基于模糊回收价格的逆向供应链定价策略研究

在由单一制造商和单一零售商构成的逆向供应链系统中，回收产品质量的不确定性导致回收价格的不确定性．针对这种不确定性，将回收价格看作三角模糊数，应用模糊理论和博弈理论对回收价格浮动的基准点进行决策，分别得出了两个非合作博弈的均衡解（斯坦克尔伯格均衡和纳什均衡）和一个合作博弈的均衡解（联合定价），并给出了各均衡条件下制造商和零售商各自回收价格的浮动范围．     

Supply chain coordination based on return contracts with a threshold ordering quantity

Return contracts are commonly used by companies selling products with short life cycles and highly uncertain demand. Current research on return contracts assumes suppliers are responsible for all surplus products. In practice, retailers tend to order more than necessary and leave suppliers with large after‐season returns. To mitigate the problem, a new type of return contract with a threshold ordering quantity has been developed by some enterprises. Under these contracts, suppliers specify a threshold for retailers’ ordering quantity. They buy back only the portion in excess of the threshold. In this paper, we show that this new type of contract can achieve two objectives: (a) the supply chain is coordinated, and (b) both the supplier and the retailer can gain more profit than they can gain under a wholesale‐price‐only contract. The new contract does not require any manipulation of wholesale prices. This makes it more acceptable in practice by supply chain members. We also illustrate our findings in a numerical example.     

Effects of uncertainty on a tire closed-loop supply chain network

In a closed-loop supply chain (CLSC) network, there are both forward and reverse supply chains. In this research, a tire remanufacturing CLSC network is designed and optimized based on tire recovery options. The objective of the optimization model is to maximize the total profit. The optimization model includes multiple products, suppliers, plants, retailers, demand markets, and drop-off depots. The application of the model is discussed based on a realistic network in Toronto, Canada using map. In addition, a new decision tree-based methodology is provided to calculate the net present value of the problem in multiple periods under different sources of uncertainty such as demand and returns. Furthermore, the discount cash flow is considered in the methodology as a novel innovative approach. This methodology can be applied in comparing the profitability of different design options for CLSCs.     

不同担保模式下考虑零售商公平关切的闭环供应链博弈模型

针对由一个制造商和一个零售商构成的闭环供应链,运用Stackelberg动态博弈理论,构建不同担保模式下考虑零售商公平关切的决策博弈模型,探讨产品担保模式及零售商公平关切对闭环供应链定价及担保期决策、经济效益和环境效益的影响,分析不同担保模式的担保效率.研究结果表明:当消费者对新产品和再制造品差异化担保期较为敏感时,制造商或零售商会为再制造品提供长期担保服务;零售商公平关切会降低新产品和再制造品批发价格,其对再制造品销售价格、担保期以及供应链经济环境效益的影响与产品担保模式密切相关;两种担保模式的经济环境效益与担保成本和再制造品相对环境优势相关,当零售商担保的相对成本优势和再制造品相对环境优势显著(微弱)时,零售商(制造商)担保模式是闭环供应链利益相关者的一致选择;零售商担保模式能够减缓零售商公平关切对闭环供应链经济效益及环境效益的负面影响.     

The price of anarchy in closed-loop supply chains

This paper measures the worst-case efficiency of price-only contracts in closed-loop supply chains (CLSCs) with the price of anarchy (PoA). We model a single-period Stackelberg game in which a manufacturer sells new products to a retailer and collects used products with exogenous retail price and collection price via three alternative reverse channels: (a) the manufacturer collects directly from customers, (b) the retailer collects for the manufacturer, and (c) a third party is awarded a collection subcontract from the manufacturer. We carry out a comprehensive investigation under push–pull configurations to observe how reverse channel structures with different gaming sequences of CLSC members influence the worst-case performance when the demand distribution is over the set of increasing generalized failure rate distributions. From our PoA analysis, we find that the pull system does not always outperform the push system, especially when the retailer is the leader, in contrast to the results for forward supply chains. While the PoA of the push system is dramatically sensitive to the quality condition of used products, the pull system has a constant efficiency loss that is independent of the quality condition. Instead, the PoA of the pull system solely changes with the gaming sequence of the manufacturer. We also find that manufacturer's direct collection is a better reverse channel choice compared to retailer's collection. Additional managerial insights are summarized for discussion.     

