Mutual activation of two restriction endonucleases: interaction of EcoP1 and EcoP15

Type III restriction endonucleases recognize nonsymmetric nucleotide sequences. A necessary condition for DNA cleavage is the presence of two unmethylated recognition sites which are inversely ('head-to-head') oriented in the DNA double strand. A DNA substrate possessing one EcoP1 and one EcoP15 site in the head-to-head configuration could not be cleaved by the individual enzymes, however, it was specifically digested in the simultaneous presence of both enzymes. In agreement with the tracking-collision model for the DNA interaction of type III enzymes cleavage could be abolished by Lac repressor bound between the two sites. We conclude that two different type III enzymes can functionally cooperate in the cleavage of DNA.     

Formation of a cleavasome: enhancer DNA-2 stabilizes an active conformation of NaeI dimer

Cleavage of DNA by NaeI-type restriction enzymes is stimulated by a DNA element with affinity for the activator site of the enzyme: a cleavage-enhancer DNA element. Measurements of the mobility of NaeI activity in comparison with protein standards on gel permeation columns and glycerol gradients demonstrated that NaeI, without enhancer, can form a 70,000 MW dimer. The dimer, however, is inactive: it could not cleave the "resistant" NaeI site in M13mp18 DNA in the absence of enhancer. In cleavage assays, enhancer stimulated either DNA nicking or DNA cleavage, depending upon NaeI concentration, and reduced the NaeI concentration required for the transition from nicking to cleavage activity. A gel mobility-shift assay of the interaction of NaeI with enhancer showed the formation of two complexes. Results using different sized DNAs and different percentage acrylamide gels for gel mobility-shift analysis implied that the two complexes were caused by NaeI monomer and dimer structures rather than one and two DNA binding. Dimer formation increased with the affinity of enhancer for NaeI. UV cross-linking "captured" the NaeI-enhancer complex; electrophoretic analysis of the cross-linked products showed NaeI dimer bound to enhancer. These results imply a model for cleavage enhancement in which enhancer binding stabilizes an active NaeI dimer conformation ("cleavasome") that cleaves both DNA strands before dissociating.     

Crystal structure of restriction endonuclease BglI bound to its interrupted DNA recognition sequence

The crystal structure of the type II restriction endonuclease BglI bound to DNA containing its specific recognition sequence has been determined at 2.2 A resolution. This is the first structure of a restriction endonuclease that recognizes and cleaves an interrupted DNA sequence, producing 3' overhanging ends. BglI is a homodimer that binds its specific DNA sequence with the minor groove facing the protein. Parts of the enzyme reach into both the major and minor grooves to contact the edges of the bases within the recognition half-sites. The arrangement of active site residues is strikingly similar to other restriction endonucleases, but the co-ordination of two calcium ions at the active site gives new insight into the catalytic mechanism. Surprisingly, the core of a BglI subunit displays a striking similarity to subunits of EcoRV and PvuII, but the dimer structure is dramatically different. The BglI-DNA complex demonstrates, for the first time, that a conserved subunit fold can dimerize in more than one way, resulting in different DNA cleavage patterns.     

Dependence of McrBC cleavage on distance between recognition elements

DNA cleavage by the modification-dependent restriction enzyme McrBC requires the presence of two suitably modified recognition elements appropriately spaced in the substrate. To characterize the spacing requirement in more detail, we have constructed a plasmid with a single McrBC cleavage site, in which the distance between recognition elements could be systematically varied while preserving the local sequence surrounding the recognition elements. Optimal separation between elements was 55-103 basepairs, with detectable cleavage observed at spacing of 32 bp to 2 kb; no cleavage was seen with spacing of 22 bp or less or with 3 kb between elements. Changing the spacing by 4 basepairs within the optimal range had little effect on the efficiency of cleavage, suggesting that the recognition elements need not lie on the same face of the DNA helix.     

