Mixed-mode fatigue crack growth of thin aluminium panels with single-side repair using experimental and numerical methods

In this paper, experimental and numerical fatigue crack growth of thin aluminium panels containing a central inclined crack of 45° with single-side glass/epoxy composite patch are performed. Effects of patch lay-up configuration on the restarting crack growth (crack re-initiation) life and crack growth rate of the repaired panels are investigated. The obtained experimental results are compared with those predicted using finite element analysis based on both mid-plane and unpatched surface fracture parameters. In the finite elements analyses, it is assumed that the crack-front remains perpendicular to the panel's surfaces during its propagation. It is shown that the finite element crack re-initiation and propagation lives predictions using the unpatched surface results are too conservative. However, the finite element mid-plane results lead to a non-conservative life prediction. It is experimentally shown that, the most effective patch lay-up configurations to retard the crack growth of the repaired panels is [−45/+45]₂; however, the most life extension including the crack propagation cycles belongs to the patch lay-up of [90₄]. It is also shown that using the asymmetric patch lay-up configuration similar to [90₂/0₂] with a proper bonding process may lead to a very slow crack growth rate, even slower than the patch lay-up of [90₄].     

Experimental fatigue crack growth and crack-front shape analysis of asymmetric repaired aluminium panels with glass/epoxy composite patches

In this study, we investigate the experimental fatigue crack-growth behaviour of centrally cracked aluminium panels in mode-I condition which have been repaired with single-side composite patches. It shows that the crack growths non-uniformly from its initial location through the thickness of the single-side repaired panels. The propagated crack-front shapes are preformed for various repaired panels with different patch thicknesses. It is shown that there are considerable differences between the crack-front shapes obtained for thin repaired panels with various patch thicknesses. However, the crack-front shapes of thick repaired panels are not significantly changed with various patch thicknesses. Furthermore, effects of patch thickness on the crack growth life of the repaired panels are investigated for two typical thin and thick panel thicknesses. It shows that the crack growth life of thin panels may increase up to 236% using a 16 layers patch. However, for thick panels, the life may extended about 21–35% using a 4 layers patch, and implementing 8 and 16 layers patches has not a significant effect on the life extension with respect to the 4 layers patch life.     

Numerical and experimental fatigue crack growth analysis in mode-I for repaired aluminum panels using composite material

Crack-front shape is an important parameter influencing the stress intensity factor and crack propagation rate in asymmetric repaired panels. In this study, the numerical and experimental fatigue crack growth behaviour of centrally cracked aluminum panels in mode-I condition repaired with single-side composite patches are investigated. It is shown that the crack growths non-uniformly from its initial location through the thickness of a single-side repaired panel. There is a good agreement between the propagated crack-front shapes obtained from finite element analysis with those obtained from the experiments for various repaired panels with different patch thicknesses. Furthermore, effects of plate and patch thickness on the crack growth life of the repaired panels are investigated. The experimental results show that the crack growth life of thin panels may increase up to 236% using a 16 layers patch. However, for thick panels, the life may extend about 21–35% using a 4 layers patch. Implementing of 8 and 16 layers patches has not a significant effect on the life extension of thick panels with respect to the 4 layers patch life.     

Fatigue Debonding Analysis of Repaired Aluminium Panels by Composite Patch using Interface Elements

Repaired panels with composite patches subjected to fatigue loading may fail due to the progressive debonding between the composite patch and aluminium panel. The objective of this paper is to study the initiation and propagation of a possible fatigue debonding in the adhesive layer while the crack also growths in the panel for single-side repaired aluminium panels. For this purpose three dimensional finite elements method with a thin layer solid like interface element is employed. Fracture mechanics approach is used for the analysis of crack growth in aluminium panel and the interface elements with fatigue constitutive law for mixed mode debonding growth in the adhesive layer. A user element routine and a damage model material routine were developed to include the interface element and to simulate the initiation and propagation of damage in adhesive layer under cyclic loading. It is shown that, the debonding propagation and crack growth rate of the repaired panels depend on the composite patch material and interface bonding properties significantly. It is also shown that using of patch material with higher elastic module leads to the faster damage or debonding growth in the adhesive layer during the fatigue loading.     

Mixed-mode 3-D crack propagation of repaired thin aluminum panels using single-side composite patches

Three dimensional finite element analyses of the single-side repaired panels using glass/epoxy composite are performed considering the general mixed mode conditions and real crack-front shape modeling (RCFM) during the crack propagation procedure. Variations of the fracture parameters through the thickness of the panels for the initial crack configuration and crack growth behavior of the repaired panels with various patch lay-ups are investigated. The effect of considering K _III on the small and large crack growth of repaired panels are also studied. The obtained lives are compared with the previously obtained lives using simplified FEM procedure and experimental results by the authors.     

Finite element fatigue propagation of induced cracks by stiffeners in repaired panels with composite patches

Fatigue crack growth analyses of aluminum panels with stiffeners repaired by composite patches have been rarely investigated. Generally, cracks may occur around the rivets which are capable to propagate under cyclic loadings. A composite patch can be used to stop or retard the crack growth rate. In this investigation, finite element method is used for the crack propagation analyses of stiffened aluminum panels repaired with composite patches. In these analyses, the crack-front can propagate in 3-D general mixed-mode conditions. The incremental 3-D crack growth of the repaired panels is automatically handled by a developed ANSYS Parametric Design Language (APDL) code. Effects of rivets distances and their diameters on the crack growth life of repaired panels are investigated. Moreover, the obtained crack-front shapes at various crack growth steps, crack trajectories, and life of the unrepaired and repaired panels with various glass/epoxy patch lay-ups and various patch thicknesses are discussed.     

Modeling and validation of composite patch repair to cracked thick and thin metallic panels

A two-dimensional finite element analysis is presented to predict crack growth behavior of cracked panels repaired with bonded composite patch. Fatigue experiments were conducted with precracked aluminum specimens of two thicknesses (1 and 6.35 mm), with and without debond, and repaired asymmetrically. Fatigue lives of thick and thin repaired panels extended four and ten times relative to unrepaired cases, respectively. The predicted fatigue crack growth rates were in agreement with experimental values at the unpatched face but not at the patched face. Thus, the present analysis provides a conservative assessment of durability and damage tolerance of repaired thin and thick panels.     

Fatigue crack growth behavior of cracked aluminum plate repaired with composite patch

In this study, we investigated the fatigue crack growth behavior of cracked aluminum plate repaired with bonded composite patch especially in thick plate. Adhesively bonded composite patch repair technique has been successfully applied to military aircraft repair and expanded its application to commercial aircraft industry recently. Also this technique has been expanded its application to the repair of load bearing primary structure from secondary structure repair. Therefore, a through understanding of crack growth behavior of thick panel repaired with bonded composite patch is needed. We investigated the fatigue crack growth behavior of thick panel repaired with bonded composite patch using the stress intensity factor range (ΔK) and fatigue crack growth rate (da/dN). The stress intensity factor of patched crack was determined from experimental result by comparing the crack growth behavior of specimens with and without repair. Also, by considering the three-dimensional (3D) stress state of patch crack, 3D finite element analyses were performed to obtain the stress intensity factor of crack repaired by bonded composite patch. Two types of crack front modeling, i.e. uniform crack front model and skew crack front model, were used. The stress intensity factor calculated using FEM was compared with the experimentally determined values.     

Fatigue crack growth analysis of stiffened cracked panel repaired with bonded composite patch

Fatigue crack growth behavior in a stiffened thin 2024-T3 aluminum panel repaired with one-sided adhesively bonded composite patch was investigated through experiments and analyses. The patch had three plies of unidirectional boron/epoxy composite. 2024-T3 aluminum stiffeners were riveted as well as bonded on the panel. Stiffeners were oriented in the loading direction and were spaced at either 102 mm or 152 mm with a crack centered between them. Also, un-repaired cracked panel with and without stiffeners were studied. Experiment involved tension-tension fatigue at constant amplitude with maximum stress of 120 MPa and stress ratio of 0.05. Bonded composite patch repair increased fatigue life about five-fold in the case of stiffened panels while it increased about ten fold in the case of un-stiffened panels. Fatigue life also increased with decrease of the distance between the stiffeners for both repaired and un-repaired panels. A three-dimensional finite element method was used to analyze the experiments. Residual thermal stresses, developed during patch bonding, requires the knowledge of temperature at which adhesive becomes effective in creating a bond between the structure and patch in the analysis. A simple method to estimate the effective curing temperature range is suggested in this study. The computed stress intensity factor versus measured crack growth relationships for all panel configurations were consistent and in agreement with the counterpart from the test material. Thus, the present approach provides a means to analyze the fatigue crack growth behavior of stiffened structures repaired with adhesively bonded composite patch.     

SIFs of CCT plate repaired with single‐sided composite patch

Constant amplitude load fatigue tests are performed to obtain crack propagation data for LF2‐aluminium centre crack tension (CCT) plates un‐repaired and repaired with single‐sided composite patches. Then, the James–Anderson method, an experimental method, is used to obtain the stress intensity factor (SIF) formula for the repaired CCT plates with carbon–fibre composite patches. At last, crack propagation life prediction and finite element (FE) calculation are carried out to validate the experimental SIF formula. It is shown that the present SIF formula can exactly predict the fatigue‐crack propagation life of the patched CCT plates and is close to the FE results, which implies the effectivity of the experimental SIF formula in the present paper.     

REPAIR EFFICIENCY IN FATIGUE-CRACKED ALUMINIUM COMPONENTS REINFORCED WITH BORON/EPOXY PATCHES

This paper describes studies on fatigue crack propagation in cracked aluminium alloy (2024 T3) panels repaired with boron/epoxy patches, adhesively bonded with either an epoxy-nitrile film adhesive or an acrylic adhesive. Studies were undertaken to assess the effect on patching efficiency of (a) disbonding of the patch system and (b) test temperature. A simple model is proposed for estimating the reduction of patching efficiency due to cyclic disbonding of the reinforcement. In the elevated-temperature tests it was found, unexpectedly, that patching efficiency in panels patched using the film adhesive was unaffected by temperatures up to 100°C.     

Fatigue characteristics of plasma treated aluminium repaired by graphite/epoxy composite patch

Abstract

In the present study, the fatigue behaviour of plasma treated aluminium patched by a graphite/epoxy composite (carbon fibre reinforced plastic, CFRP) has been investigated. The aluminium was surface treated using a dc plasma containing acetylene gas and nitrogen gas at a volume ratio of 5 : 5 for 30 s. The effect of plasma treatment on the fatigue behaviour of the aluminium/CFRP specimen was determined from fatigue testing using two different single edge notched (SEN) specimens of cracked aluminium repaired with a CFRP patch and plasma treated aluminium also repaired with a CFRP patch. The load ratio and the frequency applied in the fatigue tests were 0.1 and 10 Hz, respectively. The surfaces of the aluminium specimens were examined using atomic force microscopy (AFM) to investigate the effect of plasma treatment on the surface morphology. The results showed that plasma treated specimens exhibited almost 12% more fatigue life than untreated specimens. The surface roughness of aluminium was increased ~1.5 times by plasma treatment. The increased surface roughness improved the bonding strength between aluminium and the CFRP patch, increasing the fatigue life of aluminium patched by CFRP.     

Fatigue crack closure analysis of bridged cracks representing composite repairs

This article presents an analytical and numerical study of the fatigue crack‐closure behaviour of a bridged crack representing a crack that has been repaired by a composite patch. It is shown that, provided that the plate stress beneath the patch is less than 40% of the material’s yield stress, the crack‐closure stress of a patched crack is approximately equal to that of an unbridged crack under small‐scale yielding, depending only on the stress ratio. Furthermore, it is shown that the transient crack‐closure behaviour of a patched crack subjected to variable amplitude loading can be determined by analysing an unpatched crack subjected to the same stress intensity factor history. Based on these findings, it is proposed that the fatigue crack closure of a patched crack can be determined by analysing an unpatched centre crack subjected to an adjusted stress, for which an explicit expression is given. Predictions based on the proposed method are shown to correlate very well with experimental results obtained under two aircraft loading spectra.     

Fatigue fracture of embedded copper conductors in multifunctional composite structures

The fatigue failure mechanisms of copper strips embedded into glass/epoxy were investigated. This combination of materials composes a multifunctional electrical-composite load bearing structure that is essential for systems such as large antennas integrated into aircraft skins. In smart structures applications, bulky and heavy wiring harnesses associated with densely deployed sensors, actuators, and devices can be avoided by using embedded electrical interconnects in a manner analogous to printed circuit boards. