Investigation of R-744 Voorhees transcritical heat pump system

Using economizer in R-744 heat pump cycle is an effective way to improve the heating capacity in cold climates. In this paper, a modification construction of reciprocating compressor with economizer port, a Voorhees compressor was introduced and the heat pump cycle with Voorhees economizer was compared with the traditional screw or scroll economizer cycles. Both the R-744 transcritical heat pumps with and without Voorhees economizer were tested at the same conditions with different air mass flow rates and different evaporating temperatures. The results show that the heating capacity of the heat pump with Voorhees economizer can be two times higher than the transcritical heat pump without economizer at low evaporating temperature conditions. At the same capacity operation conditions, the efficiency of the heat pump with Voorhees economizer is higher at high refrigerant mass flow rate conditions. The optimum discharge pressure of the heat pump with Voorhees economizer is found to be higher than the heat pump without economizer at the same ambient conditions. For mobile heat pump application, CO₂ transcritical heat pump with Voorhees economizer demonstrates better performance comparing to the conventional transcritical CO₂ heat pump without economizer when the evaporating temperature is lower than −20 °C, or when the mobile is idling with low compressor RPM.     

R-744 gas cooler model development and validation

A first principles-based model was developed for a transcritical CO₂ gas cooler, using a finite element method. The model uses published correlations for refrigerant and airside heat transfer and pressure drop. Experimental results are presented at 48 operating conditions. The model predicted the gas cooler capacity within ±2% and pressure drop on the R-744 side well within the range of experimental error. The model's usefulness is demonstrated by analyzing alternative circuiting and multi-slab designs.     

Piston-cylinder work producing expansion device in a transcritical carbon dioxide cycle. Part I: experimental investigation

A simulation model for a piston-cylinder type expansion device in which the linear motion of the piston is converted to the rotational motion of a crank via a connecting rod was developed for its use in a transcritical CO₂ cycle. The model is based on lubrication theory with an assumption that the piston ring is a slippery bearing. This model has been used to verify the proper operation of the device in a prototype application and to identify the loss mechanisms of the device in the design stage. In addition, an analysis of the device has been conducted using this theoretical model for the device as installed in a prototype cycle as reported in a companion part I paper.     

Experimental validation of a prototype ejector designed to reduce throttling losses encountered in transcritical R744 system operation

This study presents experimental results obtained from a transcritical R744 system using a refrigerant ejector. The results were compared to that of a conventional system with an expansion valve. For the test conditions considered, the cooling capacity and COP simultaneously improved by up to 8% and 7%, respectively. Experiments were analyzed to quantitatively assess the effects on system performance as a result of changes in basic ejector dimensions such as motive nozzle and diffuser sizing. Small angles of 5° yielded best results for the static pressure recovery of the high-speed two-phase flow entering the diffuser. Experiments confirmed that like in a conventional transcritical R744 system with expansion valve, the high-side pressure control integrated into the ejector could be used to maximize the system performance. Numerical simulation results helped identifying this basic trend. Due to difficulties in the ejector throat pressure measurements, a more practical performance metric was introduced in order to quantify overall ejector efficiencies. According to this definition, the prototype ejector was able to recover up to 14.5% of the throttling losses.     

Thermodynamic analysis of an R744–R717 cascade refrigeration system

A thermodynamic analysis of carbon dioxide–ammonia (R744–R717) cascade refrigeration system is presented in this paper to optimize the design and operating parameters of the system. The design and operating parameters considered in this study include (1) condensing, subcooling, evaporating and superheating temperatures in the ammonia (R717) high-temperature circuit, (2) temperature difference in the cascade heat exchanger, and (3) evaporating, superheating, condensing and subcooling in the carbon dioxide (R744) low-temperature circuit. A multilinear regression analysis was employed in terms of subcooling, superheating, evaporating, condensing, and cascade heat exchanger temperature difference in order to develop mathematical expressions for maximum COP, an optimum evaporating temperature of R717 and an optimum mass flow ratio of R717 to that of R744 in the cascade system.     

Exergy maximization of cascade refrigeration cycles and its numerical verification for a transcritical CO2–C3H8 system

Analysis of an endoreversible two-stage cascade cycle has been implemented and optimum intermediate temperature for maximum exergy and refrigeration effect have been obtained analytically. Further, the heat reservoir temperatures has been optimised independently. A comprehensive numerical model of a transcritical CO₂–C₃H₈ cascade system was developed with intent to verify the theoretical results. It is seen that the simulation results agree well for optimal T_L but deviate modestly from the theoretical optimum of T_H. It has also been observed that system performance improves as T_H increases and unlike theoretical predictions, no optimal T_H is present within feasible working temperatures.     

