High pressure effects on the structure of casein micelles in milk as studied by cryo-transmission electron microscopy

Milk was processed with high hydrostatic pressure in order to modify the casein micelles. Images, that in details showed the casein micelle structure in untreated and pressure-treated skim milk, were obtained by using cryo-transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM). Sizes and shapes adopted by casein micelles in pressurised milk are concluded to be a result of an equilibrium distribution between self-assembling casein molecules in the serum phase and caseins adsorbed to surfaces of casein micelles and are governed by an initial pressure-dependent displacement of caseins into the serum phase. Pressurisation of milk at moderately high pressure, in the range 150–300 MPa, favoured formation of a large number of small micelles that coexisted with a fraction of large micelles, and which appeared perfectly spherical with smooth and well-defined surfaces, features which are suggested to originate from secondary adsorption of caseins. Pressurisation of milk at 400 MPa favoured formation of smaller casein assemblies, with sizes between 30 nm and 100 nm. Measurements of free calcium concentration [Ca²⁺] showed that calcium was rebound to casein micelles after pressurisation of milk. Furthermore, the electron microscopy images indicated that the substructures were similar for pressure-modified casein micelles and casein micelles in untreated milk.     

Properties of casein micelles cross-linked by transglutaminase

Factors affecting the cross-linking of milk proteins by transglutaminase (TGase) were studied. Cross-linking of caseins in bovine skim milk was optimal over a very wide pH range. The role of micellar calcium phosphate (MCP) in maintaining the integrity of TGase-treated casein micelles was studied by incubating skim milk with 0.01% (w/v) TGase at 30°C for 1–24 h, followed by removal of MCP from untreated or TGase-treated milk by acidification and dialysis. The protein content and profile of the samples were determined by Kjeldahl and SDS-PAGE, respectively. Whey proteins in unheated milk were not susceptible to TGase-induced cross-linking. The higher level of sedimentable protein in MCP-free TGase-treated milk than in MCP-free control milk indicated that TGase treatment partially prevented disintegration of the micelle on removal of MCP, probably due to extensive intramicellar TGase-induced cross-linking of casein molecules which led to the formation of sedimentable covalently bonded casein aggregates.     

Invited review: Caseins and the casein micelle: Their biological functions,structures, and behavior in foods

A typical casein micelle contains thousands of casein molecules, most of which form thermodynamically stable complexes with nanoclusters of amorphous calcium phosphate. Like many other unfolded proteins, caseins have an actual or potential tendency to assemble into toxic amyloid fibrils, particularly at the high concentrations found in milk. Fibrils do not form in milk because an alternative aggregation pathway is followed that results in formation of the casein micelle. As a result of forming micelles, nutritious milk can be secreted and stored without causing either pathological calcification or amyloidosis of the mother’s mammary tissue. The ability to sequester nanoclusters of amorphous calcium phosphate in a stable complex is not unique to caseins. It has been demonstrated using a number of noncasein secreted phosphoproteins and may be of general physiological importance in preventing calcification of other biofluids and soft tissues. Thus, competent noncasein phosphoproteins have similar patterns of phosphorylation and the same type of flexible, unfolded conformation as caseins. The ability to suppress amyloid fibril formation by forming an alternative amorphous aggregate is also not unique to caseins and underlies the action of molecular chaperones such as the small heat-shock proteins. The open structure of the protein matrix of casein micelles is fragile and easily perturbed by changes in its environment. Perturbations can cause the polypeptide chains to segregate into regions of greater and lesser density. As a result, the reliable determination of the native structure of casein micelles continues to be extremely challenging. The biological functions of caseins, such as their chaperone activity, are determined by their composition and flexible conformation and by how the casein polypeptide chains interact with each other. These same properties determine how caseins behave in the manufacture of many dairy products and how they can be used as functional ingredients in other foods.     

