Research on the effect of contrast enhancement and illumination condition on 3D visual fatigue

3D visual comfort can be influenced by such common factors as binocular parallax, 3D image contrast, viewing distance, and illumination condition. This paper investigates the effect of contrast enhancement and illumination condition on 3D visual fatigue by performing a visual fatigue measurement experiment, of which subjects need to watch 3D images under two illumination conditions and finish a comfort judgment task. The proportion of discomfort images, the subjective evaluation of visual fatigue under 100 lux and 500 lux illumination conditions, the effect of image contrast enhancement on 3D visual fatigue, and the relationship between visual fatigue and proportion of discomfort images were analyzed, respectively. The experimental results showed that both the contrast enhanced by Laplacian algorithm and low illumination condition have positive influence on 3D visual perception of eyes; the 3D visual fatigue of contrast enhanced by Laplacian algorithm under low illumination condition was less than other situations in the experiment. Moreover, it was examined that the proportion of discomfort images can be potential prediction indicator of the 3D visual fatigue.     

Relationship between age differences and display parameters on visual comfort for autostereoscopic display

In order to investigate the age differences for viewing autostereoscopic display, we conduct a 3 × 3 × 3 × 4 mixed design with repeated measurement experiment by using three‐dimensional (3D) video clips. Visual comfort is compared between four age groups with a questionnaire. Results of subjective evaluation are compared through the chi‐square test to check if there is a statistical significance between groups with respect to the distribution of number and proportion according to five levels of visual comfort. Then we examine age differences of visual comfort under three key display parameters including crosstalk, ambient illumination, and disparity. The results indicate that the degree of comfort varies considerably among age groups as the parameters of the display system change. Although the seniors feel most discomfort and the children get best experience in general, there is no statistical difference among the subjects when the ambient illumination is medium or disparity is large. So, it is necessary to take account of the age differences in designing 3D display parameters for enhancing visual comfort.     

Visual comfort in 2D/3D modes of glasses‐type stereoscopic displays

In this study, we compared visual comfort in 2D/3D modes of the pattern retarder (PR) and shutter glasses (SG) stereoscopic displays by changing viewing factors and image contents. The viewing factors include ambient illuminance/monitor luminance/background luminance and image contents mainly are determined with different disparity limits. The degrees of 2D/3D visual comfort were investigated by using various combinations of ambient illuminance, monitor luminance, background luminance, and disparity limit. A series of psychological experiments were also performed to compare 2D and 3D viewing experiences for the passive PR and active SG stereoscopic displays and to discover more comfortable conditions under various variable combinations. The experiment results show that the various variable combinations affecting visual comfort in the passive PR and active SG stereoscopic displays were significantly different. Finally, we suggest more comfortable conditions of viewing 2D and 3D images for the PR and SG stereoscopic displays.     

Evaluation of jerkiness of moving three‐dimensional images produced by high‐density directional display

Abstract— The jerkiness of moving three‐dimensional (3‐D) images produced by a high‐density directional display was studied. Under static viewing conditions in which subjects' heads did not move, jerkiness was more noticeable when moving 3‐D images were displayed in front of the display screen and was less noticeable when moving 3‐D images were displayed behind the screen. We found that the perception of jerkiness depended on the visual angular velocities of moving 3‐D images. Under dynamic viewing conditions in which subjects' heads were forced to move, when moving 3‐D images were displayed in front of the screen, jerkiness was less noticeable when the subjects' heads and 3‐D images moved in opposite directions and was more noticeable when they moved in the same direction. When moving 3‐D images were displayed behind the screen, jerkiness was less noticeable when subjects' heads and 3‐D images moved in the same direction and was more noticeable when they moved in opposite directions.     

3D visual comfort assessment by measuring the vertical disparity tolerance

Misalignment in stereo images leads to 3D discomfort, but the visual tolerance for disparities varies with viewing environment and stimulus. The aim of the study was twofold: first, to assess if vertical disparity tolerance (VDT) could be a reliable indicator of 3D visual comfort under certain restrained condition when vertical disparity is induced; second, to be able to predict how viewing conditions can affect visual comfort using an analytical model. Two viewing condition parameters were considered: luminance and stimulus angular size. The study was carried out in two experiments involving 17 subjects. In Experiment 1, visual comfort and vertical disparity tolerance were measured by a series of psychophysical tests for different stimulus angular sizes and luminance. Based on a regression analysis of this data, a model was proposed to estimate VDT as a function of luminance and stimulus angular size. In Experiment 2, a validation test was carried out to assess the quality of the model. Results confirm that for given viewing conditions (luminance, angular size, induced vertical disparity), the visual comfort measured is in agreement with the one predicted (ρ = 1.0008, p = 0.0026). VDT is a recognized reliable indicator of visual comfort due to vertical disparity and the model can be used to predict visual comfort for given viewing conditions.     

