week after surgery and after 3, 6 and 12 months. Initial BMD of the non-fractured hip was significantly lower for both fracture groups compared with reference material. For both fracture types there was a significant decrease in BMD of the non-fractured hip and proximal tibia of the fractured leg during the first 3 months, which still persisted a year after surgery. Improved mobilisation between two examinations was positively correlated with changes in BMD of the proximal tibia of the fractured leg and the non-fractured hip.     

Failure of femoral head fixation: a cadaveric analysis of lag screw cut-out with the gamma locking nail and AO dynamic hip screw

The most commonly reported failure mode of sliding hip screws in published literature is cut-out of the lag screw. This study investigates the resistance to failure of the femoral head, with lag screws used in two types of sliding hip screws, the gamma locking nail (Howmedica) and the dynamic hip screw (DHS) (Synthes). The investigation consisted of biomechanical tests under static loading conditions on 12 pairs of cadaveric femoral heads, to establish the failure loads due to screw cut-out for the two implant lag screws. The gamma nail appeared to reduce the tendency to cut-out in the osteoporotic bone (soft) associated with elderly patients in whom these devices are commonly used (p < 0.05). In high density bone (hard) the gamma lag screw also appeared to be stronger, because the DHS showed a tendency to bend. The larger diameter of the gamma nail lag screw resists bending and appears to reduce the risk of cut-out compared with the DHS.     

How many severely injured multiple-trauma patients can benefit from the biomechanical advantage of early mobilization following femoral intramedullary nailing?

The benefit of early operative stabilization of femoral fractures is established in patients with multiple injuries. In the last few years the unreamed femoral nail is favoured for internal fixation of femoral fractures despite pathophysiological concerns. The foremost advantage of femoral nails compared with plate fixation is the possibility of early full weight bearing. The aim of this retrospective study was to investigate, under consideration of the severity of injury, the extent of injury, and the clinical course, if multiple injured patients with concomitant femoral fractures benefit from the preferred intramedullary nailing with early weight bearing. Three hundred and two (23.8%) out of 1271 multiple injured patients (ISS > 17) had a concomitant femoral fracture. Fourty-seven out of 302 patients were children under 16 years of age, remaining 255 patients. Eighteen out of 255 patients died within the first 21 days after trauma and 66 patients required mechanical ventilation for more than three weeks (171/255). Thirty patients suffered from severe head injury (AIS-head > 3) and seven from severe pulmonary contusion with concomitant abdominal injury (134/255). Two patients had grade III open femoral fractures with vascular injury. Ipsilateral unstable pelvic fractures were seen in 11 patients, seven patients had ipsilateral intraarticular femoral fractures, and ipsilateral intraarticular fractures of the lower leg or foot were observed in 40 patients (74/255). The results demonstrate, that only 74 (29%) out of 255 multiple injured patients (> 16 years of age) had a theoretical benefit of early weight bearing. Seventy percent of the patients did not benefit from intramedullary nailing considering full weight bearing. With regard to pathophysiological concerns alternative methods of fracture fixation should be discussed for these patients. Primary fracture fixation with external fixators and secondary internal fixation proved to be a save alternative method. The complication rate of plating is comparable to intramedullary nailing but associated with less severe systemic risks. Primary plating of femoral fractures would not delay mobilization of most multiple injured patients.