Riprap Protection at Bridge Piers

Although riprap is the most commonly employed countermeasure against scouring around bridge piers, few studies exist of riprap performance under live-bed conditions. In this study, failure mechanisms, stability, and placement level effects for riprap at bridge piers are considered experimentally. Under clear-water conditions, riprap is subject to shear, winnowing, and edge failure. Under live-bed conditions, a fourth failure mechanism, destabilization by bed-form progression, becomes important. Destabilization by bed-form progression is dependent on the destabilizing influence of bed-form troughs as they pass the pier. Experiments were used to assess the ability of riprap stones to protect bridge piers under a wide range of flow conditions. The effects of placing the riprap layer at depth within the sediment bed, rather than level with the bed surface, were investigated also. The study showed that, as the flow velocity increases, the ability of riprap stones to protect a pier decreases asymptotically until the scour depth in the riprap layer reaches that of an equivalent unprotected pier. In addition, it was found that the deeper the placement level the less exposed the riprap was to destabilizing bed forms and the better the protection against local scour. Lowering the placement level also meant that the riprap performed better than for surface-placed layers as the flow velocity increased. The mode of riprap failure is also changed as the placement level below the bed surface is lowered. A pier riprap size-prediction equation is proposed, including a parameter to account for placement level.     

Reduction of Local Scour in the Vicinity of Bridge Pier Groups Using Collars and Riprap

The present study examines the use of independent and continuous pier collars in combination with riprap for reducing local scour around bridge pier groups. The efficiency of collars was studied through experiments. The data from the experiments were compared with data from earlier studies on single piers with collars and bridge pier groups without collars. The data showed that in the case of two piers in line, combination of continuous collars and riprap results in the most significant scour reduction of about 50 and 60% for the front and rear piers, respectively. In other cases for two piers in line, independent collars showed better efficiency than a continuous collar around both piers. It was also shown that efficiency of collars is more on a rectangular pier aligned with the flow than two piers in line. Experiments however, indicated that collars are not so effective in reduction of scouring around two transverse piers.     

Local Scour and Riprap Stability at Bridge Piers in a Degrading Channel

The experimental study examines local scouring and riprap stability at bridge piers in rivers subject to bed degradation. The data show that the equilibrium bed profile associated with that with or without a pier is essentially the same, except for the obvious section around the pier. Total scour depth is shown to be the sum of bed degradation and pier scour depth. The latter can be computed from the time-average live-bed scour depth associated with the undisturbed velocity ratio before bed degradation. The experimental data also show that pier-scour depth is invariant with time, for t ≥ 24?h. In a degrading channel, riprap around a pier will eventually develop into a stable mound when the bed shear stresses reduce with bed degradation. An auxiliary test shows that the mound is very vulnerable to another designed flood flow accompanied by large dunes. This type of riprap instability may be called bed-degradation induced failure.     

Wire Gabion for Protecting Bridge Piers

As a new alternative countermeasure to riprap for scour protection around bridge piers, wire gabions were investigated experimentally for failure mechanisms, effects of significant parameters on failure and its sizing in a clear-water condition. The dominating failure mechanism was found to be a shear failure. Based on the experimental data, the controlling factors for the stability of wire gabions as a scour countermeasure at the pier are flow depth relative to pier diameter, length to thickness ratio, coverage, alignment and placement depth of wire gabions. An equation for sizing of a wire gabion is proposed in terms of Froude number and factors reflecting both the effect and limit of significant parameters. Comparison of the equation with those of ripraps shows that smaller wire gabions than ripraps provide an equivalent protection implying cost effective and improved stability.     

Application of Riprap and Collar to Prevent Scouring around Rectangular Bridge Piers

Various methods to control scour around bridge piers have been proposed, including application of riprap and installing a collar around piers. In the present study application of riprap alone and a combination of riprap and collar were examined experimentally for scour control around rectangular bridge piers. Piers aligned with the flow and skewed at 5, 10, and 20° to the flow were tested. Piers with three different aspect ratios equal to 1:3, 1:5, and 1:7 were used in this study. A collar three times wider than the piers’ width was installed around the piers at the streambed level. All experiments were conducted at the threshold of motion of the bed material. The size and extent of stable riprap stones for prevention of scouring around the piers was found by experiment with and without the collar. A method previously given for calculating stable riprap size around circular piers is extended for rectangular piers with different aspect ratios and skew angles with and without collar protection. The extent of stable riprap layer in all tests is also presented.     

