Determination of dissociation constants for protein-ligand complexes by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

A fully automated biophysical assay based on electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) for the determination of the dissociation constants (KD) between soluble proteins and low molecular mass ligands is presented. The method can be applied to systems where the relative MS response of the protein and the protein-ligand complexes do not reflect relative concentrations. Thus, the employed approach enables the use of both electrostatically and nonpolar bound complexes. The dynamic range is wider than for most biological assays, which facilitates the process of establishing a structure-activity relationship. This fully automated ESI-MS assay is now routinely used for ligand screening. The entire procedure is described in detail using hGHbp, a 25-kDa extracellular soluble domain of the human growth hormone receptor, as a model protein.     

Dynamic titration: determination of dissociation constants for noncovalent complexes in multiplexed format using HPLC-ESI-MS

With recent growth in fields such as life sciences and supramolecular chemistry, there has been an ever increasing need for high-throughput methods that would permit determination of binding affinities for noncovalent complexes of various host-guest systems. These are traditionally measured by titration experiments where concentration-dependent signals of species participating in solution-based binding equilibria are monitored by methods such as UV-vis spectrophotometry, calorimetry, or nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometry. Here we present a new titration technique that unifies and allows chromatographic separation of guests with determination of dissociation constants by electrospray mass spectrometry in a multiplexed format. A theoretical model has been derived that describes the complex formation for the guests eluted from a chromatographic column when hosts are admixed postcolumn. The model takes possible competition equilibria into account; i.e., it can deal with unresolved peaks of guests with the possible addition of multiple hosts in one experiment. This on-line workflow makes determination of binding affinities for large libraries of compounds possible. The potential of the method is demonstrated on the determination of dissociation constants for complexes of beta- and gamma-cyclodextrins with nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs ibuprofen, naproxen, and flurbiprofen.     

Quantifying protein-protein interactions within noncovalent complexes using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Several electrospray-mass spectrometry (ESI-MS)-based methods are available for determining the constant of association (K(a)) between a protein and a small ligand, but current MS-based strategies are not fully adequate for measuring K(a) of protein-protein interactions accurately. We expanded the application of ESI-MS-based titration to determine the strength of noncovalent interactions between proteins, forming a complex. Taking into account relative response factors (probability of being ionized, transmitted, and detected), we determined K(a) values of an equilibrium between dimers and tetramers at three different pH values (6.8, 3.4, and 8.4). We investigated the association of the lectin concanavalin A, whose dimer-tetramer ratio in the gas phase is affected by solution concentration and by pH. To calculate the constants of association in solution, we also utilized isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) for a comparison with MS-based titration. At pH 6.8 and pH 8.4, the K(a) values measured by MS and by ITC were in agreement. ITC results allowed us to restrain the response factor to a value close to 4. At pH 3.4, we were able to measure the K(a) only by MS, but not by ITC because of limited sensitivity of calorimetry. Our investigation illustrates the great potential MS for calculating the binding strength of protein-protein interactions within noncovalent complexes. The main advantages of MS over ITC are its sensitivity (i.e., the required amount of sample is >100 times less than the one necessary for ITC), and the possibility to obtain precise information on composition of protein complexes, their stoichiometry, their subunit interactions, and their assembly pathway. Compared to previous investigations, our study shows the strong influence of response factors on determining accurate protein-protein association constants by MS.     

A method for the determination of binding constants by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

A new method for the determination of binding constants using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry is presented. The intensity of a reference complex with a known log K value is monitored before and after addition of a second host or guest. On the basis of the change in intensity of the reference complex and extrapolation from a calibration curve, the log K value is then derived for the complex of interest using a set of simultaneous equilibrium equations. Binding constants of several crown ether-alkali metal cation complexes that were previously studied were determined to validate this strategy. Log K values for complexes involving dibenzo-16-crown-5 and its sym-oxyacetate derivative with Na+ or K+ were also determined.     

