MIXED MODE SMALL CRACK GROWTH

Abstract— The fatigue crack growth behavior of small part-through cracks in 1045 steel and Inconel 718 subjected to biaxial loading has been investigated. Experiments were performed on thin-wall tubular specimens loaded in tension, torsion and combined tension torsion. Crack sizes analyzed ranged from 20 μm to 1 mm and growth rates ranged from 10^-7 to 10^-4 mm/cycle for 1045 steel and from 10^-5 to 10^-2 mm/cycle for Inconel. Nucleation and the early growth of cracks occurs on planes of maximum shear strain amplitude for both of these materials even in tensile loading. An equivalent strain based intensity factor was employed to correlate the crack growth rate under mixed mode loading conditions In loading conditions other than torsion, a transition from mode II to mode I was observed for 1045 steel. Principal strains were used to analyze mode I cracks. Cracks in Inconel 718 grow in mode II for the majority of the fatigue life. The maximum shear strain amplitude and the tensile strain normal to the maximum shear strain amplitude plane were used to calculate the strain based intensity factor for mixed mode loading.     

EFFECT OF BIAXIAL MEAN STRESS ON CYCLIC STRESS-STRAIN RESPONSE AND BEHAVIOUR OF SHORT FATIGUE CRACKS IN A HIGH STRENGTH SPRING STEEL

Abstract— Biaxial fatigue tests were conducted on a high strength spring steel using hour-glass shaped smooth specimens. Four types of loading system were employed, i.e. (a) fully reversed cyclic torsion, (b) uniaxial push—pull, (c) fully reversed torsion with a superimposed axial static tension or compression stress, and (d) uniaxial push—pull with a superimposed static torque, to evaluate the effects of mean stress on the cyclic stress—strain response and short fatigue crack growth behaviour. Experimental results indicate that a biaxial mean stress has no apparent influence on the stress—strain response in torsion, however a superimposed tensile mean stress was detrimental to torsional fatigue strength. Similarly a superimposed static shear stress reduced the push—pull fatigue lifetime. A compressive mean stress was seen to be beneficial to torsion fatigue life. The role of mean stress on fatigue lifetime, under mixed mode loading, was investigated through experimental observations and theoretical analyses of short crack initiation and propagation. Using a plastic replication technique the effects of biaxial mean stress on both Stage I (mode II) and Stage II (mode I) short cracks were evaluated and analysed in detail. A two stage biaxial short fatigue crack growth model incorporating the influence of mean stress was subsequently developed and applied to correlate data of crack growth rate and fatigue life.     

FATIGUE DAMAGE IN 1045 STEEL UNDER VARIABLE AMPLITUDE BIAXIAL LOADING

Abstract— During constant amplitude loading, two different types of crack systems have been reported In the high cycle fatigue (HCF) region, cracks nucleate on a small number of maxium shear strain amplitude planes One of these cracks becomes a dominant crack and leads to failure of the specimen In the low cycle fatigue (LCF) region, equally developed microcracks are observed over the entire gage section and grow during the majority of the life. The failure is due to a linking in which the microcracks join up during the last few cycles of the fatigue life.
To investigate the interaction of these two types of crack systems in biaxial fatigue, experiments were performed on thin-wall tubular specimens in tension, torsion and combined tension-torsion loading The test program included step loading and block loading in which two equivalent strain amplitudes were employed. One of the equivalent strain amplitudes is in the HCF region and the other was in the LCF region
Fatigue lives were predicted from constant amplitude damage curves when a single crack system dominated the fatigue process Two competitive crack systems were sometimes developed on the maximum shear strain amplitude planes in a single specimen under block loading This resulted in a conservative prediction of the fatigue life.     

Multiaxial fatigue of rubber: Part II: experimental observations and life predictions

Fatigue experiments were conducted with an axial‐torsion specimen covering a wide range of stretch biaxiality and a range of fatigue lives between 10³ and 2 × 10⁶ cycles. These experiments include combined torsion–compression, pure torsion, combined torsion–tension and pure axial tension. Both in‐phase and out‐of‐phase combinations of axial and torsion loading were considered. The multiaxial fatigue experiments described provide empirical evidence from which an understanding of the mechanics of the fatigue process in rubber can be developed. Each of the four equivalence parameters described in Part I has been applied to the axial‐torsion fatigue experiments described in this paper (Part II). These results provide the basis for an analysis of the effects of multiaxial loading on fatigue life, and an assessment of the degree to which the various equivalence parameters are able to rationalize the results in a unified way. For the combined axial and shear strain histories in this study, the maximum principal strain criterion gave the best correlation to fatigue life. Strain energy density gave the worst correlation. The cracking energy density criterion was generally found to give good correlation of fatigue crack nucleation lives from combined axial‐torsion tests. Because it provides a plane‐specific analysis, this criterion appears to be particularly well suited for use in crack nucleation analyses of multiaxial strain histories.     