Bridge Pier Scour under Flood Waves

The effect of a single-peaked flood wave on pier scour is investigated both theoretically and experimentally. The conditions considered involve clear-water scour of a cohesionless material of given median sediment size and sediment nonuniformity, an approach flow characterized by a flow depth and velocity, a circular-shaped cylindrical bridge pier, and a flood hydrograph defined by its time to peak and peak discharge. A previously proposed formula for scour advance under a constant discharge was applied to the unsteady approach flow. The generalized temporal scour development along with the end scour depth are presented in terms of mainly the densimetric particle Froude number based on the maximum approach flow velocity and the median sediment size. The effect of the remaining parameters on the end scour depth is discussed and predictions are demonstrated to be essentially in agreement with model observations.     

Clearwater Local Scour at Complex Piers

A new methodology to predict local scour depth at a complex pier is presented herein that combines existing expressions for scouring respectively at uniform piers, caisson-founded piers, pile groups with debris rafts, and pile groups alone. The method recognises the relative scouring potentials of the components of complex piers and the transition of scouring processes occurring for varying pile-cap elevation. The validity of the method is confirmed herein using the present and also historical measurements of local scour at complex piers. The proposed methodology has the advantages of being conceptually consistent with observed scour behaviours, relatively simple to apply, applicable to wide ranges of flow and sediment conditions (through incorporation into a more general analysis framework), and applicable over the entire range of possible pile-cap elevations. For design purposes, the present method highlights respective pile-cap elevations that maximize (i.e., to be avoided over the pier life) and minimize local scour at complex piers. The present method reinforces that where the pile-cap elevation relative to the bed can vary with time at a bridge site, potential local-scour depths need to be assessed over the range of possible pile-cap elevations for the pier.     

Reduction of Local Scour around Bridge Piers Using Slots and Collars

The present study examines the use of pier slots and collars for reducing local scour at bridge piers. The efficacy of slots, of different lengths and at different angles of attack, was studied through experiments. The reduction of scour due to the placement of circular collars, of different sizes and at different elevations, was also investigated. Analysis of the data from the experiments as well as data from earlier studies led to an equation for the maximum scour depth around circular bridge piers fitted with collars. The equation applies to local scour of uniform-sized sediment in clear-water flow.     

Large-Scale Flume Tests of Riprap-Apron Performance at a Bridge Abutment on a Floodplain

Laboratory tests using a large-scale model of a spill-through bridge abutment led to important findings about the performance of a riprap apron as an abutment scour countermeasure. Riprap stone is widely used for protecting side slopes of embankments against erosion, and several design guidelines are available in the literature. In contrast, only a few guidelines exist for the design of a riprap apron around an abutment. These guidelines focus only on the armoring effect of riprap, neglecting other effects. This study shows that apron performance involves several mechanisms: armoring the bed, dissipating large-scale turbulence shed from the abutment, reducing the peak unit discharge, reducing the average shear stress, and shifting the scour region away from the abutment. Together, these mechanisms substantially reduce the maximum scour depth. The test findings are compared with those from a much smaller model of riprap-apron performance.     

Scour Vulnerability of River Bridge Piers

A simple procedure is proposed to assess the vulnerability of bridge piers in rivers, taking into account the phenomena governing fluvial dynamics during flood events. The procedure requires an estimation of the maximum scour depth of the soil surrounding both the pier and the foundation as well as an analysis of the bearing capacity of the pier–foundation–soil geotechnical system. The scour depth is determined in terms of the physical and mechanical properties of the streambed soil, the shape of the pier foundation and the destabilizing effects induced by hydrodynamic forces. The coupling of both the hydraulic and geotechnical analyses enables to identify the most significant factors characterizing scour depth and affecting pier vulnerability. Two levels (low, medium) of allowable vulnerability, bounded by an extreme condition of high vulnerability, are defined and analytically determined in function of the maximum scour depth and the foundation depth. Specific diagrams corresponding to each category of foreseen actions allow a quick evaluation of the vulnerability of a bridge pier.     

