SOFC fuelled by methane without coking: optimization of electrochemical performance

In recent years, fuel cell technology has attracted considerable attention from several fields of scientific research as fuel cells produce electric energy with high efficiency, emit little noise, and are non-polluting. Solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) are particularly important for stationary applications due to their high operating temperature (1,073–1,273 K). Methane appears to be a fuel of great interest for SOFC systems because it can be directly converted into hydrogen by direct internal reforming (DIR) within the SOFC anode. Unfortunately, internal steam reforming in SOFC leads to inhomogeneous temperature distributions which can result in mechanical failure of the cermet anode. Moreover this concept requires a large amount of steam in the fed gas. To avoid these problems, gradual internal reforming (GIR) can be used. GIR is based on local coupling between steam reforming and hydrogen oxidation. The steam required for the reforming reaction is obtained by the hydrogen oxidation. However, with GIR, Boudouard and cracking reactions can involve a risk of carbon formation. To cope with carbon formation a new cell configuration of SOFC electrolyte support was studied. This configuration combined a catalyst layer (0.1%Ir–CeO₂) with a classical anode, allowing GIR without coking. In order to optimise the process a SOFC model has been developed, using the CFD-Ace+ software package, and including a thin electrolyte. The impact of a thin electrolyte on previous conclusions has been assessed. As predicted, electrochemical performances are higher and carbon formation is always avoided. However a sharp decrease in the electrochemical performances appears at high current densities due to steam clogging.     

Thermodynamic analysis for a solid oxide fuel cell with direct internal reforming fueled by ethanol

In the present study, a detailed thermodynamic analysis is carried out to provide useful information for the operation of solid oxide fuel cells (SOFC) with direct internal reforming (DIR) fueled by ethanol. Equilibrium calculations are performed to find the ranges of inlet steam/ethanol (H₂O/EtOH) ratio where carbon formation is thermodynamically unfavorable in the temperature range of 500-1500 K. Two types of fuel cell electrolytes, i.e., oxygen-conducting, and hydrogen-conducting electrolytes, are considered. The key parameters determining the boundary of carbon formation are temperature, type of solid electrolyte and extent of the electrochemical reaction of hydrogen. The minimum H₂O/EtOH ratio for which the carbon formation is thermodynamically unfavored decreases with increasing temperature. The hydrogen-conducting electrolyte is found to be impractical for use, due to the tendency for carbon formation. With a higher extent of the electrochemical reaction of hydrogen, a higher value of the H₂O/EtOH ratio is required for the hydrogen-conducting electrolyte, whereas a smaller value is required for the oxygen-conducting electrolyte. This difference is due mainly to the water formed by the electrochemical reaction at the electrodes.     

Alternative concept for SOFC with direct internal reforming operation: Benefits from inserting catalyst rod

Mathematical models of direct internal reforming solid oxide fuel cell (DIR‐SOFC) fueled by methane are developed using COMSOL® software. The benefits of inserting Ni‐catalyst rod in the middle of tubular‐SOFC are simulated and compared to conventional DIR‐SOFC. It reveals that DIR‐SOFC with inserted catalyst provides smoother temperature gradient along the system and gains higher power density and electrochemical efficiency with less carbon deposition. Sensitivity analyses are performed. By increasing inlet fuel flow rate, the temperature gradient and power density improve, but less electrical efficiency with higher carbon deposition is predicted. The feed with low inlet steam/carbon ratio enhances good system performances but also results in high potential for carbon formation; this gains great benefit of DIR‐SOFC with inserted catalyst because the rate of carbon deposition is remarkably low. Compared between counter‐ and co‐flow patterns, the latter provides smoother temperature distribution with higher efficiency; thus, it is the better option for practical applications. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE J, 2010     

