Impact of muscle type and sodium chloride concentration on the quality, sensory, and instrumental color characteristics of solution enhanced whole-muscle beef

Beef biceps femoris (n = 10; muscle sections, n = 20; BF), infraspinatus (n = 10; muscle sections, n = 20; IS), and longissimus (n = 10; muscle sections, n = 20; LM) muscles were utilized to evaluate the effect of enhancement with phosphate and varying levels of sodium chloride in beef muscles differing in composition and palatability. Muscles were untreated or solution enhanced to 112% of raw product weight with sodium tripolyphosphate at 0.4% of product weight (STPP), or STPP and sodium chloride (NaCl) at 0.5%, 1.0% or 1.5% of product weight. There was a quadratic relationship (P = 0.04) for percent free water to decrease and a linear relationship (P < 0.01) for cook yield to increase as the level of NaCl increased. The IS steaks required less (P < 0.05) shear force than either the BF or LM, with the BF and LM having similar (P > 0.05) shear force values. There was a linear relationship (P < 0.01) for shear force values to decrease with increasing salt concentration. Steaks from all four enhancement treatments had lower (P < 0.05) shear force values than untreated steaks. Sensory overall tenderness ratings revealed that the IS and LM were similar (P > 0.05) and superior (P < 0.05) to the BF in tenderness. Steaks enhanced with STPP and 0.5%, 1.0%, or 1.5% NaCl all were rated more tender (P < 0.05) than untreated or STPP-only treated steaks. The BF exhibited the lowest (P < 0.05) L* (lightness) and a* (redness) values, as well as decreased (P < 0.05) vividness. The LM generally exhibited superior color to the other two muscle types. There was a linear relationship (P < 0.01) for L*, a*, b* (yellowness) values, and vividness to decline with increasing salt concentration, but steaks enhanced with STPP and 0.5% NaCl were similar (P > 0.05) in a* values and vividness to untreated steaks. These results suggest that across three different muscles varying in composition and palatability, enhancement with 0.4% STPP and 0.5% NaCl allowed for improvements in palatability while minimizing the color deterioration associated with phosphate/salt enhancement.     

Influences of dietary conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) and total lysine content on growth, carcass characteristics and meat quality of heavy pigs

To assess the effects of dietary CLA, lysine and sex on performance, blood metabolites, carcass characteristics, meat quality and skeletal development, seventy-two pigs (initially 105.3 ± 6.6 kg live weight) barrows and gilts, were assigned to one of four diets in a 2 × 2 × 2 factorial arrangement. The diets contained 0% or 0.75% CLA, and 0% or 0.16% of l-lysine–HCl. All pigs were slaughtered at an average weight of 153.4 ± 11.0 kg. Neither CLA nor lysine supplementation influenced growth, blood metabolites or carcass characteristics. CLA reduced (P < 0.05) pH₂₄ and increased (P < 0.01) yellowness (b^*) of the Longissimus muscle. Lysine increased (P < 0.01) pH₂₄ and reduced (P < 0.01) muscle ash content. CLA reduced (P < 0.05) collagen synthesis, and lysine increased (P < 0.05) collagen synthesis in Longissimus muscle, but no influence on intramuscular collagen maturity or muscle hydroxylysylpyridinoline crosslink concentration were observed. In addition, metacarpal bone diameter was reduced (P < 0.05) by CLA. Barrows had higher ADG, final weight (P < 0.01), carcass weight, lean percentage (P < 0.05), serum cholesterol (P < 0.05) and triacylglycerol (P < 0.001) than gilts. Metatarsal diameter was larger in gilts than barrows (P < 0.05).     

The effect of production system and age on concentrations of fatty acids in intramuscular fat of the longissimus and triceps brachii muscles of Angus-cross heifers

