Mutational analysis of DNase I-DNA interactions: design, expression and characterization of a DNase I loop insertion mutant with altered sequence selectivity

A mutant of bovine pancreatic DNase I containing two additionalresidues in a loop next to C173 has been expressed in Escherichiacoli, purified and characterized biochemically. Modelling studiessuggest that the inserted arginine and glutamate side chainsof the modified loop sequence C173-R-E-G-T-V176 could contactthe bases 3' to the cleaved bond in the major groove of a boundDNA, and that up to 10 bp could interact with the enzyme andpotentially influence its cutting rate. The loop insertion mutanthas an 800-fold lower specific activity than wild-type and showsoverall cleavage characteristics similar to bovine pancreaticDNase I. Compared with the wild-type enzyme, the mutant showsa strongly enhanced preference for cutting the inverted repeat:5'-GACTT A AAGTC-3' CTGAA T TTCAG or close variants thereof.Unexpectedly for a minor groove binding protein, the preferredcutting sites in opposite strands are staggered by 1 bp in the5' direction, causing the cleavage of a TA and a TT step, respectively.This finding demonstrates that the sequence context is relativelymore important for the cutting frequency than the nature ofthe dinucleotide step of the cleaved bond, and clearly showsthat base recognition is involved in determining the sequenceselectivity of the mutant. The importance of the sequence 5'to the cleaved bond for the cutting rate suggests that the additionalmajor groove contacts may require a distortion of the DNA associatedwith a higher energy barrier, resulting in an increased selectivityfor flexible DNA sequences and a lower overall activity of themutant enzyme.     

Analysis of several key active site residues of ricin A chain by mutagenesis and X-ray crystallography

Active she residues of ricin A chain were analyzed by sitedirectedmutagenesis and X-ray diffraction to help assess their rolesin the mechanism of action of this toxic N-glycosidase enzyme.Argl80 is thought, from X-ray studies, to protonate the adeninesubstrate at N3; this facilitates bond cleavage and is crucialto the mechanisms of action. The residue was converted to Glnand initial rate data measured. Km for the mutant is not significantlyaffected, increasing only 2-fold. The K_cat, however, is decreased 1000-fold. This is consistent with a simple interpretationthat Argl80 is involved more in transition state stabilizationthan in substrate binding. Tyrosines 80 and 123 are known fromX-ray models to stack on either side of the substrate adeninering. When they were each converted to serine overall activitywas reduced 160- and 70-fold respectively against ribosomesfrom Artemia salina. These effects are each 10 times greaterthan when the residues were previously converted to phenylalanines.Sufficient protein for the Tyr80 to Phe mutant was obtainedto carry out an X-ray analysis. Together with mutagenesis data,the structure suggests that the invariance of the two activesite Tyr residues is largely caused by structural stability.     

Site-directed mutagenesis and X-ray crystallography of two phospholipase A2 mutants: Y52F and Y73F

Tyr52 and Tyr73 are conserved amino acid residues throughoutall vertebrate phospholipases A₂. They are part of an extendedhydrogen bonding system that links the N-terminal -NH⁺₃ -groupto the catalytic residues His48 and Asp99. These tyrosines werereplaced by phenylalanines in a porcine pancreatic phospholipaseA₂ mutant, in which residues 62–66 had been deleted (62–66PLA₂).The mutations did not affect the catalytic properties of theenzyme, nor the folding kinetics. The stability against denaturatlonby guanidine hydrochloride was decreased, however. To analysehow the enzyme compensates for the loss of the tyrosine hydroxylgroup, the X-ray structures of the Y52F and AY73F mutants weredetermined. After crystallographic refinement the final crystallographicR-factors were 18.1% for the %Y52F mutant (data between 7 and2.3 Å resolution) and 19.1% for the Y73F mutant (databetween 7 and 2.4 Å resolution). No conformational changesoccurred in the mutants compared with the 62–66PLA₂, butan empty cavity formed at the site of the hydroxyl group ofthe former tyrosine. In both mutants the Asp99 side chain losesone of its hydrogen bonds and this might explain the observeddestabilization.     

