Effect of Lys->Arg mutation on the thermal stability of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase: influence on the monomer-dimer equilibrium

The thermal stability of two single (K3R, K67R) and one double(K3R-K67R) mutants of Xenopus laevis B Cu,Zn superoxide dismutasehas been studied to test LysArg substitution as an ‘electrostaticallyconservative’ strategy to increase protein stability.The K3R mutant displays an increased thermostability with respectto the wild-type enzyme, whilst a decreased stability was observedin the case of the K67R and K3R-K67R mutants. Concentrationdependence of the apparent inactivation constant (k_app) of thelatter mutants, as compared to that of the wild type enzymeand K3R mutant, indicates that their higher sensitivity to heatinactivation is due to a perturbation of the dimer association.These results are confirmed also by fluorescence anisotropymeasurements of the internal probe Tyr149. The possible roleof Arg67 in perturbing the dimer dissociation equilibrium towardthe monomeric form is discussed.     

Improvement in the alkaline stability of subtilisin using an efficient random mutagenesis and screening procedure

An efficient random mutagenesis procedure coupled to a replicaplate screen facilitated the isolation of mutant subtilisinsfrom Bacillus amyloliquefaciens that had altered autolytic stabilityunder alkaline conditions. Out of about 4000 clones screened,approximately 70 produced subtilisins with reduced stability(negatives). Two dones produced a more stable subtilisin (positives)and were identified as having a single mutation, either IIe107Valor Lys2l3Arg (the wild-type amino acid is followed by the codonposition and the mutant amino acid). One of the negative mutants,Met50Val, was at a site where other homologous subtilisins containeda Phe. When the Met50Phe mutation was introduced into the B.amyloliquefaciens gene, the mutant subtilisin was more alkalinestable. The double mutant IIe107Val/Lys2l3Arg) was more stablethan the isolated single mutant parents. The triple mutant (Met50Phe/IIel07Val/Lys2l3Arg)was even more stable than IIe107Val/Lys2l3Arg (up to two timesthe autolytic half-time of wild-type at pH 12). These studiesdemonstrate the feasibility for improving the alkaline stabilityof proteins by random mutagenesis and identifying potentialsites where substitutions from homologous proteins can improvealkaline stability.     

Site-directed mutagenesis of a calcium binding site modifies specifically the different biochemical properties of annexin I

All the functions of annexins in vitro as well as in vivo aremediated and probably regulated by calcium. We have used recombinantannexin I, synthesized by Escherichia coli, and we have performedsite-directed mutagenesis. We have mutated the endonexin foldof domain 2 that binds calcium. Mutations were performed inthis domain of the molecule because it perfectly matches thecalcium binding consensus sequence. The two glycines of thisfold were mutated into glutamic acid. The helix content andthe stability of the mutants are identical to those of the wild-type,suggesting that the mutations did not drastically affect thestructure of the protein. The two mutants showed modified calciumbinding affinities. However, the calcium binding affinity ofthe G131E mutant was far more altered than that of the G129Emutant. Furthermore, other biochemical properties of these mutantswere modified to different extents. The binding to phospholipidwas not seriously affected, whereas the selfassociation waslost by the G131E mutant. In the same way, liposome aggregationis conserved, but modified, while the calcium affinity measuredby equilibrium dialysis is dramatically altered.     

Alteration of the amino acid substrate specificity of clostridial glutamate dehydrogenase by site-directed mutagenesis of an active-site lysine residue

