Estimations of creep fracture mechanics parameters for through-thickness cracked cylinders and finite element validation

This paper compares engineering estimation schemes of C* and creep crack opening displacement (COD) for cylinders with circumferential and axial through‐thickness cracks at elevated temperatures with detailed 3D elastic‐creep finite element results. Engineering estimation schemes include the GE/EPRI method; the reference stress (RS) method where the reference stress is defined based on the plastic limit load; and the enhanced reference stress (ERS) method where the reference stress is defined based on the optimised reference load, recently proposed by the authors. Systematic investigations are made not only on the effect of creep‐deformation behaviour on C* and creep COD, but also on effects of the crack location, the cylinder geometry, the crack length and the loading mode. Comparison of the finite element (FE) results with engineering estimations provides that for idealised power law creep, estimated C* and COD rate results from the GE/EPRI method agree best with FE results, suggesting that published plastic influence functions for plastic J and COD for through‐thickness cracked cylinders are reliable. For general creep‐deformation laws where either primary or tertiary creep is important and thus the GE/EPRI method is hard to apply, on the other hand, the ERS method provides more accurate and robust estimations for C* and COD rate than the reference stress method. As these two methods differ only in the definition of the reference stress, the ERS method maintains benefits of the reference stress method in terms of simplicity, but improves accuracy of the estimated J, C* and COD results.     

Improved J and COD estimation by GE/EPRI method in elastic to fully plastic transition zone

It is well known that conventional GE/EPRI method over-estimates the J-integral and crack opening displacement (COD)¹ in the elastic to fully plastic transition zone. The present paper investigates this issue and attempts to rectify this error. An improved GE/EPRI method is proposed with the modifications of α (Ramberg-Osgood coefficient) term in the equation of plastic J and COD. The proposed method has been experimentally and numerically validated.     

C* estimation for cracks in mismatched welds and finite element validation

A C^* integral estimation method is proposed for a crack located in the weld with a mismatch in mechanical properties from the surrounding base material. The method involves the definition of an equivalent stress-creep strain rate (ESCSR) relationship based on the mechanical properties of both the weld and base materials and the geometrical dimension of welding seam. The value of creep fracture mechanics parameter C^*, for the mismatched weldment, is then estimated using the proposed ESCSR in conjunction with the reference stress (RS) method where the reference stress is defined based on the plastic limit load and the GE/EPRI estimation scheme. Referring to the equivalent stress-plastic strain (ESPS) curve in R6 and SINTAP procedures, an approximate solution for the ESCSR relationship has been obtained. Detailed formulae for the compact tension (CT) specimens have been derived on the basis of limit load solutions. Nonlinear finite element analysis of 48 cases with various degrees of mismatch in creep behaviour and different dimension of welding seam has been performed for CT specimens. Overall good agreement between the ESCSR method and the FE results provides confidence in the use of the proposed method in practice.     

Reference Stress Approximations for J and COD of Circumferential Through-Wall Cracked Pipes

Reference stress approximations for the J integral and crack tip opening displacement (COD) for circumferential through-wall cracked pipes under tension and under bending are reported. The proposed J estimation equation is fully compatible with the existing reference stress based J estimation, currently embedded in the R6 assessment procedure, but involves a slightly different definition of the reference stress, using an optimised reference load instead of the limit load. This modification enhances the accuracy of the J estimation for circumferentially cracked pipes. Confidence in the proposed equation is gained from the significantly reduced hardening dependence of the plastic influence functions in the GE/EPRI method. The proposed COD estimation equation includes two further modifications. One is the use of a power-law fit to the plastic portion of the stress strain data, instead of the use of the actual stress strain data. In this context, a robust estimation equation for the strain hardening index is given. The other modification is to the plasticity correction term in contained yielding. A lower bound COD estimation equation is also given, similar to the R6 option 1 Jestimation curve, which is suitable when only limited tensile properties are available. The resulting estimation equations are simple to use. Comparisons with experimental pipe test data show that the proposed COD estimation equations provide overall good agreement, which gives confidence in applying them to Leak-before-Break (LBB) analyses.     

Approximate elastic-plastic J estimates of cylinders with off-centred circumferential through-wall cracks

This paper provides approximate J estimates for off-centred, circumferential through-wall cracks in cylinders under bending and under combined tension and bending. The proposed method is based on the reference stress approach, where the dependence of elastic and plastic influence functions of J on the cylinder/crack geometry, the off-centred angle and strain hardening is minimised through the use of a proper normalising load. Based on published limited FE results for off-centred, circumferential through-wall cracks under bending, such normalising load is found, based on which the reference stress based J estimates are proposed for more general cases, such as for a different cylinder geometry and for combined loading. Comparison of the estimated J with extensive FE J results shows overall good agreements for different crack/cylinder geometries and for combined tension and bending, which provides sufficient confidence in the use of the proposed method for fracture mechanics analyses of off-centred circumferential cracks. Furthermore, the proposed method is simple to use, giving significant merits in practice.     