Mechanism of active site exclusion in a site-specific recombinase: role of the DNA substrate in conferring half-of-the-sites activity

The Flp site-specific recombinase assembles its active site by recruiting the catalytic tyrosine (Tyr-343) from one Flp monomer into the pro-active site containing a triad of Arg-191, His-305, and Arg-308 from a second monomer. In principle, two active sites may be assembled from a Flp dimer by simultaneous, reciprocal contribution of the shared amino acids by its constituent monomers. In practice, only one of the two active sites is assembled at a time, as would be consistent with a recombination mechanism involving two steps of single-strand exchanges. By using substrates containing strand-specific base bulges, we demonstrate that the relative disposition of their DNA arms can account for this active site exclusion. We also show that the exclusion mechanism operates only at the level of positioning Tyr-343 with respect to the pro-active site, and not at the level of orienting the labile phosphodiester bond within the DNA chain. It is not negative cooperativity of substrate binding but, rather, the substrate-induced negative cooperativity in protein orientation that accomplishes half-of-the-sites activity in the Flp system.     

Changing endonuclease EcoRII Tyr308 to Phe abolishes cleavage but not recognition: possible homology with the Int-family of recombinases

Endonuclease EcoRII is one of a group of type II restriction enzymes, including Nael, Narl, BspMI, HpaII, and SacII, that require binding of an enhancer sequence to cleave DNA. Comparison of the EcoRII amino-acid sequence with the amino-acid consensus motifs that differentiate between recombinase families uncovered similarity between a 29 amino-acid sequence in the carboxyl end of EcoRII and the motif defining the integrase family of recombinases. This similarity implied that EcoRII tyrosine 308 should be involved in catalyzing hydrolysis of the scissile bond. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to mutate Tyr308 to Phe. The phenylalanine-substituted enzyme could not cleave T5 DNA under conditions in which wild-type enzyme completely cleaved this DNA. The Tyr308 to Phe mutation abolished cleavage activity but not specific binding to DNA. No evidence was found for the existence during the cleavage reaction of a covalent linkage between Tyr308 and DNA.     

Recombination by resolvase to analyse DNA communications by the SfiI restriction endonuclease

The SfiI endonuclease differs from other type II restriction enzymes by cleaving DNA concertedly at two copies of its recognition site, its optimal activity being with two sites on the same DNA molecule. The nature of this communication event between distant DNA sites was analysed on plasmids with recognition sites for SfiI interspersed with recombination sites for resolvase. These were converted by resolvase to catenanes carrying one SfiI site on each ring. The catenanes were cleaved by SfiI almost as readily as a single ring with two sites, in contrast to the slow reactions on DNA rings with one SfiI site. Interactions between SfiI sites on the same DNA therefore cannot follow the DNA contour and, instead, must stem from their physical proximity. In buffer lacking Mg2+, where SfiI is inactive while resolvase is active, the addition of SfiI to a plasmid with target sites for both proteins blocked recombination by resolvase, due to the restriction enzyme bridging its sites and thus isolating the sites for resolvase into separate loops. The extent of DNA looping by SfiI matched its extent of DNA cleavage in the presence of Mg2+.     

Construction and validation of yeast artificial chromosome contig maps by RecA-assisted restriction endonuclease cleavage

RecA-assisted restriction endonuclease (RARE) cleavage is an "Achilles' heel" approach to restriction mapping whereby a RecA-protein-oligodeoxynucleotide complex protects an individual restriction site from methylation, thus limiting subsequent digestion to a single, predetermined site. We have used RARE cleavage to cut yeast artificial chromosomes (YACs) at specific EcoRI sites located within or adjacent to sequence-tagged sites (STSs). Each cleavage reaction produces two YAC fragments whose sizes are a direct measure of the position of the STS in the YAC. In this fashion, we have positioned 45 STSs within a contig of 19 independent YACs and constructed a detailed RARE-cleavage map that represents 8.4 Mbp of human chromosome 6p21.3-22. By comparing maps of overlapping YACs, we were able to detect seven internal deletions that ranged from approximately 75 kbp to approximately 1 Mbp in size. Thirteen pairs of EcoRI sites were targeted for double RARE cleavage in uncloned total human DNA. The excised fragments, up to 2 Mbp in size, were resolved by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis and were detected by hybridization. In general, the genomic RARE-cleavage results support the YAC-based map. In one case, the distance in uncloned DNA between the two terminal EcoRI sites of a YAC insert was approximately 1 Mbp larger than the YAC itself, indicating a major deletion. The general concept of RARE-cleavage mapping as well as its applications and limitations are discussed.     