Desorption electrospray ionization mass spectrometry of glycosaminoglycans and their protein noncovalent complex

Glycosaminoglycans heparin and heparan sulfate are biologically active polysulfated carbohydrates that are among the most challenging biopolymers with regards to their structural analysis and functional assessment. Fragmentation of oligosaccharides and sulfate loss are important hindrance to their analysis by mass spectrometry (MS), requiring thus soft ionization methods. The recently introduced soft ionization method desorption electrospray ionization (DESI) has been applied here to heparin and heparan sulfate oligosaccharides, showing that DESI-MS is well suited for the detection of such fragile biomolecules in their intact form. Characterization of complicated oligosaccharides such as synthetic heparin octadecasulfated dodecasaccharide was successfully achieved. The use of water for a spray solvent instead of denaturing organic solvents allowed the first DESI-MS detection of noncovalent biomolecular complexes between heparin oligosaccharides and the chemokine Stromal Cell-derived Factor-1. The hyphenation of the DESI ion source with the high-resolution LTQ-Orbitrap MS analyzer led to high accuracy of mass measurement and enabled unambiguous determination of the protein-bound sulfated oligosaccharide.     

Quantifying ligand binding to large protein complexes using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

An electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) method for quantifying protein-ligand complexes that cannot be directly detected by ESI-MS is described. The proxy protein ESI-MS method combines direct ESI-MS binding measurements with competitive protein-ligand binding. To implement the method, a proxy protein (P(proxy)), which interacts specifically with the ligand of interest with known affinity and can be detected directly by ESI-MS, is used to quantitatively monitor the extent of ligand binding to the protein of interest. A mathematical framework for establishing the association constant (K(a)) for protein-ligand binding by the proxy protein ESI-MS method, implemented with a P(proxy) containing a single ligand binding site, is given. A modified form of the proxy protein ESI-MS method, which accounts for real-time changes in ligand concentration, is also described. The reliability of these methods is demonstrated for the interactions between the 180 kDa wildtype homotrimeric tailspike protein of the bacteriophage P22 and its endorhamnosidase point mutant (D392N) with its ligands comprising two and three O-antigen repeats from Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium: octasaccharide ([α-Gal-(1→2)-[α-Abe-(1→3)]-α-Man-(1→4)-α-Rha](2)) and dodecasaccharide ([α-Gal-(1→2)-[α-Abe-(1→3)]-α-Man-(1→4)-α-Rha](3)). A 27 kDa single chain antibody, which binds to both ligands, served as P(proxy). The results of binding measurements performed at 10 and 25 °C are in excellent agreement with K(a) values measured previously using a fluorescence quenching assay.     

Stabilization of gas-phase noncovalent macromolecular complexes in electrospray mass spectrometry using aqueous triethylammonium bicarbonate buffer

The use of triethylammonium bicarbonate (TEAB) solution in electrospray mass spectrometry proved to be a very efficient way for studying proteins or noncovalent protein complexes under "nondenaturing" conditions. The low charge states observed in the mass spectra improve the separation of ions arising from macromolecular species of close masses. Moreover, the multiply charged ions generated in a TEAB solution are significantly more stable than those formed under more conventional conditions (for example, with ammonium bicarbonate or acetate solution). The analytical interest of TEAB for the analysis of macromolecular species that can easily dissociate in the gas phase, such as hemoglobin or other macromolecular noncovalent complexes, is demonstrated.     

On-line electrodialytic salt removal in electrospray ionization mass spectrometry of proteins