Bridge Pier Scour in Clay-Sand Mixed Sediments at Near-Threshold Velocity for Sand

Local scour at circular bridge piers embedded in a clay-sand-mixed bed was investigated in laboratory flume experiments. The effects of clay content, water content, and sand size on maximum equilibrium scour depth, equilibrium scour hole geometry, scouring process, and time variation of scour were studied at velocities close to the threshold velocities for the sand in the clay-sand mixture. It was observed that clay content and water content were the key parameters that effect the scouring process, scour hole geometry, and maximum equilibrium scour depth. The bridge pier scouring process in clay-sand mixtures involved different dominating modes for removal of sediment from scour hole: chunks-of-aggregates, aggregate-by-aggregate, and particle-by-particle. Regression-based equations for estimation of nondimensional maximum scour depth and scour hole diameter for piers embedded in clay-sand mixtures having clay content of <40% and water content of <40% were proposed as functions of pier Froude number, clay content, water content, and bed shear strength.     

Case Study: Retrofitting Large Bridge Piers on the Nakdong River, South Korea

The Gupo Bridge crosses the Nakdong River near the city of Busan, South Korea. During Typhoon Maemi in 2003, the old Gupo Bridge collapsed due to excessive pier scour. More recently, the highway construction on the left-bank floodplain required right-bank channel widening to restore the channel flood-carrying capacity. This 7?m deep floodplain excavation is expected to cause significant local scour around the 8–10?m wide and 3?m thick spread footings of Piers 11 and 12 of the Subway Bridge and Piers 15 and 16 of the Gupo Bridge. Three design options are examined for retrofitting floodplain bridge piers with massive spread footings. A solution with sheet piles and riprap was recommended in 2006 as the most appropriate design, but Plan III with a conical riprap structure around the footings was ultimately constructed in 2007 for economic reasons. Laboratory experiments also highlight the need to place gravel and synthetic filters under the designed riprap.     

Effects of Inclination of Bridge Piers on Scouring Depth

For a safe design of a bridge pier footing, it is important to estimate the maximum depth of scour as accurately as possible. The aim of this experimental study is to investigate the effects of inclination of bridge piers on local scour depths around bridge piers. Single circular piers inclined toward the downstream direction were founded in a uniform bed material. Near threshold conditions were employed. The results of this study indicate that the local scour depth decreases as the inclination of the pier increases.     

Failure Behavior of Riprap Layer at Bridge Piers under Live-Bed Conditions

Experiments conducted under live-bed conditions show that a riprap layer at a cylindrical bridge pier will fail in either one of the following two modes: Total disintegration or embedment. The former refers to the break-up of the entire riprap layer where the stones are washed away by the flow field generated at the pier. The latter relates to the embedment of the riprap layer where it is buried in the sediment bed. The study proposes a criterion to demarcate the limiting condition between the two types of failure. It also identifies that embedment failure is a more common failure mode of riprap layer under live-bed conditions. The causes of embedment failure are twofold: (1) bed feature destabilization; and (2) differential mobility. Bed level fluctuations caused by the propagating bed features resulted in bed feature destabilization, whereas differential mobility is due to the different response of the riprap stones and bed sediments to the flow field. Experimental results also show that the riprap layer can degrade to an equilibrium level for a given flow condition. Finally, the study proposes a semiempirical equation to compute the maximum depth of riprap degradation, which occurs at the upper end of dune regime.     

Temporal Variation of Scour Depth at Nonuniform Cylindrical Piers

The paper proposes a semiempirical model to estimate the temporal development of scour depth at cylindrical piers with unexposed foundations. A cylindrical pier with a foundation is considered as nonuniform pier. The concept of primary vortex and the principle of volumetric rate of sediment transport are used to develop a methodology to characterize the rate of evolution of the scour hole at nonuniform cylindrical piers. The model also simulates the entire scouring process at nonuniform cylindrical piers having the discontinuous surface located below the initial bed level. The scouring process includes three zones; viz Zone 1 having the scouring phenomenon similar to that of a uniform pier, Zone 2 in which the scour depth remains unchanged with its value equal to the depth of the top level of foundation below the initial bed level while the dimensions of the scour hole increase, and in Zone 3 the geometry pier foundation influences the scouring process. A concept of superposition using an effective pier diameter is proposed to simulate the scouring process in Zone 3. In addition, the laboratory experiments were conducted to utilize the laboratory results for the validation of the model. The simulated results obtained from the proposed model are in good agreement with the present experimental results and also other experimental data. Also, the effect of unsteadiness of flow is incorporated in the model and the results of the model are compared with the experimental data. The model agrees satisfactorily with the experimental data.     

