Behavior of Cyclically Loaded Squat Reinforced Concrete Bridge Columns Upgraded with Advanced Composite-Material Jackets

This paper summarizes comprehensive experimental studies on scaled models of squat bridge columns repaired and retrofitted with advanced composite-material jackets. In the experimental program, a total of 14 half-scale squat circular and rectangular reinforced concrete columns were tested under fully reversed cyclic shear in a double bending configuration. In order to provide a basis for comparison, a total of three as-built columns were tested. Another 10 column samples were tested after being retrofitted with different composite jacket systems. One circular as-built column was repaired after failure. The repair process involved both crack injection as well as addition of carbon/epoxy composite jacket. The repaired column was then retested and evaluated. Experimental results showed that all as-built columns developed an unstable behavior and failed in brittle shear mode. The common failure mode for all retrofitted samples was due to flexure with significant improvement in the column ductility. The repaired column demonstrated ductility enhancement over the as-built sample.     

Seismic Retrofit of State Street Bridge on Interstate 80

The State Street Bridge, in Salt Lake City, was designed and built in 1965 according to the 1961 AASHO specifications; the design did not include earthquake-induced forces or displacements since only wind loads were considered. The bridge consists of four reinforced concrete (RC) bents supporting composite welded steel girders; the bents are supported on cast-in-place concrete piles and pile caps. A vulnerability analysis of the bridge was conducted that determined deficiencies in (1) confinement of column lap splice regions, (2) anchorage of longitudinal column bars in the bent cap, (3) confinement of column plastic hinge zones, and (4) shear capacity of columns and bent cap–column joints. Seismic retrofit designs using carbon-fiber-reinforced-polymer (CFRP) composites and steel jackets were performed and compared for three design spectra, including the 10% probability of exceedance in 250 years earthquake. The CFRP composite design was selected for implementation and application of the composite was carried out in the summer of 2000 and 2001, while the bridge was in service. The paper describes the CFRP composite design, which, in addition to column jackets, implemented an “ankle wrap” for improving joint shear strength and a “U-strap” for improving anchorage of column bars in the bent cap; other retrofit measures were implemented, such as bumper brackets and a deck slab retrofit. A capacity versus demand evaluation of the as-built and retrofitted bents is presented.     

Shear Retrofit of Flared RC Bridge Columns Subjected to Earthquakes

This paper presents an evaluation of the seismic performance and retrofit of reinforced-concrete bridge columns with structural flares. Experimental and analytical studies were performed on four 40%-scale specimens. Two specimens represented the as-built columns, while the other two were retrofitted with steel jackets for shear capacity enhancement. The results indicate that some of the existing methods for evaluating the shear capacity of columns can be unconservative and could overestimate the shear capacity of the columns included in this study by 60%. It is also shown that by implementing proper detailing, steel jackets can be used to enhance the shear capacity and ductility of flared columns with no appreciable increase in the shear demand.     

Seismic Rehabilitation of Reinforced Concrete Frame Interior Beam-Column Joints with FRP Composites

An experimental research program is described regarding the use of externally applied carbon fiber-reinforced plastic (CFRP) jackets for seismic rehabilitation of reinforced concrete interior beam-column joints, which were designed for gravity loads. The joints had steel reinforcement details that are known to be inadequate by current seismic codes in terms of joint shear capacity due to the absence of transverse steel hoops and bond capacity of beam bottom steel reinforcing bars at the joint. Lap splicing of beam bottom steel reinforcement at the joint using externally applied longitudinal CFRP composite laminates is investigated. Improvement of joint shear capacity using diagonal CFRP composite laminates is another strengthening scheme employed. Concrete crack widths for the as-built specimens and the extent of CFRP delamination for the rehabilitated specimens at various drift ratios are reported. The test results indicate that CFRP jackets are an effective rehabilitation measure for improving the seismic performance of existing beam-column joints with inadequate seismic details in terms of increased joint shear strength and inelastic rotation capacity. In addition, CFRP laminates are effective rehabilitation measures for overcoming problems associated with beam bottom steel bars that have inadequate embedment into the beam-column joints.     

