Evidence based practice: clinicians' use and attitudes to near patient testing in hospitals

AIM: To survey the use made of laboratory services for urgent tests and clinicians' attitudes to near patient testing. METHODS: A questionnaire was sent to clinicians working in acute hospitals within Trent and North West Thames Regions. RESULTS: 197 replies were received. Most demand came from intensive care units. Overall, clinicians requested a median of six urgent tests a day. Blood glucose and dip stick urine testing were the most commonly performed bedside tests, but 41% of clinicians did not use ward testing. The most frequently cited indication for bedside testing was the need for speed. 85% of clinicians trusted results obtained in their central hospital laboratory, but there was an almost equal division between those who did (34%) and those who did not (38%) trust the results from near patient testing. A slightly larger proportion indicated they would accept responsibility (44%) for results obtained on the ward than would not (35%). Most staff indicated that better transport to the laboratory would remove the need for near patient testing. CONCLUSIONS: Clinicians have demonstrated an apparent need for rapid response testing but there is a strong preference for rapid transport systems and central laboratory analysis rather than bedside testing as a solution to this problem. There is a need to investigate the clinical and cost-effectiveness of near patient testing as a solution to rapid response testing.     

Open-lung biopsy in the renal transplant recipient

In 22 renal transplant recipients, 23 open-lung biopsy procedures were performed. There were two (8.7%) biopsy-related complications (hemorrhage and pneumothorax) and five deaths (22.7%), although the deaths could not be definitely related to the biopsy procedure itself. Seventeen biopsy specimens yielded specific diagnoses, and six were nonspecific. The mortality rate for the patients with specific diagnoses was not significantly different from that of patients with nonspecific diagnoses (25% vs. 16.7%). Other factors analyzed, such as age, diabetes, hypoxia, leukopenia, and donor source, did not affect the result of biopsy. We conclude that the patient's underlying disease and added immunosuppressive therapy are the factors most responsible for the clinical outcome. We suggest that without early treatment of the infectious agents, the mortality rate of the group with specific diagnoses would likely have been higher.     

Value and quality of perinatal and infant postmortem examinations: cohort analysis of 400 consecutive deaths

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the contribution that perinatal and infant necropsy makes to clinical practice and to see how this might be influenced by the quality of the investigation. DESIGN: Cohort analysis, with data from the all Wales perinatal survey, of perinatal and infant deaths during 1993 of babies born to mothers usually resident in Wales. The clinicopathological classification of death based on clinical details was compared with the classification after necropsy. Similarly, cases in which necropsy yielded new information were identified. The quality of the necropsy was assessed by scoring six aspects of the examination. SUBJECTS: 400 consecutive deaths at 20 weeks of gestation to 1 year of age. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Necropsy rate, effect of necropsy on clinicopathological classification, new information disclosed by necropsy, quality of necropsies, and the link between new information and quality of the necropsy. RESULTS: Necropsy was performed in 232 cases (58%). The clinicopathological classification was altered by necropsy in 29 cases (13%). New information was obtained in 60 cases (26%), and in 42 (18%) it disclosed the cause of death. The quality of necropsy was substantially higher when the main cause of death was detected than when nothing new was found. CONCLUSION: Necropsy is underused. Clinicians should be more positive about necropsies and realise how much clinically relevant information can be obtained from a good quality examination.     

Implications of comorbidity for genetic studies of bipolar disorder: P300 and eye tracking as biological markers for illness

In large families with affective illness, identification of a biological variable is needed that reflects brain dysfunction at an earlier point than symptom development. Eye movement disorder, a possible vulnerability marker in schizophrenia, is less clearly associated with affective illness, although a subgroup of affective disorders shows smooth-pursuit eye movement disorder. The auditory P300 event-related potential may be a useful marker for risk to schizophrenia, but a role in bipolar illness is less certain. The distribution of these two biological variables and their association with symptoms in two multiply affected bipolar families is described. In a single, five-generation family identified for linkage studies through two bipolar I (BPI) probands, 128 members (including 20 spouses) were interviewed. The 108 related individuals had diagnoses of BPI (7), bipolar II (2), cyclothymia (3), or major depressive disorder (19). Eight others had generalised anxiety (1), minor depression (5), intermittent depression (1), or alcoholism (1). Sixty-nine subjects had no psychiatric diagnosis. P300 latency (81) and eye tracking (71) were recorded from a subgroup of relatives within the pedigree. Eye tracking was abnormal in 11 of 71 relatives (15.5%) and was bimodally distributed. In these 11 relatives, clinical diagnoses included minor depression (1), alcoholism (1) and generalised anxiety disorder (1). P300 latency was normally distributed and did not differ from controls. In a second family in which five of seven siblings have BPI illness, P300 latency and eye movement disorder were found in affected relatives and in some unaffected offspring. In these large families, clinical diagnoses of general anxiety, alcoholism and minor depression, when associated with eye tracking abnormality, may be considered alternative clinical manifestations of the same trait that in other relatives is expressed as bipolar illness.     

