In‐field assessment of display resolution and noise: Performance evaluation of a commercial measurement system

Abstract— Two key metrics of image quality for high‐fidelity displays, including medical displays, are resolution and noise. Until now, these properties have been primarily measured in laboratory settings. For the first time, a system consisting of a CCD camera and analysis software has been made commercially available for measuring the resolution and noise of medical displays in a clinical setting. This study aimed at evaluating this new product in terms of accuracy and precision. In particular, the project involved the measurement of the modulation transfer function (MTF) and the signal‐to‐noise ratio (SNR) of two medical imaging displays, one cathode‐ray tube (CRT) display and one liquid‐crystal display (LCD) using this camera/software system. To assess the system's precision, measurements were made multiple times at the same setting. To check for accuracy, the results were compared with published values of the MTF and noise for the same displays. The performance of the system was also ascertained as a function of the focus setting of the camera. The results indicated that for the LCD, when the camera is focused within ±0.6 mm of the optimum focus setting, the MTF values lie within approximately 14% of the best focus MTF at the Nyquist frequency and 11% of the optimum overall sharpness (∫ MTF² df). Similar results were obtained in the horizontal and vertical directions. For the CRT, this focus produced vertical and horizontal MTF values at the Nyquist frequency within 15.2% and 61.2% of the optimum focus MTF, respectively. The figures in terms of overall sharpness were 3.0% and 0.7%. The results for the noise measurements showed a repeatability of 3% for the LCD and 13% for the CRT and a relative (but not absolute) magnitude of the noise between the two displays reflective of prior measurements. Overall, the measurement system yielded reasonably precise resolution and noise results for both display devices. The accuracy was traceable to published results only for the MTF and for relative level of display noise with differences in the absolute magnitude of noise between current and prior measurements attributed to variations in the non‐standard techniques applied for display noise measurements.     

A photographic technique for assessing the viewing‐angle performance of liquid‐crystal displays

Abstract— Liquid‐crystal displays (LCDs) have notable variation in luminance and perceived contrast as a function of the angle from which they are viewed. Though this is an important performance issue for LCDs, most evaluation techniques for assessing this variation have been limited to laboratory settings. This study demonstrates the use of a photographic technique for such an evaluation. The technique is based on an actively cooled charge‐coupled‐device (CCD) detector in combination with a macro lens covering a circular angular range (θ) of ±42.5°. The camera was used to evaluate the luminance and perceived contrast properties of an LCD. Uniform field images corresponding to 17 equally spaced gray‐scale values in the digital driving level (DDL) range of the display system were acquired. The 12‐bit gray‐scale digital images produced by the camera were converted to luminance units (cd/m²) via the measured luminance vs. DDL response function of the camera. The changes in perceived contrast as a function of viewing angle were derived from the Barten model of the gray‐scale response of the human‐visual system using the methods proposed by the AAPM TG18 Report. The results of this photographic technique were compared to measurements acquired from a similar display using a Fourier‐optics‐based luminance meter. The results of the two methods generally agreed to within 5%. The photographic methods used were found to be accurate and robust for in‐field assessment of the angular response of LCDs over the FOV of the camera.     

MTF measurement method for medical displays by using a bar‐pattern image

Abstract— A modulation‐transfer‐function (MTF) measurement method that uses a bar‐pattern image for medical displays such as liquid‐crystal displays (LCDs) and cathode‐ray tubes (CRTs) has been investigated. A specific bar‐pattern image on the display was acquired with a high‐resolution single‐lens reflex‐type digital camera equipped with a close‐up lens. The MTF was calculated from the amplitudes of the fundamental‐frequency components, which were extracted from the profile data across the bar patterns by using Fourier analysis. Actual comparisons with the conventional line technique were performed for a medical CRT. The adequate accuracy and excellent reproducibility of the method were confirmed. Furthermore, unlike the line method, an advantageous feature which can use an input signal with sufficient amplitude was theoretically proved. Horizontal and vertical MTFs at the central position of the display area were measured up to the Nyquist frequency for several medical displays. From these measurements, this method has the capability to detect slight differences between the displays measured. This proposed method is useful in understanding and quantifying the medical display's performance due to excellent reproducibility and accuracy.     