Two residues, K89 and S380, thought to interact with the -carboxylgroup of the substrate L-glutamate, have been altered by site-directedmutagenesis of clostridial glutamate dehydrogenase (GDH). Thesingle mutants K89L and S380V and the combined double mutantK89L/S380V were constructed. All three mutants were satisfactorilyoverproduced in soluble form. However, only the K89L mutantwas retained by the dye column normally used in purifying thewild-type enzyme. All three mutant enzymes were purified tohomogeneity and tested for substrate specificity with 24 aminoacids. The single mutant S380V showed no detectable activity.The alternative single mutant K89L showed an activity towardsL-glutamate that was decreased nearly 2000-fold compared withwild-type enzyme, whereas the activities towards the monocarboxylicsubstrates -aminobutyrate and norvaline were increased 2- to3-fold. A similar level of activity was obtained with methionine(0.005 U/mg) and norleucine (0.012 U/mg), neither of which giveany activity with the wild-type enzyme under the same conditions.The double mutant showed decreased activity with all substratescompared with the wild-type GDH. In view of its novel activities,the K89L mutant was investigated in greater detail. A strictlylinear relationship between reaction velocity and substrateconcentration was observed up to 80 mM L-methionine and 200mM L-norleucine, implying very high K_m values. Values of k_cat/K_m,for L-methionine and L-norleucine were 6.7x10^–2 and 0.15s^–1M^–1, respectively. Measurements with dithiobisnitrobenzoicacid showed that the mutant enzymes all reacted with a stoichiometryof one -SH group per subunit and all showed protection by coenzyme,indicating essentially unimpaired coenzyme binding. With glutamateor 2-oxoglutarate as substrate the K_m values for the vestigialactivity in the mutant enzyme preparations were strikingly closeto the wild-type K_m values. Both for wild-type GDH and K89L,L-glutamate gave competitive product inhibition of 2-oxoglutaratereduction but did not inhibit the reduction of 2-oxocaproatecatalysed by K89L enzyme. This suggests that the low levelsof glutamate/2-oxoglutarate activity shown by the mutant enzymeare due to trace contamination. Since stringent precautionswere taken, it appears possible that this reflects the levelof reading error during overexpression of the mutant proteins.CD measurements indicate that the S380V mutant has an alteredconformation, whereas the K89L enzyme gave an identical CD spectrumto that of wild-type GDH; the spectrum of the double mutantwas similar, although somewhat altered in intensity. The resultsconfirm the key role of K89 in dicarboxylate recognition byGDH.     

Thermostabilization of the Bacillus circulansxylanase by the introduction of disulfide bonds

The thermostability of the 20 396 Da Bacillus circulans xylanasewas increased by the introduction of both intra and intermoleculardisulfide bridges by site-directed muta-genesis. Based on the3-D structure of the enzyme, sites were chosen where favourablegeometry for a bridge existed; in one case, to obtain favourablegeometry additional mutations around the cysteine sites weredesigned by computer modelling. The disulfide bonds introducedinto the xylanase were mostly buried and, in the absence ofprotein denaturants, relatively insensitive to reduction bydithiothreitol. The mutant proteins were examined for residualenzymatic activity after various thermal treatments, and wereassayed for enzymatic activity at elevated temperatures to assesstheir productivity. Wes have examined one of these mutants byX-ray crystallography. All of the disulfide bond designs testedincreased the thermostability of the B.circulans xylanase, butnot all enhanced the activity of the enzyme at elevated temperatures.     

A new method for random mutagenesis of complete genes: enzymatic generation of mutant libraries in vitro

A new efficient in vitro mutagenesis method for the generationof complete random mutant libraries, containing all possiblesingle base substitution mutations in a cloned gene is described.The method is based on controlled use of polymerases. Four populationsof DNA molecules are first generated by primer elongation sothat they terminate randomly, but always just before a knowntype of base (before A, C, G or T respectively). Each of thefour populations is then mutagenized in a separate misincorporationreaction, where the correct base can now be omitted. The regenerationof wild-type sequences can thus be efficiently avoided. Also,the misincorporating nucleotide concentrations can be optimizedto give the three possible single mutations in close to equalratio. The mutagenesis can be precisely localized within a predeterminedtarget region of any size, and vector sequences remain intact.We have mutagenized the DNA coding for the -fragment of Escherichiacoli ß-galactosidase, and identified 176 differentbase substitution mutations by sequencing. The present methodgives mutant yields of 40–60%, when the mutants containabout one amino acid change per protein molecule. All typesof base substitution mutations can be generated and deletionsare rare. The efficiency of this method permits the use of relativelyelaborate screening systems to isolate mutants of either structuralgenes or regulatory regions.     