Quantification of pressure-induced hoop stress effect on fracture analysis of circumferential through-wall cracked pipes

This paper provides engineering J and crack opening displacement (COD) estimation equations for through-wall cracked (TWC) pipes under internal pressure and under combined internal pressure and bending. Based on selected 3-D FE calculations for the TWC pipe under internal pressure using power law materials, elastic and plastic influence functions for fully plastic J and COD solutions are tabulated as a function of the normalised crack length and the mean radius-to-thickness ratio. These developed GE/EPRI-type solutions are then re-formulated based on the reference stress concept. Such re-formulation not only provides simpler equations for J and COD estimation, but also can be easily extended to combined internal pressure and bending. The proposed reference stress based J and COD estimation equations are compared with elastic-plastic 3-D FE results using actual stress-strain data for Type 316 stainless steels. The FE results for both internal pressure cases and combined internal pressure and bending cases compare very well with the proposed J and COD estimates.     

Advances in J‐integral estimation of circumferentially surface cracked pipes

This paper describes enhanced J‐integral estimation schemes for pipes with circumferential semi‐elliptical cracks subjected to tensile loading, global bending and internal pressure. These schemes are given in two different forms to cover the wide ranges of geometries and material parameters; the modified GE/EPRI method and the modified reference stress method. In the former method, new plastic influence functions for fully plastic J‐integral estimation are developed based on extensive three‐dimensional finite element calculations. In the latter method, new optimized reference loads are suggested and utilized to predict the J values. To verify the feasibility of these two schemes, J‐integral values obtained from further detailed FE analyses are compared to those from the proposed schemes. Because the estimated J‐integrals agree fairly well with the detailed FE analysis results, the new solutions can be applied for accurate structural integrity assessment of different size pipes with a circumferential surface crack.     

Mismatch limit loads and approximate <Emphasis Type="Italic">J</Emphasis> estimates for tensile plates with constant-depth surface cracks in the center of welds

The present work provides mismatch limit loads and approximate J estimates for tensile plates with constant-depth, part-through surface cracks in the center of the weld metal. Based on systematic three-dimensional FE limit analyses, effects of strength mismatch related variables on limit loads are firstly quantified by the strength mismatch ratio and one geometry-related parameter. Mismatch limit loads for part-through surface cracks are then correlated to those for two-dimensional, through-wall crack problems. Based on the proposed limit load solutions, the applicability of the reference stress based J estimates is also investigated. When the reference stress is defined by the mismatch limit load, predicted J values agree overall well with FE results.     

Engineering C*‐integral and COD estimates for nonidealized circumferential through‐wall cracked pipes at elevated temperature

In this study, creep fracture mechanics parameters, C^*‐integral and crack opening displacement (COD) rate, are estimated for a nonidealized circumferential through‐wall crack (TWC) in pipes. The GE/EPRI and enhanced reference stress (ERS) methods are employed. As for creep condition, the Norton and RCC‐MRx creep models are considered for secondary and primary‐secondary creep strain, respectively. The bending moment, axial tension, and internal pressure are applied to a pipe with a nonidealized circumferential TWC, as individual loads. Three‐dimensional elastic‐creep finite element (FE) analyses are performed, and the predictions from the GE/EPRI and ERS methods are compared with FE results. For the Norton creep model, both methods show good agreement with the FE results. For the RCC‐MRx creep model, only the ERS method can be used, and it provides accurate predictions comparing with FE results. Based on the comparison results, the use of the present engineering C^*‐integral and COD estimation methods for nonidealized circumferential TWC is validated.     

Approximate J estimates for axial part-through surface-cracked pipes

This paper provides net‐section limit pressures and a reference stress based J estimation method for pipes with constant depth, internal axial surface cracks under internal pressure. Based on systematic small strain finite element (FE) limit analyses using elastic perfectly plastic materials, net‐section limit pressures are firstly determined, and based on FE results, a closed‐form limit pressure solution is proposed. Furthermore, based on the proposed limit pressure solution, a method to estimate elastic–plastic J is proposed based on the reference stress approach. When the reference stress is defined by the proposed (global) limit pressure, estimated J values based on the reference stress approach are overall slightly lower than FE results, implying that the method is non‐conservative. By re‐defining the reference using optimised reference loads, resulting J estimates agree well with FE results.     

