Quantifying immunogold labelling in transmission electron microscopy

Gold particles labelling on ultrathin sections is extensively used for antigen localization in transmission electron microscopy. In establishing absolute or relative counts in tissue sections, it would be expedient to use stereologically based unbiased estimates for quantitative results. Nowadays, quantitative immunoelectron microscopy has achieved good and satisfactory results to test whether the gold labelling follows a non-random or a random pattern and then to draw statistical comparisons between cell subcompartments within a sample of cells or between experimental groups of cells. This brief informal review of literature focuses on the relative quantitative determinations of gold labelling of antigens as well as on the statistical distribution comparisons in transmission electron microscopy.     

Correlative light and electron microscopy reveals discrepancy between gold and fluorescence labelling

Electron microscopy (EM) is traditionally employed as a follow‐up to fluorescence microscopy (FM) to resolve the cellular ultrastructures wherein fluorescently labelled biomolecules reside. In order to translate the information derived from FM studies to EM analysis, biomolecules of interest must be identified in a manner compatible with EM. Although fluorescent signals can serve this purpose when FM is combined with EM in correlative light and electron microscopy (CLEM), the traditional immunogold labelling remains commonly used in this context. In order to investigate how much these two strategies relate, we have directly compared the subcellular localization of on‐section fluorescence labelling with on‐section immunogold labelling. In addition to antibody labelling of LAMP‐1, bioorthogonal click labelling was used to localize soluble cysteine cathepsins or membrane‐associated sialylated glycans. We reveal and characterize the existence of inherent discrepancies between the fluorescence signal and the distribution of gold particles in particular in the case of membrane‐associated antigens.     

Immunogold-silver staining of lymphocyte surface antigens on cells in suspension and in lymph node cryostat sections

An immunogold–silver staining (IGSS) technique for the light microscopical detection of leucocyte cell surface antigens in cell suspensions and cryostat sections is described. The specimens were first incubated with monoclonal mouse antibodies and then with colloidal gold-labelled goat anti-mouse antibodies. They were then immersed in a physical developer, counterstained and mounted. In light microscopy, the tissue architecture and the cellular morphology were well preserved. Positive cells showed dark granules on their surface membranes. Optimal labelling conditions were determined. This method proved to be a reliable tool for the enumeration of T-cells and their subsets in peripheral blood. The dense labelling permitted the use of panoptic counterstains like May-Grünwald-Giemsa or Wright's stain. This IGSS technique was used to determine the distribution of the T- and B-cell subsets in cryostat sections of reactive lymph nodes. The sensitivity of the method was comparable with that of immunofluorescence microscopy for cell suspensions and that of the biotin–avidin–peroxidase technique for tissue sections. Immunogold–silver staining was combined with enzyme cytochemistry. In dark-field or epipolarization microscopy the labelling appeared as bright granules on a dark background. With its dense granular membrane labelling and its good morphology IGSS is an ideal method for the study of particular cell types in mixed cell suspensions. In addition, it could be a general method for the detection of cell surface antigens in all kinds of cells and tissues.     

Morphological and ultrastructural characterization of ionoregulatory cells in the teleost oreochromis niloticus following salinity challenge combining complementary confocal scanning laser microscopy and transmission electron microscopy using a novel prefixation immunogold labeling technique

