Thermochemistry of protein-DNA interaction studied with temperature-controlled nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures

We introduce temperature-controlled nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures (NECEEM) and demonstrate its use to study thermochemistry of protein-DNA interactions. Being a homogeneous kinetic method, temperature-controlled NECEEM uniquely allows finding temperature dependencies of equilibrium and kinetic parameters of complex formation without the immobilization of the interacting molecules on the surface of a solid substrate. In this work, we applied temperature-controlled NECEEM to study the thermochemistry of two protein-DNA pairs: (i) Taq DNA polymerase with its DNA aptamer and (ii) E. coli single-stranded DNA binding protein with a 20-base-long single-stranded DNA. We determined temperature dependencies of three parameters: the equilibrium binding constant (Kb), the rate constant of complex dissociation (k(off)), and the rate constant of complex formation (k(on)). The Kb(T) functions for both protein-DNA pairs had phase-transition-like points suggesting temperature-dependent conformational changes in structures of the interacting macromolecules. Temperature dependencies of k(on) and k(off) provided insights into how the conformational changes affected two opposite processes: binding and dissociation. Finally, thermodynamic parameters, DeltaH and DeltaS, for complex formation were found for different conformations. With its unique features and potential applicability to other macromolecular interactions, temperature-controlled NECEEM establishes a valuable addition to the arsenal of analytical methods used to study dynamic molecular complexes.     

Selection of smart aptamers by methods of kinetic capillary electrophoresis

We coin the term "smart aptamers" -- aptamers with predefined binding parameters (k(on), k(off), Kd) of aptamer-target interaction. Aptamers, in general, are oligonucleotides, which are capable of binding target molecules with high affinity and selectivity. They are considered as potential therapeutic targets and also thought to rival antibodies in immunoassay-like analyses. Aptamers are selected from combinatorial libraries of oligonucleotides by affinity methods. Until now, technological limitations have precluded the development of smart aptamers. Here, we report on two kinetic capillary electrophoresis techniques applicable to the selection of smart aptamers. Equilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures was used to develop aptamers with predefined equilibrium dissociation constants (Kd), while nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures facilitated selection of aptamers with different dissociation rate constants (k(off)). Selections were made for MutS protein, for which aptamers have never been previously developed. Both theoretical and practical aspects of smart aptamer development are presented, and the advantages of this new type of affinity probes are described.     

Method for determination of peak areas in nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures

Nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures (NECEEM) facilitates determination of both the kinetic constants (k(off)) and the equilibrium constants (K(d)) of complex dissociation from a single experiment. A typical NECEEM electropherogram consists of two peaks and an "exponential bridge" between them, smoothly merging into the peaks. The values of k(off) and K(d) are usually calculated with simple algebraic formulas, by utilizing the areas of the peaks and the bridge. Accurate determination of the two constants requires accurate positioning of the two boundaries separating the bridge from the peaks. Here, we propose a more systematic method for the determination of boundaries between the peaks and the bridge. The method involves a simple geometrical analysis of a NECEEM electropherogram based on an assumption of symmetry in ordinary electrophoretic peaks. To test the method, we (i) constructed a series of computer-simulated NECEEM electropherograms, (ii) determined the two boundaries with our method, and (iii) calculated the values of k(off) and K(d). We found that the deviation of the calculated values from those used to simulate the electropherograms did not exceed 15% for k(off) and 25% for K(d), as long as the peaks and the bridge were visually identifiable. We finally applied the method to the determination of K(d) and k(off) values for the interaction between AlkB protein and its DNA aptamer. The developed method for rational boundary determination in NECEEM will facilitate accurate data analysis in a simple and efficient manner.     

Nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures, mathematical model

We recently introduced a new electrophoretic method, nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures (NECEEM). NECEEM provides a unique way of finding kinetic and equilibrium parameters of the formation of intermolecular complexes from a single electropherogram and allows for the use of weak affinity probes in protein quantitation. In this work, we study theoretical bases of NECEEM by developing a mathematical model for the new method. By solving a system of partial differential equations with diffusion in linear approximation, we found the analytical solution for concentrations of components involved in complex formation as functions of time from the beginning of separation and position in the capillary. The nonnumerical nature of the solution makes it a powerful tool in studying the theoretical foundations of the NECEEM method and modeling experimental results. We demonstrate the use of the model for finding binding parameters of complex formation by nonlinear regression of NECEEM electropherograms obtained experimentally.     