Salts and buffers, commonly used in isolation and stabilization of biological analytes, have a deleterious effect on electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). Excessive concentrations of salts lead to ion suppression and adduct formation, which mask or complicate ion signals. In this work, we describe a salt remover (SR), configured as a three-compartment flow-through system, where the central compartment is separated from the outer compartments by a cation-exchange membrane (CEM) and an anion-exchange membrane (AEM). One platinum electrode is placed in each of the outer compartments, where water or electrolyte is flowing. The CEM electrode is held at a negative potential relative to the AEM side; cations/anions migrate by electrophoresis to the CEM/AEM receiver liquids, respectively. Proteins have poorer electrophoretic mobility relative to the buffer components, permitting removal of the salt. The salt-free proteins proceed to the ESI source. The capillary scale SR (internal volume 2.5 μL) described here effectively desalted continuous flows of NaCl solutions (200 mequiv/L at 1 μL/min, equivalent to a flux of 200 nequiv/min with 88% efficiency) and achieved >99.8% salt removal with 154 mM NaCl (isotonic saline) at 1 μL/min. With optimized current, >80% of concurrently present 20 μM protein was transmitted. Desalting efficiency and analyte loss was evaluated with different salt concentration and flow rate combinations under different applied current. Good-quality ESI-MS spectra of cytochrome c, myoglobin, and lysozyme as test proteins in a saline solution, passed through the SR, are demonstrated.     

Direct on-line method to monitor the dynamic structure of noncovalent titanium complexes in solution by using cold-spray ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry

In this paper, we report the feasibility of using the on-line cold-spray ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (CSI-TOFMS) method to monitor directly the labile noncovalent organometallic complexes formed in the substitution reaction between a chiral titanium asymmetric catalyst and organic acid in the toluene solvent. The comparison between the conventional ESI and CSI-TOFMS spectra of [(S)1]2Ti2[(S)2]2 in THF indicated that the CSI-TOFMS is an effective method to characterize the structures of labile organometallic complexes in solution. A new strategy was designed so that [(S)1]2Ti2[(S)2]2 and organic acid solution were delivered independently to the CSI ion source by two infusion syringe pumps, and they mixed at a triple valve, and then the substitution reaction occurred in the sprayer. The mix and reaction time was approximately 5 s and can be adjusted by the length of the PEEK tube and the flow rate. The reaction products were ionized and detected directly by the CSI-TOFMS. Organic acids, such as formic, acetic, phenylpropionic, anisic, and para-methoxylphenylactic acids, were investigated. From the on line CSI-TOFMS spectra, it is observed clearly that one or two (S)2 group(s) can be substituted by the added acid to form new species. The results obtained here demonstrated that the designed strategy with on line CSI-TOFMS is effective and reliable to elucidate the dynamic structure of noncovalent titanium complexes in reaction solution.     

Analysis of noncovalent chitinase-chito-oligosaccharide complexes by infrared-matrix assisted laser desorption ionization and nanoelectrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Transferring noncovalently bound complexes from the condensed phase into the gas phase represents a challenging task due to weak intermolecular bonds that have to be maintained during the phase transition. Currently, electrospray ionization (ESI) is the standard mass spectrometric (MS) technique to analyze noncovalent complexes. Although infrared matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization (IR-MALDI)-MS also provides particular soft desorption/ionization conditions, this method has so far hardly been applied for the analysis of noncovalent complexes. In this study, we employed IR-MALDI orthogonal time-of-flight (o-TOF)-MS in combination with the liquid matrix glycerol to characterize the specific complex formation of chito-oligosaccharide (CHOS) ligands with two variants of Chitinase A (ChiA) from Serratia marcescens, the inactive E315Q mutant and the active W167A mutant, respectively. The IR-MALDI-o-TOF-MS results were compared to those obtained using nano-ESI-quadrupole (q)-TOF-MS and ultraviolet (UV)-MALDI-o-TOF-MS. Using IR-MALDI-o-TOF-MS, specific noncovalent complexes between ChiA and CHOS were detected with distributions between enzymes with bound oligosaccharides vs free enzymes that were essentially identical to those obtained by nano-ESI-q-TOF-MS. Chitinase-CHOS complexes were not detected when UV-MALDI was employed for desorption/ionization. The results show that IR-MALDI-MS can be a valuable tool for fast and simple screening of noncovalent enzyme-ligand interactions.     