Synthesis gas production using steam hydrogasification and steam reforming

Experimental work has been carried out on the mixed reforming reaction, i.e., simultaneous steam and CO₂ reforming of methane under a wide range of feed compositions and four different reaction temperatures from 700 °C to 850 °C using a commercial steam reforming catalyst. The experiments were conducted for a CO₂/CH₄ ratio from 0 to 2 and a steam to methane ratio from 3 to 5. The effect of CO₂/CH₄ ratio on the exit H₂/CO ratio and the conversions of the reactants indicate that the dry reforming reaction is dominant under increased carbon dioxide in the feed. Steam reforming of typical steam hydrogasification product gas consisting of CO, H₂ and CO₂ in addition to steam and methane has also been investigated. The H₂/CO ratio of the product synthesis gas varies from 4.3 to 3.7 and from 4.8 to 4.1 depending on the feed composition and reaction temperature. The CO/CO₂ ratios of the synthesis gas varied from 1.9 to 2.9 and 2.0 to 3.3. The results are compared with simulation results obtained through the Aspen Plus process simulation tool. The results demonstrate that a coupled steam hydrogasification and reforming process can generate a synthesis gas with a flexible H₂/CO ratio from carbon-containing feedstocks.     

Fuel processing in direct propane solid oxide fuel cell and carbon dioxide reforming of propane over Ni-YSZ

This work is aimed at understanding the reaction mechanism of propane internal reforming in the solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC). This mechanism is important for the design and operation of SOFC internal processing of hydrocarbons. An anode-supported SOFC unit with Ni-YSZ anode operating at 800 °C was tested with direct feeding of 5% propane. CO₂ reforming of propane was carried out in a reactor with Ni-YSZ catalyst to simulate internal propane processing in SOFC. The performance of this direct propane SOFC is stable. The C specie formed over the anode functional layer of SOFC can be completely removed. The major gas products of SOFC are H₂, CO, CH₄, C₂H₄ and CO₂. Pseudo-steady-state internal processing of propane in the anode catalytic layer of SOFC is associated with a CO₂/C₃H₈ molar ratio of about 1.26 and basically CO₂ reforming of propane. CO₂ dissociation to produce the O species to oxidize the C species from dehydrogenation and dissociation of propane and its fragments should be the major reaction during CO₂ reforming of propane.     

Catalytic steam reforming of model biogas

Catalytic steam reforming of a model biogas (CH₄/CO₂ = 60/40) is investigated to produce H₂-rich synthesis gas. Gas engines benefit from synthesis gas fuel in terms of higher efficiency and lower NO_x production when compared to raw biogas or CH₄. The process is realized in a fixed bed reactor with a Ni-based catalyst on CaO/Al₂O₃ support. To optimize the performance, the reactor temperature and the amount of excess steam are varied. The experimental results are compared to the theoretical values from thermodynamic calculation and the main trends of CH₄ conversion and H₂ yield are analyzed and verified. Finally, optimal reactor temperature is pointed out and a range of potential steam to methane ratios is presented. The experimental results will be applied to design a steam reformer at an existing anaerobic biomass fermentation plant in Strem, Austria.     

Effect of methane slippage on an indirect internal reforming solid oxide fuel cell

Creation of an autothermal system by coupling an endothermic to an exothermic reaction demands matching the thermal requirements of the two reactions. The application studied here is the operation of a solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) with both direct (DIR) and indirect (IIR) internal reforming of methane. Such internal reforming within a high-temperature fuel cell module can lead to an overall autothermal operation which simplifies the system design and increases efficiency. However, such coupling is not easy to achieve because of the mismatch between the thermal load associated with the rate of steam reforming at typical SOFC temperatures and the local amount of heat available from the fuel cell reactions. Previous results have shown that the use of typical metal-based (e.g. Ni) IIR catalysts leads to full methane consumption but undesirable local cooling at the reformer entrance and the use of less active IIR catalysts (e.g. non-metals or diffusion limited nickel) leads to methane being carried-over into the SOFC anode (methane slippage). In order to evaluate performance in the latter case, a combined DIR and IIR SOFC steady-state model has been developed. Simulation results have shown that, lowering the IIR catalyst activity to prevent local cooling effects at the reformer entrance is not adequate, as the fast kinetics of the direct reforming reaction then lead to full methane conversion and steep temperature gradients in the first 10% of the fuel channel length. It is shown that the simultaneous reduction of the anode DIR reaction rate improves performance considerably. The system behaviour towards changes in current density, operating pressure, and flow configuration (counter-flow vs. co-flow) has been studied. Reduction of both DIR and IIR catalyst activity combined with a counter-flow operation leads to the best performance. System performance with an IIR oxide-based catalyst is also evaluated.     