Aptamer-based detection and quantitative analysis of ricin using affinity probe capillary electrophoresis

The ability to detect sub-nanomolar concentrations of ricin using fluorescently tagged RNA aptamers is demonstrated. Aptamers rival the specificity of antibodies and have the power to simplify immunoassays using capillary electrophoresis. Under nonequilibrium conditions, a dissociation constant, Kd, of 134 nM has been monitored between the RNA aptamer and ricin A-chain. With use of this free-solution assay, the detection of 500 pM (approximately 14 ng/mL) or 7.1 amol of ricin is demonstrated. The presence of interfering proteins such as bovine serum albumin and casein do not inhibit this interaction at sub-nanomolar concentrations. When spiked with RNAse A, ricin can still be detected down to 1 nM concentrations despite severe aptamer degradation. This approach offers a promising method for the rapid, selective, and sensitive detection of biowarfare agents.     

Selection strategy to generate aptamer pairs that bind to distinct sites on protein targets

Many analytical techniques benefit greatly from the use of affinity reagent pairs, wherein each reagent recognizes a discrete binding site on a target. For example, antibody pairs have been widely used to dramatically increase the specificity of enzyme linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA). Nucleic acid-based aptamers offer many advantageous features relative to protein-based affinity reagents, including well-established chemical synthesis, thermostability, and low production cost. However, the generation of suitable aptamer pairs has posed a significant challenge, and few such pairs have been reported to date. To address this important challenge, we present multivalent aptamer isolation systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (MAI-SELEX), a technique designed for the efficient selection of aptamer pairs. In contrast to conventional selection methods, our method utilizes two selection modules to generate separate aptamer pools that recognize distinct binding sites on a single target. Using MAI-SELEX, we have isolated two groups of 2'-fluoro-modified RNA aptamers that specifically recognize the αV or β3 subunits of integrin αVβ3. These aptamers exhibit low nanomolar affinities for their targets, with minimal cross-reactivity to other closely related integrin homologues. Moreover, we show that these aptamer pairs do not interfere with each other's binding and effectively detect the target even in complex mixtures such as undiluted serum.     

Aptamer based electrochemical sensor system for protein using the generation/collection mode of scanning electrochemical microscope (SECM)

To detect the target molecules, aptamers are currently focused on and the use of aptamers for biosensing is particularly interesting, as aptamers could substitute antibodies in bioanalytical sensing. So this paper describes the novel electrochemical system for protein in sandwich manner by using the aptamers and the scanning electrochemical microscope (SECM). For protein detection, sandwich system is ideal since labeling of the target protein is not necessary. To develop the electrochemical protein sensor system, thrombin was chosen as a target protein since many aptamers for it were already reported and two different aptamers, which recognize different positions of thrombin, were chosen to construct sandwich type sensing system. In order to obtain the electrochemical signal, the glucose oxidase (GOD) used for labeling the detection aptamers since it has large amount of stability in aqueous solution. One aptamer was immobilized onto the gold electrode and the other aptamer for detection was labeled with GOD for generation of the electric signal. Thrombin was detected in sandwich manner with aptamer immobilized onto the gold electrode and the GOD labeled aptamer. The enzymatic signal, generated from glucose addition after the formation of the complex of thrombin, was measured. The generation-collection mode of SECM was used for amperometric H2O2 detection.     

Surface-immobilized peptide aptamers as probe molecules for protein detection

We demonstrate the use of surface-immobilized, oriented peptide aptamers for the detection of specific target proteins from complex biological solutions. These peptide aptamers are target-specific peptides expressed within a protein scaffold engineered from the human protease inhibitor stefin A. The scaffold provides stability to the inserted peptides and increases their binding affinity owing to the resulting three-dimensional constraints. A unique cysteine residue was introduced into the protein scaffold to allow orientation-specific surface immobilization of the peptide aptamer and to ensure exposure of the binding site to the target solution. Using dual-polarization interferometry, we demonstrate a strong relationship between binding affinity and aptamer orientation and determine the affinity constant KD for the interaction between an oriented peptide aptamer ST(cys+)_(pep9) and the target protein CDK2. Further, we demonstrate the high selectivity of the peptide aptamer STM_(pep9) by exposing surface-immobilized ST(cys+)_(pep9) to a complex biological solution containing small concentrations of the target protein CDK2.     

Molecular aptamer for real-time oncoprotein platelet-derived growth factor monitoring by fluorescence anisotropy.