Effect of mutations on the dimer stability and the pH optimum of the human foamy virus protease

To explore the role of residues being close to the catalytic aspartates in the higher pH optimum and in the lower dimer stability of human foamy virus (HFV) protease (PR) in comparison with human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease, single (Q8R, H22L, S25T, T28D) and double (Q8R-T28D, H22L-T28D) mutants were created based on sequence alignments and on the molecular model of HFV PR. The wild-type and mutant enzymes were expressed in fusion with maltose binding protein in Escherichia coli and the fusion proteins were purified by affinity chromatography. Specificity constant of most mutants was lower, but the value of Q8R-T28D double mutant enzyme was higher than that of the wild-type HFV PR. Furthermore, urea denaturation at two pH values and pH optimum values showed an increased stability and pH optimum for most mutants. These results suggest that the mutated residues may not be responsible for the higher pH optimum of HFV PR, but they may contribute to the lower dimer stability as compared with that of HIV-1 PR.     

Stability effects associated with the introduction of a partial and a complete Ca2+-binding site into human lysozyme

Two mutants of human lysozyme were synthesized. Mutant A92D,in which Ala92 was substituted by Asp, contains a partial Ca²⁺-bindingsite and mutant M4, in which Ala83, Gm86, Asn88 and Ala92 werereplaced by Lys, Asp, Asp and Asp respectively, contains thecomplete Ca -binding site of bovine a-lactalbumin. The Ca²⁺-bindingconstants of wild type human lysozyme and of mutants A92D andM4, measured at 25C and pH 7.5, were 2(1) x 102 M"1, 8(2)x l^M"1 and 9(0.5) x 10* M"1 respectively. Information gatheredfrom mkrocalorimetrk and CD spectro-scopic measurements indicatesthat the conformational changes of the M4 mutant lysozyme, inducedby Ca²⁺ binding, are smaller than those observed for bovinea-lactalbumin and for the Ca²⁺-binding equine lysozyme. At pH4.5, the thermostability of both the apo and Ca²⁺ forms of theA92D human was decreased in comparison with that of native humanlysozyme. In particular, within the apo form of this mutantan a-helix-containing sequence was destabilized. In contrast,at the same pH the thermostability of the apo and Ca²⁺ formsof the M4 mutant lysozyme was increased. The e-ammonium groupof the Lys83 side chain is assumed to be responsible for thestabilization of the apo form of this mutant.     

Increasing the thermostability of a neutral protease by replacing positively charged amino acids in the N-terminal turn of {alpha}-helices

The 247–260 and 289–299 -helices of Bacillus subtilisneutral protease have a lysine in their N-terminal turn. Theselysines were replaced by Ser or Asp in order to improve electrostaticinteractions with the -helix dipole. After replacing Lys bySer at positions 249 or 290, the thermostability of the enzymewas increased by 0.3 and 1.0°C, respectively. The Asp249and Asp290 mutants exhibited a stabilization of 0.6 and 1.2°C,respectively. The results show the feasibility of stabilizingenzymes by introducing favourable residues at the end of -helices.     

Replacing the glutamate ligand in the structural zinc site of Sulfolobus solfataricus alcohol dehydrogenase with a cysteine decreases thermostability

The alcohol dehydrogenase gene from the thermophilic archaeumSulfolobus solfataricus has been subcloned and expressed inEscherichia coli under the control of the T7 inducible promoter.Therecombinant protein shows properties analogous to those of thenative enzyme, including thermostability, despite the fact thatE.coli does not post-translationally modify two lysine residueswhich are N--methylated in the native enzyme. We constructeda 3-D model of the S.solfataricus alcohol dehydrogenase usingthe known structure of its isozyme from horse liver as a template.Our analysis of the structural zinc binding site suggested thatthis site is present andfunctional in the S.solfataricus enzymeand that a glutamate ligand can contribute to thermostabilityby influencing electrostatic interactions around the metal centre.To investigate thishypothesis, we constructed, expressed andcharacterized a mutant where the glutamate is replaced by acysteine, thus restoring the zinc binding site of mesophilicalcohol dehydrogenases. Themutant shows the same activity buta reduced thermostability with respect to the wild-type recombinantprotein, as suggested by our model.     

