Screening of combinatorial libraries for substrate preference by mass spectrometry

We present a rapid screening method for monitoring enzyme specificity using both combinatorial chemistry and mass spectrometry where, as an example, the substrate specificity of peptidylglycine alpha-amidating enzyme was determined and compared against a conventional quantitative technique. Whereas alternative methods for library screening are generally limited to certain enzymes and can present difficulties in the synthesis or derivatization of potential substrates, the approach we call chirality-based isotope labeling for a library of substrates (CHILLS) does not fall short to such limitations, since we exploit the inherent stereospecificity of enzymes to determine preferred substrates. Additionally, the CHILLS method generates accurate results, as compared to typical screening procedures that require tedious method development, because the synthesized library contains a structurally similar internal standard for each individual library component in order to quantitate the progress of enzymatic reactions.     

Traceless capping agent for peptide sequencing by partial edman degradation and mass spectrometry

An improved method for the rapid sequence determination of biologically active peptides selected from one-bead-one-peptide combinatorial libraries has been developed. In this method, beads carrying unique peptide sequences were subjected to multiple cycles of partial Edman degradation (PED) by the treatment with a 15-30:1 mixture of phenyl isothiocyanate and N-(9-fluorenylmethoxycarbonyloxy)succinimide (Fmoc-OSU), to generate a series of sequence-specific truncation products (a peptide ladder) for each resin-bound peptide. Following PED, the Fmoc group was removed from the N-terminus and any reacted side chains by piperidine treatment. The sequence of the full-length peptide on each bead was then determined by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry. The use of Fmoc-OSU as a traceless capping agent resulted in cleaner MS spectra and improved reliability for sequence assignment. This rapid, sensitive, and inexpensive sequencing method should further expand the utility of combinatorial peptide libraries in biomedical research.     

Screening of a parallel combinatorial library for selectors for chiral chromatography

A method to screen parallel combinatorial libraries for chiral selectors is described. Crucial elements to such an approach are the efficient syntheses of potential chiral selectors on synthesis resins and the rapid screening of selectors attached to these resins with circular dichroism measurement. The method does not require any immobilization of the analyte and could complement the mixture combinatorial library method developed earlier in this laboratory. The feasibility of this parallel library screening procedure is demonstrated with a model study of the chiral HPLC resolution of (1-naphthyl)leucine ester (1) using a 16-member small library.     

Microfluidic library screening for mapping antibody epitopes

The capability to screen molecular libraries using disposable microfluidic devices provides the potential to simplify and automate reagent generation and to develop integrated bioanalytical systems for clinical diagnostics. Here, antibody epitopes were mapped using a disposable microfluidic device to screen a combinatorial peptide library composed of 5 x 108 members displayed on bacterial cells. On-chip library screening was achieved in a two-stage, continuous-flow microfluidic sorter that separates antibody-binding target cells captured on microspheres through dielectrophoretic funneling. The antibody fingerprints identified were comparable to those obtained using state-of-the-art commercial cell sorting instrumentation.     

Assessment of purity and screening of peptide libraries by nested ion mobility-TOFMS: identification of RNase S-protein binders

Combinatorial peptide synthesis in combination with affinity selection and high-resolution ion mobility/time-of-flight mass spectrometry (IM/TOFMS) analysis has been used to investigate the binding of a series of 96 related eight-residue peptides (with the general sequence NH2-GX1X2FX3X4X5G-CO2H, where X1 = L, F, V, Y; X2 = N, F; X3 = E, V, T; X4 = V, L; X5 = V, L) to the ribonuclease S protein. A key advantage of this strategy is that the IM/ TOFMS approach allows the relative abundances of individual library components (including numerous sequence and structural isomers) to be characterized before and after screening. The relative binding interactions of different sequences are assessed by comparing IM/TOFMS data for those components that pass through the column (as well as those that bind) to data for the library prior to screening. The high-affinity sequences that are found in this study are compared with those selected from much larger combinatorial libraries. The results suggest that many expected sequences in the large libraries may be missing (e.g., due to issues such as failure of specific steps during the synthesis or differences in solubility). Comparison of the binding sequences obtained in these studies and those reported previously indicates that screening results from large libraries should be interpreted with caution.     