The concentrations of fatty acids were measured in intramuscular fat from the longissimus lumborum (LL) and triceps brachii (TB) muscles of Angus-cross heifers finished either on a high-concentrate ration in Washington, USA, (US cattle, n = 15) or on pasture in New Zealand (NZ cattle, n = 16). Half of the NZ cattle were of a similar age to the US cattle (NZAge) and half were of a similar weight (NZWt). Intramuscular fat levels were higher for the LL muscle and for the US cattle but only within the LL muscle (P < 0.05). Aspects of the fatty-acid patterns that are of relevance to human nutrition tended to favour the pasture-finished NZ cattle with lower n − 6/n − 3 fatty acid ratios (P < 0.001), higher concentrations of an anticarcinogenic conjugated linoleic acid (C18:2 c9,t11) (P < 0.05) and its precursor (trans-vaccenic acid, TVA) (P < 0.01), and lower levels of the 18-carbon trans monounsaturated fatty acids other than TVA (P < 0.01). Concentrations of 20 of the 22 fatty acids analysed differed significantly between the two muscles. When values were adjusted to a common intramuscular fat level by covariance, most of the group differences remained, but a number of the muscle differences became non-significant. For almost half the fatty acids considered, there was a significant interaction between treatment group and muscle, which indicates that the results for one muscle do not necessarily apply to other muscles, although the ranking of the groups was usually the same for both muscles.     

Fatty acids and tocopherol levels in M. Longissimus dorsi of beef cattle in Sweden - A comparison between seasonal diets

This study investigated the influence of Swedish outdoor feeding systems on the fatty acid composition and tocopherol content of M. Longissimus dorsi from beef. Dietary effects of pasture (PA), silage, and silage supplemented with grain (SIG) were compared. Each dietary group consisted of six animals. Higher levels (P < 0.05) of polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) were found in the PA treatment. The n − 6/n − 3 fatty acid ratio of total lipids in the muscle tissue was in the range 1.2–1.5. The SIG treatment increased the n − 6/n − 3 ratio and decreased the total PUFA content of muscle tissue. The lipid class composition and the content of -tocopherol in the meat showed no differences among treatments.     

Augmented postmortem glycolysis does not occur early postmortem in AMPKγ3-mutated porcine muscle of halothane positive pigs

The objective of this study was to determine the effects of the halothane (HAL) and Rendement Napole (RN) genes on the rate-limiting reactions of glycolysis and their relationship to pork quality development. Samples were collected from the longissimus muscle at 0, 30, 60, and 120 min and 24 h postmortem from homozygous HAL and RN pigs (NN/rn⁺rn⁺, NN/RN⁻RN⁻, nn/rn⁺rn⁺, nn/RN⁻RN⁻). Muscle pH was recorded at 0, 15, and 45 min, and 24 h postmortem. HAL mutants, compared with HAL normal, had lower (P < 0.05) ATP concentrations at 0 and 30 min, lower (P < 0.05) pH at 45 min, and hastened glycogen degradation and lactate accumulation in the first 120 min postmortem (HAL × time, P < 0.0001). RN mutants had greater (P < 0.0001) glycolytic potentials than RN normal, and lower (P < 0.05) 24 h pH compared with the normal genotype, but not the HAL mutant genotype. The HAL mutation negatively affected (P < 0.05) L*, b* and color scores whereas both HAL and RN mutations independently decreased (P < 0.05) firmness, marbling and water holding capacity. RN mutant genotypes had higher (P < 0.0001) phosphocreatine concentrations than other genotypes at 0 min. Compared with HAL normal, HAL mutants had elevated (P < 0.05) muscle glucose concentrations at 30, 60, and 120 min, and 24 h. RN mutants had higher (P < 0.05) glucose levels than RN normal after 60 min. Glucose-6-phosphate (G6P) concentrations decreased (P < 0.05) during the first hour postmortem except in HAL/RN mutants, which had higher (P < 0.01) G6P concentrations than all other genotypes at 30 min. From 60 min to 24 h postmortem, G6P increased (P < 0.05) in HAL normal genotypes. Altogether, these data show that elevated muscle glycogen content does not further aggravate rapid early postmortem metabolism.     

