Modeling farm nutrient flows in the North China Plain to reduce nutrient losses

Years of poor nutrient management practices in the agriculture industry in the North China Plain have led to large losses of nutrients to the environment, causing severe ecological consequences. Analyzing farm nutrient flows is urgently needed in order to reduce nutrient losses. A farm-level nutrient flow model was developed in this study based on the NUFER (NUtrient flows in Food chains, Environment and Resources use) model, and was used to analyze nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) flows, use efficiencies, and losses for nine representative farm types in the North China Plain. Data from 401 farms were evaluated for the years 2012–2015. The analysis showed that mixed farms were more efficient in nutrient utilization than crop-based or landless livestock farms. The efficiencies of N and P used in crop production were highest for mixed dairy farms, reaching 67% for N and 68% for P. Consistently, mixed dairy farms had the lowest N and P surpluses and losses in crop production. Mixed swine farms were 5 and 9% higher in N and P efficiency in livestock production than landless swine farms, respectively. Losses of N and P from the animal manure management chain were 20–42% lower for mixed swine and 69–78% lower for mixed poultry farms than for landless farms of the same animal type. This is at least partially due to more frequent manure removal. Integrated crop-livestock production using livestock wastes as crop fertilizer was shown to be the most sustainable model in nutrient use for the agriculture industry in the North China Plain.     

Estimating nutrient surplus and nutrient use efficiency from farm characteristics

Research on nutrient losses from agricultural systems should try to relate these losses to farm characteristics. This was done for private farms in two districts in Poland. Using data from a farm survey, nutrient surpluses and Nutrient Use Efficiency (NUE, defined as the ratio of outgoing and incoming nutrients) were calculated for nitrogen and phosphorus. Both nutrient surplus and NUE are relatively high. A model was developed to estimate surpluses and NUE from farm characteristics like location, farm size, fertilizer application level, animal density, grass production and sugar beet or potato area. The results of the model are satisfying for nutrient surplus (R2=0.9) and nitrogen NUE (R2=0.4). Estimation of phosphorus NUE was not satisfactory. High surpluses are associated with high fertilizer applications, high animal density and high grass production while an increasing share of sugar beets leads to lower surpluses. A high nitrogen NUE is associated with low fertilizer applications, low animal density and little grass production, and with a high sugar beet area share. Results suggest that, with exception of sugar beet, fertilizer recovery in Poland is very low. Sugar beet, however, combines high fertilizer applications with low surpluses and high NUE. The outcome of the model can be used in the design of environmental policies. The paper ends with some remarks on the type of measures that can be taken, and the effects these will have on private farms in Poland.     

Effects of organic wastes digestion for biogas production on mineral nutrient availability of biogas effluents

Organic farming systems are characterized by the strong regulation of the import of nutrients into the farming system to replace nutrient losses via sold products. In the present study mineral nutrient flows and balances of P, K and magnesium (Mg) were analysed for a mixed organic cropping system with dairy husbandry and for a stockless organic farming system. Also the influence of biogas digestion of farmyard residues (stable wastes, crop residues, etc.) as well as the effect of the import of substrates for biogas digestion on plant mineral nutrient uptake and farmgate nutrient balances was analysed. The objectives of the current study were; (1) to study the effects of anaerobic digestion of cattle manure and crop residues on plant mineral nutrient uptake; and (2) to model nutrient flows and balances related to the input of different kind of substrates for biogas digestion at the farmgate. Results indicated that slurry digestion did not influence plant P and K uptake. Import of single allowed substrates for digestion would lead to large imbalances in nutrient inputs compared to withdrawals. Most of the suited substrates for biogas digestion were associated with large K surpluses and insufficient P returns in comparison to mineral nutrient outputs via sold animal and plant products.     