CO2 conversion through combined steam and CO2 reforming of methane reactions over Ni and Co catalysts

Ni‐Co bimetallic and Ni or Co monometallic catalysts prepared for CO₂ reforming of methane were tested with the stimulated biogas containing steam, CO₂, CH₄, H₂, and CO. A mix of the prepared CO₂ reforming catalyst and a commercial steam reforming catalyst was used in hopes of maximizing the CO₂ conversion. Both CO₂ reforming and steam reforming of CH₄ occurred over the prepared Ni‐Co bimetallic and Ni or Co monometallic catalysts when the feed contained steam. However, CO₂ reforming did not occur on the commercial steam reforming catalyst. There was a critical steam content limit above which the catalyst facilitated no more CO₂ conversion but net CO₂ production for steam reforming and water‐gas shift became the dominant reactions in the system. The Ni‐Co bimetallic catalyst can convert more than 70% of CO₂ in a biogas feed that contains ~33 mol% of CH₄, 21.5 mol% of CO₂, 12 mol% of H₂O, 3.5 mol% of H₂, and 30 mol% of N₂. The H₂/CO ratio of the produced syngas was in the range of 1.8‐2. X‐ray absorption spectroscopy of the spent catalysts revealed that the metallic sites of Ni‐Co bimetallic, Ni and Co monometallic catalysts after the steam reforming of methane reaction with equimolar feed (CH₄:H₂O:N₂ = 1:1:1) experienced severe oxidation, which led to the catalytic deactivation.     

SOFC内部重整反应与电化学反应耦合机理

以经过预重整反应的混合气为原料的固体氧化物燃料电池（SOFC）内部,甲烷蒸气重整反应与电化学反应同时发生在阳极多孔介质中,二者受到不同的操作与设计参数的影响,对电池总体性能起着决定性作用。编制了三维数值模拟程序,对由多孔阳极层、气体流动管道、固体支撑平板构成的单个复合管道进行了研究。结果显示：重整反应主要发生在多孔材料靠近流动管道的薄层内,只有靠近管道入口处才能在较深处进行;电化学反应发生在多孔层与电解质的交界面处;重整反应生成的H2、CO扩散到多孔材料底部参加电化学反应;电化学反应生成的热量供重整反应使用。说明研究范围内,SOFC阳极复合通道具有较好的传热、传质性能,化学/电化学反应存在较好的耦合关系。     

Adsorption of Off‐Gases from Steam Methane Reforming (H2, CO2, CH4, CO and N2) on Activated Carbon

Abstract

Hydrogen is the energy carrier of the future and could be employed in stationary sources for energy production. Commercial sources of hydrogen are actually operating employing the steam reforming of hydrocarbons, normally methane. Separation of hydrogen from other gases is performed by Pressure Swing Adsorption (PSA) units where recovery of high‐purity hydrogen does not exceed 80%.

