CFD-DEM modeling of geotextile clogging in tunnel drainage systems

In this study, a coupled Computational Fluid Dynamics-Discrete Element Method (CFD-DEM) method we used to investigate the hydraulic deterioration of a geotextile due to clogging in tunnel drainage systems. Initially, a framework was developed to generate and test a numerical representation of a typical non-woven geotextile. Following model validation, we carried out parametric analysis to examine the effect of fine content, crack angle, and groundwater inflow. The results showed a general trend of pressure increase associated with increasing both the crack angle and fine content. This increase was found to decay at larger crack angles and high content of fines. Interestingly, increasing groundwater inflow was found to had minimal effect on the final deposition of the clogging particles. Finally, an approximate semi-analytical model was developed to describe the pressure increase due to clogging. The model was able to provide a good match with the data obtained from the numerical analysis.     

武山尾矿坝无纺土工织物滤层化学淤堵问题初探

土工织物作为滤层在尾矿坝排渗设施中已得到广泛应用,但有些尾矿坝遇到了土工织物淤堵问题。本文针对武山铜矿尾矿坝排渗系统中发生的土工织物淤堵问题,通过一系列试验研究对无纺土工织物化学淤堵问题进行了初步探讨。研究结果表明氢氧化铁凝胶在织物纤维上的附着是化学淤堵的主要机理,尾矿中含有充分多的细粒黄铁矿且滤层处于非饱和渗流带或饱和- 非饱和交替变化渗流带是土工织物发生严重化学淤堵的必要条件     

Improved design criteria for nonwoven geotextile filters with internally stable and unstable soils

In geotextile filtration, the soil fines are either accumulated near the interface, clogged, or washed out, which primarily depends on the grain size distribution (GSD) of soil and the constriction size distribution (CSD) of geotextile. Also, the movement of fines significantly affects the flow capacity of geotextile. Currently, the retention requirement is satisfied based on representative grain and opening sizes, whereas the hydraulic conductivity and clogging requirements are satisfied considering the properties of virgin geotextile. This paper presents a probabilistic retention criterion considering the grain and constriction sizes as random variables. The influence of geotextile thickness is incorporated into the criterion by considering the number of geotextile constrictions in a filtration path. A theoretical approach to predict CSD is presented if the measured data is unavailable. For hydraulic conductivity and clogging requirements, a criterion is presented considering the expected partial clogging of geotextile, which is predicted based on the semi-analytical approach. The limit states for the developed criteria are evaluated based on the wide range of experimental data from the current study and published literature. The developed design criteria are applicable to internally stable and unstable soils, which offers an improvement in design compared to the existing criteria in practice.     

Tailings-nonwoven geotextile filter compatibility in mining applications

Nonwoven geotextiles have been commonly used in filtration and drainage of geotechnical engineering works. This paper presents a study on the use of such materials in drainage and filtration systems of tailings dams. Different combinations of tailings and geotextiles were submitted to gradient ratio (GR) tests under confinement in the laboratory with varying values of stress levels and hydraulic gradients. The results of GR tests under confining stresses up to 2000 kPa are presented and discussed. The dimensions of the tailings particles entrapped in the geotextile specimens and those that piped through the geotextile were also assessed. Geotextile specimens from the drainage system of a tailings dam were exhumed for analyses, as part of the research programme. The results obtained showed that stress levels and the hydraulic gradients used in the tests influenced the behaviour of the system. Physical and microscopic analyses of the specimens tested showed greater geotextile impregnation by tailings particles in the field than in the laboratory. The overall performance of the geotextiles tested under laboratory conditions was satisfactory. However, in the field segregation of tailings particles and transport of fines in suspension can subject the filter to more complex and severe clogging mechanisms, not properly simulated in current standard testing procedures.     

