A comparison of the chemical,microbiological and sensory characteristics of bovine and ovine Halloumi cheese

Commercial samples of fresh and mature Halloumi cheeses made from ovine or bovine milk were studied in order to establish their chemical, microbiological and sensory characteristics. Significant differences were observed between the two types of Halloumi cheese both when fresh and mature. The free volatile fatty acid (FVFA) content of the cheeses increased with maturation from 483 to 1356 mg kg⁻¹ for the ovine product, but lower values (380–1248 mg kg⁻¹) were found in the bovine cheese. During maturation for 40 days, Enterococcus faecium, which dominated the microflora of fresh ovine cheese, was replaced by lactobacilli, including a new species, Lactobacillus cypricasei, which was not found in the bovine samples. Fewer than 100 cfu g⁻¹ lactic acid bacteria (LAB) were present in the fresh bovine cheeses, but a microflora dominated by lactobacilli developed with time. Yeast counts in the mature ovine and bovine cheeses reached 2.3–2.8×10⁵ cfu g⁻¹ and, as some of the yeasts were proteolytic and/or lipolytic, it was assumed that they were having a positive impact of the flavour of the cheeses. The sensory panel distinguished significant differences in texture and flavour between the fresh and mature samples of both ovine and bovine cheeses and, overall, there was a significant preference for the ovine brand.     

Effect of chestnut tannin extract (Castanea sativa Miller) on the proliferation of Cladosporium cladosporioides on sheep cheese rind during the ripening

Strains belonging to the genus Cladosporium can cause black spots on the surface of sheep cheese, making it impossible to sell. Two water solutions of chestnut tannin extract (i) 200 g L⁻¹ (CHE200) and (ii) 400 g L⁻¹ (CHE400), and the chestnut tannin extract powder (CHEP) were tested in a cheese making trial in which 60 cheese units were allotted to 5 experimental groups (each of 12 cheeses: C1, control 1 without any treatment; C2, control 2 treated with a silver ion solution; and cheeses LCHE200, LCHE400, and LCHEP, treated with CHE200, CHE400, and CHEP, respectively). The cheeses were ripened in a room polluted with Cladosporium cladosporioides with the aim to create conditions for the proliferation of this fungus on the cheeses. The results indicated that chestnut tannin extract at a concentration of 200 g L⁻¹ is capable of completely inhibiting C. cladosporioides proliferation, avoiding spoilage of the sheep cheese.     

Study of Enterobacteriaceae during the manufacture and ripening of San Simón cheese

The aim of this work was to study the evolution of the population of Enterobacteriaceae in one of the traditional Spanish cheeses, San Simón cheese, during the manufacture and ripening processes and its interrelation with the changes in some physico–chemical parameters.The evolution of the Enterobacteriaceae counts (VRBGA medium) and coliform counts (VRBA medium) was studied from samples of milk, curd and inner and surface zones of the cheese at different stages of ripening from five batches of traditionally manufactured artisan cheese. The counts obtained were very similar in both media and in general one log unit higher in the inner portion of the cheeses than on the surface.TheEnterobacteriaceae counts in milk were 10²–10³cfu g⁻¹and the counts increased during the first week of ripening reaching 10⁶–10⁷cfu g⁻¹in the inner portion of the cheese. From this time onwards, the counts slowly decreased to the end of ripening without disappearing completely.The most abundant species in the milk were Klebsiella oxytoca (36% of the isolated strains), Enterobacter cloacae (24%) and Klebsiella pneumoniae (20%). Escherichia coli, constituted the dominant species from the inner portion of the cheeses at the end of ripening (56% of the isolated strains), followed by Hafnia alvei (44%). However, in the samples of the surface portion of the cheese the dominant species at the end of ripening were K. oxytoca (40%), H. alvei (35%) and E. cloacae (20%).     

