Assessing the feasibility of sub-pixel burned area mapping in miombo woodlands of northern Mozambique using MODIS imagery

The goal of this study was to evaluate the feasibility of sub-pixel burned area detection in the miombo woodlands of northern Mozambique, using imagery from the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS). Multitemporal Landsat-7 ETM+ data were acquired to produce a high spatial resolution map of areas burned between mid-August and late September 2000, and a field campaign was conducted in early November 2000 to gather ground truth data. Mapping of burned areas was performed with an ensemble of classification trees and yielded a kappa value of 0.896. This map was subsequently degraded to a spatial resolution of 500 m, to produce an estimate of burned area fraction, at the MODIS pixel size. Correlation analysis between the sub-pixel burned area fraction map and the MODIS reflective channels 1-7 yielded low but statistically significant correlations for all channels. The better correlations were obtained for MODIS channels 2 (0.86 µm), 5 (1.24 µm) and 6 (1.64 µm). A regression tree was constructed to predict sub-pixel burned area fraction as a function of those MODIS channels. The resulting tree has nine terminal nodes and an overall root mean square error of 0.252. The regression tree analysis confirmed that MODIS channels 2, 5, and 6 are the best predictors of burned area fraction. It may be possible to improve these results considering, as an alternative to individual channels, some appropriate spectral indices used to enhance the burnt scar signal, and by including MODIS thermal data in the analysis. It may also be possible to improve the accuracy of sub-pixel burned area fraction using MODIS imagery by allowing the regression tree to automatically create linear combinations of individual channels, and by using ensembles of trees.     

Comparison of burned area estimates derived from SPOT-VEGETATION and Landsat ETM+ data in Africa: Influence of spatial pattern and vegetation type

An algorithm for burned area mapping in Africa based on classification trees was developed using SPOT-VEGETATION (VGT) imagery. The derived 1 km spatial resolution burned area maps were compared with 30 m spatial resolution maps obtained with 13 Landsat ETM+ scenes, through linear regression analysis. The procedure quantifies the bias in burned area estimation present in the low spatial resolution burned area map. Good correspondence was observed for seven sites, with values of the coefficient of determination (R²) ranging from 0.787 to 0.983. Poorer agreement was observed in four sites (R² values between 0.257 and 0.417), and intermediate values of R² (0.670 and 0.613) were obtained for two sites. The observed variation in the level of agreement between the Landsat and VGT estimates of area burned results from differences in the spatial pattern and size distribution of burns in the different fire regimes encompassed by our analysis. Small and fragmented burned areas result in large underestimation at 1 km spatial resolution. When large and compact burned areas dominate the landscape, VGT estimates of burned area are accurate, although in certain situations there is some overestimation. Accuracy of VGT burned area estimates also depends on vegetation type. Results showed that in forest ecosystems VGT maps underestimate substantially the amount of burned area. The most accurate estimates were obtained for woodlands and grasslands. An overall linear regression fitted with the data from the 13 comparison sites revealed that there is a strong relationship between VGT and Landsat estimates of burned area, with a value of R² of 0.754 and a slope of 0.803. Our findings indicate that burned area mapping based on 1 km spatial resolution VGT data provides adequate regional information.     

Production of Landsat ETM+ reference imagery of burned areas within Southern African savannahs: comparison of methods and application to MODIS

Accurate production of regional burned area maps are necessary to reduce uncertainty in emission estimates from African savannah fires. Numerous methods have been developed that map burned and unburned surfaces. These methods are typically applied to coarse spatial resolution (1 km) data to produce regional estimates of the area burned, while higher spatial resolution (<30 m) data are used to assess their accuracy with little regard to the accuracy of the higher spatial resolution reference data. In this study we aimed to investigate whether Landsat Enhanced Thematic Mapper (ETM+)‐derived reference imagery can be more accurately produced using such spectrally informed methods. The efficacy of several spectral index methods to discriminate between burned and unburned surfaces over a series of spatial scales (ground, IKONOS, Landsat ETM+ and data from the MOderate Resolution Imaging Spectrometer, MODIS) were evaluated. The optimal Landsat ETM+ reference image of burned area was achieved using a charcoal fraction map derived by linear spectral unmixing (k = 1.00, a = 99.5%), where pixels were defined as burnt if the charcoal fraction per pixel exceeded 50%. Comparison of coincident Landsat ETM+ and IKONOS burned area maps of a neighbouring region in Mongu (Zambia) indicated that the charcoal fraction map method overestimated the area burned by 1.6%. This method was, however, unstable, with the optimal fixed threshold occurring at >65% at the MODIS scale, presumably because of the decrease in signal‐to‐noise ratio as compared to the Landsat scale. At the MODIS scale the Mid‐Infrared Bispectral Index (MIRBI) using a fixed threshold of >1.75 was determined to be the optimal regional burned area mapping index (slope = 0.99, r ² = 0.95, SE = 61.40, y = Landsat burned area, x = MODIS burned area). Application of MIRBI to the entire MODIS temporal series measured the burned area as 10 267 km² during the 2001 fire season. The char fraction map and the MIRBI methodologies, which both produced reasonable burned area maps within southern African savannah environments, should also be evaluated in woodland and forested environments.     

