Seismic Fragility of Continuous Steel Highway Bridges in New York State

This paper presents the results of an analytical seismic fragility analysis of a typical steel highway bridge in New York State. The structural type and topological layout of this multispan I-girder bridge have been identified to be most typical of continuous bridges in New York State. The structural details of the bridge are designed as per New York State bridge design guidelines. Uncertainties associated with the estimation of material strength, bridge mass, friction coefficient of expansion bearings, and expansion-joint gap size are considered. To account for the uncertainties related to the bridge structural properties and earthquake characteristics, ten statistical bridge samples are established using the Latin Hypercube sampling and restricted pairing approach, and 100 ground motions are simulated numerically. The uncertainties of capacity and demand are estimated simultaneously by using the ratios of demands to capacities at different limit states to construct seismic fragility curves as a function of peak ground acceleration and fragility surfaces as a function of moment magnitude and epicentral distance for individual components using nonlinear and multivariate regressions. It has been observed that nonlinear and multivariate regressions show better fit to bridge response data than linear regression conventionally used. To account for seismic risk from multiple failure modes, second-order reliability yields narrower bounds than the commonly used first-order reliability method. The fragility curves and surfaces obtained from this analysis demonstrate that bridges in New York State have reasonably low likelihood of collapse during expected earthquakes.     

Seismic Performance Assessment of Simply Supported and Continuous Multispan Concrete Girder Highway Bridges

Seismic evaluations of typical concrete girder bridges are conducted for both a multispan simply supported and a multispan continuous girder bridge common to the Central and Southeastern United States. These evaluations are performed for an approximate hazard level of 2% in 50?years by performing nonlinear time history analyses on three-dimensional analytical models. The results show significant vulnerabilities in the reinforced concrete columns, the abutments, and also in unseating of the girders. In general, the longitudinal loading of the bridges results in larger demands than the transverse loading. However, the simply supported bridge sustains bearing deformations in the transverse direction which are on the same order as their longitudinal response. These results suggest that both longitudinal and transverse loading are significant and should be considered when performing seismic hazard analyses of these bridges.     

Efficient Longitudinal Seismic Fragility Assessment of a Multispan Continuous Steel Bridge on Liquefiable Soils

The increased failure potential of aging U.S. highway bridges and their susceptibility to damage during extreme events necessitates the development of efficient reliability assessment tools to prioritize maintenance and rehabilitation interventions. Reliability communication tools become even more important when considering complex phenomena such as soil liquefaction under seismic hazards. Currently, two approaches are widely used for bridge reliability estimation under soil failure conditions via fragility curves: liquefaction multipliers and full-scale two- or three-dimensional bridge-soil-foundation models. This paper offers a computationally economical yet adequate approach that links nonlinear finite-element models of a three-dimensional bridge system with a two-dimensional soil domain and a one-dimensional set of p-y springs into a coupled bridge-soil-foundation (CBSF) system. A multispan continuous steel girder bridge typical of the central and eastern United States along with heterogeneous liquefiable soil profiles is used within a statistical sampling scheme to illustrate the effects of soil failure and uncertainty propagation on the fragility of CBSF system components. In general, the fragility of rocker bearings, piles, embankment soil, and the probability of unseating increases with liquefaction, while that of commonly monitored components, such as columns, depends on the type of soil overlying the liquefiable sands. This component response dependence on soil failure supports the use of reliability assessment frameworks that are efficient for regional applications by relying on simplified but accepted geotechnical methods to capture complex soil liquefaction effects.     

Seismic Response of Multiple Span Steel Bridges in Central and Southeastern United States. II: Retrofitted

Part I of this two-part paper evaluated the seismic response of typical multispan simply supported (MSSS) and multispan continuous steel girder bridges in the central and southeastern United States. The results showed that the bridges were vulnerable to damage resulting from impact between decks, and large ductility demands on nonductile columns. Furthermore, fixed and expansion bearings were likely to fail during strong ground motion. In this paper, several retrofit measures to improve the seismic performance of typical multispan simply supported and multispan continuous steel girder bridges are evaluated, including the use of elastomeric bearings, lead-rubber bearings, and restrainer cables. It is determined that lead-rubber bearings are the most effective retrofit measure for reducing the seismic vulnerability of typical bridges. While isolation provided by elastomeric bearings limits the forces into the columns, the added flexibility results in pounding between decks in the MSSS steel girder bridges. Restrainer cables, which are becoming a common retrofit measure, are effective in reducing the hinge opening in MSSS bridges with steel bearings. However, when used with elastomeric bearings, the restrainer cables negate the isolation effect of the bearings.     

