Conventional freezing plus high pressure-low temperature treatment: Physical properties, microbial quality and storage stability of beef meat

Meat high-hydrostatic pressure treatment causes severe decolouration, preventing its commercialisation due to consumer rejection. Novel procedures involving product freezing plus low-temperature pressure processing are here investigated. Room temperature (20 °C) pressurisation (650 MPa/10 min) and air blast freezing (−30 °C) are compared to air blast freezing plus high pressure at subzero temperature (−35 °C) in terms of drip loss, expressible moisture, shear force, colour, microbial quality and storage stability of fresh and salt-added beef samples (Longissimus dorsi muscle). The latter treatment induced solid water transitions among ice phases. Fresh beef high pressure treatment (650 MPa/20 °C/10 min) increased significantly expressible moisture while it decreased in pressurised (650 MPa/−35 °C/10 min) frozen beef. Salt addition reduced high pressure-induced water loss. Treatments studied did not change fresh or salt-added samples shear force. Frozen beef pressurised at low temperature showed L, a and b values after thawing close to fresh samples. However, these samples in frozen state, presented chromatic parameters similar to unfrozen beef pressurised at room temperature. Apparently, freezing protects meat against pressure colour deterioration, fresh colour being recovered after thawing. High pressure processing (20 °C or −35 °C) was very effective reducing aerobic total (2-log₁₀ cycles) and lactic acid bacteria counts (2.4-log₁₀ cycles), in fresh and salt-added samples. Frozen + pressurised beef stored at −18 °C during 45 days recovered its original colour after thawing, similarly to just-treated samples while their counts remain below detection limits during storage.     

Effects of rigor temperature and electrical stimulation on venison quality

The effects of rigor temperature and electrical stimulation on venison quality were assessed using venison longissimus dorsi muscle. In the first trial, effect of rigor temperature (0, 15, 25, 30, 35 and 42 °C) and time post-mortem (at rigor, 3, 7 and 14 days) on drip and cooking losses, % expressible water (water holding capacity, WHC), sarcomere length, protein solubility, meat tenderness and colour were investigated. In the second trial, the effects of rigor temperature (15 and 35 °C), electric stimulation (stimulated or not stimulated) and time (at rigor, 3 and 6 weeks post-mortem) on tenderness and colour were further investigated. Results of the first trial showed no clearly established trends of the effect of rigor temperature and time on the cooking and drip losses and protein solubility except venison muscles that went into rigor at 42 °C tended to have higher drip loss and lower protein solubilities compared to muscles that went into rigor at the other temperatures. Venison water holding capacity (WHC) decreased with the increase in rigor temperature (P < 0.001) and venison became more tender with time post-mortem. Venison colour improved with increasing rigor temperature. During display, samples that went into rigor at 15, 25 and 35 °C had the lowest and those at 0 and 42 °C had the highest rate of change of redness (a^*) value with time. In the second trial, tenderness was improved by stimulation (P = 0.01). Redness (a^*) values were affected by rigor temperature (P < 0.01) and post-mortem time (P < 0.001) but not by electrical stimulation. It is concluded that venison tenderness can be improved via the manipulation of rigor temperature to obtain acceptable level of tenderness early post-mortem with less damaging effect on colour stability.     

Effect of electrical stimulation and cooking temperature on the within-sample variation of cooking loss and shear force of lamb

Electrical stimulation decreased the shear force and increased the cooking loss in seven paired lamb Longissimus dorsi (LD) muscles. This treatment did not have any effect on the within-sample variation. Cooking in 55°, 65° and 75°C water baths for 90 min caused a linear increase in the cooking loss and shear force. There was no stimulation-cooking temperature interaction observed. Cooking temperature also had no effect on the within-sample variation. A possible explanation as to why electrical stimulation did not affect the within-sample variation is given.     