MECHANISMS AND FATIGUE PERFORMANCE OF TWO STEELS IN CYCLIC TORSION WITH AXIAL STATIC TENSION/COMPRESSION

Abstract— Fatigue tests conducted under fully reversed cyclic torsion, with and without superimposed axial static tension/compression loads, were carried out using hour-glass smooth specimens in laboratory air. A high strength spring steel and a 316L stainless steel, were employed to evaluate the effects of mean stress on fatigue performance. Experimental test results show that a biaxial tensile/compressive mean stress had no influence on the cyclic stress-strain response in both materials. However a biaxial tensile mean stress was found to be detrimental to fatigue life of the high strength spring steel but had no effect on the total fatigue life of 316L stainless steel. A compressive mean stress was found to be beneficial to the life of both steels. The fatigue behaviour of the two materials was investigated by experimental observations and the application of theoretical analyses of short crack growth behaviour. Based upon the analysis of surface acetate replicas it has been found that fatigue crack growth is material/stress-state dependent. A biaxial tensile static stress promoted a change in the direction of the Stage I (mode II) crack from the longitudinal direction to a plane normal to the specimen axis in the high strength steel but not in the stainless steel. Consequently a different growth behaviour of Stage I (mode II) cracks was observed for the two materials. The effect of a biaxial mean stress on fatigue crack growth behaviour of the two materials is analysed and described in some detail.     

Deformation behaviour,short crack growth and fatigue livesunder multiaxial nonproportional loading

Experimental results of a research project on short crack growth under multiaxial nonproportional loading are presented. Fatigue lives, crack growth curves and the deformation behaviour of hollow tube specimens and notched specimens were investigated under combined tension and torsion loading. The results served as basis for the development of a cyclic plasticity model [Döring R, Hoffmeyer J, Vormwald M, Seeger T. A plasticity model for calculating stress–strain sequences under multiaxial nonproportional cyclic loading. In: Comput Mater Sci. 28(3–4);2003:587–96; Döring R, Hoffmeyer J, Seeger T, Vormwald M. Constitutive modelling of nonproportional hardening, cyclic hardening and ratchetting. In: Proceedings of the seventh international conference on biaxial/multiaxial fatigue and fracture, DVM, Berlin; 2004. p. 291–6; Hoffmeyer J. Anrisslebensdauervorhersage bei mehrachsiger Beanspruchung auf Basis des Kurzrisskonzepts. PhD-Thesis, TU Darmstadt; 2004.] and a short crack model [Hoffmeyer J. Anrisslebensdauervorhersage bei mehrachsiger Beanspruchung auf Basis des Kurzrisskonzepts. PhD-Thesis, TU Darmstadt; 2004; Döring R, Hoffmeyer J, Seeger T, Vormwald M. Fatigue lifetime prediction based on a short crack growth model for multiaxial nonproportional loading. In: Proceedings of the seventh international conference on biaxial and multiaxial fatigue and fracture, DVM, Berlin; 2004. p. 253–8].Stress–strain paths including nonproportional hardening and experimental fatigue lives of the unnotched specimens under different loading cases are discussed and compared with calculations. Load-time-sequences were in-phase, 45° and 90° out-of-phase loading with constant and variable amplitudes, torsion without and with superimposed static normal stress, and strain paths like box, butterfly, diamond and cross path. For the notched specimens fatigue lives under 0° and 90° out-of-phase loading are compared with calculations based on finite element results and the short crack model. During some tests the initiation, growth and orientation of short cracks was studied using the plastic replica technique.     

Multiaxial fatigue behaviour of A356‐T6

Aluminum alloy A356‐T6 was subjected to fully reversed cyclic loading under tension, torsion and combined loading. Results indicate that endurance limits are governed by maximum principal stress. Fractography demonstrates long shear mode III propagation with multiple initiation sites under torsion. Under other loadings, fracture surfaces show unique initiation sites coincidental to defects and mode I crack propagation. Using the replica technique, it has been shown that the initiation life is negligible for fatigue lives close to 10⁶ cycles for combined loading. The natural crack growth rate has also been shown to be comparable to long cracks in similar materials.     