Shear work induced changes in the viscoelastic properties of model Mozzarella cheese

Three model Mozzarella type cheeses (full-fat, non-fat and full-fat with added tri-sodium citrate) were prepared by working cheese components together at 70 °C in a twin screw Blentech cooker. G′ at 70 °C increased with shear work input suggesting work thickening. At lower shear work inputs (<30 kJ kg⁻¹), cheese behaved like a viscoelastic liquid exhibiting typical entangled polymer melt behaviour with moderate frequency dependence. A definite critical point for structural and viscoelastic transition was identified at higher shear work levels (∼58 kJ kg⁻¹ at 150 rpm). Excessive shear work levels (>70 kJ kg⁻¹) resulted in a viscoelastic solid material exhibiting low frequency dependence. Similar viscoelastic property changes occurred in non-fat cheese suggesting that major changes were taking place in the protein matrix during working. Good correlation was found between oscillatory rheological properties such as G′ and LT_max and the melting properties of test cheeses.     

Effect of commercial adjunct cultures on proteolysis in low-fat Kefalograviera-type cheese

The effect of two commercially available adjunct cultures, LBC 80 (Lactobacillus casei subsp. rhamnosus) and CR-213 (containing Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris and Lc. lactis subsp. lactis) on the proteolysis in low-fat hard ewes’ milk cheese of Kefalograviera-type was investigated. Two controls, a full-fat cheese (306 g kg⁻¹ fat, 378 g kg⁻¹ moisture) and a low-fat cheese (97 g kg⁻¹ fat, 486 g kg⁻¹ moisture, made using a modified procedure), were also prepared. The effect of adjunct culture on proteolysis, as examined by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of cheese and water soluble cheese extracts, was marginal. The reverse-phase HPLC peptide profiles of the water soluble extracts from low-fat cheeses were similar although some quantitative differences were observed between low-fat control cheese and experimental cheeses. The fat content as reflected by the differences in peptide profiles affected the pattern of proteolysis. Proteolysis, as measured by the percentage of total nitrogen soluble in water or in 120 g L⁻¹ trichloroacetic acid, was significantly (P<0.05) affected by the addition of adjunct cultures. Furthermore, the adjunct cultures enhanced the production of low molecular mass nitrogenous compounds; the levels of total nitrogen, soluble in 50 g L⁻¹ phosphotungstic acid, and of free amino acids were significantly (P<0.05) higher in the low-fat experimental cheeses than in the low-fat control cheese.     

Behaviour of Escherichia coli strains during semi-hard and hard raw milk cheese production

The behaviour of two Escherichia coli strains, one with a high and the other with a low thermotolerance phenotype, was investigated during production and ripening of Swiss semi-hard and hard raw milk cheese. In semi-hard cheese, counts of E. coli increased during production, before a log-linear decrease occurred during ripening, with a faster rate of reduction in core than in rind samples, and faster reduction of the more heat-sensitive strain in rind samples. Nevertheless, at the end of semi-hard cheese ripening, E. coli were present at least at 1.3 log₁₀ cfu g⁻¹ in rind samples and remained detectable by enrichment of core samples. During the first day of hard cheese production, both E. coli strains were almost completely inactivated. Detection by enrichment was possible in one of twelve spiked cheeses after 16 weeks, indicating the potential of a thermotolerant E. coli strain to survive until the end of ripening.     

Survival of Listeria monocytogenes in Galotyri,a traditional Greek soft acid-curd cheese,stored aerobically at 4°C and 12°C