High pre rigor temperature limits the ageing potential of beef that is not completely overcome by electrical stimulation and muscle restraining

Two simultaneous trials were conducted to determine the effects of electrical input [electrical stunning and stimulation (ES)], wrapping, pre rigor temperature (15 °C and 38 °C) and different post rigor chilling rates on beef quality using M. longissimus lumborum (n=100). The high pre rigor temperature induced a faster pH decline than ES. The loins at 38 °C had significantly greater protein denaturation, more purge and drip loss, higher shear force values and less desmin degradation compared with the loins at 15 °C. No difference in sarcomere length was determined between the pre rigor temperatures regardless of ES and wrapping. Different post rigor chilling rates did not play a substantial role in water-holding capacity, proteolysis, or shear force values during ageing. These results suggest that high pre rigor temperature induces temperature-related toughness of muscle due to protein denaturation with subsequent limitation of proteolysis by μ-calpain, regardless of ES and wrapping treatments.     

The effects of electrical stimulation and ageing on beef tenderness

Seventeen beef carcasses from cattle with a range of breeds, ages and body conditions were used in this trial. The four treatments applied to each carcass were control (C), electrical stimulation (ES), ageing for 28 days (A) and electrical stimulation plus ageing for 28 days (ES + A). Post-mortem muscle pH was measured at 0, 0·5, 4 and 24h post-stimulation. Significantly lower muscle pH values (P < 0·01) were achieved by the stimulated carcass side sompared to the unstimulated side at 0·5 (pH 6·47 vs. 6·91) and 4 h (pH 5·96 vs. 6·44) post-stimulation.

Warner-Bratzler shear and taste panel methods were used to assess the tenderness of Longissimus dorsi muscle samples from each of the four treatments. The ES, A and ES + A treatments were significantly more tender (P < 0·01) than the control treatment. The ES and the A treatments resulted in a similar improvement in tenderness compared to the control. The ES + A treatment was significantly more tender (P < 0·01) than the ES treatment alone, but there was no significant difference in tenderness between the A and the ES + A treatments.     

Effect of high power ultrasound and ageing on the physical properties of bovine Semitendinosus and Longissimus muscles

Tenderness is an important meat quality parameters and the use of high power ultrasound to disrupt muscle structure may prove effective for reducing both myofibrillar and collagenous toughness. The experiment was carried out with Longissimus lumborum et thoracis and Semitendinosus muscles from 3 to 4 year old steers. Uncooked beef samples (60 × 40 × 20 mm) were treated with high power ultrasound (24 kHz, 12 W/cm²) for up to 240 s, and aged for up to 8.5 days before evaluation of pH, drip loss, cook losses Warner–Bratzler shear (WBS), compression hardness, and colour. Ultrasound treatment significantly reduced WBS force and hardness, but significantly increased pH. Ageing significantly reduced hardness and WBS force, but there was no significant interaction between ultrasound treatment and ageing time. Ultrasound treatment did not affect any of the colour parameters (L^*a^*b^*, chroma and hue) but the ageing time significantly increased the lightness, chroma and hue. There was no significant effect of ultrasound treatment on drip loss, but it did significantly reduce the cook and total loss. During ageing, cook loss and total losses significantly increased. The results suggest that high power ultrasound is capable of reducing objective texture measurements of beef without compromising the other quality parameters investigated.     

Effects of freezing, thawing and storage on some quality factors for portion-size beef cuts

Portion-size beef cuts packaged in oxygen impermeable plastic bags were used to study the effects of rates of freezing and thawing, and storage time and temperature on drip and cooking losses, shear force, destruction of glutathione and accumulation of protein-breakdown products in meat. Portions weighing 150 g or over and frozen in an air-blast at −30°C gave lower losses of drip and lower amounts of nitrogenous constituents in drip than samples weighing less than 150 g or samples frozen in cardboard boxes in still air at −18°C. Freezing and thawing or frozen storage had no significant effect on shear force of meat frozen after ageing. During frozen storage, the destruction of glutathione and accumulation of protein-breakdown products increased, depending directly on storage temperature and time. The results show that a test based on these two biochemical changes would be suitable for assessing the quality of frozen beef.     

