Improved positioning of cylindrical cutter for flank milling ruled surfaces

An optimized positioning procedure for flank milling ruled surfaces with cylindrical cutter is described in the paper. The tool axis trajectory surface is a ruled surface, which is generated by moving the tool axis. The proposition that the envelope surface of cylindrical cutter is the offset surface of tool axis trajectory surface is proved using kinematics approach. It is a complement of Bedi's [Bedi S, Mann S, Menzel C. Flank milling with flat end cutter. Comput Aided Des 2003; 35:293-300] analysis about the envelope surface of cylindrical cutter. Subsequently, we get another proposition that the deviation at extremum point between the designed surface and the envelope surface of cylindrical cutter is equal to that between the offset surface of designed surface and the tool axis trajectory surface. Based on this proposition, we propose three points offset (TPO) strategy to approximate the offset surface. In order to reduce errors further, a simple least square approximation scheme is established to make the tool axis trajectory surface fit the offset surface of designed surface as much as possible. By solving the linear system of equations, the tool axis trajectory surface is deformed. Simultaneously, the corresponding envelope surface is deformed to approximate the designed surface better. Two examples are given to verify the effectiveness of the developed 5-axis flank milling technique.     

Continuity-preserving tool path generation for minimizing machining errors in five-axis CNC flank milling of ruled surfaces

Five-axis CNC flank machining has been commonly used in the industry for shaping complex geometries. Geometrical errors typically occur in five-axis flank finishing of non-developable surfaces using a cylindrical cutter. Most existing tool path planning methods adjust discrete cutter locations to reduce these errors. An excessive change in the cutter center or axis between consecutive cutter locations may deteriorate the machined surface quality. This study developed a tool path generation method for minimizing geometrical errors on finished surfaces while preserving high-order continuity in the cutter motion. A tool path is described using the moving trajectory of the cutter center and changes in two rotational angles in compact curve representations. An optimization scheme is proposed to search for optimal curve control points and the resulting tool path. A curve subdivision mechanism progressively increases the control points during the search process. Simulation results confirm that the proposed method not only enhances the computational efficiency of tool path generation but also improves the machined surface finish. This study provides a computational approach for precision tool path planning in five-axis CNC flank finishing of ruled surfaces.     

Analytical calculation of the envelope surface for generic milling tools directly from CL-data based on the moving frame method

Two closed-form solutions for calculating tool envelope surfaces are proposed based on the moving frame method. They have several advantages: (a) Given a sequence of cutter location (CL) data before post-processing into NC code, although we do not know the special configuration of machine tool, the tool envelope surface can be calculated accurately; (b) The two methods fit for a generic milling tool with a surface of revolution, such as a cylindrical cutter, conical cutter, drum cutter, and so on; (c) Since the calculation is developed based on the representation of the parametric form of the generating curve, it is convenient to use Bézier method, B-Spline or NURBS to unify the representation of the cutters and calculation of tool envelope surfaces. Several examples are presented to prove their effectiveness and good adaptability. The two methods can be used for NC machining simulation, evaluation and correction of the tool path.     

基于四点偏置法的非可展直纹面侧铣刀位计算

针对非可展直纹面五轴侧铣加工的问题,分析了非可展直纹面几何特点,根据等距 映射下的极差不变性,提出了一种计算非可展直纹面叶片五轴侧铣刀位数据的新方法。以刀具包 络面与设计曲面之间的整体误差为优化目标,建立了圆柱铣刀侧铣非可展直纹面的刀位计算方 法,运用四点偏置法确定初始刀位,采用最小二乘法对初始刀位进行优化,建立刀轴矢量偏转模 型进一步修正刀位以减小过切误差。通过实例计算分析,表明该方法可以在一定程度上减小加工 误差。     

Global optimization of tool path for five-axis flank milling with a conical cutter

In this paper, optimum positioning of the conical cutter for five-axis flank milling of slender surfaces is addressed from the perspective of approximating the tool envelope surface to the data points on the design surface following the minimum zone criterion recommended by ANSI and ISO standards for tolerance evaluation. Based on the observation that a conical surface can be treated as a canal surface, i.e. envelope surface of one-parameter family of spheres, the swept envelope of a conical cutter is represented as a sphere-swept surface. Then, an approach is presented to efficiently compute the signed distance between a point in space and the swept surface without constructing the swept surface itself. The first order differential increment of the signed point-to-surface distance with respect to the differential deformation of the tool axis trajectory surface is derived. By using the distance function, tool path optimizations for semi-finish and finish millings are formulated as two constrained optimization problems in a unified framework, and a sequential approximation algorithm along with a hierarchical algorithmic structure is developed for the optimization. Numerical examples are given to confirm the validity and efficiency of the proposed approach. Comparing with the existing approaches, the present one improves the machining accuracy greatly. The rationale developed applies to general rotary cutters.     