Galotyri is a traditional Greek soft acid-curd cheese, which is made from ewes’ or goats’ milk and is consumed fresh. Because cheese processing may allow Listeria monocytogenes post-process contamination, this study evaluated survival of the pathogen in fresh cheese during storage. Portions (0.5 kg) of two commercial types (<2% salt) of Galotyri, one artisan (pH 4.0±0.1) and the other industrial (pH 3.8±0.1), were inoculated with ca. 3 or 7 log cfu g⁻¹ of a five-strain cocktail of L. monocytogenes and stored aerobically at 4°C and 12°C. After 3 days, average declines of pathogen's populations (PALCAM agar) were 1.3–1.6 and 3.7–4.6 log cfu g⁻¹ in cheese samples for the low and high inocula, respectively. These declines were independent (P>0.05) of the cheese type or the storage temperature. From day 3, however, declines shifted to small or minimal to result in 1.4–1.8 log cfu g⁻¹ of survivors at 28 days of storage of all cheeses at 4°C, indicating a strong “tailing” independent of initial level of contamination. Low (1.2–1.7 log cfu g⁻¹) survival of L. monocytogenes also occurred in cheeses at 12°C for 14 days, which were prone to surface yeast spoilage. When ca. 3 log cfu g⁻¹ of L. monocytogenes were inoculated in laboratory scale prepared Galotyri of pH ≅4.4 and ≅3% salt, the pathogen died off at 14 and 21 days at 12°C and 4°C, respectively, in artisan type cheeses fermented with the natural starter. In contrast, the pathogen survived for 28 days in cheeses fermented with the industrial starter. These results indicate that L. monocytogenes cannot grow but may survive during retail storage of Galotyri despite its low pH of or slightly below 4.0. Although contamination of Galotyri with L. monocytogenes may be expected low (<100 cfu g⁻¹) in practice, that long-term survival of the pathogen in commercial cheeses was shown to be unaffected by the artificial contamination level (3 or 7 logs) and the storage temperature (4°C or 12°C), which should be a concern.     

Ripening of Cheddar cheese made from blends of raw and pasteurised milk

Cheddar cheeses were made from pasteurised milk (P), raw milk (R) or pasteurised milk to which 10 (PR10), 5 (PR5) or 1 (PR1) % of raw milk had been added. Non-starter lactic acid bacteria (NSLAB) were not detectable in P cheese in the first month of ripening, at which stage PR1, PR5, PR10 and R cheeses had 10⁴, 10⁵, 10⁶ and 10⁷ cfu NSLAB g⁻¹, respectively. After ripening for 4 months, the number of NSLAB was 1–2 log cycles lower in P cheese than in all other cheeses. Urea–polyacrylamide gel electrophoretograms of water-soluble and insoluble fractions of cheeses and reverse-phase HPLC chromatograms of 70% (v/v) ethanol-soluble as well as -insoluble fractions of WSF were essentially similar in all cheeses. The concentration of amino acids were pro rata the number of NSLAB and were the highest in R cheese and the lowest in P cheese throughout ripening. Free fatty acids and most of the fatty acid esters in 4-month old cheeses were higher in PR1, PR5, PR10 and R cheeses than in P cheese. Commercial graders awarded the highest flavour scores to 4-month-old PR1 cheeses and the lowest to P or R cheese. An expert panel of sensory assessors awarded increasingly higher scores for fruity/sweet and pungent aroma as the level of raw milk increased. The trend for aroma intensity and perceived maturity was R>PR10>PP5>PR1>P. The NSLAB from raw milk appeared to influence the ripening and quality of Cheddar cheese.     

Contribution of coagulant and native microflora to the volatile-free fatty acid profile of an artisanal cheese

The contributions of the coagulant Cynara cardunculus and of the microflora of raw milk to the volatile-free fatty acid profile of Serra da Estrela cheese were evaluated. The experimental design included both a model system and, dual cheeses. The study in the model system showed that isovaleric acid was the predominant volatile compound after 7 d of ripening. The systems inoculated with Enterococcus faecium produced the highest amount of this volatile (ca. 135.8 mg kg⁻¹ curd), while those inoculated with Lactobacillus plantarum produced the least (21.4 mg kg⁻¹ curd); Lactococcus lactis produced moderate amounts (ca. 34.2 mg kg⁻¹ curd) but a total amount of volatile-free fatty acids similar to those found in control samples. This is considered advantageous since this volatile fatty acid confers a harsh, piquant, mature flavour to cheese, coupled with the realisation that excess volatiles may result in off-flavours. The addition of cultures in experimental cheeses helped reduce ripening time to about one half. Inclusion of Lb. plantarum led to cheeses containing the highest amounts of volatiles, and exhibiting an aroma closest to that of typical Serra da Estrela cheese.     