Experimental study of the refrigeration cycle performance for the R744/R290 mixtures

A new binary mixture of R744 and R290 as an alternative natural refrigerant to R13 was first presented in this paper. Its environmental performance is friendly. It has an ODP of zero and GWP smaller than 20. Experimental studies for this mixture and R13 were performed on a cascade refrigeration system only with modification to capillary in low-temperature circuit. COP and refrigeration capacity of this binary mixture were higher than those of R13, at the same time, condensing pressure, evaporating pressure, compression ratio, and discharge temperature were also higher than that of R13 when the high-temperature circuit of cascade refrigeration system was kept invariable. The new binary mixture of R744 and R290 is considered as a promising alternative refrigerant to R13 when the evaporator temperature is higher than 201 K.     

Effect of heat conduction through the fins of a microchannel serpentine gas cooler of transcritical CO2 system

This paper presents results of an experimental study to investigate the effect of conduction through the fins on the capacity of a serpentine gas cooler. The gas cooler was a part of a transcritical CO₂ system which was operated in A/C mode. The capacity of the gas cooler was carefully measured in the chamber which simulated the outdoor condition with the original heat exchanger. In order to experimentally validate the conduction effect on the capacity, some sections of the fins, where the conduction was most significant, were cut by EDM (Electrical Discharge Machining). The capacity of the heat exchanger, after cutting fins, was measured in the same chamber at nearly identical test conditions as before cutting. Gas cooler capacity was improved up to 3.9% by cutting the fins, and temperature difference between refrigerant exit and air inlet for the gas cooler was reduced by 0.9–1.5 °C. The maximum uncertainty in the capacity measurements was 2.5% and the accuracy of temperature measurements was 0.1 °C. It was shown by system simulation that system COP could be improved by 5% by eliminating this severe conduction effect, as was done in this experiment. The tube surface temperature at some points of the gas cooler was measured and infrared images were taken to show the conduction effect before and after cutting fins.     

Natural refrigerant-based subcritical and transcritical cycles for high temperature heating

Theoretical analyses of subcritical/transcritical heat pumps using four natural refrigerants, carbon dioxide, ammonia, propane and isobutane have been carried out for high temperature heating applications at different heating outlet temperatures and heat sources using computer models. The compressor discharge pressures have been optimized for transcritical and subcritical (with near critical operation of condenser) cycles. Results show that for subcritical heat pumps, use of subcooling is efficient for heating applications with a gliding temperature. Results also show that although propane yields better coefficient of performance (COP) in low temperature heating applications, ammonia performs the best in high temperature heating applications. Finally, design aspects of major components of all the four heat pumps for high temperature heating have been discussed, particularly with reference to suitability of available lubricants to the newly evolved operating conditions.     

Control optimisation of CO2 cycles for medium temperature retail food refrigeration systems

This paper describes a detailed procedure into the investigation of optimised control strategies for CO₂ cycles in medium temperature retail food refrigeration systems. To achieve this objective, an integrated model was developed composing of a detailed condenser/gas cooler model, a simplified compressor model, an isenthalpic expansion process and constant evaporating temperature and superheating. The CO₂ system can operate subcritically or transcritically depending on the ambient temperature. For a transcritical operation, a prediction can be made for optimised refrigerant discharge pressures from thermodynamic cycle calculations. When the system operates in the subcritical cycle, a floating discharge pressure control strategy is employed and the effect of different transitional ambient temperatures separating subcritical and transcritical cycles on system performance is investigated. The control strategy assumes variable compressor speed and adjustable air flow for the gas cooler/condenser to be modulated to achieve the constant cooling load requirement at different ambient conditions.     

Blends of carbon dioxide and HFCs as working fluids for the low-temperature circuit in cascade refrigerating systems

This paper describes an analysis on the performances of a cascade refrigeration cycle operated with blends of carbon dioxide (CO₂, or R744) and hydrofluorocarbons (HFC) as the low-temperature working fluid. The aim of this work was to study the possibility of using carbon dioxide mixtures in those applications where temperatures below CO₂ triple point (216.58 K) are needed. The analysis was carried out by developing a software based on the Carnahan–Starling–De Santis (CSD) equation of state (EoS) using binary interaction parameters derived from our experimental data. The properties of the investigated blends (R744/R125, R744/R41, R744/R32, R744/R23) were used to simulate the behavior of a cascade cycle using ammonia (R717) as the high-temperature-circuit working fluid and operating at evaporating temperatures down to −70 °C. The use of a suction–liquid heat exchanger on the low-temperature side of the circuit was also investigated. Results show that the R744 blends are an attractive option for the low-temperature circuit of cascade systems operating at temperatures approaching 200 K.     