Focal epithelial hyperplasia: Heck disease

BACKGROUND: The increasing numbers of cancer patients, the high costs of terminal care, and the development of palliative care services have led to a growing interest in patterns of terminal cancer care. These patterns are relevant to the formulation and evaluation of health services policy. AIMS: To investigate trends in the place of death of South Australian cancer patients between 1981 and 1990, and to examine associations of socio-demographic and clinical variables with the place of death. METHODS: Data relating to 2715 deaths attributed to cancer in 1990 were extracted from the Central Cancer Registry. To assess trends, these data were directly standardised to the age-sex distribution of cancer deaths in 1981 and 1985 which were investigated in a previous study. Unconditional logistic regression was used to investigate predictors of place of death. RESULTS: The proportion of deaths which occurred in major metropolitan public hospitals decreased from 40% in 1981 to 28% in 1990. Conversely, the proportion which occurred in hospice units increased from 5% to 20% over the same period. There was a decline in the proportion of deaths which occurred in private hospitals, but there was no significant change in the proportion which occurred in country hospitals or nursing homes. The proportion of deaths at home remained around 14%. Associated with place of death were age, sex, type of malignancy, survival time from diagnosis to death, Aboriginality, and area of residence. Further research to assess the clinical appropriateness of terminal care patterns is suggested.     

Possible involvement of a sigma receptor subtype in the neck dystonia in rats

AIMS: (1) To establish whether gastroenterologists wish to train in abdominal ultrasound according to the Royal College of Radiologists' document, Guidance for the training in ultrasound of medical non-radiologists. (2) To determine whether the ultrasound workload generated by gastroenterologists differs from that by other clinicians. METHODS: A postal questionnaire was sent to all 278 gastroenterology trainees. The indications and findings of 100 consecutive gastroenterologist requested scans were compared with 100 scans requested sequentially by other clinicians through a teaching hospital radiology department. RESULTS: 82% of the survey forms were returned. 77% of trainees wished to train in abdominal ultrasound and 68% were prepared to train in the manner outlined in the guideline document. However, 86% felt that they would ideally prefer not to assess renal or pelvic pathology, restricting to hepatobiliary diagnosis only. 73% of trainees did not anticipate that a further scan by a radiologist would be required. Comparison of gastroenterology scans with those requested by other clinicians revealed a relative excess of hepatobiliary indications and findings, and a notable paucity of renal and pelvic pathology in gastroenterology practice. CONCLUSIONS: There is general interest in abdominal ultrasound training among gastroenterology trainees and broad acceptance of the guideline document. However, most trainees perceive a focus of training restricted to hepatobiliary disease to be most appropriate. The case mix study provides support for this viewpoint. It is suggested that a more focused ultrasound training for gastroenterologists be considered.     

Misdiagnosis of lung cancer in a 2000 consecutive autopsy study in Budapest

OBJECTIVE: To determine the accuracy of lung cancer mortality data based on clinical observations in the absence of autopsy and to identify factors affecting the accuracy of diagnosis. METHODS: Admission, pre-autopsy and post-autopsy diagnoses were recorded for 1000 consecutive autopsies in each of two University departments in Budapest with high autopsy rates for persons dying in hospital. In those 87 cases where one or more diagnosis included primary lung cancer, additional data were collected concerning clinical investigations relevant to the diagnosis and the histological type lung cancer, and on smoking habits. RESULTS: 59% (36/61) of lung cancers seen at autopsy were not detected pre-autopsy, while 50% (25/50) of those diagnosed pre-autopsy were not confirmed at autopsy. Many misdiagnoses arose because patients were too ill to be properly investigated and/or died before investigations could be completed. Accuracy of diagnosis increased with the number of diagnostic techniques applied, but was still far from perfect in the absence of necropsy. Underdiagnosis was commoner in non-smokers and overdiagnosis commoner in smokers. CONCLUSIONS: Without necropsy, lung cancer misdiagnosis is common, especially when modern diagnostic procedures cannot be fully employed. Knowledge of smoking habits may affect diagnostic accuracy.     