Retrofitting of Rectangular Columns with Deficient Lap Splices

The cyclic behavior of eight 0.4-scale reinforced concrete column specimens is investigated. The columns incorporated deficient design details to simulate bridge columns built in Washington State prior to 1971. Two columns were tested as reference specimens, five were tested after retrofitting using carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP), and one was tested after retrofitting using a conventional steel jacket. All the specimens were tested under constant gravity load and incrementally increasing lateral loading cycles. The specimens had rectangular cross sections with aspect ratios of 1.5 and 2.0. The parameters investigated included the amount of CFRP reinforcement, different retrofitting jacket configurations, and different retrofitting materials. For the as-built specimens, two modes of failure occurred, namely low cyclic fatigue of longitudinal reinforcement and lap splice failure. For the retrofitted specimens, no lap splice failure was observed. All the retrofitted specimens failed due to low cyclic fatigue failure of the longitudinal bars. The retrofitting measures improved the displacement ductility, energy dissipation, and equivalent viscous damping. In addition, increasing the amount of CFRP reinforcement improved the performance of the test specimens.     

Residual Performance of FRP-Retrofitted RC Columns after Being Subjected to Cyclic Loading Damage

Numerous recent research findings evidenced the success of retrofitting existing RC columns using fiber-reinforced plastic (FRP) jacketing. However, little is known about the residual performance of FRP-retrofitted RC columns following limited seismic damage. In this paper, the residual performance of FRP-retrofitted columns damaged after simulated seismic loading is studied. Eight model columns with a shear aspect ratio of 5.0 were tested first under cyclic lateral force and a constant axial load equal to 20% of the column gross axial load capacity. The main parameters considered were the type of FRP jacket and peak drift ratio where the lateral loading was interrupted. Glass fiber-reinforced plastic (GFRP) and carbon fiber-reinforced plastic (CFRP) were both used for retrofitting. Five of the model columns were subjected to long-term axial loading after being subjected to limited damage by lateral cyclic loading. From the results of long-term loading test, it was found that FRP-retrofitted columns had much smaller creep deformation than the counterpart as-built model. The deformation of retrofitted columns under long-term axial loading depended on the previous damage intensity and the modulus of elasticity of FRP. The effective creep Poisson’s ratios of the retrofitted columns were much smaller than the as-built column but identical for GFRP and CFRP retrofitted columns. Under the testing conditions of this study, the long-term axial deformation of retrofitted columns tends to be sufficiently stable, despite the simulated earthquake damage.     

Seismic Repair and Strengthening of Lap Splices in RC Columns: Carbon Fiber–Reinforced Polymer versus Steel Confinement

A design approach, developed specifically for seismic bond strengthening of the critical splice region of reinforced concrete columns or bridge piers, is presented and discussed. The approach is based on providing adequate concrete confinement within the splice zone for allowing the spliced bars to theoretically develop enough postelastic tension strains demanded by large earthquakes before experiencing splitting bond failure. The accuracy of the approach was validated experimentally by evaluating the seismic behavior of full-scale gravity load-designed (as-built) rectangular columns that were strengthened or repaired in accordance with the proposed approach. Three types of confinement were used and compared, namely, internal steel ties, external fiber polymer reinforced jackets, and a combination of both. The repaired/strengthened columns developed sizable postyield strains of the spliced bars, considerable increases in the lateral load and drift capacities, and much less concrete damage within the splice zone when compared with the as-built columns. As a further support of the adequacy of the design strengthening approach, the backbone lateral load-drift response of the strengthened columns showed a good agreement with the envelope response generated using nonlinear flexural analysis assuming perfect bond between the column reinforcement and concrete.     

Seismic Retrofit of Hollow Rectangular Bridge Columns

The seismic performance of rectangular hollow bridge columns is a significant issue of the high-speed rail project in Taiwan. The flexural ductility and shear capacity of such columns with the configuration of lateral reinforcement used in Taiwan have been studied recently. This paper reports that hollow rectangular bridge columns retrofitted with fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) sheets were tested under a constant axial load and a cyclically reversed horizontal load to investigate their seismic behavior, including flexural ductility, dissipated energy, and shear capacity. An analytical model was also developed to predict the moment-curvature curve of sections and the load-displacement relationship of columns. Based on the test results, the seismic behavior of such columns will be presented. The test results were also compared to the proposed analytical model. It was found that the ductility factors of the tested piers are in the range from 3.4 to 6.3, and the proposed analytical model can predict the load-displacement relationship of such columns with acceptable accuracy. All in all, FRP sheets can effectively improve both the ductility factor and shear capacity of hollow rectangular bridge columns.     