Influence of dietary inclusion level of manganese on pork quality during retail display

Boneless pork loins (n = 112) were used to test the influence of dietary manganese (Mn) inclusion level on pork quality traits during retail display. Crossbred barrows and gilts were fed diets formulated with 0, 20, 40, 80, 160, or 320 ppm Mn from Availa^®Mn (AvMn; a Mn–amino acid complex) from 23.8 to 106.8 kg live weight. At approximately 48 h postmortem, boneless pork loins were fabricated into longissimus thoracis et lumborum (LM) chops, which were subsequently placed in open-topped, coffin-chest display cases (2.6 °C) under continuous warm-white, fluorescent lighting (1600 lx) for 7 days. Dietary Mn level had no effect on LM pH (P = 0.47), purge volume (P = 0.60) and loss (P = 0.53), or moisture loss (P = 0.95) during retail display. Chops from pigs fed 80 ppm Mn received higher (P < 0.05) American and Japanese color scores than pigs fed 0 and 40 ppm Mn. Even though the LM from pigs fed 80, 160, and 320 ppm Mn tended to be darker (lower L^* values; P = 0.07) than chops from pigs fed 40 ppm Mn, a^* (redness) and b^* (yellowness) values, as well as hue angle and chroma, were not (P  0.19) affected by dietary Mn. On days 0 and 1, the reflectance ratio of 630 nm/580 nm was similar (P > 0.05) among dietary Mn supplementation levels; yet, by day 4 of retail display, chops from pigs fed 80 ppm Mn had higher (P < 0.05) reflectance ratios than chops from pigs fed 0, 20, 40, and 160 ppm, whereas LM chops from pigs fed 40 ppm Mn had lower (P < 0.05) reflectance ratios than all other dietary treatments on day 7 (Mn supplementation level × display day; P = 0.04). Although TBARS were greater (P < 0.001) on day 7 than 0 of retail display, TBARS values did not (P = 0.43) differ among dietary Mn levels. Results indicate that supplementing swine diets with 80 ppm Mn may improve pork color during retail display without increasing the likelihood of lipid oxidation.     

Effects of transportation at high ambient temperatures on physiological responses, carcass and meat quality characteristics of three breeds of Omani goats

The experiment was designed to determine the effects of short road transportation in an open truck during the hot season on live weight shrink, physiological responses, carcass, and meat quality characteristics in three breeds of Omani goats. Forty-two male goats (12 months of age) representing equally three breeds of Omani goats (Batina, Dhofari, and Jabal Akhdar) were divided into two groups: 2 h transportation stress (TS) or not transported (NT). The NT group remained unstressed in holding pens with feed and water provided ad libitum prior to slaughter, while the TS group was transported on the day of slaughter 100 km in an open truck. The average temperature during transportation was 37 °C. All animals were blood-sampled before loading and prior to slaughter via jugular venipuncture. Animals were weighed just before loading onto a truck and after transport to assess shrinkage. Muscle shear force, sarcomere length, pH, expressed juice, color, and cooking loss were measured on samples from Mm longissimus dorsi (LD), biceps femoris (BF), and semitendinosus (ST) muscles collected at 24 h postmortem at 1–3 °C. Live weight shrinkage losses were between 1.07 and 1.28 kg. The TS goats had higher plasma cortisol (P < 0.01), adrenaline, nor-adrenaline, and dopamine concentrations (P < 0.05) than NS goats. Blood serum from Batina goats had significantly (P < 0.05) higher cortisol, adrenaline and dopamine and nor-adrenaline concentrations than those from Jabal Akdhar goats. Transportation stress had a significant (P < 0.05) effect on meat quality characteristics of the LD, BF, and ST muscles. Meat from TS goats had significantly higher ultimate pH, expressed juice, cooking loss percentage, shear force, but significantly lower sarcomere length, L^*, a^*, and b^* values. LD muscles of Batina goats had significantly higher ultimate pH values and lower L^* values than Dhofari and Jabal Akdhar goats. These results indicated that subjecting goats to the 2-hour road transportation with high ambient temperatures can generate major physiological and muscle metabolism responses.     

Meat quality characteristics of springbok (Antidorcas marsupialis). 3: Fatty acid composition as influenced by age, gender and production region

The effects of age, gender and production region on the fatty acid composition of springbok Musculus longissimus dorsi (LD) were investigated. The major fatty acid of the LD muscle was stearic acid (C18:0), which contributed 23.92–27.02%. Oleic acid (C18:1) represented the largest component (16.33–20.45%) of the mono-unsaturated fatty acids (MUFA). The major n − 6 polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA) was C18:2n − 6, which formed 18.77–21.62%, whereas C18:3n − 3 (3.33–4.00%) was the most abundant n − 3 PUFA. The n − 6:n − 3 ratio of the meat varied from 3.02 to 3.35, with an average ratio of 3.2. Polyunsaturated to saturated (P:S) ratios varied between 0.96 and 1.18 and averaged at 1.06. Total MUFA was found to be higher (P < 0.05) in males (20.99%) than females (16.67%). The cholesterol content of the meat varied from 54.45 to 59.34 mg/100 g muscle. Linear correlations between the fatty acid and the intramuscular fat (IMF) content indicated a significant increase in certain saturated and mono-unsaturated fatty acids with increasing IMF content of the meat.     