The effect of post-mortem ageing and heating on water retention in bovine muscles

The muscles semitendinosus (ST) and psoas major (PM) were removed from chilled young bull carcasses 24 h after slaughter and stored at 4 °C. At the 1st, 6th and 12th day of post-mortem ageing the chemical composition (moisture, fat, protein, collagen) and contents of free, immobilized and unfreezable water in the muscles were estimated. The muscle steaks were boiled at 100 °C, roasted at 170 °C or fried at 160 °C to an internal temperature of 75 °C, and the amounts of total, free, immobilized, and unfreezable water in heated muscles were evaluated. The unfreezable water was estimated by DSC. In the raw muscles immobilized water constituted 74–75%, free water 16.6–17.6% and unfreezable water 7–8% of the total water. Independent of time of ageing, PM muscle contained significantly more free water than ST muscle. During post-mortem ageing, changes in free, immobilized and unfreezable water in muscles were not significant. The level of free water was highest in boiled and least in fried meat, however the amount of immobilized water was highest in fried and lowest in boiled meat. The amount of unfreezable water in muscles heated after 12 days of post-mortem ageing decreased.     

Effect of muscle restraint on sheep meat tenderness with rigor mortis at 18°C

The effect on shear force of skeletal restraint and removing muscles from lamb m. longissimus thoracis et lumborum (LT) immediately after slaughter and electrical stimulation was undertaken at a rigor temperature of 18°C (n=15). The temperature of 18°C was achieved through chilling of electrically stimulated sheep carcasses in air at 12°C, air flow 1-1.5 ms(-2). In other groups, the muscle was removed at 2.5 h post-mortem and either wrapped or left non-wrapped before being placed back on the carcass to follow carcass cooling regimes. Following rigor mortis, the meat was aged for 0, 16, 40 and 65 h at 15°C and frozen. For the non-stimulated samples, the meat was aged for 0, 12, 36 and 60 h before being frozen. The frozen meat was cooked to 75°C in an 85°C water bath and shear force values obtained from a 1 × 1 cm cross-section. Commencement of ageing was considered to take place at rigor mortis and this was taken as zero aged meat. There were no significant differences in the rate of tenderisation and initial shear force for all treatments. The 23% cook loss was similar for all wrapped and non-wrapped situations and the values decreased slightly with longer ageing durations. Wrapping was shown to mimic meat left intact on the carcass, as it prevented significant prerigor shortening. Such techniques allows muscles to be removed and placed in a controlled temperature environment to enable precise studies of ageing processes.     

Softness in dry-cured porcine biceps femoris muscles in relation to meat quality characteristics and processing conditions

The aim of the study was to quantify the effect of meat quality characteristics and some processing conditions on the softness of dry-cured biceps femoris (BF) muscles. The BF muscles were dissected from forty hams and classified according to their pH_BF into three groups: LpH (pH < 5.66), MpH (5.66  pH  6.00) and HpH (pH > 6.00). BF muscles within each pH_BF group were distributed into three different Salting levels (1%, 2% or 4% of added NaCl). Muscles were salted, vacuum-packed and stored at 3 °C for 30 days. The post-salting BF muscles were classified into two intramuscular fat (IMF) levels: Low (IMF < 4%) and High (IMF  4%). Thereafter, the muscles were divided into two pieces and dried at two of the three different Drying levels (1.5, 2 and 2.5 g H₂O/g desalted dry matter). Then, each piece was divided into two samples that were packed in N₂ and stored at 5 °C or 30 °C for 1 month. Stress Relaxation was used to evaluate texture. Dry-cured BF muscles with initial pH > 6.0, with IMF > 4% or with added NaCl levels less than 2% were more prone to show soft texture. Softness in dry-cured muscles can be reduced by applying an ageing temperature of 30 °C for 30 days, despite increasing proteolysis. The softness reduction by ageing at 30 °C compared with 5 °C is expected to be higher when applied to drier samples, which show a smaller increase in proteolysis.     

An assessment of the effects of an alternative method of carcass suspension and conditioning on the tenderness of beef

The effects of leg-twisting treatment—making a slit in the flank, at the level of the cranio-ventral tip of the Rectus abdominis and tucking one hoof of the leg into this slit—plus 10 days ageing at 5–7°C, on shear value, sarcomere length, fibre diameter and fragmentation score of Semimembranosus (SM) and Adductor (ADD) muscles were assessed in fifteen mature good grade White Fulani.