Stoichiometric selection of tight-binding inhibitors by wild-type and mutant forms of malarial (Plasmodium falciparum) dihydrofolate reductase

A simple method for screening combinatorial and other libraries of inhibitors of malarial (Plasmodium falciparum) dihydrofolate reductase (PfDHFR) has been developed, based on the affinities of the inhibitors with the enzyme. In the presence of limiting amounts of the enzyme, a number of inhibitors in the library were bound to extents reflecting the relative binding affinities. Following ultrafiltration and guanidine hydrochloride treatment to release bound inhibitors, the amounts of free and bound inhibitors could be determined by high-performance liquid chromatography and liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. The differences in the patterns reflected the binding of high-affinity components compared with the other members in the library. A good correlation was found between the inhibition constants (Ki values) and the extent of binding of inhibitors to wild-type, double (C59R+S108N) and quadruple mutant (N51I+C59R+S108N+I164L) of PfDHFR, as well as human DHFR. In addition to identifying lead components of the libraries with high affinities (low Ki values) and stabilities (low k(off) rates), this simple method also provides an alternative way for quickly and accurately calculating enzyme binding affinities of inhibitors in combinatorial chemical libraries.     

A method for connecting solution-phase enzyme activity assays with immobilized format analysis by mass spectrometry

This paper reports an enzyme activity assay that combines the assets of both homogeneous and solid-phase formats. In this method, enzyme reactions are carried out in solution using substrates that are tagged with an immobilization reagent that allows the substrates to be selectively immobilized to self-assembled monolayers (SAMs), for direct analysis by matrix assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight (MALDI-TOF) mass spectrometry (MS). As a model enzyme reaction, this work examined the transfer of a methyl group from S-adenosyl-l-methionine (AdoMet) to an arginine side chain of a peptide substrate by the enzyme protein arginine methyltransferase 1 (RMT1). A cysteine-terminated peptide substrate was methylated by RMT1 in solution and then applied to a maleimide-presenting SAM to give selective immobilization of the peptide. Time-dependent analysis of methylation using MALDI-TOFMS clearly showed that both the presence and relative amount of the two reaction products-the mono- and dimethylated peptides-can be conveniently evaluated. This assay strategy is rapid, takes advantage of solution-phase assay conditions, avoids the use of labels and complicated purification steps, and is applicable to multianalyte analyses.     

Dioxin-binding pentapeptide for use in a high-sensitivity on-bead detection assay

The purpose of this study is to develop a dioxin detection method using a short peptide alternative to an immunoantibody. A full peptide library consisting of 2.5 million possible amino acid combinations was constructed by a solid-phase split synthesis approach using 19 natural amino acids. The peptide beads were subjected to a competitive binding assay between 2,3,7-trichlorodibenzo-p-dioxin and N-NBD-3-(3',4'-dichlorophenoxy)-1-propylamine (NBD-DCPPA) in a buffer containing 20% 1,4-dioxane. Two almost identical pentapeptides, FLDQI and FLDQV, that could bind dioxin were screened from the combinatorial library. NBD-DCPPA and the peptide synthesized on resin beads could be utilized to determine dioxin concentrations. The fluorescence intensity of the beads was measured using fluorescence microscopy to make a calibration curve for the dioxin concentrations. 2,3,7,8-Tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (2,3,7,8-TeCDD) could also detected in the presence of 30% 1,4-dioxane. To optimize the peptide sequence, a one-amino acid-substituted library was prepared using amino acids including nonnatural amino acids. The internal amino acids, LDQ, could not be substituted by any other amino acids. This result indicates that these three side chains are essential to recognize dioxins. The peptide C terminus substituted by phenylglycine showed a 10 times lower detection limit of 2,3,7,8-TeCDD of 150 pM (50 pg/mL) than the original sequence FLDQV. The cross reactivity of the dioxin binding peptides including the secondary derivatives was investigated. Some polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons bound to the peptide beads, but nonchlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxin and PCB did not. From these results, we demonstrate the potential of short peptides as a practical sensor material targeting low molecular weight compounds such as dioxin.     

