Rescue of self-reactive B cells by provision of T cell help in vivo

We have previously demonstrated that antigen-specific T cell help can rescue mature Ig transgenic (Tg) hen egg lysozyme (HEL)-specific B cells from tolerance induction upon transfer into soluble HEL-expressing Tg hosts. Here we extend these findings by showing that T cell help could also rescue both immature and mature self-reactive B cells from rapid deletion in response to high-avidity membrane-bound HEL. Moreover, although short-lived anergic peripheral B cells that had matured in the presence of soluble self antigen could not be rescued by provision of T cell help, a proportion of immature anergic IgM+ IgD- CD23- B cells from the bone marrow of the same donors survived and proliferated when given help following transfer to a soluble or membrane HEL-expressing host. In other words, T cell help must be available relatively soon after the antigen signal to prevent induction of tolerance. Consistent with this interpretation, the stronger stimulus provided by membrane-bound antigen, which deletes immature B cells before they leave the bone marrow, did not afford an opportunity for T cell help to rescue tolerant immature bone marrow-derived B cells upon transfer in vivo. Nevertheless, these B cells were capable of responding to T cell help in vitro, which speaks against an immutable susceptibility of immature B cells to tolerance induction. Taken together, these data indicate that the strength of the antigen signal and availability of T cell help are the primary determinants of the fate of both immature and mature B cells, consistent with the model proposed by Bretscher and Cohn more than 25 years ago.     

Tolerant B lymphocytes acquire resistance to Fas-mediated apoptosis after treatment with interleukin 4 but not after treatment with specific antigen unless a surface immunoglobulin threshold is exceeded

Susceptibility to Fas-mediated apoptosis in nontolerant B cells is regulated in a receptor-specific fashion. To explore the regulation of Fas killing in tolerant, autoreactive B cells, mice doubly transgenic for hen egg lysozyme (HEL)-specific B cell receptors and soluble HEL were examined. Engagement of CD40 led to enhanced Fas expression and acquisition of sensitivity to Fas-mediated apoptosis in tolerant B cells, similar to that observed in nontolerant, receptor transgenic B cells. Engagement of surface immunoglobulin by specific (HEL) antigen failed to induce Fas resistance in tolerant B cells, in contrast to its effect on nontolerant B cells; however, cross-linking of biotinylated HEL with streptavidin induced similar levels of Fas resistance in tolerant and nontolerant B cells, which approximated the degree of Fas resistance produced by anti-Ig. Unlike surface Ig (sIg) engagement, physiological engagement of IL-4 receptors produced similar levels of Fas resistance in tolerant and nontolerant B cells. Thus, tolerant B cells differ from nontolerant B cells in the diminished capacity of surface immunoglobulin engagement to produce Fas resistance; however, tolerant B cells can be induced to become resistant to Fas-mediated apoptosis by IL-4 or by higher order cross-linking of sIg receptors.     

Impaired lymphokine secretion in anergic CD4+ T cells leads to defective help for B cell growth and differentiation

The ability of anergic helper T cells to interact with resting B cells was examined in vitro. B cell growth and differentiation in cocultures were found to be dependent on the expression of CD40 ligand (CD40L) on the cloned T cells, and the expression of this molecule was only marginally blocked by the induction of anergy. In contrast, secretion of IL-3, IL-4, IL-5, and IL-6 within the cocultures was found to be significantly reduced following the induction of anergy, and this correlated with the development of a 3- to 10-fold decrease in the ability of the T cells to induce B cell proliferation and IgG secretion. In contrast to the B cells, the activation of the T cells in these cocultures did not result in proliferation; thus, the effects of T cell anergy observed on the B cell responses were independent of an ability of clonal anergy to block T cell clonal expansion. In one T cell clone (E6), lymphokine production was reduced in part because of an increased propensity to undergo apoptosis; nevertheless, two other clones (A.E7 and 16B.2) showed no reduced viability after anergy induction. Finally, the addition of rIL-2 to the anergic T cells significantly improved their helper activity relative to control cells; this was associated with a partial reversal of the IL-3, - 4, and -5 production defects. Therefore, clonal anergy can interfere with the delivery of helper lymphokines by T cells, resulting in a decreased capacity to stimulate the growth and differentiation of B cells.     