Probability of Exceedance Estimates for Scour Depth around Bridge Piers

Scour at a bridge pier is the formation of a hole around the pier due to the erosion of soil by flowing water; this hole in the soil reduces the carrying capacity of the foundation and the pier. Excessive scour can cause a bridge pier to fail without warning. Current predictions of the depth of the scour hole around a bridge pier are based on deterministic models. This paper considers two alternative deterministic models to predict scour depth. For each deterministic model, a corresponding probabilistic model is constructed using a Bayesian statistical approach and available field and experimental data. The developed probabilistic models account for the estimated bias in the deterministic models and for the model uncertainty. Parameters from both prediction models are compared to determine their accuracy. The developed probabilistic models are used to estimate the probability of exceedance of scour depth around bridge piers. The method is demonstrated on an example bridge pier. The paper addresses model uncertainties for given hydrologic variables. Hydrologic uncertainties have been presented in a separate paper.     

Effect of Sediment Size Scaling on Physical Modeling of Bridge Pier Scour

Local pier scour experiments were performed in the laboratory to investigate the effect of relative sediment size on pier scour depth using three uniform sediment sizes and three bridge pier designs at different geometric model scales. When the data from a large number of experimental and field investigations are filtered according to a Froude number criterion, the effect of relative sediment size on dimensionless pier scour depth is brought into focus. The choice of sediment size in the laboratory model distorts the value of the ratio of pier width to sediment size in comparison with the prototype which in turn causes larger values of scour depth in the laboratory than in the field. This model distortion due to sediment size is shown to be related to the scaling of the large-scale unsteadiness of the horseshoe vortex by studying the relevant time scales of its coherent structure upstream of a bridge pier using acoustic Doppler velocimeter measurements. Observations of sediment movement, probability distributions of velocity components, and phase-averaging of velocity measured upstream of a bridge pier reveal properties of coherent motions that are discussed in terms of their contribution to the relationship between dimensionless pier scour depth and the ratio of pier width to sediment size over a large range of physical scales.     

Design Method of Time-Dependent Local Scour at Circular Bridge Pier

A reliable prediction of local scour depth related to hydrological characteristics such as peak discharge, and time corresponding to the equilibrium scour depth is essential for the efficient design of bridge pier foundation. In this paper, a design method to predict the local scour depth with time is proposed. An experimental program was carried out using a cylindrical pier placed in uniform beds under clear-water flows. The pier scour depth was calculated on the basis of a sediment transport equation. Equilibrium local scour depth is reached when the bed-shear stress tends to critical bed-shear stress in the scour hole. Hence, changes to bed-shear stress at the circular bridge pier should be incorporated in the sediment transport theory. The proposed method follows experimental data of various sources.     

Maximum Local Scour Depth at Bridge Piers under Unsteady Flow

The temporal effect of hydrograph on local scour depth is investigated under clear-water scour condition. By analyzing the characteristics of scour-depth evolutions at bridge piers for different rising hydrographs, a relation for estimating the maximum scour depth in uniform sediment is proposed. In the relation, the flow unsteadiness effect is taken into account by an unsteady flow parameter combining the peak-flow intensity and time-to-peak factors. For nonuniform sediment with d84 employed as the effective sediment size, this relation can yield reasonably good results of the maximum scour depth under rising hydrograph.     

Countermeasure Toe Protection at Spill-Through Abutments

An experimental study of scour countermeasures for spill-through abutments situated on the flood plain of a compound channel is reported. The purpose of the study was to determine the variations in the scour hole geometry under clear water conditions by varying the compound channel and abutment geometries, and to determine the extent and type of scour countermeasure toe protection provided. This approach avoids one of the inherent difficulties in conducting scour countermeasure experiments—that is, the subjectivity of determining whether the countermeasure used in the experiment is a success or a failure. Riprap and cable-tied block countermeasures are incorporated. The results show that for most cases, as the countermeasure apron width (i.e., the extent of toe protection) is increased, the scour hole is deflected further away from the abutment and reduces in size. However, for abutment and compound channel configurations where the scour hole forms close to the main channel bank, the scour hole increases in size as the apron width is increased. The results also show that cable-tied block mats allow the scour hole to form closer to the abutment than equivalent riprap aprons and result in deeper scour holes. A suggested design methodology for the extent of apron protection is presented. The method is an improvement on the current, rather-simplified practice of providing aprons of fixed width equal to twice the flow depth.