Flexural Strengthening of RC Beams with Prestressed CFRP Sheets: Using Nonmetallic Anchor Systems

This paper presents the flexural behavior of reinforced concrete beams strengthened with prestressed carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) sheets using nonmetallic anchor systems. The developed nonmetallic anchor systems replace the permanent steel anchorage. Nine doubly reinforced concrete beams are tested with various types of nonmetallic anchor systems such as nonanchored U-wraps, mechanically anchored U-wraps, and CFRP sheet-anchored U-wraps. The flexural behavior of the tested beams, including detailed failure modes of each nonmetallic anchor system, is investigated. The study shows that the developed nonmetallic anchors are more effective in resisting peeling-off cracks compared to the permanent steel anchors and the beams strengthened with the nonmetallic anchors provide comparable load-carrying capacity with respect to the steel anchored control beam.     

Concrete Beams Strengthened with Prestressed Near Surface Mounted CFRP

Retrofitting concrete structures with fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) has today grown to be a widely used method throughout most parts of the world. The main reason for this is that it is possible to obtain a good strengthening effect with a relatively small work effort. It is also possible to carry out strengthening work without changing the appearance or dimensions of the structure. Nevertheless, when strengthening a structure with external FRP, it is often not possible to make full use of the FRP. The reason for this depends mainly on the fact that a strain distribution exists over the section due to dead load or other loads that cannot be removed during strengthening. This implies that steel yielding in the reinforcement may already be occurring in the service limit state or that compressive failure in the concrete is occurring. By prestressing, a higher utilization of the FRP material is made possible. It is extremely important to ensure that, if external prestressing is used, the force is properly transferred to the structure. Most of the research conducted with prestressing carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP) for strengthening has been on surface bonded laminates. However, this paper presents research on prestressed CFRP quadratic rods bonded in sawed grooves in the concrete cover. This method has proven to be an advantageous means of bonding CFRP to concrete, and in comparison to surface bonded laminates, the shear and normal stress between the CFRP and the concrete are more efficiently transferred to the structure. In the presented test, no mechanical device has been used to maintain the prestress during testing, which means that the adhesive must transfer all shear stresses to the concrete. Fifteen beams with a length of 4?m have been tested. The tests show that the prestressed beams exhibited a higher first-crack load as well as a higher steel-yielding load as compared to nonprestressed strengthened beams. The ultimate load at failure was also higher, as compared to nonprestressed beams, but in relation not as large as for the cracking and yielding. In addition, the beams strengthened with prestressed FRP had a smaller midpoint deflection. All strengthened beams failed due to fiber rupture of the FRP.     

RC Slabs Strengthened with Prestressed and Gradually Anchored CFRP Strips under Monotonic and Cyclic Loading

This paper presents the test results of reinforced concrete slabs strengthened with prestressed and gradually anchored carbon fiber–reinforced polymer (CFRP) strips under monotonic and cyclic loading. To take full advantage of the externally bonded CFRP technique, it is beneficial to apply the laminates in a prestressed state, which relieves the stress in the steel reinforcement and reduces crack widths and deflection. The aim of the monotonic tests was to determine the strengthening efficiency of the new prestressing technique and to investigate serviceability and ultimate states. The cyclic tests were performed to identify the fatigue behavior of the strengthened slabs and to investigate the influence of long-term cyclic loading and elevated temperature on the bond properties of the prestressed CFRP laminates and the ductility and flexural strength of the strengthened slabs. A nonlinear analytical model of reinforced concrete members strengthened with passive and prestressed CFRP strips under static loading is proposed in the paper. A comparison of the experimental and predicted results reveals an excellent agreement in the full range of loading.     

Flexural Strengthening of RC Beams with Prestressed CFRP Sheets: Development of Nonmetallic Anchor Systems

This paper presents a novel anchoring technique for strengthening reinforced concrete beams with prestressed carbon fiber- reinforced polymer (CFRP) sheets. Permanent steel anchors are commonly used for the application of prestressed CFRP sheets. The steel anchors are, however, susceptible to corrosion and may not blend into the aesthetics of the original structure. As a result, it may be preferable to remove the steel anchors after transferring the required prestress to the structure with minimal losses of sustained prestress. A technique for replacing the steel anchors with nonmetallic anchors is investigated and reported herein. Nine doubly reinforced concrete beams are tested with various types of nonmetallic anchor systems such as nonanchored U-wraps, mechanically anchored U-wraps, and CFRP sheet-anchored U-wraps. The developed nonmetallic anchorages successfully transfer the sustained prestress in the CFRP sheets with insignificant prestress losses. A closed-form solution for the transfer of prestress is developed and compared to the experimental results.     

