Critical-point drying versus freeze drying for scanning electron microscopy: a quantitative and qualitative study on isolated hepatocytes

Critical-point drying and freeze drying were compared both quantitatively and qualitatively as preparative procedures for scanning electron microscopy. Isolated hepatocytes were used as model cells. Nomarski differential interference contrast microscopy was used for light microscopic measurements of the hepatocytes in the unfixed, the glutaraldehyde fixed, the glutaraldehyde + OsO₄ fixed, the critical-point dried and the freeze dried states. Critical-point dried hepatocytes were found to shrink to 38% of glutaraldehyde + OsO₄ fixed volume, whereas optimal freeze dried hepatocytes (frozen in water saturated with chloroform and freeze dried at 183 K for 84 h) were found to shrink to 51% of glutaraldehyde + OsO₄ fixed volume. Transmission and scanning electron micrographs of the critical-point dried cells showed well-preserved ultrastructure and surface structure. Micrographs of the freeze dried cells showed ultrastructure destroyed by internal ice crystals and surface structure destroyed by external ice crystals. Double-fixed isolated hepatocytes were shown to swell during storage in buffer and to shrink during storage after critical-point drying. For low magnification scanning electron microscopy (up to about 3000 times) both critical-point drying and freeze drying can be used. However, for high magnification scanning electron microscopy, critical-point drying is superior to freeze drying.     

Backscattered electron image of osmium‐impregnated/macerated tissues as a novel technique for identifying the cis‐face of the Golgi apparatus by high‐resolution scanning electron microscopy

The osmium maceration method with scanning electron microscopy (SEM) enabled to demonstrate directly the three‐dimensional (3D) structure of membranous cell organelles. However, the polarity of the Golgi apparatus (that is, the cis–trans axis) can hardly be determined by SEM alone, because there is no appropriate immunocytochemical method for specific labelling of its cis‐ or trans‐faces. In the present study, we used the osmium impregnation method, which forms deposits of reduced osmium exclusively in the cis‐Golgi elements, for preparation of specimens for SEM. The newly developed procedure combining osmium impregnation with subsequent osmium maceration specifically visualised the cis‐elements of the Golgi apparatus, with osmium deposits that were clearly detected by backscattered electron‐mode SEM. Prolonged osmication by osmium impregnation (2% OsO₄ solution at 40°C for 40 h) and osmium maceration (0.1% OsO₄ solution at 20°C for 24 h) did not significantly impair the 3D ultrastructure of the membranous cell organelles, including the Golgi apparatus. This novel preparation method enabled us to determine the polarity of the Golgi apparatus with enough information about the surrounding 3D ultrastructure by SEM, and will contribute to our understanding of the global organisation of the entire Golgi apparatus in various differentiated cells.     

A new fixation procedure for preserving the ultrastructure of marine invertebrate tissues

Addition of 0·05% OsO₄ to a conventional glutaraldehyde fixative for the first 10 min of fixation was found to improve greatly the preservation of ultrastructure in the eggs of Urechis caupo. Several workers have since confirmed this result in other marine invertebrate tissues. Specific protocols and techniques are given. We believe that the OsO₄ rapidly renders the plasma membranes of cells freely permeable to glutaraldehyde, allowing faster penetration of this fixative. This method should be applicable to a wide variety of tissues that are difficult to fix.     

Comparison of manual and automatic processing of biological samples for electron microscopy

The ultrastructure of a sample can be observed by electron microscopy (EM), which has become an indispensable research tool in morphological studies. However, EM sample preparation techniques are complicated and time‐consuming, with a high labor cost. The current study was conducted to compare the conventional manual and automated methods for sample processing and post‐staining for electron microscopy. Automated sample processing reduces OsO₄ contamination, improves the efficiency of sample preparation and is easy to use. Therefore, the results of their study provide a practical and feasible method for the preparation of biological samples for electron microscopy.     