Supramolecular structure of the casein micelle

The supramolecular structure of colloidal casein micelles in milk was investigated by using a sample preparation protocol based on adsorption of proteins onto a poly-l-lysine and parlodion-coated copper grid, staining of proteins and calcium phosphate by uranyl oxalate, instantaneous freezing, and drying under a high vacuum. High-resolution transmission electron microscopy stereo-images were obtained showing the interior structure of casein micelles. On the basis of our interpretation of these images, an interlocked lattice model was developed in which both casein-calcium phosphate aggregates and casein polymer chains act together to maintain casein micelle integrity. The caseins form linear and branched chains (2 to 5 proteins long) interlocked by the casein-stabilized calcium phosphate nanoclusters. This model suggests that stabilization of calcium phosphate nanoclusters by phosphoserine domains of α_s1-, α_s2-, or β-casein, or their combination, would orient their hydrophobic domains outward, allowing interaction and binding to other casein molecules. Other interactions between the caseins, such as calcium bridging, could also occur and further stabilize the supramolecule. The combination of having an interlocked lattice structure and multiple interactions results in an open, sponge-like colloidal supramolecule that is resistant to spatial changes and disintegration. Hydrophobic interactions between caseins surrounding a calcium phosphate nanocluster would prevent complete dissociation of casein micelles when the calcium phosphate nanoclusters are solubilized. Likewise, calcium bridging and other electrostatic interactions between caseins would prevent dissociation of the casein micelles into casein-calcium phosphate nanocluster aggregates when milk is cooled or urea is added to milk, and hydrophobic interactions are reduced. The appearance of both polymer chains and small aggregate particles during milk synthesis would also be expected based on this interlocked lattice model of casein micelles, and its supramolecule structure thus exhibits the principles of self-aggregation, interdependence, and diversity observed in nature.     

Dynamics of casein micelles in skim milk during and after high pressure treatment

The effect of high hydrostatic pressure on turbidity of skim milk was measured in situ together with casein micelle size distribution. High pressure (HP) treatment reduced the turbidity of milk with a stronger pressure dependency between 50 and 300 MPa when the temperature was decreased from 20 to 5 °C, while at 30 °C (50–150 MPa) turbidity exceeded that of untreated milk. At 250 and 300 MPa turbidity decreased extremely. During pressurization of milk at 250 and 300 MPa, the turbidity initially decreased, but treatments longer than 10 min increased the turbidity progressively, indicating that re-association followed dissociation of casein micelles. Especially at 40 °C and at 250 and 300 MPa, the turbidity increased beyond untreated milk. Dynamic light scattering was used to investigate casein micelle sizes in milk immediately after long time (up to 4 h) pressurization at 250 and 300 MPa and casein micelle size distributions were bimodal with micelle sizes markedly smaller and markedly larger than those of untreated milk. Pressure modified casein micelles present after treatment of milk at 250 and 300 MPa were concluded to be highly unstable, since the larger micelles induced by pressure showed marked changes toward smaller particle sizes in milk left at ambient pressure.     

Chemical fractionation of caseins by differential precipitation: influence of pH,calcium addition,protein concentration and temperature on the depletion in α- and β-caseins

The impact of pH, calcium and casein concentrations, and temperature on the efficiency of the differential precipitation of caseins by calcium affinity was investigated, using native phosphocaseinate as starting material. We adapted one of the most recent methods for the separation of caseins that is based on the addition of calcium at alkaline pH. Increasing the pH to 11 disturbed the micellar structure by enhancing electrostatic repulsion of caseins, leading to a marked viscosity increase and a significant particle size decrease, indicating casein micelle disruption. This pH-driven increase in negative charges enhanced the affinity of individual caseins for calcium, proportionally to the number of phosphate groups carried by each casein. The addition of calcium first led to a progressive increase in the proportion of precipitated caseins, before reaching a plateau. Hence, an optimal calcium/casein molar ratio of about 40 was evidenced to optimise casein precipitation (and fractionation), leading to significant depletion of α-casein (around 80%) and, in a lesser extent, β-casein (around 65%) and κ-casein (around 55%). This method led to relative proportions of caseins significantly differing from the starting material: 31% α-casein, 45% β-casein and 24% κ-casein.     

Cryo-transmission electron tomography of native casein micelles from bovine milk

Caseins are the principal protein components in milk and an important ingredient in the food industry. In liquid milk, caseins are found as micelles of casein proteins and colloidal calcium nanoclusters. Casein micelles were isolated from raw skim milk by size exclusion chromatography and suspended in milk protein-free serum produced by ultrafiltration (molecular weight cut-off of 3 kDa) of raw skim milk. The micelles were imaged by cryo-electron microscopy and subjected to tomographic reconstruction methods to visualize the 3-dimensional and internal organization of native casein micelles. This provided new insights into the internal architecture of the casein micelle that had not been apparent from prior cryo-transmission electron microscopy studies. This analysis demonstrated the presence of water-filled cavities (∼20 to 30 nm in diameter), channels (diameter greater than ∼5 nm), and several hundred high-density nanoclusters (6 to 12 nm in diameter) within the interior of the micelles. No spherical protein submicellar structures were observed.     

