Live-Load Analysis of a Curved I-Girder Bridge

Horizontally curved, steel girder bridges are often used in our modern infrastructural system. The curve in the bridge allows for a smother transition for traffic, which creates better road travel. However, some of the disadvantages of horizontally curved bridges are that they are more difficult to analyze, design, and sometimes construct in comparison to conventional straight bridges. This study focuses on a three-span, curved steel I-girder bridge which was tested under three boundary condition states to determine it’s response to live load. The measured live-load strains were used to calibrate a finite-element model. The finite-element design moments and distribution factors for the three condition states were then compared with the results based on the V-load method. These different boundary conditions provided the researchers a unique opportunity to evaluate the impact that these changes had on the bridges behavior. It was found that while the V-load method produced positive bending moments that were close to the finite-element moments for some of the girders, this was a result of the V-load moment being unconservative and the distribution factor being conservative.     

Roebling Suspension Bridge. II: Ambient Testing and Live-Load Response

This is the second part of a two-part paper on the evaluation of the historic Roebling suspension bridge using dynamic-analysis techniques. Dynamic properties are determined using ambient field testing under natural excitation. The finite-element (FE) model described in the first part of this two-part paper is modified to more accurately represent current bridge properties. Modifications of the model are based on correlating the FE model frequencies with ambient test frequencies by adjusting the FE model stiffness parameters. The updated 3D FE model is subsequently subjected to an extreme live-load condition to evaluate static safety margins. In addition, cable areas are reduced by 10 to 40% to simulate further deterioration and corrosion. The safety margin of the main cables is demonstrated to be good even when assuming a very conservative 40% cable area reduction, and truss member forces remain within the maximum load-carrying capacity even when the cable areas are reduced by 40%.     

Field Investigation of a Sandwich Plate System Bridge Deck

This paper presents the results of a live-load test of the Shenley Bridge, the first bridge application of the sandwich plate system technology in North America. The investigation focused on the evaluation of in-service performance including lateral load distribution behavior and dynamic load allowance. Real-time midspan deflections and strain values were measured under both static and dynamic conditions and under various loading configurations to assess the in-service performance. Distribution factors were determined for interior and exterior girders subjected to single and paired truck loadings. In addition, dynamic load allowance was determined from a comparison of the bridge’s response under static conditions to the response under dynamic conditions. From a comparison of measured results to AASHTO LRFD, AASHTO standard, and CHBDC provisions, it was determined that the current provisions tend to produce conservative predictions for lateral load distribution, but can be unconservative for dynamic load allowance. As a result of the testing program containing a single field test, a finite-element model was also used for determination of lateral load distribution and yielded predictions similar to measured results. The results from the finite-element models were often less conservative than the code provisions.     

Structural Damage Detection Using Dynamic Properties Determined from Laboratory and Field Testing

Studies have shown that experimentally determined dynamic properties can be used to identify the characteristics of a structure. In this paper, a damage detection technique is developed and demonstrated using system identification, finite-element modeling, and a modal update process. The proposed approach, SFM, provides a rapid estimate of damage locations and magnitudes. The proposed methodology is applied to three case studies. The first is a numerical simulation using computer generated data. The second is an ASCE benchmark problem for structural health monitoring, where the results can be compared to other researchers. The third is a full-scale highway bridge that was field tested using a forced vibration shaking machine. In this case study, the bridge was shaken in several states of damage and the proposed methodology was utilized to detect and determine the location and extent of the damage. It was found that, using the collected data, the SFM approach was able to consistently predict the location of damage as well as estimate the magnitude of the damage.     

Live-Load Distribution Factors in Prestressed Concrete Girder Bridges

This paper presents an evaluation of flexural live-load distribution factors for a series of three-span prestressed concrete girder bridges. The response of one bridge, measured during a static live-load test, was used to evaluate the reliability of a finite-element model scheme. Twenty-four variations of this model were then used to evaluate the procedures for computing flexural live-load distribution factors that are embodied in three bridge design codes. The finite-element models were also used to investigate the effects that lifts, intermediate diaphragms, end diaphragms, continuity, skew angle, and load type have on distribution factors. For geometries similar to those considered in the development of the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials Load and Resistance Factor Design Specifications, the distribution factors computed with the finite-element models were within 6% of the code values. However, for the geometry of the bridge that was tested, the discrepancy was 28%. Lifts, end diaphragms, skew angle, and load type significantly decreased the distribution factors, while continuity and intermediate diaphragms had the least effect. If the bridge had been designed using the distribution factors calculated with the finite-element model rather than the code values, the required concrete release strength could have been reduced by 6.9 MPa (1,000 psi) or the live load could have been increased by 39%.     