Structural study of mutants of Escherichia coli ribonuclease HI with enhanced thermostability

Systematic replacement of the amino acid residues in Escherichiacoli ribonuclease HI with those in the thermophilic counterparthas revealed that two mutations, His62–Pro (H62P) andLys95Gly (K95G), increased the thermostability of the protein.These single-site mutant proteins, together with the mutantproteins His62Ala (H62A), Lys95Asn (K95N) and Lys95Ala (K95A),were crystallized and their structures were determined at 1.8Å resolution. The crystal structures of these mutant proteinsreveal that only the local structure around each mutation siteis essential for the increase in thermostability. For each mutantprotein, the stabilization mechanism is considered to be asfollows: (i) H62P is stabilized because of a decrease in theentropy of the unfolded state, without a change in the nativebackbone structure; (ii) K95G is stabilized since the straincaused by the left-handed backbone structure in the typical3:5 type loop is eliminated; and (iii) K95N is slightly stabilizedby a hydrogen bond formed between the side-chain N-atom of themutated aspargine residue and the main-chain carbonyl oxygenwithin the same residue.     

Crystallographic phases through genetic engineering: experiences with colicin A

Colicins are antibiotic proteins that kill sensitive Escherichiacoli cells. The structure of the pore-forming fragment of colicinA has been solved to 2.5 A resolution using the techniques ofX-ray crystallography and genetic engineering. Site-directedmutagenesis was used to construct a number of cysteine-containingmutant proteins, one of which yielded an excellent mercurialderivative. Our experiences suggest strategies for obtaininguseful heavy-atom derivatives for protein crystallography usinggenetic engineering techniques.     

Identification of two glutamic acid residues essential for catalysis in the {beta}-glycosidase from the thermoacidophilic archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus

The Sulfolobus solfataricus, strain MT4, ß-glycosidase(Ssßgly) is a thermophilic member of glycohydrolasefamily 1. To identify active-site residues, glutamic acids 206and 387 have been changed to isosteric glutamine by site-directedmutagenesis. Mutant proteins have been purified to homogeneityusing the Schistosoma japonicum glutathione S-transferase (GST)fusion system. The proteolytic cleavage of the chimeric proteinwith thrombin was only obtainable after the introduction ofa molecular spacer between the GST and the Ssß-glydomains. The Glu387 Gin mutant showed no detectable activity,as expected for the residue acting as the nucleophile of thereaction. The Glu206 Gin mutant showed 10- and 60-fold reducedactivities on aryl-galacto and aryl-glucosides, respectively,when compared with the wild type. Moreover, a significant K_mdecrease with plo-nitrophenyl-ß-D-glucoside was observed.The residual activity of the Glu206 Gln mutant lost the typicalpH dependence shown by the wild type. These data suggest thatGlu206 acts as the general acid/base catalyst in the hydrolysisreaction.     

Engineering a heavy atom derivative for the X-ray structure analysis of cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase

Based on a preliminary structural model of cyclodextrin glycosyltransferasefrom Bacillus circulans (EC 2.4.1.19 [EC] ), Ser428 and Ser475 ofthe enzyme were mutated to cysteines in order to produce suitableheavy atom derivatives. Mutant Ser475 - Cys could not be expressedas protein. Mutant Ser428 - Cys was expressed in Escherichiacoli and purified. It crystallized isomorphously and gave riseto a mercury derivative that improved the electron density map.The structural results show that the new mercury-binding siteis in a pocket at the protein surface.     