Permeability prediction in geotextile envelope after chemical clogging: a coupled model

This study develops a coupled model of chemical clogging and permeability coefficient of geotextile envelope. Based on the distribution characteristics of crystal precipitates on geotextile envelope and their influence on the permeability coefficient, a permeability coefficient model of an actual geotextile envelope that considers the overlapping effect is developed. Then, the densification effects of geosynthetic fiber hypothesis and the filter cake effect hypothesis are proposed to simulate the processes of increasing fiber diameter after crystal precipitation and the accumulation of crystal precipitates on the surface of geotextile envelope. The crystal precipitation module and permeability coefficient module are coupled, and their experimental values are used to confirm the availability of the model. Results indicate the satisfactory performance of the model. In addition, the parameter sensitivity analysis and trend prediction show that the saturation index SI and solution flow rate V are the main factors that affect the chemical clogging and permeability of geotextile envelope. When the solution conditions are not considered, the sensitivity of geotextile envelope parameter d_f increased with the amount of precipitation in crystal precipitation. When the pores of the geotextile envelope are completely clogged, the permeability coefficient of the geotextile envelope will drop sharply, then decline slowly.     

一种整体式反滤排水体在工程中的应用

针对公路边坡挡墙及水利工程中采用的反滤与排水材料经常出现的反滤布撕裂、空洞等等问题,提出了一整套反滤土工布选用的方法,即整体式反滤排水体,对其技术特点进行了简单介绍,并指出其具有反滤排水效果好、施工简单等等优点,值得推广应用。     

Hydraulic conductivity requirement of granular and geotextile filter for internally stable soils

A filter media satisfying the hydraulic conductivity requirements allows unimpeded seepage without generation of surplus pressure head and decrease of flow rate. This paper proposes design criteria for the hydraulic conductivity requirements of a filter based on governing flow equations. The results have shown that the hydraulic conductivity requirements of pressure head and flow rate are satisfied with a single condition of hydraulic conductivity of filter greater than or equal to the hydraulic conductivity of soil times the hydraulic gradient in soil. The proposed model is developed for saturated conditions and is also applicable for partially saturated conditions. The developed model is validated based on the experimental evaluations of sandy soil with three granular filters and two needle punched non-woven geotextile filters. The developed design criterion applies to internally stable soils with granular and geotextiles filters and offers an improvement in the standards and current design guidelines for protective filters.     

Influence of clogging substances on pore characteristics and permeability of geotextile envelopes of subsurface drainage pipes in arid areas

This study investigates the influence of clogging substances on pore characteristics and permeability of geotextile envelopes that were used for 3, 7 and 15 years in irrigated farmlands in Xinjiang region, which is arid and suffers from the soil salinity problem. Results show that the macropores (above 125 μm) of envelopes are evidently clogged, whereas the smaller pores less than 100 μm are still unblocked after operation. The permeability coefficients of geotextile envelopes after serving for 3 and 15 years are smaller than the minimum required permeability coefficients after clogging. The main chemical components of clogging substances in the geotextile envelope are silicon dioxide and calcium carbonate. Calcium carbonate content of the geotextile envelope is consistent with calcium carbonate content of soil. Chemical clogging susceptibility increases with the operation time of the subsurface drainage pipes. The ratio of O₉₀ size of envelope material over d₉₀ of soils (O₉₀/d₉₀) and saturation index (SI) can be used to assess the susceptibility of physical and chemical clogging respectively. This study provides a preliminary reference for estimating the clogging susceptibility of geotextile envelopes in arid areas.     

Fine fraction filtration test to assess geotextile filter performance

The proper design of the openings of a geotextile filter requires a balance between providing upstream soil particle retention and avoiding excessive geotextile clogging. While this balance can be reasonably achieved quite well for most soil types and hydraulic conditions, it is different when the flowing liquid is turbid (containing a large amount of suspended particles) and/or under high, or dynamic, hydraulic gradients. This paper presents a test method to assess the behavior of individual soil particles in a slurry form as they approach, encounter and interact with a geotextile filter.

The paper describes the concept and details of the test method, called the fine fraction filtration (F³) test, and presents data on five different geotextiles which were evaluated using three different soil types. It was seen that soils with particle sizes larger than the geotextile's opening structure can build a stable upstream network; soil with particle sizes smaller than the geotextile's opening structure can pass through the geotextile; and intermediate particle size conditions can give rise to excessive clogging. An additional series of tests were conducted using the same five geotextile filters but now using a pre-placed upstream soil filter above the geotextiles. Clogging conditions generally occurred albeit within the soil column rather than within the geotextile.