Balanced pasture fertilization in the Basque Country: I. Phosphorus and potassium budgets on dairy farms

Dairy farming is the main agricultural activity of the Basque Country. A dairy farm is characterized as a system with soils and crops, forage, cattle and manure as main components, and in such a system, nutrient cycling is very important to maintain soil fertility and optimize forage production. To quantify nutrient transfers in the cycle, a simple system was developed and has been applied to seventeen farms to examine its ability to achieve a balanced P and K fertilization. These farms have provided data on inputs (fertilizer, feeds, concentrates), pasture and manure management, and outputs (milk production), and soil samples have been taken from farm pastures. Phosphorus and K in excreta and uneaten pasture is used with a relatively high efficiency as suggested by the relatively high efficiency of P and K utilization by the pasture that usually ranges from 70 to 90%. Concentrate feeding (3000 kg cow^–1 yr^–1) represents one of the main P and K inputs in Basque Country dairy farms, averaging 26 and 66 kg ha^–1, respectively. Besides, release of K in the soil through slow liberation from non-exchangeable sites was estimated as 30 kg ha^–1. Thus, a high efficiency in excreta recycling would diminish substantially P and K mineral fertilizer needs. Farm nutrient budgets appear to be a convenient tool for determining nutrient shortages and surpluses at farm level, and thus they are considered as a first step to support a better management of maintenance fertilization of permanent pastures.     

Farm typologies,soil fertility variability and nutrient management in smallholder farming in Sub-Saharan Africa

Farm typologies are a useful tool to assist in unpacking and understanding the wide diversity among smallholder farms to improve targeting of crop production intensification strategies. Sustainable crop production intensification will require the development of an array of nutrient management strategies tailored to farm-specific conditions, rather than blanket recommendations across diverse farms. This study reviewed key literature on smallholder farm typologies focusing on three countries (Kenya, Malawi and Zimbabwe), to gain insights on opportunities for crop production intensification, and the importance of developing farm-specific nutrient management practices. Investigations on farm typologies have done well in highlighting the fundamental differences between farm categories, with 3–5 typologies often adequate to represent the wide differences in resource endowment. Resource-endowed farmers have ready access to large quantities of manure and mineral fertilizers, which contribute to higher soil fertility and crop productivity on their farms. Resource-constrained households use little or no manure and mineral fertilizers, and have limited capacity to invest in labour-demanding soil fertility management technologies. These farmers often have to rely on off-farm opportunities for income that are largely limited to selling unskilled labour to their resource-endowed neighbors. The variability in management practices by farmers has resulted in three main soil fertility classes that can be used for targeting soil fertility management technologies, characterized by potential response to fertilizer application as: (1) low-responsive fertile fields that receive large additions of manure and fertilizer; (2) high-responsive infertile fields that receive moderate nutrient applications; (3) poorly responsive degraded soils cultivated for many years with little or no nutrient additions. The main conclusions drawn from the review are: (1) resource constrained farmers constitute the widest band across the three countries, with many of the farmers far below the threshold for sustainable maize production intensification and lacking capacity to invest in improved seed and fertilizer, (2) farm sizes and livestock ownership were key determinants for both farmer wealth status and farm productivity, and (3) soil organic carbon and available P were good indicators for predicting previous land management, that is also invariably linked to farmer resource endowment.     

Evaluating the spatial and temporal dynamics of farm and field phosphorus and potassium balances on a mixed crop and livestock farm

Methods to track P and K on farms over time at varying spatial scales can improve farm agronomic and environmental performance monitoring. An annual nutrient balance was used to determine P and K balances at varying spatial scales on a 128 ha mixed crop and dairy farm in a central Pennsylvania limestone valley for each of nine years. Alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) and corn (Zea mays L.) occupied 60% and 40% of the cropland, respectively. Inputs of P and K to the farm exceeded outputs over the study period. Net increases of P and a decrease in K were determined in the aggregate of all fields over the 9-yr period. The balance of P and K varied with time within a field, and by field within a year because nutrient inputs and removals varied with crop selection, management tactics, and year in the rotation. Recognizing that increases in field P are in proportion to P entering the farm can help reduce P accumulation in fields by addressing surpluses at their source or balancing managed flows for the farm. Conversely, decreases in field K associated with forage crops may be the reason for additional supplemental K inputs to the farm. Monitoring nutrient stocks (soil testing) and flows (input/output balances) at different scales in conjunction with spatial patterns of nutrient balances can be the foundation for integrating farm activities and information technologies in a new generation of performance enhancing tools.     