零售电商和回收政策对闭环供应链的影响研究

构建第三方回收下的双渠道闭环供应链模型,考虑了三种不同的决策情形来探讨零售电商参与和处理基金政策对供应链中决策、利润、需求和消费者剩余的影响。结果表明：零售电商参与使得传统零售商的产品价格和利润水平降低,制造商可以通过调整对零售电商的批发价格来提高其利润;第三方回收商的回收决策和最优利润不受到零售电商参与的影响,处理基金政策可以有效地提高产品回收数量,但也会使得正向供应链中企业的定价提高;零售电商会蚕食制造商原有的市场份额,但产品总需求量不发生变化。当进一步考虑处理基金政策时,市场总需求量出现下降的趋势;此外,零售电商参与和处理基金政策都会造成供应链中消费者总剩余的减少。     

A particle swarm approach for optimizing a multi-stage closed loop supply chain for the solar cell industry

In order to implement sustainable strategies in a supply chain, enterprises should provide highly favorable and effective solutions for reducing carbon dioxide emissions, which brings out the issues of designing and managing a closed-loop supply chain (CLSC). This paper studies an integrated CLSC network design problem with cost and environmental concerns in the solar energy industry from sustainability perspectives. A multi-objective closed-loop supply chain design (MCSCD) model has been proposed, in consideration of many practical characteristics including flow conservation at each production/recycling unit of forward/reverse logistics (FL/RL), capacity expansion, and recycled components. A deterministic multi-objective mixed integer linear programming (MILP) model capturing the tradeoffs between the total cost and total CO₂ emissions was developed to address the multistage CSLC design problem. Subsequently, a multi-objective PSO (MOPSO) algorithm with crowding distance-based nondominated sorting approach is developed to search the near-optimal solution of the MCSCD model. The computational study shows that the proposed MOPSO algorithm is suitable and effective for solving large-scale complicated CLSC structure than the conventional branch-and-bound optimization approach. Analysis results show that an enterprise needs to apply an adequate recycling strategy or energy saving technology to achieve a better economic effectiveness if the carbon emission regulation is applied. Consequently, the Pareto optimal solution obtained from MOPSO algorithm may give the superior suggestions of CLSC design, such as factory location options, capacity expansion, technology selection, purchasing, and order fulfillment decisions in practice.     

需求依赖于产品价格和消费者时间偏好的定价与订货决策

研究产品的市场需求依赖于价格和消费者时间偏好情形下的供应链及其成员的最优定价与订货问题. 利用时间偏好因子刻画消费者的时间偏好, 利用产品市场需求关于零售价格的弹性指数反映消费者的价格敏感程度, 建立存在强势零售商、强势供应商和供需双方势力均衡3 种渠道权力结构下的定价与订货模型. 数值结果表明, 在3 种渠道权力结构下, 消费者的时间偏好和产品市场需求关于零售价格的弹性指数是供应链主导者最优定价、订货量和期望利润的单调减函数, 将其纳入定价与订货决策的影响因素予以考量能够增加供应链主导者的最大期望利润.

     

Development of RFID-based Reverse Logistics System

Reverse logistics, which is the management or return flow due to product recovery, goods return, or overstock, form a closed-loop supply chain. The success of the closed-loop supply chain depends on actions of both manufacturers and customers. Now, manufacturers require producing products which are easy for disassembly, reuse and remanufacturing owing to the law of environmental protection. On the other hand, the number of customers supporting environmental protection by delivering their used products to collection points is increasing. According to the findings, the total cost spent in reverse logistics is huge. In order to minimize the total reverse logistics cost and high utilization rate of collection points, selecting appropriate locations for collection points is critical in reverse logistics. This paper proposes a genetic algorithm to determine such locations in order to maximize the coverage of customers. Also, the use of RFID is suggested to count the quantities of collected items in collection points and send the signal to the central return center. This can facilitate the vehicle scheduling for transferring the items from collection points to the return center. The significance of this research is the proposal of RFID-based reverse logistics framework and optimization of locations of collection points which allow economically and ecologically reasonable recycling. Simulation results indicated that the genetic algorithm is able to produce good-quality solutions in terms of coverage of collection points by choosing suitable locations for collection points and RFID can help detect the quantity of returned products so as to increase efficiency of logistics operations.     

loss-averse测度的低碳闭环供应链最优减排研究

以低碳产品销售为不确定市场环境为背景,以Stackelberg博弈理论为方法,以loss-averse为工具,构建了双第三方回收低碳风险再制造闭环供应链模型,研究了制造商低碳减排能力、碳排放征税政策、销售商风险厌恶程度和废旧低碳产品回收市场竞争特性等因素的影响作用机理;揭示非合作博弈和协调运作下,订单数量、交易价格、低碳废旧产品回收价格等重要变量和节点企业收益、期望效用及整个链条收益的变化规律及隐含的经济意义与管理理念。设计正向渠道收益共享、逆向渠道风险共担契约,克服风险规避效应和双重边际效应的不利影响,实现低碳再制造闭环供应链的协调;通过数值仿真研究和灵敏度分析,验证了低碳风险再制造闭环供应链模型的有效性及实用性,为供应链上下游企业开展低碳减排合作提供了理论依据和政策建议。     