The treatment and 10 days ageing significantly (P ≤ 0·05) lengthened the sarcomeres, reduced the fibre diameter, increased the fragmentation score and reduced the shear value of the oven-broiled SM and ADD samples.     

A modified hot processing strategy for beef: effects on fresh meat quality

A modified hot processing (MHP) strategy for beef carcasses using known chilling technology to maintain quality in the higher priced cuts while retaining lower value cuts for further, immediate hot processing was evaluated. Following high voltage electrical stimulation, paired sides from 36 carcasses were either conventionally processed (CP) or reduced in a manner similar to the French pan traité cut. The sides were help in a pre-chiller for 1 h prior to blast chilling at −20°C for 3 h at an air speed of 2·3 m s⁻¹, followed by chilling at 2°C for the remainder of the 24 h period. Overall, MHP of beef carcass sides had minimal effects on fresh meat quality in the longissimus thoracis et lumborum (LTL) and the semimembranosus (SM) muscles despite removing over 50% of the carcass side weight in the form of lower value cuts. Sarcomere length was significantly shorter (P ≤ 0·05) in the anterior (AL) and posterior (PL) LTL which was attributed to the removal of skeletal restraint and carcass weight. The increase in shear value in the AL, location of MHP sides although statistically significant (P ≤ 0·05) would not likely be percieved by consumers. Hence a non-traditional method of processing carcasses by treating low value and high value primal cuts separately, may be viable.     

Effect of pressure treatments on the mechanical properties of pre- and post-rigor meat

Pressure-heat treatment of beef semitendinosus samples post-rigor gave shear and tensile results similar to those obtained with pressure treatment pre-rigor. Post-rigor pressure-heat treatment did not affect the contraction state, unlike pre-rigor pressure treatment which caused samples to contract by about 40%. Maximum tenderizing effect by pressure-heat treatment (150 M Nm⁻² at 60°C for 30 min) was achieved when samples were heated at 45°C for 45–180 min immediately before application of the treatment. As the pre-pressurization temperature was increased, the duration of heating became more critical until at temperatures ≥ 60°C the effects of subsequent pressure-heat treatment became very small. Pressure-heat treated samples did not show the increase in shear force values for cooking temperatures ≥ 60°C associated with myofibrillar hardening. It was concluded that pressure-heat treatment primarily affected the myofibrillar structure.     

High and low rigor temperature effects on sheep meat tenderness and ageing

Immediately after electrical stimulation, the paired m. longissimus thoracis et lumborum (LT) of 40 sheep were boned out and wrapped tightly with a polyethylene cling film. One of the paired LT's was chilled in 15°C air to reach a rigor mortis (rigor) temperature of 18°C and the other side was placed in a water bath at 35°C and achieved rigor at this temperature. Wrapping reduced rigor shortening and mimicked meat left on the carcass. After rigor, the meat was aged at 15°C for 0, 8, 26 and 72 h and then frozen. The frozen meat was cooked to 75°C in an 85°C water bath and shear force values obtained from a 1×1 cm cross-section. The shear force values of meat for 18 and 35°C rigor were similar at zero ageing, but as ageing progressed, the 18 rigor meat aged faster and became more tender than meat that went into rigor at 35°C (P<0.001). The mean sarcomere length values of meat samples for 18 and 35°C rigor at each ageing time were significantly different (P<0.001), the samples at 35°C being shorter. When the short sarcomere length values and corresponding shear force values were removed for further data analysis, the shear force values for the 35°C rigor were still significantly greater. Thus the toughness of 35°C meat was not a consequence of muscle shortening and appears to be due to both a faster rate of tenderisation and the meat tenderising to a greater extent at the lower temperature. The cook loss at 35°C rigor (30.5%) was greater than that at 18°C rigor (28.4%) (P<0.01) and the colour Hunter L values were higher at 35°C (P<0.01) compared with 18°C, but there were no significant differences in a or b values.     

