Mutagenesis of conserved residues within the active site of Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase yields enzymes with increased kcat

The likelihood for improvement in the catalytic properties ofEscherichia coli alkaline phosphatase was examined using site-directedmutagenesis. Mutants were constructed by introducing sequencechanges into nine preselected amino acid sites within 10 A ofthe catalytic residue serine 102. When highly conserved residuesin the family of alkaline phosphatases were mutated, many ofthe resulting enzymes not only maintained activity, but alsoexhibited greatly improved tra,. Of –170 mutant enzymesscreened, 5% (eight mutants) exhibited significant increasesin specific activity. In particular, a substitution by serineof a totally invariant AsplOl resulted in a 35-fold increaseof specific activity over wild-type at pH 10.0. Up to 6-foldincreases the k_cat/k_m ratio were observed.     

Function of the fully conserved residues Asp99, Tyr52 and Tyr73 in phospholipase A2

In the active centre of pancreatic phospholipase A₂ His48 isat hydrogen-bonding distance to Asp99. This Asp-His couple isassumed to act together with a water molecule as a catalytictriad. Asp99 is also linked via an extended hydrogen bondingsystem to the side chains of Tyr52 and Tyr73. To probe the functionof the fully conserved Asp99, Tyr52 and Tyr73 residues in phospholipaseA₂, the Asp99 residue was replaced by Asn, and each of the twotyrosines was separately replaced by either a Phe or a Gln.The catalytic and binding properties of the Phe52 and Phe73mutants did not change significantly relative to the wild-typeenzyme. This rules out the possibility that either one of thetwo Tyr residues in the wild-type enzyme can function as anacyl acceptor or proton donor in catalysis. The Gln73 mutantcould not be obtained in any significant amounts probably dueto incorrect folding. The Gln52 mutant was isolated in low yield.This mutant showed a large decrease in catalytic activity whileits substrate binding was nearly unchanged. The results suggesta structural role rather than a catalytic function of Tyr52and Tyr73. Substitution of asparagine for aspartate hardly affectsthe binding constants for both monomeric and micellar substrateanalogues. Kinetic characterization revealed that the Asn99mutant has retained no less than 65% of its enzymatic activityon the monomeric substrate rac 1,2-dihexanoyldithio-propyl-3-phosphocholine,probably due to the fact that during hydrolysis of monomericsubstrate by phospholipase A₂ proton transfer is not the rate-limitingstep. The Asp to Asn substitution decreases the catalytic rateon micellar 1,2-dioctanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine 25-fold.To explain this remaining activity we suggest that in the mutantthe Asn99 orients His48 in the same way as Asp99 orients His48in native phospholipase A₂ and that the lowered activity iscaused by a reduced stabilization of the transition state.     

Site-directed mutagenesis study on the roles of evolutionally conserved aspartic acid residues in human glutathione S-transferase P1-1

The evolutionally conserved aspartyl residues (Asp57, Asp98and Asp152) in human glutathione S-transferase P1-1 were replacedwith alanine by site-directed mutagenesis to obtain the mutants(D57A, D98A and D152A). The replacement of Asp98 with alanineresulted in a decrease of the affinity for S-hexyl-GSH-agarose,a 5.5-fold increase of the K_m^GHS and a 2.9-fold increase ofthe I₅₀ of S-hexyl-GSH for GSH–CDNB conjugation. Asp98seems to participate in the binding of GSH through hydrogenbonding with the -carboxylate of the -glutamyl residue of GSH.The k_cat of D98A was 2.6-fold smaller than that of the wild-type,and the pK_a of the thiol group of GSH bound in D98A was {smalltilde}0.8 pK units higher than those in the wild-type. Asp98also seems to contribute to the activation of GSH to some extent.On the other hand, most of the kinetic parameters of D57A andD152A were similar to those of the wild-type. However, the thermostabilitiesof D57A and D152A were significantly lower than that of thewild-type. Asp57 and Asp152 seem to be important for maintainingthe proper conformation of the enzyme.     