In this work we report adsorption equilibrium and kinetics of five pure gases present in off‐gases from steam reforming of methane for hydrogen production (H₂, CO₂, CH₄, CO and N₂). Adsorption equilibrium data were collected in activated carbon at 303, 323, and 343 K between 0‐22 bar and was fitted to a Virial isotherm model. Carbon dioxide is the most adsorbed gas followed by methane, carbon monoxide, nitrogen, and hydrogen. This adsorbent is suitable for selective removal of CO₂ and CH₄. Diffusion of all the gases studied was controlled by micropore resistances. Binary (H₂‐CO₂) and ternary (H₂‐CO₂‐CH₄) breakthrough curves are also reported to describe the behavior of the mixtures in a fixed‐bed column. With the data reported it is possible to completely design a PSA unit for hydrogen purification from steam reforming natural gas in a wide range of pressures.     

Experimental Study of the Carbon Deposition from CH4 onto the Ni/YSZ Anode of SOFCs

A challenge in the operation of solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) with hydrocarbon fuels is the carbon deposition on the nickel/yttria‐stabilized zirconia (Ni/YSZ) anode. The Grabke‐type kinetic model has been proposed for the carbon formation based upon the assumption of elementary steps, which consist of a rate‐limiting dissociative chemisorption step and a stepwise dehydrogenation of the chemisorbed methyl group. This work experimentally studied the carbon formation on a SOFC Ni/YSZ anode exposed to CH₄+H₂ gas mixtures. Experiments were conducted with various gas compositions of CH₄/H₂ and temperatures in the range from 873 K to 1,123 K. The experimental results were used to determine a kinetic model that was applied to the SOFC operating environments. Based on the experimental data, the formula for the carbon formation rate that is dependent on the operating temperature and the gas compositions of CH₄/H₂ was established.     

Oxidative reforming of methane on structured Ni-Al<Subscript>2</Subscript>O<Subscript>3</Subscript>/cordierite catalysts

The catalytic properties of Ni/Al₂O₃ composites supported on ceramic cordierite honeycomb monoliths in oxidative methane reforming are reported. The prereduced catalyst has been tested in a flow reactor using reaction mixtures of the following compositions: in methane oxidation, 2–6% CH₄, 2–9% O₂, Ar; in carbon dioxide and oxidative carbon dioxide reforming of methane, 2–6% CH₄, 6–12% CO₂, and 0–4% O₂, and Ar. Physicochemical studies include the monitoring of the formation and oxidation of carbon, the strength of the Ni-O bond, and the phase composition of the catalyst. The structured Ni-Al₂O₃ catalysts are much more productive in the carbon dioxide reforming of methane than conventional granular catalysts. The catalysts performance is made more stable by regulating the acid-base properties of their surface via the introduction of alkali metal (Na, K) oxides to retard the coking of the surface. Rare-earth metal oxides with a low redox potential (La₂O₃, CeO₂) enhance the activity and stability of Ni-Al₂O₃/cordierite catalysts in the deep and partial oxidation and carbon dioxide reforming of methane. The carbon dioxide reforming of methane on the (NiO + La₂O₃ + Al₂O₃)/cordierite catalyst can be intensified by adding oxygen to the gas feed. This reduces the temperature necessary to reach a high methane conversion and does not exert any significant effect on the selectivity with respect to H₂.     

入口气体组成对天然气重整工作温度的影响

重整催化剂是影响重整制氢系统造价和寿命的重要因素。由于在所需重整温度下容易烧结积炭,廉价的Ni系催化剂在分布式中小型重整反应器中的应用受到了限制。为了使Ni系催化剂在不易发生烧结积炭的温度下工作,分析了在一定原料CH4空速和转化率下入口气体组成对重整工作温度的影响,并探讨了在原料气中导入循环气来改变重整入口气体组成的方法。结果表明：Ni系催化剂在导入一定组成和流量比的循环气与不导入循环气时相比,一定原料CH4空速和转化率下的重整工作温度大幅降低。据此,提出了一种用于燃料电池电站氢源系统的重整制氢工艺流程,其特征是将部分燃料电池阳极出口气作为循环气与原料气混合后导入重整反应器,使天然气重整工作温度大幅降低。     