Transcritical CO2 refrigeration cycle with ejector-expansion device

An ejector expansion transcritical CO₂ refrigeration cycle is proposed to improve the COP of the basic transcritical CO₂ cycle by reducing the expansion process losses. A constant pressure mixing model for the ejector was established to perform the thermodynamic analysis of the ejector expansion transcritical CO₂ cycle. The effect of the entrainment ratio and the pressure drop in the receiving section of the ejector on the relative performance of the ejector expansion transcritical CO₂ cycle was investigated for typical air conditioning operation conditions. The effect of different operating conditions on the relative performance of the ejector expansion transcritical CO₂ cycle was also investigated using assumed values for the entrainment ratio and pressure drop in the receiving section of the ejector. It was found that the COP of the ejector expansion transcritical CO₂ cycle can be improved by more than 16% over the basic transcritical CO₂ cycle for typical air conditioning operation conditions.     

Commercial refrigeration system using CO2 as the refrigerant

Various field-test systems using carbon dioxide as the only refrigerant have been installed since December 2001. In this paper we will analyse an ‘all-CO₂’ supermarket, which has been operating in the North of Italy since January 2003.The seasonal COP is calculated, based on prior laboratory measurements, and a comparison is made with a conventional direct expansion system using R404A.The total annual energy consumption of the installed CO₂ system is estimated to be about 10% higher than the direct expansion R404A solution. It is still possible to further improve efficiency and approach the efficiency of present R404A systems. These improvements are identified.The cost of the CO₂ installation is compared to the cost of an equivalent direct expansion R404A installation, the most economic among the various present types of commercial refrigeration systems. Because of the lack of suitable mass-produced components, the CO₂ installation is estimated to be, today, about 20% more expensive.     

Experimental investigation of a bottle-sublimation cooler

A bottle-sublimation cooler is an open-cycle cooler of novel design combining the advantages of Joule–Thomson and sublimation coolers. The store of a refrigerant is bottled without heat leakages at ambient temperature. Sublimation of the refrigerant solid phase is the cold-generating process in the cooler. The cooler design and a discovered effect of the solid phase spontaneous capillary-porous structuring provide autoadjustability of the system operational characteristics. The results of experimental investigations of the stored-carbon dioxide bottle-sublimation cooler are reported in this paper. The experimental set-up and procedure of the system principal parameters measurement are covered. Temperature, thermal and overall size-mass parameters of the cooler are measured and reported. Performance specification of the cooler, which had been used for refrigerating of the IR module of a star spectrophotometer during astronomical observations, is presented.     

Development and validation of “grey-box” models for refrigeration applications: A review of key concepts

“Grey-box” modelling combines the use of first-principle based “white-box” models and empirical “black-box” models, offering particular benefits when: (a) there is a lack of fundamental theory to describe the system or process modelled; (b) there is a scarcity of suitable experimental data for validation or (c) there is a need to decrease the complexity of the model. The grey-box approach has been used, for example, to create mathematical models to predict the shelf life of chilled products or the thermal behaviour of imperfectly mixed fluids, or to create models that combine artificial neural networks and dynamic differential equations for control-related applications. This paper discusses the main characteristics of white-box, black-box and their integration into grey-box models, the requirements and sourcing of accurate data for model development and important validation concepts and measures.     

Optimized transcritical CO2 heat pumps: Performance comparison of capillary tubes against expansion valves

A capillary tube based CO₂ heat pump is unique because of the transcritical nature of the system. The transcritical cycle has two independent parameters, pressure and temperature, unlike the subcritical cycle. In the present study, a steady state simulation model has been developed to evaluate the performance of a capillary tube based transcritical CO₂ heat pump system for simultaneous heating and cooling at 73 °C and 4 °C, respectively against optimized expansion valve systems. Capillary tubes of various configurations having diameters of 1.4, 1.5 and 1.6 mm along with internal surface roughness of 0.001–0.003 mm have been tested to obtain the optimum design and operating conditions. Subcritical and supercritical thermodynamic and transport properties of CO₂ are calculated employing a precision in-house property code.

It is observed that the capillary tube system is quite flexible in response to changes in ambient temperature, almost behaving to offer an optimal pressure control. System performance is marginally better with a capillary tube at higher gas cooler exit temperature. Capillary tube length turns out to be the critical parameter that influences system optimum conditions. A novel nomogram has been developed that can be employed as a guideline to select the optimum capillary tube.     