Monitoring proteins in real time and in homogeneous solution has always been a difficult task. We have applied a fluorophore-labeled molecular probe based on a high-affinity platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) aptamer for the ultrasensitive detection of PDGF in homogeneous solutions. The aptamer is labeled with fluorescein to specifically bind with the PDGF protein. Fluorescence anisotropy is used for the real-time monitoring of the binding between the aptamer and the protein. When the labeled aptamer is bound with its target protein, the rotational motion of the fluorophore attached to the complex becomes much slower because of an increased molecular weight after binding, resulting in a significant fluorescence anisotropy change. Using the anisotropy change, we are able to detect the binding events between the aptamer and the protein in real time and in homogeneous solutions (detection without separation). This assay is highly selective and ultrasensitive. It can detect PDGF in the subnanomolar range. The new method for protein detection is simple and inherits all of the advantages of molecular aptamers. Efficient oncoprotein detection using aptamer-based fluorescence anisotropy measurement will find wide applications in protein monitoring, in cancer diagnosis as well as other studies in which protein analysis is important.     

Retention and separation of adenosine and analogues by affinity chromatography with an aptamer stationary phase

A biotinylated-DNA aptamer (molecular weight 16,600) that binds adenosine and related compounds in solution was immobilized by reaction with streptavidin, which had been covalently attached to porous chromatographic supports. The aptamer medium was packed into fused-silica capillaries (50-150-microm i.d.) to form affinity chromatography columns. Frontal chromatography analysis indicated that the dissociation constants (Kd) of cyclic-AMP, AMP, ATP, ADP, and adenosine were 138 +/- 18, 58 +/- 2, 38 +/- 2, 28 +/- 6 and 3 +/- 1 microM, respectively, for aptamer immobilized on a controlled pore glass support. Similar values were obtained for aptamer immobilized on a polystyrene support except for a slightly higher Kd for adenosine. The Kd for adenosine is similar to the previously reported value of 6 +/- 3 microM for adenosine-aptamer in solution indicating that immobilized aptamers can have affinity similar to that of the solution forms. Columns had 20 nmol of binding sites/100 microL of support media, which is 3.3-fold higher than that previously reported for immobilization of IgG on similar media, indicating that the aptamer can be immobilized with higher density than antibodies. Variation of mobile-phase conditions revealed that ionic strength and Mg2+ level had strong effects on retention of analytes while pH and buffer composition had less of an effect. It was demonstrated that the column could selectively retain and separate cyclic-AMP, NAD+, AMP, ADP, ATP, and adenosine, even in complex mixtures such as tissue extracts.     

Ultrasensitive detection of protein using an aptamer-based exonuclease protection assay

Currently, methods for protein detection are not as sensitive and specific as methods for detection of specific nucleic acid sequences. Here, we present an analogous technique for detection of proteins using aptamers as ligands for target binding. We have named this method the aptamer-based exonuclease protection assay. We applied a special oligonucleotide probe containing a thrombin aptamer, which has the capacity to recognize thrombin with high affinity and specificity. The aptamer probe is a 22-base-long single-strand oligonucleotide with the thrombin aptamer sequence at the 3'-terminus and 7 additional nucleotides at the 5'-terminus, which is able to bind thrombin with high affinity and specificity. In the exonuclease protection assay, thrombin binds the aptamer and thereby protects it from degradation by exonuclease I, whereas any unbound aptamer probe is degraded by exonuclease I. Subsequently, the aptamer probes that were protected from exonuclease I by thrombin act as linkers to join two free connectors, which contain sequences matching the probe. The joined products, which reflect the identity and amount of the target protein, are amplified by PCR. The exonuclease protection assay is extremely sensitive, since it is based on PCR amplification. This method can detect as few as several hundred molecules of target protein without using washes or separations. In addition, this new method for protein detection is simple and inherits all the advantages of aptamers. The mechanism, moreover, may be generalized and used for other forms of protein analysis.     

Aptamer-functionalized microgel particles for protein detection

Highly sensitive and multiplexed detection of clinically relevant proteins in biologically complex samples is crucial for the advancement of clinical proteomics. In recent years, aptamers have emerged as useful tools for protein analysis due to their specificity and affinity for protein targets as well as their compatibility with particle-based detection systems. In this study, we demonstrate the highly sensitive detection of human α-thrombin on encoded hydrogel microparticles functionalized with an aptamer capture sequence. We use static imaging and microfluidic flow-through analysis techniques to evaluate the detection capabilities of the microgels in sandwich-assay formats that utilize both aptamers and antibodies for the reporting of target-binding events. Buffers and reagent concentrations were optimized to provide maximum reaction efficiency while still maintaining an assay with a simple workflow that can be easily adapted to the multiplexed detection of other clinically relevant proteins. The three-dimensional, nonfouling hydrogel immobilization scaffold used in this work provides three logs of dynamic range, with a limit of detection of 4 pM using a single aptamer capture species and without the need for spacers or signal amplification.     

