基于损失函数的随机设施布局优化分析

现有的随机设施布局问题的优化方法或是优化总物料处理成本的均值以获得最鲁棒的布局,或是优化其方差以获得最稳定的布局,但两者均只优化了总物料处理成本随机特征中的一个方面.通过引入田口损失函数的概念,建立了新的随机设施布局优化模型,对总物料处理成本的均值和方差同时进行优化求解,相比于现有的优化方法,新方法得到的布局形式能够使系统同时获得较好的鲁棒性和稳定性.     

Simulated annealing based parallel genetic algorithm for facility layout problem

The facility layout problem (FLP), a typical combinational optimisation problem, is addressed in this paper by implementing parallel simulated annealing (SA) and genetic algorithms (GAs) based on a coarse-grained model to derive solutions for solving the static FLP with rectangle shape areas. Based on the consideration of minimising the material flow factor cost (MFFC), shape ratio factor (SRF) and area utilisation factor (AUF), a total layout cost (TLC) function is derived by conducting a weighted summation of MFFC, SRF and AUF. The evolution operations (including crossover, mutation, and selection) of GA provide a population-based global search in the space of possible solutions, and the SA algorithm can lead to an efficient local search near the optimal solution. By combing the characteristics of GA and SA, better solutions will be obtained. Moreover, the parallel implementation of simulated annealing based genetic algorithm (SAGA) enables a quick search for the optimal solution. The proposed method is tested by performing a case study simulation and the results confirm its feasibility and superiority to other approaches for solving FLP.     

An improved heuristic approach for multi-objective facility layout problem

Multi-objective facility layout problem (mFLP) generates a different layout by varying objectives weights. Since the selection of objective weights in mFLP is critical, stages of designing layout having multiple objectives, the objective weights therefore play an important role in the layout design of mFLP. In practice, it is selected randomly by the layout designer based on his/her past experience that restricts the layout designing process completely designer dependent and thus the layout varies from designer to designer. This paper aims to resolve the issues of selecting the objective weight for each objective. We propose four methods to determine objective weight which makes the design process of mFLP completely designer independent.     

Using queuing theory and simulated annealing to design the facility layout in an AGV-based modular manufacturing system

An automated guided vehicle-based flow production system is used for manufacturing prefabricated bathroom units. One unit can occupy a space of more than 10?m². Due to large time deviations in sequential processes, queues are formed and greater plant space is needed. Reducing work-in-progress helps to save plant space but renders manufacture less efficient. The research explores better workstation arrangements. An open queuing network (OQN) model was used to approximate the flow production system. Since the problem of workstation arrangement is a combinatorial optimisation problem, simulated annealing (SA) was applied to search for a good solution. The combination of an OQN model and SA provides a powerful tool to solve the facility layout problem for a stochastic flow production system. The experimental results show that the proposed approach has the potential to guide industrial layout design and practice.     

A large-scale hybrid simulated annealing algorithm for cyclic facility layout problems

The cyclic facility layout problem (CFLP) is a special case of the dynamic facility layout problem (DFLP) in which there are several production periods and the production cycle repeats itself by going to the first period after the last one because of the seasonal nature of products. In this article, a mixed integer programming formulation is developed for the CFLP. In the DFLP literature, department shapes are assumed to be given or fixed. However, this assumption does not hold in the case of the CFLP because the facility size is limited and the area requirements of the departments change significantly throughout the planning horizon. Therefore, department dimensions and sizes are considered as decision variables in the CFLP. A large-scale hybrid simulated annealing algorithm (LS-HSA) is proposed to solve the formulated problem and shown to be effective and versatile as it can be applied to various facility layout problems.     

Two-level modified simulated annealing based approach for solving facility layout problem

In this paper, we are considering the quadratic assignment model (QAP) of the facility layout problem (FLP) which is known to be NP-hard. We relax the integer constraints of the QAP and solve it on a commercially available package called LINGO 8. In the optimal solution so obtained, X_ij s take real values between zero and one. We identify promising X_ij s having a value strictly greater than 0.5 in the optimal solution and set them to one. We add the constraints (X_ij ?=?1) associated with promising X_ij s into the QAP (with integer restrictions) and resolve using LINGO 8. In all the cases attempted we obtained a superior feasible solution to the QAP which was further improved by the proposed modified simulated annealing (MSA) procedure. An encouraging comparative performance of this procedure is thus reported.     