CD4+ T cells orchestrate both amplification and deletion of CD8+ T cells

This review focuses on the role of CD4+ T cells in regulating immune responses, orchestrating both the amplification and deletion of immune cells, particularly CD8+ T cells. These two functions, which represent only an apparent contradiction, appear to be two faces of the same process of regulation. In fact, because the immune response, once activated, needs to be carefully controlled or switched off when the antigenic stimulus is eliminated, the immune system has developed several strategies either to regulate clonal amplification or to avoid useless expansion of activated cells. In particular, we have reported many data demonstrating that CD4+ T cells may be indicated as the regulatory element in the activation as well as the deletion of CD8+ T cells. New data are also reported on the ability of anergic CD4+ T cells to suppress CD8+ T-cell activation through induction of apoptosis, and on the need for CD8+ T cells for antigen recognition in inducing cell death in CD4+ T cells. Moreover, the central role of CD4+ T cells in the maintenance of peripheral tolerance has been widely described.     

Meat from dairy cows: possible microbiological hazards and risks

The outcome of the signals transduced through the B cell antigen receptor (BCR) depends both on their maturational stage and on the extent of receptor cross-linking. It is established that the BCR-mediated apoptosis of immature B cells represents an important mechanism for tolerance induction in the pre-immune B cell compartment. We show here that mature germinal center (GC) B cells can re-acquire sensitivity to BCR-induced cell death following CD40 ligation. In contrast, neither virgin nor memory B cells become susceptible to antigen receptor-triggered apoptosis upon CD40 stimulation, suggesting that this phenomenon may play a role in the shaping of the mature B cell repertoire in GC. Our data reveal that the death signal evoked through the BCR does not involve the Fcgamma receptors, does not operate through the Fas/Fas ligand system, and can be blocked by interleukin-4. Finally, we found that the acquisition of sensitivity to the death-promoting effect of anti-Ig antibodies in CD40-stimulated GC B cell cultures correlates with the induction of a centrocytic phenotype. We propose that negative regulatory signals via the BCR may delete somatically mutated centrocytes with self-reactivity.     

Evidence for clonal deletion and clonal anergy after intrathymic antigen injection in a transplantation model

Intrathymic (IT) antigen injection has been shown to induce antigen-specific systemic tolerance in the rodent. To delineate the mechanisms responsible for the induction of tolerance, we used the 2C line of T cell receptor transgenic mice. The majority of T cells in 2C mice express an antigen receptor specific for the major histocompatibility complex class I alloantigen Ld and can be identified with the clonotypic monoclonal antibody 1B2. IT injection of lymphoid cells expressing Ld was found to induce a significant prolongation in BALB/c skin allograft survival. The allograft prolongation was associated with a marked reduction in the number of developing 1B2+ thymocytes (clonal deletion), which occurred primarily at the CD4+ CD8+ stage of thymocyte development, as well as a reduction in the number of mature CD8+ 1B2+ 2C T cells in peripheral lymphoid tissue. In addition, CD8+ 1B2+ 2C T cells that survive deletion have decreased CD8 expression levels and a significantly reduced in vitro proliferative response to specific alloantigen (clonal anergy). Exogenous recombinant interleukin 2 restores the capacity of 2C T cells to respond in vitro to alloantigen. Experiments involving separation of cells by fluorescence-activated cell sorter indicate that there is a precise correlation between the reduction in CD8 expression and anergy induction. Collectively, these data indicate that IT antigen injection can induce antigen-specific systemic tolerance by both clonal deletion and clonal anergy.     

Induction of specific T cell tolerance by Fas ligand-expressing antigen-presenting cells