Effect of ripening temperature on the growth and significance of non-starter lactic acid bacteria in Cheddar cheese made from raw or pasteurised milk

Two cheese-making trials were conducted, each involving four cheeses, two made from raw milk (R1, R8) and two from pasteurised milk (P1, P8), and ripened at 1°C (R1, P1) or 8°C (R8, P8). The 1-day-old R1 and R8 cheese in trials 1 and 2 contained ∼10⁴ non-starter lactic acid bacteria (NSLAB) g⁻¹. In trial 1, no NSLAB were detected in 1-day-old P1 and P8 cheeses while those in trial 2 contained 10² cfu g⁻¹. In both trials, the maximum differences between the number of NSLAB in the cheeses ripened at 1 or 8°C were observed at 4 months, when the number of NSLAB in cheeses ripened at 8°C were 3 log cycles higher than in those ripened at 1°C. At the end of ripening (6-months), the number of NSLAB in P8 and R8 were ∼2 log cycles higher than in P1 and R1 cheeses, respectively. Primary proteolysis in the cheeses was markedly affected by ripening temperature, but not by pasteurisation of the cheese milk. Urea-polyacyrlamide gel electrophoretograms and reverse-phase (RP)-HPLC of the water-soluble fraction showed differences between cheeses made from raw or pasteurised milk and between cheeses ripened at 1 or 8°C. The concentration of amino acids and fatty acids were in the order R8>P8>R1>P1. Commercial graders awarded highest flavour scores to the R1 cheeses during gradings at 4, 5 and 6 months. A sensory panel found that most flavour and aroma attributes and maturity were in the order of R8>P8>R1=P1. The results of this study suggest that NSLAB play an important role in the development of flavour in Cheddar cheese by contributing to the production of amino acids and fatty acids.     

A feasibility study on the pilot scale manufacture of fresh cheese from skim milk retentates without acid whey production: Effect of calcium content on bitterness and texture

The sensory and structural properties of fresh cheeses (8.0%, w/w, protein) made from fermented skim milk retentates [concentrated-fermented (CoF) fresh cheese] with different calcium-protein ratios (Ca:Prot; 15.9–36.6 mg g⁻¹) by means of pilot plant scale microfiltration (MF) and MF in the diafiltration (DF) mode without acid whey (AW) production were characterised. Calcium reduction reduced the bitterness level significantly (by 53.4%) and the bitter peptide content (by ≈33%) of the CoF fresh cheese after ≤ 1 week of storage; however, storage for ≥ 2 weeks resulted in an increase of both bitterness and bitter peptide content, and quantitatively changed the peptide pattern, possibly due to lack of thermisation. Fresh cheese with a lower bitterness level can be successfully manufactured, while avoiding AW production, if the Ca:Prot of the milk retentate is decreased to ≤15.9 mg g⁻¹ (calcium content = 1240 mg kg⁻¹ at 7.81%, w/w, protein) prior to fermentation.     

Effect of post-ripening processing on the histamine and histamine-producing bacteria contents of different cheeses

Histamine is the most active biogenic amine and the one most commonly involved in food-borne intoxications. In this work, the effect of the post-ripening processing (cutting, slicing and grating) of different types of cheese on their histamine and histamine-producing bacteria contents was analysed. The average histamine content detected in Emmental cheeses was 220.8 mg kg⁻¹; the highest concentrations (up to 734.1 mg kg⁻¹) were recorded in grated samples. Significantly more histamine-producing bacteria were detected by real-time quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) in the post-ripening-processed samples than in entire cheeses in all the cheese types analysed. A good association was obtained between the number of histamine-producing bacteria determined by RT-qPCR and histamine concentrations as determined by HPLC. Results for the analysis of entire Emmental cheeses and their post-ripening processed products suggested that processing had an important influence on the presence of histamine in cheese.     