Orthogonal Effects in Seismic Analysis of Skewed Bridges

In seismic analysis of bridges, the designer chooses the direction of the applied earthquake forces arbitrarily. This paper investigates the effects of seismic force direction on the responses of slab-girder skewed bridges in response spectrum and time history linear dynamic analyses. The combination rules for orthogonal earthquake effects, such as the 100/30, 100/40?percentage rules and the SRSS method are also examined. It is concluded that either the SRSS or the 100/40?percentage rule in the skew direction should be used in the response spectrum analysis of skewed bridges. For time history analysis none of the combination rules provide conservative results. In this case, the application of paired acceleration time histories in several angular directions is recommended.     

Seismic Response of Multiple Span Steel Bridges in Central and Southeastern United States. I: As Built

The seismic response of typical multispan simply supported (MSSS) and multispan continuous steel girder bridges in the central and southeastern United States is evaluated. Nonlinear time history analyses are conducted using synthetic ground motion for three cities for 475 and 2,475-year return period earthquakes (10 and 2% probability of exceedance in 50 years). The results indicate that the seismic response for the 475-year return period earthquake would lead to an essentially linear response in typical bridges. However, the seismic response for a 2,475-year return period earthquake resulted in significant demands on nonductile columns, fixed and expansion bearings, and abutments. In particular, pounding between decks in the MSSS bridge would result in significant damage to steel bearings and would lead to the toppling of rocker bearings, which may result in unseating of the bridge deck.     

Seismic Effect on Highway Bridges in Chi Chi Earthquake

This paper reports the bridge damage in the Chi Chi earthquake. Damage to bridge structures may occur in the superstructure, the substructure, or the approaches. Typical types of damage are discussed and illustrated in this paper. A review of the design specifications in Taiwan is also presented to give the background on the seismic design of highway bridges in Taiwan.     

Probabilistic Seismic Demand Models and Fragility Estimates for Reinforced Concrete Highway Bridges with One Single-Column Bent

In performance-based seismic design, general and practical seismic demand models of structures are essential. This paper proposes a general methodology to construct probabilistic demand models for reinforced concrete (RC) highway bridges with one single-column bent. The developed probabilistic models consider the dependence of the seismic demands on the ground motion characteristics and the prevailing uncertainties, including uncertainties in the structural properties, statistical uncertainties, and model errors. Probabilistic models for seismic deformation, shear, and bivariate deformation-shear demands are developed by adding correction terms to deterministic demand models currently used in practice. The correction terms remove the bias and improve the accuracy of the deterministic models, complement the deterministic models with ground motion intensity measures that are critical for determining the seismic demands, and preserve the simplicity of the deterministic models to facilitate the practical application of the proposed probabilistic models. The demand data used for developing the models are obtained from 60 representative configurations of finite-element models of RC bridges with one single-column bent subjected to a large number of representative seismic ground motions. The ground motions include near-field and ordinary records, and the soil amplification due to different soil characteristics is considered. A Bayesian updating approach and an all possible subset model selection are used to assess the unknown model parameters and select the correction terms. Combined with previously developed capacity models, the proposed seismic demand models can be used to estimate the seismic fragility of RC bridges with one single-column bent. Seismic fragility is defined as the conditional probability that the demand quantity of interest attains or exceeds a specified capacity level for given values of the earthquake intensity measures. As an application, the univariate deformation and shear fragilities and the bivariate deformation-shear fragility are assessed for an example bridge.     

Thermal Effects on Skewed Steel Highway Bridges and Bearing Orientation

An investigation is conducted to characterize and quantify external effects in composite steel highway bridges under thermal loading. Based on the results of a literature review, including thermal and thermoelastic analyses as well as current design code provisions, a simple but realistic thermal loading is developed for winter and summer conditions for AASHTO load and resistance factor design (LRFD) Zone 3. Three cases of bearing orientation, representative of current design practice, are examined. Parametric studies are then conducted. Hypothetical bridges are designed for a range of different span lengths, section depths, widths, and skews. Each bridge model is tested under all three constraint cases and both winter and summer thermal loading. Variations in structural response with each parameter are plotted, and the relative influence of each parameter is discussed. Design equations to predict the observed displacements and restraint forces at the bearings are then developed by a systematic regression procedure. The applicability of these proposed design equations is demonstrated by examples.     

Seismic Behavior of Steel Girder Bridge Superstructures

Recent earthquakes exposed the vulnerabilities of steel plate girder bridges when subjected to ground shaking. This paper discusses the behavior of steel plate girder bridges during recent earthquakes such as Petrolia, Northridge, and Kobe. The paper also discusses the recent experimental and analytical investigations that were conducted on steel plate girder bridges and their components. Results of these investigations showed the importance of shear connectors in distributing and transferring the lateral forces to the end and intermediate cross frames. Also, these investigations showed the potential of using end cross frames as ductile elements that can be used to dissipate the earthquake input energy. The paper also gives an update on specifications and guidelines for the seismic design of steel plate girder bridges in the United States.     