Specificity determinants of rat tissue kallikrein probed by site-directed mutagenesis

Site-specific mutagenesis was employed to study structure-functionrelationships at the substrate binding site of rat tissue kallikrein.Four kallikrein mutants, the Pro219 deletion (P219del), the34–38 loop Tyr-Tyr-Phe-Gly to Ile-Asn mutation [YYFG(34–38)IN],the Trp215Gly exchange (W215G) and the double mutant with Tyr99Hisand Trp215Gly exchange (Y99H:W215G) were created by site-directedmutagenesis to probe their function in substrate binding. Themutant proteins were expressed in Esclzerichia coli at highlevels and analyzed by Western blot. These mutant enzymes werepurified to apparent homogeneity. Each migrated as a singleband on SDS-PAGE, with slightly lower molecular mass (36 kDa)than that of the native enzyme, (38 kDa) because of their lackof glycosylation. The recombinant kallikreins are immunologicallyidentical to the native enzyme, displaying parallelism withthe native enzyme in a direct radioimmunoassay for rat tissuekallikrein. Kinetic analyses of K_m and k_cat using fluorogenicpeptide substrates support the hypothesis that the Tyr99–Trp215interaction is a major determinant for hydrophobic P2 specificity.The results suggest an important role for the 34–38 loopin hydrophobic P3 affinity and further show that Pro219 is essentialto substrate binding and efficient catalysis of tissue kallikrein.     

Proposal for new catalytic roles for two invariant residues in Escherichia coli ribonuclease HI

Three mutants of Escherichia coli ribonuclease HI, in whichan invariant acidic residue Asp134 was replaced, were crystallized,and their three-dimensional structures were determined by X-raycrystallography. The D134A mutant is completely inactive, whereasthe other two mutants, D134H and D134N, retain 59 and 90% activitiesrelative to the wild-type, respectively. The overall structuresof these three mutant proteins are identical with that of thewild-type enzyme, except for local conformational changes ofthe flexible loops. The ribonuclease H family has a common activesite, which is composed of four invariant acidic residues (Asp10,G1u48, Asp70 and Asp134 in E.coli ribonuclease HI), and theirrelative positions in the mutants, even including the side-chainatoms, are almost the same as those in the wild-type. The positionsof the -polar atoms at residue 134 in the wild-type, as wellas D134H and D134N, coincide well with each other. They arelocated near the imidazole side chain of His124, which is assumedto participate in the catalytic reaction, in addition to thefour invariant acidic residues. Combined with the pH profilesof the enzymatic activities of the two other mutants, H124Aand H124A/D134N, the crystallographic results allow us to proposea new catalytic mechanism of ribonuclease H, which includesthe roles for Asp134 and His124.     

Introduction of a stabilizing 10 residue {beta}-hairpin in Bacillus subtilis neutral protease

A 10 residue ß-hairpin, which is characteristic ofthermostable Bacillus neutral proteases, was engineered intothe thermolabile neutral protease of Bacillus subtilis. Therecipient enzyme remained fully active after introduction ofthe loop. However, the mutant protein exhibited autocatalyticnicking and a 0.4°C decrease in thermostability. Two additionalpoint mutations designed to improve the interactions betweenthe enzyme surface and the introduced ß-hairpin resultedin reduced nicking and increased thermostability. After theintroduction of both additional mutations in the loopcontainingmutant, nicking was largely prevented and an increase in thermostabilityof 1.1°C was achieved.     