Structural study of mutants of Escherichia coli ribonuclease HI with enhanced thermostability

Systematic replacement of the amino acid residues in Escherichiacoli ribonuclease HI with those in the thermophilic counterparthas revealed that two mutations, His62–Pro (H62P) andLys95Gly (K95G), increased the thermostability of the protein.These single-site mutant proteins, together with the mutantproteins His62Ala (H62A), Lys95Asn (K95N) and Lys95Ala (K95A),were crystallized and their structures were determined at 1.8Å resolution. The crystal structures of these mutant proteinsreveal that only the local structure around each mutation siteis essential for the increase in thermostability. For each mutantprotein, the stabilization mechanism is considered to be asfollows: (i) H62P is stabilized because of a decrease in theentropy of the unfolded state, without a change in the nativebackbone structure; (ii) K95G is stabilized since the straincaused by the left-handed backbone structure in the typical3:5 type loop is eliminated; and (iii) K95N is slightly stabilizedby a hydrogen bond formed between the side-chain N-atom of themutated aspargine residue and the main-chain carbonyl oxygenwithin the same residue.     

X-ray structures of two single-residue mutants of DNase I: H134Q and Y76A

The structures of the single-residue mutants H134Q and Y76Aof bovine pancreatic DNase I have been determined and refinedincluding data to 2.3 and 2.4 Å resolution respectively,by X-ray crystallography. H134 is an essential catalytic residue,while Y76 contributes to the binding of DNA by providing a largevan der Waals contact area that stabilizes the wide minor grooveseen in DNase I-DNA complexes. The mutant proteins, which showstrongly reduced activities of 0.001% (H134Q) and 0.3% (Y76A),were expressed in E.coli and both crystallize in space-groupC2 with almost identical unit cells. The crystal packing schemeis different from that found in wild type crystals grown undervery similar conditions, presumably due to the absence of thecarbohydrate moiety. In both mutants the conformation of theprotein is nearly identical to that of the wild type enzymeand changes are confined to surface loops involved in packing.The disruption of the hydrogen bonds between H134, E78 and Y76in both mutants leads to an increased mobility and positionalshifts in the DNA-binding loop, mainly around residue Y76. Thisin turn may further reduce DNA-binding affinity and, thus, contributeto the low activity. In contrast, symmetry contacts involvingresidues 97–108 lead to a stabilization of the flexibleloop compared to wild type DNase I.     

An unequivocal example of cysteine proteinase activity affected by multiple electrostatic interactions

The role of electrostatic interactions between the ionizableAsp158 and the active site thiolate-imidazolium ion pair ofsome cysteine proteinases has been the subject of controversyfor some time. This study reports the expression of wild typeprocaricain and Asp158Glu, Asp158Asn and Asp158Ala mutants fromEscherichia coli. Purification of autocatalytically maturedenzymes yielded sufficient fully active material for pH (k_cat/K_m)profiles to be obtained. Use of both uncharged and charged substratesallowed the effects of different reactive enzyme species tobe separated from the complications of electrostatic effectsbetween enzyme and substrate. At least three ionizations aredetectable in the acid limb of wild type caricain and the Gluand Asn mutants. Only two pK_a, values, however, are detectablein the acid limb using the Ala mutant. Comparison of pH activityprofiles shows that whilst an ionizable residue at position158 is not essential for the formation of the thiolate-imidazoliumion pair, it does form a substantial part of the electrostaticfield responsible for increased catalytic competence. Changingthe position of this ionizable group in any way reduces activity.Complete removal of the charged group reduces catalytic competenceeven further. This work indicates that hydronations distantto the active site are contributing to the electrostatic effectsleading to multiple active ionization states of the enzyme.     

Involvement of a residue at position 75 in the catalytic mechanism of a fungal aspartic proteinase, Rhizomucor pusilus pepsin. Replacement of tyrosine 75 on the flap by asparagine enhances catalytic efficiency