Influence of Input Motion and Site Property Variabilities on Seismic Site Response Analysis

Seismic site response analysis evaluates the influence of local soil conditions on earthquake ground shaking. There are multiple sources of potential uncertainty in this analysis; the most significant pertaining to the specification of the input motions and to the characterization of the soil properties. The influence of the selection of input ground motions on equivalent-linear site response analysis is evaluated through analyses performed with multiple suites of input motions selected to fit the same target acceleration response spectrum. The results indicate that a stable median surface response spectrum (i.e., within ±20% of any other suite) can be obtained with as few as five motions, if the motions fit the input target spectrum well. The stability of the median is improved to ±5 to 10% when 10 or 20 input motions are used. If the standard deviation of the surface response spectra is required, at least 10 motions (and preferably 20) are required to adequately model the standard deviation. The influence of soil characterization uncertainty is assessed through Monte Carlo simulations, where variations in the shear-wave velocity profile and nonlinear soil properties are considered. Modeling shear-wave velocity variability generally reduces the predicted median surface motions and amplification factors, most significantly at periods less than the site period. Modeling the variability in nonlinear properties has a similar, although slightly smaller, effect. Finally, including the variability in soil properties significantly increases the standard deviation of the amplification factors but has a lesser effect on the standard deviation of the surface motions.     

Effect of Near-Fault Vertical Ground Motions on Seismic Response of Highway Overcrossings

Results of comprehensive nonlinear response history analyses on a range of configurations representing typical highway overcrossings subjected to combined effects of vertical and horizontal components of near-fault ground motions are reported. Current seismic design guidelines in California neglect the vertical components of ground motions for peak ground accelerations less than 0.6?g and provide rather simplistic measures to account for vertical effects when they need to be incorporated in the design. Results from the numerical simulations show that the vertical components of ground motions cause significant amplification in the axial force demand in the columns and moment demands in the girder at both the midspan and at the face of the bent cap. Axial capacity of the columns and moment capacity of the girder at the face of the bent cap were generally found to be sufficient to resist the amplification in the respective demands due to vertical effects. However, midspan moments in negative bending due to vertical motions are found to exceed the capacity of the girder. The amplified midspan moments lead to yielding of the top reinforcement resulting in average peak strains on the order of 1%. It is concluded that seismic demand analysis of ordinary highway bridges in general and overcrossings in particular should incorporate provisions for considering the adverse vertical effects of near-fault ground motions.     

Effect of Asynchronous Earthquake Motion on Complex Bridges. II: Results and Implications on Assessment

Nonuniform seismic excitation has been shown through previous analytical studies to adversely affect the response of long-span bridge structures. To further understand this phenomenon, this study investigates the response of complex straight and curved long-span bridges under the effect of parametrically varying asynchronous motion. The generation process and modeling procedures are presented in a companion paper. A wide-ranging parametric study is performed aimed at isolating the effect of both bridge curvature and the two main sources of asynchronous strong motion: geometric incoherence and the wave-passage effect. Results from this study indicate that response for the 344?m study structure is amplified significantly by nonsynchronous excitation, with displacement amplification factors between 1.6 and 3.4 for all levels of incoherence. This amplification was not constant or easily predicable, demonstrating the importance of inelastic dynamic analysis using asynchronous motion for assessment and design of this class of structure. Additionally, deck stiffness is shown to significantly affect response amplification, through response comparison between the curved and an equivalent straight bridge. Study results are used to suggest an appropriate domain for consideration of asynchronous excitation, as well as an efficient methodology for analysis.     

Seismic Vulnerability and Mitigation during Construction of Cable-Stayed Bridges

The implications of earthquake loading during balanced cantilever construction of a cable-stayed bridge are examined. Finite-element models of a cable-stayed bridge were developed and multiple ground motion time history records were used to study the seismic response at the base of the towers for six stages of balanced cantilever construction. Probabilistic seismic hazard relationships were used to relate ground motions to bridge responses. The results show that there can be a high probability of having seismic responses (forces/moments) in a partially completed bridge that exceed, often by a substantial margin, the 10%/50-year design level (0.21% per annum) for the full bridge. The maximum probability of exceedance per annum was found to be 20%. This occurs because during balanced-cantilever construction the structure is in a particularly precarious and vulnerable state. The efficacy of a seismic mitigation strategy based on the use of tie-down cables intended for aerodynamic stability during construction was investigated. This strategy was successful in reducing some of the seismic vulnerabilities so that probabilities of exceedance during construction dropped to below 1% per annum. Although applied to only one cable-stayed bridge, the same approach can be used for construction-stage vulnerability analysis of other long-span bridges.     