The influence of cooking rate and holding time on beef chuck and round flavor

Steaks from seven muscles from 10 beef carcasses were cooked quickly or slowly and held 0 or 1 h to explore the influence of cooking rate and holding time on beef flavor. Moisture, ash, pH, and heme–iron concentration were determined for each muscle. Trained sensory panels evaluated the steaks for tenderness, juiciness, connective tissue, and off-flavor intensity in addition to identifying specific off-flavors. Off-flavor intensity was lowest when beef was cooked slowly (on a 149 °C gas grill instead of a 249 °C grill) and when it was held for 1 h prior to sensory evaluation. The M. infraspinatus had the least intense off-flavor and the M. vastus intermedius had the most intense off-flavor. Slow cooking or holding for 1 h prior to consumption reduced the intensity of off-flavor in value cuts from the beef chuck and round while chemical characteristics did not contribute to off-flavor in this study.     

Blast chilling and low voltage electrical stimulation influences on bison (Bison bison bison) meat quality

Conventional carcass chilling is a lengthy and energy expensive process. Blast chilling (BL) can reduce cooling time and associated shrink loss, although its application may compromise meat quality, particularly in lean carcasses or those with localized finish such as bison. Low voltage electrical stimulation (LVES) can reduce the risk of decreased meat quality by inducing rapid rigor onset prior to exposure of the musculature to extreme cold temperature. BL (−20°C, 3 m·s⁻¹ air velocity, 2 h) accelerated temperature decline of bison Longissimus lumborum (LL) and significantly reduced cooler shrink loss versus conventional chilling (CONV: 0–2°C, 24 h). While BL tended to produce darker meat, this effect was tempered by the application of LVES, and samples from the combined treatment were significantly lighter than CONV. BL resulted in reduced tenderness in the LL, as assessed by shear force measurement, in part due to significantly shorter sarcomere length in BL samples. Taste panelists, however, were unable to detect a significant or detrimental BL effect. Where LVES was incorporated, there was an improved tenderness response with ageing. The combined LVES/BL treatment of bison carcasses is recommended for rapid processing without compromising meat quality.     

The effects of spray and blast-chilling on carcass shrinkage and pork muscle quality

Combinations of blast- and spray-chilling of pork carcasses were compared to spray-chilling at conventional chilling temperatures with regard to carcass shrinkage during chilling and pork muscle quality. In experiment 1, pork sides were spray-chilled at 1°C for the first 10 h (40 spray cycles of 60-s duration every 15 min) of cooling or blast-chilled at −20°C for 1, 2 or 3 h followed by spray-chilling for 9, 8 or 7 h duration, respectively. All pork sides were then chilled to 24 h post mortem at 1°C. Experiment 2 followed the same procedures as experiment 1, except that −40°C was used as the blast-chill temperature.

Carcass shrinkage was similar for all treatments in experiment 1 at 24 h ranging from 0·5–0·7 g 100 g⁻¹. Blast/spray-chilling increased the rate of chilling and reduced the rate of post-mortem pH decline in two muscles (longissimus thoracis, LT and semimembranosus, SM) compared to the combined conventional/spray-chill treatment. Carcasses that were blast-chilled for 3 h had LT muscles that were darker with a higher protein solubility, less drip loss, shorter lengths and higher shear values compared to those from carcasses in the conventional/spray-chill treatment. In experiment 2, carcasses blast-chilled for 3 h at −40°C recorded a weight gain at 24 h of 0·4 g 100 g⁻¹, compared to a weight loss in all other treatments (0·2–0·4 g 100 g⁻¹). Muscle colour was darker in both the LT and SM of carcasses blast-chilled for 3 h at −40°C compared to carcasses from the conventional/spray-chill treatment, but most other measurements of muscle quality showed an inconsistent response to chilling treatment.     