Effect of dietary oregano oil supplementation on lamb meat characteristics

The effect of dietary oregano essential oil supplementation on lamb meat characteristics was investigated. Eight male and eight female Chios lambs were divided into two equal groups. The first group was fed with the control diet consisting of concentrated feed and alfalfa hay, whereas the second group consumed the same diet, the only difference being that the concentrated feed was uniformly sprayed with oregano essential oil (1 ml/kg). Duration of the experimental period was two months.

No differences were observed after oregano essential oil supplementation in final body weight (kg), body weight gain (g) and carcass yield (%). Tenderness of longissimus thoracis muscle, expressed as sarcomere length and shear force value, was not influenced by the treatment, whereas pH and colour parameters (yellowness–redness) appeared to increase (P < 0.05). Moreover, results showed that dietary incorporation of oregano essential oil exerted strong antioxidant effects retarding lipid oxidation (MDA formation) in meat during refrigerated and long-term frozen storage (P < 0.001).     

Association of polymorphisms in the calpain I, calpain II and growth hormone genes with tenderness in bovine M. longissimus dorsi

The objective of this study was to determine if there is an association between tenderness in bovine M. longisimus dorsi (LD) and polymorphisms in the bovine calpain I (exons 9 & 14), calpain II (regulatory subunit) or growth hormone (intron 3) genes. Genomic DNA was isolated from bovine LD (n = 281) on which quality attributes (Warner Bratzler shear force (WBSF), sarcomere length and composition) were also characterised. DNA polymorphisms were analysed using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis. Association analyses were performed between genotypes at the four polymorphic loci and day 14 WBSF values. It was found that the calpain 1 exon 9 genotypes had an association with WBSF such that animals with the GA genotype exhibited decreased WBSF and increased tenderness when compared to animals with the GG genotype (P < 0.05). This observation concurs with that of earlier studies, suggesting that this polymorphism is a functional marker for beef tenderness.     

Novel method for determination of myofibril fragmentation post-mortem

Multi angle light scattering was used to determine the myofibril fragmentation of pig longissimus dorsi muscle which was then compared with results from the common turbidity method. The method is based on measurement of the myofibril particle size distribution with the use of a special optical unit containing several individual detectors. The method was able to determine post-mortem changes in a pig muscle homogenate without purification of the myofibrils and is therefore simpler and much faster than the traditional turbidity method. There was a significant correlation (p < 0.01) between Warner–Bratzler shear force (WBSF) and particle size distribution. The root mean square error of prediction was found to be 6.1 N (10–15% of the measured WBSF) when multivariate data analysis was used to make a prediction model for WBSF. Multi angle light scattering is very useful for estimation of myofibril fragmentation since the method is fast and the sample preparation is simple.     

Sensory properties of hot-deboned ostrich (Struthio camelus var. domesticus) Muscularis gastrocnemius, pars interna

Cold-deboning is currently practiced in South African ostrich abattoirs. However, the advantages of hot-deboning include the reduction of costs and time, but there is always the risk of cold-shortening. The effects of hot-deboning of ostrich M. gastrocnemius, pars interna on meat sensory attributes were investigated. The data showed that the hot-deboned muscles’ pH₄₈ (6.57 ± 0.18) was significantly negatively correlated (r = −0.7813; P < 0.038) to the mean Warner–Bratzler shear force values (71.28 ± 18.62 N, 12.7 mm⁻¹ diameter) and positively correlated (r = 0.789; P < 0.035) to the mean scores for taste panel tenderness (66.39 ± 15.45). After storage for 48 h post-mortem, the hot-deboned muscles were found to be less juicy (P < 0.004) and, according to both sensory tenderness scores and Warner–Bratzler shear force values, tougher (P < 0.0001) than the cold-deboned muscles.     

