Minimizing makespan subject to minimum flowtime on two identical parallel machines

We consider the problem of scheduling jobs on two parallel identical machines where an optimal schedule is defined as one that gives the smallest makespan (the completion time of the last job) among the set of schedules with optimal total flowtime (the sum of the completion times of all jobs). We propose an algorithm to determine optimal schedules for the problem, and describe a modified multifit algorithm to find an approximate solution to the problem in polynomial computational time. Results of a computational study to compare the performance of the proposed algorithms with a known heuristic shows that the proposed heuristic and optimization algorithms are quite effective and efficient in solving the problem.Scope and purposeMultiple objective optimization problems are quite common in practice. However, while solving scheduling problems, optimization algorithms often consider only a single objective function. Consideration of multiple objectives makes even the simplest multi-machine scheduling problems NP-hard. Therefore, enumerative optimization techniques and heuristic solution procedures are required to solve multi-objective scheduling problems. This paper illustrates the development of an optimization algorithm and polynomially bounded heuristic solution procedures for the scheduling jobs on two identical parallel machines to hierarchically minimize the makespan subject to the optimality of the total flowtime.     

A branch-and-bound algorithm for the three-machine flowshop scheduling problem with bicriteria of makespan andtotal flowtime

This paper addresses the three‐machine flowshop scheduling problem with a bicriteria of minimizing a weighted sum of makespan and total flowtime. Three lower bounds, an upper bound, and several dominance relations are developed. The upper bound is developed using a two‐phase hybrid heuristic method. A branch‐and‐bound algorithm, incorporating the developed bounds and dominance relations, is presented. An extensive computational analysis on randomly generated problems is conducted. The analysis indicates that the proposed bounds, dominance relations, and branch‐and‐bound algorithm are efficient.     

A genetic algorithm for minimizing the makespan in the case of scheduling identical parallel machines

Identical parallel machine scheduling problem for minimizing the makespan is a very important production scheduling problem, but there have been many difficulties in the course of solving large scale identical parallel machine scheduling problem with too many jobs and machines. Genetic algorithms have shown great advantages in solving the combinatorial optimization problem in view of its characteristic that has high efficiency and that is fit for practical application. In this article, a kind of genetic algorithm based on machine code for minimizing the makespan in identical machine scheduling problem is presented. Several different scale numerical examples demonstrate the genetic algorithm proposed is efficient and fit for larger scale identical parallel machine scheduling problem for minimizing the makespan, the quality of its solution has advantage over heuristic procedure and simulated annealing method.     

基于递阶遗传算法的并行多机调度优化

针对最小化完工时间的等同和非等同并行多机调度一类问题，提出了一种递阶遗传算法。该算法根据问题的特点，采用一种递阶编码方案，此编码与调度方案一一对应。用递阶遗传算法优化并行多机调度不需设计专门的遗传算子，操作简单。计算结果表明，递阶遗传算法是有效的，能适用于大规模等同和非等同并行多机调度问题。     

Minimizing total weighted flowtime subject to minimum makespan on two identical parallel machines

We study the problem of scheduling n jobs on two identical parallel processors or machines where an optimal schedule is defined as one with the shortest total weighted flowtime (i.e., the sum of the weighted completion time of all jobs), among the set of schedules with minimum makespan (i.e., the completion time of the last job finished). We present a two phase non-linear Integer Programming formulation for its solution, admittedly not to be practical or useful in most cases, but theoretically interesting since it models the problem. Thus, as an alternative, we propose an optimization algorithm, for small problems, and a heuristic, for large problems, to find optimal or near optimal solutions. Furthermore, we perform a computational study to evaluate and compare the effectiveness of the two proposed methods.     

