Reducing tardy jobs by integrating process planning and scheduling functions

This paper presents a dynamic approach to reduce tardy jobs through the integration of process planning and scheduling in a batch-manufacturing environment. The developed method aims at re-generating a schedule with fewer tardy jobs, step by step, by exploring the process plan solution space of the tardy jobs. The integrated system comprises a process planning module, a scheduling module, and an integrator module. The process planning module employs an optimisation approach in which the entire plan solution space is first generated and a search algorithm is then used to find the optimal plan, while the scheduling module is based on commonly used heuristics. Based on the job tardiness information of the generated schedule, the integrator module automatically issues a modification order to the process plan solution space of the tardy jobs. The process planning and scheduling modules are then re-run to generate a new plan/schedule solution. Through this iterative process, a satisfactory schedule can be gradually achieved. The uniqueness of this approach is characterised by the flexibility of the process planning strategy, which makes full use of the plan solution space intuitively to achieve a satisfactory schedule. Several examples are presented to confirm the efficacy and the effectiveness of the developed integration system.     

GA-based adaptive setup planning toward process planning and scheduling integration

Setup planning of a part for more than one available machine is a typical combinatorial optimisation problem under certain constraints. It has significant impact not only on the whole process planning but also on scheduling, as well as on the integration of process planning and scheduling. Targeting the potential adaptability of process plans associated with setups, a cross-machine setup planning approach using genetic algorithms (GA) for machines with different configurations is presented in this paper. First, based on tool accessibility analysis of different machine configurations, partially sequenced machining features can be grouped into certain setups; then by responding to the requirements from a scheduling system, optimal or near-optimal setup plans are selected for certain criteria, such as cost, makespan and/or machine utilisation. GA is adopted for the combinatorial optimisation, which includes gene pool generation based on tool accessibility examination, setup plan encoding and fitness evaluation, and optimal setup plan selection through GA operations. The proposed approach is implemented in a GA toolbox, and tested using a sample part. The results demonstrate that the proposed approach is applicable to machines with varying configurations, and adaptive to different setup requirements from a scheduling system due to machine availability changes. It is expected that this approach can contribute to process planning and scheduling integration when a process plan is combined with setups for alternative machines during adaptive setup planning.     

Integrated process planning and scheduling using an imperialist competitive algorithm

Effective performance of modern manufacturing systems requires integrating process planning and scheduling more tightly, which is consistently challenged by the intrinsic interrelation and intractability of these two problems. Traditionally, these two problems are treated sequentially or separately. Integration of process planning and scheduling (IPPS) provides a valuable approach to improve system performance. However, IPPS is more complex than job shop scheduling or process planning. IPPS is strongly NP-hard in that, compared to an NP-hard job shop scheduling problem with a determined process plan, the process plan for each job in IPPS is also to be optimised. So, an imperialist competitive algorithm (ICA) is proposed to address the IPPS problem with an objective of makespan minimisation. An extended operation-based representation scheme is presented to include information on various flexibilities of process planning with respect to determined job shop scheduling. The main steps of the proposed ICA, including empires construction, assimilation, imperialistic competition, revolution and elimination, are elaborated using an illustrative example. Performance of the proposed ICA was evaluated on four sets of experiments taken from the literature. Computational results of the ICA were compared with that of some existing algorithms developed for IPPS, which validates the efficiency and effectiveness of the ICA in solving the IPPS problem.     

Optimisation of integrated process planning and scheduling using a particle swarm optimisation approach

Traditionally, process planning and scheduling are two independent essential functions in a job shop manufacturing environment. In this paper, a unified representation model for integrated process planning and scheduling (IPPS) has been developed. Based on this model, a modern evolutionary algorithm, i.e. the particle swarm optimisation (PSO) algorithm has been employed to optimise the IPPS problem. To explore the search space comprehensively, and to avoid being trapped into local optima, the PSO algorithm has been enhanced with new operators to improve its performance and different criteria, such as makespan, total job tardiness and balanced level of machine utilisation, have been used to evaluate the job performance. To improve the flexibility and agility, a re-planning method has been developed to address the conditions of machine breakdown and new order arrival. Case studies have been used to a verify the performance and efficiency of the modified PSO algorithm under different criteria. A comparison has been made between the result of the modified PSO algorithm and those of the genetic algorithm (GA) and the simulated annealing (SA) algorithm respectively, and different characteristics of the three algorithms are indicated. Case studies show that the developed PSO can generate satisfactory results in optimising the IPPS problem.     