Tool path deformation in 5-axis flank milling using envelope surface

This paper deals with assessment and correction of tool path in 5-axis machining. The tool trajectory is described using two curves; each one corresponding to the trajectory of two particular points of the tool axis. The assessment of the tool path is performed via the calculation of the envelope surface, which is calculated using a kinematics approach. The geometrical deviations between the envelope surface and the nominal surface are calculated. When necessary, the tool path is corrected, so that the envelope surface fits the ideal surface as much as possible. This correction is carried out by the deformation of both curves that are representative of the tool trajectory. We choose to illustrate our purpose through flank milling of sculptured surfaces.     

Improving optimization of tool path planning in 5-axis flank milling using advanced PSO algorithms

This paper studies optimization of tool path planning in 5-axis flank milling of ruled surfaces using advanced Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) methods with machining error as an objective. We enlarge the solution space in the optimization by relaxing the constraint imposed by previous studies that the cutter must make contact with the boundary curves. Advanced Particle Swarm Optimization (APSO) and Fully Informed Particle Swarm Optimization (FIPS) algorithms are applied to improve the quality of optimal solutions and search efficiency. Test surfaces are constructed by systematic variations of three surface properties, cutter radius, and the number of cutter locations comprising a tool path. Test results show that FIPS is most effective in reducing the error in all the trials, while PSO performs best when the number of cutter locations is very low. This research improves tool path planning in 5-axis flank milling by producing smaller machining errors compared to past works. It also provides insightful findings in PSO based optimization of the tool path planning.     

5-axis flank milling free-form surfaces considering constraints

A new tool path generation method of flank milling considering constraints is proposed for ball-end cutters in this paper. It will not only reduce the machining error range but also meet the following two constraints: (a) The ball end of the milling tool is tangential to the constraint surface; (b) There is no overcut and the minimum error is zero, which is called nonnegative-error constraint. The two constraints are very useful in some situations of engineering applications, such as flank milling impeller blades. Based on the proposed method, two types of cutter will be used to generate tool paths for the same designed surface and constraint surface. The effectiveness and accuracy of the proposed method will be finally proved with some examples.     

Analysis of improved positioning in five-axis ruled surface milling using envelope surface

This article covers side milling of ruled surfaces using a milling cutter. Flank milling is useful for machining objects such as impellers, turbine blades, fan vanes and all workpieces defined by non-developable, ruled surfaces. In the present article, we first introduce two types of positioning on ruled surfaces developed within the Toulouse Mechanical Engineering Laboratory. The positioning studied is taken from the geometric situation not taking the instantaneous speed of rotation of the milling cutter into account. The swept profile of the tool is then determined based on the tool motion. Having defined the envelope surface, we seek to analyse improved and standard positioning errors comparing envelope surfaces with the ruled surface. We then introduce an example to illustrate positioning developed through a first theoretical study before experimentation including machining and measurement of the test piece. Finally, we give our conclusions as to the validity of improved positioning without taking the instantaneous speed of rotation of the milling cutter into account.     

An innovative approach to NC programming for accurate five-axis flank milling of spiral bevel or hypoid gears

To transfer power, a pair of spiral bevel or hypoid gears engages. From beginning to end of two tooth surfaces engaging with each other: for their rigid property, they contact at different points; and for their plastic property, they contact at small ellipses around the points. On each surface, the contact line (or called as contact path) by connecting these points and the contact area by joining these ellipses are critical to driving performance. Therefore, to machine these surfaces, it is important to machine the contact line and area with higher accuracy than other areas. Five-axis flank milling is efficient and is widely used in industry. However, tool paths for flank milling the gears, which are generated with the existing methods, can cause overcuts on the contact area with large machining errors. To overcome this problem, an innovative approach to NC programming for accurate and efficient five-axis flank milling of spiral bevel or hypoid gears is proposed. First, the necessary conditions of the cutter envelope surface tangent with the designed surface along a designed line are derived to address the overcut problem of five-axis milling. Second, the tooth surface including the contact line and area are represented using their machining and meshing models. Third, according to the tooth surface model, an optimization method based on the necessary conditions is proposed to plan the cutter location and orientation for flank milling the tooth surface. By using these planned tool paths, the overcut problem is eliminated and the machining errors of contact area are reduced. The proposed approach can significantly promote flank milling in the gear manufacturing industry.     

