Dry versus wet aging of beef: Retail cutting yields and consumer sensory attribute evaluations of steaks from ribeyes, strip loins, and top sirloins from two quality grade groups

Top Choice (n=48) and Select (n=48) paired bone-in ribeye rolls, bone-in strip loins, and boneless top sirloin butts were assigned randomly to one of two aging treatments, dry or wet, and were aged for 14, 21, 28 or 35d. Cutting tests, performed to determine retail yields and processing times, showed dry-aged subprimals had lower total saleable yield percentages and increased processing times compared to wet-aged subprimals. Sensory and Warner-Bratzler shear evaluation was conducted to determine palatability characteristics. For the most part, aging treatment and aging period did not affect consumer sensory attributes. However, ribeye and top loin steaks from the Top Choice quality grade group received higher sensory ratings than their Select counterparts. For top sirloin steaks, no consumer sensory attributes were affected by aging treatment, aging period, or quality grade group.     

National beef tenderness survey - 2006: Assessment of Warner-Bratzler shear and sensory panel ratings for beef from US retail and foodservice establishments

Beef from retail and foodservice establishments in 11 US cities was evaluated using Warner-Bratzler shear (WBS) and consumer evaluation panels. Postmortem aging times ranged from 3 to 83d for retail and 7 to 136d for foodservice with mean aging times of 22.6d and 30.1d, respectively. For retail, the three cuts from the round - top round, bottom round, and eye of round - had the highest (P<0.05) WBS values compared to cuts from the chuck, rib, and loin. Top loin steaks had the lowest (P<0.05) WBS value compared to ribeye and top sirloin foodservice steaks. Retail bone-in top loin, top loin, ribeye, T-bone, and porterhouse received the highest (P<0.05) ratings by consumers for overall like and like tenderness. Quality grade had little or no effect on foodservice sensory evaluations. Improvements in round tenderness are needed to increase consumer acceptability.     

Tenderness of major muscles from three breed-types of cattle at different times-on-feed

Seventy-five steers (9 to 12 months of age) of Angus (n = 25), Brahman (n = 25) and Brahman × Angus (n = 25) breed-types of known history were fed a high-energy diet and five steers from each breed-type were slaughtered after 0, 56, 112, 168 and 224 days on test. At seven days post mortem, the left side of each carcass was fabricated and eight major primals or subprimals were obtained. Steaks were removed from the shoulder clod, strip loin, tenderloin, top sirloin, knuckle, top round, bottom round and eye of round for Warner-Bratzler shear (WBS) determinations and from the strip loin and bottom round for sensory panel evaluations. Steaks from Angus and Brahman × Angus steers were generally more tender than steaks from Brahman steers. Tenderness of steaks from steers of the three breed-types responded to time-on-feed differently: (a) steaks from Brahman steers improved (P < 0·05) in tenderness with increasing time-on-feed for all muscles except the M. psoas major (tenderloin); (b) with the exception of the M. longissimus muscle (strip loin), the tenderness of steaks from Angus steers did not change (P > 0·05) as time-on-feed increased and (c) for the Brahman × Angus steers, five of the ten muscles studied improved (P < 0·05) in tenderness with increasing time-on-feed. 'Acceptable' tenderness (WBS values of less than 4·5 kg) for most of the muscles was achieved at feeding periods from 112 to 224 days for Brahman, from 0 to 56 days for Angus and from 56 to 168 days for Brahman × Angus.     

Impact of price and thickness on consumer selection of ribeye, sirloin, and top loin steaks

Consumers (n=316) were recruited from college football picnickers to select ribeye, sirloin, and top loin steaks from 3 price groups based on thickness (n=10 steaks per price/type combination). Constant weight steaks were assigned to these groups: P1, thinnest, $19.80/kg ribeye and top loin, $10.99/kg sirloin; P2, average thickness, $22.00/kg ribeye and top loin, $13.19/kg sirloin; P3, thickest, $24.21/kg ribeye and top loin, $15.40/kg sirloin. Consumers selected 3 steaks per type and ranked selection criteria (price, color, marbling, thickness, texture). Percentage of steaks chosen from each price group did not differ (P>0.05), but consumers tended to select thinner ribeye steaks (P1 and P2) and thicker sirloin steaks (P2 and P3). Across all steak types, a greater number of consumers reported that marbling, color, and thickness were more important than price and visual texture. Data indicate that consumers may select steaks that display their preferred attributes, even if the steaks cost more.     