回收数量不确定的双重竞争闭环供应链定价研究

为解决双重竞争闭环供应链中回收产品数量不确定对财政干预政策及定价决策影响的问题,运用博弈论和Matlab数值仿真的方法,构建回收产品数量不确定的双重竞争闭环供应链定价决策模型,从4个维度剖析并验证回收产品数量不确定对闭环供应链竞争强度、销售及回收价格、供应链节点企业利润及社会福利、回收率的影响规律,研究结果表明：当回收产品数量波动较大,回收商和再制造商的回收价格及回购价格呈现增加的趋势;闭环供链中回收商利润、销售商利润以及社会福利呈现增加的趋势,但是制造商利润下降,即回收数量不确定直接影响闭环供链中起主导作用的制造商执行再制造的积极性。     

考虑损失厌恶和锚定心理的供应链订货与协调

为更合理地实现供应链协调的整体最优绩效,以具有损失厌恶和锚定心理的零售商和风险中性的供应商组成的两级供应链为研究对象,探讨回购契约下的供应链订货及协调情况。建立集中和分散决策下考虑零售商损失厌恶和锚定心理的回购契约协调模型,分析了零售商最优订货量与批发价格、回购价格之间的关系,以及各契约参数对回购价格和各节点利润的影响,并给出了供应链实现协调需要达成的条件。结果表明,当零售商订购的产品为高利润产品时,能够实现供应链整体最优绩效,达到供应链协调,且利润在供应链双方之间的分配随着批发和回购价格的提升而向供应商倾斜,但零售商损失厌恶和锚定心理的加深会使得供应商提升回购价格,使整体供应链的利润下降,成本费用增加。     

An integrated model for closed-loop supply chain configuration and supplier selection: Multi-objective approach

Reverse logistics consists of all operations related to the reuse of products. External suppliers are one of the important members of reverse logistics and closed loop supply chain (CLSC) networks. However in CLSC network configuration models, suppliers are assessed based on purchasing cost and other factors such as on-time delivery are ignored. In this research, a general closed loop supply chain network is examined that includes manufacturer, disassembly, refurbishing, and disposal sites. Meanwhile, it is managed by the manufacturer. We propose an integrated model which has two phases. In the first phase, a framework for supplier selection criteria in RL is proposed. Besides, a fuzzy method is designed to evaluate suppliers based on qualitative criteria. The output of this stage is the weight of each supplier according to each part. In the second phase, we propose a multi objective mixed-integer linear programming model to determine which suppliers and refurbishing sites should be selected (strategic decisions), and find out the optimal number of parts and products in CLSC network (tactical decisions). The objective functions maximize profit and weights of suppliers, and one of them minimizes defect rates. To our knowledge, this model is the first effort to consider supplier selection, order allocation, and CLSC network configuration, simultaneously. The mathematical programming model is validated through numerical analysis.     

Ordering,wholesale pricing and lead-time decisions in a three-stage supply chain under demand uncertainty

This paper develops a game theoretic model of a three-stage supply chain consisting of one retailer, one manufacturer and one subcontractor to study ordering, wholesale pricing and lead-time decisions, where the manufacturer produces a seasonal/perishable product. We explicitly model the effects of the lead-time and the length of selling season on both demand uncertainty and inventory-holding costs. We present the equilibrium outcome of the decentralized supply chain. When the lead-time increases, we find that the retailer increases the order quantity, the manufacturer offers a lower unit-wholesale price and the subcontractor decreases its unit-wholesale price if the manufacturer subcontracts part of the retailer’s order. In the endogenous lead-time setting, we illustrate the effects of some factors such as unit holding cost and capacity on the equilibrium outcome. We find that a higher unit holding cost implies a lower optimal lead-time and order quantity while higher unit-wholesale prices; the basic demand uncertainty increases the optimal lead-time and order quantity while decreases the unit-wholesale prices. The effects of distribution form on equilibrium outcome/profits are investigated by employing a numerical example. The profit loss of decentralization decreases (increases) with the basic demand uncertainty and manufacturer’s capacity (mean demand).     

An optimization model for reverse logistics network under stochastic environment by using genetic algorithm

Recovery of used products has become increasingly important recently due to economic reasons and growing environmental or legislative concern. Product recovery, which comprises reuse, remanufacturing and materials recycling, requires an efficient reverse logistic network. One of the main characteristics of reverse logistics network problem is uncertainty that further amplifies the complexity of the problem. The degree of uncertainty in terms of the capacities, demands and quantity of products exists in reverse logistics parameters. With consideration of the factors noted above, this paper proposes a probabilistic mixed integer linear programming model for the design of a reverse logistics network. This probabilistic model is first converted into an equivalent deterministic model. In this paper we proposed multi-product, multi-stage reverse logistics network problem for the return products to determine not only the subsets of disassembly centers and processing centers to be opened, but also the transportation strategy that will satisfy demand imposed by manufacturing centers and recycling centers with minimum fixed opening cost and total shipping cost. Then, we propose priority based genetic algorithm to find reverse logistics network to satisfy the demand imposed by manufacturing centers and recycling centers with minimum total cost under uncertainty condition. Finally, we apply the proposed model to a numerical example.     