Effect of coregistration error on patchy target detection using high-resolution imagery

Many factors influence classification accuracy and a typical error budget includes uncertainty arising from the 1) selection of processing algorithms, 2) selection of training sites, 3) quality of orthorectification, and 4) atmospheric effects. With the development of high spatial resolution imagery, the impact of errors in geographic coregistration between imagery and field sites has become apparent - and potentially limiting - for classification applications, especially those involving patchy target detection. The goal of this study was to document and quantify the effect of coregistration error between imagery and field sites on classification accuracy. Artificial patchy targets were randomly placed over a study area covered by a QuickBird image. Classification accuracy of these targets was assessed at two levels of coregistration. Results showed that producer's accuracy of target classification increased from 37.5% to 100% between low and high levels of coregistration respectively. In addition, “Error due to Location”, a measure of how well pixels were located within respective classes, decreased to zero at high coregistration levels. This study highlights the importance of considering coregistration between imagery and field sites in the error budget, especially with studies involving high spatial resolution imagery and patchy target detection.     

A performance evaluation of a burned area object-based classification model when applied to topographically and non-topographically corrected TM imagery

Operational use of remote sensing as a tool for post-fire Mediterranean forest management has been limited by problems of classification accuracy arising from confusion between burned and non-burned land, especially within shaded areas. Object-oriented image analysis has been developed to overcome the limitations and weaknesses of traditional image processing methods for feature extraction from high spatial resolution images. The aim of this work was to evaluate the performance of an object-based classification model developed for burned area mapping, when applied to topographically and non-topographically corrected Landsat Thematic Mapper (TM) imagery for a site on the Greek island of Thasos. The image was atmospherically and geometrically corrected before object-based classification. The results were compared with the forest perimeter map generated by the Forest Service. The accuracy assessment using an error matrix indicated that the removal of topographic effects from the image before applying the object-based classification model resulted in only slightly more accurate mapping of the burned area (1.16% increase in accuracy). It was concluded that topographic correction is not essential prior to object-based classification of a burned Mediterranean landscape using TM data.     

A MODIS direct broadcast algorithm for mapping wildfire burned area in the western United States

Improved wildland fire emission inventory methods are needed to support air quality forecasting and guide the development of air shed management strategies. Air quality forecasting requires dynamic fire emission estimates that are generated in a timely manner to support real-time operations. In the regulatory and planning realm, emission inventories are essential for quantitatively assessing the contribution of wildfire to air pollution. The development of wildland fire emission inventories depends on burned area as a critical input. This study presents a Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) - direct broadcast (DB) burned area mapping algorithm designed to support air quality forecasting and emission inventory development. The algorithm combines active fire locations and single satellite scene burn scar detections to provide a rapid yet robust mapping of burned area. Using the U.S. Forest Service Fire Sciences Laboratory (FiSL) MODIS-DB receiving station in Missoula, Montana, the algorithm provided daily measurements of burned area for wildfire events in the western U.S. in 2006 and 2007. We evaluated the algorithm's fire detection rate and burned area mapping using fire perimeter data and burn scar information derived from high resolution satellite imagery. The FiSL MODIS-DB system detected 87% of all reference fires > 4 km², and 93% of all reference fires > 10 km². The burned area was highly correlated (R² = 0.93) with a high resolution imagery reference burn scar dataset, but exhibited a large over estimation of burned area (56%). The reference burn scar dataset was used to calibrate the algorithm response and quantify the uncertainty in the burned area measurement at the fire incident level. An objective, empirical error based approach was employed to quantify the uncertainty of our burned area measurement and provide a metric that is meaningful in context of remotely sensed burned area and emission inventories. The algorithm uncertainty is ± 36% for fires 50 km² in size, improving to ± 31% at a fire size of 100 km². Fires in this size range account for a substantial portion of burned area in the western U.S. (77% of burned area is due to fires > 50 km², and 66% results from fires > 100 km²). The dominance of these large wildfires in burned area, duration, and emissions makes these events a significant concern of air quality forecasters and regulators. With daily coverage at 1-km² spatial resolution, and a quantified measurement uncertainty, the burned area mapping algorithm presented in this paper is well suited for the development of wildfire emission inventories. Furthermore, the algorithm's DB implementation enables time sensitive burned area mapping to support operational air quality forecasting.     