Redesign of the substrate specificity of human cathepsin D: the dominant role of position 287 in the S2 subsite

Interest in the active site specificity of human cathepsin Dstems from the search for specific therapeutic agents againstmany of the sequentially and structurally homologous membersofthe aspartic proteinase family. The work presented here examinedone amino acid in the cathepsin D sequence, located in the S₂subsite, which contributes substantially to the specificityof enzyme-Ugand interactions at the enzyme active site. Previousstudies reported on the specificity of binding and catalysisby native and recombinant human cathepsin D explored throughkinetic studies using a systematic series of synthetic substrates.Utilizing a rulebased molecular model of human cathepsin D,Met287 was suggested as a candidate for mutagenesis to furtherexplore selectivity within the S₂ subsite of the cathepsin Dactive site. Met287 mutant derivatives of human cathepsin Dwere designed, expressed and characterized in kineticstudies.Native cathepsin D accommodates large hydrophobic residues inthe P₂ position of a substrate; positively charged residuesin P₂ are not favorable for catalysis.It was demonstrated thataltering Met287 of human cathepsin D to more polar amino acidsproduced active mutant enzymes with significantly altered substratespecificity.     

Molecular recognition at the active site of subtilisin BPN': crystallographic studies using genetically engineered proteinaceous inhibitor SSI (Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor)

Unlike trypsin-like serine proteases having only one conspicuousbinding pocket in the active site, subtilisin BPN' has two suchpockets, the S1 and S4 pockets, which accommodate the P1 andP4 residues of ligands (after Schechter and Berger notation)respectively. Using computer graphics, the geometrical natureof the two pockets was carefully examined and strategies forsite-directed mutagenesis studies were set up against a proteinSSI (Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor), which is a strong proteinaceousinhibitor (or a substrate analogue) of subtilisin BPN'. It wasdecided to convert the P1 residue, methionine 73, into lysine(M73K) with or without additional conversion of the P4 residue,methionine 70, into glycine (M70G). The crystal structures ofthe two complexes of subtilisin BPN', one with the single mutantSSI (M73K) and the other with the double mutant SSI (M73K, M70G)were solved showing that (i) small ‘electrostatic induced-fitmovement’ occurs in the S1 pocket upon introducing theterminal plus charge of the lysine side chain, and (ii) large‘mechanical induced-fit movement’ occurs in theS4 pocket upon reducing the size of the P4 side chain from methionineto glycine. In both (i) and (ii), the induced-fit movement occurredin a concerted fashion involving both the enzyme and ‘substrate’amino acid residues. The term ‘substrate-assisted stabilization’was coined to stress the cooperative nature of the induced-fitmovements.     

Combinatorial exploration of the catalytic site of a drug-resistant dihydrofolate reductase: creating alternative functional configurations

We have applied a global approach to enzyme active site exploration, where multiple mutations were introduced combinatorially at the active site of Type II R67 dihydrofolate reductase (R67 DHFR), creating numerous new active site environments within a constant framework. By this approach, we combinatorially modified all 16 principal amino acids that constitute the active site of this enzyme. This approach is fundamentally different from active site point mutation in that the native active site context is no longer accounted for. Among the 1536 combinatorially mutated active site variants of R67 DHFR we created, we selected and kinetically characterized three variants with highly altered active site compositions. We determined that they are of high fitness, as defined by a complex function consisting jointly of catalytic activity and resistance to trimethoprim. The k(cat) and K(M) values were similar to those for the native enzyme. The favourable Delta(DeltaG) values obtained (ranging from -0.72 to -1.08 kcal/mol) suggest that, despite their complex mutational pattern, no fundamental change in the catalytic mechanism has occurred. We illustrate that combinatorial active site mutagenesis can allow for the creation of compensatory mutations that could not be predicted and thus provides a route for more extensive exploration of functional sequence space than is allowed by point mutation.     

Catalytic role of the active site histidine of porcine pancreatic phospholipase A2 probed by the variants H48Q, H48N and H48K