Torsional Capacity of CFRP Strengthened Reinforced Concrete Beams

Many buildings and bridge elements are subjected to significant torsional moments that affect the design, and may require strengthening. Fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) has shown great promise as a state-of-the-art material in flexural and shear strengthening as external reinforcement, but information on its applicability in torsional strengthening is limited. Furthermore, available design tools are sparse and unproven. This paper briefly recounts the experimental work in an overall investigation of torsional strengthening of solid and box-section reinforced concrete beams with externally bonded carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP). A database of previous experimental research available in literature was compiled and compared against fib Bulletin 14. Modifications consistent with the space truss model were proposed to correct the poor accuracy in predictions of CFRP contribution to strength. Subsequently, a design tool to analyze the full torsional capacity of strengthened reinforced concrete beams was validated against the experimental database.     

Flexural Strengthening of RC Beams with Externally Bonded CFRP Systems: Test Results and 3D Nonlinear FE Analysis

This paper presents experimental results and a numerical analysis of the reinforced concrete (RC) beams strengthened in flexure with various externally bonded carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) configurations. The aim of the experimental work was to investigate the parameters that may delay the intermediate crack debonding of the bottom CFRP laminate, and increase the load carrying capacity and CFRP strength utilization ratio. Ten rectangular RC specimens with a clear span of 4.2?m, categorized in two series, were tested to evaluate the effect of using the additional U-shaped CFRP systems on the intermediate crack debonding of the bottom laminate. Two different configurations of the additional systems were proposed, namely, continuous U-shaped wet layup sheets and spaced side-bonded CFRP L-shaped laminates. The fiber orientation effect of the side-bonded sheets was also investigated. A numerical analysis using an incremental nonlinear displacement-controlled 3D finite-element (FE) model was developed to investigate the flexural and CFRP/concrete interfacial responses of the tested beams. The finite-element model accounts for the orthotropic behavior of the CFRP laminates. An appropriate bond-slip model was adopted to characterize the behavior of the CFRP/concrete interface. Comparisons between the FE predictions and experimental results show very good agreement in terms of the load-deflection and load-strain relationships, ultimate capacities, and failure modes of the beams.     

Flexure of Two-Way Slabs Strengthened with Prestressed or Nonprestressed CFRP Sheets

This paper presents a study on the flexural behavior of two-way reinforced concrete slabs externally strengthened with prestressed or nonprestressed carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) sheets. Four large-scale flat plate slabs (3,000?mm×3,000?mm×90?mm) are tested and a nonlinear three-dimensional finite-element analysis is conducted to predict the flexural behaviors of the tested slabs, including the load-deflection response, strain distribution, crack propagation, and crack mouth opening displacement. An increase in the load-carrying capacity of 25 and 72% is achieved for the slabs strengthened with nonprestressed and prestressed CFRP sheets, respectively, in comparison to the unstrengthened slab. A reduction of the deflections up to 32% in service is noted for the strengthened slabs. The unstrengthened slab shows very ductile behavior, whereas, progressive failure is observed for the strengthened slabs, exhibiting pseudoductility in postpeak behavior. Stress redistribution between the internal and external reinforcement is significant in the slab strengthened with prestressed CFRP sheets.     

Experimental Behavior of Reinforced Concrete Beams Strengthened with Prestressed CFRP Shear Straps

One promising means of increasing the capacity of existing shear-deficient beams is to strengthen the structure using external prestressed carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP) straps. In this system, layers of CFRP tape are wrapped around a beam to form a strap that acts like a discrete unbonded vertical prestressing tendon. Experiments were undertaken to investigate the influence of the strap spacing, the strap stiffness, the initial strap prestress level and/or any preexisting damage on the strengthened behavior, and mode of failure. An unstrengthened control beam was tested and failed in shear. In contrast, all of the strengthened beams showed a significant increase in their ultimate load capacity with several of the strengthened beams failing in flexure. A number of different failure modes were noted and initial guidelines on the design parameters that influence the propensity for a particular failure mode were developed.     