Seismic Behavior of As-Built, ACI-Complying, and CFRP-Repaired Exterior RC Beam-Column Joints

In this paper, the efficiency and effectiveness of carbon-fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) sheets for upgrading the shear strength and ductility of a seismically deficient exterior beam-column joint were studied and compared with an American Concrete Institute (ACI)-based design joint specimen. One as-built joint specimen, representing the preseismic code design and construction practice for joints and one ACI-based design joint specimen, satisfying the seismic design requirements of the current code of practice were cast. The as-built specimen was used as baseline (control) specimen. These two specimens (i.e., the as-built control and the ACI-based specimens) were subjected to cyclic lateral load histories to induce damage equivalent to damage expected from a severe earthquake. The damaged control specimen was then repaired by filling its cracks with epoxy and externally bonding CFRP sheets to the joint, the beam, and part of the column regions. This specimen was identified as the repaired specimen. The repaired specimen was subjected to a similar cyclic lateral load history, and its response history was recorded. The response histories of the as-built control, the repaired, and the ACI-based design specimen were then compared. The test results demonstrated that externally bonded CFRP sheets can effectively improve both the shear strength and the deformation capacity of seismically deficient and damaged beam-column joints to a state comparable to the ACI-based design joint.     

Shear Retrofit of Hollow Bridge Piers with Carbon Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Sheets

Hollow bridge piers are currently being used in high-speed rail and highway projects in Taiwan. The flexural ductility and shear capacity of such piers with the configuration of lateral reinforcement used in Taiwan has recently been studied.?This paper reports that circular and rectangular hollow bridge piers retrofitted by carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) sheets were tested under a constant axial load and a cyclic reversed horizontal load to investigate their seismic behavior, including flexural ductility, dissipated energy, and shear capacity. An analytical model is also developed to predict the moment-curvature relationship of sections and the lateral load-displacement relationship of piers. Based on the test results, the seismic behavior of such piers is presented. The test results are also compared with the proposed analytical model. It was found that the ductility factors of the tested piers ranged from 3.3 to 5.5 and that the proposed analytical model could predict the lateral load-displacement relationship of such piers with reasonable accuracy. All in all, CFRP sheets can effectively improve both the ductility factor and the shear capacity of hollow bridge piers.     

Experimental Study of Seismic Behaviors of As-Built and Carbon Fiber Reinforced Plastics Repaired Reinforced Concrete Bridge Columns

In order to reliably obtain seismic responses of as-built and repaired reinforced concrete bridge columns under near-fault ground motions, pseudodynamic testing of two bridge columns with a reduced scale of 2/5 was performed. Pseudodynamic test results reveal that a ductile member may have no chance to entirely develop its ductile behavior to dissipate seismic energy, because it may suddenly be destroyed by a significant pulse-like wave. The seismic performance of the two damaged bridge columns can be recovered after repair with carbon fiber reinforced plastics composite sheets. It is also experimentally confirmed that the flexural failure moment obtained from the pseudodynamic test is in good agreement with the plastic moment predicted by the ACI 318 code. As pseudodynamic test results are believed to be more accurate than numerical solutions, they can be considered as reference solutions in developing a finite-element model. An identical specimen was tested under cyclic loading to estimate basic properties of these columns, such as shear strength, flexural strength, and ductility, so that the seismic responses obtained from pseudodynamic tests can be thoroughly discussed. Furthermore, its hysteretic response may also be used to match a mathematical model to simulate the very complicated load-displacement relation for analysis.     