The catalytic contribution of His48 in the active site of porcinepancreatic phospholipase A2 was examined using site-directedmutagenesis. Replacement of His48 by lysine (H48K) gives riseto a protein having a distorted lipid binding pocket. Activityof this variant drops below the detection limit which is 10⁷-foldlower than that of the wild-type enzyme. On the other hand,the presence of glutamine (H48Q) or asparagine (H48N) at thisposition does not affect the structural integrity of the enzymeas can be derived from the preserved lipid binding propertiesof these variants. However, the substitutions H48Q and H48Nstrongly reduce the turnover number, i.e. by a factor of 10⁵.Residual activity is totally lost after addition of a competitiveinhibitor. We conclude that proper lipid binding on its ownaccelerates ester bond hydrolysis by a factor of 10². With theselected variants, we were also able to dissect the contributionof the hydrogen bond between Asp99 and His48 on conformationalstability, being 5.2 kJ/mol. Another hydrogen bond with His48is formed when the competitive inhibitor (R)-2-dodecanoylamino-hexanol-1-phosphoglycolinteracts with the enzyme. Its contribution to binding of theinhibitor in the presence of an interface was found to be 5.7kJ/mol.     

Effects of introduced aspartic and glutamic acid residues on the Pi substrate specificity, pH dependence and stability of carboxypeptidase Y

Carboxypeptidase Y is a serine carboxypeptidase isolated fromSaccharomyces cerevisiae with a preference for Cterminal hydrophobicamino acid residues. In order to alter the inherent substratespecificity of CPD-Y into one for basic amino acid residuesin P'₁, we have introduced Asp and/or Glu residues at a numberof selected positions within the Si binding site. Hie effectsof these substitutions on the substrate specificity, pH dependenceand protein stability have been evaluated. The results presentedhere demonstrate that it is possible to obtain significant changesin the substrate preference by introducing charged amino acidsinto the framework provided by an enzyme with a quite differentspecificity. The introduced acidic amino acid residues providea marked pH dependence of the (k_{cat/Km)FA-A-R-OH/(kcatm})_FA-A-R-OHratio. The change in stability upon introduction of Asp/Gluresidues can be correlated to the difference in the mean buriedsurfac surface area between the substituted and the substitutingamino acid. Thus, the effects of acidic amino acid residueson the protein stability depend upon whether the introducedamino acid protrudes from the solvent accessible surface asdefined by the surrounding residues in the wild type enzymeor is submerged below.     

Site-directed mutagenesis of aspartic acid 372 at the ATP binding site of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase: over-expression and characterization of the mutant enzyme

A new phosphoglycerate kinase over-expression vector, pYE-PGK,has been constructed which greatly facilitates the insertionand removal of mutant enzyme genes by cleavage at newly introducedBamtHI sites. This vector has been used to prepare mutant proteinin appreciable (100 mg) quantities for use in kinetic, crystaUographicand NMR experiments. Aspartate 372 is an invariant amino acidresidue in genes known to code for a functionally active PGK.The function of this acidic residue appears to be to help desolvatethe magnesium ion compfexed with either ADP or ATP when thissubstrate binds to the enzyme. Both crystallographk and nuclearmagnetic resonance experiments show that the replacement ofthe residue with asparagine has only minimal effects on theoverall structure. The substitution of the charged carboxylgroup with that of the neutral amide affects the binding ofthe nucleotide substrate as predicted but not, as might havebeen expected, the binding of 3-phospho-glycerate. The overallvelocity of the enzymic reaction (V_max) is reduced 10-fold bythe substitution of aspartic acid 372 by an asparagine residue(D372N). This reduction in V_max is considerably less than onewould expect from its known position within the structure ofthe enzyme. This result therefore poses questions about ourunderstanding of charged groups at the active centres of enzymesand of the reason for their apparent conservation.     

Thermosensitive mutants of Aspergillus awamori glucoamylase by random mutagenesis: inactivation kinetics and structural interpretation