随机需求和奖惩机制下的闭环供应链决策模型

研究新产品和再制造产品需求均为不确定下的闭环供应链系统。通过比较两种产品的消费者WTP(willing to pay)差异性,构建三种政府奖惩机制条件下的闭环供应链模型。深入分析不同制造商主导的博弈模型及其数值实验。结果表明:无论是基于回收率还是回收量的政府奖惩机制,第三方回收模式下回收率最高,制造商利润最高,制造商回收模式下零售商利润最高;消费者对再制造产品WTP差异增加时,制造商利润、零售商利润及渠道总利润先减少后增加;政府奖惩机制变化时,第三方回收模式的回收率随政府奖惩的增加而增幅最大。     

需求随机偏差下带有主从零售商的供应链协调

研究了确定环境下带有主从零售商的供应链协调的基本模型,提出了应急环境下当需求偏差随机发生时集权和分权供应链的最优决策.证明了无论需求随机偏差存在与否都可以运用线性数量折扣合同使得供应链有效达到协调,并相应给出了最优批发单价、最优线性折扣率和转移支付的范围.最后对最优售价、最优总订货量和最优批发单价随需求偏差幅度及其概率的变化进行了仿真分析.     

A Closed-Loop Supply Chain Equilibrium Model with Random and Price-Sensitive Demand and Return

This paper proposes a decentralized closed-loop supply chain network model consisting of raw material suppliers, manufacturers, retailers, and recovery centers. We assume that the demands for the product and the corresponding returns are random and price-sensitive. Retailers and recovery centers face penalties associated with shortage demand and supply, respectively. We derive the optimality conditions of the various decision-makers, and establish that the governing equilibrium conditions can be formulated as a finite-dimensional variational inequality problem. The qualitative properties of the solution to the variational inequality are discussed. Numerical examples are provided to illustrate the effects of demand and return uncertainties on quantity shipments and prices.     

Price and leadtime competition,and coordination for make-to-order supply chains

This paper develops a game theoretic model of a one-manufacturer and one-retailer supply chain facing an outside integrated chain (manufacturer) to study the price and leadtime competition and investigate coordination of the supply chain, where the make-to-order production mode is employed and consumers are sensitive to retail price and leadtime. We find that decentralization of the supply chain increases its leadtime while decreases the rival’s leadtime; and the decentralization increases the retail prices. The existence of the outside competitor raises the leadtime. A higher reservation price or brand differentiation increases the retail prices but decreases the leadtimes; a higher transportation cost or lower leadtime sensitivity increases the retail prices and the leadtimes. The coordination of the supply chain facing integrated rival harms the integrated rival. We design contracts to coordinate the supply chain under leadtime-decision-first scenario and wholesale-price-decision-first scenario, respectively. Further, we find that the sequence of decisions affects the validity of the all-unit quantity discount scheme in coordinating the supply chain.     

Modeling and optimization of two-stage procurement in dual-channel supply chain

An online marketing platform should be designed to fairly take the benefits of buyers and suppliers into consideration based on their risk preferences and business strategies. In this paper, the dual-channel supply chain models are developed to implement the risk-averse strategy for buyers and risk-neutral strategy for suppliers, respectively. The buyers under the consideration are the manufacturers who acquire raw materials, parts, or components to make their final products. The major factors in the developed models include the risk preferences of buyers and suppliers, random price fluctuations of goods, and varying demands of final products. To reflect the purchasing practice of a manufacturer, (1) a supply chain is considered to have two supply channels, i.e., contract-based purchase with a lead-time before the goods are used and a direct purchase from online spot markets when the goods are used; (2) the time factor on decision making is specially taken into account, and the procurements are divided into the contract stage of purchase and online stage of purchase. Gaming analysis is conducted to develop the supply chain models for manufactures and suppliers to implement their purchasing or pricing strategies. The simulation is conducted and the result has shown that two-stage purchases in a dual-channel supply chain have improved the performances of suppliers and manufacturers in terms of the profits they can make, their supply–demand relations, and their adjustability to uncertainties in globalized and segmented markets. The proposed model has its significance for manufacturers to better control the price risk of goods and the demand risk of final products; on the other hand, suppliers can benefit from adjusting dynamic sales using online spot markets.