Investigation of a proton-conducting SOFC with internal autothermal reforming of methane

This study presents a performance analysis of a proton-conducting SOFC (SOFC-H⁺) with internal reforming of methane. The autothermal reforming within the SOFC-H⁺ stack is considered to be a potential solution of the carbon formation problem facing in operation of internal steam reforming SOFC-H⁺. A one-dimensional, steady-state model of the SOFC-H⁺ coupled with a detailed electrochemical model is employed to investigate its performance in terms of power density and fuel cell efficiency. The simulation results show that when SOFC-H⁺ is operated under an autothermal reforming environment, the presence of carbon monoxide, which is a major cause of carbon formation, in the fuel cell stack decreases. Effect of key operating parameters, such as temperature, steam-to-carbon and oxygen-to-carbon feed ratios, current density and fuel utilization, on the SOFC-H⁺ performance in terms of electrical efficiencies and energy demand is also investigated. The results indicate that operating temperatures have strong influence on SOFC-H⁺ performance, carbon monoxide production and heat generation.     

The catalytic performance of Ni/MgSiO3 catalyst for methane steam reforming in operation of direct internal reforming MCFC

Active and tolerant Ni-based catalyst for methane steam reforming in direct internal reforming molten carbonate fuel cell (DIR-MCFC) was developed. Deactivation of reforming catalysts by alkali metals from electrolyte composed of Li₂CO₃ and K₂CO₃ is one of the major obstacles to be overcome in commercialization of DIR-MCFC. Newly developed Ni/MgSiO₃ reforming catalyst showed activities of ca. 82% methane conversion for 240 min in out-of-cell test. In duration test, the unit cell containing Ni foam impregnated with Ni/MgSiO₃ in anode gas channel did not give performance degradation for more than 2000 h, while the unit cell assembled with Ni/MgSiO₃-coated anode showed a significant performance loss after an operation of 1200 h. Results obtained from X-ray diffraction and Brunauer–Emmett–Teller technique revealed that Ni sintering and support deterioration were decisive factors in decreasing the catalytic activity.     

Coupling and reforming of methane by means of low pressure radio-frequency plasmas

Non-oxidative coupling of CH₄/H₂ mixtures was carried out by means of radio frequency (rf) glow discharges for the first time. A central composite design was employed to determine the best experimental conditions for methane transformation into higher hydrocarbons and to fit the experimental data. rf power was the factor showing the highest effect on the results while CH₄/H₂ mole ratio showed the lowest. Conversion was 46.4% at 100 W, 0.07 mbar and CH₄/H₂ mole ratio of 1/2. Selectivity was 56.9% for C₂, 6.9% for C₃, and 36.2% for C₄ hydrocarbons. Least squares fits of quadratic equations yielded approximating functions permitting to predict results of random experiments with errors of about 5%. The same rf system was used for the reforming of methane with CO₂, O₂, and steam plasmas, respectively. The highest oxidation was observed with oxygen whilst steam plasma produced the best results. H₂/CO mole ratio was adjusted by setting specific experimental parameters of the latter. CO₂ free synthesis gas was produced at higher H₂O and CH₄ flow rates, i.e. 0.8 mmol/h and higher power, i.e. 100 W. CO₂ and CO free H₂ was produced at 0.3 and 0.6 mmol/h flow rates of H₂O and CH₄, respectively, and 50 W.     