Abstract Seven thermosensitive glucoamylase mutants generated by randommutagenesis and expressed inSaccharomyces cerevisiae were sequencedand their inactivation kinetics were determined. Wild-type glucoamylaseexpressed in S.cerevisiae was more glycosylated and more stablethan the native Aspergillus niger enzyme. All mutants had lowerfree energies of inactivation than wild-type glucoamylase. Inthe Ala39 Val, Ala302 Val and Leu410 Phe mutants, small hydrophobicresidues were replaced by larger ones, showing that increasesin size and hydrophobicity of residues included in hydrophobicclusters were destabilizing. The Gly396 Ser and Gly407 Aspmutants had very flexible residues replaced by more rigid ones,and this probably induced changes in the backbone conformationthat destabilized the protein. The Prol28 Ser mutation changeda rigid residue in an a-helix to a more flexible one, and destabilizedthe protein by increasing the entropy of the unfolded state.The Ala residue in the Ala442 Thr mutation is in the highlyO-glycosylated region surrounded by hydrophilk residues, whereitmay be a hydrophobic anchor Unking the O-glycosylated arm tothe catalytic core. It was replaced by a residue that potentiallyis O-glycosylated. In five of the seven mutations, residuesthat were part of hydrophobic microdomains were changed, confirmingthe importance of the latter in protein stability and structure     

pH-sensitive interactions between IgG and a mutated IgG-binding protein based upon two B domains of Protein A from Staphylococcus aureus

A fusion protein, consisting of the N-terminal 81 amino acidsfrom an inactive bovine DNase I (Q38,E39–E38,Q39) andtwo sequential synthetic IgG-binding domains based upon domainB of Protein A from Staphylococcus aureus has been shown tobind to porcine IgG with a similar affinity and pH profile toProtein A. The same residue in each B domain (Tyr111 and Tyr169)has been mutated by cassette mutagenesis to Ser, Glu, His, Lysor Arg and the effect of the mutation on binding interactionswith porcine IgG investigated. The evidence presented suggeststhat the interactions at the B domain are highly sensitive tothe presence of a charged residue.     

Mapping of residues involved in the interaction between the Bacillus subtilis xylanase A and proteinaceous wheat xylanase inhibitors

The Bacillus subtilis xylanase A was subjected to site-directed mutagenesis, aimed at changing the interaction with Triticum aestivum xylanase inhibitor, the only wheat endogenous proteinaceous xylanase inhibitor interacting with this xylanase. The published structure of Bacillus circulans XynA was used to target amino acids surrounding the active site cleft of B.subtilis XynA for mutation. Twenty-two residues were mutated, resulting in 62 different variants. The catalytic activity of active mutants ranged from 563 to 5635 XU/mg and the interaction with T.aestivum xylanase inhibitor showed a similar variation. The results indicate that T.aestivum xylanase inhibitor interacts with several amino acid residues surrounding the active site of the enzyme. Three different amino acid substitutions in one particular residue (D11) completely abolished the interaction between T.aestivum xylanase inhibitor and B.subtilis xylanase A.     

Structure prediction of the EcoRV DNA methyltransferase based on mutant profiling, secondary structure analysis, comparison with known structures of methyltransferases and isolation of catalytically inactive single mutants

The EcoRV DNA methyltransferase (M·EcoRV) is an -adeninemethyltransferase. We have used two different programs to predictthe secondary structure of M·EcoRV. The resulting consensusprediction was tested by a mutant profiling analysis. 29 neutralmutations of M·EcoRV were generated by five cycles ofrandom mutagenesis and selection for active variants to increasethe reliability of the prediction and to get a secondary structureprediction for some ambiguously predicted regions. The predictedconsensus secondary structure elements could be aligned to thecommon topology of the structures of the catalytic domains ofM·HhaI and M·TaqI. In a complementary approachwe have isolated nine catalytically inactive single mutants.Five of these mutants contain an amino acid exchange withinthe catalytic domain of M·EcoRV (Val20-Ala, Lys81Arg,Cys192Arg, Asp193Gly, Trp231Arg). The Trp231Arg mutant bindsDNA similarly to wild-type M·EcoRV, but is catalyticallyinactive. Hence this mutant behaves like a bona fide activesite mutant. According to the structure prediction, Trp231 islocated in a loop at the putative active site of M·EcoRV.The other inactive mutants were insoluble. They contain aminoacid exchanges within the conserved amino acid motifs X, IIIor IV in M·EcoRV confirming the importance of these regions.     