Potential impact of agroforestry on soil nutrient balances at the farm scale in the East African Highlands

There is much current interest in the potential role of agroforestry in the mitigation of nutrient depletion in Sub-Saharan Africa. Using data from farm surveys and trials, a static model of N and P flows was constructed for a standard farm system, representative of typical subsistence farms in humid parts of the East African Highlands. The model was used to explore the possible impact of improved agroforestry systems on nutrient budgets, to identify priorities for research.Soil nutrient balances in the standard farm system were - 107 kg N and - 8 kg P ha^–1 yr^–1. Agroforestry systems did not significantly reduce the N deficits except when a high proportion of the total biomass was returned to the soil, rather than removed from the farm. Agroforestry increased N input through biological N fixation and deep N uptake, but this was offset by a larger nutrient removal from the farm in harvested products, which increased from 38 kg N in the standard system to 169 kg N ha^–1 yr^–1 in an intensive dairy-agroforestry system. Agroforestry did not increase P inputs, and harvested P increased from 6 kg P in the standard farm system to 29 kg P ha^–1 yr^–1 in the dairy-agroforestry system. Thus, moderate P inputs, of 20 kg P ha^–1 yr^–1 were required to maintain soil P stocks.N leaching from the field was the most significant nutrient loss from the farm system, with a range of 68 to 139 kg N ha^–1 yr^–1. The capture of subsoil N by deep-rooted trees in agroforestry systems substantially increased N-use efficiency, providing 60 kg N ha^–1 yr^–1 in the dairy-agroforestry system. The budgets were sensitive to N mineralization rates in subsoils, N losses from soils and manures, and effectiveness of deep-rooted plants in subsoil N capture, for which there is little data from the region. Therefore, high priority should be given to research in these areas.The current model can not account for important feedback mechanisms that would allow analysis of the long-term effects of nutrient budgets on nutrient availability and plant productivity. Dynamic models of farm nutrient budgets that include such interactions are needed to further assess the sustainability of farming systems.     

Modeling the soil nutrient balance of integrated agriculture-aquaculture systems in the Mekong Delta,Vietnam

This study quantifies soil nutrient balances of Integrated Agriculture-Aquaculture Systems in the Mekong Delta of Vietnam. Eleven farms were monitored to collect data on farm activities and nutrient inputs and outputs to compute these balances of the rice-based and high input fish system in O Mon district (R-HF); the rice-based and medium input fish system in Tam Binh district (R-MF); and the orchard-based and low input fish system in Cai Be district (O-LF). For the estimation, the Nutmon model has been adapted to the specific conditions in these integrated systems in Asia (Nutmon-Asia). New regression models of leaching and gaseous losses of nitrogen were applied to fields used for upland crops and paddy rice. Reference values were used for the assessment of nitrogen fixation in paddy soils, wet atmospheric deposition, and irrigation water. The results showed that farms in all three systems have nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium surpluses (84 kg N, 73 kg P, and 69 kg K ha⁻¹ year⁻¹). The O-LF system had the smallest nitrogen surplus while the smallest surplus of phosphorus and potassium was seen in the R-HF system. High surpluses of phosphorus and potassium were found in vegetable fields, whereas a negative potassium balance was found in the rice fields of all three systems. The positive farm nutrient balances indicate that it is likely that soil fertility will be maintained although there is a risk for environmental contamination.     

Use of the partial nutrient budget as an indicator of nutrient depletion in the highlands of southwestern Uganda

Agricultural management has its roots in the manipulation of the system to optimise conditions for crop production. It is now widely recognised that this could result in land degradation with subsequent serious impact on crop productivity if the nutrient losses to the agricultural system are not replaced. A nutrient budget is an account of gains and losses of nutrients in an agricultural system, a tool that could be used to develop sound nutrient management and sustainable agriculture. This tool was applied to the annual crop farming system in the highlands of southwestern Uganda to demonstrate (i) within farm nutrient depletion and accumulating zones, and (ii) the extent of nutrient losses at farm and district levels through marketing pathways. Partial nutrient budgets were constructed at field and farm levels using farmer-recorded resource inputs and outputs over a period of one year, and at the district level using annual inventory data of agricultural imports and exports. The computed nutrient balances were highly variable at field and farm levels, but predominantly negative. Nitrogen (N) gains and losses averaged 30.6 and 72.3 kg ha^–1 yr^–1, respectively in the homestead fields; 10.8 and 33.4 kg ha^–1 yr^–1 in the outfields; 15.8 and 17.4 kg ha^–1 yr^–1 at the farm level; and only losses of 5.6 kg ha^–1 yr^–1 at the district level. Potassium (K) gains and losses followed a similar trend, although less in magnitude. The phosphorus (P) balance was positive but only in the homestead fields and at the farm level. Where agricultural produce were marketed, nutrient losses were reflected more at the higher scales (e.g. district level) and became tied up in pools from which recycling back to agriculture was barely feasible, and with quite alarming monetary implications. Such results can be used to influence policies at different scales on nutrient management.     