Autocrine interaction of Fas and Fas ligand leads to apoptosis of activated T cells, a process that is critical for the maintenance of peripheral T cell tolerance. Paracrine interactions of Fas ligand with T cells also may play an important role in the maintenance of tolerance, as Fas ligand can create immune-privileged sites and prevent graft rejection by inducing apoptosis in T cells. We surmised that APCs that express Fas ligand might directly induce apoptosis of T cells during presentation of Ag to the T cells, thus inducing Ag-specific, systemic T cell tolerance. Here, we show that profound, specific T cell unresponsiveness to alloantigen was induced by treatment of H-2k mice with H-2b APCs that expressed Fas ligand and that profound T cell unresponsiveness specific for the H-Y Ag was induced by treatment of H-2Db/H-Y TCR transgenic female mice with H-2Db/H-Y APCs that expressed Fas ligand. The induction of this systemic T cell tolerance required the expression of Fas ligand on the APCs as well as the expression of Fas on the T cells. The tolerance was restricted to the Ag presented by the APCs. The rapid and profound clonal deletion of the Ag-specific, peripheral T cells mediated by the Fas ligand-expressing APCs contributed to the induction of tolerance. These findings demonstrate that Ag-specific T cell tolerance can be induced by APCs that express Fas ligand and suggest a novel function for APCs in the induction of T cell apoptosis. Furthermore, they indicate a novel immunointervention strategy for treatment of graft rejection and autoantigen-specific autoimmune diseases.     

Fas (CD95)-transduced signal preferentially stimulates lupus peripheral T lymphocytes

Fas (CD95) is a cell surface receptor whose biological function in circulating peripheral T cells is not well understood. To address the question of abnormal T cell sensitivity to Fas stimulation in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), we studied Fas-transduced stimulation and apoptosis in peripheral blood T cells from patients with SLE and normal control. Immobilized anti-Fas monoclonal antibodies (mAb) (imCH-11; IgM type) significantly stimulated SLE T cell proliferation compared to T cells from normal donors and patients with rheumatoid arthritis (p < 0.003 and p < 0.005, respectively). The soluble form of CH-11 and other immobilized anti-Fas mAb (UB-2, ZB-4; IgG type) failed to stimulate lupus T cells while immobilized human Fas ligand did. Furthermore, imCH-11 induced IL-2 and IL-6 mRNA expression. However, imCH-11 activation failed to induce expression of the T cell activation surface molecules CD25 and CD69. Addition of exogenous ceramide, a second messenger for Fas-mediated apoptosis signaling, also induced T cell proliferation in SLE and normal controls. Moreover, fumonisin B1, a specific ceramide synthase inhibitor, and caspase inhibitors markedly suppressed imCH-11 induced T cell proliferation, suggesting that the ceramide pathway may be involved in Fas-transduced stimulation signals in SLE T cells. These results show that SLE T cells have an alteration in the Fas signal transduction pathway leading to cell proliferation. This defect may be important in Fas-mediated peripheral immune homeostasis.     

In vivo ablation of surface immunoglobulin on mature B cells by inducible gene targeting results in rapid cell death

Gene targeting experiments have demonstrated that the expression of immunoglobulin heavy chain in the pre-B cell receptor (pBCR) and of heavy and light chains in the B cell antigen receptor (BCR) marks checkpoints in early B cell development that the cells have to pass to survive. To investigate whether the persistence of mature B cells in the peripheral immune system also depends on BCR expression, we have generated a transgenic mouse in which the BCR can be inducibly ablated through V region gene deletion. Ablation leads to rapid death of mature B lymphocytes, which is preceded by down-regulation of MHC antigens and up-regulation of CD95 (Fas) and can be delayed by constitutive bcl-2 expression.     

Evidence that induction of tolerance in vivo involves active signaling via a B7 ligand-dependent mechanism: CTLA4-Ig protects V beta 8+ T cells from tolerance induction by the superantigen staphylococcal enterotoxin B

Co-stimulation through CD28 is thought to be necessary for the activation of unprimed CD4+ T cells, which are otherwise rendered tolerant. However, we previously found that CD4+ T cell priming was normal or augmented in mice which overexpressed a soluble form of CTLA4 where co-stimulation through CD28 was abrogated. To investigate this CD4+ T cell response, we exploited the capacity of the superantigen staphylococcal enterotoxin B to stimulate T lymphocytes bearing V beta 8+, which represent approximately 30% of all CD4+ T cells. In litter-mate controls of CTLA4-Ig transgenic mice, immunization with staphylococcal enterotoxin B leads to expansion, followed by deletion of V beta 8+ T cells, and the remaining cells are tolerant when stimulated in vitro. Comparable expansion and deletion of V beta 8 T cells occurs in CTLA4-Ig transgenic mice. However, in contrast to normal mice, the remaining V beta 8+ T cells from CTLA4-Ig transgenic mice are not anergic and remain responsive to superantigen in vitro.     