The F³ test is felt to be a meaningful test for those conditions where the upstream soil particles are not in intimate contact with the geotextile filter. In such cases, the test method can probably be considered to be a performance test. For other, more typical soil placement conditions, the test method can be considered to be a very challenging indext test.     

Exploring the effects of geotextiles in the performance of highway filter drains

Highway Filter Drains (HFD) are one of the most utilised drainage systems for roads, being considered as an environmental solution for sustainable drainage in transport infrastructures. However, little research has been done to understand their performance, representing a significant knowledge gap. This article therefore determines the hydraulic and clogging response of 3 different HFD designs in the laboratory; one standard design with British Standard Type B aggregate, and 2 new designs including a geotextile located at 50?mm and 500?mm depth from the surface of the HFD structure in order to assess the effect of the geotextile. The laboratory models were initially subjected to 9 rainfall scenarios with 3 rainfall intensities (2.5, 5 and 10?mm/h) and 3 storm durations (5, 10 and 15?min). Subsequently, the equivalent of 2-years’ worth of pollutants were added to test possible clogging issues under the highest intensity rainfall event, corresponding to a 1 in 1 year return period for the West Midlands, UK. No clogging issues were found in any of the models although the majority of the sediments were concentrated in the first 50?mm of the HFD profile, with higher percentages (>90% of the sediment added) in those models with an upper geotextile. Location of the geotextile significantly influenced (p-value?=?0.05) the hydraulic performance of the HFD.     

Numerical parametric investigation of infiltration in one-dimensional sand–geotextile columns

Geotextiles are routinely used in separation and filtration applications. Design of these systems is currently based on saturated properties of the geotextiles and the surrounding soils. However, in the field, soil and geotextile can be in an unsaturated state for much of their design life during which they are essentially hydraulically non-conductive. Periodic wetting and drying cycles can result in rapid and large changes in hydraulic performance of soil–geotextile systems. The writers have reported the results from physical water infiltration tests on sand columns with and without a geotextile inclusion. The geotextile inclusions were installed in new and modified states to simulate the influence of clogging due to fines and to broaden the range of hydraulic properties of the geotextiles in the physical tests. This paper reports the results of numerical simulations that were undertaken to reproduce the physical tests and strategies adopted to adjust soil and geotextile properties from independent laboratory tests to improve the agreement between numerical and physical test results. For example the paper shows that the hydraulic conductivity function of the geotextile must be reduced by up to two orders of magnitude to give acceptable agreement. The lower hydraulic conductivity is believed to be due to soil intrusion that is not captured in conventional laboratory permeability tests. The calibrated numerical model is used to investigate the influence of geotextile and soil hydraulic conductivity and thickness as well as height of ponded water at the surface on wetting front advance below the geotextile and potential ponding of water above the geotextile due to a capillary break mechanism. A simple analytical model is also developed that predicts the maximum ponding height of water above the geotextile based on two-layer saturated media and 1-D steady state flow assumptions. The analytical model is used to generate a design chart to select geotextiles to minimize potential ponding of water above the geotextile. Ponding can lead to lateral flow of water along the geotextile in reinforced wall, slope, embankment and road base applications.     

Effective control of pore water pressures on tunnel linings using pin-hole drain method

Leakage and pore water pressure are the main hydraulic factors to be considered in the design of a tunnel below the groundwater table. In particular, pore water pressure, which is the penetrating pressure, may accelerate structural deterioration and consequently increase leakage. Avoiding high water pressure is, therefore, one of the main concerns in the design of underwater tunnels. Reduction of pore water pressure is often necessary to secure structural safety, and is generally achieved by adopting peripheral filter drainage systems. The drainage system is, however, no longer valid for large and/or non-circular tunnels in deep water conditions. In addition, it is not possible to install such a drainage system for single shell tunnels. As an alternative measure, a pin-hole drain system has been increasingly used. However, there is not a great deal of information about the design of the system in the literature examined for this study. In this study, the hydraulic behavior of a pin-hole drain is investigated using the numerical method, and the applicability of the pin-hole method is evaluated by performing a numerical parametric study for various design parameters. Based on the analysis results, some design comments for the pin drainage system are made.     