Preparation method for SEM and X-ray projection microscopy of mouse embryos

In this paper we described a new preparation method: Routine Bouin fixation of mammalian tissues (e.g. mouse-embryos) allows not only light microscopy, but also SEM and x-ray microscopic studies on the same samples. Bouin's fixative combined with 3% OsO₄ postfixation gave best contrast in SEM and x-ray projection microscopy.     

SEM sample preparation for cells on 3D scaffolds by freeze-drying and HMDS

Common dehydration methods of cells on biomaterials for scanning electron microscopy (SEM) include air drying, hexamethyldisilazane (HMDS) or tetramethysilane (TMS) treatment and critical point drying (CPD). On the other side, freeze-drying has been widely employed in dehydrating biological samples and also in preparing porous biomaterial scaffolds but not in preparing cells on three-dimensional (3D) biomaterials for SEM examination. In this study, we compare cells on porous hydroxyapatite (HA) prepared by air drying, HMDS and freeze-drying. The effects of fixation and using phosphate buffered saline (PBS) in the fixation were also assessed on three porous calcium phosphate (CaP) materials, namely, HA, α-tricalcium phosphate (α-TCP) and β-tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP) samples. There is no significant difference in samples prepared by HMDS treatment and freeze-drying viewed at low magnification. Besides, it is better not to use phosphate buffer in the fixation step for CaP materials to avoid undesirable spontaneous precipitation of CaPs. On the other hand, fewer exchanges of liquids are required for freeze-drying and hence chemical fixation may not be absolutely required for samples prepared by freeze-drying. Other technical details of the preparation were also investigated and discussed. This study suggests both HMDS and freeze-drying can be employed to dehydrate cells on 3D scaffolds for SEM examination.     

Morphological polarity in oral epithelial cells revealed by boric acid partial dissociation

Layers of epithelium were stripped with adhesive tape from the surface of rat palatal mucosa after that tissue had been fixed in OsO₄, treated in 0.2 M boric acid and critical point or freeze dried. Cell layers stripped off evenly with very few intracellular fractures. The oral surface of cells in the stratum corneum was characterized by small pits and raised cell boundaries. By contrast the deep aspect of these cells displayed microvilli and linear grooves which exactly matched the pits and raised boundaries on the opposing cell beneath. Partial dissociation with boric acid after OsO₄ fixation greatly assists the demonstration of complementary cell surfaces deep in the epithelium.     

Scanning electron microscopy of piliated Neisseria gonorrhoeae processed with hexamethyldisilazane

Piliated Neisseria gonorrhoeae are virulent and attach readily to some human mucosal cells. The study of interactions between piliated Neisseria gonorrhoeae and surface structures of eukaryotic cells in tissue culture requires consistent high resolution imaging in scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The combination of the fixatives glutaraldehyde, osmium, tannic acid, and uranyl acetate improves preservation of pili and other delicate structures. Following the critical point drying (CPD) process, pili bundles remained intact, but charging produced image distortion in most of the specimens. The use of hexamethyldisilazane (HMDS) with air drying substantially reduced charging and image distortion. Less contrast and greater resolution of pili bundles and surface structures of bacteria or tissue culture cells were obtained at magnifications of 10,000 or higher. As an alternative to CPD, HMDS processing of cell culture monolayers was simple and was more efficient when a large number of samples was processed.     

Air-drying of human leucocytes for scanning electron microscopy using the GTGO procedure

The utilization of tannic acid and guanidine hydrochloride as mordants for better osmium binding has been shown to serve as an excellent alternative to metal coating of organ tissue specimens for scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The present report describes the GTGO procedure, a modification of the TAO technique introduced by Murakami et al. (1977, 1978), which we have found successful for the preparation of air dried peripheral blood leucocytes for SEM studies. Air dried, GTGO-treated leucocytes show excellent preservation of surface features with minimal cell shrinkage. When critical point dried, GTGO-treated cells are examined, they also show less shrinkage than cells prepared with standard glutaraldehyde fixation and critical point drying. The potential application of this air drying procedure (GTGO-AD) to other soft biological specimens is currently under investigation. This technique is recommended as a new and effective air drying procedure for the successful preparation of cells for SEM.     