Hysteretic Behavior of Bridge Columns with FRP-Jacketed Lap Splices Designed for Moderate Ductility Enhancement

This paper presents test results of six specimens representing older bridge columns with inadequate reinforcement detailing consisting of short lap splices at the base and widely spaced transverse reinforcement. Four of these specimens were rehabilitated using fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) jackets of two different composite materials (carbon and aramid) to avoid premature failure of the lapped bars after a limited number of postyield cycles. The test results indicate that thin FRP jackets can be used to avoid failure of short lap splices at moderate displacement ductilities. Displacement capacities consistent with expected demands in regions of moderate or low seismicity were achieved after jacket retrofitting. The hysteretic behavior of rehabilitated columns was assessed with emphasizing issues related to variation of stiffness and damping ratio as a function of ductility demand for this class of columns. Equations that account for the effect of axial load level on estimates of effective stiffness and damping as a function of displacement ductility are proposed for this class of columns.     

Active Confinement of Reinforced Concrete Bridge Columns Using Shape Memory Alloys

This paper presents experimental and analytical work conducted to explore the feasibility of using an innovative technique for seismic retrofitting of RC bridge columns using shape memory alloys (SMAs) spirals. The high recovery stress associated with the shape recovery of SMAs is being sought in this study as an easy and reliable method to apply external active confining pressure on RC bridge columns to improve their ductility. Uniaxial compression tests of concrete cylinders confined with SMA spirals show a significant improvement in the concrete strength and ductility even under small confining pressure. The experimental results are used to calibrate the concrete constitutive model used in the analytical study. Analytical models of bridge columns retrofitted with SMA spirals and carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) sheets are studied under displacement-controlled cyclic loading and a suite of strong earthquake records. The analytical results proves the superiority of the proposed technique using SMA spirals to CFRP sheets in terms of enhancing the strength and effective stiffness and reducing the concrete damage and residual drifts of retrofitted columns.     

Fiber-Reinforced Plastic Jackets for Ductility Enhancement of Reinforced Concrete Bridge Columns with Poor Lap-Splice Detailing

This paper presents an inclusive testing program conducted on scaled models of reinforced concrete (RC) bridge columns with insufficient lap-splice length. Thirteen half-scale circular and square column samples were tested in flexure under lateral cyclic loading. Three columns were tested in the as-built configuration whereas ten samples were tested after being retrofitted with different composite-jacket systems. A brittle failure was observed in the as-built samples due to bond deterioration of the lap-spliced longitudinal reinforcement. The jacketed circular columns demonstrated a significant improvement in their cyclic performance. Yet, tests conducted on square jacketed columns showed a limited improvement in clamping on the lap-splice region and for enhancing the ductility of the column.     

Seismic Rehabilitation of Corner RC Beam-Column Joints Using CFRP Composites

In this paper, efficiency and effectiveness of carbon fiber reinforced polymers (CFRPs) in upgrading the shear strength and ductility of seismically deficient corner or knee reinforced concrete beam-column joints have been studied. For this purpose, four as-built corner/knee joints were constructed with no transverse reinforcement, representing extreme case of preseismic code design construction practice of joints and encompassing many existing beam-column corner joints. Out of these four as-built specimens, two specimens were used as baseline specimens (control specimens) and other two were strengthened with CFRP sheets under two different schemes (strengthened specimens). In the first scheme, CFRP sheets were epoxy bonded to joint, beams, and part of the column regions. In the second scheme, however, sheets were epoxy bonded to joint region only but they were effectively prevented against any possible debonding through mechanical anchorages. All these four subassemblages were subjected to cyclic lateral load histories to simulate loading due to earthquake and provide the equivalent of severe earthquake damage. The damaged control specimens were then repaired by filling their cracks through epoxy and externally bonding them with CFRP sheets under the same above two schemes. These repaired specimens were subjected to the similar cyclic lateral load history and their response histories were obtained. Response histories of control, repaired, and strengthened specimens were then compared. The results were compared through hysteretic loops, load-displacement envelopes, column profiles, ductility, and stiffness degradation. The comparison shows that CFRP sheets are very effective in improving shear resistance and deformation capacity of the corner beam-column joints and delaying their stiffness degradation. Shear capacities of control, repaired, and strengthened specimens were also predicted using writers’ published formulation. The predicted shear capacities were in a good agreement with the experimental values.     