Hydrogen production from steam methane reforming coupled with in situ CO2 capture: Conceptual parametric study

The work deals with fundamental analysis of the sorption-enhanced steam methane reforming (SE-SMR) process in which the simultaneous removal of carbon dioxide by hydrotalcite-based chemisorbent is coupled. A two-section reactor model is developed to describe the SE-SMR reactor, decoupling the complexity in process analysis. The model defines two subsequent sections in the reactor: an equilibrium conversion section (upstream) and an adsorption reforming section (downstream). The material balance relationship in the equilibrium conversion section is directly determined by thermodynamic equilibrium calculation, providing an equilibrated atmosphere to the next section. The adsorption reforming section is described using an isothermal multi-component dynamic model into which the SMR reactions and the high-temperature CO₂ adsorption are embedded. The multiple requirements (including H₂ purity, H₂ productivity, CH₄ conversion enhancement, and carbon oxides concentrations) are taken into account simultaneously so as to analyze and define feasible operation window for producing high-purity hydrogen with ppm-level CO impurity. The performances of the reactors with different dimensions (laboratory-scale and pilot-scale) are explored, highlighting the importance of operation parameter control to the process feasibility.     

Effect of methane concentration on reaction behavior in direct-methane solid oxide fuel cells with (Ce,Gd)O2−x-impregnated FeCr layer for fuel processing

A solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) with a Ni-yttria-stabilized zirconia anode of 1 cm² area was set up with a porous disk of gadolinia-doped ceria-impregnated FeCr as a gas diffusion layer (GDL) under direct-methane feeding. In this setup of SOFC plus GDL, the tests at 800 °C and ambient pressure show that the current density, the methane conversion rate, the product formation rates, and the CO₂ selectivity increased with increasing methane concentration. The major reaction in the GDL is CO₂ reforming of methane to produce the syngas (CO plus H₂). The anodic electrochemical oxidation of CO from GDL results in an overall rate of CO₂ formation being much larger than that of CO formation. There is a synergy between the rate of reaction in the GDL and that over the anode.     

Catalytic aspects of the steam reforming of hydrocarbons in internal reforming fuel cells

Steam reforming of hydrocarbons such as natural gas is an attractive method of producing the hydrogen fuel gas required by fuel cells. It may be carried out external to the fuel cell or internally. The two types of fuel cell in which internal reforming is most appropriate are the molten carbonate (MCFC), operating at ca. 650°C and the solid oxide (SOFC) which currently operates above 800°C. At such temperatures, the heat liberated by the electrochemical reactions within the cell can be utilised by the endothermic steam reforming reaction. This paper reviews some of the catalytic aspects of internal reforming in these two types of cell. In the MCFC the major catalyst issue is that of long term activity in the presence of a corrosive alkaline environment produced by the cell's electrolyte. In Europe, this is being addressed by British Gas and others, in a programme part-funded by the European Commission. In this programme, potential catalysts for the direct internal reforming MCFC were evaluated in ‘out-of-cell’ tests. This has led to the demonstration of a 1 kW proof-of-concept DIR-MCFC stack and the start of a European ‘Advanced DIR-MCFC’ project. For the SOFC, it has been shown that state-of-the-art nickel cermet anodes can provide sufficient activity for steam reforming without the need for additional catalyst. However, anode degradation may occur when steam reforming is carried out for long periods. New anode materials could therefore offer significant benefits.     

Optimising H2 production from model biogas via combined steam reforming and CO shift reactions

H₂ production was studied through steam reforming of a clean model biogas in a fluidized-bed reactor followed by two stages of CO shift reactions (fixed-bed reactors). The steam reforming of biogas was performed over 11.5 wt.% Ni/Al₂O₃ and a molar CH₄/CO₂ ratio of 1.5 was employed as clean model biogas. Excess steam resulted in strong inhibition of carbon formation and an almost complete CH₄ (>98%) conversion was achieved.To optimise H₂ production, CO shift reactions were carried out at high (523–723 K) and low temperatures (423–523 K) using commercial catalysts, based on Cu/Fe/Cr and Cu/Zn, respectively. Increasing steam concentrations led to a lean CO, high H₂ product. The final product compositions following low temperature CO shift reaction (steam to dry gas ratio of 1.5 at 483 K) yielded H₂ at 68% and a CO concentration of 0.2% (equivalent to CO conversion of >99%).