Screening for noncovalent ligand-receptor interactions by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry-based diffusion measurements

The application of a novel method for the identification of low-molecular-weight noncovalent ligands to a macromolecular target is reported. This technique is based on the measurement of analyte diffusion coefficients by electrospray mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) (Clark et al., Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom. 2002, 16, 1454-1462). Potential ligands have large diffusion coefficients as long as they are free in solution. Binding to a macromolecular target, however, drastically reduces the diffusional mobility of any ligand species. Mixtures containing six different saccharides [ribose, rhamnose, glucose, maltose, maltotriose, and N,N',N'-triacetylchitotriose (NAG(3))] were screened for noncovalent binding to lysozyme. Of these six compounds, only NAG(3) is known to bind to the protein. In "direct" binding tests, NAG(3) shows a significantly reduced diffusion coefficient in the presence of the protein. No changes were observed for any of the other saccharides. In a second set of experiments, the use of a "competition" screening method was explored in which mixtures of candidate saccharides were tested for their ability to displace a reference ligand from the target. The addition of NAG(3)-containing mixtures significantly increased the diffusion coefficient of the reference ligand NAG(4) (N,N',N',N'-tetraacetylchitotetrose), whereas mixtures that did not contain NAG(3) had no effect. These data clearly indicate the potential of ESI-MS-based diffusion measurements as a novel tool to screen compound libraries for binding to proteins and other macromolecular targets. In contrast to conventional ESI-MS-based ligand-receptor binding studies, this method does not rely on the preservation of noncovalent interactions in the gas phase.     

High mass measurement accuracy determination for proteomics using multivariate regression fitting: application to electrospray ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry

Important factors that limit the mass measurement accuracy from a mass spectrometer are related to (1) the type of mass analyzer used and (2) the data processing/calibration methods used to obtain mass values from the raw data. Here, two data processing methods are presented that correct for systematic deviations when the mass of ions is measured using a time-of-flight (TOF) mass spectrometer. The first fitting method is one where m/z values are obtained from fitting peak distributions using double Gaussian functions. A second calibration method takes into account the slight nonlinear response of the TOF analyzer in addition to the drift in the calibration over time. Using multivariate regression, both of these two effects can be corrected for using a single calibration formula. Achievable performance was evaluated with a trypsin digestion of serum albumin and proteins from the organism D. radiodurans that was analyzed using gradient reversed-phase liquid chromatography combined with an electrospray ionization orthogonal TOF mass spectrometer. The root-mean-square deviation between the theoretical and experimental m/z values for serum albumin tryptic peptides was found to be 8 ppm using the double Gaussian-multivariate method compared to 29 ppm determined using linear calibration and normal peak centroiding. An advantage of the methods presented here is that no calibrant compounds need to be added to the mobile phase, thereby avoiding interference effects and signal suppression of analytes.     

Structural analysis of polymer end groups by electrospray ionization high-energy collision-induced dissociation tandem mass spectrometry

Chemical structures of polymer end groups play an important role in determining the functional properties of a polymeric system. We present a mass spectrometric method for determining end group structures. Polymeric ions are produced by electrospray ionization (ESI), and they are subject to source fragmentation in the ESI interface region to produce low-mass fragment ions. A series of source-fragment ions containing various numbers of monomer units are selected for high-energy collision-induced dissociation (CID) in a sector/time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometer. It is shown that high-energy CID spectra of source-induced fragment ions are very informative for end group structure characterization. By comparing the CID spectra of fragment ions with those of known chemicals, it is possible to unambiguously identify the end group structures. The utility of this technique is illustrated for the analysis of two poly(ethylene glycol)-based slow-releasing drugs where detailed structural characterization is of significance for drug formulation, quality control, and regulatory approval. Practical issues related to the application of this method are discussed.     