Drying cells for SEM, AFM and TEM by hexamethyldisilazane: a study on hepatic endothelial cells

Critical point drying (CPD) is a common method of drying biological specimens for scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Drying by evaporation of hexamethyldisilazane (HMDS) has been described as a good alternative. This method, however, is infrequently used. Therefore, we reassessed HMDS drying. Cultured rat hepatic sinusoidal endothelial cells (LEC), possessing fragile fenestrae and sieve plates, were subjected to CPD and HMDS drying and evaluated in the scanning electron microscope, atomic force microscope (AFM) and transmission electron microscope (TEM). We observed no differences between the two methods regarding cellular ultrastructure. In contrast with CPD, HMDS drying takes only a few minutes, less effort, low costs for chemicals and requires no equipment. We conclude that HMDS-dried specimens have equal quality to CPD ones. Furthermore, the method also proved useful for drying whole-mount cells for TEM and AFM.     

The effect varied scanning electron microscopy desiccation techniques has on demineralized dentin

The study objective was to assess (a) the effect of a rubbing‐application of ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) or citric acid (CA) has on the ultrastructure of surface dentin and (b) the effect of two scanning electron microscopy (SEM) desiccation preparation techniques have on the collagen surface produced. Treatment regions on proximal root surfaces of extracted human teeth were root planned to expose dentin. Cotton pellets soaked in either 30% CA or 24% EDTA solution were rubbed on the treatment region then processed for SEM using one of two desiccation techniques, that is, (a) critically point dried from liquid CO₂ (control) or (b) air‐dried from tetramethylsilane (experimental). Specimens were coated with gold/palladium and viewed/photographed with an SEM. Specimens of the control groups displayed tufted fibrils (CA > EDTA) with many dentin tubules being partially obscured by overhanging fibrils. Air‐dried specimens of both treatment groups displayed a flat intact monolayer devoid of a matted meshwork of fibrous collagen. Discrete fibril “sprigs,” emanating from the surface monolayer, were characteristic of the EDTA group only. The rubbing‐application of EDTA on dentin produces a tufted fibril surface somewhat similar to that produced by CA. Air‐drying desiccation of both resulted in marked distortion with fibril collapse/coalescence of the tufted collagen matrix.     

Freeze-substitution techniques for preparing nematodes for scanning electron microscopy

The effect of different substitution times, temperatures and the incorporation of fixatives on the preservation of three species of nematode for scanning electron microscopy by freeze substitution with methanol, followed by critical point drying, is investigated. Hammerschmidtiella diesingi adults and Trichostrongylus colubriformis infective juveniles were successfully preserved using methanol at 253 K as the substitution medium. Preservation deteriorated with long substitution times, suggesting the extraction of material and that substitution times should be kept as brief as possible. Panagrolaimus davidi was not successfully preserved using pure methanol, but preservation was improved by using fixatives in the substitution medium, the best results being obtained with 1% OsO₄/3% glutaraldehyde in methanol. A substitution temperature of 193 K did not give any improvement in preservation. The differences in the quality of preservation between the three species may be due to the relative ability of the cuticle to withstand collapse during critical point drying. Chemical fixation using cold fixative resulted in the retention of a natural posture but poor preservation, whereas hot fixatives resulted in good preservation but the loss of a natural posture. Freeze substitution in methanol may prove useful in the preparation of specimens possessing cuticles or cell walls which have sufficient strength to withstand the drying process (e.g. arthropods, plants, fungi, nematodes). More delicate specimens may require the incorporation of fixatives into the substitution medium or conventional fixation.     

A procedure for rupture-free preparation of confluently grown monolayer cells for scanning electron microscopy

Monolayers of PtK-1 and HeLa cells grown on glass or plastic supports are extremely susceptible to lacerations, e.g., splits and cracks caused mainly by shrinkage when prepared for scanning electron microscopy (SEM). We find that a four-step fixation procedure including glutaraldehyde, OsO₄, tannic acid, and uranylacetate application, in combination with critical point drying, drastically reduces these structural damages. In addition, the conductivity of the specimens is enhanced, so that they can be investigated without gold coating. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) investigation of perpendicular sections in the area of lacerations provides evidence that the subcortical cytoskeletal elements are of crucial importance in maintaining cell membrane stability during the preparations. Our relatively quick and simple procedure results in an improved structural appearance of the cells.     