Assessing phosphorus management among organic farming systems: a farm input,output and budget analysis in southwestern France

Organic farming is gaining interest worldwide due to its low environmental impact. However, questions still remain about its long-term sustainability, particularly in terms of nutrient management. There is debate about the ability of organic farming systems to compensate for nutrient exports due to crop and animal production. Stockless systems are considered as the most critical and they are generally associated with negative farm-gate nutrient budgets. In this study, we examined the farm-gate nutrient budgets of 23 organic farms located in southwestern France, with special focus on stockless farming systems. Phosphorus (P) was taken as a case study due to the issue of its critical management in organic farming systems. The farms were characterised on the basis of interviews with farmers and the soil nutrient status was assessed through soil sampling. Results showed that none of the farms imported rock phosphate fertiliser. On the contrary, most farms imported organic fertiliser and/or compost and manure, the latter from neighbouring farms or urban areas. As a consequence, stockless farm P budgets were not necessarily negative and options existed from achieving better nutrient cycle closure. However, soil P test was low to moderate in many cases. These results suggested that P management in organic farming systems is not simply related to the mixed versus specialised characteristics of the farms and that nutrient cycling should be addressed and assessed at a larger, e.g., district, scale.     

The use of farmgate balances and soil surface balances as estimator for nitrogen leaching to surface water

Farmgate balances (FGBs), defined as the difference between nutrient input and nutrient output at farm level, are currently used as a tool to monitor changes in nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) leaching to groundwater and surface water. We postulate that the estimator value of FGBs for N and P leaching to groundwater and surface water depends on (1) the distribution of N and P surpluses over fields within farms, and (2) the partitioning of the surplus over the various nutrient loss pathways. In this study, we assessed intra-farm variability of N and P surpluses and its possible consequences on N leaching to surface waters. Furthermore, we investigated the effect of policies to decrease N and P surpluses at farm level on N and P surpluses at field level. FGBs were derived for six dairy farms in a hydrologically rather isolated polder with grassland on peat soil for three years (1999, 2000 and 2001). Soil surface balances (SSBs), defined as the differences between nutrient input and nutrient output at field level, were derived for the accompanying 65 fields for the same years. On average, FGB surpluses decreased from 271 kg N ha^–1 y^–1 and 22 kg P ha^–1 y^–1 in 1999 to 213 kg N ha^–1 y^–1 and 13 kg P ha^–1 y^–1 in 2001. Variances in N and P surpluses between fields per farm were compared with variances between farms. For N, variances between fields per farm exceeded variances between farms for all years. A non-linear model was fitted on the measured N loading of the surface water. This model showed that N leaching to surface water was underestimated by 5–46% if the variability in N surpluses between fields per farm was not taken into account. We concluded that estimation of N leaching to surface water, based on data at farm level, can lead to underestimation of the N leaching due to the large variability in N surpluses between fields per farm. The extent of this bias by a given distribution of N surpluses within farms was largely controlled by the partitioning of the N surplus over the various nutrient loss pathways, notably denitrification.     

The significance of available nutrient fluxes in N and P budgets for maize cropping on a Rhodic Kandiustox: a study with compost,NP fertilizer and stubble removal

Nutrient budgets may be useful tools for nutrient management of crops especially if they estimate the nutrient fluxes available from a variety of sources including organic and inorganic fertilizer, crop residues and soil organic matter. The aim of the present study was to develop a budget of available nutrients by determining the contribution of mineralized nutrient fluxes and fertilizer input relative to nutrient losses and removal in harvested products in the overall N and P balances. N and P inputs and outputs and available N and P fluxes in the soil were estimated for 3 consecutive maize crops where inputs and outputs were altered by NP fertilizer, compost and stubble removal on a Rhodic Kandiustox. A sensitivity analysis of calculated and measured nutrient budget items was conducted to identify the main factors affecting the accuracy of the nutrient balance calculations. Mineral fertilizer rate was the major factor for maize nutrient budgets as shown by its contribution to N and P balances. Without mineral fertilizer application, soil organic matter (SOM) mineralization was the most important within-season nutrient input. In the case of N, shoot uptake was the main output followed by denitrification. Phosphorus adsorption by the soil was the major P output from the available pools followed by shoot uptake. SOM mineralization maintained the pools of available N and P if stubble of the previous crop was returned. Mineral fertilizer application, which produced surplus balances of N and P, would however, be needed to attain high yield, even with stubble return. The available N and P from compost were not significant inputs in the nutrient balances until year 3. Total N and resin extractable P in soil after five crops supported the calculated nutrient balances indicating the importance of available nutrient fluxes in calculating N and P balances.     