Ligation of CD40 potentiates Fas-mediated activation of the cysteine protease CPP32, cleavage of its death substrate PARP, and apoptosis in Ramos-Burkitt lymphoma B cells

The proliferation and survival of a B cell population is necessarily tightly controlled to prevent the arisal of malignancy or autoimmunity. The expansion or elimination of a B cell clone is determined through a complex interaction of the tumour necrosis factor receptor/nerve growth factor receptor family members CD40 and Fas, which are expressed on the B cell surface, with their respective physiological ligands (CD40L and FasL) expressed on the surface of CD4+ T cells. The regulation of B cell growth by signals transduced through CD40 and Fas contributes to the maintenance of peripheral tolerance and likely takes place and in the germinal centres (GC) of secondary lymphoid tissues. In this study, we investigate the relationship between the expression of Fas and B cell survival following engagement of CD40 and Fas in the Epstein-Barr virus-genome-negative Ramos-Burkitt lymphoma (Ramos-BL) B cell line model of GC B lymphocyte selection during maturation of the humoral immune response. We now present evidence that Ramos-BL B cells constitutively express both Fas and FasL on their surface and that expression of Fas, but not FasL, is enhanced following ligation of CD40. Coligation of CD40 and Fas, triggers for growth inhibition, activation of the interleukin-1 beta-converting enzyme, now caspase, family member CPP32 (caspase-3) but not Ich-1L (caspase-2), cleavage of its death substrate poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase, and apoptosis from the G1 phase of cell cycle; engagement of Fas alone fails to trigger for growth inhibition and apoptosis but enhances AgR-mediated cellular death. This CD40-potentiated Fas-triggered growth inhibition and apoptosis occurs in the presence of CD40-induced expression of the anti-apoptotic proteins Bcl-xL and Bcl-2. Taken together, these data indicate that ligation of CD40 facilitates efficient coupling of Fas to the caspase-mediated pathway of apoptosis.     

Membrane-bound glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase and multiphasic erythrocyte sugar transport

Fas is an apoptosis-signaling receptor important for homeostasis of the immune system. In this study, Fas-mediated apoptosis and Fas mutations were analyzed in three Japanese children from two families with a lymphoproliferative disorder characterized by lymphadenopathy, hepatosplenomegaly, pancytopenia, hypergammaglobulinemia and an increase in TCR alphabeta+ CD4- CD8- T cells. Apoptosis induced by anti-Fas mAb was defective in both activated T cells and B cells, and granulocytes from these patients. Truncated Fas receptor lacking the cytoplasmic death domain caused by a point mutation in the splice region of intron 7 were demonstrated in two siblings. A homozygous point mutation in the splice acceptor of intron 3 was found in the Fas gene of the third patient, which resulted in the skipping of exon 4 and complete loss of Fas expression. Corresponding to these mutations, soluble Fas concentrations were decreased and reciprocally soluble Fas ligands were increased in patients' sera. Interestingly, co-stimulation by immobilized anti-Fas mAb in T cells from the two siblings was comparable to that seen in normal T cells. These results suggest that Fas-mediated apoptosis plays a pivotal role in immunological homeostasis in vivo, especially regarding clonal deletion of immune cells in humans.     

Fas expression and apoptosis in human B cells

Mechanisms of B cell apoptosis are critical in reducing aberrant B cell proliferations such as those that arise in autoimmune disease and in B cell malignancies. The physiologic interaction of CD4+ helper T cells and B lymphocytes has been extensively studied over the past two decades. Although CD4+ T cells are considered primarily to offer positive costimulatory signals for B cell differentiation into active immunoglobulin-secreting cells, recent studies have shown that CD4+ T cells are crucial in downregulating the humoral immune response. In the course of cognate interaction between CD40 ligand (CD40L)-bearing CD4+ T cells and CD40-expressing germinal center B cells, CD40 ligation results in augmented Fas expression at the B cell surface. Like CD40L, Fas ligand is expressed on activated CD4+ Th1 cells and when bound to Fas receptor on the B cell surface, initiates an apoptotic signal in that cell. Thus, CD4+ T cells limit the growth of autologous germinal center B cells by first inducing Fas expression and then instigating a death signal via Fas ligand. In this work, we will consider these observations about CD4+ T-cell-induced, Fas-mediated B cell death in the context of other factors that affect apoptosis in B cells, normal and malignant.     