Analysis of physician attitudes concerning requests for autopsy

To quantify the role of failure to request consent as a determinant of the autopsy rate, questionnaires asking whether an autopsy had been requested and the reasons for that decision were distributed to primary physicians after each death in a consecutive series of 75 patient deaths. Autopsies were requested in only 56% of cases. Common reasons to request an autopsy included unanswered medical questions (37%), medical education (22%), research protocol participation (16%), or routine policy (14%). When autopsies were not requested, the most common reason was the belief that there were no outstanding medical questions (64%). Follow-up interviews with 14 oncologists and hematologists revealed that 8 generally request autopsies (usually to contribute to medical education or to discover unexpected findings) and 6 generally do not (usually because no unexpected findings are anticipated). Attempts to increase the current low autopsy rate should address the question of when and why physicians are willing to request this procedure.     

Validity of self-reported rheumatoid arthritis in elderly women

OBJECTIVE: To determine the validity of a self-reported physician diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) in elderly women. METHODS: Women with self-reported RA were contacted and permission requested to contact their physician. Physicians were mailed a questionnaire requesting information on the subject's arthritic condition. Hand radiographs obtained at study entry were read for changes of RA. RESULTS: The self-reported diagnosis of RA could be confirmed in 26 (21%) individuals. CONCLUSION: The positive predictive value of self-reported RA was low in this cohort. Caution needs to be exercised in the use and interpretation of self-report data concerning arthritic conditions in epidemiologic studies.     

Performance of four computer-based diagnostic systems

BACKGROUND: Computer-based diagnostic systems are available commercially, but there has been limited evaluation of their performance. We assessed the diagnostic capabilities of four internal medicine diagnostic systems: Dxplain, Iliad, Meditel, and QMR. METHODS: Ten expert clinicians created a set of 105 diagnostically challenging clinical case summaries involving actual patients. Clinical data were entered into each program with the vocabulary provided by the program's developer. Each of the systems produced a ranked list of possible diagnoses for each patient, as did the group of experts. We calculated scores on several performance measures for each computer program. RESULTS: No single computer program scored better than the others on all performance measures. Among all cases and all programs, the proportion of correct diagnoses ranged from 0.52 to 0.71, and the mean proportion of relevant diagnoses ranged from 0.19 to 0.37. On average, less than half the diagnoses on the experts' original list of reasonable diagnoses were suggested by any of the programs. However, each program suggested an average of approximately two additional diagnoses per case that the experts found relevant but had not originally considered. CONCLUSIONS: The results provide a profile of the strengths and limitations of these computer programs. The programs should be used by physicians who can identify and use the relevant information and ignore the irrelevant information that can be produced.     

Recent advances in skeletal-muscle-based gene therapy

OBJECTIVE: To determine the sensitivity and specificity of postmortem dementia diagnoses based on a retrospective informant interview by comparison with criterion standard neuropathological diagnoses and the results of previous clinical examinations. SETTING: Three university-based academic research centers. SUBJECTS: Fifty-four deceased elderly persons with Alzheimer disease, another dementing disorder, a neurologic disease resulting in functional impairment but no dementia, or no neurologic disorder. METHODS: Blinded nonclinician interviewers administered the Dementia Questionnaire (DQ) by telephone to informants, typically close relatives, who were familiar with the intellectual and functional status of the subjects before death. Two senior clinicians (LJ.T. and C.K.) rated each DQ for the presence or absence of a dementia syndrome during life and for the specific disorders causing the dementia, if present. Raters were blinded to the neuropathological findings and based their assessments only on data provided by responses to the DQ. Comparison was made with diagnoses based on neuropathological assessment. In most cases, the results of antemortem clinical examinations were also available as a check on the clinical diagnosis of the dementia syndrome. Sensitivity and specificity of the DQ diagnoses were computed, and chance-corrected agreement measures were calculated for the 2 independent DQ raters (LJ.T. and C.K.). RESULTS: Compared with antemortem clinical diagnosis, the average sensitivity of the DQ for the clinical syndrome of dementia was 92.8%, the specificity was 89.5%, and the interrater agreement was 98% (kappa = 0.96). Among 7 subjects with mild dementia (Mini-Mental State Examination score > or = 24 at the last clinical examination), 5 (71%) were correctly identified using the DQ. The DQ correctly indicated the absence of dementia in 8 (80%) of 10 subjects with other neurologic disorders causing functional impairment. Compared with the neuropathological diagnoses, the DQ differentiated Alzheimer disease from other primary causes of dementia with a sensitivity of 89% and a specificity of 72%. The interrater agreement was 93.8% (kappa = 0.85). CONCLUSIONS: Compared with the results of the antemortem clinical examinations, the DQ was sensitive to the presence of dementia, detected most cases of mild dementia, and discriminated dementia from other neurologic disorders causing functional impairment. Compared with the neuropathological diagnoses, the ability of the DQ to differentiate Alzheimer disease from other dementing disorders indicates that it may be useful as a research tool.     