Quantification of nitrogen inputs from biological nitrogen fixation to whole farm nitrogen budgets of two dairy farms in Atlantic Canada

Legume biological N fixation (BNF) is a large source of uncertainty in farm N budgets. This study sought to quantify the BNF-N input to two whole farm nitrogen budgets and establish a simple and accurate method for incorporating BNF values as inputs in whole farm N budgets. Nitrogen inputs and outputs as well as flows of N between animal and crop production components were determined for a dairy farm in New Brunswick (NB) and Prince Edward Island (PE) over a two year period. The ¹⁵N natural abundance method was used to determine the %N derived from the atmosphere (%Ndfa) through BNF at both sites. Red clover (Trifolium pratense) at the PE site derived 77 % of its N from BNF and alfalfa (Medicago sativa) collected at both the PE and NB farms derived 72 % of its N from BNF. Total BNF-N present in legume biomass from mixed forage fields measured with the ¹⁵N natural abundance method ranged from 39 to 116 kg N ha^?1 year^?1. A legume dry matter conversion model adjusted with %Ndfa and %N of red clover and alfalfa samples from both farm sites was selected to estimate BNF-N inputs from mixed forage fields on the farms. Averaged across the entire cropland area at each farm site, the BNF-N inputs ranged from 27 to 52 kg N ha^?1 year^?1. The farmgate BNF-N inputs are low in comparison to other studies, possibly due to low legume contents in forage fields. BNF accounted for 18–29 % of farmgate N inputs at the farms. Surpluses of N found at both farm sites ranged from 98 to 135 kg N ha^?1 year^?1, typical to the whole farm N budgets of similar dairy farms.     

Nutrient cycling in organic farms: stall balance of a suckler cow herd and beef bulls

In organic agriculture, the internal farm nutrient cycle must bequantified to ensure high system productivity accompanied by environmentallysound production processes. In contrast to common farm-gate and field balances,budgeting at the stall level is seldom undertaken. When budgeting mixed farmingsystems, a substantial lack of nutrients can be detected in the forageand straw input – stall – manure output nutrient flow chain.Therefore, stall balances focus on a central component of whole-farm nutrientbudgets for developing efficient nutrient management strategies. At theexperimental farm for organic agriculture at Wiesengut in Hennef, Germany, allsolid mass flows for a suckler herd and a herd of beef bulls were measured.Relative balance values obtained for dry matter and C (45 to 56%), N (16to 36%), P (–7 to 22.5%), K (0 to 13%) and ash(–4 to 7%) varied over a wide range. Balances are very sensitive tovariations in mass flow and nutrient content for components with high nutrientcontents and/or a large contribution to total mass flow (e.g. manure, silage).In developing strategies to minimise N losses, by reducing N surplus in theration, one must consider, that, in contrast to dairy farms, a suckler herd forbeef production integrated in an organic farm has to adapt to crop productiondemands.     

A phosphorus budget of a poultry farm and a dairy farm in the southeastern U.S., and the potential impacts of diet alterations