A cross-entropy approach to the single row facility layout problem

The single row facility layout problem is to arrange a given number of facilities along a straight line so as to minimise the total cost associated with the interactions between the facilities. In this paper, a metaheuristic algorithm based on the cross-entropy method, incorporating a local search procedure and symmetry-breaking techniques, is developed to solve this problem. The proposed algorithm has been tested on some widely used benchmark instances. The computational results show that the proposed algorithm has found the optimal or the best solutions known so far for the instances of size with up to 100 facilities and is competitive with some existing algorithms.     

A similarity score-based two-phase heuristic approach to solve the dynamic cellular facility layout for manufacturing systems

The dynamic cellular facility layout problem (DCFLP) is a well-known NP-hard problem. It has been estimated that the efficient design of DCFLP reduces the manufacturing cost of products by maintaining the minimum material flow among all machines in all cells, as the material flow contributes around 10–30% of the total product cost. However, being NP hard, solving the DCFLP optimally is very difficult in reasonable time. Therefore, this article proposes a novel similarity score-based two-phase heuristic approach to solve the DCFLP optimally considering multiple products in multiple times to be manufactured in the manufacturing layout. In the first phase of the proposed heuristic, a machine–cell cluster is created based on similarity scores between machines. This is provided as an input to the second phase to minimize inter/intracell material handling costs and rearrangement costs over the entire planning period. The solution methodology of the proposed approach is demonstrated. To show the efficiency of the two-phase heuristic approach, 21 instances are generated and solved using the optimization software package LINGO. The results show that the proposed approach can optimally solve the DCFLP in reasonable time.     

Heuristic approach for solving the multi-objective facility layout problem

A new heuristic approach for the generation of preferred objective weights to solve the multi-objective facility layout problem is presented. By applying a multi-pass halving and doubling procedure, a paired comparison method based on the strength of preference among objectives given by the decision-maker is developed. Furthermore, a ‘prior test’ is proposed to examine the consistency of the paired comparison matrix. An efficient method to transform the inconsistent matrix into a consistent one so the result can closely approximate the decision-maker's original assessments is also offered. The geometric mean method is then employed to obtain the objective weights and the final solution. There are five phases in the proposed heuristic approach. The first generates a basic solution; the second involves constructing a paired comparison matrix by using the multi-pass halving and doubling procedure; the third identifies the consistency of the paired comparison matrix; the fourth transforms the inconsistent matrix into a consistent one; and the fifth generates the preferred weights and obtains the facility layout solution. An illustrative example is given to demonstrate an application of the proposed approach for solving the multi-objective facility layout problem.     

A two-step heuristic algorithm for layout design of unequal-sized facilities with input/output points

The facility layout problem (FLP) is to arrange facilities within a given area so as to minimise the total material-handling cost. An efficient arrangement of facilities plays an important part in the achievement of high productivity in a manufacturing system. This paper focuses on the layout design of unequal-sized facilities with fixed shapes and input/output (I/O) points. A mixed-integer programming (MIP) model is developed to obtain optimal solutions. Since the MIP model is not applicable to large-sized problems, a two-step heuristic algorithm is developed to solve the FLPs. In the first step, a layout solution with moderate quality is generated by using an interconnected zone algorithm and a simulated annealing (SA) algorithm. The zone algorithm is a newly developed layout construction technique which places facilities successively within designated zones according to a placing sequence. The zone concept is introduced to reduce the solution space such that the computational effort is decreased, while SA is used to search for the placing sequences. The second step improves that solution further using the reduced MIP by employing the relative position information obtained from the first step. Computational experiments indicate that the algorithm in the first step can yield on average a 1.048% improvement on the best solutions obtained by the existing algorithms. The second step can further improve the solutions obtained in the first step by 0.484% on average. Compared to the commercial software VIP-PLANOPT 2006 (Engineering Optimization Software 2005 Engineering Optimization Software. 2005. PLANOPT User’s Manual, Florida: Deltona.  [Google Scholar]), the proposed two-step algorithm improves the solutions by 9.113% on average.     