Development of submillisecond time-resolved mass spectrometry using desorption electrospray ionization

Reaction kinetics studied by mass spectrometry (MS) has previously been limited to millisecond time resolution. This paper presents the development of a submillisecond time-resolved mass spectrometric method for fast reaction kinetic study, based on the capability of desorption electrospray ionization (DESI) for direct and fast ionization of a high-speed liquid jet stream. The principle underlying this methodology is that two reactant solutions undergo rapid mixing to produce a free liquid jet which is ionized by DESI at different positions corresponding to different reaction times. Due to the high velocity of the liquid jet, high time resolution can be achieved. In this study, the fast reduction reaction of 2, 6-dichlorophenolindophenol (DCIP) and L-ascorbic acid (L-AA) was chosen as an example to demonstrate this concept, and the reaction rate constant was successfully measured with an unprecedented time resolution of 300 μs. The good agreement of the measured value of (116 ± 3) s(-1) with that measured by the stopped-flow optical method (105 ± 2) s(-1) validates the feasibility of such a DESI-MS approach. Unlike classical spectroscopic techniques that require either chromophoric substrates or labeling, MS is a general detector with high chemical specificity. Therefore, this time-resolved DESI-MS method should find wide applications in fast (bio)chemical reaction investigations.     

Thermal dissociation of multimeric protein complexes by using nanoelectrospray mass spectrometry

The behavior of macromolecular systems at different temperatures is often crucial to their biological activity and function. While heat-induced changes of individual proteins are readily monitored by a number of spectroscopic methods, changes in noncovalent complexes of biomolecules are more challenging to interpret. Nanoelectrospray mass spectrometry is becoming increasingly powerful in the study of large noncovalent complexes, and here we describe the design, characterization, and application of a novel probe that allows the thermocontrol of the solution in the electrospray capillary. The transition temperature for the unfolding of the protein lysozyme is readily obtained and correlates closely with that measured by fluorescence spectroscopy, thereby demonstrating the validity of this approach. We apply this technique to the study of the 200-kDa complex of the small heat shock protein TaHSP16.9, revealing both its dissociation into suboligomeric species and an increase in its size and polydispersity at elevated temperatures. In contrast, gas-phase activation of this complex is also carried out and yields a dissociation pathway fundamentally different from that observed for thermal activation in solution. As such, this probe allows the study of the reversible heat-induced changes of noncovalent complexes in a biologically relevant manner.     

Determination of ligand-protein dissociation constants by electrospray mass spectrometry-based diffusion measurements

A novel approach for the quantification of ligand-protein interactions is presented. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) is used to monitor the diffusion behavior of noncovalent ligands in the presence of their protein receptors. These data allow the fraction of free ligand in solution to be determined, such that the corresponding dissociation constants can be calculated. A set of conditions is developed that provides an "allowable range" of concentrations for this type of assay. The method is tested by applying it to two different inhibitor-enzyme systems. The dissociation constants measured for benzamidine-trypsin and for N,N',N' '-triacetylchitotriose-lysozyme are (50 +/- 10) and (6 +/- 1) mM, respectively. Both of these results are in good agreement with previous data from the literature. In contrast to traditional ESI-MS-based methods, the approach used in this work does not rely on the preservation of specific solution-type noncovalent interactions in the gas phase. It is shown that this method allows an accurate determination of dissociation constants, even in cases in which the ion abundance ratio of free to ligand-bound protein in ESI-MS does not reflect the corresponding concentration ratio in solution.     

Quantitative determination of noncovalent binding interactions using automated nanoelectrospray mass spectrometry

Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) has proven to be an extremely powerful tool for studying biomolecular structures and noncovalent interactions. Here we report a method using a fully automated, chip-based nanoESI-MS system to determine the dissociation constants (Kd) for the complexes of two different proteins with their ligands. The automated nanoelectrospray system, consisting of the NanoMate and ESI chip, serves functionally as a combination of autosampler and nanoelectrospray ionization source. This system provides all the advantages of conventional nanoelectrospray plus automated, high-throughput analyses without carryover. The automated nanoESI system was used to investigate quantitative noncovalent interactions between ribonuclease A (RNase A) and cytidylic acid ligands (2'-CMP, CTP), a well-characterized model protein-ligand complex, and between an inactive endocellulase mutant (Thermobifida fusca Cel6A D117Acd) and four oligosaccharide ligands (cellotriose, cellotetraose, cellopentaose, cellohexaose). Both titration and competitive binding approaches were performed prior to automated nanoESI-MS analysis with a Q-TOF mass spectrometer. Dissociation constants for each complex were calculated from the sum of ion peak areas of free and complexed proteins during the titration and competition experiments. The measured Kd values for the RNase A-CMP and Cel6A D117Acd-G3 complexes were found to be in excellent agreement with the available published values obtained by standard spectroscopic titration techniques. To our knowledge, this is the first report of using an ESI-MS approach to study the interactions between a cellulase and oligosaccharides. The results provide new insights for understanding the nature of cellulase-cellulose interactions.     