Simultaneous optimization of tool path and shape for five-axis flank milling

By representing the swept envelope of a generic rotary cutter as a sphere-swept surface, our previous work on distance function based tool path optimization is extended to develop the model and algorithm for simultaneous optimization of the tool path and shape for five-axis flank milling. If the tool path is fixed, a novel tool shape optimization method is obtained. If the tool shape is fixed, a tool path optimization method applicable to any rotary cutter is obtained. The approach applies to non-ruled surfaces, and also finds applications in cutter dimension optimization and flank millable surface design. Numerical examples are given to confirm its validity.     

Generation of reciprocating tool motion in 5-axis flank milling based on particle swarm optimization

This paper proposes a novel method for generation of optimized tool path in 5-axis flank milling of ruled surfaces based on Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO). The 3D geometric problem, tool path generation, is transformed into a mathematical programming task with the machined surface error as the objective function in the optimization. This approach overcomes the limitation of greedy planning methods employed by most previous studies. By allowing the cutter to move backforward, reciprocating tool path produces smaller machining error compared with the traditional one consisting of only forward cutter movement. A cutting experiment is conducted with different tool paths and the CMM measurement verifies the effectiveness of the proposed method.     

Tool path planning for 5-axis flank milling of ruled surfaces considering CNC linear interpolation

This paper investigates tool path planning for 5-axis flank milling of ruled surfaces in consideration of CNC linear interpolation. Simulation analyses for machining error show insights into the tool motion that generates a precision machined surface. Contradicting to previous thoughts, the resultant tool path does not necessarily produce minimal machining error when the cutter contacts the rulings of a developable surface. This effect becomes more significant as the distance between two cutter locations is increased. An optimizing approach that adjusts the tool position locally may not produce minimal error as far as the entire surface is concerned. The optimal tool path computed by a global search scheme based on dynamic programming supports this argument. A flank milling experiment and CMM measurement further validate the findings of this work.     

New approach to 5-axis flank milling of free-form surfaces: Computation of adapted tool shape

This paper develops a new approach to solve the problem of interferences during the flank milling of a non-developable ruled surface. Many articles propose to modify the tool path to reduce this problem. A novel approach is proposed here, Computation of Adapted Tool Shape (CATS), which computes and optimizes the tool shape to reduce these interferences. The aim of this CATS method is to maintain a standard CAM system thanks to the tool shape modification. This method is presented for the machining of an industrial part and for a numerical experimental design of nine surfaces.     

Accurate tool position for five-axis ruled surface machining by swept envelope approach

This paper presents a swept envelope approach to determining tool position for five-axis ruled surface machining. The initial tool position is traditionally located to contact with two directrices of a ruled surface. The swept profile of the tool is then determined based on the tool motion. By comparing the swept profile with the ruled surface, the tool position is corrected to avoid machining errors. The cutter's swept envelope is further constructed by integrating the intermediate swept profiles, and applied to NC simulation and verification. This paper presents the explicit solution for the swept profile of a taper-end cutter in five-axis ruled surface machining. The relation of the ruled surface geometry, the tool motion and the machining errors is developed. Therefore, the error sources can be detected early and prevented during tool path planning. The explicit swept envelope indicates that the machined surface is not a ruled surface in five-axis ruled surface machining. Manufacturing industries should take extra care in high precision ruled surface machining. Computer illustrations and example demonstrations are shown in this paper. The results reveal that the developed method can accurately position tool location and reduce machining errors for five-axis ruled surface machining.     