Asp34 of PvuII endonuclease is directly involved in DNA minor groove recognition and indirectly involved in catalysis

The PvuII restriction endonuclease is a homodimer that recognizes and cleaves the DNA sequence 5'-CAGCTG-3' in double-stranded DNA, and the structure of this enzyme has been reported. In the wild-type enzyme, Asp34 interacts with the internal guanine of the recognition sequence on the minor groove side. The Asp34 codon was altered to specify Gly (D34G), and in vitro studies have revealed that the D34G protein has lost binding specificity for the central G.C base-pairs, and that it cuts the canonical sequence with 10(-4)-fold reduced activity as compared to the wild-type enzyme. We have now determined the structure at 1.59 A resolution of the D34G PvuII endonuclease complexed with a 12 bp duplex deoxyoligonucleotide containing the cognate sequence. The D34G alteration results in several structural changes relative to wild-type protein/DNA complexes. First, the sugar moiety of the internal guanine changes from a C2'-endo to C3'-endo pucker while that of the 3' guanine changes from C3'-endo to C2'-endo pucker. Second, the axial rise between the internal G.C base-pairs is reduced while that between the G.C and flanking base-pairs is expanded. Third, two distinct monomeric active sites are observed that we refer to as being "primed" and "unprimed" for phosphodiester bond cleavage. The primed and unprimed sites differ in the conformation of the Asp58 side-chain, and in the absence from unprimed sites of four networked water molecules. These water molecules, present in the primed site, have been implicated in the catalytic mechanism of this and other endonucleases; some of them can be replaced by the Mg2+ necessary for cleavage. Taken together, these structural changes imply that the Asp34 side-chains from the two subunits maintain a distinct conformation of its DNA substrate, properly situating the target backbone phosphates and indirectly manipulating the active sites. This provides some insight into how recognition of the specific DNA sequence is linked to catalysis by the highly specific restriction endonucleases, and reveals one way in which the structural conformation of the DNA is modulated coordinately with that of the PvuII protein.     

A novel system for the rapid generation of precise DNA deletions

To generate DNA deletions, a tandem array of class IIS restriction enzyme recognition sites was cloned into a plasmid. The recognition sites were arranged so that each enzyme cleaves at a different site within an adjacent target sequence. Digestion with both enzymes followed by end repair and ligation resulted in the deletion of DNA between the two sites of cleavage. Because both recognition sites are preserved following deletion, it was found that sequential deletions could be generated using cycles of restriction enzyme digestion, end repair and ligation. Therefore, this system represents a valuable tool in the definition of functional DNA sequences.     

Sequence specific modulation of DNA restriction enzyme cleavage by minor groove binders

The inhibition of restriction endonuclease cleavage by a series of bisquaternary ammonium derivatives (BQA-derivatives) which bind to the minor groove of DNA has been studied. The derivatives considered included six sequence-selective binders (SN 6570, SN 6999, SN 6050, SN 6132, SN 6131 and SN 18071) and four non-specific binders (SN 6113, SN 5754, SN 6324 and SN 4094) and can be distinguished by their activity on restriction endonucleases. Digestion experiments with pUC19 DNA were monitored electrophoretically using the transition of the covalently closed circular (ccc) DNA into the linear double stranded (lds) one. Only the sequence-specific binders inhibit the cleavage activity of restriction endonucleases EcoRI, SspI and DraI with four and six dAdT-base pairs within their restriction sites, while the activity of SalI and BamHI with less than four dAdT-sequences was unaffected. In contrast, the non-specific binding ligands were incapable of suppressing enzyme digestion. The inhibition of the restriction endonuclease PvuII indicates that ligand binding in close vicinity to the cleavage sites is also involved in the enzyme inhibition. The dAdT-content in proximity to the palindromic sequences of three DraI cutting sites in pUC19 DNA explains why the derivative SN 6053 protects these sequences in different manners. Gel shift experiments indicated that BQA-derivatives inhibit the DNA-enzyme complex formation if the ligand was added to the DNA before the enzyme. In contrast, complex formation between DNA and enzyme remained unchanged when the enzyme was added first.     