解决并行多机提前/拖后调度问题的混合遗传算法方法

研究了带有公共交货期的并行多机提前/拖后调度问题.提出了一种混合遗传算法 方法,以便于确定公共交货期和每台机器上加工的任务代号及其加工顺序,即找到一个最优 公共交货期和最优调度,使加工完所有任务后交货期安排的成本、提前交货成本和拖后交货 成本的总和最小.数值计算结果表明了该混合遗传算法优于启发式算法,并能适用于较大规 模并行多机提前/拖后调度问题.算法计算量小,鲁棒性强.     

Semi-online scheduling problems on a small number of machines

We consider the semi-online parallel machine scheduling problem of minimizing the makespan given a priori information: the total processing time, the largest processing time, the combination of the previous two or the optimal makespan. We propose a new algorithm that can be applied to the problem with the known total or largest processing time and prove that it has improved competitive ratios for the cases with a small number of machines. Improved lower bounds of the competitive ratio are also provided by presenting adversary lower bound examples.     

Minimizing mean flowtime and makespan on master–slave systems

The master–slave scheduling model is a new model recently introduced by Sahni. It has many important applications in parallel computer scheduling and industrial settings such as semiconductor testing, machine scheduling, etc. In this model each job is associated with a preprocessing task, a slave task and a postprocessing task that must be executed in this order. While the preprocessing and postprocessing tasks are scheduled on the master machine, the slave tasks are scheduled on the slave machines. In this paper, we consider scheduling problems on single-master master–slave systems. We first strengthen some previously known complexity results for makespan problems, by showing them to be strongly NP-hard. We then show that the problem of minimizing the mean flowtime is strongly NP-hard even under severe constraints. Finally, we propose some heuristics for the mean flowtime and makespan problems subject to some constraints, and we analyze the worst-case performance of these heuristics.     

The Tricriteria Two-Machine Flowshop Scheduling Problem

The literature on the two-machine flowshop scheduling problem reveals that the problem has been addressed with bicriteria of either makespan and mean flowtime or makespan and maximum tardiness (lateness). This paper extends the problem to all the three criteria (tricriteria) where the objective is to minimize a weighted sum of makespan, mean flowtime, and maximum lateness. A dominance relation and a lower bound are established. The dominance relation and the lower bound are used to develop a branch-and-bound algorithm. The dominance relation is also used to develop several heuristics. An extensive computational analysis is conducted to evaluate the performance of the dominance relation and the heuristics. The analysis shows that the dominance relation is effective. The analysis also shows that the heuristics are quite efficient, and some heuristics have an error of less than 1%. Moreover, these heuristics have the desirable property that the error does not increase by the number of jobs.     

Tight bounds for the identical parallel machine-scheduling problem: Part II

A companion paper introduces new lower bounds and heuristics for the problem of minimizing makespan on identical parallel machines. The objective of this paper is threefold. First, we describe further enhancements of previously described lower bounds. Second, we propose a new heuristic that requires solving a sequence of 0–1 knapsack problems. Finally, we show that embedding these newly derived bounds in a branch‐and‐bound procedure yields a very effective exact algorithm. Moreover, this algorithm features a new symmetry‐breaking branching strategy. We present the results of computational experiments that were carried out on a large set of instances and that attest to the efficacy of the proposed algorithm. In particular, we report proven optimal solutions for some benchmark problems that have been open for some time.     

Worst-case and numerical analysis of heuristic algorithms for flowshop scheduling problems with a time-dependent learning effect

In this paper, we investigate a time-dependent learning effect in a flowshop scheduling problem. We assume that the time-dependent learning effect of a job was a function of the total normal processing time of jobs scheduled before the job. The following objective functions are explored: the makespan, the total flowtime, the sum of weighted completion times, the sum of the kth power of completion times, and the maximum lateness. Some heuristic algorithms with worst-case analysis for the objective functions are given. Moreover, a polynomial algorithm is proposed for the special case with identical processing time on each machine and that with an increasing series of dominating machines, respectively. Finally, the computational results to evaluate the performance of the heuristics are provided.     