Aspects of ionoregulatory or mitochondria‐rich cell (MRC) differentiation and adaptation in Nile tilapia yolk‐sac larvae following transfer from freshwater to elevated salinities, that is, 12.5 and 20 ppt are described. Investigations using immunohistochemistry on whole‐mount Nile tilapia larvae using anti‐ Na⁺/K⁺‐ATPase as a primary antibody and Fluoronanogold? (Nanoprobes) as a secondary immunoprobe allowed fluorescent labeling with the high resolution of confocal scanning laser microscopy combined with the detection of immunolabeled target molecules at an ultrastructural level using transmission electron microscopy (TEM). It reports, for the first time, various developmental stages of MRCs within the epithelial layer of the tail of yolk‐sac larvae, corresponding to immature, developing, and mature MRCs, identifiable by their own characteristic ultrastructure and form. Following transfer to hyperosmotic salinities the density of immunogold particles and well as the intricacy of the tubular system appeared to increase. In addition, complementary confocal scanning laser microscopy allowed identification of immunopositive ramifying extensions that appeared to emanate from the basolateral portion of the cell that appeared to be correlated with the localization of subsurface tubular areas displaying immunogold labeled Na⁺/K⁺‐ATPase. This integrated approach describes a reliable and repeatable prefixation immunogold labeling technique allowing precise visualization of NaK within target cells combined with a 3D imaging that offers valuable insights into MRC dynamics at an ultrastructural level. Microsc. Res. Tech., 76:1016–1024, 2013. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Neuronal imaging with colloidal gold

Colloidal gold is easily prepared, and readily adsorbs to a number of immunoreagents and other proteins for a wide variety of uses for neuronal visualization. Gold probes serve a role as immunolabels for both light and electron microscopy. As an ultrastructural immunocytochemical marker for detection of proteins, peptides or amino acids, gold can be used for immunostaining thick or thin sections prior to embedding, or for immunostaining ultrathin sections after embedding tissue in conventional or unusual embedding matrices. By virtue of its particulate nature, gold as an immunolabel facilitates a semi-quantitative analysis of relative antigen densities on ultrathin sections. Various combinations of different size gold particles or dual immunolabelling with enzymatic immunolabels together with colloidal gold or silver-intensified gold serve well for ultrastructural immunocytochemical localization of two antigens in the same tissue section. Colloidal gold can be detected with light microscopy, transmission and scanning electron microscopy, and with confocal laser microscopy. Silver intensification allows detection of gold at both the light and electron microscope level, and increases the sensitivity of immunogold procedures. Colloidal gold is useful as a tracer for physiological studies of transport and internalization in neurons in vivo and in vitro; computer-assisted video imaging techniques allow detection and tracking of single gold particles in living cells.     

Energy dispersive spectroscopy‐scanning transmission electron microscope observations of free radical production in human polymorphonuclear leukocytes phagocytosing non‐opsonized Tannerella forsythia

We investigated the association between human polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs) and non‐opsonized Tannerella forsythia ATCC 43037 displaying a serum‐resistant surface layer (S‐layer). When PMNs were mixed with T. forsythia in suspension, the cells phagocytosed T. forsythia cells. Nitro blue tetrazolium (NBT) reduction, indicative of production, was observed by light microscopy; cerium (Ce) perhydroxide deposition, indicative of H₂O₂ production, was observed by electron microscopy. We examined the relationship between high‐molecular‐weight proteins of the S‐layer and Ce reaction (for T. forsythia phagocytosis) using electron microscopic immunolabeling. Immunogold particles were localized within the PMNs and on cell surfaces, labelling at the same Ce‐reacted sites where the S‐layer was present. We then used energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS)‐scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM) to perform Ce and nitrogen (N) (for S‐layer immunocytochemistry) elemental analysis on the phagocytosed cells. That is, the elemental mapping and analysis of N by EDS appeared to reflect the presence of the same moieties detected by the 3,3′‐diaminobenzidine‐tetrahydrochloride (DAB) reaction with horseradish peroxidase (HRP)‐conjugated secondary antibodies, instead of immunogold labeling. We focused on the use of EDS‐STEM to visualize the presence of N resulting from the DAB reaction. In a parallel set of experiments, we used EDS‐STEM to perform Ce and gold (Au; from immunogold labeling of the S‐layer) elemental analysis on the same phagocytosing cells.     