Residue 75 on the flap, a beta hairpin loop that partially coversthe active site cleft, is tyrosine in most members of the asparticproteinase family. Site-directed mutagenesis was carried outto investigate the functional role of this residue in Rhizomucorpusilus pepsin, an aspartic proteinase with high milk-clottingactivity produced by the fungus Rhizomucor pusillus. A set ofmutated enzymes with replacement of the amino acid at position75 by 17 other amino acid residues except for His and Gly wasconstructed and their enzymatic properties were examined. Strongactivity, higher than that of the wild-type enzyme, was foundin the mutant with asparagine (Tyr75Asn), while weak but distinctactivity was observed in Tyr75Phe. All the other mutants showedmarkedly decreased or negligible activity, less than 1/1000of that of the wild-type enzyme. Kinetic analysis of Tyr75Asnusing a chromogenic synthetic oligopeptide as a substrate revealeda marked increase in k_cat with slight change in K_m, resultingin a 5.6-fold increase in k_cat/k_m. When differential absorptionspectra upon addition of pepstatin, a specific inhibitor foraspartic proteinase, were compared between the wild-type andmutant enzymes, the wild-type enzyme and Tyr75Asn, showing strongactivity, had spectra with absorption maxima at 280, 287 and293 nm, whereas the others, showing decreased or negligibleactivity, had spectra with only two maxima at 282 and 288 nm.This suggests a different mode of the inhibitor binding in thelatter mutants. These observations suggest a crucial role ofthe residue at position 75 in enhancing the catalytic efficiencythrough affecting the mode of substrate-binding in the asparticproteinases.     

Structural interpretation of site-directed mutagenesis and specificity of the catalytic subunit of protein kinase CK2 using comparative modelling

The catalytic subunit of protein kinase casein kinase 2 (CK2),which has specificity for both ATP and GTP, shows significantamino acid sequence similarity to the cyclin-dependent kinase2 (CDK2). We constructed site-directed mutants of CK2 and useda three-dimensional model to investigate the basis for the dualspecificity. Introduction of Phe and Gly at positions 50 and51, in order to restore the pattern of the glycine-rich motif,did not seriously affect the specificity for ATP or GTP. Weshow that the dual specificity probably originates from theloop situated around the position His115 to Asp120 (HVNNTD).The insertion of a residue in this loop in CK2 subunits, comparedwith CDK2 and other kinases, might orient the backbone to interactwith the base A and G; this insertion is conserved in all knownCK2. The mutant N118, the design of which was based on the modelling,showed reduced affinity for GTP as predicted from the model.Other mutants were intended to probe the integrity of the catalyticloop, alter the polarity of a buried residue and explore theimportance of the carboxy terminus. Introduction of Arg to replaceAsn189, which is mapped on the activation loop, results in amutant with decreased k_cat, possibly as a result of disruptionof the interaction between this residue and basic residues inthe vicinity. Truncation at position 331 eliminates the last60 residues of the subunit and this mutant has a reduced catalyticefficiency compared with the wild-type. Catalytic efficiencyis restored in the truncation mutant by the replacement of apotentially buried Glu at position 252 by Lys, probably owingto a higher stability resulting from the formation of a saltbridge between Lys252 and Asp208.     

Enzyme IIIlac of the staphylococcal phosphoenolpyruvate-dependent phosphotransferase system: site-specific mutagenesis of histidine residues, biochemical characterization and 1H-NMR studies

The lactose-specific pbosphocarrier protein enzyme III of thebacterial phosphoenol-pyruvate-dependent phosphotransferasesystem of Staphylococcus aureus was modified by sitespecificmutagenesis on the corresponding lacF gene in order to replacethe histidine residues 78 and 82 of the amino acid sequencewith a serine residue. Wild-type and both mutant genes wereoverexpressed in Escherichia coli and the gene products werepurified to homogeneity. The conformation of wild-type and mutantproteins were monitored by ¹H-NMR spectroscopy. In vitro phosphorylationstudies on mutant lactose-specific enzyme III, as well as evidencefrom NMR spectroscopy, lead to the conclusion that His78 isthe activesite for phosphorylation of lactose-specific enzymeIII by phospho-HPr (histidine-containing protein). The roleof His82 probably is the enhancement of velocity and efficiencyof the phosphotransfer from lactose-specific enzyme in to lactosespecifkenzyme II. This result refutes the conclusion of former workbased on data by protelytk cleavage and sequencing of the ³²P-labeledpeptide of lactose-specific enzyme DTI that His82 is the active-sitefor phosphorylation.     