Identification of halothane genotypes by calcium accumulation and their meat quality using live pigs

The three halothane genotypes (NN, Nn, and nm) were identified by measuring the capacity for Ca²⁺ accumulation by sarcoplasmic reticulum in whole muscle homogenate preparations of M. longissimus dorsi with a Ca²⁺ specific electrode at 35°C. Significant differences (P < 0·001) in deterioration (%) of Ca²⁺ accumulation, 12% for NN, 35% for Nn, and 81% for nn pigs, were observed after ageing the whole muscle homogenate preparations for 24 h in ice.

Predictions of meat quality in live pigs (n = 34) based on the values for water-holding capacity, assessed as fluid (g/0·5 g wet wt LD), and pH (fluid) by using small biopsy LD samples (Cheah et al. 1993) were performed on all the halothane genotypes. The halothane genotype NN (n = 11) showed a fluid value of 0·37 ± 0·01 and a pH (fluid) value of 6·62 ± 0·03 as compared with 0·61 ± 0·02 and 5·84 ± 0·04, respectively, for the halothane genotype nn (n = 13). The Nn pigs (n = 10) showed fluid (0·49 ± 0·03) and pH (fluid) (6·19 ± 0·11) values between those values observed for the two homozygotes (NN and nn). Predictions of meat quality in live pigs from biopsy LD muscles were confirmed from assessments on post-mortem LD muscles based on pH₁ and fibre optic probe (FOP) measurements.

The extent of deterioration (%) in Ca²⁺ accumulation showed high correlations with fluid (r = −0·861) and pH (fluid) (r = −0·831) in the biopsy LD samples, and with pH₁ (r = 0·663), FOP (r = −0·812), and drip (%) loss (r = −0·777) in the post-mortem LD samples.     

The influence of season on quality characteristics of hot-boned beef m. longissimus thoracis

Samples of m. longissimus thoracis (LT) muscle were randomly collected from 70 Omani beef cattle 1 h after slaughter between August 2001 and July 2002 in the Muscat Municipality central slaughterhouse to investigate the effect of seasonal parameters on meat quality during the hot and cool seasons of Oman. The collection period (12 months) was divided into two seasons according to ambient temperatures and relative humidity and termed: Cool Season (November–March with average temperature of 21.2±1.40 °C and 57.9±1.61% relative humidity) and Hot Season (April–October with average temperature of 34.3±1.67 °C and 48.8±7.57% relative humidity). The season had a significant effect on meat quality characteristics of the LT muscle. Muscles collected during the hot season had significantly (P<0.001) higher ultimate pH values (6.24) with significantly (P<0.001) lower Warner–Bratzler (WB) shear force values (10.12) than those collected during the cool season (5.54 and 15.58). In these hot-boned samples, there was a linear relationship between ultimate pH and WB shear values. Cooking loss was significantly (P<0.001) higher for cool season samples (26.01%) than from hot season samples (19.75%). Beef from the hot season group had significantly (P<0.001) darker meat than that of the cold season group, based on L* (31.45 vs 35.58), a* (18.53 vs 23.19) and b* (4.16 vs 6.40) colour measurements. There was a linear relationship between ultimate pH and cooking loss, L*, a* and b*. These results indicated that heat stress (>30 °C) lead to physiological stress in beef cattle, which in turn increased muscle ultimate pH and influenced related meat quality characteristics.     

Effects of electrical stimulation and ageing of beef on the gelation properties and protein extractability of isolated myofibrils

The gelation properties of bovine myofibrils, as evaluated by dynamic rheological measurements, were shown to be very sensitive to the variables investigated: stimulation and/or ageing of the meat used, presence of 5 mM pyrophosphate and 5 mM MgCl₂ (PP) and concentration of NaCl (0·3 or 0·M). Statistical evaluation of final gel storage moduli (determined at 70°C) revealed ageing to have a consistent detrimental effect. Fresh, stimulated processing of meat), gave gels of about 40% lower elasticity (storage modulus) than did non-stimulated myofibrils; when PP was included in the gel-forming mixture no effect from electrical stimulation was seen. In spite of the negative effects observed for gel elasticity, the myofibrils in question displayed enhanced protein extractability prior to heating. Electrophoretic results suggest myosin degradation to be partly responsible.