Model Validation for Bridge-Road-Vehicle Dynamic Interaction System

The dynamic response of highway bridges subjected to moving truckloads has been observed to be dependent on (1) dynamic characteristics of the bridge; (2) truck configuration, speed, and lane position on the bridge; and (3) road surface roughness profile of the bridge and its approach. Historically, truckloads were measured to determine the load spectra for girder bridges. However, truckload measurements are either made for a short period of time [for example, weigh-in-motion (WIM) data] or are statistically biased (for example, weigh stations) and cost prohibitive. The objective of this paper is to present results of a 3D computer-based model for the simulation of multiple trucks on girder bridges. The model is based on the grillage approach and is applied to four steel girder bridges tested under normal truck traffic. Actual truckload data collected using a discrete bridge WIM system are used in the model. The data include axle loads, truck gross weight, axle configuration, and statistical data on multiple presence (side by side or following). The results are presented as a function of the static and dynamic stresses in each girder and compared with code provisions for dynamic load factor. The study provides an alternate method for the development of live-load models for bridge design and evaluation.     

Development of Live-Load Distribution Factors for Glued-Laminated Timber Girder Bridges

This paper presents simple relationships for calculating live-load distribution factors for glued-laminated timber girder bridges with glued-laminated timber deck panels. Analytical models were developed using the Ansys 113 finite-element program, and the results were validated using recorded data from four in-service timber bridges. The effects of the bridge span length, the spacing between girders, and the bridge width on the distribution of the live load were investigated by using the validated models. The live-load distribution factors obtained from the field test and the analytical models were compared with those obtained using the AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specifications2 live-load distribution relations. The comparison showed that the live-load distribution factors obtained by using the AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specifications2 were conservative. For this reason, statistical methods were used to develop accurate relationships that can be used to calculate the live-load distribution factors in the design of glued-laminated girder bridges.     

In-Situ Load Testing of Corrugated Steel Pipe-Arch Culverts

A large number of corrugated metal pipe-arch culverts are located under highways. This study investigates the field performance of four existing pipe-arch culverts under static and dynamic loads. Effects of various parameters were considered in selection of the culverts, including backfill height, loading conditions, age of placement, and culvert geometry. Static loads were applied at ten different locations above each culvert using heavily loaded test trucks. Six dynamic tests were conducted at speeds varying from 8 to 64?km/h. A portable instrumentation frame was installed inside each test culvert to monitor the deflections at five critical locations. During each test, strains were also measured using 14 strain gauges. Test results indicated that culvert response was influenced significantly by the backfill height. Nearly symmetrical deflection patterns were recorded for symmetrical loading about the longitudinal vertical plane through the crown. The maximum static deflections were larger than the maximum dynamic deflections for each culvert.     

Higher Level Evaluation of a Reinforced Concrete Slab Bridge

In New Mexico, many reinforced concrete slab (RCS) bridges provide service on interstates I-10, I-25, and I-40. The load rating for this type of bridge largely depends on the live-load moment in the slab. Consequently, the objective of this study was to determine a more accurate value for the equivalent strip width using higher level evaluation techniques. A continuous RCS bridge was evaluated starting with an AASHTO load and resistance factor rating analysis. A diagnostic test was then conducted to measure live-load strains which showed that the slab stiffness fit within cracked and gross section behavior. Furthermore, slab moments from finite element analysis agreed reasonably well with experimental moments derived using the average of the cracked and gross section modulus. From refined analysis, the equivalent strip widths for positive moment were 26.1 and 22.1% greater than those calculated by the AASHTO approximate method for the exterior and interior spans, respectively. The refined widths for negative moment were greater than AASHTO by 13.1 and 11.1%. This increase in the equivalent strip width reduced the live-load effects, which proportionally increased the rating factors.     