Dynamic Stress Analysis of Long Suspension Bridges under Wind, Railway, and Highway Loadings

Computation of the dynamic stress of long suspension bridges under multiloadings is essential for either the strength or fatigue assessment of the bridge. This paper presents a framework for dynamic stress analysis of long suspension bridges under wind, railway, and highway loadings. The bridge, trains, and road vehicles are respectively modeled using the finite-element method (FEM). The connections between the bridge and trains and between the bridge and road vehicles are respectively considered in terms of wheel-rail and tire-road surface contact conditions. The spatial distributions of both buffeting forces and self-excited forces over the bridge deck surface are considered. The Tsing Ma suspension bridge and the field measurement data recorded by a wind and structural health monitoring system (WASHMS) installed in the bridge are utilized as a case study to examine the proposed framework. The information on the concerned loadings measured by the WASHMS is taken as inputs for the computation simulation, and the computed stress responses are compared with the measured ones. The results show that running trains play a predominant role in bridge stress responses compared with running road vehicles and fluctuating wind loading.     

Seismic Modeling of Skewed Bridges with Elastomeric Bearings and Side Retainers

Elastomeric expansion bearings are often restrained laterally by retainers on each side. The retainers are in the form of a concrete shear block, rolled steel angles, or welded plates. To allow for longitudinal temperature movements, the retainers are placed with a slight clearance (gap) from the elastomer. The gap introduces nonlinearity in the seismic analysis of the bridge and, therefore, is often ignored by designers for the sake of simplicity. This paper compares the seismic response of straight and skewed slab-girder single-span bridges under the conditions of zero gap and standard gap for the retainers. Nonlinear time-history analysis is employed to measure the seismic demand on retainers, elastomers, and pinned bearings in each case. The stiffness of end-diaphragms and elastomeric bearings is included in the analysis. It is shown that these relationships are nonlinear in nature and depend on the frequency content of the input motion. It is also proved that ignoring the nonlinearity in the seismic bridge model can lead to erroneous results that are unsafe to use.     

Assessment of Multispan Masonry Arch Bridges. II: Examples and Applications

Modern approaches to multispan masonry bridges are approximate in many ways: load distribution, masonry degradation, fill-to-barrel, span-to-span, and span-to-pier interaction are taken into account by means of approximate models or are neglected. At the end of the assessment procedure, the approximation to the load carrying capacity of the bridge cannot be easily quantified. In Part I of this paper, an extension of the classical approach to masonry arches was formulated taking into account the nonlinear response of masonry, a limit to compressive inelastic strains, and assuming simplifying but conservative assumptions. The procedure allows the analysis of multispan masonry bridges considering the nonlinear response of arches and barrels and the mutual interaction. The response of two- and three-span prototypes is compared to that of a single arch; then the procedure is applied to a six- 18.5-m span in-service viaduct. A detailed comparison with the single-span-bridge approach is discussed. Specific attention is paid to the evolution of the collapse mechanism and to the effect of load distribution, addressing the concentrated loads versus distributed equivalent loads problem and showing how the limit to compressive inelastic strains, i.e., to masonry ductility, may be of great importance to the structural analysis of masonry bridges.     

Effect of Asynchronous Earthquake Motion on Complex Bridges. I: Methodology and Input Motion

Based on observed damage patterns from previous earthquakes and a rich history of analytical studies, asynchronous input motion has been identified as a major source of unfavorable response for long-span structures, such as bridges. This study is aimed at quantifying the effect of geometric incoherence and wave arrival delay on complex straight and curved bridges using state-of-the-art methodologies and tools. Using fully parametrized computer codes combining expert geotechnical and earthquake structural engineering knowledge, suites of asynchronous accelerograms are produced for use in inelastic dynamic analysis of the bridge model. Two multi-degree-of-freedom analytical models are analyzed using 2,000 unique synthetic accelerograms with results showing significant response amplification due to asynchronous input motion, demonstrating the importance of considering asynchronous seismic input in complex, irregular bridge design. The paper, Part 1 of a two-paper investigation, presents the development of the input motion sets and the modeling and analysis approach employed, concluding with sample results. Detailed results and implications on seismic assessment are presented in the companion paper: Effect of Asynchronous Motion on Complex Bridges. Part II: Results and Implications on Assessment.     

Damage Analysis of Hanshin Expressway Viaducts during 1995 Kobe Earthquake. III: Three-Span Continuous Girder Bridges

Almost all the single reinforced concrete (RC) piers from P35 to P350 received consistently severe damage, considering the large residual inclination of piers included in earthquake-induced severe damage. However, some of the piers in the section from P35 to P350 remained lightly damaged, and this phenomenon is observed especially in many piers under fixed bearings in continuous girder bridges. In this study, using experimentally based models for metal bearings and installing them to an existing FEM code, a nonlinear dynamic response analysis of a continuous girder bridge system is conducted. It is shown that the results depend on the ground motion, but the fuse effect of the breaking of the bearings could have been a reason for the phenomenon.