Patient responses to request for written permission to review medical records

2,163 patients of 55 physicians in one county, were sent letters asking for their written permission to have their medical records audited by the University of Michigan research team. The overall positive response rate was 64.1% for one county. Differences in response rates were statistically significant among specialties, among diagnoses, and among individual physicians.     

An exploration of clinicians' diagnostic approaches to premenstrual symptomatology.

Explored whether non-medical clinicians and medical clinicians use a medical and/or sociocultural model to diagnose women presenting with PMS. Equal groups of female and male, Anglophone and Francophone, medical and non-medical clinicians (aged 24–82 yrs) were chosen in random samples of Quebec's professional orders. All clinicians were asked to diagnose a female patient described in a scenario as having symptoms construed to look like PMS. While 73% of the clinicians gave a PMS diagnosis, only 5% indicated that they would use prospective data to confirm their diagnosis. Clinicians who gave a PMS diagnosis explored more medical issues in the intake interview than those who did not. Medical clinicians considered more medical issues and a larger proportion of medical issues than non-medical clinicians did. Anglophone clinicians, female clinicians, and clinicians who did not diagnose PMS considered a greater number of sociocultural factors than did Francophones, males, and clinicians who did diagnose PMS. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Risk factors for major thromboembolism and bleeding tendency after elective general surgical operations. The Fragmin Multicentre Study Group

OBJECTIVE: To elucidate those factors that contribute to the risk of major postoperative thromboembolism and perioperative bleeding tendency. DESIGN: Retrospective multiple logistic regression analysis. SETTING: 7 Scandinavian hospitals (6 Swedish and 1 Norwegian). SUBJECTS: 2070 patients undergoing elective major abdominal surgery. INTERVENTIONS: Patients were randomised to receive 2500 or 5000 XaI units of low molecular weight heparin daily. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Major thromboembolism (proximal deep vein thrombosis confirmed by phlebography or necropsy, or pulmonary embolism confirmed by scintigraphy or necropsy, or both). Bleeding tendency (bleeding complications which were not explained by local haemorrhagic lesions or by coexisting disease). RESULTS: Previous thromboembolism, leg fracture or arthroplasty, present leg ulcer or malignant disease, operating time longer than 150 minutes, preoperative transfusion of 2 or more units, and preoperative hospital stay of 6 days or more (but not age, body weight, or varicose veins) were independent predictors for major postoperative thromboembolism. The risk was significantly increased with an increasing number of such risk factors. The risk of developing a diffuse bleeding complication was dependent on the dose of low molecular weight heparin, particularly in patients without risk factors. CONCLUSIONS: The use of a narrow definition of thromboembolism lead to a pattern of risk factors which was partly different from that found in previous studies, which were usually based on diagnosis with the 125I-fibrinogen uptake test.     

The relationship between panic disorder and major depression. A new family study

OBJECTIVE: The comorbidity between panic disorder and major depression (MDD) in individuals has been amply documented. However, data from family studies to determine whether panic disorder and MDD aggregate separately or together in families have been inconclusive, in part because of the absence of studies with the full range of proband groups. This report presents results from a family study with the necessary mutually exclusive groups: panic disorder without MDD, panic disorder with MDD, MDD without panic disorder, and normal controls. METHODS: Diagnostic information was obtained from 193 probands and 1047 of their adult relatives with the Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia--Lifetime Version for Anxiety Disorders by direct interview, and/or from multiple informants, without knowledge of proband diagnoses. Best-estimate diagnoses were based on all available information by clinicians independently of data collection and without knowledge of probands' and other relatives' status. RESULTS: Findings indicated the specific and independent transmission of panic disorder and MDD, the separation of panic disorder from MDD, and the nonfamilial nature of late-onset MDD. The pattern of results was unaffected by the use of different diagnostic criteria, number of informants, interview status of relatives, presence of substance abuse or agoraphobia or the sequence of MDD and panic disorder in probands, or whether probands were selected from treatment clinics or community sample. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that panic disorder and MDD are separate disorders with substantial co-occurrence in individuals, and that panic comorbid with MDD is not a single, distinct disorder. Finally, we illustrate an approach to examining comorbidity in family data through analysis of mutually exclusive, parallel diagnoses in probands and relatives.     

Measuring expressed emotion: An evaluation of the shortcuts.