The influence of constant axial compression pre-stress on the fatigue failure of torsion loaded tube springs

This paper reports the results of a series of biaxial static compression and torsion experiments performed to evaluate the effects of static compression stress on the fatigue life those smooth tubes made of high strength spring steel. Compression pre-stress was introduced by a solid steel bar inserted into a hollow spring and loaded with a screw-joint. The experimentally obtained results show a significant extension of fatigue strain life as a result of combining axial compression loading with torsion. Cracking behavior was observed and it was noted that compression pre-stresses contribute to retardation of the fatigue crack initiation process and, consequently, contribute to the extension of fatigue life. The fatigue shear crack initiated in a transverse direction. This crack continues to propagate in the same direction until it starts to propagate as a macro-crack on the maximum shear plane.     

Influence of loading path on fatigue crack growth under multiaxial loading condition

In this study, the specimens made of carbon steel S45 with an initial surface straight edge notch were subjected to combined cyclic axial‐torsion loading at room temperature. The fatigue life, surface crack extension direction and crack length were experimentally investigated. The effects of loading path, stress amplitude ratio and phase angle on the crack growth behaviour were also discussed. The results showed that, under the combination of cyclic axial and torsion loading, the tension stress amplitude had more effect on the initial crack growth path than the latter. The shear stress amplitude contributed mainly to the latter crack extension. The crack extension path was mainly determined by the stress amplitudes and the ratio of the normal stress to the shear stress, and almost independent of the mean stresses. The increase of the tension stress amplitude and shear stress amplitude would both accelerate the crack growth rate.     

Surface crack and cracks networks in biaxial fatigue

Semi-elliptical fatigue crack growth in 304 L stainless steel, under biaxial loading, was investigated. Compared to those of through-cracks under uniaxial loading, the growth rate of surface cracks is increased by a non-singular compressive stress and reduced by a tensile stress, when R = 0. Plasticity-induced crack closure under biaxial loading was investigated through 3D finite element simulations with node release. Roughness and phase-transformation-induced closure effects were also discussed. The interactions in two-directional crack networks under biaxial tension were investigated numerically. It appears that the presence of orthogonal cracks should not be ignored. The beneficial influence of interaction-induced mode-mixities was highlighted.     

Fatigue crack growth for a surface crack in a round bar under multi-axial loading condition

In this paper, the fatigue life, surface crack extension direction and crack growth rate in an elastic bar with a circular cross section are determined through experiments under cyclic torsion with axial static and cyclic tension/compression loading. The effects of the loading type, loading value and stress ratio on the crack growth behaviour are discussed. The results show that, under pure fatigue torsion loading, the crack extension direction is almost the same whatever the value of torsion loading. Under fatigue torsion with cyclic tension loading, it is found that the crack extension direction is mainly determined by the alternating parts of the stresses and is almost independent of the average parts of the stresses, whereas the fatigue life is obviously dependent on the average stress.     

Fatigue crack growth from small defects under out-of-phase combined loading

A modified linear elastic fracture mechanics analysis is presented for the evaluation of the crack growth and threshold behavior of small cracks initiated from small defects under combined loading fatigue. For the detailed evaluation of the behavior of small fatigue cracks, the Kitagawa effect, the elastic–plastic behavior of cracks in biaxial stress fields and crack closure effects are taken into account. In-phase and out-of-phase combined tension and torsion fatigue tests were conducted using annealed carbon steel specimens containing small holes. The direction of crack propagation, S–N curves and fatigue limits were found to be in good agreement with the theoretical predictions.     