Simultaneously identifying S-phase labelled cells and immunogold-labelling of vinculin in focal adhesions

A new combination of autoradiography and immunolabelling techniques is presented that allows the simultaneous identification of both S‐phase cells and their focal adhesions using scanning electron microscopy. The technique allows both labels to be discerned visually by their unique shapes and location within and on the cell. S‐phase cells were radio‐labelled with a pulse of tritiated thymidine, selectively incorporated into synthesizing DNA. The cells were then immunogold‐labelled for the focal adhesion protein, vinculin, prepared for autoradiography, and embedded in resin. The resin was then polymerized before removing the substrate, to expose the embedded cell undersurface. Electron‐energy ‘sectioning’ of the sample by varying the accelerating voltage of the electron beam allowed separate S‐phase cell identification in one electron‐energy ‘section’ and visualization of immunogold label in another ‘section’, within the same cell. As a result of applying this technique it was possible to positively identify S‐phase cells and immunogold‐labelled focal adhesions on the same cell simultaneously, which could be used to quantify focal adhesion sites on different substrates.     

Immuno-EM using colloidal metal nanoparticles and electron spectroscopic imaging for co-localization at high spatial resolution

Multiple‐labelling immuno‐EM is a powerful tool for localizing and co‐localizing different antigens simultaneously in cells and tissues at high spatial resolution. Commonly used labels for this purpose are differently sized gold spheres. A comparison of results obtained with differently sized markers is often difficult, because the diameters of markers influence labelling efficiency. In the current study, we investigate a method for high‐resolution multiple‐labelling immuno‐EM, using equally sized colloidal markers made of different metals. Energy filtering transmission electron microscopy is used to differentiate particles based on elemental composition. The labels consist of colloidal gold, palladium and platinum‐core gold‐shell particles of approximately 6 nm in diameter, which are conjugated to different primary antibodies. Applicability of the electron spectroscopic imaging, methodology is demonstrated by labelling of actin, α‐actinin and myosin on ultra‐thin cryosections of skeletal muscle tissue.     

Characterization of the μ and P phase precipitates in the CMSX‐4 single crystal superalloy

A combination of scanning electron microscopy (SEM), transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning‐transmission electron microscopy (STEM) using high‐angle annular‐dark‐field (HAADF) imaging, focussed ion beam‐ scanning electron microscopy (FIB‐SEM) tomography, selected area electron diffraction with beam precession (PED), as well as spatially resolved energy‐dispersive X‐ray spectroscopy (EDS) and electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS), was used to investigate topologically close‐packed (TCP) phases, occurring in the CMSX‐4 superalloy subjected to high temperature annealing and creep deformation. Structural and chemical analyses were performed to identify the TCP phases and provide information concerning the compositional partitioning of elements between them. The results of SEM and FIB‐SEM tomography revealed the presence of merged TCP particles, which were identified by TEM and PED analysis as coprecipitates of the μ and P phases. Inside the TCP particles that were several micrometres in size, platelets of alternating μ and P phases of nanometric width were found. The combination of STEM‐HAADF imaging with spatially resolved EDS and EELS microanalysis allowed determination of the significant partitioning of the constituent elements between the μ and P phases.     

Quantitative phase-amplitude microscopy II: differential interference contrast imaging for biological TEM

Although phase contrast microscopy is widespread in optical microscopy, it has not been as widely adopted in transmission electron microscopy (TEM), which has therefore to a large extent relied on staining techniques to yield sufficient contrast. Those methods of phase contrast that are used in biological electron microscopy have been limited by factors such as the need for small phase shifts in very thin samples, the requirement for difficult experimental conditions, or the use of complex data analysis methods. We here demonstrate a simple method for quantitative TEM phase microscopy that is suitable for large phase shifts and requires only two images. We present a TEM phase image of unstained Radula sp. (liverwort spore). We show how the image may be transformed into the differential interference contrast image format familiar from optical microscopy. The phase images contain features not visible with the other imaging modalities. The resulting technique should permit phase contrast TEM to be performed almost as readily as phase contrast optical microscopy.     