Object-based image classification for burned area mapping of Creus Cape, Spain, using NOAA-AVHRR imagery

Due to the ability of the NOAA-AVHRR sensor to cover a wide area and its high temporal frequency, it is possible to quickly obtain a general overview of the prevailing situation over a large area of terrain and, more specifically, quickly assess the damage caused by a recent large forest fire by mapping the extent of the burned area. The aim of this work was to map a large forest fire that recently took place on the Spanish Mediterranean coast using innovative image classification techniques and low spatial resolution imagery. The methodology involved developing an object-based classification model using spectral as well as contextual object information. The burned area map resulting from the image classification was compared with the fire perimeter provided by the Catalan Environmental Department in terms of spatial overlap and size in order to determine to what extent they were compatible. Results of the comparison indicated a high degree (≈90%) of spatial agreement. The total burned area of the classified image was found to be 6900 ha, compared to a fire perimeter of 6000 ha produced by the Catalan Environmental Department. It was concluded that, although the object-oriented classification approach was capable of affording very promising results when mapping a recent burn on the Spanish Mediterranean coast, the method in question required further assessment to ascertain its ability to map other burned areas in the Mediterranean.     

Mapping reedbed habitats using texture-based classification of QuickBird imagery

Many organisms rely on reedbed habitats for their existence, yet, over the past century there has been a drastic reduction in the area and quality of reedbeds in the UK due to intensified human activities. In order to develop management plans for conserving and expanding this threatened habitat, accurate up-to-date information is needed concerning its current distribution and status. This information is difficult to collect using field surveys because reedbeds exist as small patches that are sparsely distributed across landscapes. Hence, this study was undertaken to develop a methodology for accurately mapping reedbeds using very high resolution QuickBird satellite imagery. The objectives were to determine the optimum combination of textural and spectral measures for mapping reedbeds; to investigate the effect of the spatial resolution of the input data upon classification accuracy; to determine whether the maximum likelihood classifier (MLC) or artificial neural network (ANN) analysis produced the most accurate classification; and to investigate the potential of refining the reedbed classification using slope suitability filters produced from digital terrain data. The results indicate an increase in the accuracy of reedbed delineations when grey-level co-occurrence textural measures were combined with the spectral bands. The most effective combination of texture measures were entropy and angular second moment. Optimal reedbed and overall classification accuracies were achieved using a combination of pansharpened multispectral and texture images that had been spatially degraded from 0.6 to 4.8 m. Using the 4.8 m data set, the MLC produced higher classification accuracy for reedbeds than the ANN analysis. The application of slope suitability filters increased the classification accuracy of reedbeds from 71% to 79%. Hence, this study has demonstrated that it is possible to use high resolution multispectral satellite imagery to derive accurate maps of reedbeds through appropriate analysis of image texture, judicious selection of input bands, spatial resolution and classification algorithm and post-classification refinement using terrain data.     