Site-directed mutagenesis of the putative active site residues of 3C proteinase of coxsackievirus B3: evidence of a functional relationship with trypsin-like serine proteinases

Picornavirus 3C proteinases (3C^pro) are cysteine proteinasesbut recent sequence analyses have shown that they are relatedto trypsin-like serine proteinases. Two models of 3C^pro structurehave been presented. Both models indicate that residues His40and Cysl47 are members of the catalytic triad but the modelsdiffer in the designation of the third member of the catalytictriad, which is assigned as either Glu71 or Asp85. To test theimportance of these four residues in the catalytic activityof 3C^pro of coxsackievirus B3, a member of the enterovirus subgroupof the picornavirus family, single amino acid substitutionswere introduced at each of the four sites. All of these mutationsresulted in the reduction or inactivation of autocatalytic cleavageof the 3C precursor protein expressed in Escherichia coli, suggestingthat all of these residues are essential for the proteolyticreaction. The substitution of Cysl47 with Ala abolished 3C^proactivity while the mutant in which Cysl47 was replaced withSer retained reduced proteolytic activity both in cis and intrans. Our results strongly support the proposal that Cysl47of 3C^pro functions as a nucleophile analogous to Serl95 of trypsin-likeserine proteinases.     

A thermoresistant mutant of ribonuclease T1 having three disulfide bonds

Molecular-dynamic calculations predict that, if Tyr24 and Asn84are each replaced by a Cys residue, it should be possible toform a third disulfide bond in ribonuclease T1 (RNase T1) betweenthese residues, with only minimal conformational changes atthe catalytic site. The gene encoding such a mutant variantof RNase T1 (Tyr24 – Cys24, Asn84 – Cys84) was constructedby the cassette mutagenesis method using a chemically synthesizedgene. In order to reduce the toxic effect of the mutant enzyme(RNase T1S) on an Escherichia coli host, we arranged for theprotein to be secreted into the periplasmic space by using avector that harbors a gene for an alkaline phosphatase signalpeptide under the control of the trp promoter. The nucleolyticactivity of RNase T1S toward pGpC was approximately the sameas that of RNase T1 at 37°C (pH 7.5). Moreover, at 55°C,RNase T1S retained nearly 70% of its activity while the activityof the wild-type enzyme was reduced to <10%. RNase T1S wasalso more resistant to denaturation by urea than the wild-typeenzyme. However, unlike RNase T1, RNase T1S was irreversiblyand almost totally inactivated by boiling at 100°C for 15min.     

The structural basis for the altered substrate specificity of the R292D active site mutant of aspartate aminotransferase from E.coli

Two refined crystal structures of aspartate aminotransferasefrom E.coli are reported. The wild type enzyme is in the pyridoxalphosphate (PLP) form and its structure has been determined to2.4 Å resolution, refined to an R-factor of 23.2%. Thestructure of the Arg292Asp mutant has been determined at 2.8Å resolution, refined to an R–factor of 20.3%. Thewild type and mutant crystals are isomorphous and the two structuresare very similar, with only minor changes in positions of importantactive site residues. As residue Arg292 is primarily responsiblefor the substrate charge specificity in the wild type enzyme,the mutant containing a charge reversal at this position mightbe expected to catalyze transamination of arginine as efficientlyas the wild type enzyme effects transamination of aspartate[Cronin,C.N. and Kirsch,J.F. (1988) Biochemistry, 27, 4572–4579].This mutant does in fact prefer arginine over aspartate as asubstrate, however, the rate of catalysis is much slower thanthat of the wild type enzyme with its physiological substrate,aspartate. A comparison of these two structures indicates thatthe poorer catalytic efficiency of R292D, when presented witharginine, is not due to a gross conformational difference, butis rather a consequence of both small side chain and main chainreorientations and the pre–existing active site polarenvironment, which greatly favors the wild type ion pair interaction.     

Multiple interactions of lysine-128 of Escherichia coli glutamate dehydrogenase revealed by site-directed mutagenesis studies

A highly conserved lysine at position 128 of Escherichia coliglutamate dehydrogenase (GDH) has been altered by sitedirectedmutagenesis of the gdhA gene. Chemical modification studieshave previously shown the importance of this residue for catalyticactivity. We report the properties of mutants in which lysine-128has been changed to histidine (K128H) or arginine (K128R). Bothmutants have substantially reduced catalytic centre activitiesand raised pH optima for activity. K128H also has increasedrelative activity with amino acid substrates other than glutamate,especially L-norvaline. These differences, together with alterationsin K_m values, K_d values for NADPH and K₁ values for D-glutamate,imply that lysine-128 is intimately involved in either director indirect interactions with all the substrates and also incatalysis. These multiple interactions of lysine-128 explainthe diverse effects of chemical modifications of the correspondinglysine in homologous GDHs. In contrast, lysine-27, another highlyreactive residue in bovine GDH, is not conserved in all of thesequenced NADP-specific GDHs and is therefore not likely tobe involved in catalysis.     