Analytical estimation of error in flank milling of ruled surfaces

This article introduces a method to estimate geometric error during flank milling of a ruled surface. The various positioning schemes developed by researchers are intended to reduce this geometric error in order to mill with larger sized milling cutters while respecting the tolerance interval. There are two trends in positioning: either positioning is simple and right from the start it is easy to determine design of the maximum allowed milling cutter radius, or positioning is complex and determination of the maximum milling cutter dimensions can only be conducted after digital calculations of the error. It will then be necessary to choose another milling cutter radius and recommence the positioning procedure and error calculation in order to validate the tool. In the present study, a method to estimate error in the scope of complex positioning is presented. The aim is to be capable of choosing a maximum cutting tool radius that respects the tolerance interval.     

Five-axis NC cylindrical milling of sculptured surfaces

In theory, the five-axis numerical control (NC) machining of sculptured surfaces can be classified into facing milling and cylindrical milling (or side milling). In general, the first one, using flat-end cutter, is suitable for the machining of large sculptured surfaces, e.g. the blade of hydraulic turbine, whose binding relations with drive surface (DS) and check surface (CS) are simple, and the second one, using cylindrical cutter, has wide applications for the milling of small and middle dimensional surfaces whose binding relations with DS and CS are more complex, such as the milling of integral turbine wheels. In practice, the second one suffers more difficulties than the first one, which are mostly related to gouge avoidance, interference avoidance and tool strength. This paper, on the basis of the theories of differential geometry and analytical geometry, describes research on algorithms for the toolpath generation of five-axis cylindrical milling of sculptured surfaces with cylindrical cutter. The approach includes (a) single point offset (SPO) algorithm, and (b) double point offset (DPO) algorithm for the cutter location data (CLDATA) calculation of five-axis cylindrical milling.     

Constant scallop-height tool path generation for three-axis sculptured surface machining

This paper presents a new approach for the determination of efficient tool paths in the machining of sculptured surfaces using 3-axis ball-end milling. The objective is to keep the scallop height constant across the machined surface such that redundant tool paths are minimized. Unlike most previous studies on constant scallop-height machining, the present work determines the tool paths without resorting to the approximated 2D representations of the 3D cutting geometry. Two offset surfaces of the design surface, the scallop surface and the tool center surface, are employed to successively establish scallop curves on the scallop surface and cutter location tool paths for the design surface. The effectiveness of the present approach is demonstrated through the machining of a typical sculptured surface. The results indicate that constant scallop-height machining achieves the specified machining accuracy with fewer and shorter tool paths than the existing tool path generation approaches.     

Towards efficient 5-axis flank CNC machining of free-form surfaces via fitting envelopes of surfaces of revolution

We introduce a new method that approximates free-form surfaces by envelopes of one-parameter motions of surfaces of revolution. In the context of 5-axis computer numerically controlled (CNC) machining, we propose a flank machining methodology which is a preferable scallop-free scenario when the milling tool and the machined free-form surface meet tangentially along a smooth curve. We seek both an optimal shape of the milling tool as well as its optimal path in 3D space and propose an optimization based framework where these entities are the unknowns. We propose two initialization strategies where the first one requires a user’s intervention only by setting the initial position of the milling tool while the second one enables to prescribe a preferable tool-path. We present several examples showing that the proposed method recovers exact envelopes, including semi-envelopes and incomplete data, and for general free-form objects it detects envelope sub-patches.     

Iso-planar piecewise linear NC tool path generation from discrete measured data points

This article presents a method of generating iso-planar piecewise linear NC tool paths for three-axis surface machining using ball-end milling directly from discrete measured data points. Unlike the existing tool path generation methods for discrete points, both the machining error and the machined surface finish are explicitly considered and evaluated in the present work. The primary direction of the generated iso-planar tool paths is derived from the projected boundary of the discrete points. A projected cutter location net (CL-net) is then created, which groups the data points according to the intended machining error and surface finish requirements. The machining error of an individual data point is evaluated within its bounding CL-net cell from the adjacent tool swept surfaces of the ball-end mill. The positions of the CL-net nodes can thus be optimized and established sequentially by minimizing the machining error of each CL-net cell. Since the linear edges of adjacent CL-net cells are in general not perfectly aligned, weighted averages of the associated CL-net nodes are employed as the CL points for machining. As a final step, the redundant segments on the CL paths are trimmed to reduce machining time. The validity of the tool path generation method has been examined by using both simulated and experimentally measured data points.