Sequence-specific DNA binding by EcoKI, a type IA DNA restriction enzyme

The type I DNA restriction and modification enzymes of prokaryotes are multimeric enzymes that cleave unmethylated, foreign DNA in a complex process involving recognition of the methylation status of a DNA target sequence, extensive translocation of DNA in both directions towards the enzyme bound at the target sequence, ATP hydrolysis, which is believed to drive the translocation possibly via a helicase mechanism, and eventual endonucleolytic cleavage of the DNA. We have examined the DNA binding affinity and exonuclease III footprint of the EcoKI type IA restriction enzyme on oligonucleotide duplexes that either contain or lack the target sequence. The influence of the cofactors, S-adenosyl methionine and ATP, on binding to DNA of different methylation states has been assessed. EcoKI in the absence of ATP, with or without S-adenosyl methionine, binds tightly even to DNA lacking the target site and the exonuclease footprint is large, approximately 45 base-pairs. The protection is weaker on DNA lacking the target site. Partially assembled EcoKI lacking one or both of the subunits essential for DNA cleavage, is unable to bind tightly to DNA lacking the target site but can bind tightly to the recognition site. The addition of ATP to EcoKI, in the presence of AdoMet, allows tight binding only to the target site and the footprint shrinks to 30 base-pairs, almost identical to that of the modification enzyme which makes up the core of EcoKI. The same effect occurs when S-adenosyl homocysteine or sinefungin are substituted for S-adenosyl methionine, and ADP or ATPgammaS are substituted for ATP. It is proposed that the DNA binding surface of EcoKI comprises three regions: a "core" region which recognises the target sequence and which is present on the modification enzyme, and a region on each DNA cleavage subunit. The cleavage subunits make tight contacts to any DNA molecule in the absence of cofactors, but this contact is weakened in the presence of cofactors to allow the protein conformational changes required for DNA translocation when a target site is recognised by the core modification enzyme. This weakening of the interaction between the DNA cleavage subunits and the DNA could allow more access of exonuclease III to the DNA and account for the shorter footprint.     

Roles of the helicase and primase domain of the gene 4 protein of bacteriophage T7 in accessing the primase recognition site

The 63 kDa gene 4 protein of bacteriophage T7 provides both helicase and primase activities. The C-terminal helicase domain of the gene 4 protein is responsible for DNA-dependent NTP hydrolysis and for hexamer formation, whereas the N-terminal primase domain contains the zinc motif that is, in part, responsible for template-directed oligoribonucleotide synthesis. In the presence of beta, gamma-methylene dTTP, the protein forms a hexamer that surrounds and binds tightly to single-stranded DNA and consequently is unable to translocate to primase recognition sites, 5'-GTC-3', or to dissociate from the molecule to which it is bound. Nonetheless, in the presence of beta,gamma-methylene dTTP, it catalyzes the synthesis of pppAC dimers at primase sites on M13 DNA. When bound to single-stranded DNA in the presence of beta,gamma-methylene dTTP, the primase can function at recognition sites on the same molecule to which it is bound provided that a sufficient distance exists between the recognition site and the site to which it is bound. Furthermore, the primase bound to one DNA strand can function at a primase site located on a second DNA strand. The results indicate that the primase domain resides on the outside of the hexameric ring, a location that enables it to access sites distal to its site of binding.     

Structure of FokI has implications for DNA cleavage

FokI is a member an unusual class of restriction enzymes that recognize a specific DNA sequence and cleave nonspecifically a short distance away from that sequence. FokI consists of an N-terminal DNA recognition domain and a C-terminal cleavage domain. The bipartite nature of FokI has led to the development of artificial enzymes with novel specificities. We have solved the structure of FokI to 2.3 A resolution. The structure reveals a dimer, in which the dimerization interface is mediated by the cleavage domain. Each monomer has an overall conformation similar to that found in the FokI-DNA complex, with the cleavage domain packing alongside the DNA recognition domain. In corroboration with the cleavage data presented in the accompanying paper in this issue of Proceedings, we propose a model for FokI DNA cleavage that requires the dimerization of FokI on DNA to cleave both DNA strands.     