Low-voltage transmission electron microscopy reveals SV40 viral particles within secretory granules in pancreatic cells

Novel approach in low voltage transmission electron microscopy (TEM) has revealed the presence of SV40 viral like particles in the secretory zymogen granules and in spherical membrane-bound dense bodies of SV40 infected pancreatic cells. The presence of SV40 antigen in these cellular compartments was confirmed by immunocytochemistry of the VP1 antigen. Visualization of the viral particles was only possible by examining ultrathin tissue sections with low-voltage TEM that significantly enhances imaging contrast. Results indicate that following infection of the cell entry and trafficking of the viral particles are present in unique cellular compartments such as ER, dense bodies, and secretory granules.     

Perspectives on low voltage transmission electron microscopy as applied to cell biology

Low voltage transmission electron microscopy (LVTEM) with accelerating voltages as low as 5 kV was applied to cell biology. To take advantage of the increased contrast given by LVTEM, tissue preparation was modified omitting all heavy metals such as osmium, uranium, and lead from the fixation, on block staining and counterstaining. Nonstained ultra‐thin tissue sections (40 nm thick) generated highly contrasted images. While the aspect of the cells remains similar to that obtained by conventional TEM, some new substructures were revealed. The pancreatic acinar cells granules present a heterogeneous matrix with partitions corresponding to segregation of their different secretory proteins. Microvilli display their core of microfilaments anchored to the dense top membrane. Mitochondria revealed the presence of distinct particles along their cristea membranes that may correspond to the ATP synthase complexes or oxysomes. The dense nuclear chromatin displays a honey‐comb appearance while distinct beads aligned along thin threads were seen in the dispersed chromatin. These new features revealed by LVTEM correlate with structures described or predicted through other approaches. Masking effects due to thickness of the tissue sections and to the presence of heavy metals must have prevented their observation by conventional TEM. Furthermore, the immunogold was adapted to LVTEM revealing nuclear lamin‐A at the edge of the dense chromatin ribbons. Combining cytochemistry with LVTEM brings additional advantages to this new approach in cell biology. Microsc. Res. Tech. 77:999–1004, 2014. © 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Cryogenic‐temperature electron microscopy direct imaging of carbon nanotubes and graphene solutions in superacids

Cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo‐EM) is a powerful tool for imaging liquid and semiliquid systems. While cryogenic transmission electron microscopy (cryo‐TEM) is a standard technique in many fields, cryogenic scanning electron microscopy (cryo‐SEM) is still not that widely used and is far less developed. The vast majority of systems under investigation by cryo‐EM involve either water or organic components. In this paper, we introduce the use of novel cryo‐TEM and cryo‐SEM specimen preparation and imaging methodologies, suitable for highly acidic and very reactive systems. Both preserve the native nanostructure in the system, while not harming the expensive equipment or the user. We present examples of direct imaging of single‐walled, multiwalled carbon nanotubes and graphene, dissolved in chlorosulfonic acid and oleum. Moreover, we demonstrate the ability of these new cryo‐TEM and cryo‐SEM methodologies to follow phase transitions in carbon nanotube (CNT)/superacid systems, starting from dilute solutions up to the concentrated nematic liquid‐crystalline CNT phases, used as the ‘dope’ for all‐carbon‐fibre spinning. Originally developed for direct imaging of CNTs and graphene dissolution and self‐assembly in superacids, these methodologies can be implemented for a variety of highly acidic systems, paving a way for a new field of nonaqueous cryogenic electron microscopy.     

Combining Ar ion milling with FIB lift-out techniques to prepare high quality site-specific TEM samples

Focused ion beam (FIB) techniques can prepare site‐specific transmission electron microscopy (TEM) cross‐section samples very quickly but they suffer from beam damage by the high energy Ga⁺ ion beam. An amorphous layer about 20–30 nm thick on each side of the TEM lamella and the supporting carbon film makes FIB‐prepared samples inferior to the traditional Ar⁺ thinned samples for some investigations such as high resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) and electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS). We have developed techniques to combine broad argon ion milling with focused ion beam lift‐out methods to prepare high‐quality site‐specific TEM cross‐section samples. Site‐specific TEM cross‐sections were prepared by FIB and lifted out using a Narishige micromanipulator onto a half copper‐grid coated with carbon film. Pt deposition by FIB was used to bond the lamellae to the Cu grid, then the coating carbon film was removed and the sample on the bare Cu grid was polished by the usual broad beam Ar⁺ milling. By doing so, the thickness of the surface amorphous layers is reduced substantially and the sample quality for TEM observation is as good as the traditional Ar⁺ milled samples.     