Current and potential environmental problems associated with P transport from lands receiving high application rates of animal waste are a major concern. Phosphorus management strategies are needed to reduce P loading on land. This study was conducted to compare on-farm P budgets for a modern broiler farm and a dairy farm under traditional diets and management practices. Phosphorus inputs, recycling and outputs were assessed for both farms. A typical broiler and a dairy farmer from North Carolina were interviewed and pertinent information for the study was obtained, in cooperation with extension agents, and other professionals associated with the farms. The annual on-farm P surplus for the broiler farm was 6,380 kg, while that for the dairy farm was 1,141 kg. This corresponds to an annual application of 65 kg P ha^–1 for the broiler farm and 20 kg P ha^–1 for the dairy farm in excess of removal. The potential for reducing P surpluses by the addition of phytase enzymes and/or the use of low phytic acid corn (Zea mays L.) feed in the broiler farm diet was also assessed. Estimates by animal nutritionists indicate that feed supplementation with phytase enzyme can reduce the broiler farm's P surplus by 33%. The use of low phytic acid corn can reduce the surplus by 49% and a combination of the two can reduce the surplus by 58%. In this study, the incorporation of soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr.) and alfalfa (Medicago sativa) land into the waste utilization plan of the dairy farm decreases the annual P surplus from 20 to 9 kg P ha^–1. The use of new feed technology and expanding waste application to a larger land base can significantly alter the P budgets of broiler and dairy farms and reduce P surpluses, minimizing the risk of environmental problems.     

Nitrogen,phosphorus and potassium balances and cycles of Swiss agriculture from 1975 to 2008

Intensification of Swiss agriculture after 1950 led to an increase in productivity and a range of environmental and health problems provoked by growing inputs of nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) into the agricultural cycle. In 2008, farm-gate balances showed surpluses of 108 kg N ha⁻¹, 5.5 kg P ha⁻¹ and 28 kg K ha⁻¹ for Swiss agriculture. Nutrient surpluses rose between 1975 and 1980 and then decreased significantly until 2008, with percentage reductions being higher for P (80%) and K (54%) than for N (27%). The introduction of direct payments for ecological programmes such as integrated production in 1993 led to a more pronounced decrease in nutrient surpluses for several years, until most farmers had joined these programmes. Lower surpluses could primarily be attributed to reductions in mineral fertilizer use and N deposition. Biological N fixation and atmospheric deposition contributed most to the uncertainty in calculating nutrient balances. N cycle was characterized by substantial inputs into and outputs out of the agricultural sector, whereas P and K cycles were more closed. In future, nutrient balances at a regional level are required to identify areas with high surpluses. In Switzerland, a further reduction in surpluses could be achieved by better feeding strategies and an improved fertilizer management, mainly of animal manure.     

Major nutrient balances in small-scale vegetable farming systems in peri-urban areas in China

Balances of major nutrients such as nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and potassium (K) in small-scale farming systems are of critical importance to nutrient management and sustainable agricultural development. Mass balances of N, P, and K and some of their influencing factors were studied for two years from July 2003 to July 2005 on small-scale vegetable-farming systems in two contrasting peri-urban areas (Nanjing and Wuxi) of the Yangtze river delta region of China. This balance approach considered organic fertilizer inputs (cow manure, pig manure, and human biosolids), inorganic fertilizer inputs (urea, composite fertilizer, and phosphates), irrigation water, and atmospheric deposition; and considered outputs by vegetables. Input via organic fertilizers was significant for all element balances in the Nanjing area. Inorganic and organic fertilizer, particularly inorganic fertilizer, contributed major nutrient inputs to the system in the Wuxi area. Compared with nutrient output by vegetables, there were significant surpluses of N and P on two vegetable farm systems. Furthermore, N surplus in the Nanjing area was higher than that in the Wuxi area with an inverse relationship to P surplus. In contrast, the general trend of K balances was negative on both sites; hence, the nutrient use efficiency was significantly lower for N and P than K. The nutrient imbalance may be attributed to the differences between fertilizer types and management modes driven by social economic status differences among farmer households. The large N and P net excess creates an environmental threat because of potential losses to ground or surface waters, whereas negative K balance creates soil fertility risks. The results highlight researchers’ and farmers’ need to develop rational fertilization technology to optimize nutrient management on vegetable farmlands to promote sustainable agricultural development in peri-urban areas.     