Closure-free biaxial fatigue crack growth rate and life prediction under various biaxiality ratios in SAE 1045 steel

Biaxial fatigue tests were performed on thin-walled tubular 1045 steel specimens in a test fixture that applied internal and external pressure and axial load. There were two test series, one in which constant amplitude fully reversed strains (CAS) were applied and another in which large periodic compressive overstrain (PCO) cycles causing strains normal to the crack plane were inserted in a constant amplitude history of smaller strain cycles. Ratios of hoop strain to axial strain of λ = ?1, ?0.625, ?ν and +1 were used in each test series. Fatigue crack growth behaviours under CAS and PCO histories were compared, and revealed that the morphology of the fracture surface near the crack tip and the crack growth rate changed dramatically with the application of the compressive overstrains. When the magnitude of the compressive overstrains was increased, the height of the fracture surface irregularities was reduced as the increasing overstrain progressively flattened the fracture surface asperities near the crack tip. The reduced asperity height was accompanied by drastic increases in crack growth rate and decreases in fatigue life. Using a pressurizing device attached to the confocal scanning laser microscope (CSLM), crack opening measurements were obtained. Crack opening measurements showed that the biaxial cracks were fully open at zero internal pressure for block strain histories containing in-phase PCO cycles of yield stress magnitude. Therefore, for the shear-strained samples, there was no crack face interference and the strain intensity range was fully effective. For PCO tests (with biaxial strain ratios of ?0.625 and +1), effective strain intensity data were obtained from tests with positive stress ratios for which cracks did not close. A number of strain intensity parameters derived from well-known fatigue life parameters were used to correlate fatigue crack growth rates for the various strain ratios investigated. Predicted fatigue lifetimes based on a fatigue crack growth rate prediction program using critical shear plane parameters showed good agreement with the experimental fatigue life data.     

SHEAR FATIGUE CRACK GROWTH: A LITERATURE SURVEY

A fatigue crack is often initiated by a localized cyclic plastic deformation in a crystal where the active slip plane coincides with the plane of maximum shear stress. Once a crack is initiated, the crack will propagate on the maximum shear plane for a while and, in the majority of the cases, will eventually change to the plane of the applied tensile stress. The “shear” and “tensile” modes of fatigue crack propagation are termed stage I and stage II fatigue crack growth. They are also known as mode II and mode I fatigue crack growth. However, the mechanism of the tensile mode fatigue crack propagation is shear in nature. Considerable progress has been made recently in the understanding of mode II fatigue crack growth. This paper reviews the various test methods and related data analyses. The combined mode I and mode II elastic crack tip stress field is reviewed. The development and the design of the compact shear specimen are described and the results of fatigue crack growth tests using the compact shear specimens are reviewed. The fatigue crack growth tests and the results of inclined cracks in tensile panels, center cracks in plates under biaxial loading, cracked beam specimens with combined bending and shear loading, center cracked panels and the double edge cracked plates under cyclic shear loading are reviewed and analyzed in detail.     

Biaxial fatigue for proportional and non‐proportional loading paths

In order to study the use of a local approach to predict crack‐initiation life on notches in mechanical components under multiaxial fatigue conditions, the study of the local cyclic elasto‐plastic behaviour and the selection of an appropriate multiaxial fatigue model are essential steps in fatigue‐life prediction. The evolution of stress–strain fields from the initial state to the stabilized state depends on the material type, loading amplitude and loading paths. A series of biaxial tension–compression tests with static or cyclic torsion were carried out on a biaxial servo‐hydraulic testing machine. Specimens were made of an alloy steel 42CrMo4 quenched and tempered. The shear stress relaxations of the cyclic tension–compression with a steady torsion angle were observed for various loading levels. Finite element analyses were used to simulate the cyclic behaviour and good agreement was found. Based on the local stabilized cyclic elastic–plastic stress–strain responses, the strain‐based multiaxial fatigue damage parameters were applied and correlated with the experimentally obtained lives. As a comparison, a stress‐invariant‐based approach with the minimum circumscribed ellipse (MCE) approach for evaluating the effective shear stress amplitude was also applied for fatigue life prediction. The comparison showed that both the equivalent strain range and the stress‐invariant parameter with non‐proportional factors correlated well with the experimental results obtained in this study.     

Shear mode threshold for a small fatigue crack in a bearing steel

The fatigue behaviour of small, semi‐elliptical surface cracks in a bearing steel was investigated under cyclic shear‐mode loading in ambient air. Fully reversed torsion was combined with a static axial compressive stress to obtain a stable shear‐mode crack growth in the longitudinal direction of cylindrical specimens. Non‐propagating cracks less than 1 mm in size were obtained (i) by decreasing the stress amplitude in tests using notched specimens and (ii) by using smooth specimens in constant stress amplitude tests. The threshold stress intensity factor ranges, ΔK_IIth and ΔK_IIIth, were estimated from the shape and dimensions of non‐propagating cracks. Wear on the crack faces was inferred by debris and also by changes in microstructure in the wake of crack tip. These effects resulted in a significant increase in the threshold value. The threshold value decreased with a decrease in crack size. No significant difference was observed between the values of ΔK_IIth and ΔK_IIIth.     