Irradiation effect on fatty acid composition and conjugated linoleic acid isomers in frozen lamb meat

The effect of gamma radiation processing on the lipid content, fatty acid composition and conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) profile in frozen lamb meat was investigated. Samples of longissimus thoracis muscle from lambs fed lucerne basal diets either unsupplemented or supplemented with polyunsaturated vegetable oils were irradiated (7 kGy) and analysed. CLA contents in lamb meat did not affect (P > 0.05) the levels of lipid oxidation induced by the irradiation. No significant differences (P > 0.05) were observed for fatty acid composition, related nutritional indexes (n − 6/n − 3 and PUFA/SFA), as well as for total lipid and CLA contents, between non-irradiated (control) and irradiated meat samples. In contrast, meat irradiation affected the relative proportions of total trans, trans and cis/trans CLA isomers (P < 0.001), in addition to the percentage of some minor individual CLA isomers (t11, t13 and t9, t11, with P < 0.05 and P < 0.001, respectively). The percentage of total cis/trans CLA isomers slightly decreased in irradiated samples, while the relative proportion of total trans, trans isomers slightly increased. This observation may be explained by the higher susceptibility to autoxidation of the cis double bond relative to the trans configuration.     

The effect of grazing saltbush with a barley supplement on the carcass and eating quality of sheepmeat

The carcass and eating quality of sheep grazing a saltbush dominant saline pasture system or on a ‘control’ dry pasture, stubble plot both supplemented with barley for 14 weeks was investigated (Experiment 1, 50 (2 × 25) 6 month merino lamb wethers and Experiment 2, 50 (2 × 25) 18 month old merino hogget wethers). Treatment had no significant effect on eating quality attributes (P > 0.05). Saltbush grazed sheep in both experiments had a significantly (P < 0.01) lower carcass fat and significantly higher lean (P < 0.01) content than the control grazed sheep. This is a positive finding as fat denudation is a significant cost to processors. The long term consumption of saltbush and barley prior to slaughter did increase muscle fluid content (P < 0.05) but did not result in a decreased carcass weight loss at slaughter due to confounding changes in body composition. Grazing saltbush resulted in increased urine weight (P < 0.001) and decreased urine concentration (P < 0.05) at slaughter indicating an improved hydration status at slaughter. However both experiments demonstrated sub-optimal liveweight gains indicating that saltbush with a barley supplement can still be effectively used as a maintenance ration without compromising carcass and eating quality.     

Fat deposition, fatty acid composition and meat quality: A review

This paper reviews the factors affecting the fatty acid composition of adipose tissue and muscle in pigs, sheep and cattle and shows that a major factor is the total amount of fat. The effects of fatty acid composition on meat quality are also reviewed. Pigs have high levels of polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA), including the long chain (C20-22) PUFA in adipose tissue and muscle. The full range of PUFA are also found in sheep adipose tissue and muscle whereas cattle ‘conserve’ long chain PUFA in muscle phospholipid. Linoleic acid (18:2n − 6) is a major ingredient of feeds for all species. Its incorporation into adipose tissue and muscle in relation to the amount in the diet is greater than for other fatty acids. It is deposited in muscle phospholipid at a high level where it and its long chain products eg aracidonic acid (20:4n − 6) compete well for insertion into phospholipid molecules. Its proportion in pig adipose tissue declines as fat deposition proceeds and is an index of fatness. The same inverse relationships are not seen in ruminant adipose tissue but in all species the proportion of 18:2n − 6 declines in muscle as fat deposition increases. The main reason is that phospholipid, where 18:2n − 6 is located, declines as a proportion of muscle lipid and the proportion of neutral lipid, with its higher content of saturated and monounsaturated fatty acids, increases. Oleic acid (18:1cis − 9), formed from stearic acid (18:0) by the enzyme stearoyl Co-A desaturase, is a major component of neutral lipid and in ruminants the same enzyme forms conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), an important nutrient in human nutrition. Like 18:2n − 6, -linolenic acid (18:3n − 3) is an essential fatty acid and is important to ruminants since it is the major fatty acid in grass. However it does not compete well for insertion into phospholipid compared with 18:2n − 6 and its incorporation into adipose tissue and muscle is less efficient. Greater biohydrogenation of 18:3n − 3 and a long rumen transit time for forage diets also limits the amount available for tissue uptake compared with 18:2n − 6 from concentrate diets. A positive feature of grass feeding is that levels of the nutritionally important long chain n − 3 PUFA are increased ie EPA (20:5n − 3) and DHA (22:6n − 3). Future research should focus on increasing n − 3 PUFA proportions in lean carcasses and the use of biodiverse pastures and conservation processes which retain the benefits of fresh leafy grass offer opportunities to achieve this. The varying fatty acid compositions of adipose tissue and muscle have profound effects on meat quality. Fatty acid composition determines the firmness/oiliness of adipose tissue and the oxidative stability of muscle, which in turn affects flavour and muscle colour. Vitamin E is an essential nutrient, which stabilises PUFA and has a central role in meat quality, particularly in ruminants.     