The use of a simple method to avoid cell shrinkage during SEM preparation

In the course of preparing specimens for scanning electron microscopy, both glutaraldehyde and OsO₄-fixed cells exhibit a considerable shrinkage with a reduction of the mean cellular diameter of about 45% after critical point drying. However, if cells are successively treated with glutaraldehyde, OsO₄, tannic acid and uranyl acetate solutions, cellular shrinkage of only 5% is observed.     

Volume changes during preparation of mouse embryonic tissue for scanning electron microscopy

This paper describes the results of experiments in which the volume changes in mouse embryo limb samples were followed more or less continuously after fixation through dehydration and critical point drying, with in some instances data relating to post critical point drying shrinkage. 14 and 15 day p. c. mouse embryos were fixed in 3 % glutaraldehyde in cacodylate buffer and stored in this fixative until use. Single specimens were studied using a Quantimet image analysing computer to record the changes in projected area of the unmounted specimens as they were passed through the usual series of reagents according to various commonly used dehydration schedules. The area changes were converted to volume changes for the purposes of presentation in this paper. The Quantimet system could not be used to follow volume changes in the CPD bomb so that most experiments detail the volume in the intermediate fluid before CPD and the size of the specimen immediately after it was removed from the CPD bomb. A few experiments were conducted in which the specimens were measured whilst they were in the CPD bomb. The measurements relating to dehydration and CPD procedures were compared with measurements of air dried and freeze dried specimens. All three drying methods cause considerable shrinkage: freeze drying to 85 % of the glutaraldehyde fixed tissue volume; critical point drying to 41% (after 24 h); and air drying from a volatile solvent to about 18% of the fixed tissue volume. Air drying from water caused a shrinkage to about 12% of the original volume. There was no significant difference between the various commonly used CPD schedules or between GA only and GA + Os O₄ fixed tissue. CPD via cellosolve and CO₂ caused substantially more shrinkage than other methods. Dimensional changes during specimen preparation are probably associated with changes in shape and in relative relationships between organelles, cells and tissues having different compositions. This should be borne in mind by all those interpreting scanning electron micrographs of dried animal soft tissue specimens.     

Comparing different methods to fix and to dehydrate cells on alginate hydrogel scaffolds using scanning electron microscopy

Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) is commonly used in the analysis of scaffolds morphology, as well as cell attachment, morphology and spreading on to the scaffolds. However, so far a specific methodology to prepare the alginate hydrogel (AH) scaffolds for SEM analysis has not been evaluated. This study compared different methods to fix/dehydrate cells in AH scaffolds for SEM analysis. AH scaffolds were prepared and seeded with NIH/3T3 cell line; fixed with glutaraldehyde, osmium tetroxide, or the freeze drying method and analyzed by SEM. Results demonstrated that the freeze dried method interferes less with cell morphology and density, and preserves the scaffolds structure. The fixation with glutaraldehyde did not affect cells morphology and density; however, the scaffolds morphology was affected in some level. The fixation with osmium tetroxide interfered in the natural structure of cells and scaffold. In conclusion the freeze drying and glutaraldehyde are suitable methods for cell fixation in AH scaffold for SEM, although scaffolds structure seems to be affected by glutaraldehyde. Microsc. Res. Tech. 78:553–561, 2015. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