More MILP models for integrated process planning and scheduling

The integration of process planning and scheduling is important for an efficient utilisation of manufacturing resources. In general, there are two types of models for this problem. Although some MILP models have been reported, most existing models belong to the first type and they cannot realise a true integration of process planning and scheduling. Especially, they are completely powerless to deal with the cases where jobs are expressed by network graphs because generating all the process plans from a network graph is difficult and inefficient. The network graph-specific models belong to the other type, and they have seldom been deliberated on. In this research, some novel MILP models for integrated process planning and scheduling in a job shop flexible manufacturing system are developed. By introducing some network graph-oriented constraints to accommodate different operation permutations, the proposed models are able to express and utilise flexibilities contained in network graphs, and hence have the power to solve network graph-based instances. The established models have been tested on typical test bed instances to verify their correctness. Computational results show that this research achieves the anticipant purpose: the proposed models are capable of solving network graph-based instances.     

An approach to integrate production-transportation planning and scheduling in an aluminium supply chain network

This article is based on a real-life problem of a global aluminium supply chain network driven by an aluminium smelter. At each echelon of the aluminium supply chain network, several members are involved which are scattered around the world. Producing aluminium begins with bauxite mining. Next, aluminium oxide is made from bauxite and finally aluminium is produced from aluminium oxide. A novel type of mixed-integer decision-making model, including a time-continuous representation of the planning period, is presented. The model enables coordination of production quantities and times of all supply chain members in order to minimise production and transportation costs of the whole supply chain minus bonus payments for early deliveries which are stipulated between the supply chain network and its customers. Material flows can take place with or without temporary storage of intermediate products at supplying and/or receiving sites. Furthermore, relax-and-fix heuristics are presented. A number of randomly generated scenarios are presented to demonstrate that the heuristics can find nearly optimal solutions along with drastically reduced computation times. The relax-and-fix heuristic enables iterative planning between centralised and decentralised decision makers.     

Multi-objective process planning and scheduling using controlled elitist non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm

The integration of process planning and scheduling is considered as a critical component in manufacturing systems. In this paper, a multi-objective approach is used to solve the planning and scheduling problem. Three different objectives considered in this work are minimisation of makespan, machining cost and idle time of machines. To solve this integration problem, we propose an improved controlled elitist non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm (NSGA) to take into account the computational intractability of the problem. An illustrative example and five test cases have been taken to demonstrate the capability of the proposed model. The results confirm that the proposed multi-objective optimisation model gives optimal and robust solutions. A comparative study between proposed algorithm, controlled elitist NSGA and NSGA-II show that proposed algorithm significantly reduces scheduling objectives like makespan, cost and idle time, and is computationally more efficient.     

A multi-objective optimisation model to integrating flexible process planning and scheduling based on hybrid multi-objective simulated annealing

Process planning and production scheduling play important roles in manufacturing systems. In this paper we present a mixed integer linear programming (MILP) scheduling model, that is to say a slot-based multi-objective multi-product, that readily accounts for sequence-dependent preparation times (transition and set up times or machine changeover time). The proposed scheduling model becomes computationally expensive to solve for long time horizons. The aim is to find a set of high-quality trade-off solutions. This is a combinatorial optimisation problem with substantially large solution space, suggesting that it is highly difficult to find the best solutions with the exact search method. To account for this, the hybrid multi-objective simulated annealing algorithm (MOHSA) is proposed by fully utilising the capability of the exploration search and fast convergence. Two numerical experiments have been performed to demonstrate the effectiveness and robustness of the proposed algorithm.     

Studying the impact of sequence-dependent set-up times in integrated process planning and scheduling with E-ACO heuristic

In job-shop scheduling, the importance of set-up issues is well known and has been considered in many solution approaches. However, in integrated process planning and scheduling (IPPS) involving flexible process plans, the set-up times are often ignored, or absorbed into processing times in IPPS domain, with the purpose to reduce the complexity. This is based on the assumption that set-up times are sequence-independent, or short enough to be ignored compared to processing times. However, it is not uncommon to encounter sequence-dependent set-up times (SDSTs) in practical production. This paper conducts a detailed investigation on the impact of SDSTs on the practical performance of the schedule: a comparative study is made for different cases where set-up times are (1) separately considered, (2) absorbed into processing times, or (3) totally ignored. An enhanced version of ant colony optimisation (E-ACO) algorithm is used to solve the IPPS problem, with the objective to minimise the total makespan. The following four types of set-up issues are considered: part loading/unloading, fixture preparation, tool switching and material transportation. Situations with various set-up time lengths have been studied and compared. A special case of IPPS problem involving a large number of identical jobs has been specifically studied and discussed. The results have shown that, set-up times should be carefully dealt with under different circumstances.     