The construct of expressed emotion (EE) is a highly reliable and valid predictor of poor clinical outcomes in patients with major psychopathology. Patients are at early risk for relapse if they live with family members who are classified as high in EE. Conventionally, EE is assessed with the Camberwell Family Interview (CFI), a semistructured interview that is conducted with the patient's key relatives. Unfortunately, training in the CFI is difficult to obtain. The CFI is also time-consuming to administer and labor intensive to rate. In this article, the authors discuss alternative ways of assessing EE. They also evaluate the predictive validity of these measures and make recommendations for researchers and clinicians interested in using these assessments. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Neural tube defects among twin births

To obtain accurate, unbiased rates of neural tube defects (NTDs) in twins, we conducted a population-based study that included live births and fetal deaths in Los Angeles County, California, ascertaining cases by multiple methods. Twenty-eight twin cases yielded a prevalence-at-birth of 1.6/1,000 twin births, which is significantly higher than the singleton prevalence of 1.1/1,000 births. In twins compared with singletons, the prevalences of both encephalocele and anencephaly are increased, whereas spina bifida is decreased. The twin case male/female sex ratio (.55) is lower than the singleton case sex ratio (.77). Concordance is relatively low at 3.7%, but appears to be higher than recently reported recurrence risks in other low prevalence areas. Stillbirths were most common among female cases and like-sex twins. Our study tends to support proposed etiologic theories associating NTDs with females or monozygotic twins, or both. There is increasing evidence that the etiology of NTDs may differ in high and low prevalence areas. We suggest also that twins and singletons may differ in their response to etiologic factors. The variations among anencephaly, spina bifida, and encephalocele in their association with twinning suggest that there may be different factors that influence the development of each specific NTD. The noted differences among the malformations also indicate that some of the variation among results of other studies of NTDs and twinning may be due to case ascertainment. Including spina bifida cases would decrease the proportion of twins in a study population, while including anencephalics would increase the proportion. Importantly, ascertaining fetal deaths would increase the proportion of anencephalics and case females, so studies of NTDs that do not include fetal deaths will show fewer twins than expected. On the basis of our findings and those of Layde et al., excluding encephaloceles will also decrease the number of twins among NTD cases. When investigating etiologic hypotheses for NTDs, these potential biases must be recognized.     

The Science Information Exchange: A clearinghouse for current research.

A plethora of research makes it imperative for the scientist to know what has been done in his field and what is being done at present. To avoid duplication of efforts, he may also wish to get information on current grants and intramural projects. He may want to get in touch with fellow researchers whose interests coincide with his own. The Science Information Exchange (SIE) can supply him with this information. The SIE's unique mission is to make available information on current research either in the form of statistical data to agencies or through the investigator's own words, the summary which he has prepared for the Notice of Research Projects. The researcher is requested to omit confidential data, and the recipient of the summary is advised that he must not use the information for quotation or reference without the written permission of the principal investigator. The SIE maintains a professional and clerical staff to cope with the mammoth undertaking of storing and retrieving information on current research. The Exchange provides a valuable tool, but it is up to the scientific community to participate through registration and use, and thus insure maximum coverage of all fields of scientific endeavor. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Multicenter transverse study of the neurological ambulatory care in the Spanish Health System in Aragon: overall results

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate clinical, diagnostic and therapeutic aspects and how the Neurology Outpatient Departments of Aragon work in practice. MATERIAL AND METHODS: For three consecutive months all patients attending the Neurology Outpatient Departments of the Health Areas of the Health Service of Aragón for the first time were given a specially designed questionnaire. RESULTS: The majority of the patients were women (57%). The average age was 51.5 +/- 20.6 years. The family doctor referred 79.5% of the patients. The average waiting time for patients to be seen was 12.4 +/- 10.7 days. Further investigations were requested in 48.9% of the patients (cerebral CT in 18.1%, MR in 2.6%, EEG in 12% and ENG-EMG in 6.8%). The commonest diagnoses were headache (25.5%), cerebrovascular pathology (12.5%), extrapyramidal pathology (7.5%), syncope (6.5%), convulsions (6%), vertigo (5.9%), psychiatric disorders (5%), non-neurological disorders (4.4%). No treatment was given to 15.64% of the patients attending for the first time. The commonest drugs used were: calcium antagonists (32.5%), platelet antiaggregants (20.9%), antidepressives (17%), antiepileptic drugs (15.6%) and NSAIDS (5.3%). CONCLUSIONS: There is a considerable demand for neurological consultations and there are few neurologists in proportion to the population. Better selection of the patients sent for consultation and a better understanding by family doctors of the commoner neurological disorders would considerably reduce the number of patients sent to the Outpatient Department.