Filtration performance of geotextile encasement to minimize the clogging of stone column during soil liquefaction

Stone columns, which are frequently employed to stabilize the liquefiable soil, are susceptible to accumulation of soil particles. The progressive accumulation of the soil particles causes clogging of the stone column which decreases its drainage capacity. The stone column can be encased with geotextile to sustain its long term drainage function. The encasement prevents the movement of the soil particles into the stone pores. In the present paper, a mathematical model is presented to assess the filtration performance of the geotextile encasement to prevent the clogging. The filtration capacity of the geotextile is related to its maximum pore size, porosity and soil characteristics. It is observed that the encased stone column dissipates the excess pore pressure at a faster rate compared to the stone column without encasement. The peak maximum excess pore water pressure (U_max) is not significantly affected due to selection of the opening size of the geotextiles for single earthquake. However, the opening size can significantly affect the peak U_max value for multiple earthquakes. Depending on the capture coefficient of the stone column, the clogging can be fully prevented for higher hydraulic gradient if geotextile with maximum opening size in between D₁₀ to D₅ is used as encasement.     

The effect of submersion in the ochre formation in geotextile filters

This analyzes the effect of submersion in the formation of ochre biofilm in geotextile filters used in drainage systems. The chemical microbiological aspects involved in ochre formation and clogging of drainage systems are discussed. Clogging by ochre may be considered a major threat in the performance of filters and drainage systems. This process has been observed in the field and demonstrated in laboratory tests under well-controlled conditions. Oxygen is needed for ochre formation and is available at the water–air interface of the filters. If the filters are submerged, oxygen may also be available dissolved in the water, with higher concentrations close to the surface due to the diffusion process. Column filter tests with the introduction of iron bacteria under three different filter submersion conditions were carried out. Woven geotextile filters were used in all tests. Biofilm formation on the geotextile filters were evaluated through the analysis of EDS (Energy Dispersive X-ray detector) and scanning electron microscopy. Ochre formation was verified in all tests, confirming that ochre formation can occur even under submerged conditions. The formation of ochre biofilm decreased with the depth of the geotextile filter in relation to the water surface, following the expected reduction of available oxygen below the water surface.     

On the hydraulic behavior of unsaturated nonwoven geotextiles

Geotextiles have been widely used in soil structures for separation, filtration, reinforcing, and drainage. They are often used to provide reinforcement and drainage for retaining walls and embankments. It has been reported, however, that geotextiles may not drain water as effectively as was initially expected. In this study, published data on the hydraulic properties of unsaturated geotextiles are compiled and analyzed in order to highlight the hydraulic characteristics of unsaturated geotextiles.

The application of the van Genuchten equations originally developed for the water characteristic curve and the hydraulic conductivity curve of unsaturated soil to unsaturated geotextiles is then examined and discussed. Finally, the drainage from a one-dimensional sand column having a horizontal geotextile layer was analyzed using the finite element method and the van Genuchten equations to assess the utility of this procedure for further study of unsaturated/saturated water flow within the soil–geotextile system.     

The effect of thickness reduction on the hydraulic transmissivity of geonet drains using rigid and non-rigid flow boundaries

In this paper, relationships between in-plane flow capacity reduction and thickness reduction are presented in tri-planar and bi-planar geonets for rigid and non-rigid flow boundaries. Using these equations, the long-term flow capacity of geonets can be determined using creep test results. To validate these relationships, geonet thickness was measured under different conditions and the theoretical values of the transmissivity reduction ratios were calculated by substituting the results in the equations. Transmissivity tests were then performed under the same conditions to obtain experimental values of the reduction ratios. A comparison showed that the theoretical and experimental values of the transmissivity reduction ratios were in agreement, and the relationships provide a useful tool to predict the drainage capacity of both tri-planar and bi-planar geonets influenced by loading pressure. However, special precautions must be taken when applying the equations to investigate the hydraulic capacity of other types of geosynthetic drains as well as when the geonet is covered by geotextile material acting as a filter between the geonet and adjacent soil, is overlain by geosynthetic clay liner material where the swelling potential of the bentonite in the geonet exists, is placed in inclined positions or is subjected to complex combinations of load.     