Modular high-throughput test stand for versatile screening of thin-film materials libraries

Versatile high-throughput characterization tools are required for the development of new materials using combinatorial techniques. Here, we describe a modular, high-throughput test stand for the screening of thin-film materials libraries, which can carry out automated electrical, magnetic and magnetoresistance measurements in the temperature range of −40 to 300 °C. As a proof of concept, we measured the temperature-dependent resistance of Fe–Pd–Mn ferromagnetic shape-memory alloy materials libraries, revealing reversible martensitic transformations and the associated transformation temperatures. Magneto-optical screening measurements of a materials library identify ferromagnetic samples, whereas resistivity maps support the discovery of new phases. A distance sensor in the same setup allows stress measurements in materials libraries deposited on cantilever arrays. A combination of these methods offers a fast and reliable high-throughput characterization technology for searching for new materials. Using this approach, a composition region has been identified in the Fe–Pd–Mn system that combines ferromagnetism and martensitic transformation.     

Mass spectrometry screening of combinatorial mixtures, correlation of measured and predicted electrospray ionization spectra

Methodology was developed to afford rapid characterization of multicomponent mixtures of small organic molecules prepared by split-and-mix combinatorial synthesis. This methodology involved the use of liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (LC/MS) combined with correlation analysis of measured versus predicted electrospray ionization mass spectra. Low-resolution mass spectra of complex mixtures revealed predictable patterns that confirm library products, assisted in identifying chemical synthesis errors, and assessed overall library integrity. In general, equal signal intensities were observed for most combinatorial mixture components, indicating that differences in electrospray ionization efficiency was not a major limitation to this approach. High-throughput data processing programs and informatics tools were used to speed data analysis and to simplify the presentation of the library characterization results. This approach has been used to characterize combinatorial libraries that were synthesized for a variety of drug-discovery programs. Examples are shown for library formats of 1, 40, 66, 280, and 400 component(s)/well. The applicability of this approach to large combinatorial mixtures should allow direct characterization of massive combinatorial libraries.     

Modular high-throughput test stand for versatile screening of thin-film materials libraries

Abstract

Versatile high-throughput characterization tools are required for the development of new materials using combinatorial techniques. Here, we describe a modular, high-throughput test stand for the screening of thin-film materials libraries, which can carry out automated electrical, magnetic and magnetoresistance measurements in the temperature range of ?40 to 300 °C. As a proof of concept, we measured the temperature-dependent resistance of Fe–Pd–Mn ferromagnetic shape-memory alloy materials libraries, revealing reversible martensitic transformations and the associated transformation temperatures. Magneto-optical screening measurements of a materials library identify ferromagnetic samples, whereas resistivity maps support the discovery of new phases. A distance sensor in the same setup allows stress measurements in materials libraries deposited on cantilever arrays. A combination of these methods offers a fast and reliable high-throughput characterization technology for searching for new materials. Using this approach, a composition region has been identified in the Fe–Pd–Mn system that combines ferromagnetism and martensitic transformation.     