Introduction of disulfide bonds into Bacillus subtilis neutral protease

The effects of engineered disulfide bonds on autodigestion andthermostability of Bacillus subtilis neutral protease (NP-sub)were studied using site-directed mutagenesis. After modellingstudies two locations that might be capable of forming disulfidebonds, both near previously determined autodigestion sites inNP-sub, were selected for the introduction of cysteines. Analysisof mutant enzymes showed that disulfide bonds were indeed formedin vivo, and that the mutant enzymes were fully active. Theintroduced disulfides did not alter the autodigestion patternof the NP-sub. All mutant NP-subs exhibited decreased thermostability,which, by using reducing agents, was shown to be caused by theintroduction of the cysteines and not by the formation of thedisulfides. Mutants containing one cysteine exhibited intermoleculardisulfide formation at elevated temperatures, which, however,was shown not to be the cause of the decreased thermostability.Combining the present data with literature data, it would seemthat the introduction of disulfide bridges is unsuitable forthe stabilization of proteases. Possible explanations for thisphenomenon are discussed.     

Structural study of mutants of Escherichia coli ribonuclease HI with enhanced thermostability

Systematic replacement of the amino acid residues in Escherichiacoli ribonuclease HI with those in the thermophilic counterparthas revealed that two mutations, His62–Pro (H62P) andLys95Gly (K95G), increased the thermostability of the protein.These single-site mutant proteins, together with the mutantproteins His62Ala (H62A), Lys95Asn (K95N) and Lys95Ala (K95A),were crystallized and their structures were determined at 1.8Å resolution. The crystal structures of these mutant proteinsreveal that only the local structure around each mutation siteis essential for the increase in thermostability. For each mutantprotein, the stabilization mechanism is considered to be asfollows: (i) H62P is stabilized because of a decrease in theentropy of the unfolded state, without a change in the nativebackbone structure; (ii) K95G is stabilized since the straincaused by the left-handed backbone structure in the typical3:5 type loop is eliminated; and (iii) K95N is slightly stabilizedby a hydrogen bond formed between the side-chain N-atom of themutated aspargine residue and the main-chain carbonyl oxygenwithin the same residue.     

Contribution of the C-terminal amino acid to the stability of Bacillus subtilis neutral protease

The role of the C-terminal Leu300 in maintaining thermal stabilityof the neutral protease of Bacillus subtilis was investigated.From model building studies based on the three dimensional structureof thermolysin, the neutral protease of B.thermoproteolyticus,it was conduded that this residue is located in a hydrophobicpocket composed of residues located in the C-terminal and themiddle domain. To test the hypothesis that Leu300, by contributingto a stabilizing interaction between these domains, is importantfor enzyme stability, several neutral protease mutants wereconstructed and characterized. The thermostability of the enzymewas lowered by deleting Leu300 or by replacing this residueby a smaller (Ala), a polar (Asn) or a sterically unfavourable(He) amino acid. Thermostabiity was increased upon replacingLeu300 by Phe. These results are in agreement with model-buildingstudies. The effects on thermostability observed after mutatingthe corresponding Val318 in the thermostable neutral proteaseof B.stearothermophilus were less pronounced.     

Stabilization of the neutral protease of Bacillus stearothermophilus by removal of a buried water molecule

Using site-directed mutagenesis, Ala166 in the neutral proteaseof Bacillus stearothermophilus was changed into Ser. Model buildingand molecular dynamics simulations of the mutant enzyme indicatedthat the Ser hydroxyl group fits well in a cavity which containsa water molecule in the wild-type enzyme. The Alal66 - Ser mutationwas expected to exert a stabilizing effect because of the gainin entropy resulting from the release of a water molecule fromthe folded protein to the solvent. In addition, the hydrogen-bondingnetwork around residue 166 was improved upon the mutation. Asa result of this mutation the thermostability of the neutralprotease was increased by 1.2 ± 0.1°C.     