Biaxial tension fatigue response of concrete

Concrete structures such as rigid airport pavements are subjected to repeated high-amplitude loads resulting from passing aircraft. The resulting stress-state in concrete is a biaxial combination of compression and tension. It is of interest to understand the response of plain concrete to such loading conditions, which will enable development of realistic material models for implementation in mechanistic pavement design procedures.The objective of this work is to characterize the quasi-static and low-cycle fatigue response of concrete subjected to biaxial stresses in the biaxial tension region, where the principal tensile stress is larger than or equal in magnitude when compared with the principal compressive stress. An experimental investigation of material behavior in the biaxial tension region is conducted. The experimental setup consists of the following test configurations: (a) notched concrete beams tested in three-point bend configuration, and (b) hollow concrete cylinders subjected to torsion.Failure of concrete in the biaxial tension region is shown to be a local phenomenon under quasi-static and fatigue loading, wherein the specimen fails owing to a single crack. The crack propagation is studied using the equivalent elastic crack concept. It is observed that the crack growth rate in constant amplitude fatigue loading exhibits a two-phase process: a deceleration phase followed by an acceleration stage. The crack growth in the acceleration stage is shown to follow Paris law. The model parameters obtained from uniaxial fatigue tests are shown to be sufficient for predicting the considered biaxial fatigue response.     

An energy method for predicting fatigue life,crack orientation,and crack growth under multiaxial loading conditions

A method based on a virtual strain-energy (VSE) concept has been shown to be effective for use in predicting multiaxial fatigue lives of two widely-used commercial alloys subjected to in-phase and out-of-phase biaxial loading conditions [1], [2]. This paper is intended to reaffirm the effectiveness of the VSE method for predicting fatigue life and to demonstrate its inherent ability of describing fatigue behavior such as crack orientations and crack growth characteristics. To this end, the basic concept of the method is briefly reintroduced and validated with fatigue data obtained from two different heats, a domestic and a foreign origin, of type 316 stainless steel subjected to cyclic torsion with static axial loading in tension or compression. Excellent agreement in general was observed between predictions and experimental results except in a case of cyclic torsion with a static compression, which appeared to show beneficial to torsional fatigue life.     

Fatigue fracture in plates in tension and out-of-plane shear

Straight cracks near a stiffening element, or curved cracks, in a pressurized shell can be subjected to out-of-plane tearing stresses in addition to normal tensile stresses due to the membrane stresses in the shell. To predict the rate of fatigue crack growth in such situations a theory and a crack growth rate correlation are needed. Such loadings are modelled as a superposition of plane stress tensile fracture (mode I) and Kirchhoff plate theory shearing fracture (mode 2). Finite element analyses using shell elements are used to compute the energy release rate and stress intensity factors associated with the loading. Three fatigue crack growth rate experiments were carried out on sheets of 2024-T3 aluminium alloy loaded in tension and torsion. The first set of experiments is constant amplitude fatigue crack growth tests. The second consists of experiments where crack closure is artificially eliminated to determine the rate of crack growth in the absence of crack face contact. The third is a set of constant stress intensity factor amplitude tests. The results all show that as the crack grows extensive crack face contact occurs, retarding crack growth. In the absence of crack face contact, however, the addition of out-of-plane shear loading increases the crack growth rate substantially.     

FATIGUE RESISTANCE OF A MEDIUM CARBON STEEL WITH A WEAR RESISTANT THERMAL SPRAY COATING

Abstract— The fatigue behaviour of a Ni-Cr-base powder flame-spray coating on a 0.4% C steel is investigated. Fatigue tests were carried out using mild hour-glass profile specimens. Cracks were detected and measured using plastic replicas and an image analysis system. Coated specimens showed a slightly lower fatigue endurance than plain specimens under torsion loading, while the opposite was observed for push-pull loading. Microcracks in coated specimens invariably form at pores.
Contrary to the usual case of stage I shear growth for a plain 0.4% C steel in tension or torsion loading, the coated specimens show initial crack growth from pores along directions perpendicular to the maximum tensile stress. The crucial behaviour of short cracks, and their growth rates, relative to the thickness of the coating, are discussed in some detail.