A study on biological clogging of nonwoven geotextiles under leachate flow

This paper presents results of long-term permittivity tests using leachate to evaluate biological clogging of nonwoven geotextiles. Three types of geotextiles with varying masses per unit area were used in the tests. The identification and quantification of microorganisms in the geotextile were carried out as well as microscopic investigations. The accuracies of semi-empirical models to evaluate the kinetics of bacteria growth and to correlate hydraulic properties and microbiological parameters were examined. Permittivity tests under increasing water heads were also performed on the geotextile samples already subjected to long-term leachate flow in order to evaluate the values of water heads required to wash the biofilms out of the geotextile pores. The results of the tests showed the marked reduction of geotextile permeability due to biological clogging and that the results of the predictions by semi-empirical methods were consistent with the biological mechanisms observed.     

Drainage performance of geotextiles

It should be noted that the drainage conditions and mechanisms are somewhat different when geotextiles are used as back fill material behind retaining walls. One of the major differences is that the soil installed by the geotextile may not necessaroly be saturated. Generally, the drainage performance of geotextiles can be evaluated by examining combined behavior of geotextiles, soil particles and water. However, in addition to the above materials, in investigating the drainage performance of geotextiles as back fill material behind retaining walls, the effect of air should be taken into account. Therefore, this study has concentrated on investigating the effect of drainage performance of an initially dry geotextile. A further long-term test was carried out primarily to examine the mechanism and development of self-induced filters, which is believed to determine the drainage performance of the geotextile.     

Metal sorption to natural filter substrates for storm water treatment--column studies

Storm water generated from road runoff contains pollutants such as metals that are either dissolved in storm water or bound to particulates. Using detention ponds for the treatment of storm water from road runoff, where particles can settle, can reduce the level of particulate-bound metals in the water, while small particles and dissolved matter pass through the detention pond. Some of these metals can be removed by filtrating water through specially constructed filter systems. This investigation is a laboratory study where different filter substrates were tested in order to evaluate their efficiency in reducing heavy metals from water. Metal solutions were filtered through columns filled with various substrates consisting of combinations of calcium silicate rock (opoka), zeolite and peat. The metal-removal efficiency was correlated to hydraulic load, and for the metal species the reduction efficiency decreased with increased hydraulic load. Mixtures of opoka and zeolite were found to be superior to the other filter-substrate combinations tested with regard to both hydraulic aspects and removal efficiency. Peat mixed with the calcium silicate rock was not successful due to clogging which stopped the experiment. A manufactured product made from the calcium silicate rock (burned opoka) was found to be less useful because of its calcium oxide (CaO) content. Among the tested filter substrates, mixtures of opoka and zeolite seemed to be the most useful compositions with respect to reduction-efficiency and clogging aspects. The removal capacity of metals varied from 0.6 to 1.8 kg m(-3) depending on the metal and the filter substrate.     

Design of non-woven geotextiles for coal refuse filtration

This paper presents research findings on grain size distribution changes of coal refuse affecting the design of non-woven geotextiles used as filters in rock drains at coal waste impoundments. The research involved performing hydraulic conductivity tests on refuse - geotextile filters followed by grain size distribution tests. Data was evaluated for geotextile filter retention, permittivity, and clogging potential requirements as published by the U.S. Mine Safety and Health Administration’s Second Edition, “Engineering and Design Manual Coal Refuse Disposal Facilities”.Key findings indicate that refuse particles undergo slaking and aggregation which change the initial grain size distribution. Grading envelopes were developed and indicate that particle size zones influence the geotextile design parameters for retention, filtration, and clogging. The clogging criteria do not appear to be easily satisfied by the typical ranges of coarse coal refuse, at pre- and post-compaction grain size, for compatibility with non-woven geotextiles having an AOS = 0.212 mm.Conclusions impacting the specification and field installation of geotextiles include: i) post grain size distribution tests are suggested to be performed on specimens and at all compaction levels to observe changes in key indices of D₈₅ and D₁₅ for meeting retention and clogging criteria requirements; ii) the evaluation of the initial refuse stability indicate that at the low compaction energy conditions, which have mobile fines and high Cu values, are initially unstable with regards to their internal soil gradation; and iii) construction of geotextile wrapped drains is preferred to be made in pre-compacted refuse lifts. This condition is beneficial because the filter becomes more stable for retention and permeability; however clogging is still a concern.