Quality of Restructured Steaks: Effects of Days on Feed, Fat Level, and Cooking Method

Top rounds from steers fed grain 0, 28, or 56 days were flaked and formed into restructured steaks containing 15, 20, or 25% fat. Steaks were cooked on a browning dish in a microwave oven or broiled. Microwave-heated steaks appeared more well done, were less tender, released less moisture, and had greater cooking losses and penetration hardness and chewiness than broiled steaks. As fat level increased, tenderness, moisture release, and greasiness increased. Length of time on grain influenced Warner-Bratzler shear values but did not affect sensory scores. Results of the study suggest that the use of meat from grain-fed animals in the production of restructured steaks is feasible.     

Physical, chemical, histological and palatability characteristics of muscles from three breed-types of cattle at different times-on-feed

Forty-five steers (9-12 months of age) of Angus (n =15), Brahman (n = 15) and Brahman × Angus (n = 15) breed-types were fed a high-energy diet and then slaughtered after 0, 112 or 224 days of feeding. At 7 days post mortem, the M. longissimus and M. biceps femoris were removed from the left side of each carcass and steaks were obtained for determination of sensory panel ratings, Warner-Bratzler shear force, sarcomere length, collagen content and collagen solubility. Tenderness ratings of steaks from the M. longissimus and M. biceps femoris from Angus were generally higher than ratings for steaks from Brahman or Brahman × Angus steers. Steaks from Brahman × Angus received higher tenderness ratings than steaks from Brahman steers in only a few comparisons. The three breed-types of cattle responded to time-on-feed differently; Brahman cattle needed to have been fed longer than Angus cattle to produce equally tender beef. With increased time-on-feed, M. longissimus tenderness increased for all breed-types, but M. biceps femoris tenderness was not related to time-on-feed. Few significant differences were observed among breed-types and among time-on-feed periods for collagen content or collagen solubility. Tenderness differences were closely correlated with the contractile state of the muscle which, in turn, was associated with weight, subcutaneous fat thickness and temperature decline of the carcass.     

The influence of mechanical tenderization on the palatability of certain bovine muscles

Twelve different muscles or muscle groups were removed from both sides of 25 Canada AA beef carcasses. Muscles or muscle groups from alternate carcass sides were either mechanically tenderized or served as controls. Mechanical tenderization increased thaw-drip losses from the brisket approximately 1.25% and cooking losses from the blade eye by approximately 2.75%, but did not influence cooking times. Mechanical tenderization also improved initial and overall tenderness of the outside round, top sirloin, striploin, inside round and chuck tender. In addition initial tenderness of the sirloin tip eye and overall tenderness of the eye of the round were improved by mechanical tenderization. Moreover, connective issue in the top sirloin, striploin, and eye of the round was less perceptible after mechanical tenderization, but juiciness was decreased in the blade eye and top sirloin. Flavor intensity of the top sirloin and rib-eye was also reduced by mechanical tenderization. However, the desirability of the flavor of the inside round was improved by mechanical tenderization and the overall palatability of the inside round and eye of the round improved with mechanical tenderization. Mechanical tenderization decreased the proportion of inside round samples rated tough initially and overall from 52 to 20% and from 36 to 12% respectively. Mechanical tenderization also reduced the proportion of outside round samples perceived to contain a slight or greater amount of connective tissue from 36 to 12%. In addition, mechanical tenderization reduced the proportion of inside round samples with undesirable flavor from 16 to 0% and reduced the proportion of unpalatable rib-eye, inside round, and eye of the round samples from 12 to 0, 36 to 8 and 80 to 40%, respectively. Consequently, mechanical tenderization can be effectively utilized to reduce the variability and improve the tenderness and palatability of certain muscles, particularly hip muscles.     

On-line classification of US Select beef carcasses for longissimus tenderness using visible and near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy

The current experiment was conducted to evaluate the on-line application of visible and near-infrared spectroscopy (VISNIR) to US Select carcasses during commercial beef carcass grading procedures to predict tenderness of longissimus steaks after 14 days of refrigerated storage. A regression model was calibrated using 146 carcasses and tested against an additional 146 carcasses. Carcasses were segregated into VISNIR-based tenderness classes based on whether their VISNIR-predicted slice shear force value was less than (tender) or greater than (tough) the median predicted slice shear force value. Carcasses classified as tender by VISNIR had a lower mean SSF value, were less likely to have slice shear force values greater than 245 N, had higher trained sensory panel tenderness ratings, and were less likely to have trained sensory panel tenderness ratings below slightly tender than were carcasses classified as tough (P<0.001). This technology might be useful for identification of US Select carcasses that excel in longissimus tenderness.     