Structural analysis of the environment of calcium ions in crystalline and amorphous calcium phosphates by X-ray absorption spectroscopy and a hypothesis concerning the biological function of the casein micelle

Determination of the structural environment around calcium ions, using X-ray absorption spectroscopy, in crystalline calcium phosphates is described. The spherically averaged short-range order in an amorphous calcium phosphate can be quantitatively determined using, as a model, the environment of calcium ions in the crystalline calcium phosphate which is closest to it in chemical composition. Structural studies, together with other evidence, suggest that the colloidal calcium phosphate in milk comprises small clusters of Ca²⁺ and HPO₄²⁻ ions in a fairly disordered state. The ion clusters are distributed throughout the micelle and are probably linked through phosphoseryl residues, to the Ca²⁺-sensitive caseins. Calculations indicate that probably about five polypeptide chains interact with a typical ion cluster.The small size of the ion clusters, their amorphous nature and the relative conformational flexibility of the casein proteins suggests a possible biological function for caseins and the casein micelle in the control of calcium phosphate precipitation. During calcium transport by the secretory cells of the mammary epithelium, calcium phosphate is precipitated in the Golgi vesicles. It is suggested that the caseins trap the growth of the precipitate at the nucleation stage, effectively preventing a potentially disastrous first-order phase transition.     

Distribution of Ca,P and Mg and casein micelle mineralisation in donkey milk from the second to ninth month of lactation

Ca, P and Mg content and distribution between soluble and colloidal phases of donkey milk (DM) were investigated in 62 individual milk samples collected from 9 Ragusano donkeys followed from the second to the ninth month of lactation. Ca (69%) and P (64%) were mainly associated with casein, while Mg was largely found in the soluble form (69%). Only 25% of the colloidal P was present as phosphorylated residues of caseins (casein-P). The colloidal contents of Ca, casein-P, inorganic P (as a constituent of the colloidal calcium phosphate; CCP) and Mg were 1.84, 1.30, 0.45 and 0.15 mmol g casein⁻¹, respectively, revealing a high level of mineralisation of DM casein micelle. The colloidal Ca to colloidal inorganic-P ratio was 1.51, suggesting that most colloidal Ca was in the form of CCP. All parameters were affected by the period of lactation, except casein level in milk and its level of phosphorylation.     

Interactive effects of casein micelle size and calcium and citrate content on rennet‐induced coagulation in bovine milk

Interactive effects of casein micelle size and milk calcium and citrate content on rennet‐induced coagulation were investigated. Milk samples containing small (SM) and large (LM) micelles, obtained from individual Holstein cows, were modified by addition of calcium and/or citrate and milk coagulation properties were evaluated in a full factorial design. The results showed that LM milk had a higher relative proportion of casein, coagulated faster, and resulted in a stronger gel than SM milk. Addition of calcium slightly decreased casein micelle size, while addition of citrate slightly increased micelle size. Calcium addition resulted in a shorter coagulation time and the strongest gels, while citrate addition increased the coagulation time and resulted in the weakest gels. Addition of calcium and citrate in combination resulted in intermediate coagulation properties. The interactive effect of micelle size and citrate was significant for gel strength. Microstructural differences between the milk gels were consistent with the rheological properties, for example, the micrographs revealed that a more homogeneous network was formed when calcium was added, resulting in a stronger gel. A more inhomogeneous network structure was formed when citrate was added, resulting in a weaker gel. Thus, variations in casein micelle size and in calcium and citrate content influence rennet‐induced coagulation in bovine milk. The calcium and citrate contents in Swedish milk have changed over time, whereby calcium content has increased and citrate content has decreased. In practical cheese making, calcium is added to cheese milk, most likely altering the role of inherent citrate and possibly influencing casein micelle size. The observed interaction effect between casein micelle size and citrate in this study, suggests that larger micelles with moderate citrate level will result in firmer gels, whereas a higher citrate content reduced gel strength more in case of large than SM. Since firmer gels are likely to retain more protein and fat than less firmer gels, this interaction effect could have implications in practical cheese production.     