Ambient Vibration Data Analysis for Structural Identification and Global Condition Assessment

System identification is an area which deals with developing mathematical models to characterize the input-output behavior of an unknown system by means of experimental data. Structural health monitoring (SHM) provides the tools and technologies to collect and analyze input and output data to track the structural behavior. One of the most commonly used SHM technologies is dynamic testing. Ambient vibration testing is a practical dynamic testing method especially for large civil structures where input excitation cannot be directly measured. This paper presents a conceptual and reliable methodology for system identification and structural condition assessment using ambient vibration data where input data are not available. The system identification methodology presented in this study is based on the use of complex mode indicator functions (CMIFs) coupled with the random decrement (RD) method to identify the modal parameters from the output only data sets. CMIF is employed for parameter identification from the unscaled multiple-input multiple-output data sets generated using the RD method. For condition assessment, unscaled flexibility and the deflection profiles obtained from the dynamic tests are presented as a conceptual indicator. Laboratory tests on a steel grid and field tests on a long-span bridge were conducted and the dynamic properties identified from these tests are presented. For demonstrating condition assessment, deflected shapes obtained from unscaled flexibility are compared for undamaged and damaged laboratory grid structures. It is shown that structural changes on the steel grid structure are identified by using the unscaled deflected shapes.     

Stiffness Assessment through Modal Analysis of an RC Slab Bridge before and after Strengthening

As part of Main Roads Western Australia’s (MRWA) bridge management and bridge upgrading program, MRWA bridge no. 3014 was assessed to evaluate its condition before and after strengthening works with carbon-fiber-reinforced-polymers (CFRP). The assessment process coupled analytical results with field observations and dynamic testing of the structure. Vibration-based structural assessment of the bridge was conducted before and after the completion of the upgrading works. This paper presents the results of the vibration tests and modal analysis performed before and after the structure upgrading. In particular, the change in the structural properties and stiffness, before and after the strengthening, based on the analyses of the updated models of the bridge, is presented and discussed. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of using the dynamic assessment method to determine the elastic flexural stiffness of bridge structures retrofitted with CFRP.     

Parameter Estimation for Multiple-Input Multiple-Output Modal Analysis of Large Structures

Experimental modal analysis (EMA) has been explored as a technology for condition assessment and damage identification of constructed structures. However, successful EMA applications such as damage detection to constructed systems pose certain difficulties. The properties of constructed systems are influenced by temperature changes as well as other natural influences such as movements in addition to any deterioration and damage. Writers were challenged in their attempts to measure the dynamic properties of an aged bridge by EMA due to inconsistencies within the data set due to short-term variations in ambient conditions. A complex interaction was observed between the dynamic properties of the bridge, hour-to-hour changes in temperature, and controlled damages applied to the bridge. Inconsistencies in the data set made curve fitting difficult for some common parameter estimation algorithms that have been designed to handle consistent data sets. Although the quality of measurements within the entire data set was affected by time variance and nonlinearity, increasing the number of reference measurements significantly improved the reliability of the information which could be extracted. In conjunction with the multiple-input multiple-output technique, a parameter estimation method using complex mode indicator function (CMIF) was developed and implemented in this study to determine the modal properties with proper scaling to obtain modal flexibility. This method proved to be very successful among many others with the data acquired from the aged and deteriorated highway bridge. In this paper, challenges in reliable identification of modal parameters from large structures are reviewed and the new CMIF based algorithm is documented. The method is evaluated on actual bridge data sets from a damage detection research study.     

Dynamic Load Allowance for Through-Truss Bridges

The objective of the present study was to experimentally evaluate the statistics of dynamically induced stress levels in steel through-truss bridges as a function of bridge component type, component peak static stress, vehicle type, and vehicle speed. Better understanding of critical bridge rating parameters will enable more accurate bridge evaluations of this type of structure. Three 60-year-old, steel through-truss bridges with similar characteristics were investigated in the present study. Several bridge components on each of the three bridges were instrumented (truss members, stringers, and floor beams), and dynamic strain data were collected under controlled and normal traffic conditions. The dynamic strain histories were processed to obtain bridge component peak static response and peak dynamic response, resulting in the determination of the dynamic load allowance (DLA) for each of the instrumented bridge components for each of several truck crossings. The calculated DLA value are plotted as a function of member peak static stress for each bridge member instrumented. The DLA data are examined as a function of component type, component location, truck type, number of axles, truck speed, and truck direction. This study has demonstrated that the DLA is dependent on truck location, component location, component type, and component peak static stress but appears to be nearly independent of vehicle speed.     