Approximate J estimates for tension-loaded plates with semi-elliptical surface cracks

This paper provides a simplified engineering J estimation method for semi-elliptical surface cracked plates in tension, based on the reference stress approach. Note that the essential element of the reference stress approach is the plastic limit load in the definition of the reference stress. However, for surface cracks, the definition of the limit load is ambiguous (“local” or “global” limit load), and thus the most relevant limit load (and thus reference stress) for the J estimation should be determined. In the present work, such limit load solution is found by comparing reference stress based J results with those from extensive 3-D finite element (FE) analyses. Based on the present FE results, the global limit load solution proposed by Goodall for surface cracked plates in combined bending and tension was modified, in the case of tension loading only, to account for a weak dependence on w/c and was defined as the reference normalizing load. Validation of the proposed equation against FE J results based on actual experimental tensile data of a 304 stainless steel shows excellent agreements not only for the J values at the deepest point but also for those at an arbitrary point along the crack front, including at the surface point. Thus the present results provide a good engineering tool for elastic-plastic fracture analyses of surface cracked plates in tension.     

Effect of biaxial loads on elastic-plastic <Emphasis Type="Italic">J</Emphasis> and crack tip constraint for cracked plates: finite element study

Based on detailed two-dimensional (2-D) and three-dimensional (3-D) finite element (FE) analyses, this paper attempts to quantify in-plane and out-of-plane constraint effects on elastic-plastic J and crack tip stresses for a plate with a through-thickness crack and semi-elliptical surface crack under positive biaxial loading. For the plate with a through-thickness crack, plate thickness and relative crack length are systematically varied, whereas for the plate with a semi-elliptical surface crack, the relative crack depth and aspect ratio of the semi-elliptical crack are systematically varied. It is found that the reference stress based approach for uniaxial loading can be applied to estimate J under biaxial loading, provided that the limit load specific to biaxial loading is used, implying that quantification of the biaxiality effect on the limit load is important. Investigation on the effect of biaxiality on the limit load suggests that for relatively thin plates with small cracks, in particular with semi-elliptical surface cracks, the effect of biaxiality on the limit load can be neglected for positive biaxial loading, and thus elastic-plastic J for a biaxially loaded plate could be estimated, assuming that such plate is subject to uniaxial load. Regarding the effect of biaxiality on crack tip stress triaxiality, it is found that such effect is more pronounced for a thicker plate. For plates with semi-elliptical surface cracks, the crack aspect ratio is found to be more important than the relative crack depth, and the effect of biaxiality on crack tip stress triaxiality is found to be more pronounced near the surface points along the crack front.     

Limit loads and approximate J estimates for axial through-wall cracked pipe bends

This paper presents plastic limit loads and approximate J estimates for axial through-wall cracked pipe bends under internal pressure and in-plane bending. These loads and estimates are based on small strain finite element limit analyses using elastic-perfectly plastic materials. Geometric variables associated with the crack and pipe bend are systematically varied, and three possible crack locations (intrados, crown and extrados) are considered. Effects of the bend and crack geometries on plastic limit loads are quantified, and closed-form limit load solutions are given. Based on the proposed limit load solutions, a reference stress based the J estimation scheme for axial through-wall cracked pipe bends under internal pressure and in-plane bending is proposed.     

Surface effects on time-dependent fracture parameter of subsurface crack in plates under tension

Based on the comprehensive finite element (FE) creep analyses, the influence of free surface on the time dependent fracture mechanics parameter of a crack near the free surface in plates under tension has been investigated. It is found that the time dependent fracture parameter C* increases as the crack tip closes to the free surface. Such an increment is related not only to the crack configurations but also to the material properties, especially the creep exponent n of power creep law. In addition, more pronounced interaction is observed between the C* of subsurface crack and that of a single isolated crack compared to that denoted by SIF under the linear elastic fracture condition. Under the framework of reference stress method, we also developed a closed form solution for creep interaction factor. Overall good agreement is achieved between the proposed method for the C* of subsurface crack and the FE results which provides us confidence in practical application.     

Effect of Lüders strain on engineering crack opening displacement estimations for leak-before-break analysis: finite element study

As a companion paper to our previous paper [ Fatigue Fract. Engng Mater. Struct. 24, 243–254], this note provides further validation on the engineering crack opening displacement (COD) estimation equation based on the enhanced reference stress method against three-dimensional, elastic–plastic finite element (FE) results using actual tensile data of three typical ferritic steels exhibiting a wide range of Lüders strain. Furthermore, the resulting FE results are also compared with the GE/EPRI COD predictions. It is found that the proposed enhanced reference stress method gives overall more accurate and robust COD results than the GE/EPRI method, compared with the FE results.     

