Reliable computation of PID gain space for general second-order time-delay systems

This paper addresses the problem of determining the stability gain space of a PID controller for general second-order time-delay systems. First, a review of existing results and the associated drawbacks is presented. Subsequently, a new algorithm to compute the entire PID stability gain space is developed. The new algorithm is based upon existing results on the relationship between the stability of a quasi-polynomial and its derivatives, an extended version of the Hermit–Biehler theorem, and also the Nyquist criterion. The algorithm entails extraction of an admissible range for the PID parameter K_p, and then based on this range, a stability region in the (K_i ? K_d) plane is computed. Well-known examples are studied to demonstrate the reliability and accuracy of the results.     

Computation of stabilizing PI-PD controllers

The PI-PD controller structure provides an excellent four-parameter controller for control of integrating, unstable and resonant processes to set point changes while the conventional PID controller has limitations in controlling such systems. In this paper, a graphical method for the computation of all stabilizing PI-PD controllers is given. The proposed method is based on plotting the stability boundary locus, which is a locus dependent on the parameters of the controller and frequency, in the parameter plane. The stability boundary loci are first obtained in the (K _d , K _f ) and (K _p , K _i ) planes and then it is shown that all the stabilizing values of the parameters of a PI-PD controller can be found. Computation of stabilizing PI-PD controllers which achieve user specified gain and phase margins is also studied. The method is used to design robust PI-PD controllers for control systems with parametric uncertainties. A design procedure for interval control systems is proposed. Examples are given to show the benefit of the method presented. Recommended by Editorial Board member Jietae Lee under the direction of Editor Young Il Lee. Nusret Tan was born in Malatya, Turkey, in 1971. He received his B.Sc. degree in Electrical and Electronics Engineering from Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey, in 1994. He received the Ph.D. degree in Control Engineering from University of Sussex, Brighton, U.K., in 2000. He is currently working as an Associate Professor in the Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering at Inonu University, Malatya, Turkey. His primary research interest lies in the area of systems and control.     

Robust FOPID controller design for fractional‐order delay systems using positive stability region analysis

In this paper, a robust fractional‐order PID (FOPID) controller design method for fractional‐order delay systems is proposed based on positive stability region (PSR) analysis. Firstly, the PSR is presented to improve the existing stability region (SR) in D‐decomposition method. Then, the optimal fractional orders λ and μ of FOPID controller are achieved at the biggest three‐dimensional PSR, which means the best robustness. Given the optimal λ and μ, the other FOPID controller parameters k_p, k_i, k_d can be solved under the control specifications, including gain crossover frequency, phase margin, and an extended flat phase constraint. In addition, the steps of the proposed robust FOPID controller design process are listed at length, and an example is given to illustrate the corresponding steps. At last, the control performances of the obtained robust FOPID controller are compared with some other controllers (PID and FOPI). The simulation results illustrate the superior robustness as well as the transient performance of the proposed control algorithm.     

Domains of PID controller coefficients which guarantee stability and performance for LTI time-delay systems

In this work, the computation of the regions in the space of coefficients of a PID controller, inside which the controller stabilizes an LTI time-delay plant and guarantees a performance specification for the closed-loop system, is addressed. To ascertain the sensor noise attenuation, as a sample performance requirement, the H_∞-norm of the weighted complementary sensitivity function is kept below a desired bound. The problem of minimization of the H_∞-norm is transformed into the simultaneous stabilization of a family of quasipolynomials. Then, the stable domains of the PID coefficients are computed for these quasipolynomials using the parameter space approach. This work extends the previous results on the computation of the stability domains of a PID controller to ensure the desired performance specification for the closed-loop system.     

Non-fragile multivariable PID controller design via system augmentation

In this paper, the issue of designing non-fragile H_∞ multivariable proportional-integral-derivative (PID) controllers with derivative filters is investigated. In order to obtain the controller gains, the original system is associated with an extended system such that the PID controller design can be formulated as a static output-feedback control problem. By taking the system augmentation approach, the conditions with slack matrices for solving the non-fragile H_∞ multivariable PID controller gains are established. Based on the results, linear matrix inequality -based iterative algorithms are provided to compute the controller gains. Simulations are conducted to verify the effectiveness of the proposed approaches.     

时滞系统分数阶PI?? 极点配置控制器设计

利用参数空间法研究用PIλ控制器实现时滞系统的闭环极点配置问题。复平面上的阻尼角扇形区域和相对稳定度区域(该两区域构成一个梯形区域)被映射到控制器参数平面,相应的控制器参数可以将闭环极点配置在梯形区域内,从而保证所要求的系统性能。仿真结果显示,对于适当选取的分数阶PIλ控制器的参数,采用分数阶控制器可以取得比整数阶控制器更好的控制效果,从极点配置的角度揭示了分数阶控制器的优越性。     

Plasma multivariable robust control system design and simulation for a thermonuclear tokamak-reactor

The paper reports results on the design and analysis of the multivariable feedback H_infin; robust system for plasma current, position and shape control in the fusion energy advanced tokamak (FEAT) developed in the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) project. The system contains the fast loop with the SISO plasma vertical speed robust controller and the slow loop with the MIMO plasma current and shape robust controller. The goal is to study the resources of the system robustness to achieve a higher degree of the FEAT operation reliability. Two H_infin; block diagonal controllers {K _SISO, K _MIMO} were designed by a mixed sensitivity approach in the framework of the disturbance rejection configuration. These controllers were compared with block diagonal decoupling, PI and LQG controllers at the set of FEAT key scenario points according to the multiple-criterion: nominal performance at minor disruptions, robust stability and robust performance. The H_infin; controllers showed larger multivariable stability margin and better nominal performance.     