Relationship between phoria and visual fatigue in autostereoscopic 3D displays

Many people complain about visual fatigue arising from viewing three‐dimensional (3D) displays. This paper investigates relationship between visual fatigue and viewers' phoria for viewing autostereoscopic 3D displays. Visual fatigue is evaluated through subjective symptoms with a questionnaire and optometric indicators comprising fusion range as well as accommodation convergence/accommodation (AC/A) ratio to measure the variation in visual functions. A screening test is adopted to divide the subjects into two groups based on whether they suffer from phoria. Then a 2 × 2 × 2 mixed design experiment is conducted with display type, viewing stage, and visual state as factors to examine visual fatigue during viewing session. The results show that phoria subjects obtain more severe visual fatigue than normal on subjective evaluation. The normal subjects reveal a more marked difference with phoria in fusion range and AC/A ratio after viewing 3D video clip. Fusion range can significantly distinguish between the two‐dimensional (2D) and 3D condition as well as between the pre‐ and post‐viewing stages. The sensitivity and specificity of fusion range is higher than AC/A ratio with respect to viewing of 3D contents, so it is more appropriate as an optometric indicator of visual fatigue for autostereoscopic 3D displays.     

Visual comfort in autostereoscopic display

Autostereoscopic displays are likely to become widely used products in the future. However, certain physiological factors, especially visual comfort, limit their development. In this study, four observational parameters – ambient illuminance, image content, scaling ratio, and horizontal distance between major and minor objects – were evaluated to determine the degree of visual comfort offered by 3D computer‐generated images on an autostereoscopic display. Visual comfort score with the range of 0–1 is designed to represent the degree of visual comfort for the 3D images with different manipulations of ambient illuminance, image content, scaling ratio, and horizontal distance between major and minor objects in this study. Subjects were asked to indicate images that produced discomfort. The proportion of images for each condition where participants indicated that viewing the image was comfortable was computed. Images receiving a proportion of 0.5 or greater were classified as acceptable. The disparity ranges over which acceptable images were attained for each participant and for each condition were analyzed with analysis of variance. The analytical results indicate that ambient illuminance and image content have a significant effect on the acceptable disparity range, while scaling ratio and horizontal distance between major and minor objects did not.     

Effects of contrast and ambient illumination on visual discomfort of autostereoscopic display

The conflict between vergence and accommodation is the main perceptual factors contributing to visual discomfort when viewing autostereoscopic display. The key factors relevant to the accommodation and vergence are the ambient illumination and the contrast. The current study was a 2 × 3 × 3 mixed design comparing VFSI and VIMS symptoms between 2D and 3D video clips with three contrast levels under three ambient illumination levels on the autostereoscopic display. Twenty participants were required to evaluate the degree of discomfort by filing out questionnaires after watching those video clips. According to the result analysis, the 3D viewing participants reported more severe symptoms compared to 2D. The moderate contrast conditions were found to be the optimum for viewing comfort. The difference between VFSI and VIMS symptoms become larger with increasing contrast. The results also suggested the optimum 3D illumination condition should not be too high to effectively relieve visual discomfort. VIMS symptoms were more sensitive to the changes in ambient illumination than VFSI. Moreover, significant interaction between contrast and ambient illumination was found. Participants felt the most comfortable in the combination effect of moderate level of contrast and the high level of ambient illumination.     

Electro‐optical transfer function preferences for LCD TVs: The effect of display brightness and surround illumination on preferred gamma

Abstract— Recent commercial liquid‐crystal‐display (LCD) televisions are larger and brighter than traditional televisions, thus impacting the viewing conditions in which they are viewed. These changes in viewing conditions may require different electro‐optical transfer functions (EOTFs) for LCD TVs than those for conventional TVs. Here, the way various EOTFs affect the preferred image quality of test images with changes in brightness and surround illumination conditions are examined. The first method used a gain, offset, and gamma (GOG) function with a range of gamma values, and the second method altered the intrinsic EOTFs. Image preference for the simulated EOTFs was determined using a paired‐comparison experiment for ten images. The first experiment took place in a darkened room at two display luminance levels. The results indicated that a gamma of 1.6 was most preferred overall although more so at a lower screen luminance level. In a second experiment, the procedure was repeated with a dim surround of 10% of the display's white point. With this surround, preference for a gamma value of around 1.6 at both screen luminance levels was more enhanced. These results indicated that image preference for different EOTFs is dependent on display luminance and that this dependence is maintained with a dim surround.     

Evaluation of Three Tablet Computers at Two Levels of Ambient Illumination

Background: Tablet computers are increasingly widespread in this digital era. During tablet computer use, two important factors are display quality and ambient illumination. The purpose of this experiment was to understand the effects of the display quality of tablet computers (a Sony, a Samsung, and an iPad) and ambient illumination levels (200 lx, 500 lx) on visual fatigue, comfort perception, and task performance.

Methods: Thirty-five university students (17 males and 18 females) were recruited for this experiment. They performed six 40-min trials of playing computer games in all experimental conditions. Visual fatigue, comfort perception, and task performance were collected at the end of each trial.

Results and Discussion: There were no interactions between display model and ambient illumination. Display model had a significant effect on visual fatigue and visual performance, and the best display quality caused less visual fatigue during long periods of viewing. We found no significant effect between 200 lx and 500 lx of ambient illumination on visual fatigue or visual performance; therefore, further research should be conducted to determine what levels of ambient illumination, both high and low, can affect visual fatigue and task performance.     

Adapting softcopy color reproduction to ambient illumination

Abstract— The perceived colors of an image seen on a self‐luminous display are affected by ambient illumination. The ambient light reflected from the display faceplate is mixed with the image‐forming light emitted by the display. In addition to this direct physical effect of viewing flare, ambient illumination causes perceptual changes by affecting the adaptation state of the viewer's visual system. This paper first discusses these effects and how they can be compensated, outlining a display system able to adjust its output based on prevailing lighting conditions. The emphasis is on compensating for the perceptual effects of viewing conditions by means of color‐appearance modeling. The effects of varying the degree of chromatic adaptation parameter D and the surround compensation parameters c and N_c of the CIECAM97s color‐appearance model were studied in psychophysical experiments. In these memory‐based paired comparison experiments, the observers judged the appearance of images shown on an LCD under three different ambient‐illumination conditions. The dependence of the optimal parameter values on the level of ambient illumination was evident. The results of the final experiment, using a category scaling technique, showed the benefit of using the color‐appearance model with the optimized parameters in compensating for the perceptual changes caused by varying ambient illumination.     

DP3 signal as a neuro-indictor for attentional processing of stereoscopic contents in varied depths within the ‘comfort zone’

When viewing stereoscopic 3D (S3D) displays, excessive binocular disparity is one of the major sources for the induced visual fatigue. Limiting the disparity within a certain range termed ‘comfort zone’ is a useful approach to alleviate the negative impact of viewing the S3D displays. Using the event-related potential (ERP) approach, we have previously showed that the differential P3 (DP3) signal evoked in an oddball task could be a useful neural indicator of the involvement of high-level cognitive functions in viewing S3D contents within the comfort zone compared to viewing 2D contents, despite of the similar subjective comfort of viewing experience for the two display conditions. It remains unclear whether the DP3 signal is sensitive enough for examination of the high-level processing when viewing S3D contents in different disparities within the comfort zone. Here, the DP3 signals were recorded while subjects performed an oddball task presented in S3D modality for three disparities (0.15, 0.45 and 0.76 arcdeg) within the comfort zone. Whereas the oddball task was of similar comfort by subjective measurement for different disparities, the DP3 signal showed monotonic delay in latency for increasing disparity, suggesting the capability of the DP3 signal for establishing a ‘cognitive comfort zone’ in terms of the high-level cognitive functions.     

Using electromyography responses to investigate the effects of the display type,viewing distance,and viewing time on visual fatigue

The rapid success of 3D display technology and daily accessibility to 3D images has greatly increased the interest in such applications for a wide range of fields. This paper compares the effects of watching movies with 2D and 3D displays depending on the viewing distance (3H vs. 6H, where H is the height of the screen) and viewing time to determine the visual fatigue using electromyography (EMG) in terms of the percentage of maximum voluntary contraction (%MVC) of the orbicularis oculi (OO) muscle activity and a subjective visual discomfort score. Twenty healthy male university students with a mean age of 27.7 ± 2.53 years participated in this study as volunteers. None had color blindness, and all had normal vision acuity. A mixed-measures design was performed. The results showed that the viewing time and distance had significant effects on the %MVC and OO muscle activity depending on the display type. Watching the 3D display from a short viewing distance produced significantly high visual fatigue compared to watching the 2D display from a short viewing distance. However, the 3D display seemed to be less stressful than the 2D display at long viewing distances.     