Assessment of Highway Bridge Upgrading by Dynamic Testing and Finite-Element Model Updating

The Land Transport Authority of Singapore has a continuing program of highway bridge upgrading for refurbishing and strengthening bridges to allow for increasing vehicle traffic and increasing axle loads. One subject of this program has been a short-span bridge taking a busy main road across a coastal inlet near a major port facility. Experiment-based structural assessments of the bridge were conducted before and after upgrading works including strengthening. Each assessment exercise comprised three separate components: (1) a strain and acceleration monitoring exercise lasting approximately one month; (2) a full-scale dynamic test carried out in a single day without closing the bridge; and (3) a finite-element model updating exercise to identify structural parameters and mechanisms. This paper presents the dynamic testing and the modal analysis used to identify the vibration properties and the quantification of the effectiveness of the upgrading through the subsequent model updating. Before and after upgrade, similar sets of vibration modes were identified, resembling those of an orthotropic plate with relatively weak transverse bending stiffness. Conversion of bearings from nominal simple supports to nominal full fixity was shown via model updating to be the principal cause of natural frequency increases of up to 50%. The utility of the combined experimental and analytical process in direct identification of structural properties has been proven, and the procedure can be applied to other structures and their capacity assessments.     

Live-Load Distribution Factors for Prestressed Concrete, Spread Box-Girder Bridge

This study presents an evaluation of shear and moment live-load distribution factors for a new, prestressed concrete, spread box-girder bridge. The shear and moment distribution factors were measured under a live-load test using embedded fiber-optic sensors and used to verify a finite element model. The model was then loaded with the American Association of State Highway and Transportation (AASHTO) design truck. The resulting maximum girder distribution factors were compared to those calculated from both the AASHTO standard specifications and the AASHTO LRFD bridge design specifications. The LRFD specifications predictions of girder distribution factors were accurate to conservative when compared to the finite element model for all distribution factors. The standard specifications predictions of girder distribution factors ranged from highly unconservative to highly conservative when compared to the finite element model. For the study bridge, the LRFD specifications would result in a safe design, though exterior girders would be overdesigned. The standard Specifications, however, would result in an unsafe design for interior girders and overdesigned exterior girders.     

Using Inclinometers to Measure Bridge Deflection

Deflection of a bridge span under designed loads is an important parameter for bridge safety evaluation. However, it is inconvenient to obtain the bridge deflections directly. For bridges over rivers, railways, or highways, a direct measurement method is impractical. A promising bridge deflection measurement method (inclinometer method) is presented in this paper. It offers a simple, practical and inexpensive method of measuring static and dynamic deflections of bridge spans under loads, even for bridge spans that traverse great heights. Hundreds of experiments and practical tests on simple and continuous bridges, utilizing dynamic and static loads, under various vehicle speeds, show that the method has very high precision, which provides an authentic basis for new-built bridge acceptance and old bridge safety evaluation. The method does not need fixed observation positions as other deflection measurement methods because the inclinometers are installed on the bridge directly, which increases measurement efficiency greatly. These features indicate that as a potential method of measuring bridge deflection, inclinometers have significant engineering application value and a promising future.     

Damage Localization and Finite-Element Model Updating Using Multiresponse NDT Data