Expression and characterization of Lactobacillus 30a histidine decarboxylase in Escherichia coli

The genes coding for histidine decarboxylase from a wild-typestrain and an autoactivation mutant strain of Lactobacillus30a have been cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli. Themutant protein, G58D, has a single Asp for Gly substitutionat position 58. The cloned genes were placed under control ofthe ß-galactosidase promoter and the products arenatural length, not fusion proteins. The enzyme kinetics ofthe proteins isolated from E. coli are comparable to those isolatedfrom Lactobacillus 30a. At pH 4.8 the K_m of wild-type enzymeis 0.4 mM and the k_cat = 2800 min^–1; the correspondingvalues for G58D are 0.5 mM and 2750 min^–1. The wild-typeand G58D have autoactivation half-times of 21 and 9 h respectivelyunder pseudophysiological conditions of 150 mM K⁺ and pH 7.0.At pH 7.6 and 0.8 M K⁺ the half times are 4.9 and 2.9 h. Therelatively slow rate of autoactivation for purified proteinand the differences in cellular and non-cellular activationrates, coupled with the fact that wild-type protein is readilyactivated in wild-type Lactobacillus 30a but poorly activatedin E. coli, suggest that wild-type Lactobacillus 30a containsa factor, possibly an enzyme, that enhances the activation rate.     

Site-directed mutagenesis of aspartic acid 372 at the ATP binding site of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase: over-expression and characterization of the mutant enzyme

A new phosphoglycerate kinase over-expression vector, pYE-PGK,has been constructed which greatly facilitates the insertionand removal of mutant enzyme genes by cleavage at newly introducedBamtHI sites. This vector has been used to prepare mutant proteinin appreciable (100 mg) quantities for use in kinetic, crystaUographicand NMR experiments. Aspartate 372 is an invariant amino acidresidue in genes known to code for a functionally active PGK.The function of this acidic residue appears to be to help desolvatethe magnesium ion compfexed with either ADP or ATP when thissubstrate binds to the enzyme. Both crystallographk and nuclearmagnetic resonance experiments show that the replacement ofthe residue with asparagine has only minimal effects on theoverall structure. The substitution of the charged carboxylgroup with that of the neutral amide affects the binding ofthe nucleotide substrate as predicted but not, as might havebeen expected, the binding of 3-phospho-glycerate. The overallvelocity of the enzymic reaction (V_max) is reduced 10-fold bythe substitution of aspartic acid 372 by an asparagine residue(D372N). This reduction in V_max is considerably less than onewould expect from its known position within the structure ofthe enzyme. This result therefore poses questions about ourunderstanding of charged groups at the active centres of enzymesand of the reason for their apparent conservation.     

Roles of catalytic residues in {alpha}-amylases as evidenced by the structures of the product-complexed mutants of a maltotetraose-forming amylase

The crystal structures of the four product-complexed singlemutants of the catalytic residues of Pseudomonas stutzeri maltotetraose-forming-amylase, E219G, D193N, D193G and D294N, have been determined.Possible roles of the catalytic residues Glu219, Asp193 andAsp294 have been discussed by comparing the structures amongthe previously determined complexed mutant E219Q and the presentmutant enzymes. The results suggested that Asp193 predominantlyworks as the base catalyst (nucleophile), whose side chain atomlies in close proximity to the C1-atom of Glc4, being involvedin the intermediate formation in the hydrolysis reaction. WhileAsp294 works for tightly binding the substrate to give a twistedand a deformed conformation of the glucose ring at position–1 (Glc4). The hydrogen bond between the side chain atomof Glu219 and the O1-atom of Glc4, that implies the possibilityof interaction via hydrogen, consistently present throughoutthese analyses, supports the generally accepted role of thisresidue as the acid catalyst (proton donor).     