Effects of cooking beef muscles from frozen or thawed states on cooking traits and palatability

Biceps femoris and longissimus lumborum steaks were cooked from either a frozen or thawed state on an electric belt grill (TBG-60 MagiKitch'n Inc., Quakertown, PA) at 93?°C to the endpoint temperature of 70?°C. Cooking loss, cooking time, Warner-Bratzler shear force (WBSF), and color (Illuminant A, L(?), a(?), b(?)) were evaluated. Trained panelists (n=6) evaluated palatability attributes on an eight-point scale for myofibrillar tenderness, juiciness, flavor, overall tenderness, and connective tissue amount (1=extremely tough, dry, bland, tough, and abundant; 8=extremely tender, juicy, intense, tender, and none). L(?), a(?), WBSF, juiciness, flavor, connective tissue amount, and overall tenderness did not differ (P>0.05) between steaks cooked from frozen and thawed states. However, thawed steaks cooked faster and had lower cooking losses than frozen steaks. The biceps femoris had higher WBSF values than the longissimus lumborum and was rated less tender by trained panelists. L(?), a(?), or b(?) values did not differ (P>0.05) between muscles. The biceps femoris needed more time to cook and had greater cooking losses than longissimus lumborum. Dimensional changes of steaks cooked to either 60 or 70?°C were studied. The width of biceps femoris steaks decreased 12.2%, and width of longissimus lumborum decreased 6.3%. Longissimus lumborum steaks became shorter (P<0.01) than biceps femoris steaks. Thickness of biceps femoris steaks decreased 25.6%, and thickness of longissimus lumborum steaks decreased 23.3%. Muscle type had a more pronounced effect on dimensional changes of steaks than endpoint temperature.     

Consumer Acceptance of Steaks and Roasts from Charolais Crossbred Bulls and Steers

Forty-eight Charolais bulls (n=24) and steers (n=24) were commercially fed, slaughtered and subprimals were distributed to three retail stores. Consumers were able to detect differences in tenderness for steaks from the rib, loin and top sirloin of bulls and steers, but not for steaks or roasts from the round (except for the eye of round steak) and chuck of bulls and steers. However, 91.7% and 86.8% of the consumers of steaks from steers and bulls, respectively, indicated that they would purchase similar steaks again while 92.3% and 93.2% of the consumers of roasts indicated they would purchase similar roasts from steers and bulls, respectively.     

IDENTIFICATION OF THRESHOLD LEVELS FOR WARNER-BRATZLER SHEAR FORCE IN BEEF TOP LOIN STEAKS

Threshold Warner-Bratzler shear (WBS) values were determined by regression analysis of WBS force values and trained sensory panel overall tenderness ratings of beef top loin steaks from A- and B-maturity carcasses (n = 678). Guidelines for retail and foodservice beef were based on 50 and 68% confidence levels, respectively, for overall tenderness ratings of "slightly tender." Due to the extreme variation in tenderness that exists in the current U.S. beef population, more stringent confidence levels were not practical. Threshold WBS values for retail and foodservice beef were 4.6 and 3.9 kg, respectively. When these values were tested against the population of beef in the National Consumer Retail Beef Study, the 4.6 kg value was 88.6% accurate at determining whether or not a steak would be rated less than "slightly tender"by consumers.     

Establishing tenderness thresholds of Venezuelan beef steaks using consumer and trained sensory panels

The tenderness thresholds for ribeye steaks at 2 d postmortem were found by using sensory trained (n = 734 steaks) and consumers panel data (55 ribeye steaks and 296 consumers). Also, consumers’ perceptions of sensory attributes of beef steaks were assessed to establish their relationships and to determine acceptability levels. The tenderness threshold obtained by regression analysis from trained panelists was 37.98 N (3.87 kg). Customer satisfaction of 81% was obtained when beef steaks had Warner-Bratzler shear force values (WBSF) less than 40.13 N (4.09 kg), suggesting that 40.13 N could be considered as a tenderness threshold to segregate tough from tender steaks, for Venezuelan beef consumers. According to correlation and regression analyses, consumers focused on flavor to assign their overall liking score. Results suggest that consumers are able to detect changes in tenderness of steaks with different WBSF and that flavor drives customer satisfaction when the beef tenderness is acceptable.     