The effect of fat content on the rheology,microstructure and heat-induced functional characteristics of Cheddar cheese

Cheddar cheeses with the different fat contents were made in triplicate and ripened at 4°C for 30 d and at 7°C for the remainder of the 180-d investigation period. The cheeses were designated: full-fat (FFC), 300 g kg⁻¹; reduced-fat (RFC), 219 g kg⁻¹; half-fat (HFC), 172 g kg⁻¹; and low-fat (LFC), 71.5 g kg⁻¹. A decrease in the fat content from 300 to ≤172 g kg⁻¹ resulted in significant (P<0.05) decreases in contents of moisture in non-fat substance and pH 4.6 soluble N (expressed as % total N), and increases in the contents of moisture, protein, intact casein and free amino acids. Reduction in fat content resulted in an increase in the volume fraction of the casein matrix and a decrease in the extent of fat globule clumping and coalescence. The mean values of fracture stress and firmness for the FFC were significantly lower than those of the RFC and HFC, which had similar values; the values for the LFC exceeded the limits of the test and were markedly higher than those of the other cheeses at all times. On baking the cheese, reduction in fat content resulted in significant increases in the mean melt time (time required for shred fusion) and apparent viscosity and a decrease in the mean flowability of the melted cheese. The stretchability of the FFC increased most rapidly and, at ∼15 and 30 d, attaining mean values which were significantly higher than those of the other cheeses. Thereafter the stretchability of the FFC decreased progressively to values that were significantly (i.e. at 150 d) or numerically (i.e., at 180 d) lower than those of the RFC and HFC. At ripening times ≥15 and ≤90 d, the stretchability of the LFC was significantly lower than that of the RFC, and significantly or numerically lower than the HFC.     

Staphylococcus aureus Growth and Toxin Production in Imitation Cheeses

The ability of eleven imitation (or substitute) cheeses to support the growth and toxin production of Staphylococcus aureus at 26°C was evaluated. All established enterotoxin serotypes were tested by inoculating suspensions of the requisite strains into 100-g samples of cheese (about 30 staphylococci/g). Water activity (a_w) of the cheese samples ranged from 0.942–0.973; pH values ranged from 5.33–6.14. Seven cheeses supported extensive growth of S. aureus; one or more serotypes of enterotoxin were produced in six cheeses. Enterotoxin in the cheese was detected in 4 days at 3 × 10⁶ staphylococci/g. However, the ability of some cheeses to support growth and toxin production of S. aureus could not be correlated with pH, a_w, or product formulation.     

Determination of endogenous concentrations of nitrites and nitrates in different types of cheese in the United States: method development and validation using ion chromatography

Nitrites and nitrates can be present in dairy products from both endogenous and exogenous sources. In the European Union (EU), 150 mg kg^–1 of nitrates are allowed to be added to the cheese milk during the manufacturing process. The CODEX General Standard for Food Additives has a maximum permitted level of 50 mg kg^–1 residue in cheese, while in the United States (U.S.) nitrates are unapproved for use as food additives in cheese. In order to be able to investigate imported cheeses for nitrates intentionally added as preservatives and the endogenous concentrations of nitrates and nitrites present in cheeses in the U.S. marketplace, a method was developed and validated using ion chromatography with conductivity detection. A market sampling of cheese samples purchased in the Washington DC metro area was performed. In 64 samples of cheese, concentrations ranged from below the method detection limit (MDL) to 26 mg kg^–1 for nitrates and no concentrations of nitrites were found in any of the cheese samples above the MDL of 0.1 mg kg^–1. A majority of the samples (93%) had concentrations below 10 mg kg^–1, which indicate the presence of endogenous nitrates. The samples with concentrations above 10 mg kg^–1 were mainly processed cheese spread, which can contain additional ingredients often of plant-based origin. These ingredients are likely the cause of the elevated nitrate concentrations. The analysis of 12 additional cheese samples that are liable to the intentional addition of nitrates, 9 of which were imported, indicated that in this limited study, concentrations of nitrate in the U.S.-produced cheeses did not differ from those in imported samples.     