Isolation of caseins from whey proteins by microfiltration modifying the mineral balance in skim milk

The objective of this work was to study the effect of different salts and salt concentration on the isolation of casein micelles from bovine raw skim milk by tangential flow microfiltration. Tangential flow microfiltration (0.22 μm) was conducted in a continuous process adding a modified buffer to maintain a constant initial sample volume. This buffer contained calcium chloride (CaCl₂), sodium phosphate (Na₂HPO₄), or potassium citrate (K₃C₆H₅O₇) in concentrations ranging from 0 to 100 mM. The concentrations of caseins and whey proteins retained were determined by sodium dodecyl sulfate-PAGE and analyzed using the Scion Image software (Scion Corporation, Frederick, MD). A complete isolation of caseins from whey proteins was achieved using sodium phosphate in the range of 10 to 50 mM and 20 times the initial volume of buffer added. No whey proteins were detected at 50 mM but this was at the expense of low caseins being retained. When lower sodium phosphate concentrations were used, the amount of caseins retained was higher but a small amount of whey proteins were still detected by sodium dodecyl sulfate-PAGE. Among the salts tested, calcium chloride at 50 mM and all volumes of buffer showed the higher retention of casein proteins. The highest casein:whey protein ratio was found at 30 mM CaCl₂, but no complete casein micelle isolation was achieved. Potassium citrate was the most ineffective salt because a rapid loss of caseins and whey proteins was observed at all concentrations and with low quantities of buffer added during the filtration process. Our results show the potential of altering the mineral balance in milk for isolation of casein micelles from whey proteins in a continuous tangential flow microfiltration system.     

pH treatment as an effective tool to select the functional and structural properties of yak milk caseins

Qula is made from yak milk after defatting, acidifying, and drying. Yak milk caseins are purified from Qula by dissolving in alkali solution. The effects of different pH treatments on the functional and structural properties of yak milk caseins were investigated. Over a broad range of pH (from 6.0 to 12.0), functional properties of yak milk caseins, including solubility, emulsifying activities, and thermal characteristics, and the structural properties, including 1-anilino-8-naphthalene-sulfonate fluorescence, turbidity and particle diameter, were evaluated. The results showed that the yak milk casein yield increased as the pH increased from 6.0 to 12.0. The solubility dramatically increased as the pH increased from 6.0 to 8.0, and decreased as the pH increased from 9.0 to 12.0. The changes in emulsifying activity were not significant. Caseins were remarkably heat stable at pH 9.0. The turbidity of the casein solution decreased rapidly as the pH increased from 6.0 to 12.0, and the results suggested that reassembled casein micelles were more compact at low pH than high pH. At pH values higher than 8.0, the yield of yak milk caseins reached more than 80%. The highest solubility was at pH 8.0, the best emulsification was at pH 10.0 and the greatest thermal stability was at pH 9.0. According to the functional characteristics of yak milk caseins, alkali conditions (pH 8.0–10.0) should be selected for optimum production. These results suggested that pH-dependent treatment could be used to modify the properties of yak milk caseins by appropriate selection of the pH level.     

Effect of micellar structure of casein and its modification on plasmin-induced hydrolysis

Plasmin-induced hydrolysis of casein in milk can lead to many defects including proteolysis, age gelation, and bitterness. The susceptibility of casein to plasmin can be affected by micellar structure and modification of the lysine residues on caseins. Different levels of casein modification and dissociation of the casein micelle structure were achieved through succinylation. Succinylation occurred at residues Lys7, Lys34, Lys36, Lys42, Lys83 and Lys124 in α_S1-casein; Lys80, Lys150, Lys152, Lys158 and Lys165 in α_S2-casein; Lys28, Lys29, Lys32, Lys99, Lys105, Lys107 and Lys113 in β-casein, as identified using liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry. The dissociation of caseins from the casein micelle reduced steric hindrance and made the protein more readily susceptible to hydrolysis by plasmin. However, the formation of succinyl-lysine rendered β-casein unrecognisable to the substrate-binding pocket of plasmin, resulting in a non-linear decrease in level of hydrolysis because of the competitive effect of micelle dissociation.     