The fixation,dehydration, drying and coating of cultured cells for SEM

Cultivated cells form a valuable model system for studies on the effects of various preparative protocols for scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The various effects of each preparative step can be followed in detail in the light microscope and no diffusion gradients complicate the fixation and other procedures as in the case of solid tissues. Studies on cultivated cells indicate that the glutaraldehyde component of a glutaraldehyde-based fixative does not contribute to the effective osmotic pressure of the fixative and thus the osmolarity of the buffer, and other components, must be equalized to that of the medium in which the cells grow. Even small deviations from this ideal effective osmotic pressure will result in osmotically induced artefacts. Disturbances of pH and temperature of the cultures prior to and during fixation will result in changes in the appearance of many cellular structures such as microspikes and ruffles. We find that osmium fixation is advisable in most instances for best possible membrane preservation and that even long periods of glutaraldehyde fixation do not compensate for osmium fixation. Dehydration always results in shrinkage. Freeze drying (FD) and critical point drying (CPD) also give rise to shrinkage, the former to a lesser degree than the latter. A gold-palladium alloy gives a less granular coating that does gold alone. When cultured cells are studied, a metal thickness of between 5 and 15 nm is usually sufficient to give rise to an adequate secondary electron production and to avoid charging even at accelerating voltages of 30–40 kV. Without treatment with OsO₄ a thicker metal coating is required.     

Effects of glutaraldehyde fixative osmolarities on smooth muscle cell volume,and osmotic reactivity of the cells after fixation

The contribution of glutaraldehyde (GA) to the effective osmolarity of GA fixatives, the osmotic reactivity of the cells after fixation in GA, and also the duration of fixation in GA on cell volume, were investigated using cultured smooth muscle cells (SMC) and spiral aortic strips. Four fixation procedures were studied. We found that GA contributes to the total effective osmolarity of the fixatives, and that the type of buffers used for the fixatives can also affect the cell volume differently during GA fixation. After GA fixation, the cells were still osmotically reactive, regardless of the buffer types for making up the GA fixatives, so that the osmolarity of the wash buffer after GA fixation is important. However, OsO₄ eliminates osmotic responses, thus the osmolarity of OsO₄ fixative and wash buffer have negligible influence on the cell volume. Longer fixation time up to 4 h had no effect on the cell volume.     

New application of air-drying techniques for studying Ephemeroptera and Plecoptera eggs by scanning electron microscopy

Hexamethyldisilizane (HMDS) and tetramethylsilane are organic compounds that are volatile at ambient temperature and which can therefore be used for air-drying biological samples for SEM studies. The techniques using these compounds provide results that are comparable with those obtained by critical point drying, but which involve a very simple process that saves time and money. Both techniques were applied to SEM studies of Ephemeroptera and Plecoptera eggs in order to assess their suitability as alternative methods to critical point drying for these kinds of biological material. The results show no morphological differences between eggs HMDS air-dried and critical point-dried.     

Effects of fixation on electrophysiology and structure of human jejunal villi

The villi of human jejunum vary in size and shape during different functional conditions. In the base the lamina propria is isotonic with blood, in the tip hyperosmotic. Here we study electrophysiological and morphological effects of incubation in hypotonic, isotonic, or hypertonic solutions, and to test various isotonic fixatives for microscopy. Samples of jejunal mucosae, obtained during surgery in obese patients, were studied in Ussing chambers where electrical parameters were registered during incubation in Krebs solution at various osmolarities, and during fixation in formaldehyde, glutaraldehyde, or osmium tetroxide (OsO₄). The same fixatives were used for other jejunal specimens that were fixed directly for light microscopy. Morphometry was carried out to determine size and height of villi, proportion of lamina propria, and surface enlargement due to villi. Ussing chamber incubation in fluids with low osmolarity resulted in increased electrical resistance and epithelial swelling. Opposite results were obtained at high osmolality. Fixation was faster in formaldehyde than in glutaraldehyde or OsO₄. In biopsies processed directly for light microscopy the proportions of lamina propria of the mucosa, and of lamina propria of villi, were significantly larger in biopsies fixed in formaldehyde than after fixation in glutaraldehyde or OsO₄. The villus tips sometimes ended with a bleb with prominent spaces between the epithelial cells. In summary, jejunal villi swell in vitro when exposed to hypotonic solutions, and shrink in hypertonic solutions. Much of the morphological changes occurring during fixation can be related to the physiological hyperosmolar milieu in villus tips.