Evaluation of a hybrid method for refrigerant flow balancing in multi-circuit evaporators

A companion paper [Kim, J.-H., Braun, J.E., Groll, E.A., 2009. A hybrid method for refrigerant flow balancing in multi-circuit evaporators: upstream versus downstream control. International Journal of Refrigeration doi:10.1016/j.ijrefrig.2009.01.013 presented a hybrid approach for providing control of refrigerant flow distribution in evaporators that involves the use of small balancing valves in each circuit along with a primary expansion device to control the overall superheat from the evaporator. Furthermore, the companion paper demonstrated that the flow balancing valves should be located upstream rather than downstream of the evaporator in order to realize significant benefits. The current paper utilizes the model presented in the companion paper to more fully evaluate the effects of uneven air and refrigerant flow distributions and the benefits of upstream hybrid control in response to these effects.     

Experimental performance analysis and modelling of liquid desiccant cooling systems for air conditioning in residential buildings

The paper presents a new desiccant cooling cycle to be integrated in residential mechanical ventilation systems. The process shifts the air treatment completely to the return air side, so that the supply air can be cooled by a heat exchanger. Purely sensible cooling is an essential requirement for residential buildings with no maintenance guarantee for supply air humidifiers. As the cooling power is generated on the exhaust air side, the dehumidification process needs to be highly efficient to provide low supply air temperatures. Solid rotating desiccant wheels have been experimentally compared with liquid sorption systems using contact matrix absorbers and cross flow heat exchangers. The best dehumidification performance at no temperature increase was obtained in an evaporatively cooled heat exchanger with sprayed lithium chloride solution. Up to 7 g kg⁻¹ dehumidification could be reached in an isothermal process, although the surface wetting of the first prototype was low. The process then provides inlet air conditions below 20 °C for the summer design conditions of 32 °C, 40% relative humidity. With air volume flow rates of 200 m³ h⁻¹ the system can provide 886 W of cooling power.A theoretical model for both the contact absorber and the cross flow system has been developed and validated against experimental data for a wide range of operating conditions. A simulation study identified the optimisation potential of the system, if for example the surface wetting of the liquid desiccant can be improved.     

Cooling performance of a variable speed CO2 cycle with an electronic expansion valve and internal heat exchanger

The cooling performance of a CO₂ cycle must be improved to develop a competitive air-conditioning system with the conventional air-conditioners using HFCs. In this study, the cooling performance of a variable speed CO₂ cycle was measured and analyzed by varying the refrigerant charge amount, compressor frequency, EEV opening, and length of an internal heat exchanger (IHX). The basic CO₂ system without the IHX showed the maximum cooling COP of 2.1 at the compressor discharge pressure of 9.2 MPa and the optimum normalized charge of 0.282. The cooling COP decreased with the increase of compressor frequency at all normalized charges. The optimum EEV opening increased with compressor frequency. Simultaneous control of EEV opening and compressor frequency allowed optimum control of the compressor discharge pressure. The optimal compressor discharge pressure of the modified CO₂ cycle with the IHX was reduced by 0.5 MPa. The IHX increased the cooling capacity and COP of the CO₂ cycle by 6.2–11.9% and 7.1–9.1%, respectively, at the tested compressor frequencies from 40 to 60 Hz.     

Experimental studies on the evaporative heat transfer and pressure drop of CO2 in smooth and micro-fin tubes of the diameters of 5 and 9.52 mm

Carbon dioxide among natural refrigerants has gained a considerable attention as an alternative refrigerant due to its excellent thermophysical properties. In-tube evaporation heat transfer characteristics of carbon dioxide were experimentally investigated and analyzed as a function of evaporating temperature, mass flux, heat flux and tube geometry. Heat transfer coefficient data during evaporation process of carbon dioxide were measured for 5 m long smooth and micro-fin tubes with outer diameters of 5 and 9.52 mm. The tests were conducted at mass fluxes of from 212 to 656 kg m⁻² s⁻¹, saturation temperatures of from 0 to 20 °C and heat fluxes of from 6 to 20 kW m⁻². The difference of heat transfer characteristics between smooth and micro-fin tubes and the effect of mass flux, heat flux, and evaporation temperature on enhancement factor (EF) and penalty factor (PF) were presented. Average evaporation heat transfer coefficients for a micro-fin tube were approximately 150–200% for 9.52 mm OD tube and 170–210% for 5 mm OD tube higher than those for the smooth tube at the same test conditions. The effect of pressure drop expressed by measured penalty factor of 1.2–1.35 was smaller than that of heat transfer enhancement.