A new heuristic for integrated process planning and scheduling in reconfigurable manufacturing systems

Integrated process planning and scheduling (IPPS) is a manufacturing strategy that considers process planning and scheduling as an integrated function rather than two separated functions performed sequentially. In this paper, we propose a new heuristic to IPPS problem for reconfigurable manufacturing systems (RMS). An RMS consists mainly of reconfigurable machine tools (RMTs), each with multiple configurations, and can perform different operations with different capacities. The proposed heuristic takes into account the multi-configuration nature of machines to integrate both process planning and scheduling. To illustrate the applicability and the efficiency of the proposed heuristic, a numerical example is presented where the heuristic is compared to a classical sequential process planning and scheduling strategy using a discrete-event simulation framework. The results show an advantage of the proposed heuristic over the sequential process planning and scheduling strategy.     

Remanufacturing-oriented process planning and scheduling: mathematical modelling and evolutionary optimisation

Remanufacturing has been widely studied for its potential to achieve sustainable production in recent years. In the literature of remanufacturing research, process planning and scheduling are typically treated as two independent parts. However, these two parts are in fact interrelated and often interact with each other. Doing process planning without considering scheduling related factors can easily introduce contradictions or even infeasible solutions. In this work, we propose a mathematical model of integrated process planning and scheduling for remanufacturing (IPPSR), which simultaneously considers the process planning and scheduling problems. An effective hybrid multi-objective evolutionary algorithm (HMEA) is presented to solve the proposed IPPSR. For the HMEA, a multidimensional encoding operator is designed to get a high-quality initial population. A multidimensional crossover operator and a multidimensional mutation operator are also proposed to improve the convergence speed of the algorithm and fully exploit the solution space. Finally, a specific legalising method is used to ‘legalise’ possible infeasible solutions generated by the initialisation method and mutation operator. Extensive computational experiments carried out to compare the HMEA with some well-known algorithms confirm that the proposed HMEA is able to obtain more and better Pareto solutions for IPPSR.     

Integrated process planning and scheduling for large-scale flexible job shops using metaheuristics

In this paper, we discuss an integrated process planning and scheduling problem in large-scale flexible job shops (FJSs). We assume that products can be manufactured in different ways, i.e. using different bills of materials (BOM) and routes for the same product. The total weighted tardiness is the performance measure of interest. A Mixed Integer Programming formulation is provided for the researched problem. Because of the NP-hardness of the investigated problem, an iterative scheme is designed that is based on variable neighbourhood search (VNS) on the process planning level. Appropriate neighbourhood structures for VNS are proposed. Because the evaluation of each move within VNS requires the solution of a large-scale FJS scheduling problem instance, efficient heuristics based on local search from previous research are considered on the scheduling level. Extensive computational experiments based on new randomly generated problem instances are conducted. In addition, a parallel version of the VNS is investigated within the computational experiments. The proposed iterative scheme is benchmarked against a genetic algorithm (GA) from the literature that simultaneously considers process planning and scheduling for the special case where a single BOM is available for each product. It turns out that the new iterative scheme outperforms the GA and a memetic algorithm based on the GA. It is able to solve even large-size problem instances in reasonable amount of time.     

Lagrangean relaxation approach to joint optimization for production planning and scheduling of synchronous assembly lines

This paper focuses on simultaneous optimisation of production planning and scheduling problem over a time period for synchronous assembly lines. Differing from traditional top-down approaches, a mixed integer programming model which jointly considers production planning and detailed scheduling constraints is formulated, and a Lagrangian relaxation method is developed for the proposed model, whereby the integrated problem is decomposed into planning, batch sequencing, tardiness and earliness sub-problems. The scheduling sub-problem is modelled as a time-dependent travelling salesman problem, which is solved using a dynasearch algorithm. A proposition of Lagrangian multipliers is established to accelerate the convergence speed of the proposed algorithm. The average direction strategy is employed to solve the Lagrangian dual problem. Test results demonstrate that the proposed model and algorithm are effective and efficient.     

Development and challenges of planning and scheduling for petroleum and petrochemical production

Production planning and scheduling are becoming the core of production management, which support the decision of a petrochemical company. The optimization of production planning and scheduling is attempted by every refinery because it gains additional profit and stabilizes the daily production. The optimization problem considered in industry and academic research is of different levels of realism and complexity, thus increasing the gap. Operation research with mathematical programming is a conventional approach used to address the planning and scheduling problem. Additionally, modeling the processes, objectives, and constraints and developing the optimization algorithms are significant for industry and research. This paper introduces the perspective of production planning and scheduling from the development viewpoint.     