Fluorescence polarization based displacement assay for the determination of small molecules with aptamers

The conversion of an aptamer-target binding event into a detectable signal is an important step in the development of aptamer-based sensors. In this work, we show that the displacement of a fluorescently labeled oligo from the aptamer by the target can be detected by fluorescence polarization (FP). We used Ochratoxin A (OTA), a small organic molecule (MW = 403) as a case study. A detection limit of 5 nM OTA was achieved. The method presented here provides an advantage over fluorophore-quenching systems and other steady-state fluorescence approaches in that no modification of the aptamer or the target is required. Additionally, the signal is produced by the displacement event itself, so no further aggregation or conformational events have to be considered. This analytical method is particularly useful for small targets, as for large targets a direct measurement of the FP change of a labeled aptamer upon binding can be used to determine the concentration of the target. The results presented here demonstrate that aptamers and inexpensive labeled oligos can be used for rapid, sensitive, and specific determination of small molecules by means of FP.     

Protein-protein interaction studies based on molecular aptamers by affinity capillary electrophoresis

Protein-DNA/protein-protein interactions play critical roles in many biological processes. We report here the investigation of protein-protein interactions using molecular aptamers with affinity capillary electrophoresis (ACE). A human alpha-thrombin binding aptamer was labeled with 6-carboxyfluorescein and exploited as a selective fluorescent probe for studying thrombin-protein interactions using capillary electrophoresis with laser-induced fluorescence. A 15-mer binding DNA aptamer can be separated into two peaks in CE that correspond to the linear aptamer (L-Apt) and the thrombin-binding G-quadruplex structure in the presence of K(+) or Ba(2+). In a bare capillary, the peak area of G-quadruplex aptamer (G-Apt) was found to decrease with the addition of thrombin while that of L-Apt remained unchanged. Even though the peak of the G-Apt/thrombin binding complex is broad due to a weaker binding affinity between aptamer and thrombin, we were still able to quantify the thrombin and anti-thrombin proteins (human anti-thrombin III, AT III) based on the peak areas of free G-Apt. The detection limits of thrombin and AT III were 9.8 and 2.1 nM, respectively. The aptamer-based competitive ACE assay has also been applied to quantify thrombin-anti-thrombin III interaction and to monitor this reaction in real time. The addition of poly(ethylene glycol) to the sample matrix stabilized the complex of the G-Aptthrombin. This assay can be used to study the interactions between thrombin and proteins that do not disrupt G-Apt binding property at Exosit I site of the thrombin. Our aptamer-based ACE assay can be an effective approach for studying protein-protein interactions and for analyzing binding site and binding constant information in protein-protein and protein-DNA interaction studies.     

Improving aptamer selection efficiency through volume dilution, magnetic concentration, and continuous washing in microfluidic channels

The generation of nucleic acid aptamers with high affinity typically entails a time-consuming, iterative process of binding, separation, and amplification. It would therefore be beneficial to develop an efficient selection strategy that can generate these high-quality aptamers rapidly, economically, and reproducibly. Toward this goal, we have developed a method that efficiently generates DNA aptamers with slow off-rates. This methodology, called VDC-MSELEX, pairs the volume dilution challenge process with microfluidic separation for magnetic bead-assisted aptamer selection. This method offers improved aptamer selection efficiencies through the application of highly stringent selection conditions: it retrieves a small number (<10(6)) of magnetic beads suspended in a large volume (>50 mL) and concentrates them into a microfluidic chamber (8 μL) with minimal loss for continuous washing. We performed three rounds of the VDC-MSELEX using streptavidin (SA) as the target and obtained new DNA aptamer sequences with low nanomolar affinity that specifically bind to the SA proteins.     

Cancer cell targeting using multiple aptamers conjugated on nanorods

Molecular recognition toward specific cells is a key issue for effective disease, such as cancer, diagnosis and therapy. Although many molecular probes such as aptamers and antibodies can recognize the unique molecular signatures of cancer cells, some of these probes only have relatively weak binding affinities. This results in poor signaling and hinders cell targeting. Here, we use Au-Ag nanorods (NRs) as a nanoplatform for multivalent binding by multiple aptamers on the rod to increase both the signal and binding strengths of these aptamers in cancer cell recognition. Up to 80 fluorophore-labeled aptamers can be attached on a 12 nm x 56 nm NR, resulting in a much stronger fluorescence signal than that of an individual dye-labeled aptamer probe. The molecular assembly of aptamers on the NR surfaces also significantly improves the binding affinity with cancer cells through simultaneous multivalent interactions with the cell membrane receptors. This leads to an affinity at least 26-fold higher than the intrinsic affinity of the original aptamer probes. As determined by flow cytometric measurements, an enhancement in fluorescence signal in excess of 300-fold is obtained for the NR-aptamer-labeled cells compared with those labeled by individual aptamer probes. Therefore, the molecular assembly of aptamers clearly shows potential applications for the elucidation of cells with low density of binding sites, or with relatively weak binding probes, and can thus greatly improve our ability to perform cellular imaging and targeting. This is an excellent example of using nanomaterials to develop advanced molecular binders with greatly improved properties for cellular studies.     