Ductility and Cracking Behavior of Prestressed Concrete Beams Strengthened with Prestressed CFRP Sheets

This paper investigates the flexure of prestressed concrete beams strengthened with prestressed carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) sheets, focusing on ductility and cracking behavior. Structural ductility of a beam strengthened with CFRP sheets is critical, considering the abrupt and brittle failure of CFRP sheets themselves. Cracking may also affect serviceability of a strengthened beam, and may be especially important for durability. Midscale prestressed concrete beams (L = 3.6?m) are constructed and a significant loss of prestress is simulated by reducing the reinforcement ratio to observe the strengthening effects. A nonlinear iterative analytical model, including tension of concrete, is developed and a nonlinear finite-element analysis is conducted to predict the flexural behavior of tested beams. The prestressed CFRP sheets result in less localized damage in the strengthened beam and the level of the prestress in the sheets significantly contributes to the ductility and cracking behavior of the strengthened beams. Consequently, the recommended level of prestress to the CFRP sheets is 20% of the ultimate design strain with adequate anchorages.     

Bond Behavior of CFRP Bars in Simply Supported Reinforced Concrete Beam with Hanging Region

This paper presents an experimental study on the bond behavior of longitudinal reinforcements in the hanging region (i.e., the part of the beam outside the support) of a simply supported reinforced concrete beam. Twenty-three reinforced concrete beams were tested to failure. Carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) bars were used as longitudinal reinforcements in place of ordinary steel bars. The main test variables were (1) stirrup ratio in the hanging region; (2) stirrup ratio in the shear span; and (3) bond length in the hanging region. The test results showed that, even though the beam had a sufficient stirrup ratio in the shear span, bond-splitting failure occurred in the shear span of the beam with insufficient bond length in the hanging region. Based on the test results, the provision of ACI and AIJ codes on the additional anchorage length in the hanging region was evaluated, and a model for predicting tension force at the support was presented.     

Performance in Fire of Small-Scale CFRP Strengthened Concrete Beams

When strengthening concrete members with fiber-reinforced plastic (FRP) materials the strengthening is, typically, undertaken to carry live load. This live load is assumed to remove itself from the strengthened member in the event of a fire. Thus, the fire performance of the FRP is not important. However, if the strengthening system was designed such that the FRP took some of the dead load, then the performance in fire would become important. In this series of tests, 24 reinforced concrete beams were cast. They were divided into eight sets of three. The sets were split into fire tested and control. In the control group were an unstrengthened control set, a set strengthened with bonded carbon FRP (CFRP) plates, and a set with bonded CFRP plates with bolted anchorages. In the fire-tested group were an unstrengthened control set, a set strengthened with bonded CFRP plates, a set with bonded CFRP plates with bolted anchorages, a set strengthened with bonded CFRP plates and a cementitous fire protection system, and a set with bonded CFRP plates with bolted anchorages and a cementitous fire protection system. The unloaded beams were then subjected to a cellulosic fire in a furnace. The adhesive on the unprotected beams was destroyed by the fire, as was the resin in the CFRP plate. On the strengthened beams with a cementitous fire protection system the adhesive was destroyed by the fire but the resin in the CFRP plate was undamaged. All the beams were tested in four-point bending to determine their load capacity and stiffness. Of the non-fire-tested beams the control beams were weakest and the strengthened beams were stronger and stiffer, there being no significant difference between the bolted and nonbolted beams. The fire-tested beams were load tested postfire exposure. Of the fire-tested beams the control beams had the same properties as the non-fire-tested control beams. The unbolted beams had the same strength regardless of fire protection. One of the bolted beams with fire protection was stronger than those without fire protection but not as strong as the nonfire-tested beams. It can be concluded that the strengthening system in the unprotected beams was destroyed in the fire test. Where fire protection was provided this protected the resin in the CFRP plate but not the adhesive bonding the plate to the beams. Bolts helped to keep the plate attached to the beam but did not provide as good a connection as the adhesive.     