APPLICATION OF ACTINIDIN FROM KIWIFRUIT TO MEAT TENDERIZATION AND CHARACTERIZATION OF BEEF MUSCLE PROTEIN HYDROLYSIS

The effect of actinidin on the tenderness of broiled bovine semitendinosus (ST) steaks was studied. An actinidin activity of 400 U/mL resulted in Kramer shear values and sensory tenderness scores equivalent to that produced by Adolph's papain-based meat tenderizer (18 U/mL). Both were significantly (P<0.05) more tender than steaks having no tenderizing treatment. Actinidin did not over-tenderize the steak surface as did Adolph's meat tenderizer. Hydrolysis of myofibrillar proteins in enzyme-treated steaks prior to broiling was considerably less for actinidin than for papain when using activities to attain equal Kramer shear values of broiled steaks.     

INCREASING THE TENDERNESS OF BULLOCK BEEF BY USE OF ANTEMORTEM ENZYME INJECTION

Steaks from 58 beef carcasses were used to determine the effects of antemortem injections of proteolytic enzyme in increasing tenderness and/or in reducing tenderness variability among bullock carcasses. Sensory panel ratings indicated that steaks from the carcasses of treated bullocks did not differ significantly from steaks from treated steer carcasses in tenderness or overall satisfaction, but were significantly more tender and satisfactory overall than steaks from untreated bullocks. Variation in tenderness scores within the group of steaks from treated bullocks was reduced to a level more nearly comparable to that of steaks from treated steers. Since antemortem injections of papain increased tenderness and reduced the variability in tenderness among steaks from bullock carcasses, such treatment could be used to more effectively merchandise beef from young bulls.     

Influence of vacuum-aging period on bloom development of the beef gluteus medius from top sirloin butts

The gluteus medius (GM) from USDA Select beef carcasses was used to test the effect of aging period on bloom development. Top sirloin butts (IMPS #184) were randomly allocated to 0, 7, 14, 21, 28, and 35 d vacuum-aging at 2 °C (n = 10/aging period). Each week, aged top sirloin butts were faced before two 2.5-cm-thick, non-adjacent steaks were cut and instrumental color (L^∗, a^∗, and b^∗) of the GM was measured at 10-min intervals for 2 h after cutting. Steaks aged for 7 and 14 d were a more vivid (greater chroma values; P < 0.05), redder (greater a^∗ values; P < 0.05), and more yellow (greater b^∗ values; P < 0.05) color than steaks from the other aging periods. Change in total color (ΔE) was greater (P < 0.05) for steaks from top sirloin butts aged 7, 14, and 21 d than steaks from top butts aged 28 and 35 d, whereas oxymyoglobin percentages for steaks from top butts aged 7 and 14 days were greater (P < 0.05) than those from top sirloin butts aged 28 and 35 d. As much as 90% of the total increase (P < 0.05) in a^∗, b^∗, and chroma values, as well as hue angles and oxymyoglobin percentages, was achieved during the first 60 min after cutting.     

Determination of sensory, chemical and cooking characteristics of retail beef cuts differing in intramuscular and external fat

Top loin (TLS), top sirloin (TSS), and eye of round (EYS) steaks, and loin end (LRR) and blade end (BRR) rib, and eye of round (EYR) roasts were used to determine the effect of USDA quality grade, Choice or Select, external fat trim level, and internal temperature endpoint on sensory, chemical and cooking characteristics. Cuts cooked with external fat required slightly greater cooking times and had higher fat content in the lean than cuts cooked without external fat (p < 0.05). Regardless of quality grade or external fat trim, increasing internal temperature endpoint resulted in tougher, drier cuts with longer cooking times and greater cooking loss (p < 0.05). Choice TLS, TSS and LRR were higher (p < 0.05) in palatability than Select, but quality grade did not affect palatability of BRR, EYS or EYR.     