Aptamer-based detection of plasma proteins by an electrochemical assay coupled to magnetic beads

The DNA thrombin aptamer has been extensively investigated, and the coupling of this aptamer to different transduction principles has demonstrated the wide applicability of aptamers as bioreceptors in bioanalytical assays. The goal of this work was to design an aptamer-based sandwich assay with electrochemical detection for thrombin analysis in complex matrixes, using a simple target capturing step by aptamer-functionalized magnetic beads. The conditions for the aptamer immobilization and for the protein binding have been first optimized by surface plasmon resonance, and then transferred to the electrochemical-based assay performed onto screen-printed electrodes. The assay was then applied to the analysis of thrombin in buffer, spiked serum, and plasma and high sensitivity and specificity were found. Moreover, thrombin was generated in situ in plasma by the conversion of its precursor prothrombin, and the formation of thrombin was followed at different times. The concentrations detected by the electrochemical assay were in agreement with a simulation software that mimics the formation of thrombin over time (thrombogram). The proposed work demonstrates that the high specificity of aptamers together with the use of magnetic beads are the key features for aptamer-based analysis in complex matrixes, opening the possibility of a real application to diagnostics or medical investigation.     

Functional-group specific aptamers indirectly recognizing compounds with alkyl amino group

Aptamers are usually generated against a specific molecule. Their high selectivity makes them only suitable for studying specific targets. Since it is nearly impossible to generate aptamers for every molecule, it can be of great interest to select aptamers recognizing a common feature of a group of molecules in many applications. In this paper, we describe the selection of aptamers for indirect recognition of alkyl amino groups. Because amino groups are small and positive charged, we introduced a protection group, p-nitrobenzene sulfonyl (p-nosyl) to convert them into a form suitable for aptamer selection. Taking N(ε)-p-nosyl-l-lysine (PSL) as a target, we obtained a group of aptamers using the SELEX technique. Two optimized aptamers, M6b-M14 and M13a exhibit strong affinity to PSL with the K(d) values in the range of 2-5 μM. They also show strong affinity to other compounds containing p-nosyl-protected amino groups except those also possessing an α-carboxyl group. Both aptamers adopt an antiparallel G-quadruplex structure when binding to targets. An aptamer beacon based on M6b-M14 showed good selectivity toward the reaction mixture of p-nosyl-Cl and alkyl amino compounds, and could recognize lysine from amino acid mixtures indirectly, suggesting that aptamers against a common moiety of a certain type of molecules can potentially lead to many new applications. Through this study, we have demonstrated the ability to select aptamers for a specific part of an organic compound, and the chemical conversion approach may prove to be valuable for aptamer selection against molecules that are generally difficult for SELEX.     

Using nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures for the determination of temperature in capillary electrophoresis

Until now, all methods for temperature sensing in capillary electrophoresis (CE) relied on molecular probes with temperature-dependent spectral/optical properties. Here we introduce a nonspectroscopic approach to determining temperature in CE. It is based on measuring a temperature-dependent rate constant of complex dissociation by means of a kinetic CE method known as nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures (NECEEM). Conceptually, a calibration curve of "the rate constant versus temperature" is built using NECEEM and a CE instrument with a reliable temperature control or, alternatively, a nonelectrophoretic method, such as surface plasmon resonance. The calibration curve is then used to find the temperature during CE in the same buffer but with another CE apparatus or under otherwise different conditions (cooling efficiency, length and diameter of the capillary, electrical field, etc.). In this proof-of-principle work, we used the dissociation of a protein-DNA complex to demonstrate that the NECEEM-based temperature determination method allows for temperature determination in CE with a precision of 2 degrees C. Then, we applied the NECEEM-based temperature determination method to study heat dissipation efficiency in CE instruments with active and passive cooling of the capillary. The nonspectroscopic nature of the method makes it potentially applicable to nonspectroscopic detection schemes, e.g. electrochemical detection. A "kinetic probe" can be coloaded into the capillary along with a sample for in situ temperature measurements. Higher order chemical reactions can also be used for temperature sensing, provided a kinetic CE method for measuring a corresponding rate constant is available.