Effect of heat and transglutaminase on solubility of goat milk protein‐based films

The effect of heat, transglutaminase and combination of heat and transglutaminase treatments on the solubility of films prepared from goat milk casein, goat milk whey proteins and whole goat milk proteins was investigated. Goat milk casein films were less soluble when treated with transglutaminase and combination of heat with transglutaminase compare with heat‐treated caseins alone. Heat treatment was more effective at decreasing the solubility of whey protein films. SDS‐PAGE patterns demonstrated that goat milk caseins were better cross‐linked by transglutaminase, whereas whey proteins were better cross‐linked by heat. The extent of cross‐linking was further enhanced when a combination of heat and transglutaminase was used.     

Effects of mineral salts and calcium chelating agents on the gelation of renneted skim milk

The effects of adding CaCl2, orthophosphate, citrate, EDTA, or a mixture of these, to reconstituted skim milk (90 g of solids/kg solution) on the gelation of renneted milk were mediated by changes in Ca2+ activity and the casein micelle. At pH 6.65, the addition of citrate or EDTA, which removed more than 33% of the original colloidal calcium phosphate with the accompanying release of 20% casein from the micelle, completely inhibited gelation. Reformation of the depleted colloidal calcium phosphate and casein in the micelle, by the addition of CaCl2, removed this inhibition. When the minimum requirements for colloidal calcium phosphate and casein in the micelle were met, the coagulation time decreased with increasing Ca2+ activity, leveling off at high Ca2+ activity. The storage modulus of renneted gels, measured at 3 h, increased with increasing colloidal calcium phosphate content of micelles up to a level at which it was approximately 130% of the original colloidal calcium phosphate in the micelles. Further increases in colloidal calcium phosphate by the addition of CaCl2, orthophosphate, or mixtures of these, which did not change the proportion of casein in the micelle, decreased the storage modulus. The gelation of the renneted milk was influenced by Ca2+ activity, the amounts of colloidal calcium phosphate, and casein within the micelle, with the effects of colloidal calcium phosphate and casein within the micelle clearly dominating the storage modulus. These results are consistent with the model of Horne (Int. Dairy J. 8:171-177, 1998) which postulates that, following cleavage of the stabilizing K-casein hairs by rennet, the properties of the rennet gel are determined by the balance between the electrostatic and hydrophobic forces between casein micelles.     

Seasonal variations in composition,properties, and heat-induced changes in bovine milk in a seasonal calving system

We determined seasonal variations in the composition and characteristics of bovine milk, as well as heat-induced changes in the physicochemical properties of the milk, in a typical seasonal-calving New Zealand herd over 2 full milking seasons. Fat, protein, and lactose contents varied consistently during the year in patterns similar to those of the lactation cycle. Seasonality also had significant effects on milk calcium, ionic calcium, fat globule size, buffering capacity, and ethanol stability, but not on casein micelle size. The ratio of casein to total protein did not vary significantly over the season, but late-season milk had the highest content of glycosylated κ-casein (G-κ-CN) and the lowest content of α-lactalbumin in both years. We observed significant between-year effects on protein, total calcium, ionic calcium, pH, and casein:total protein ratio, which might have resulted from different somatic cell counts in the 2 years. Compared with heating at 90°C for 6 min, UHT treatment (140°C for 5 s) induced greater dissociation of κ-casein, a similar extent of whey protein denaturation, a lower extent of whey protein–casein micelle association, and a larger increase in casein micelle size. Indeed, UHT treatment might have triggered significant dissociation of G-κ-CN, resulting in aggregation among the casein micelles and increased apparent mean casein micelle diameter. Seasonality had significant effects on the partitioning of G-κ-CN between the micelle and the serum phase, the extent of whey protein–casein micelle association under both heating conditions, and the casein micelle size of the UHT milk.     