Color stability and tenderness variations within the gluteus medius from beef top sirloin butts

Beef top sirloin butts (n = 48) from USDA quality grade (QG; upper 2/3 US Choice vs. US Select) and yield grade categories (YG; 1 and 2 vs. 4 and 5) were aged 14 days, GM steaks were cut, with 2 steaks removed from the anterior (ANT), middle (MID) and posterior (POST) sections of the GM. One steak from each section was cut into lateral (LAT), central (CENT) and medial (MED) portions, packaged aerobically, and displayed for 7 days, whereas the second steaks were cooked to 71 °C for WBSF. Top Choice-steaks were redder and more yellow (P < 0.05) than Select steaks during display. Cooking losses were greatest (P < 0.05) in the MED, and least (P < 0.05) in the CENT, portions of GM steaks. Neither QG nor YG category affected WBSF, but differences within the GM were found for (P < 0.05) WBSF. Results of this experiment indicate tenderness and color stability gradients exist within the GM.     

Predicting beef tenderness using color and multispectral image texture features

The objective of this study was to investigate the usefulness of raw meat surface characteristics (texture) in predicting cooked beef tenderness. Color and multispectral texture features, including 4 different wavelengths and 217 image texture features, were extracted from 2 laboratory-based multispectral camera imaging systems. Steaks were segregated into tough and tender classification groups based on Warner–Bratzler shear force. The texture features were submitted to STEPWISE multiple regression and support vector machine (SVM) analyses to establish prediction models for beef tenderness. A subsample (80%) of tender or tough classified steaks were used to train models which were then validated on the remaining (20%) test steaks. For color images, the SVM model correctly identified tender steaks with 100% accurately while the STEPWISE equation identified 94.9% of the tender steaks correctly. For multispectral images, the SVM model predicted 91% and STEPWISE predicted 87% average accuracy of beef tender.     

Predicting beef tenderness using color and multispectral image texture features

The objective of this study was to investigate the usefulness of raw meat surface characteristics (texture) in predicting cooked beef tenderness. Color and multispectral texture features, including 4 different wavelengths and 217 image texture features, were extracted from 2 laboratory-based multispectral camera imaging systems. Steaks were segregated into tough and tender classification groups based on Warner-Bratzler shear force. The texture features were submitted to STEPWISE multiple regression and support vector machine (SVM) analyses to establish prediction models for beef tenderness. A subsample (80%) of tender or tough classified steaks were used to train models which were then validated on the remaining (20%) test steaks. For color images, the SVM model correctly identified tender steaks with 100% accurately while the STEPWISE equation identified 94.9% of the tender steaks correctly. For multispectral images, the SVM model predicted 91% and STEPWISE predicted 87% average accuracy of beef tender.     

CONSUMER EVALUATION OF THE PALATABILITY OF USDA SELECT,USDA CHOICE AND CERTIFIED ANGUS BEEF STRIP LOIN STEAKS FROM RETAIL MARKETS IN LUBBOCK,TEXAS, U.S.A.

ABSTRACT

Select, Choice and Certified Angus Beef (CAB) strip loin steaks were sold in Lubbock, TX to determine consumer acceptability. A home survey was attached to each package of steaks (return = 191 steak evaluations). Consumers did not detect differences in tenderness or flavor, but rated CAB steaks juicier (P < 0.05) than Select or Choice. However, 68% of CAB consumers rated steaks as extremely or very tender, but less than half rated Choice and Select steaks the same way. Consumer tenderness and flavor scores for Select steaks were more variable, but consumer satisfaction and tenderness acceptability did not differ (P > 0.05) between grades. Trained sensory panelists rated CAB steaks higher (P < 0.05) than Choice or Select for all palatability traits except flavor intensity. Shear force decreased (P < 0.05) by quality grade as CAB steaks sheared with the least resistance. These results showed marbling influenced objective palatability measures and decreased the variation in both objective and consumer measures of palatability.

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS

Quality grades were established to predict beef palatability, but marbling can be an unreliable predictor of tenderness. Branded beef programs, such as Certified Angus Beef (CAB), have been developed to distinguish higher palatability products and provide more consistent products for consumers. Consumers can distinguish between levels beef tenderness and are willing to pay a premium for tender beef. Moreover, consumers find product consistency is moderately important when purchasing fresh beef. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to determine consumer acceptability based on in‐home evaluations of strip loin steaks from United States Department of Agriculture Select and Choice grades and CAB purchased from a retail supermarket environment.