Ultrastructural analysis of cell wall of drug resistant and sensitive Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolated from cerebrospinal fluid by transmission electron microscope

Drug‐resistant tuberculosis is being increasingly recognized and is one among the leading cause of death worldwide. Remarkable impermeability of cell wall to antituberculous drugs protects the mycobacteria from drug action. The present study analyzed the cell wall thickness among first‐line drug resistant and sensitive Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) isolated from cerebrospinal fluid by transmission electron microscopy (TEM). The average thickness of the cell wall of sensitive isolates was 13.60 ± 0.98 nm. The maximum difference (26.48%) in the cell wall thickness was seen among multi‐drug resistant (18.50 ± 1.71 nm) isolates and the least difference (4.14%) was shown by streptomycin‐resistant (14.18 ± 1.38 nm) isolates. The ultrastructural study showed evident differences in the cell wall thickness among sensitive and resistant isolates. Preliminary TEM examination of cells indicates that morphological changes occur in the cell wall which might be attributed to the drug resistance. The thickened wall of Mtb appears to help the bacilli to overcome the action of antituberculous drugs.     

Immunogold labeling of insulin growth factor-I receptors in elderly human skeletal muscle

Age-associated muscle wasting, or sarcopenia, can be delayed or reversed with interventions, including exercise and pharmaceutical agents. Mapping morphometric changes in the skeletal muscle insulin growth factor 1 receptor can provide valuable information regarding mechanisms controlling muscle protein metabolism. Immunocolloidal gold labeling is a powerful immunocytochemistry procedure for detecting antigens at the ultrastructural level, providing plausible biological markers of cell and tissue adaptations to stimuli. The intent here was to employ immunogold labeling to identify, localize, and quantify the insulin growth factor receptor-I (IGF-IR) in elderly human skeletal muscle. Needle biopsy specimens of the leg vastus lateralis muscle were fixed with 1% glutaraldehyde and 4% paraformaldehyde, dehydrated, and embedded in LR white resin. Pilot experiments were carried out to establish optimal dilutions of primary and secondary antibodies and to employ controls to establish staining specificity. The 6 nm gold particles were first evident when viewed at transmission electron microscopy (TEM) magnifications at 54,000x and clearest at 71,000x. Consistencies were noted in the staining patterns, with the majority of particles lying in proximity to the myofilaments. Gold particles were also found randomly along the outer membrane of the sarcolemma and the mitochondrial membranes. National Institutes of Health (NIH) Image 1.55 version software was used to measure receptor density (NIH, Bethesda, Md., USA). It appears that immunogold labeling of postembedded tissue samples is a sensitive method for detecting IGF-I receptors at the ultrastructural level.     

Imaging analysis of the interface between osteoblasts and microrough surfaces of laser‐sintered titanium alloy constructs

Previous work using focused ion beam (FIB) analysis of osteoblasts on smooth and microrough Ti surfaces showed that the average cell aspect ratio and distance from the surface are greater on the rough surface. In order to better interrogate the relationship between individual cells and their substrate using multiple imaging modalities, we developed a method that tracks the same cell across confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) to correlate surface microroughness with cell morphology and cytoskeleton; scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to provide higher resolution for observation of nanoroughness as well as chemical mapping via energy dispersive X‐ray spectroscopy; and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) for high‐resolution imaging. FIB was used to prepare thin sections of the cell‐material interface for TEM, or for three‐dimensional electron tomography. Cells were cultured on laser‐sintered Ti‐6Al‐4V substrates with polished or etched surfaces. Direct cell to surface attachments were observed across surfaces, though bridging across macroscale surface features occurred on rough substrates. Our results show that surface roughness, cell cytoskeleton and gross morphology can be correlated with the cell‐material cross‐sectional interface at the single cell level across multiple high‐resolution imaging modalities. This work provides a platform method for further investigating mechanisms of the cell‐material interface.     