Effects of reverse CO2 acidification cycles,calcium supplementation,pH adjustment and chilled storage on physico-chemical and rennet coagulation properties of reconstituted low- and medium-heat skim milk powders

The reversibility extent of one and two reverse CO₂ acidification cycles on the physico-chemical and rennet coagulation properties of milks reconstituted from low- (LH) or medium- (MH) heat skim powder, enriched or not with calcium and pH adjusted or not was investigated. The ionized calcium concentration, buffering properties and average casein micelle size of untreated and CO₂-treated milks were evaluated before and after a chilled storage for 2 days. The ionized calcium concentration and buffering properties have been modified by the CO₂-treatment, particularly after a second CO₂-cycle. These modifications were highly dependent on the initial milk properties and chilled storage. Inversely, the average casein micelle size was not significantly changed. In addition, the rennet-clotting behaviour checked by near infrared spectroscopy (NIR-S) and rheology (SAOR) indicated the main factors responsible for changes in the casein micelles environment and dynamic casein micellar calcium phosphate reorganization, especially after two CO₂-cycles. A single CO₂-cycle induced a better rennetability for non Ca-enriched milk reconstituted from MH-powder. A second CO₂-cycle was particularly efficient to improve Ca-enriched pH-adjusted milks.     

Casein micelle dissociation in skim milk during high-pressure treatment: Effects of pressure, pH, and temperature

The effect of pH (from 5.5 to 7.5) and temperature (from 5 to 40°C) on the turbidity of reconstituted skim milk powder was investigated at ambient pressure and in situ under pressure (up to 500 MPa) by measurement of light scattering. High-pressure treatment reduced the turbidity of milk for all combinations of pH and temperature due to micelle dissociation. The turbidity profiles had a characteristic sigmoidal shape in which almost no effect on turbidity was observed at low pressures (100 MPa), followed by a stronger pressure dependency over a pressure range of 150 MPa during which turbidity decreased extremely. From the turbidity profiles, the threshold pressure for disruption of micelle integrity was determined and ranged from 150 MPa at low pH to 350-400 MPa at high pH. The threshold pressure diagram clearly showed a relationship between the barostability of casein micelles and pH, whereas almost no effect of temperature was shown. This remarkable pH effect was a consequence of pressure-induced changes in the electrostatic interactions between colloidal calcium phosphate and the caseins responsible for maintaining micellar structure and was explained by a shift in the calcium phosphate balance in the micelle-serum system. Accordingly, a mechanism for high pressure-induced disruption of micelle integrity is suggested in which the state of calcium plays a crucial role in the micelle dissociation process.     

The liquid-state 31P-nuclear magnetic resonance study on microfiltrated milk

To gain further insight into diversiform phosphorus in bovine milk, we separated skim milk into casein micelle and serum fractions by microfiltration and subjected them to liquid-state 31P-nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. As previously reported, the skim milk spectrum showed a broad and indistinct peak from phosphoserine residue (SerP) of casein. In the casein micelle spectrum, however, the SerP peak was more clearly observed with a phosphate peak that may be from micellar calcium phosphate (MCP). The serum spectrum was the same as skim milk spectrum, except for SerP peak. Furthermore, two types of casein micelle fractions, with 0.90 and 1.04 of [beta-casein + kappa-casein]/[alpha(s1)-casein + alpha(s2)-casein] ratios were generated by different temperature microfiltrations, occurring because beta-casein is released from the micelle at a low temperature. The shape of SerP peaks changed dramatically in both the casein micelle spectra, when the temperature dropped from 35 to 5 degrees C. Deconvolution analysis indicated that each SerP peak comprised the same set of four peaks. Half-width and composition discriminated between the two types of casein micelle fractions. As a consequence, there was significant interaction between casein micelle and milk serum, causing cloudiness of SerP in the liquid-state 31P-NMR spectrum of milk. Casein composition influenced the SerP-MCP interaction in micellar structure. Shape changing of the SerP peak was discussed in connection with beta-casein-release phenomenon.     

Post-secretory aggregation of caseins.

Particles as large as several micrometer diam. have been observed occasionally in normal milk and commonly in prepartum and postpartum colostrum. These particles can be dissociated by EDTA and their appearance closely resembles that of normal casein micelles. However, they are often too large to have been completely formed within the Golgi vesicles of mammary epithelium and hence some degree of post-secretory aggregation of caseins is thought to occur. Two possible mechanisms of post-secretory aggregation of caseins are: (1) a continuation of the normal processes of micelle assembly in the alveolus and (2) aggregation as a result of limited proteolysis of the caseins during the time the milk is in the mammary gland. Incubation of milk with fibrinolysin, however, failed to produce aggregation of normal micelles.