Study of electrochemical reactions using nanospray desorption electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

The combination of electrochemistry (EC) and mass spectrometry (MS) is a powerful analytical tool for studying mechanisms of redox reactions, identification of products and intermediates, and online derivatization/recognition of analytes. This work reports a new coupling interface for EC/MS by employing nanospray desorption electrospray ionization, a recently developed ambient ionization method. We demonstrate online coupling of nanospray desorption electrospray ionization MS with a traditional electrochemical flow cell, in which the electrolyzed solution emanating from the cell is ionized by nanospray desorption electrospray ionization for MS analysis. Furthermore, we show first coupling of nanospray desorption electrospray ionization MS with an interdigitated array (IDA) electrode enabling chemical analysis of electrolyzed samples directly from electrode surfaces. Because of its inherent sensitivity, nanospray desorption electrospray ionization enables chemical analysis of small volumes and concentrations of sample solution. Specifically, good-quality signal of dopamine and its oxidized form, dopamine o-quinone, was obtained using 10 μL of 1 μM solution of dopamine on the IDA. Oxidation of dopamine, reduction of benzodiazepines, and electrochemical derivatization of thiol groups were used to demonstrate the performance of the technique. Our results show the potential of nanospray desorption electrospray ionization as a novel interface for electrochemical mass spectrometry research.     

Characterization of archaeological beeswax by electron ionization and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

To better detect and identify beeswax in ancient organic residues from archaeological remains, we developed a new analytical methodology consisting of the analysis of (i) the trimethylsilylated organic extract by GC/MS and (ii) the crude extract by ESI-MS. Selective scanning modes, such as SIM or MRM, permit separate quantification of each chemical family (fatty acids, monoesters, monohydroxyesters, and diesters) and allow an improvement in sensitivity and selectivity, allowing the crude extract to be treated without further purification. GC/MS (SIM) was revealed to be a powerful method for the detection of components, with a detection limit down to a total lipid extract in the range of approximately 50 ng in a complex matix, such as archaeological degraded material, whereas ESI-MS/MS is instead used for the detection of nonvolatile biomarkers. Identification by GC/MS (SIM) and ESI-MS/ MS (MRM) of more than 50 biomarkers of beeswax in an Etruscan cup at the parts-per-million level provides the first evidence for the use of this material by the Etruscans as fuel or as a waterproof coating for ceramics.     

Determination of dissolved metal species by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

The distribution of metal species in solution was determined using flow injection electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Complexes formed by selected metal ions with added organic ligands in 50:50 water/acetonitrile and 50:50 water/methanol under acidic, neutral, and basic conditions were detected using electrospray ionization conditions optimized to best represent solution-phase interactions. Metal species containing acetate, nitrate, and solvent molecules predominated in acidic solution but became less abundant at higher pH. Interactions between metal ions and added organic ligands became more selective with increasing pH, showing the expected preference of hard and soft ligands for metal ions of the corresponding type. Species distributions also tended toward larger complexes as pH increased. Overall ion yield was greater for aqueous acetonitrile than for aqueous methanol solutions; however, reduction of copper(II) in aqueous acetonitrile resulted in the detection of copper(I) complexes for certain ligands. Experimental results for copper(II) and 8-hydroxyquinoline in 50:50 water/methanol showed good agreement with aqueous speciation predicted using the thermodynamic equilibrium model MINEQL. Detection of neutral complexes was achieved by protonation, deprotonation, or electrochemical oxidation during electrospray.