Biased mutation-assembling: an efficient method for rapid directed evolution through simultaneous mutation accumulation

We have developed an efficient optimization technique, 'biased mutation-assembling', for improving protein properties such as thermostability. In this strategy, a mutant library is constructed using the overlap extension polymerase chain reaction technique with DNA fragments from wild-type and phenotypically advantageous mutant genes, in which the number of mutations assembled in the wild-type gene is stochastically controlled by the mixing ratio of the mutant DNA fragments to wild-type fragments. A high mixing ratio results in a mutant composition biased to favor multiple-point mutants. We applied this strategy to improve the thermostability of prolyl endopeptidase from Flavobacterium meningosepticum as a case study and found that the proportion of thermostable mutants in a library increased as the mixing ratio was increased. If the proportion of thermostable mutants increases, the screening effort needed to find them should be reduced. Indeed, we isolated a mutant with a 1200-fold longer activity half-life at 60 degrees C than that of wild-type prolyl endopeptidase after screening only 2000 mutants from a library prepared with a high mixing ratio. Our results indicate that an aggressive accumulation of advantageous mutations leads to an increase in the quality of the mutant library and a reduction in the screening effort required to find superior mutants.     

Use of a minimum perturbation approach to predict TIM mutant structures

A minimum perturbation conformational search approach is usedto model the structures of the yeast triosephosphate isomerase(TIM) single mutant in which the catalytic base Glul65 is changedto Asp, and the double mutant in which Glul65 is changed toAsp and Ser96 to Pro. In chicken TIM this double mutant is referredto as a pseudo–revertant because some of the catalyticactivity lost due to the first mutation is regained when thesecond mutation occurs. Three minimum energy structures werecalculated for the Asp 165 conformation in the yeast TEM singlemutant and another three for the double mutant One of the calculatedminimum energy conformations for Aspl65 in the E165D structureagrees well with the X–ray structure. However, this conformationis not that of the lowest energy and is not one of the threemost common conformers for Asp found by Ponder and Richards.This suggests that when an amino acid is introduced it may notbe able to conform to the more general rules that apply to proteinstructures of evolutionary origin. While the van der Waals energylargely determines the allowed minima, the relative rankingof the final minima is determined by electrostatic effects andcan therefore be affected by the inclusion of crystal watersin the calculation. When the E165D calculation is repeated withan active–site water molecule fixed in its E165D X–raystructure position, the relative ranking of the minima shiftsand the X–ray conformation for Asp 165 is the lowest interactionenergy conformer. Two of the E165D calculated minimum energystructures are essentially identical to two of the S96P/E165Dminima. All of the calculated minima for both the E165D andS96P/E165D mutants position the Asp side chain such that theanti–orbital, and not the more basic syn–orbital,of the carboxylate would be utilized for proton abstraction.This observation may explain why the chicken TIM S96P/E165Dmutant, for which the X-ray structure indicates that the syn–orbitalis used, is a pseudo–revertant while the yeast TIM doublemutant is not; no X–ray structure is available for thelatter. The multiplicity of minima found in the present analysismakes clear that predicting the exact orientation of a singleside chain is not as simple as might be expected.     

Experimental verification of the `stability profile of mutant protein' (SPMP) data using mutant human lysozymes

The stability profile of mutant protein (SPMP) (Ota,M., Kanaya,S.and Nishikawa,K., 1995, J. Mol. Biol., 248, 733–738) estimatesthe changes in conformational stability due to single aminoacid substitutions using a pseudo-energy potential developedfor evaluating structure–sequence compatibility in thestructure prediction method, the 3D–1D compatibility evaluation.Nine mutant human lysozymes expected to significantly increasein stability from SPMP were constructed, in order to experimentallyverify the reliability of SPMP. The thermodynamic parametersfor denaturation and crystal structures of these mutant proteinswere determined. One mutant protein was stabilized as expected,compared with the wild-type protein. However, the others werenot stabilized even though the structural changes were subtle,indicating that SPMP overestimates the increase in stabilityor underestimates negative effects due to substitution. Thestability changes in the other mutant human lysozymes previouslyreported were also analyzed by SPMP. The correlation of thestability changes between the experiment and prediction dependedon the types of substitution: there were some correlations forproline mutants and cavity-creating mutants, but no correlationfor mutants related to side-chain hydrogen bonds. The presentresults may indicate some additional factors that should beconsidered in the calculation of SPMP, suggesting that SPMPcan be refined further.