Combinatorial screening of enzyme activity by using multiplexed capillary electrophoresis

Efficient and comprehensive screening of enzyme activity was accomplished in a combinatorial array of 96 reaction microvials. Quantitation of the extent of the reaction at well-defined time intervals was achieved by using 96-capillary array electrophoresis coupled with a multiplexed absorption detector. Capillary electrophoresis provides high separation resolution to isolate the product from the reactants. Absorption detection provides universal applicability to combinatorial screening. For the conversion of NADH to NAD+, the catalytic activity of LDH was confirmed to be the highest at pH 7. This scheme should be useful for high-throughput drug discovery, clinical diagnosis, substrate binding, as well as combinatorial synthesis.     

Immunoaffinity Ultrafiltration with Ion Spray HPLC/MS for Screening Small-Molecule Libraries

A solution-phase screening method for libraries of pharmaceutically relevant molecules is presented. The technique is applicable to screening combinatorial libraries of 20-30 closely related molecules. In this report, individual benzodiazepines are selected from a multicomponent library mixture by formation in solution of noncovalent immunoaffinity complexes with antibodies raised to therapeutically proven drugs such as nitrazepam, temazepam, or oxazepam. Captured compounds are separated from nonspecifically bound library components by centrifugal ultrafiltration. The specifically selected molecules retained on the filter are subsequently liberated from the antibodies by acidification and analyzed by HPLC coupled with pneumatically assisted electrospray (ion spray) ionization mass spectrometric detection. Competition by the benzodiazepines for limited antibody binding sites is controlled by varying the stoichiometry of the complexation mixture. This procedure selects library components with the greatest affinity for a particular antibody. Specific capture of benzodiazepines is demonstrated by screening both a pool of structurally similar benzodiazepines and a more complex mixture of benzodiazepines with an additional set of unrelated compounds. Affinity ultrafiltration and electrospray mass spectrometry complement each other to enhance screening and identification of pooled drug candidates and potentially can be extended to other small-molecule combinatorial libraries and macromolecular receptor preparations.     

Screening of mixture combinatorial libraries for chiral selectors: a reciprocal chromatographic approach using enantiomeric libraries

An approach to screen mixture combinatorial libraries for chiral selectors is described. Crucial elements to such an approach are the reciprocity of chromatographic separation and the use of enantiomeric libraries. The feasibility of this method is demonstrated with a model study of the chiral resolution of (1-naphthyl)leucine ester 1 with a small peptide library.     

Nanomolar Synthesis in Droplet Microarrays with UV‐Triggered On‐Chip Cell Screening

Miniaturization and parallelization of combinatorial organic synthesis is important to accelerate the process of drug discovery while reducing the consumption of reagents and solvents. This work presents a miniaturized platform for on‐chip solid‐phase combinatorial library synthesis with UV‐triggered on‐chip cell screening. The platform is based on a nanoporous polymer coating on a glass slide, which is modified via photolithography to yield arrays of hydrophilic (HL) spots surrounded by superhydrophobic (SH) surface. The combination of HL spots and SH background enables confinement of nanoliter droplets, functioning as miniaturized reactors for the solid‐phase synthesis. The polymer serves as support for nanomolar solid‐phase synthesis, while a photocleavable linker enables the release of the synthesized compounds into the droplets containing live cells. A 588 compound library of bisamides is synthesized via a four‐component Ugi reaction on the chip and products are detected via stamping of the droplet array onto a conductive substrate and subsequent matrix‐assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry. The light‐induced cleavage shows high flexibility in screening conditions by spatial, temporal, and quantitative control.     

High-throughput screening for enzyme inhibitors using frontal affinity chromatography with liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry

This work presents new frontal affinity chromatography (FAC) methodologies for high-throughput screening of compound libraries, designed to increase screening rates and improve sensitivity and ruggedness in performance. A FAC column constructed around the enzyme N-acetylglucosaminyltransferase V (GnT-V) was implemented in the identification of potential enzyme inhibitors from two libraries of trisaccharides. Effluent from the FAC column was fractionated, sequentially processed via LC/MS, and referenced to a similar analysis through a control FAC column lacking the enzyme. The resulting multidimensional data sets were compared across corresponding sample and control fractions to identify binders, in a semiautomated approach. A strong binder in the protonated form at m/z 795 was identified from the first library of 81 compounds, exhibiting an estimated Kd value of 0.3 microM. Other binders yielded Kd values ranging from 0.35 to 3.35 microM. To demonstrate the improvement in performance of this FAC-LC/MS approach over the conventional online FAC/MS approach, 15 compounds from this library were blended with a second library of 1000 synthetic trisaccharides and screened against GnT-V. All ligands in the 15-compound set were identified in this larger screen, and no ligands of greater affinity than compound 1 were found. Our results show that FAC-LC/MS is a reliable method for screening large compound libraries directly and useful for large-scale ligand discovery initiatives.     

High-throughput solution-based medicinal library screening against human serum albumin

High-throughput screening of combinatorial libraries has evolved from studying large diverse libraries to analyzing small, structurally similar, focused libraries. This paradigm shift has generated a need for rapid screening technologies to screen both diverse and focused libraries in a simple, efficient, and inexpensive manner. We have proactively addressed these needs by developing a high-throughput, solution-based method combining size exclusion (SEC), two-dimensional liquid chromatography (2-D LC), and mass spectrometry (MS) for determining the relative binding of drug candidates in small, focused medicinal libraries against human serum albumin (HSA). Two types of libraries were used to evaluate the performance of the system. The first consisted of five diverse ligands with a wide range of hydrophobicities and whose association constants to HSA cover 3 orders of magnitude. A beta-lactam library composed of structurally similar compounds was used to further confirm the validity of the methodology. The ability to distinguish site-specific interactions of drugs competing for individual domains of the HSA receptor is also demonstrated. Comparison of chromatographic profiles of the library components before and after incubation with the receptor using multiple reaction monitoring allowed a ranking of the ligands according to their relative binding affinities. The observed rankings correlate closely with literature values of the association constants between the respective ligands and HSA. This simple, rugged methodology can screen a wide spectrum of chemical entities from combinatorial mixtures in less than 6 min.     

Encoding microcarriers by spatial selective photobleaching

Bead-based assays on very large numbers of molecules in gene expression studies, drug screening and clinical diagnostics, require the encoding of each of the microspheres according to the particular ligand bound to its surface. This allows mixing the uniquely encoded microspheres and subjecting them to an assay simultaneously. When a particular microsphere gives a positive reaction, the substance on its surface can be identified by reading the code. Previously reported techniques for colour encoding polymer microspheres only allow for a limited number of unique codes. Graphical encoding methods use metallic particles, which are rather uncommon in screening applications. Here, we demonstrate a new approach to encode polymer microspheres that are commonly used in screening applications, such as polystyrene microspheres, with a method that provides a virtually unlimited number of unique codes. Patterns can be written in fluorescently dyed microspheres by 'spatial selective photobleaching' and can be identified by confocal microscopy. Such encoded microparticles can find broad application in the collection and analysis of genetic information, high-throughput screening, medical diagnostics and combinatorial chemistry, and can also be used for labelling of consumer goods or as security labels to prevent counterfeiting.     

Multifunctional Materials through Modular Protein Engineering

The diversity of potential applications for protein‐engineered materials has undergone profound recent expansion through a rapid increase in the library of domains that have been utilized in these materials. Historically, protein‐engineered biomaterials have been generated from a handful of peptides that were selected and exploited for their naturally evolved functionalities. In recent years, the scope of the field has drastically expanded to include peptide domains that were designed through computational modeling, identified through high‐throughput screening, or repurposed from wild type domains to perform functions distinct from their primary native applications. The strategy of exploiting a diverse library of peptide domains to design modular block copolymers enables the synthesis of multifunctional protein‐engineered materials with a range of customizable properties and activities. As the diversity of peptide domains utilized in modular protein engineering continues to expand, a tremendous and ever‐growing combinatorial expanse of material functionalities will result.