A non-parametric,supervised classification of vegetation types on the Kaibab National Forest using decision trees

Traditional land classification techniques for large areas that use Landsat Thematic Mapper (TM) imagery are typically limited to the fixed spatial resolution of the sensors (30 m). However, the study of some ecological processes requires land cover classifications at finer spatial resolutions. We model forest vegetation types on the Kaibab National Forest (KNF) in northern Arizona to a 10-m spatial resolution with field data, using topographical information and Landsat TM imagery as auxiliary variables. Vegetation types were identified by clustering the field variables total basal area and proportion of basal area by species, and then using a decision tree based on auxiliary variables to predict vegetation types. Vegetation types modelled included pinyon-juniper, ponderosa pine, mixed conifer, spruce- and deciduous-dominated mixes, and openings. To independently assess the accuracy of the final vegetation maps using reference data from different sources, we used a post-stratified, multivariate composite estimator. Overall accuracy was 74.5% (Kappa statistic = 49.9%). Sources of error included differentiating between mixed conifer and spruce-dominated types and between openings in the forest and deciduous-dominated mixes. Overall, our non-parametric classification method successfully identified dominant vegetation types on the study area at a finer spatial resolution than can typically be achieved using traditional classification techniques.     

Regionally adaptable dNBR-based algorithm for burned area mapping from MODIS data

Recent advances in instrument design have led to considerable improvements in wildfire mapping at regional and global scales. Global and regional active fire and burned area products are currently available from various satellite sensors. While only global products can provide consistent assessments of fire activity at the global, hemispherical or continental scales, the efficiency of their performance differs in various ecosystems. The available regional products are hard-coded to the specifics of a given ecosystem (e.g. boreal forest) and their mapping accuracy drops dramatically outside the intended area. We present a regionally adaptable semi-automated approach to mapping burned area using Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) data. This is a flexible remote sensing/GIS-based algorithm which allows for easy modification of algorithm parameterization to adapt it to the regional specifics of fire occurrence in the biome or region of interest. The algorithm is based on Normalized Burned Ratio differencing (dNBR) and therefore retains the variability of spectral response of the area affected by fire and has the potential to be used beyond binary burned/unburned mapping for the first-order characterization of fire impacts from remotely sensed data. The algorithm inputs the MODIS Surface Reflectance 8-Day Composite product (MOD09A1) and the MODIS Active Fire product (MOD14) and outputs yearly maps of burned area with dNBR values and beginning and ending dates of mapping as the attributive information. Comparison of this product with high resolution burn scar information from Landsat ETM+ imagery and fire perimeter data shows high levels of accuracy in reporting burned area across different ecosystems. We evaluated algorithm performance in boreal forests of Central Siberia, Mediterranean-type ecosystems of California, and sagebrush steppe of the Great Basin region of the US. In each ecosystem the MODIS burned area estimates were within 15% of the estimates produced by the high resolution base with the R² between 0.87 and 0.99. In addition, the spatial accuracy of large burn scars in the boreal forests of Central Siberia was also high with Kappa values ranging between 0.76 and 0.79.     

地球观测1号高光谱与全色图像融合的最佳方法

受制于成像原理及制造技术等因素,航天高光谱遥感图像的空间分辨率相对较低,为此提出将高光谱图像与高空间分辨率图像进行融合处理,设计最佳的增强高光谱遥感图像空间分辨率的融合算法。针对地球观测1号(EO-1)Hyperion高光谱图像和高级陆地成像仪（ALI）全色波段图像的特点,从9种具体遥感图像融合算法中选用4种融合算法开展山区与城市的数据融合实验,即Gram-Schmidt光谱锐化融合法、平滑调节滤波(SFIM)变换融合法、加权平均法（WAM）融合法和小波变换（WT）融合法,并分别从定性、定量和分类精度三方面对这些方法的融合效果进行综合评价与对比分析,从而确定适合EO-1高光谱与全色图像融合的最佳方法。实验结果显示：从图像融合效果看,在所采用的4种融合方法中,Gram-Schmidt光谱锐化融合法的效果最好;从图像分类效果看,基于融合图像的分类效果要优于基于源图像的分类效果。理论分析与实验结果均表明：Gram-Schmidt光谱锐化融合法是一种较为理想的高光谱与高空间分辨率遥感图像的融合算法,为提高高光谱遥感图像的清晰度、可靠性及图像的地物识别和分类的准确性提供有力的支持。     