Parallel machine scheduling with splitting jobs by a hybrid differential evolution algorithm

The problem of parallel machine scheduling for minimizing the makespan is an open scheduling problem with extensive practical relevance. It has been proved to be non-deterministic polynomial hard. Considering a job’s batch size greater than one in the real manufacturing environment, this paper investigates into the parallel machine scheduling with splitting jobs. Differential evolution is employed as a solution approach due to its distinctive feature, and a new crossover method and a new mutation method are brought forward in the global search procedure, according to the job splitting constraint. A specific local search method is further designed to gain a better performance, based on the analytical result from the single product problem. Numerical experiments on the performance of the proposed hybrid DE on parallel machine scheduling problems with splitting jobs covering identical and unrelated machine kinds and a realistic problem are performed, and the results indicate that the algorithm is feasible and efficient.     

The optimal number of used machines in a two-stage flexible flowshop scheduling problem

We study practical scheduling problems with a major decision referring to the number of machines to be used. We focus on a two-stage flexible flowshop, where each job is processed on the first (critical) machine, and then continues to one of the second-stage parallel machines. Jobs are assumed to have identical processing times, and are processed in batches. A setup time is required when starting a new batch. We consider two objective functions: minimum makespan and minimum flowtime. In both cases, a closed form expression for the optimal number of machines to be used is introduced, and a unique and unusual sequence of decreasing batch sizes is shown to be optimal.     

A genetic algorithm and a simulated annealing algorithm combined with column generation technique for solving the problem of scheduling in the hybrid flowshop with additional resources

In this paper, a heuristic is proposed for solving the problem of scheduling in a two-stage flowshop with parallel unrelated machines and additional renewable resources at the first stage and a single machine at the second stage. Resource requirements are arbitrary integers. The availability of additional resources is limited at every moment. The objective is the minimization of makespan. The problem is NP-hard. The proposed heuristic combines column generation technique with a genetic algorithm (the heuristic algorithm HG) or a simulated annealing algorithm (the heuristic algorithm HS). The performance analysis is performed experimentally by comparing heuristic solutions to the lower bound on the optimal makespan. Results of the computational experiment show that both the heuristic algorithms yield good quality solutions using reasonable computation time and that HS outperforms HG for the most difficult problems.     

Reduction of permutation flowshop problems to single machine problems using machine dominance relations

The Permutation Flowshop Scheduling Problem with Makespan objective (PFSP-M) is known to be NP-hard for more than two machines, and literally hundreds of works in the last decades have proposed exact and approximate algorithms to solve it. These works—of computational/experimental nature—show that the PFSP-M is also empirically hard, in the sense that optimal or quasi-optimal sequences statistically represent a very small fraction of the space of feasible solutions, and that there are big differences among the corresponding makespan values. In the vast majority of these works, it has been assumed that (a) processing times are not job- and/or machine-correlated, and (b) all machines are initially available. However, some works have found that the problem turns to be almost trivial (i.e. almost every sequence yields an optimal or quasi-optimal solution) if one of these assumptions is dropped. To the best of our knowledge, no theoretical or experimental explanation has been proposed by this rather peculiar fact.Our hypothesis is that, under certain conditions of machine availability, or correlated processing times, the performance of a given sequence in a flowshop is largely determined by only one stage, thus effectively transforming the flowshop layout into a single machine. Since the single machine scheduling problem with makespan objective is a trivial problem where all feasible sequences are optimal, it would follow that, under these conditions, the equivalent PFSP-M is almost trivial. To address this working hypothesis from a general perspective, we investigate some conditions that allow reducing a permutation flowshop scheduling problem to a single machine scheduling problem, focusing on the two most common objectives in the literature, namely makespan and flowtime. Our work is a combination of theoretical and computational analysis, therefore several properties are derived to prove the conditions for an exact (theoretical) equivalence, together with an extensive computational evaluation to establish an empirical equivalence.     