Noise estimation and reduction on five medical liquid‐crystal displays

Abstract— Liquid‐crystal displays (LCDs) are replacing cathode‐ray tube (CRT) displays as primary diagnostic viewing devices in clinics. They exhibit higher spatial noise than CRTs, which can interfere with diagnosis and reduce the efficiency especially when subtle abnormalities are presented. A study by the authors on LCD spatial noise has recently been reported. A high‐quality CCD camera was used to acquire images from the LCD. Noise properties were estimated from the digital‐camera images. Then, an error‐diffusion‐based operation was applied to reduce the display spatial noise. This paper presents the noise estimation and reduction results on five different medical‐grade LCDs using the same study protocol. These five different LCDs vary in terms of matrix size, pixel size, pixel structure, and vendors. The purpose of this work is to demonstrate that the LCD spatial‐noise estimation and reduction scheme proposed earlier by the authors is valid, robust, and necessary for various medicalgrade LCDs used in clinics today.     

Angular dependence of the performance of stereoscopic liquid‐crystal‐display (LCD) television using shutter glasses (SG)

Abstract— 3‐D cross‐talk typically represents the ratio of image overlap between the left and right views. For stereoscopic LCDs using shutter‐glasses technology, 3‐D cross‐talk for stereoscopic LCD TV with a diagonal size of 46 in. and vertical alignment (VA) mode was measured to change from 1% to 10% when the stereoscopic display is rotated around the vertical axis. Input signals consist of the left and right images that include patterns of different amounts of binocular disparity and various gray levels. Ghost‐like artifacts are observed. Furthermore, intensities of these artifacts are observed to change as the stereoscopic display is rotated about the vertical axis. The temporal luminance of the LCD used in stereoscopic TV was found to be dependent on the viewing direction and can be considered as one cause of the phenomenon of angular dependence of performance for stereoscopic displays.     

Development of “Advanced TFT‐LCD” with good legibility under any ambient light intensity

A new LCD referred to as an “Advanced TFT‐LCD” has been developed. It consists of both transmissive and reflective electrodes in every pixel. Its subjective legibility and characteristics, such as contrast ratio, color gamut, and luminance, have been investigated at several ambient illumination intensities. As a result, it was confirmed that Advanced TFT‐LCDs offer better legibility than transmissive LCDs under any ambient illumination intensity.     

Current status and future prospect of in‐cell‐polarizer technology

Abstract— A thin‐crystalline‐film (TCF) polarizer has been developed which can be used internally in liquid‐crystal‐display cells. Based on this material, a manufacturing process has been developed for the fabrication of monochrome LCDs with internal polarizers. A new TCF polarizer material and coating equipment, developed to realize a high‐performance color TFT‐LCD, are discussed.     

Reflective full‐color LCD using low‐temperature polysilicon TFTs in low‐frequency driving: Analysis of image persistence and flicker with scientific CMOS camera

Image persistence and flicker are major issues for low‐frequency driving of LCDs. Detailed investigation of the mechanisms that produce these phenomena, using image analysis with a scientific CMOS camera, enabled us to reduce it to acceptable levels. We successfully developed a 7.0‐in. WUXGA (1200 × RGBW × 1920) reflective color LCD driven by low‐temperature polysilicon TFTs at 1 Hz.     

Performance of liquid‐crystal displays for fire‐service thermal‐imaging cameras

Abstract— As use of handheld thermal‐imaging cameras (TICs) becomes more prevalent in the first‐responder community, it is important that standard test metrics be available to characterize imaging performance. A key performance consideration is the quality of the image presented on the TIC display. This paper focuses on TICs that use liquid‐crystal displays to render an image for the user. Current research on TIC performance for first‐responder applications makes use of trained observers and/or composite‐video‐output‐signal measurements. Trained observer tests are subjective and composite video output tests do not evaluate the performance of the complete imaging system. A non‐destructive objective method was developed that tests the performance of the entire thermal‐imaging system, from the infrared sensor to the display. A thermal target was used to correlate the measured thermal imager composite video output signal with the luminance of the display. A well‐characterized charge‐coupled‐device (CCD) camera and digital recording device were used to measure the display luminance. An electro‐optical transfer function was determined that directly relates the composite video output signal to the luminance of the display, providing a realistic characterization of system performance.     

OLED‐based pico‐projection system

Abstract— Two pico‐projection systems, a monochrome green and a full‐color system, based on high‐efficiency OLED microdisplays (VGA; pixel size, 12 μm) are presented. Both optical systems are described by a numerical aperture of about 0.3, a magnification of 15x, and a working distance of 300–360 mm. The frequency limit of both systems is 42 cycles/mm at an image contrast of about 60%. The monochrome projection system with a volume smaller than 10 cm³ consists of one green OLED and a projection lens with five elements. The measured luminance in the image plane is about 0.061 lm. The image has a diagonal of 150 mm with a working distance of about 300 mm and has a considerable image contrast of 396:1. The second system combines three high‐brightness OLEDs, red, green, and blue colored, together with a projection lens and an image‐combining element, and an X‐Cube to achieve full‐color projection. The estimated luminance value for the three‐panel projection unit with an OLED luminance of 10,000 cd/m² for each display will be about Φcalculated = 0.147 lm. In this paper, the system concepts, the optical designs, and the realized prototypes of the monochrome and full‐color projection system are presented.     