Nutritional profile of restructured beef steak with added walnuts

Amino acid, fatty acid profile, cholesterol, vitamin E and mineral contents were assessed in restructured beef steak with 20% added walnut (20W). Compared with control restructured beef steak (0% added walnut), the product with added walnut presented a lower (P < 0.05) lysine/arginine ratio, larger (P < 0.05) quantities (mg/100 g product) of monounsaturated (MUFA) and n3 polyunsaturated (PUFA) fatty acids (mainly -linolenic acid), a lower (P < 0.05) n6/n3 PUFA ratio and a higher (P < 0.05) polyunsaturated/saturated fatty acid ratio. The replacement of raw meat material by walnut reduced (P < 0.05) the cholesterol content and increased (more than 400 times) the amount of γ-tocopherol. Iron, calcium, magnesium and manganese contents of 20W sample were greater (P < 0.05) than in the control. Some changes induced by added walnut in the nutritional quality of the restructured product may present health benefits.     

The effect of journey time and stocking density during transport on carcass and meat quality in rabbits

Four hundred and fifty hybrid commercial rabbits (half males and half females) at the end of their productive cycle (82 days old) were transported in cages (98 × 52 × 24 cm, length × width × height) at high or low density (75.5 or 49.0 kg/m² – 15 or 10 animals per cage) on an uncovered truck for 1, 2 or 4 h. Live weight before and after transport as well as slaughter data were recorded for each rabbit. A subset of 180 carcasses were evaluated for meat quality on the basis of meat pH, colour (CIELab system), cooking loss, drip loss and shear force. As a representative of the whole carcass muscle/bone ratio, the left hind leg was separated, dissected and its meat analysed in order to determine its water, protein, ash and lipid content. It was found that a longer journey significantly increases the live weight losses (3.3% vs. 2.0% vs. 1.6% for 4, 2 or 1 h, respectively; P < 0.001), as a result not only of urine and fecal losses, but also of a decrease in carcass weight (P < 0.01) during transport. Ultimate pH (pH_u) was higher and pH drop lower in rabbits transported for 4 h compared to those transported for 2 h (P < 0.05). Moreover, the meat from animals that had undergone the longest journey was more purple-red (P < 0.05), darker (P < 0.0001), and firmer when raw and showed less cooking loss than meat from those that underwent shorter journeys. Transport density did not influence any of the considered parameters and there was no interaction between transport time and density.     

Selection of muscles as indicators of tenderness after seven days of ageing

The selection of a muscle that could be used as an index muscle for beef tenderness was performed using nine commercially important muscles. A total of 50 bulls, Charolais × Alentejano (n = 9), Simmental × Alentejano (n = 9) and Alentejano (n = 32), were slaughtered at two different commercial live weights: crossbred animals (sample A) between 500 and 600 kg (carcass weight between 310 and 370 kg) and purebred Alentejano (sample B) between 350 and 450 kg (carcass weight between 185 and 295 kg). Slaughter ages varied between 16 and 24 months in both groups. The shear force of nine muscles (Mm. biceps femoris, gastrocnemius, longissimus thoracis, longissimus lumborum, quadriceps femoris, semimembranosus, semitendinosus, supraspinatus and triceps brachii caput longum) was assessed seven days post-mortem. In both samples, the comparison between different muscle means and the combined mean of all muscles and the respective correlations showed that the Mm. biceps femoris and semimembranosus could be used as index muscles. However, the biceps femoris is preferred, because it showed greater stability in terms of the coefficient of variation.