Minimizing makespan and total flowtime in permutation flowshops by a bi-objective multi-start simulated-annealing algorithm

In this study, a bi-objective multi-start simulated-annealing algorithm (BMSA) is presented for permutation flowshop scheduling problems with the objectives of minimizing the makespan and total flowtime of jobs. To evaluate the performance of the BMSA, computational experiments were conducted on the well-known benchmark problem set provided by Taillard. The non-dominated sets obtained from each of the existing benchmark algorithms and the BMSA were compared, and then combined to form a net non-dominated front. The computational results show that more than 64% of the solutions in the net non-dominated front are contributed by the proposed BMSA. It is believed that these solutions can serve as new benchmarks for future research.     

Genetic algorithms for the optimal common due date assignment and the optimal scheduling policy in parallel machine earliness/tardiness scheduling problems

Earliness/tardiness scheduling problems with undetermined common due date which have wide application background in textile industry, mechanical industry, electronic industry and so on, are very important in the research fields such as industry engineering and CIMS. In this paper, a kind of genetic algorithm based on sectional code for minimizing the total cost of assignment of due date, earliness and tardiness in this kind of scheduling problem is proposed to determine the optimal common due date and the optimal scheduling policy for determining the job number and their processing order on each machine. Also, simulated annealing mechanism and the iterative heuristic fine-tuning operator are introduced into the genetic algorithm so as to construct three kinds of hybrid genetic algorithms with good performance. Numerical computational results focusing on the identical parallel machine scheduling problem and the general parallel machine scheduling problem shows that these algorithms outperform heuristic procedures, and fit for larger scale parallel machine earliness/tardiness scheduling problem. Moreover, with practical application data from one of the largest cotton colored weaving enterprises in China, numerical computational results show that these genetic algorithms are effective and robust, and that especially the performance of the hybrid genetic algorithm based on simulated annealing and the iterative heuristic fine-tuning operator is the best among them.     

Tight bounds for the identical parallel machine scheduling problem

We address the problem of minimizing makespan on identical parallel machines. We propose new lower bounding strategies and heuristics for this fundamental scheduling problem. The lower bounds are based on the so‐called lifting procedure. In addition, two optimization‐based heuristics are proposed. These heuristics require iteratively solving a subset‐sum problem. We present the results of computational experiments that provide strong evidence that the new proposed lower and upper bounds consistently outperform the best bounds from the literature.     

Online hierarchical scheduling: An approach using mathematical programming

This paper considers an online hierarchical scheduling problem on parallel identical machines. We are given a set of m machines and a sequence of jobs. Each machine has a different hierarchy, and each job also has a hierarchy associated with it. A job can be assigned to a machine only if its hierarchy is no less than that of the machine. The objective is to minimize the makespan, i.e., the maximum load of all machines. Two models are studied in the paper. For the fractional model, we present an improved algorithm and lower bounds. Both the algorithm and the lower bound are based on solutions of mathematical programming. For any given m, our algorithm is optimal by numerical calculation. For the integral model, we present both a general algorithm for any m, and an improved algorithm with better competitive ratios of 2.333 and 2.610 for m=4 and 5, respectively.     

Scheduling algorithms to minimize the number of tardy jobs in two-stage hybrid flow shops

This paper considers a two-stage hybrid flow shop scheduling problem for the objective of minimizing the number of tardy jobs. Each job is processed through the two production stages in series, each of which has multiple identical parallel machines. The problem is to determine the allocation of jobs to the parallel machines as well as the sequence of the jobs assigned to each machine. To solve the problem, a branch and bound algorithm, which incorporates the methods to obtain the lower and upper bounds as well as the dominance properties to reduce the search space, is suggested that gives the optimal solutions. In addition, two-phase heuristic algorithms are suggested to obtain good solutions for large-size problems within a reasonable amount of computation time. To show the performances of the optimal and heuristic algorithms suggested in this paper, computational experiments are done on a number of randomly generated test problems, and the test results are reported.