Low‐order H∞ controller design on the frequency domain by partial optimization

In this paper, an optimization method of low‐order multivariable controllers for H_∞ control is proposed. Starting from a low‐order stabilizing controller, our method gives a sequence of controllers for which the H_∞ norm performance index is monotonically non‐increasing by tuning the numerator coefficient matrices of the low‐order controller. This controller class includes multivariable PID controllers. The proposed method is a descent method where the feasible direction is calculated by solving a linear matrix inequality that represents a sufficient condition for the H_∞ criterion for each frequency. Usefulness is shown by two numerical examples. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Restricted Structure Control Loop Performance Assessment For Pid Controllers And State‐Space Systems

A novel H₂ optimal control performance assessment and benchmarking problem is considered for discrete‐time state‐space multivariable systems, where the structure of the controller is assumed to be fixed apriori. The controller structure may be specified to be of PID, reduced order, or lead/lag forms. The theoretical problem considered is to represent the state‐space model in discrete polynomial matrix form and to then obtain the causal, stabilising, controller, of a prespecified form, that minimises an H₂ criterion. This then provides the performance measure against which other controllers can be judged. The underlying practical problem of importance is to obtain a simple method of performance assessment and benchmarking low order controllers. The main theoretical step is to derive a simpler cost‐minimization problem whose solution can provide both the full order and restricted structure (PID) optimal benchmark cost values. This problem involves the introduction of spectral factor and diophantine equations and is solved via a Wiener type of cost‐function expansion and simplification. The numerical solution of this problem is straightforward and involves approximating the simplified integral criterion by a fixed number of frequency points. The main benchmarking theorem applies to multivariable systems that may be unstable, non‐minimum phase and non‐square.     

A Simultaneous Mixed LQR/H∞ Control Approach to the Design of Reliable Active Suspension Controllers

This paper is concerned with the synthesis of reliable controllers for quarter‐car active suspension systems. By a simultaneous mixed LQR/H_∞ control approach, a static output feedback controller is derived for guaranteeing good suspension performance under possible sensor fault or suspension component breakdown. The considered simultaneous mixed LQR/H_∞ control problem is a nonconvex optimization problem; therefore, the linear matrix inequality approach is not applicable. Based on the barrier method, we solve an auxiliary minimization problem to get an approximate solution for the simultaneous mixed LQR/H_∞ control problem. Necessary conditions for the local optimum of the auxiliary minimization problem are derived. Moreover, a three‐stage solution algorithm is developed for solving the auxiliary minimization problem. The simulation shows that the obtained static output feedback suspension controllers can improve suspension performance in nominal mode and all considered failure modes.     

Non‐smooth structured control design with application to PID loop‐shaping of a process

Feedback controllers with specific structure arise frequently in applications because they are easily apprehended by design engineers and facilitate on‐board implementations and re‐tuning. This work is dedicated to H_∞ synthesis with structured controllers. In this context, straightforward application of traditional synthesis techniques fails, which explains why only a few ad hoc methods have been developed over the years. In response, we propose a more systematic way to design H_∞ optimal controllers with fixed structure using local optimization techniques. Our approach addresses in principle all those controller structures which can be built into mathematical programming constraints. We apply non‐smooth optimization techniques to compute locally optimal solutions, and provide practical tests for descent and optimality. In the experimental part we apply our technique to H_∞ loop‐shaping proportional integral derivative (PID) controllers for MIMO systems and demonstrate its use for PID control of a chemical process. Copyright © 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Application of flower pollination algorithm in load frequency control of multi-area interconnected power system with nonlinearity

This work presents an application of bio-inspired flower pollination algorithm (FPA) for tuning proportional–integral–derivative (PID) controller in load frequency control (LFC) of multi-area interconnected power system. The investigated power system comprises of three equal thermal power systems with appropriate PID controller. The controller gain [proportional gain (K _p), integral gain (K _i) and derivative gain (K _d)] values are tuned by using the FPA algorithm with one percent step load perturbation in area 1 (1 % SLP). The integral square error (ISE) is considered the objective function for the FPA. The supremacy performance of proposed algorithm for optimized PID controller is proved by comparing the results with genetic algorithm (GA) and particle swarm optimization (PSO)-based PID controller under the same investigated power system. In addition, the controller robustness is studied by considering appropriate generate rate constraint with nonlinearity in all areas. The result cumulative performance comparisons established that FPA-PID controller exhibit better performance compared to performances of GA-PID and PSO-PID controller-based power system with and without nonlinearity effect.