New techniques for both finite-element model updating and damage localization are presented using multiresponse nondestructive test (NDT) data. A new protocol for combining multiple parameter estimation algorithms for model updating is presented along with an illustrative example. This approach allows for the simultaneous use of both static and modal NDT data to perform model updating at the element level. A new damage index based on multiresponse NDT data is presented for damage localization of structures. This index is based on static and modal strain energy changes in a structure as a result of damage. This method depicts changes in physical properties of each structural element compared to its initial state using NDT data. Deficient or potentially damaged structural elements are then selected as the unknown parameters to be updated by parameter estimation. Error function normalization, error function stacking, and multiresponse parameter estimation methods are proposed for using multiple data types for simultaneous stiffness and mass parameter estimation. Also, multiple sets of measurements with various sizes and missing data points can be utilized. This paper uses a laboratory grid model of a bridge deck built at the University of Cincinnati Infrastructure Institute and the corresponding NDT data for validation of the above damage localization and model updating methods. Multiresponse parameter estimation has been utilized to update the stiffness of bearing pads, and both the stiffness and mass of the connections, using static and dynamic NDT data. The static and modal responses of the updated grid model presented a closer match with the NDT data than the responses from the initial model.     

Nonlinear Analysis of Ordinary Bridges Crossing Fault-Rupture Zones

Rooted in structural dynamics theory, three approximate procedures for estimating seismic demands for bridges crossing fault-rupture zones and deforming into their inelastic range are presented: modal pushover analysis (MPA), linear dynamic analysis, and linear static analysis. These procedures estimate the total seismic demand by superposing peak values of quasi-static and dynamic parts. The peak quasi-static demand in all three procedures is computed by nonlinear static analysis of the bridge subjected to peak values of all support displacements applied simultaneously. In the MPA and the linear dynamic analysis procedures, the peak dynamic demand is estimated by nonlinear static (or pushover) analysis and linear static analysis, respectively, for forces corresponding to the most-dominant mode. In the linear static analysis procedure, the peak dynamic demand is estimated by linear static analysis of the bridge due to lateral forces appropriate for bridges crossing fault-rupture zones. The three approximate procedures are shown to provide estimates of seismic demands that are accurate enough to be useful for practical applications. The linear static analysis procedure, which is much simpler than the other two approximate procedures, is recommended for practical analysis of “ordinary” bridges because it eliminates the need for mode shapes and vibration periods of the bridge.     

Experimental Assessment of Dynamic Responses Induced in Concrete Bridges by Permit Vehicles

Results from experimental testing of three permit vehicles are presented in the paper. The selected heavy vehicles, which require permits from state DOTs, included two tractor-trailer systems and a midsize crane. The vehicles were experimentally tested on popular existing speed bumps and on a representative highway bridge. The selected bridge was a reinforced-concrete structure constructed in 1999, located on the U.S. 90 in Northwest Florida. The bridge approach depression, combined with a distinct joint gap between the asphalt pavement and the concrete deck, triggered significant dynamic responses of the vehicle-bridge system. Similar dynamic vibrations were observed and recorded when the permit vehicles were driven over the speed bumps. Time histories of relative displacements, accelerations, and strains for selected locations on the vehicle-bridge system were recorded. The analysis of experimental data allowed for assessment of actual dynamic interactions between the vehicles and the speed bumps as well as dynamic load allowance factors for the selected bridge.     

Free Out-of-Plane Vibrations of Masonry Walls Strengthened with Composite Materials

The natural frequencies and the out-of-plane vibration modes of one-way masonry walls strengthened with composite materials are studied. Due to the inherent nonlinear behavior of the masonry wall, the dynamic characteristics depend on the level of out-of-plane load (mechanical load or forced out-of-plane deflections) and the resulting cracking, nonlinear behavior of the mortar material, and debonding of the composite system. In order to account for the nonlinearity and the accumulation of damage, a general nonlinear dynamic model of the strengthened wall is developed. The model is mathematically decomposed into a nonlinear static analysis phase, in which the static response and the corresponding residual mechanical properties are determined, and a free vibration analysis phase, in which the dynamic characteristics are determined. The governing nonlinear differential equations of the first phase, the linear differential eigenvalue problem corresponding to the second phase, and the solution strategies are derived. Two numerical examples that examine the capabilities of the model and study the dynamic properties of the strengthened wall are presented. The model is supported and verified through comparison with a step-by-step time integration analysis, and comparison with experimental results of a full-scale strengthened wall under impulse loading. The results show that the strengthening system significantly affects the natural frequencies of the wall, modifies its modes of vibration, and restrains the deterioration of the dynamic properties with the increase of load. The quantification of these effects contributes to the understanding of the performance of damaged strengthened walls under dynamic and seismic loads.