Direct evidence that functionally impaired CD4+ T cells persist in vivo following induction of peripheral tolerance

A small population of CD4+ OVA-specific TCR transgenic T cells was tracked following the induction of peripheral tolerance by soluble Ag to address whether functionally unresponsive, or anergic T cells, persist in vivo for extended periods of time. Although injection of OVA peptide in the absence of adjuvant caused a transient expansion and deletion of the Ag-specific T cells, a population that showed signs of prior activation persisted in the lymphoid tissues for several months. These surviving OVA-specific T cells had long-lasting, but reversible defects in their ability to proliferate in lymph nodes and secrete IL-2 and TNF-alpha in vivo following an antigenic challenge. These defects were not associated with the production of Th2-type cytokines or the capacity to suppress the clonal expansion of a bystander population of T cells present in the same lymph nodes. Therefore, our results provide direct evidence that a long-lived population of functionally impaired Ag-specific CD4+ T cells is generated in vivo after exposure to soluble Ag.     

Evidence for repression of IL-2 gene activation in anergic T cells

The induction of clonal anergy in a T cell inhibits IL-2 secretion because of the development of a proximal signal transduction defect. Fusion of anergic murine T cells to human Jurkat T leukemia cells and formation of heterokaryons failed to result in a complementation of this signaling defect and restoration of murine IL-2 mRNA inducibility. Instead, signal transduction to the human IL-2 gene became disrupted. Heterokaryons formed by the fusion of anergic murine T cells to normal murine T cells also failed to accumulate intracellular IL-2 protein in response to stimulation either with the combination of CD3 and CD28 mAbs or with ionomycin plus a protein kinase C-activating phorbol ester. The results argue against a loss-of-function signaling defect as the sole basis for clonal anergy induction and document the presence of a dominant-acting repressor molecule that inhibits signal transduction to the IL-2 gene within viable anergic T cells.     

Novel repair action of vitamin C upon in vivo oxidative DNA damage

The Nef protein of HIV-1 binds to and induces apoptotic cytolysis of uninfected but activated human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) and various cell line cells derived from CD4+ T, CD8+ T and B lymphocytes, macrophages, and neutrophils. The Nef-induced apoptosis also occurs with blood cells not expressing CD95 (Fas). The Nef-induced apoptosis as well as Fas-mediated apoptosis was inhibited by acetyl-Try-Val-Ala-Asp-CHO, an IL-1beta converting enzyme (ICE) inhibitor. On the other hand, serine/threonine protein kinase (PK) inhibitors, H-7, fasudil hydrochloride and M3, inhibited the Nef-induced apoptosis, and not the Fas-mediated one, without affecting the cell-binding activity of Nef and Nef-binding capacity of the activated cells. Preincubation of the cells with the drugs before being bound by Nef was required for the inhibition of apoptosis. These results suggest that the PK inhibitors specifically act on a cellular protein involved in the upper stream of signal transduction pathway of the Nef-induced apoptosis, which is different from the Fas-mediated pathway but meets it upstream of ICE. In addition, the drugs suppressed the cellular activation-associated cell surface expression of a putative Nef-binding protein in PBMC, although they had no influence on its expression in cell line cells. These findings suggest the feasibility of clinical use of the PK inhibitors to prevent the development of AIDS by inhibiting the Nef-induced apoptosis of uninfected blood cells.     

Resistance to Fas-mediated T cell apoptosis in asthma

Over activation of CD4+ T cells in the peripheral blood and airway tissues is characteristic of asthma; therefore, we investigated whether activated T cells from asthmatic subjects have altered apoptotic potential through the Fas death receptor. We found that mitogen-stimulated peripheral blood T cells of asthmatic subjects expressed cell surface Fas, but failed to undergo the normal degree of apoptosis after Fas receptor ligation. T cells from asthmatics exhibited normal apoptotic responses to gamma-irradiation (dependent on IL-1 converting enzyme family proteases), ceramide, and mitogen challenge, suggesting functional integrity of the apoptotic pathway. Furthermore, the defect in Fas-dependent apoptosis was overcome by prestimulation with allogeneic accessory cells instead of mitogen. Taken together, the findings suggest that selective resistance to Fas-dependent apoptosis reflects altered Ag-driven, accessory cell-dependent signaling and that ineffective activation of Fas signal transduction may contribute to T cell-dependent immunoinflammation in asthma.     