Analysis of the Flexural Behavior of Partially Bonded FRP Strengthened Concrete Beams

An investigation was conducted on the flexural behavior of partially bonded fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) strengthened concrete beams focusing on the improvement of ductility. An analytical model was developed based on the curvature approach to predict the behavior of beams strengthened with partially bonded FRP systems. The result of the analysis showed that ductility of the partially bonded system was improved while sustaining high load carrying capacity in comparison to the fully bonded system. To verify the analytical model, an experimental program was carried out with reinforced concrete beams strengthened with the externally bonded FRP system. A comparison of the analytical prediction and experimental results showed good agreement.     

Modeling of an Unbonded CFRP Strap Shear Retrofitting System for Reinforced Concrete Beams

A retrofitting technique has been developed that uses carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) straps to increase the shear capacity of reinforced concrete beams. The vertical straps are not bonded to the beam but are instead anchored against the beam, which makes this technique potentially more effective than bonded FRP retrofitting techniques. However, it also means that models for bonded FRPs are not appropriate for use with the straps. Instead, a model based on a shear friction approach has been developed where the strain in the straps is calculated based on a term that accounts for the effects of prestress and additional strain in the strap due to shear crack opening. The model can either consider the shear reinforcement to be smeared along the length of the beam or discrete elements. The “smeared” model was checked against an experimental database consisting of rectangular, T-, and deep beams, both in terms of predicted capacity and predicted strain in the straps. Overall the smeared model predicted the capacity of the specimens and, with some adjustments, the strains quite accurately. There were, however, cases when it was more appropriate to use the “discrete” model such as when the transverse reinforcement ratio was low or when the transverse reinforcement spacing was high. Further experimental data are required to fully validate the models and to determine appropriate limits on the use of the smeared model and the discrete model. However, the initial results are promising.     

Performance of Mechanically Fastened FRP Strengthened Concrete Beams in Flexure

The use of adhesively bonded fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) materials has become widely accepted for use in flexural strengthening applications; however, the method of attachment presents drawbacks in application. These include extensive time and labor investments, as well as a tendency of the system to fail in a brittle manner. This paper presents a study of a series of reinforced concrete beams each strengthened in flexure with an FRP strip attached with large diameter concrete screws. The concrete screws were arranged in a variety of patterns. The effect of fastener number and spacing, as well as the effect of fastener pattern on the behavior of the beam, was investigated through the use of two groups of specimens. The beams in each group were tested to failure to verify the behavior of the strengthening system. Measured behavior was then used to determine an analytical approach for prediction of load response behavior of mechanically fastened systems. It was found that the strengthening method investigated improved the flexural capacity of the specimens 12 to 39% with little or no loss in ductility.     

Size Effects for Reinforced Concrete Beams Strengthened in Shear with CFRP Strips

The principal motivation of this study is to obtain a clear understanding of size effects for fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) shear-strengthened beams. The experimental program consists of seven beams of various sizes grouped in three test series. One beam of each series is used as a benchmark and its behavior is compared with a beam strengthened with a U-shaped carbon FRP (CFRP) jacket. The third test series includes an additional beam strengthened with completely wrapped external CFRP sheets. The experimental results show that the effective axial strains of the CFRP sheets are higher in the smaller specimens. Moreover, with a larger beam size, one can expect less strain in the FRPs. A nonlinear finite-element numerical analysis is developed to model the behavior of the CFRP shear-strengthened beams. The numerical model is able to simulate the characteristics of the shear-strengthened beams, including the interfacial behavior between the concrete and the CFRP sheets. Three prediction models available in current design guidelines for computing the CFRP effective strain and shear contribution to the shear capacity of the CFRP shear-strengthened beams are compared with the experimental results.     

Flexural and Interfacial Behavior of FRP-Strengthened Reinforced Concrete Beams

Although there is a large amount of experimental data available on the fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) strengthening of concrete structures, a full understanding of the various debonding phenomena is somewhat lacking. As a contribution to fill this need, two-dimensional and three-dimensional (3D) nonlinear displacement-controlled finite-element (FE) models are developed to investigate the flexural and FRP/concrete interfacial responses of FRP-strengthened reinforced concrete beams. Interface elements are used to simulate the FRP/concrete interfacial behavior before and after cracking. The analysis is carried out using two different relations for the interface; namely, nonlinear and bilinear bond–slip laws. The results predicted using these two laws are compared to those based on the full-bond assumption. The FE models are capable of simulating the various failure modes, including debonding of the FRP, either at the plate end or at intermediate cracks. The 3D model is created to accommodate cases of FRP-strengthened reinforced concrete beams utilizing FRP anchorage systems. In addition, the models successfully represent the actual interfacial behavior at the vicinities of cracks including the stress/slip concentrations and fluctuations. Results are presented in terms of the ultimate load carrying capacities, failure modes and deformational characteristics. Special emphasis is placed on the FRP/concrete interfacial behavior and cracking of the concrete. The numerical results are compared to available experimental data for 25 specimens categorized in six series, and they show a very good agreement.     