PCA与移动窗小波变换的高光谱决策融合分类

目的 高光谱数据具有较高的谱间分辨率和相关性,给分类处理带来了一定的困难.为了提高分类精度,提出一种结合PCA与移动窗小波变换的高光谱决策融合分类算法.方法 首先,利用相关系数矩阵对原始高光谱数据进行波段分组;然后,利用主成分分析对每组数据进行谱间降维;再根据提出的移动窗小波变换法进行空间特征提取;最后,采用线性意见池(LOP)决策融合规则对多分类器的分类结果进行融合.结果 采用两组来自不同传感器的数据进行实验,所提算法的分类精度和Kappa系数均高于已有的5种分类算法.与SVM-RBF算法相比,本文算法的分类精度高出了8％左右.结论 实验结果表明,本文算法充分挖掘了高光谱图像的谱间-空间信息,能有效提高分类正确率,在小样本情况下和噪声环境中也具有良好的分类性能.     

The effects of ecologically determined spatial complexity on the classification accuracy of simulated coral reef images

Numerous studies have been conducted to compare the classification accuracy of coral reef maps produced from satellite and aerial imagery with different sensor characteristics such as spatial or spectral resolution, or under different environmental conditions. However, in additional to these physical environment and sensor design factors, the ecologically determined spatial complexity of the reef itself presents significant challenges for remote sensing objectives. While previous studies have considered the spatial resolution of the sensors, none have directly drawn the link from sensor spatial resolution to the scale and patterns in the heterogeneity of reef benthos. In this paper, we will study how the accuracy of a commonly used maximum likelihood classification (MLC) algorithm is affected by spatial elements typical of a Caribbean atoll system present in high spectral and spatial resolution imagery.The results indicate that the degree to which ecologically determined spatial factors influence accuracy is dependent on both the amount of coral cover on the reef and the spatial resolution of the images being classified, and may be a contributing factor to the differences in the accuracies obtained for mapping reefs in different geographical locations. Differences in accuracy are also obtained due to the methods of pixel selection for training the maximum likelihood classification algorithm. With respect to estimation of live coral cover, a method which randomly selects training samples from all samples in each class provides better estimates for lower resolution images while a method biased to select the pixels with the highest substrate purity gave better estimations for higher resolution images.     

Object-based land cover classification of shaded areas in high spatial resolution imagery of urban areas: A comparison study

A significant proportion of high spatial resolution imagery in urban areas can be affected by shadows. Considerable research has been conducted to investigate shadow detection and removal in remotely sensed imagery. Few studies, however, have evaluated how applications of these shadow detection and restoration methods can help eliminate the shadow problem in land cover classification of high spatial resolution images in urban settings. This paper presents a comparison study of three methods for land cover classification of shaded areas from high spatial resolution imagery in an urban environment. Method 1 combines spectral information in shaded areas with spatial information for shadow classification. Method 2 applies a shadow restoration technique, the linear-correlation correction method to create a “shadow-free” image before the classification. Method 3 uses multisource data fusion to aid in classification of shadows. The results indicated that Method 3 achieved the best accuracy, with overall accuracy of 88%. It provides a significantly better means for shadow classification than the other two methods. The overall accuracy for Method 1 was 81.5%, slightly but not significantly higher than the 80.5% from Method 2. All of the three methods applied an object-based classification procedure, which was critical as it provides an effective way to address the problems of radiometric difference and spatial misregistration associated with multisource data fusion (Method 3), and to incorporate thematic spatial information (Method 1).     

An active-fire based burned area mapping algorithm for the MODIS sensor

We present an automated method for mapping burned areas using 500-m Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) imagery coupled with 1-km MODIS active fire observations. The algorithm applies dynamic thresholds to composite imagery generated from a burn-sensitive vegetation index and a measure of temporal texture. Cumulative active fire maps are used to guide the selection of burned and unburned training samples. An accuracy assessment for three geographically diverse regions (central Siberia, the western United States, and southern Africa) was performed using high resolution burned area maps derived from Landsat imagery. Mapped burned areas were accurate to within approximately 10% in all regions except the high-tree-cover sub-region of southern Africa, where the MODIS burn maps underestimated the area burned by 41%. We estimate the minimum detectable burn size for reliable detection by our algorithm to be on the order of 120 ha.     