High resolution crystal structure of a paired (Pax) class cooperative homeodomain dimer on DNA

The crystal structure of the paired homeodomain bound to DNA as a cooperative dimer has been determined to 2.0 A resolution. Direct contacts between each homeodomain and the DNA are similar to those described previously. In addition, an extensive network of water molecules mediates contacts between the recognition helix and the DNA major groove. Several symmetrical contacts between the two homeodomains underlie the cooperative interaction, and deformations in the DNA structure are necessary for the establishment of these contacts. Comparison with structures of homeodomains bound monomerically to DNA suggests that the binding of a single paired homeodomain can introduce these DNA distortions, thus preparing a template for the cooperative interaction with a second homeodomain. This study shows how the paired (Pax) class homeodomains have achieved cooperativity in DNA binding without the assistance of other domains, thereby enabling the recognition of target sequences that are long enough to ensure specificity.     

Asymmetry in Flp-mediated cleavage

Flp is a member of the integrase family of site-specific recombinases. Members of the integrase family mediate DNA strand cleavage via a transesterification reaction involving an active site tyrosine residue. The first step of the reaction results in covalent linkage of the protein to the 3'-phosphoryl DNA terminus, leaving a 5'-hydroxyl group at the site of the nick. We have used Flp recognition target (FRT) sites containing a 5'-bridging phosphorothioate linkage at the site of Flp cleavage to accumulate intermediates in which Flp is covalently bound at a cleavage site. We have probed these intermediates with dimethylsulfate using methylation protection and find that Flp-mediated cleavage is associated with protection of two adenine residues that are opposite the sites of cleavage and covalent attachment by Flp. Methylation interference studies showed that cleavage and covalent attachment are also accompanied by differences in the contacts of Flp with each of the two cleavage sites and with the surrounding symmetry elements. Therefore, we provide evidence that Flp-mediated cleavage and covalent attachment result in changes to the conformation of the Flp-FRT complex. These changes may be required for Flp-mediated strand exchange activity.     

Modulation of the activity of RNase E in vitro by RNA sequences and secondary structures 5' to cleavage sites

The endoribonuclease RNase E is believed to initiate the degradation of many mRNAs in Escherichia coli, yet the mechanism by which it recognizes cleavage sites is poorly understood. We have prepared derivatives of the mRNA encoding ribosomal protein S20 which contain a single major RNase E cleavage site at residues 300/301 preceded by variable 5' extensions. Three of these RNAs are cleaved in vitro with significantly reduced efficiencies relative to the intact S20 mRNA by both crude RNase E and pure Rne protein (endonuclease component of RNase E). In all three substrates as well as in the full-length mRNA the major cleavage site itself remains single-stranded. One such substrate (t84D) contains a 5' stem-loop structure characterized by three noncanonical A-G pairs. Removal or denaturation of the stem restores efficient cleavage at the major RNase E site. The other two contain single-stranded 5'-termini but apparently lack cleavage sites near the termini. Our data show that sensitivity to RNase E can be influenced by distant structural motifs in the RNA and also suggest a model in which the initial recognition and cleavage of a substrate near its 5' end facilitates sequential cleavages at more distal sites. The model implies that RNase E contains at least a dimer of the Rne subunit and that the products of the first cleavage are retained by Rne prior to the second cleavage.     

The paradoxical influence of thymine analogues on restriction endonuclease cleavage of oligodeoxynucleotides

Thymine residues in the DNA of eucaryotes may be replaced occasionally by uracil (U) or 5-(hydroxymethyl)uracil (H) as consequences of dUMP misincorporation or thymine oxidation, respectively. In this study, we constructed a series of 44-base oligonucleotides containing site-specific U or H residues and 5'-fluorescein labels in order to probe the influence of such modifications on sequence-specific DNA-protein interactions using several type II restriction endonucleases. We find that substitution within the recognition sites of several restriction endonucleases increases initial cleavage velocity by up to an order of magnitude. These results contrast dramatically with several previous studies which demonstrated that U substitution in short oligonucleotides inhibits or prevents nuclease cleavage. We propose that this apparent paradox results because the rate-limiting step in the cleavage of longer oligonucleotides is product release whereas for shorter oligonucleotides substrate binding is most probably rate-limiting. For longer oligonucleotides and DNA, more rapid release of the cleaved, substituted oligonucleotides results in more rapid turnover and a faster apparent cleavage rate. The sequence length at which the transition in rate-limiting step occurs likely corresponds to the size of the enzyme footprint on its DNA recognition site. We conclude that both U and H do perturb sequence-specific DNA-protein interactions, and the magnitude of this effect is site-dependent.