Prestressed Carbon Fiber Reinforced Polymer Sheets for Strengthening Concrete Beams at Room and Low Temperatures

A technique for strengthening damaged concrete beams using prestressed carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP) sheets was developed at Queen’s University and the Royal Military College of Canada. As part of this study, an anchorage system was developed to directly prestress the CFRP sheets by jacking and reacting against the strengthened concrete beam itself. The feasibility and effectiveness of using bonded prestressed CFRP sheets to strengthen precracked concrete beams at both room (+22°C,+72°F) and low (?28°C,?20°F) temperatures have been investigated experimentally. Materials and prestress changes due to temperature variations that would affect and cause changes in flexural behavior were studied. The strengthened beams showed significant increases in flexural stiffness and ultimate capacity as compared to the control-unstrengthened beams. The flexural behavior of the strengthened beams was not adversely affected by short-term exposure to reduced temperature (?28°C,?20°F). In addition to the experimental investigation, analytical models were developed to predict the overall flexural behavior of the strengthened beams during prestressing of the CFRP sheets and under external loading at both room and low temperatures. The model accurately predicted the flexural beam behavior. Improved serviceability behavior and higher strength were predicted for beams strengthened with the bonded prestressed CFRP sheets.     

Strength and Ductility of Concrete Beams Reinforced with Carbon Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Plates and Steel

Seven concrete beams reinforced internally with varying amounts of steel and externally with precured carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) plates applied after the concrete had cracked under service loads were tested under four-point bending. Strains measured along the beam depth allowed computation of the beam curvature in the constant moment region. Results show that FRP is very effective for flexural strengthening. As the amount of steel increases, the additional strength provided by the carbon FRP plates decreases. Compared to a beam reinforced heavily with steel only, beams reinforced with both steel and carbon have adequate deformation capacity, in spite of their brittle mode of failure. Clamping or wrapping of the ends of the precured FRP plate enhances the capacity of adhesively bonded FRP anchorage. Design equations for anchorage, allowable stress, ductility, and amount of reinforcement are discussed.     

Live Load Distributions on an Impact-Damaged Prestressed Concrete Girder Bridge Repaired Using Prestressed CFRP Sheets

This paper describes detailed flexural behavior, including live load distributions, of a four-span prestressed concrete girder bridge supported by 14?m long C-shape girders (4 @ 14.05 = 56.2?m). The bridge has been damaged by frequent impact from heavy trucks, and repaired using prestressed carbon fiber-reinforced polymer sheets. A calibrated finite element analysis is conducted to investigate the flexural behavior (i.e., stress redistribution, deflection, live load distribution, and applied load effects) of the bridge in three different phases (i.e., undamaged, damaged, and repaired states) under various loading configurations. Strain localizations are noted at the damaged and repaired locations. Assessment of existing bridge codes such as the Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials Load Resistance Factor Design and Canadian Highway Bridge Design Code is conducted. The bridge codes predict well the nominal live load effect on the exterior girder, but underestimate the effect on the interior girders. A refined analysis may be recommended for this type of bridge.     

Flexural Behavior of Reinforced Concrete Beams Strengthened with CFRP Sheets and Epoxy Mortar

Experiments were conducted to study the effect of using epoxy mortar patch end anchorages on the flexural behavior of reinforced concrete beams strengthened with carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) sheets. More specifically, the effect of the end anchorage on strength, deflection, flexural strain, and interfacial shear stress was examined. The test results show that premature debonding failure of reinforced concrete beams strengthened with CFRP sheet can be delayed or prevented by using epoxy mortar patch end anchorages. A modified analytical procedure for evaluating the flexural capacity of reinforced concrete beams strengthened with CFRP sheets and epoxy mortar end anchorage is developed and provides a good prediction of test results.