Seismic Behavior and Retrofit of Outrigger Knee Joints

Experimental tests were conducted on six 1/3-scale specimens to define the vulnerabilities of existing outrigger bents under in-plane and out-of-plane seismic loading and to develop retrofit measures that address the identified vulnerabilities. The specimens represented knee joints in the SR 99 Spokane Street overcrossing in western Washington State but included deficiencies present in a number of older bridges. The as-built specimens failed at low ductility levels due to shear distress, low torsional strength of the outrigger beam, and reinforcement bond failures within the joint. Threshold principal tension stress values describing the expected condition of the joints were established and compared to values obtained by other researchers. Circular steel jackets were used to retrofit the as-built specimens. The retrofitted specimens developed plastic hinging in the column, with enhanced strength, energy, and ductility capacities. Design and detailing guidelines for retrofitting outrigger bents were proposed.     

Performance-Based Seismic Retrofit Strategy for Existing Reinforced Concrete Frame Systems Using Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Composites

The feasibility and efficiency of a seismic retrofit intervention using externally bonded fiber-reinforced polymer composites on existing reinforced concrete frame systems, designed prior to the introduction of modern standard seismic design code provisions in the mid-1970s, are herein presented, based on analytical and experimental investigations on beam-column joint subassemblies and frame systems. A multilevel retrofit strategy, following hierarchy of strength considerations, is adopted to achieve the desired performance. The expected sequence of events is visualized through capacity-demand curves within M-N performance domains. An analytical procedure able to predict the enhanced nonlinear behavior of the panel zone region, due to the application of CFRP laminates, in terms of shear strength (principal stresses) versus shear deformation, has been developed and is herein proposed as a fundamental step for the definition of a proper retrofit solution. The experimental results from quasi-static tests on beam-column subassemblies, either interior and exterior, and on three-storey three-bay frame systems in their as-built and CFRP retrofitted configurations, provided very satisfactory confirmation of the viability and reliability of the adopted retrofit solution as well as of the proposed analytical procedure to predict the actual sequence of events.     

Carbon Fiber Shear Retrofit of Forty-Two-Year-Old AASHTO I-Shaped Girders

Sixteen shear capacity tests were performed on eight decommissioned AASHTO prestressed concrete girders that had been in service for over 42 years. These bridge members presented a unique opportunity to investigate carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) retrofit schemes to enhance the shear capacity of underreinforced girders that were nonrectangular. Four destructive tests were performed to quantify the in-service strength of the girders and the remaining 12 tests were performed on CFRP retrofitted girders. In all, five configurations of the CFRP reinforcement were evaluated. Two anchoring techniques were investigated that either involved epoxying a horizontal CFRP strip over the vertical strips or a new methodology of epoxying a CFRP laminate into a groove over the vertical strips that was cut at the web-to-flange interface. Two methodologies that predicted the shear contribution of the carbon fiber reinforcement were compared with the test results. A carbon fiber-reinforcing scheme of vertical strips and horizontal anchorage strip was found to be the most effective in resisting the applied shear.     

Textile-Reinforced Mortar versus FRP Jacketing in Seismic Retrofitting of RC Columns with Continuous or Lap-Spliced Deformed Bars

The effectiveness of a new structural material, namely, textile-reinforced mortar (TRM), was investigated experimentally in this study as a means of confining oldtype reinforced concrete (RC) columns with limited capacity due to bar buckling or due to bond failure at lap splice regions. Comparisons with equal stiffness and strength fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) jackets allow for the evaluation of the effectiveness of TRM versus FRP. Tests were carried out on nearly full scale nonseismically detailed RC columns subjected to cyclic uniaxial flexure under constant axial load. Ten cantilevertype specimens with either continuous or lap-spliced deformed longitudinal reinforcement at the floor level were constructed and tested. Experimental results indicated that TRM jacketing is quite effective as a means of increasing the cyclic deformation capacity of oldtype RC columns with poor detailing, by delaying bar buckling and by preventing splitting bond failures in columns with lap-spliced bars. Compared with their FRP counterparts, the TRM jackets used in this study were found to be equally effective in terms of increasing both the strength and deformation capacity of the retrofitted columns. From the response of specimens tested in this study, it can be concluded that TRM jacketing is an extremely promising solution for the confinement of reinforced concrete columns, including poorly detailed ones with or without lap splices in seismic regions.