Transmission electron microscopy with a liquid flow cell

The imaging of microscopic structures at nanometre-scale spatial resolution in a liquid environment is of interest for a wide range of studies. Recently, a liquid flow transmission electron microscopy (TEM) holder equipped with a microfluidic cell has been developed and shown to exhibit flow of nanoparticles through an electron transparent viewing window. Here we demonstrate the application of the flow cell system for both scanning and conventional transmission electron microscopy imaging of immobilized nanoparticles with a resolution of a few nanometres in liquid water of micrometre thickness. The spatial resolution of conventional TEM bright field imaging is shown to be limited by chromatic aberration due to multiple inelastic scattering in the water, and we demonstrate that the liquid in the cell can be displaced by a gas phase that forms under intense electron irradiation. Our data suggest that under appropriate conditions, TEM imaging with a liquid flow cell is a promising method for understanding the in situ behaviour of nanoscale structures in a prescribed and dynamically changing chemical environment.     

Ultrastructural characteristics of ovine bone marrow‐derived mesenchymal stromal cells cultured with a silicon stabilized tricalcium phosphate bioceramic

Bioceramics are being used in experimental bone engineering application in association with bone marrow derived mesenchymal stem cells (BM‐MSCs) as a new therapeutic tool, but their effects on the ultrastructure of BM‐MSCs are yet unknown. In this study we report the morphological features of ovine (o)BM‐MSCs cultured with Skelite, a resorbable bioceramic based on silicon stabilized tricalcium phosphate (SiTCP), able to promote the repair of induced bone defect in sheep model. oBM‐MSCs were isolated from the iliac crest, cultured until they reached near‐confluence and incubated with SiTCP. After 48 hr the monolayers were highly damaged and only few cells adhered to the plastic. Thus, SiTCP was removed, and after washing the cells were cultured until they became confluent. Then, they were trypsinizated and processed for transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and RT‐PCR analysis. RT‐PCR displayed that oBM‐MSCs express typical surface marker for MSCs. TEM revealed the presence of electron‐lucent cells and electron‐dense cells, both expressing the CD90 surface antigen. The prominent feature of electron‐lucent cells was the concentration of cytoplasmic organelles around the nucleus as well as large surface blebs containing glycogen or profiles of endoplasmic reticulum. The dark cells had a multilocular appearance by the presence of peripheral vacuoles. Some dark cells contained endocytic vesicles, lysosomes, and glycogen aggregates. oBM‐MSCs showed different types of specialized interconnections. The comparison with ultrastructural features of untreated oBM‐MSCs suggests the light and dark cells are two distinct cell types which were differently affected by SiTCP bioceramic. Skelite cultured ovine BM‐MSCs display electron‐dense and electron‐lucent cells which are differently affected by this bioceramic. This suggests that they could play a different role in bioceramic based therapy.     

Protein-A gold particles as markers in replica immunocytochemistry: high resolution electron microscope investigations of plasma membrane surfaces

Due to their high atomic number contrast in transmission electron microscopy, gold particles are ideal markers in surface replicas of cultured cells. The suitability of protein-A-coated gold particles in replica immunocytochemistry for labelling surface antigens is demonstrated using measles virus-infected cells as a model system. Labelled areas can easily be distinguished from unlabelled areas, and even markers positioned in the evaporation shadow of large structures can be accurately identified, which is a prerequisite for an exact quantification and mapping of antigen. In addition, the ultrastructure of labelled areas can still be visualized because of the small size of the marker.