Site-directed mutagenesis at the active site Trpl20 of Aspergillus awamori glucoamylase

Trpl20 of Aspergillus awamori glucoamylase has previously beenshown by chemical modification to be essential for activityand tentatively to be located near subsite 4 of the active site.To further test its role, restriction sites were inserted inthe cloned A.awamori gene around the Trpl20 coding region, andcassette mutagenesis was used to replace it with His, Leu, Pheand Tyr. All four mutants displayed 2% or less of the maximalactivity (k_cat) of wild-type glucoamylase towards maltose andmaltoheptaose. MichaelLs constants (K_M) of mutants decreased2- to 3-fold for maltose and were essentially unchanged formaltoheptaose compared with the wild type, except for a >3-fold decrease for maltoheptaose with the Trp120 – Tyrmutant. This mutant also bound isomaltose more strongly andhad more selectivity for its hydrolysis than wild-type glucoamylase.A subsite map generated from malto-oligosaecharide substrateshaving 2 – 7 D-glucosyl residues indicated that subsites1 and 2 had greater affinity for D-glucosyl residues in theTrp120 – Tyr mutant than in wild-type glucoamylase. Theseresults suggest that Trpl20 from a distant subsite is crucialfor the stabilization of the transition-state complex in subsites1 and 2.     

Conformational modeling of substrate binding to endocellulase E2 from Thermomonospora fusca

Molecular mechanics calculations have been used to place a cellotetraosesubstrate into the active site of the crystallographlcally determinedstructure of endocellulase E2 from Thermomonospora fusca. Inthe lowest energy model structure, the second residue of thesubstrate oligosaccharide is tilted away from the planar ribbongeometry of cellulose as it is in the X–ray structureof the E2_cd–cellobiose cocrystal. This tilt is the resultof the topology of the binding site, and results in severalstrong carbohydrate–protein hydrogen bonds. The tiltingproduces a twisting of the glycosidic linkage of the cleavagesite between residues two and three. In the predicted enzyme–substratecomplex both of the Asp residues believed to function in generalacid and base roles in the previously proposed model for themechanism are distant from the bond being cleaved. Moleculardynamics simulations of the complex were conducted, and whilethe putative catalytic Asp residues remained distant from thecleavage site, the proton of Tyr73 briefly came within van derWaals contact of the linkage oxygen.     

Fluorescent properties of the Escherichia coli D-xylose isomerase active site

The consequences of active site mutations of the Escherichiacoli D-xylose isomerase (E.C. 5.3.1.5 [EC] ) on substrate bindingwere examined by fluorescence spectroscopy. Site-directed mutagenesisof conserved tryptophan residues in the E.coli enzyme (Trp49and Trpl88) reveals that fluorescence quenching of these residuesoccurs during the binding of xylose by the wild-type enzyme.The fluorescent properties of additional active site substitutionsat His101 were also examined. Substitutions of His101 whichinactivate the enzyme were shown to have altered spectral characteristics,which preclude detection of substrate binding. In the case ofH101S, a mutant protein with measurable isomerizing activity,substrate binding with novel fluorescent properties was observed,possibly the bound pyranose form of xylose under steady-stateconditions.     

Increasing the thermostability of D-xylose isomerase by introduction of a proline into the turn of a random coil

Thermostability can be increased by introducing prolines atsuitable sites in target proteins. Two single (G138P, G247D)mutants and one double (G138P/G247D) mutant of xylose isomerasefrom Streptomyces diastaticus No.7, strain M1033 have been constructedby site-directed mutagenesis. With respect to the wild-typeenzyme, G138P showed about a 100% increase in thermostability,and G247D showed an increased catalytic activity. Significantly,the double mutant, G138P/G247D displayed even higher activitythan G247D and better heat stability than G138P. Its half lifewas about 2.5-fold greater than the wild-type enzyme, usingxylose as a substrate. Molecular modelling suggested that theintroduction of a proline residue in the turn of a random coilmay cause the surrounding conformation to be tightened by reducingthe backbone flexibility. The change in thermostability can,therefore, be explained based on changes in the molecular rigidity.Furthermore, the improvements in the properties of the doublemutant indicated that the advantages of two single mutants canbe combined effectively.