A simulated annealing algorithm based on a closed loop layout for facility layout design in flexible manufacturing systems

Facility layout design problems in flexible manufacturing systems (FMS) differ from traditional facility design problems and are more difficult to solve because there are more constraints that must be considered (i.e., cell shape, cell orientation, pick-up and drop-off point positions). The focus of this paper is on the closed loop type layout, which is based on a predetermined layout pattern. This layout pattern is commonly found in manufacturing settings since it requires a simplified material handling system configuration and since it facilitates a modular and expandable layout structure. The open-field type layout problem, where there is no predetermined layout pattern, may potentially have a more efficient configuration, since there are fewer restrictions. However, this problem is more difficult to solve and may result in configurations that are not desirable due to the lack of structure or modularity. The procedure developed in this paper improves the efficiency of the closed loop configuration by changing the rectangular shape of the loop to different sizes. In many cases, the resulting closed loop layout proves to be as efficient as the open field layout. A simulated annealing procedure (SA-CL) is used to search for the configuration that minimizes the total material handling costs. A comparison of the results with existing methods indicates that, based on solution quality and computational time, the SA-CL offers a favourable alternative for efficient layout design.     

On the effectiveness of Monte Carlo simulation and heuristic search for solving large-scale block layout problems

The effectiveness of Monte Carlo simulation relative to intelligent search strategies for solving block layout problems is investigated. For testing purposes, 810 block layout problems are constructed to span a wide range of problem sizes, material flow variation levels, work centre space requirements distributions, and work centre shape distributions. Contrary to preliminary results reported in earlier studies, greedy search and simulated annealing consistently outperform Monte Carlo Simulation across the full range of test problems and sample sizes. This divergence is explained through a comparison based on probabilistic derivations between the proportion of good solutions sampled by the Monte Carlo method and those found by the heuristic search methods. Conditions for the superiority of either method are identified. Therefore, the current study complements earlier studies by providing analytical arguments and additional experimental evidence for the effectiveness of simple Monte Carlo method and intelligent search heuristics on solving layout problems.     

A sequence-pair representation and MIP-model-based heuristic for the facility layout problem with rectangular departments

In Facility Layout Problem (FLP) research, the continuous-representation-based FLP can consider all feasible all-rectangular-department solutions. Given this flexibility, this representation has become the representation of choice in FLP research. Much of this research is based on a methodology of Mixed-Integer Programming (MIP) models. However, these MIP-FLP models can only solve problems with a limited number of departments to optimality due to the large number of combinations of the binary variables used in the models to maintain feasibility with respect to departments overlapping. Our research centers around the sequence-pair representation, a concept that originated in the Very Large Scale Integration (VLSI) design literature. We show that an exhaustive search of the sequence-pair solution space will result in finding the optimal layout of the MIP-FLP and that every sequence-pair solution is position consistent (although possibly not layout feasible) in the MIP-FLP. We propose a genetic-algorithm-based heuristic that combines the sequence-pair representation with the MIP-FLP model. Numerical experiments based on different sized test problems from both the literature and industrial applications are provided and the solutions are compared with both the optimal solutions and the solutions from other heuristics to show the effectiveness and efficiency of our heuristic. For 11 data sets from the literature we provide solutions better than those previously found. For two large industrial application data sets we perform a sensitivity analysis with respect to the department aspect ratio constraint.     

A multi-improved genetic algorithm for facility layout optimisation based on slicing tree

For the facility layout optimisation problem, we use the slicing tree structure based on the order of traversal to form a new chromosome encoding system demonstrating facilities’ order, the relationship and the location. We generate the initial solution based on two principles namely the facilities’ adjacency and random generation. The structure of chromosome is made up with three sections in the research so that we can do the genetic operations to these three sections respectively, and we use dynamic and feedback mechanisms to improve the penalty function. As a result, the analysis of typical cases shows that there are certain improvements to this algorithm both in effectiveness and efficiency.     