     

Robustness improvement of a nonlinear H∞ controller for robot manipulators via saturation functions

In this paper, previous works on nonlinear H_∞ control for robot manipulators are extended. In particular, integral terms are considered to cope with persistent disturbances, such as constant load at the end‐effector. The extended controller may be understood as a computed‐torque control with an external PID, whose gain matrices vary with the position and velocity of the robot joints. In addition, in order to increase the controller robustness, an extension of the algorithms with saturation functions has been carried out. This extension deals with the resulting nonlinear equation of the closed‐loop error. A modified expression for the required increment in the control signal is provided, and the local closed‐loop stability of this approach is discussed. Finally, simulation results for a two‐link robot and experimental results for an industrial robot are presented. The results obtained with this technique have been compared with those attained with the original controllers to show the improvements achieved by means of the proposed method. © 2005 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Robust ℋ︁∞ PID control for multivariable networked control systems with disturbance/noise attenuation

In this paper, we study the design problem of PID controllers for networked control systems (NCSs) with polyhedral uncertainties. The load disturbance and measurement noise are both taken into account in the modeling to better reflect the practical scenario. By using a novel technique, the design problem of PID controllers is converted into a design problem of output feedback controllers. Our goal of this paper is two‐fold: (1) To design the robust PID tracking controllers for practical models; (2) To develop the robust ??_∞ PID control such that load and reference disturbances can be attenuated with a prescribed level. Sufficient conditions are derived by employing advanced techniques for achieving delay dependence. The proposed controller can be readily designed based on iterative suboptimal algorithms. Finally, four examples are presented to show the effectiveness of the proposed methods. Copyright © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Stability domains of the delay and PID coefficients for general time-delay systems

Time delays are encountered in many physical systems, and they usually threaten the stability and performance of closed-loop systems. The problem of determining all stabilising proportional-integral-derivative (PID) controllers for systems with perturbed delays is less investigated in the literature. In this study, the Rekasius substitution is employed to transform the system parameters to a new space. Then, the singular frequency (SF) method is revised for the Rekasius transformed system. A novel technique is presented to compute the ranges of time delay for which stable PID controller exists. This stability range cannot be readily computed from the previous methods. Finally, it is shown that similar to the original SF method, finite numbers of singular frequencies are sufficient to compute the stable regions in the space of time delay and controller coefficients.     

Decentralised H ∞ control for singular systems

In this article, considering the design problem of decentralised H _∞ controller of singular systems, the two cases of controllers via measurement feedback are designed: one is precise controller, and the other is additive controller gain variation. The design procedures of the two cases of controllers are presented in terms of the solutions to generalised algebraic Riccati inequalities. The designed controllers in each case guarantee that closed-loop singular systems are admissible and with H _∞-norm bound on disturbance attenuation. Finally, a numerical example to demonstrate the validity of the proposed approach is given.     

Stabilization of control loops consisting of FOPDT process and parameter-dependent PID controller

In this paper, problem of stability analysis of the control loops consisting of first-order plus dead time (FOPDT) processes and proportional-integrative-derivative (PID) controllers is studied, where the controller coefficients are functions of one or more independent parameters. An effective procedure is presented to determine a stability region in the independent parameters space. This method does not require complex numerical calculations such as solving nonlinear equations. It is based on usage of a two-valued indicator function and by using that, a stability region is easily determined. In order to clarify that, why the stability region needs to be specified in the “independent parameters space” an optimal method is given to design the PID controller for the FOPDT processes, as an instance. In this optimal method the controller coefficients are obtained as the functions of a free parameter, where this parameter needs to be chosen by the designer such that it should be near to the maximum operating frequency of the system, besides on the other hand the closed-loop system to be stable. In the end, two illustrative examples are given in order to show the usefulness and effectiveness of the proposed method, and to compare the obtained stability regions with the whole stability regions.     

An approach for the robustness comparison between piecewise linear PID -like fuzzy and classical PID controllers

The comparison of the stability robustness between the classical PID controller and two piecewise linear PID-like fuzzy controllers to the variations of the parameters in the second order plant is provided in this paper. The definition of a stability robust controller (to the parameter variations of the plant model) is presented. Then Kharitonov’s theorem is applied to find the regions of robustness to the parameter variations for the control systems with different controllers. Based on the size of regions of robustness, the relative robustness factor is defined, and the robustness comparison is provided. For every classical PID controller with gain coefficients determined and fixed, it is shown that we can always design the piecewise linear PID-like fuzzy controllers to be more robust than the specific classical PID controller. The results of robustness comparison is further confirmed in the simulation included for the second order uncertain plant.     

PD–PID controller for delayed systems with two unstable poles: a frequency domain approach

This paper deals with the stability problem of linear delayed systems containing two unstable real poles by means of PD controllers. The analysis presented is based on frequency domain techniques. Necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of stabilising controllers are given in terms of the parameters of the system and the time delay size. The main result is extended to delayed systems with two unstable poles and n stable real poles. PID controllers are also considered in order to control the studied systems, obtaining similar stability conditions. Numerical examples are presented in order to illustrate the control performance.