Influence of size and polarity of residue 31 in porcine pancreatic phospholipase A2 on catalytic properties

Residue 31 of porcine pancreatic phospholipase A₂ (PLA₂) islocated at the entrance to the active site. To study the roleof residue 31 in PLA₂, six mutant enzymes were produced by site-directedmutagenesis, replacing Leu by either Trp, Arg, Ala, Thr, Seror Gly. Direct binding studies indicated a three to six timesgreater affinity of the Trp31 PLA₂ for both monomeric and micellarsubstrate analogs, relative to the wild-type enzyme. The otherfive mutants possess an unchanged affinity for monomers of theproduct analog n-decylphosphocholine and for micelles of thediacyl substrate analog rac-l,2-dioctanoylamino-dideoxy-glycero-3-phosphocholine.The affinities for micelles of the monoacyl product analog n-hexadecylphosphocholinewere decreased 9–20 times for these five mutants. Kineticstudies with monomeric substrates showed that the mutants haveV_max values which range between 15 and 70% relative to the wild-typeenzyme. The V_max values for micelles of the zwitterionic substratel,2-dioctanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine were lowered 3–50times. The K_m values for the monomeric substrate and the k_mvalues for the micellar substrate were hardly affected in thecase of five of the six mutants, but were considerably decreasedwhen Trp was present at position 31. The results of these investigationspoint to a versatile role for the residue at position 31: involvementin the binding and orientating of monomeric substrate (analogs),involvement in the binding of the enzyme to micellar substrateanalogs and possibly involvement in shielding the active sitefrom excess water.     

Novel features of serine protease active sites and specificity pockets: sequence analysis and modelling studies of glutamate-specific endopeptidases and epidermolytic toxins

With a view to obtaining a better understanding of the structuraldeterminants of P1 glutamate specificity in glutamate-specincendopeptidases (GSEs), the active sites and specificity pocketsof such enzymes from Bacillus ticheniformis (gse-bl), Bacillussubtilis (mpr) and Staphylococcus aureus (v8 protease) weremodelled. This approach was extended to the epidermolytic toxins(ETs), responsible for the staphylococcal scalded skin syndrome.We identify a canonical structure for the S1 subsite, composedof H213 and T190, both of which we predict to interact directlywith the P1 glutamate. The possible importance of R30 (for gse-bland mpr) and of the N-terminus (for gse-bl, mpr and v8 protease)was also examined. In the case of mpr, a G193C substitutionis predicted to participate in a novel disulphide bridge whichstabilizes C193 in such a way as to maintain the oxyanion hole.In v8, the loss or substitution of several important structuralcomponents around D102 of the catalytic triad probably explainsits reduced catalytic efficiency in comparison with other GSEs.In the case of the epidermolytic toxins K216 may be importantfor the previously reported phospholipase C-like activity, sincethe model predicts that it may stabilize the negative chargeon the phosphonyl group.     

Hyperthermostable mutants of Bacillus licheniformis {alpha}-amylase: multiple amino acid replacements and molecular modelling

We have identified previously two critical positions for thethermostability of the highly thermostable -amylase from Bacilluslicheniformis. We have now introduced all 19 possible aminoacid residues to these two positions, His 133 and Ala209. Themost favourable substitutions were to Ile and Val, respectively,which both increased the half-life of the enzyme at 80°Cby a factor of 3. At both positions a stabilizing effect ofhydrophobic residues was observed, although only in the caseof position 133 could a clear correlation be drawn between thehydrophobicity of the inserted amino acid and the gain in proteinstability. The construction of double mutants showed a cumulativeeffect of the most favourable and/or deleterious substitutions.Computer modelling was used to generate a 3-D structure of thewild-type protein and to model substitutions at position 209,which lies in the conserved (/ß)₈ barrel domain of-amylase; Ala209 would be located at the beginning of the thirdhelix of the barrel, in the bottom of a small cavity facingthe fourth helix. The model suggests that replacement by, forexample, a valine could fill this cavity and therefore increaseintra- and interhelical compactness and hydrophobic interactions.