A genetic algorithm and queuing theory based methodology for facilities layout problem

Facilities layout, being a significant contributor to manufacturing performance, has been studied many times over the past few decades. Existing studies are mainly based on material handling cost and have neglected several critical variations inherent in a manufacturing system. The static nature of available models has reduced the quality of the estimates of performance and led to not achieving an optimal layout. Using a queuing network model, an established tool to quantify the variations of a system and operational performance factors including work-in-process (WIP) and utilisation, can significantly help decision makers in solving a facilities layout problem. The queuing model utilised in this paper is our extension to the existing models through incorporating concurrently several operational features: availability of raw material, alternate routing of parts, effectiveness of a maintenance facility, quality of products, availability of processing tools and material handling equipment. On the other hand, a queuing model is not an optimisation tool in itself. A genetic algorithm, an effective search process for exploring a large search space, has been selected and implemented to solve the layout problem modelled with queuing theory. This combination provides a unique opportunity to consider the stochastic variations while achieving a good layout. A layout problem with unequal area facilities is considered in this paper. A good layout solution is the one which minimises the following four parameters: WIP cost, material handling cost, deviation cost, and relocation cost. Observations from experimental analysis are also reported in this paper. Our proposed methodology demonstrates that it has a potential to integrate several related decision-making problems in a unified framework.     

Solving the facility and layout and location problem by ant-colony optimization-meta heuristic

This paper describes a heuristic algorithm for solving the plant/facility location problem by applying ant-colony optimization meta-heuristic. The facility location problem is discussed, and a mathematical formulation is presented. The problem is then modelled as a quadratic assignment problem. An ant algorithm is developed to solve the problem. The results reveal that the proposed algorithm can be adaptively constructed to solve discrete plant location problems. This has been applied to a set of known test problems and appears to be able to compete with other current solutions with encouraging results.     

Optimisation of facility layout design problem with safety and environmental factors by stochastic DEA and simulation approach

This article presents an integrated computer simulation–stochastic data envelopment analysis (SDEA) approach to deal with the job shop facility layout design problem (JSFLD) with stochastic outputs and safety and environmental factors. Stochastic outputs are defined as non-crisp operational and deterministic inputs. At first, feasible layout alternatives are generated under expert decision. Then, computer simulation network is used for performance modelling of each layout design. The outputs of simulation are average time-in-system, average queue length and average machine utilisation. Finally, SDEA is used with Lingo software for finding the optimum layout alternative amongst all feasible generated alternatives with respect to stochastic, safety and environmental indicators. The integrated approach of this study was more precise and efficient than previous studies with the stated outputs. The results have been verified and validated by principal component analysis. The unique features of this study are the ability of dealing with multiple inputs (including safety) and stochastic (including environmental) outputs. It also uses mathematical programming for optimum layout alternatives. Moreover, it is a practical tool and may be applied in real cases by considering safety and environmental aspects of the manufacturing process within JSFLD problems.     

A corrected formulation for the double row layout problem

This paper presents a corrected formulation to the mixed integer programming model of the double-row layout problem (DRLP), first proposed by Chung and Tanchoco (2010 Chung, J and Tanchoco, J. 2010. The double row layout problem. International Journal of Production Research, 48(3): 709–727. [Taylor &; Francis Online], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar], The double row layout problem. International Journal of Production Research, 48 (3), 709–727). In the DRLP, machines are placed along two rows of a corridor, where the objective is to minimise the total cost of material handling for products that move between these machines. We highlight the errors in the original formulation, propose corrections to the formulation, and provide an analytical validation of the corrections.     

New Tabu search heuristics for the dynamic facility layout problem

A manufacturing facility is a dynamic system that constantly evolves due to changes such as changes in product demands, product designs, or replacement of production equipment. As a result, the dynamic facility layout problem (DFLP) considers these changes and is defined as the problem of assigning departments to locations during a multi-period planning horizon such that the sum of the material handling and re-arrangement costs is minimised. In this paper, three tabu search (TS) heuristics are presented for this problem. The first heuristic is a simple TS heuristic. The second heuristic adds diversification and intensification strategies to the first, and the third heuristic is a probabilistic TS heuristic. To test the performances of the heuristics, two sets of test problems from the literature are used in the analysis. The results show that the second heuristic out-performs the other proposed heuristics and the heuristics available in the literature.     

A Monte Carlo simulation based heuristic procedure for solving dynamic line layout problems for facilities using conventional material handling devices

A simple procedure is proposed to identify line layout solutions when a production facility with work centres of unequal size uses conventional material handling devices and operates under stochastic demand scenarios. The procedure uses Monte Carlo simulation (MCS) to empirically search for robust solutions defined as those that simultaneously meet minimum material handling cost performance levels across all demand scenarios. The results reported in this study suggest that ‘robust’ line layout solutions can be identified using a modest volume of random sampling. The procedure and results are demonstrated through a series of sample problems.