Issues relating to numerical modelling of creep crack growth

In this paper creep crack growth behaviour of P92 welds at 923 K are presented. Creep crack growth behaviour for P92 welds are discussed with C^* parameter. Creep crack growth behaviour of P92 welds has been compared with that of P91 welds with C^* parameter. NSW and NSW-MOD model were compared with the experimental creep crack growth data. Plane strain NSW model significantly overestimates the crack growth rate, and plane stress NSW model underestimates it. Whilst, NSW-MOD model for plane stress and plane strain conditions gives lower and upper bound of the experimental data, respectively.FE analysis of creep crack growth has been conducted. Constrain effect for welded joints has been examined with C^* line integrals of C(T) specimens. As a result, constant C^* value using the material data of welded joint gives 10 times lower than that of only HAZ property. Whilst, the predicted CCG rates for welded joint are 10 times higher than those for only HAZ properties. Compared with predicted CCG rate from FE analysis and the experimental CCG rate, it can be suggested that creep crack growth tests for lower load level or for large specimen should be conducted, otherwise the experimental data should give unconservative estimation for components operated in long years.     

Creep crack growth simulations in 316H stainless steel

Virtual methods of predicting creep crack growth (CCG), using finite element analysis (FE), are implemented in a compact tension specimen, C(T). The material examined is an austenitic type 316H stainless steel at 550 °C, which exhibits power-law creep–ductile behaviour. A local damage-based approach is used to predict crack propagation and the CCG rate data are correlated with the C^∗ parameter. Two-dimensional elastic–plastic–creep analyses are performed under plane stress and plane strain conditions. Finite element CCG rate predictions are compared to experimental data and to the NSW and modified NSW (NSW–MOD) CCG models’ solutions, which are based on ductility exhaustion arguments. An alternative version of the NSW–MOD model is presented for direct comparison with the FE implementation. The FE predictions are found to be in agreement with the appropriate analytical solutions, and follow the trends of the experimental data at high C^∗ values. Accelerated cracking behaviour is observed experimentally at low C^∗ values, which is consistent with the standard plane strain NSW–MOD prediction. The FE model may be developed to predict this accelerated cracking at low C^∗ values so that the trends between CCG rates at high and low C^∗ values may be determined.     

Interfacial crack-tip constraints and <Emphasis Type="Italic">J</Emphasis>-integral for bi-materials with plastic hardening mismatch

This paper investigates interfacial crack tip stress fields and the J-integral for bi-materials with plastic hardening mismatch via detailed elastic-plastic finite element analyses. For small scale yielding, the modified boundary layer formulation with the elastic T-stress is employed. For fully plastic yielding, plane strain single-edge- cracked specimens under pure bending are considered. Interfacial crack tip stress fields are explained by modified Prandtl slip-line fields. It is found that, for bi-materials consisting of two elastic-plastic materials, increasing plastic hardening mismatch increases both crack-tip stress constraint in the lower hardening material and the J-contribution there. The implication of asymmetric J-integral in bi-materials is also discussed.     

Polymer/metal interfacial crack growth characterized by C*

This paper establishes a simple testing scheme to simultaneously measure the linear elastic strain energy release rate G, the non-linear J-integral, and the rate-dependent C ^*-integral for a growing crack at a polymer/metal interface. The test is applicable to fracture of adhesive bonds. A criterion governing C ^*-controlled fracturing is derived, analogous to the Hutchinson-Paris -criterion for J-controlled growth. The interfacial toughness of an adhesive commonly used for bonding metal plates is characterized at room temperature, and is shown to fracture in a C ^*-controlled manner. A relationship between C ^* and the crack growth rate is observed. The nature of this relationship warrants further exploration.     

Crack opening analysis of complex cracked pipes

Based on the reference stress approach, two sets of the crack opening displacement (COD) estimation equations are proposed for a complex cracked pipe. One set of equations can be used for the case when full stress-strain data are known, and the other for the case when only yield and tensile strengths are available. To define the reference stress, a simple plastic limit analysis for the complex cracked pipe subject to combined bending and tension is performed, considering the crack closure effect in the compressive-stressed region. Comparison with ten published test data and the results from the existing method shows that the present method not only reduces non-conservatism associated with the existing method, but also provides consistent and overall satisfactory results. These results provide sufficient confidence in the use of the present method to estimate the COD (and thus the leak rate) for the Leak-before-Break (LBB) analysis of complex cracked pipes. Finally, the J-estimation equations are also provided for complex cracked pipes, for the LBB analysis of complex cracked pipes.