Integration of process planning and scheduling by exploring the flexibility of process planning

A unique method for the integration of process planning and scheduling in a batch-manufacturing environment is reported. This integration is essential for the optimum use of production resources and for the generation of realistic process plans that can be readily executed with little modification. The integration problem is modelled at two levels: process planning and scheduling, which are linked by an intelligent facilitator. The process-planning module employs an optimization approach in which the whole plan solution space in terms of available machines, tools, tool accessibility and precedence constraints is first generated and a search algorithm is then used to find the optimal plan. For a given set of jobs, the scheduling module takes the optimal plans for each job and generates a schedule based on a given criterion, as well as the performance parameters (machine utilization and number of tardy jobs). An unsatisfied performance parameter is fed back to the facilitator, which then identifies a particular job and issues a change to its process plan solution space. The iteration of process Planning -scheduling-solution space modification continues until a schedule is satisfactory or until no further improvement can be made. The uniqueness of this approach is characterized by the flexibility of the process-planning strategy and the intelligent facilitator, which makes full use of the plan solution space intuitively to reach a satisfactory schedule. (It may not be the optimal, though.) The integrated system was implemented in the manufacturing of prismatic parts. The testing results show that the developed integration method can achieve satisfactory process plans and a schedule in an effective and efficient manner.     

An assessment of the integration of nurse timetable changes with operating room planning and scheduling

The objective of this paper is to understand the links between the management of operating rooms and nurses, and to investigate the trade-offs between the number of operating rooms used, nurses used and overtime work. To do so, we proposed a model that plans and schedules surgical interventions in the operating rooms while considering the availabilities of surgeons and anesthesiologists; the model also includes or discards nurse scheduling. The flexible modeling approach allows us to compare different alternatives, each one representing a different scenario of managing the operating rooms at an operational level. The scenarios were applied to two data-sets and compared on the basis of performance indicators, which include operating costs, utilisation rates of nurses and number of overtime hours done. The important findings were that there is no relationship between the number of nurses required and the number of operating rooms used; the simultaneous scheduling of nurses and surgical interventions provided a better resource usage, a higher occupation rate of nurses, less overtime and furthermore, operating costs were lowered by at least 10% on average.     

An integrated approach for production and distribution planning in supply chain management

Many firms have been trying to optimize their production and distribution systems separately, but using this approach limits any possible increase in profit. Thus, it is becoming more important to analyse these two systems simultaneously. This paper presents the solutions for integrated production and distribution planning and investigates the effectiveness of their integration through a computational study, in a multi-plant, multi-retailer, multi-item, and multi-period logistic environment where the objective is to maximize the total net profit. Computational results on test problems using the proposed heuristic confirm the substantial advantage of the integrated planning approach over the decoupled one. Sensitivity analysis on the input parameters indicates that, under the right conditions, the effectiveness of integrating production and distribution functions can be extremely high.     

Integrated maintenance planning and production scheduling with Markovian deteriorating machine conditions

In many industries, production capacity diminishes as machine conditions deteriorate. Maintenance operations improve machine conditions, but also occupy potential production time, possibly delaying the customer orders. Therefore, one challenge is to determine the joint maintenance and production schedule to minimize the combined costs of maintenance and lost production over the long term. In this paper, we address the problem of integrated maintenance and production scheduling in a deteriorating multi-machine production system over multiple periods. Assuming that at the beginning of each period the demand becomes known and machine conditions are observable, we formulate a Markov decision process model to determine the maintenance plan and develop sufficient conditions guaranteeing its monotonicity in both machine condition and demand. We then formulate an integer programming model to find the maintenance and the production schedule in each period. Our computational results show that exploiting online condition monitoring information in maintenance and production decisions leads to 21% cost savings on average compared to a greedy heuristic and that the benefit of incorporating long-term information in making short-term decisions is highest in industries with medium failure rates.     

Joint cell loading and scheduling approach to cellular manufacturing systems

A hierarchical multi-objective heuristic algorithm and pricing mechanism are developed to first determine the cell loading decisions, and then lot sizes for each item and to obtain a sequence of items comprising the group technology families to be processed at each manufacturing cell that minimise the setup, inventory holding, overtime and tardiness costs simultaneously. The linkage between the different levels is achieved using the proposed pricing mechanism through a set of dual variables associated with the resource and inventory balance constraints, and the feasibility status feedback information is passed between the levels to ensure internally consistent decisions. The computational results indicate that the proposed algorithm is very efficient in finding a compromise solution for a set of randomly generated problems compared with a set of competing algorithms.     

Auction-based approach for a flexible job-shop scheduling problem with multiple process plans

This study addresses the flexible job-shop scheduling problem with multiple process plans with the objective of minimizing the overall makespan. A nonlinear programming model is formulated to allocate machines and schedule jobs. An auction-based approach is proposed to address the integrated production route selection and resource allocation problem and focus on improving resource utilization and productive efficiency to reduce the makespan. The approach consists of an auction for process plans and an auction for machines. The auctions are evaluated to select a more suitable route for production and allocate resources to a more desirable job. Numerical experiments are conducted by testing new large benchmark instances. A comparison of Lingo and other existing algorithms demonstrates the effectiveness and stability of the proposed auction-based approach. Furthermore, SPSS is used to prove that the proposed method exhibits an absolute advantage, particularly for medium-scale or large-scale instances.