Development of autologous, oligoclonal, poorly functioning T lymphocytes in a patient with autosomal recessive severe combined immunodeficiency caused by defects of the Jak3 tyrosine kinase

Defects of the common gamma chain subunit of the cytokine receptors (gamma c) or of Jak3, a tyrosine kinase required for gamma c signal transduction, result in T-B+ severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID). However, atypical cases, characterized by progressive development of T lymphocytes, have been also reported. We describe a child with SCID caused by Jak3 gene defects, which strongly but not completely affect Jak3 protein expression and function, who developed a substantial number (> 3,000/microL) of autologous CD3+CD4+ T cells. These cells showed a primed/activated phenotype (CD45R0+ Fas+ HLA-DR+ CD62L(lo)), defective secretion of T-helper 1 and T-helper 2 cytokines, reduced proliferation to mitogens, and a high in vitro susceptibility to spontaneous (caused by downregulation of bcl-2 expression) as well as activation-induced cell death. A restricted T-cell receptor repertoire was observed, with oligoclonal expansion within each of the dominant segments. These features resemble those observed in gamma c-/y and in Jak3-/- mice, in which a population of activated, anergic T cells (predominantly CD4+) also develops with age. These results suggest that residual Jak3 expression and function or other Jak3-independent signals may also permit the generation of CD4+ T cells that undergo in vivo clonal expansion in humans; however, these mechanisms do not allow development of CD8+ T cells, nor do they fully restore the functional properties of CD4+ T lymphocytes.     

Spontaneous development of plasmacytoid tumors in mice with defective Fas-Fas ligand interactions

B cell malignancies arise with increased frequency in aging individuals and in patients with genetic or acquired immunodeficiency (e.g., AIDS) or autoimmune diseases. The mechanisms of lymphomagenesis in these individuals are poorly understood. In this report we investigated the possibility that mutations at the Fas (lpr) and Fasl (gld) loci, which prevent Fas-mediated apoptosis and cause an early onset benign lymphoid hyperplasia and autoimmunity, also predispose mice to malignant lymphomas later in life. Up to 6 mo of age, hyperplasia in lpr and gld mice results from the predominant accumulation of polyclonal T cell subsets and smaller numbers of polyclonal B cells and plasma cells. Here, we examined C3H-lpr, C3H-gld, and BALB-gld mice 6-15 mo of age for the emergence of clonal T and B cell populations and found that a significant proportion of aging mice exclusively developed B cell malignancies with many of the hallmarks of immunodeficiency-associated B lymphomas. By 1 yr of age, approximately 60% of BALB-gld and 30% of C3H-gld mice had monoclonal B cell populations that grew and metastasized in scid recipients but in most cases were rejected by immunocompetent mice. The tumors developed in a milieu greatly enriched for plasma cells, CD23- B cells and immunodeficient memory T cells and variably depleted of B220+ DN T cells. Growth factor-independent cell lines were established from five of the tumors. The majority of the tumors were CD23- and IgH isotype switched and a high proportion was CD5+ and dull Mac-1+. Considering their Ig secretion and morphology in vivo, most tumors were classified as malignant plasmacytoid lymphomas. The delayed development of the gld tumors indicated that genetic defects in addition to the Fas/Fasl mutations were necessary for malignant transformation. Interestingly, none of the tumors showed changes in the genomic organization of c-Myc but many had one or more somatically-acquired MuLV proviral integrations that were transmitted in scid passages and cell lines. Therefore, insertional mutagenesis may be a mechanism for transformation in gld B cells. Our panel of in vivo passaged and in vitro adapted gld lymphomas will be a valuable tool for the future identification of genetic abnormalities associated with B cell transformation in aging and autoimmune mice.