Beyond adding up inputs and outputs: Process assessment and upscaling in modelling nutrient flows

Departing from the historical background of scientific interest in soil fertility and sustainable agricultural production in sub-Saharan Africa, a review is conducted of nutrient budget studies carried out in semi-arid West Africa at scales ranging from individual fields to the sub-continent. For both, nitrogen and phosphorus, the comparison discloses largely diverging balances calculated for similar agro-ecosystems. In a first step, the modes of calculation of the nutrient budgets are examined. It is demonstrated that the calculations used in the different studies differ by the variables and biophysical processes taken into account, and by the choice of spatial scales as well as related time scales. One important discrepancy between approaches is whether and to which extent nutrient flows are internalized when upscaling. The extent to which the impact of individual and communal management, especially of pastoral and forestry resources, on nutrient flows is accounted for is a second cause of divergence. Moreover, it was observed that nutrient budgets tend to be increasingly negative as the spatial scale of the study increases from farm to sub-continent. This unexpected trend is traced back to the lack of internalization of nutrient flows when upscaling. The complexity of the scale patterns of nutrient flows and that of the interactions and the tradeoffs in the effects of management calls for the use of models to calculate nutrient budgets. Therefore, in a second step, examples of a static model, a multiple-goal linear programming model and a decision rules model were reviewed, all of which include the calculation of nutrient flows and balances and which were applied to West-African farming systems. The models are analyzed for their way of dealing with the critical issues of spatial and temporal scales and the impact of resource management on nutrient flows, taking into account that they have different objectives and were designed for different spatio-temporal scales. To conclude, suggestions were made for strengthening the use of models as tools enabling ex-ante testing of alternative agricultural technologies and policies that could improve soil nutrient balances in semi-arid sub-Saharan Africa.     

Beyond adding up inputs and outputs: Process assessment and upscaling in modelling nutrient flows

Departing from the historical background of scientific interest in soil fertility and sustainable agricultural production in sub-Saharan Africa, a review is conducted of nutrient budget studies carried out in semi-arid West Africa at scales ranging from individual fields to the sub-continent. For both, nitrogen and phosphorus, the comparison discloses largely diverging balances calculated for similar agro-ecosystems. In a first step, the modes of calculation of the nutrient budgets are examined. It is demonstrated that the calculations used in the different studies differ by the variables and biophysical processes taken into account, and by the choice of spatial scales as well as related time scales. One important discrepancy between approaches is whether and to which extent nutrient flows are internalized when upscaling. The extent to which the impact of individual and communal management, especially of pastoral and forestry resources, on nutrient flows is accounted for is a second cause of divergence. Moreover, it was observed that nutrient budgets tend to be increasingly negative as the spatial scale of the study increases from farm to sub-continent. This unexpected trend is traced back to the lack of internalization of nutrient flows when upscaling. The complexity of the scale patterns of nutrient flows and that of the interactions and the tradeoffs in the effects of management calls for the use of models to calculate nutrient budgets. Therefore, in a second step, examples of a static model, a multiple-goal linear programming model and a decision rules model were reviewed, all of which include the calculation of nutrient flows and balances and which were applied to West-African farming systems. The models are analyzed for their way of dealing with the critical issues of spatial and temporal scales and the impact of resource management on nutrient flows, taking into account that they have different objectives and were designed for different spatio-temporal scales. To conclude, suggestions were made for strengthening the use of models as tools enabling ex-ante testing of alternative agricultural technologies and policies that could improve soil nutrient balances in semi-arid sub-Saharan Africa.     

Subnational nutrient budgets to monitor environmental risks in EU agriculture: calculating phosphorus budgets for 243 EU28 regions using public data

This paper presents a method to estimate soil surface phosphorus (P) budgets for 243 subnational regions in EU28. This is about the maximum spatial resolution that can be achieved mainly using international datasets that are regularly updated. Similar subnational budgets could be established for nitrogen (N) with some additions to this method. Increasing the spatial resolution from national to subnational is one way to address the well-known issue that national nutrient budgets sometimes mask considerable heterogeneity, i.e., regional surpluses and deficits that are not seen in national averages. Our results indeed show how a rich structure of different P budgets emerges when moving from national to subnational level. Another approach is to exclude the most extensively managed areas from the budgets, to better represent the surplus in intensive agriculture areas. Here, we show that both approaches are useful and sometimes important as they can affect P surplus estimates by about 10 kg P ha^??1 y^??1 or more. The choice of spatial resolution is a trade-off between accuracy and precision. National budgets are the most accurate thanks to good data coverage, but they sometimes fail to identify considerable P surpluses and deficits at subnational level. Increasing the precision (spatial resolution) gradually reveals this heterogeneity but comes at the cost of growing data gaps, which we discuss in detail. These subnational P surpluses represent a middle ground which may prove useful as one indicator among others to monitor the development of environmental risks and resource problems over time.