Mapping invasive plants using hyperspectral imagery and Breiman Cutler classifications (randomForest)

Invasive nonindigenous plants are threatening the biological integrity of North American rangelands, as well as the economies that are supported by those ecosystems. Spatial information is critical to fulfilling invasive plant management strategies. Traditional invasive plant mapping has utilized ground-based hand or GPS mapping. The shortfalls of ground-based methods include the limited spatial extent covered and the associated time and cost. Mapping vegetation with remote sensing covers large spatial areas and maps can be updated at an interval determined by management needs. The objective of the study was to map leafy spurge (Euphorbia esula L.) and spotted knapweed (Centaurea maculosa Lam.) using 128-band hyperspectral (5-m and 3-m resolution) imagery and assess the accuracy of the resulting maps. Beiman Cutler classifications (BCC) were used to classify the imagery using the randomForest package in the R statistical program. BCC builds multiple classification trees by repeatedly taking random subsets of the observational data and using random subsets of the spectral bands to determine each split in the classification trees. The resulting classification trees vote on the correct classification. Overall accuracy was 84% for the spotted knapweed classification, with class accuracies ranging from 60% to 93%; overall accuracy was 86% for the leafy spurge classification, with class accuracies ranging from 66% to 93%. Our results indicate that (1) BCC can achieve substantial improvements in accuracy over single classification trees with these data and (2) it might be unnecessary to have separate accuracy assessment data when using BCC, as the algorithm provides a reliable internal estimate of accuracy.     

Sub-pixel mapping and sub-pixel sharpening using neural network predicted wavelet coefficients

Sub-pixel mapping and sub-pixel sharpening are techniques for increasing the spatial resolution of sub-pixel image classifications. The proposed method makes use of wavelets and artificial neural networks. Wavelet multiresolution analysis facilitates the link between different resolution levels. In this work a higher resolution image is constructed after estimation of the detail wavelet coefficients with neural networks. Detail wavelet coefficients are used to synthesize the high-resolution approximation. The applied technique allows for both sub-pixel sharpening and sub-pixel mapping. An algorithm was developed on artificial imagery and tested on artificial as well as real synthetic imagery. The proposed method resulted in images with higher spatial resolution showing more spatial detail than the source imagery. Evaluation of the algorithm was performed both visually and quantitatively using established classification accuracy indices.     

结合像元形状特征分割的高分辨率影像面向对象分类

针对高分辨率遥感影像空间分辨率高,结构形状、纹理、细节信息丰富等特点,提出一种新的融合特征的面向对象影像分类方法来提取城市空间信息。基本过程包含以下4个方面:①提取影像的几何纹理等结构;②融合几何与纹理特征的面向对象影像分割;③提取对象的形状、纹理和光谱特征,并优选最佳特征子集;④最后基于支持向量机(SVM)完成面向对象的影像分类。通过对福州IKONOS影像数据实验,结果表明融入影像特征后的分割效果明显优于原始影像的分割结果,而信息最大化(mRMR)的特征选择能够快速地获得较好的特征子集。通过与eCognition最邻近分类方法比较,表明本文方法的分类总体精度大约提高了6%,效果显著。     

Linear mixture modelling applied to AVHRR data for crop area estimation

Abstract

A technique for estimating crop coverage using linear mixture modelling of multi-temporal Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR) data is presented for a study area in northern Greece. This paper identifies some of the problems associated with using satellite sensor data with coarse spatial resolution for crop area estimation. Using satellite sensor imagery with a high spatial resolution to extrapolate ground measurements to AVHRR scales, the paper shows how the mixture model can be applied to AVHRR data in a mixed agricultural system. Crop areas are estimated to an average accuracy of 89 percent on regional scale using this technique. The results show that this linear mixture modelling has potential for operational crop area monitoring on a regional basis.     

Mapping burned areas in Mediterranean countries using spectral mixture analysis from a uni‐temporal perspective

The main aim of this study was to evaluate the usefulness of spectral mixture analysis (SMA) for mapping forest areas burned by fires in the Mediterranean area using low and medium spatial resolution satellite sensor data. A methodology requiring only one single post‐fire image was used to carry out the study (uni‐temporal techniques). This methodology is based on the contextual classification of the fraction images obtained after applying SMA to the original post‐fire image. The results showed that the proposed method, using only one image acquired post‐fire, could accurately identify the burned surface area (Kappa coefficient>0.8). The spatial resolution of the satellite images had practically no influence on the accuracy of the burned area estimate but did affect the possibility of detecting areas inside the perimeter of the burned area which were only slightly damaged.