Comparison of different methods for fortifying Cheddar cheese with vitamin D

Fortification of Cheddar cheese with vitamin D was tested using three different addition methods to cheesemilk at a final concentration of 400 IU L⁻¹: addition of a commercial water-soluble emulsion of vitamin D (Vitex D); homogenization of crystalline liposoluble vitamin D in a portion of cream used for cheesemilk standardization; and addition of water-soluble vitamin D entrapped in multilamellar liposomes (Prolipo-Duo^TM). The recovery of vitamin D in cheese curd, losses in whey and stability of vitamin D during cheese making and ripening over a 7 months period were measured. The method of vitamin D addition did not affect significantly the composition of experimental cheeses (protein, fat, moisture and salt), which was not different from that of control cheeses made without vitamin D. The recovery of vitamin D in cheese was significantly higher when vitamin D was entrapped in liposomes (61.5±5.4%) than for vitamin D homogenized in cream (40.5±2.2%) and for Vitex D (42.7±1.7%). Vitamin D concentration in experimental cheeses was stable for 3–5 months of ripening depending on the addition method, but decreased thereafter, particularly with liposome-encapsulated vitamin D. Vitamin D concentration after 7 months of ripening was very similar for all experimental cheeses, and corresponded to approximately 60, 89 and 84% of that measured after production in cheese fortified by vitamin D in liposomes, cream, and Vitex D, respectively.     

Influence of rennet milk-clotting activity on the proteolytic and sensory characteristics of an ovine cheese

Roncal cheese (regulated by an Apellation of Origin) is a traditional hard cheese manufactured from raw ewe's milk in the region of Navarre in Spain. Roncal cheeses, manufactured using two lamb rennets with different milk-clotting activity levels, were evaluated to compare their chemical, proteolytic, and sensory characteristics. A preliminary study of samples of lamb rennets indicated that a large proportion of such rennets did not fulfil current microbiological requirements and likewise revealed considerable variation in the milk-clotting activity of the samples examined. Trends in the overall physicochemical parameter values (pH, dry matter, fat, and protein) were similar in both cheese batches. Proteolysis of the nitrogen fractions was observed to take place at a faster rate in the cheeses made using the rennet with the higher milk-clotting activity (soluble nitrogen, non-protein nitrogen, and amino acid nitrogen values around 13–20% higher than in the cheeses made using the rennet with the lower milk-clotting activity after 180 days of ripening). Urea-PAGE electrophoretic analysis of the caseins from the cheeses manufactured using both types of rennet showed that the β-caseins were less susceptible to proteolysis than the α_s-caseins. The effect of the different milk-clotting activity levels was most pronounced on the α_s-caseins, in which the rennet with the higher milk-clotting activity gave higher breakdown. Nevertheless, the differences in the proteolysis rates did not yield any appreciable sensory differences.     

Utilization of interesterified fat in the production of Turkish white cheese

The chemical, physicochemical, proteolysis, sensory, and texture characteristics of white cheeses made from interesterified fat were examined throughout ripening for 90 days. The water-soluble nitrogen based ripening indexes of cheeses increased throughout the ripening period. However, there were not large quantitative differences between the peptide profiles of the all cheese samples. Cheeses produced by using fully interesterified fat had higher values for hardness, chewiness, and gumminess than that of control cheese (p<0.05). The polyunsaturated to saturated fatty acid ratios of cheeses were increased due to the presence of interesterified fat. The cholesterol values of cheeses decreased at the rate of between 58.83–89.04% depending on interesterified fat addition. In the sensory analysis, similar scores were obtained for both the control cheese and the other cheeses. The results showed that interesterified fat in cheese production could be used to fully or partially replace the milk fat in cheese.