Survey of actual viewing conditions at home and appropriate luminance of LCD‐TV screens

Abstract— To understand actual viewing conditions at home is important for TV design. And the preferred luminance level of LCD TVs under actual viewing conditions is also important in order to obtain both good picture quality and low power consumption. The actual viewing conditions of households and the preferred luminance levels was investigated. In a field test of 83 households, the display luminance, screen illuminance, and viewing locations were measured on site. In laboratory experiments, young and elderly subjects adjusted the luminance of an LCD‐TV screen to their preferred levels under different screen illuminance levels, angular screen sizes, and average luminance levels (ALL) of the images. As a result, two equations, which represent the preferred luminance level of LCD‐TV screens corresponding to different viewing conditions for young and elderly subjects were obtained. When the ALL of the images was 25% and the screen illuminance and angular screen size were set at 100 lx and 20°, respectively, the preferred luminance was 1 60 cd/m² for the young subjects and 248 cd/m² for the elderly subjects. By using the setting of the preferred luminance of an LCD TV under actual viewing conditions, it is possible to conserve energy consumption.     

基于视差重映射的立体图像视觉舒适度提升

目的 针对人眼观看立体图像内容可能存在的视觉不舒适性,基于视差对立体图像视觉舒适度的影响,提出了一种结合全局线性和局部非线性视差重映射的立体图像视觉舒适度提升方法。方法 首先,考虑双目融合限制和视觉注意机制,分别结合空间频率和立体显著性因素提取立体图像的全局和局部视差统计特征,并利用支持向量回归构建客观的视觉舒适度预测模型作为控制视差重映射程度的约束;然后,通过构建的预测模型对输入的立体图像的视觉舒适性进行分析,就欠舒适的立体图像设计了一个两阶段的视差重映射策略,分别是视差范围的全局线性重映射和针对提取的潜在欠舒适区域内视差的局部非线性重映射;最后,根据重映射后的视差图绘制得到舒适度提升后的立体图像。结果 在IVY Lab立体图像舒适度测试库上的实验结果表明,相较于相关有代表性的视觉舒适度提升方法对于欠舒适立体图像的处理结果,所提出方法在保持整体场景立体感的同时,能更有效地提升立体图像的视觉舒适度。结论 所提出方法能够根据由不同的立体图像特征构建的视觉舒适度预测模型来自动实施全局线性和局部非线性视差重映射过程,达到既改善立体图像视觉舒适度、又尽量减少视差改变所导致的立体感削弱的目的,从而提升立体图像的整体3维体验。     

Influence of the ambient illuminance on the subjective brightness measurements

The subjective brightness is determined by not only the display screen luminance but also the light surrounding the display. A metric for space brightness named “Feu” is adopted to consider the effect of luminance distribution. The relation between the pupil diameter and the space brightness is applied to obtain the subjective brightness. The measured subjective brightness is obtained both for direct‐view display and augmented reality (AR) display. The results indicate that the measured subjective brightness is much closer to the perceived result. The subjective brightness increases along with the increase of the screen luminance under the same ambient illuminance. While under the same screen luminance, the subjective brightness decreases with the increase of the ambient illuminance in most cases.     

Effects of illumination conditions on preferred viewing distance of portable liquid‐crystal television

This study explored the effect of TV size, light source, and ambient illumination on the preferred viewing distance of portable liquid‐crystal‐display televisions. Results showed that the mean preferred viewing distance was 1389 mm. TV size had significant effects on preferred viewing distance. The larger the screen size, the greater the preferred viewing distance, at around 6.7–14.7 times the width of the screen (W). Light sources revealed no significant effect on preferred viewing distance. The effect of ambient illumination on preferred viewing distance was significant. The higher the ambient illumination was, the longer the preferred viewing distance.     

Psychophysical research on switching between light emitting and reflecting modes of light adaptable display considering equal visibility

Viewing high-luminance displays such as liquid crystal displays or organic light emitting diode displays under low-light conditions causes an unbearable glare, while viewing them with low luminance under bright-light conditions reduces visibility. Recently, several research groups have reported light adaptable displays (LADs) to extend display visibility over a wide range of light conditions. Here, we present a psychophysical study on how to effectively utilize the LAD using two different display types for the first time. LAD features two switchable display types: light emitting mode (LEM) and light reflecting mode (LRM). To maintain visibility and prevent visual artifacts, we investigate when to switch modes between LEM and LRM. We conduct psychophysical experiments involving seventy subjects. They are asked to select illuminance levels under which they perceive that the LEM and LRM look the same depending on luminance of the LEM. We propose a mode-switching condition by combining our previous results on the comfortable luminance of LEM display according to the ambient illuminance and the selected illuminance results providing equal visibility of both LEM and LRM displays.     

Accommodation and convergence in integral imaging 3D display

In this paper, we analyze the visual fatigue of integral imaging three‐dimensional (3D) display by studying the accommodation and convergence when viewing the integral imaging 3D images. The theoretical analyses show that there is no inconsistency between the accommodation and convergence distances, which means that the integral imaging 3D display has no visual fatigue. Experiments are implemented, and the results finally demonstrate the rationality of the theoretical analyses. These analyses can be quite beneficial for researchers to better understand the performances and promote the practical applications of the integral imaging 3D display.