Switching directional BLUs for full‐resolution auto‐stereoscopic 3D/2D and 2D/3D LCDs

Directional backlight unit (BLU) design concept was applied to realize full‐resolution field alternate auto‐stereoscopic liquid crystal displays (LCDs) with built‐in 3D/2D and 2D/3D. The application‐oriented BLU design requires priority in realizing 2D mode or 3D mode. The switching characteristic of BLU with two confronting illuminating sets was applied to build 2D mode into 3D display and 3D mode into 2D display. An LCD with 2D mode as primary function requires higher double‐sided luminance uniformity than 3D mode. On the other hand, an LCD with 3D mode requires higher single‐sided luminance uniformity than 2D mode. For increasing the double‐sided luminance uniformity for 2D mode as a primary function of the display, the former BLU design was realized by using uniform prismatic structure, that is, using uniform bilateral prismatic structure with a cross section of isosceles triangle on the back surface of the light‐guide plate. For increasing single‐sided luminance uniformity for 3D mode as a primary function of the display, the latter was realized by using graded angle design, that is, unilateral prisms with a cross section of a scalene triangle on the back surface of the light‐guide plate. The LCDs of small‐sized‐handheld game devices and still cameras were fabricated using the 3D/2D and 2D/3D displays.     

How to reduce light leakage and clipping in local‐dimming liquid‐crystal displays

Abstract— In conventional LCDs, the backlight is set to maximum luminance regardless of the image. For dark scenes, this approach causes light leakage and power waste. Especially, light leakage in dark scenes degrades the contrast ratio of LCDs; to circumvent this problem, local‐dimming systems have been proposed. In these systems, the LED backlight is divided into several local blocks and the backlight luminance of each local block is controlled individually, and pixel values are adjusted simultaneously according to the luminance profile of the dimmed backlight. In this paper, a method of determining the LED backlight luminance of each local block depending on the image is proposed; this method significantly improves the image quality of LCDs. First, we introduce methods of quantifying light‐leakage at dark gray levels and clipping at bright gray levels. Then, the proposed method to determine the dimming duty, which controls the LED backlight luminance by compromising between these two measures, was derived. The proposed algorithm preserves the original image with little clipping distortion and effectively reduces light leakage.     

LCDs for TV applications

Abstract— Super IPS (S‐IPS) technology has intrinsic advantages in several aspects required for TV applications. Particularly, the wide‐viewing‐angle property and fast gray‐to‐gray response time of S‐IPS LCDs are both necessary requirements for family and individual use for LCD TVs. Given these benefits and other advantages S‐IPS provides, LG.Philips LCD has developed high‐performance S‐IPS LCDs for TV, which have now become competitive with plasma‐display panels (PDPs), in addition to other modes of LCD TVs as well as CRTs. This article will discuss why S‐IPS technology is the leading choice for LCD‐TV applications.     

A novel quarter‐wave retardation film for improving viewing angle properties in time‐sequential stereoscopic 3D‐LCDs

We have successfully developed a quarter‐wave retardation film (QWF) for wide viewing angle 3D liquid crystal displays (3D‐LCDs) that provides high luminance, low crosstalk, low color change, and low head‐tilt‐angle dependency. It was found that the out‐of‐plane retardation (Rth) of the QWF in the LCD needs to be close to 0 nm in order to improve the 3D display properties at an off‐axis position and that the in‐plane retardation (Re) needs to be adjusted from 120 to 130 nm to achieve low color change with head tilting. We adopted a coating process for making our QWF because of its potential for retardation control. 3D‐LCDs with this QWF whose Rth was nearly zero had high performance and allowed off‐axis other than on‐axis.     

Competing display technologies for the best image performance

Abstract— Cathode‐ray tubes (CRTs) have been the dominant display technology for years, having the best image performance and low cost. During the last several years, flat‐panel‐display technologies, such as liquid‐crystal displays (LCDs), began to replace the CRT mainly because of its favorable form factor. Today, the image performance of LCDs are equal to that of a CRT, and attractive flat‐display products have become so affordable that they have replaced the CRT from its dominating market position and have obtained the largest market share. In the past, the CRT set the standards for digital imaging technologies, but today, modern image capturing, storage, transport, signal processing, and printing technologies have improved to such high levels that they demand better display technologies and standards. At present, the LCD is at the forefront of this display‐technology evolution. This paper will focus on the latest image‐quality improvements in LCD technology and briefly touch alternatives such as plasma‐display panels (PDP) and microdisplay projection. Special attention will be given to the latest developments in wide‐color‐gamut technologies and methods to reproduce accurate colors within a display device.     

Line‐time optimization technology for ultra‐large and high‐resolution liquid crystal displays

This paper proposes a line‐time optimization (LTO) technology for ultra‐large and high‐resolution liquid crystal display (LCD) televisions. Line‐time optimization enables a single‐bank data driver configuration without severe image degradation. When the proposed method is applied to an ultra‐high‐definition (UHD) LCD with a single‐bank data driver scheme, the LCD performance comparable to that of a dual‐bank data driver method can be obtained. The implementation of the proposed method helps in achieving desirable goals such as a reduction in the number of drivers and realization of a much more flexible design of UHD LCDs.     

A field‐sequential‐color display with a local‐primary‐desaturation backlight scheme

Abstract— Field‐sequential‐color technology eliminates the need for color filters in liquid‐crystal displays (LCDs) and results in significant power savings and higher resolution. But the LCD suffers from color breakup, which degrades image quality and limits practical applications. By controlling the backlight temporally and spatially, a so‐called local‐primary‐desaturation (LPD) backlight scheme was developed and implemented in a 180‐Hz optically compensated bend (OCB) mode LCD equipped with a backlight consisting of a matrix of light‐emitting diodes (LEDs). It restores image quality by suppressing color breakup and saves power because it has no color filter and uses local dimming. A perceptual experiment was implemented for verification, and the results showed that a field‐sequential‐color display with a local‐primary‐desaturation backlight reduced the color breakup from very annoying to not annoying and even invisible.     

Novel mobile TFT‐LCDs based on SLS technology

Abstract— Single‐crystal‐like silicon (SLS) technology is the most cost‐effective laser‐crystallization process ever invented. The throughput of the SLS process is about two times higher than that of the conventional excimer‐laser annealing (ELA) method. In addition, the performance of the TFTs fabricated by the SLS process is among the best utilized in mass production. Various TFT‐LCDs employing SLS technology, which included a 1.02‐in. full SOG LCD using an icon display for the sub‐display of cellular phones, a 1.9‐in. qVGA TFT‐LCD with a low‐power analog interface employing a low‐voltage driving scheme, and a 3.0‐in. VGA TFT‐LCD compatible with the 480i data format without additional signal processing were developed. Because the SLS process enables us to achieve highly uniform and reliable transistors, it can be effectively utilized in the mass production of mobile TFT‐LCDs with low power consumption and enhanced image quality.     

Energy‐efficient liquid‐crystal displays (e2‐LCDs) using a photonic‐crystal backlight system

Abstract— Cholesteric liquid crystals automatically form one‐dimensional photonic crystals. For a photonic crystal in which light‐emitting moieties are embedded, unique properties such as microcavity effects and simultaneous light emission and light reflection can be expected. Three primary‐color photonic‐crystal films were prepared based on cholesteric liquid crystal in which fluorescent dye is incorporated. Microcavity effects, i.e., emission enhancement and spectrum narrowing, were observed. Two types of demonstration liquid‐crystal displays (LCDs) were fabricated using the prepared photonic‐crystal films in a backlight system. One is an area‐color LCD in which a single photonic‐crystal layer is used for each color pixel and the other is a full‐color TFT‐LCD in which three stacked photonic‐crystal layers are used as light‐conversion layers. The area‐color LCD was excited by using 365‐nm UV light, and the full‐color TFT‐LCD was excited by using 470‐nm blue LED light. Because of the photonic crystal's unique features that allow it to work as light‐emitting and light‐reflecting layers simultaneously, both LCDs demonstrate clear readable images even under strong ambient light, such as direct‐sunlight conditions, under which conventional displays including LCDs and OLED displays cannot demonstrate clear images. In particular, an area‐color LCD, which eliminated color filters, gives clear images under bright ambient light conditions even without backlight illumination. This fact suggests that a backlight system using novel photonic‐crystal layers will be suitable for energy‐efficient LCDs (e²‐LCDs), especially for displays designed for outdoor usage.     

LTPS circuit integration for system‐on‐glass LCDs

Abstract— A 3.5‐in. QVGA‐formatted driving‐circuit fully integrated LCD has been developed using low‐temperature poly‐Si (LTPS) technology. This display module, in which no external ICs are required, integrates all the driving circuits for a six‐bit RGB digital interface with an LTPS device called a “FASt LDD TFT” and achieves a high‐quality image, narrow frame width, and low power consumption. The LTPS process, device, and circuit technologies developed for system‐on‐glass LCD discussed. The development phase of LTPS circuit integration for system‐on‐glass LCDs is also reviewed.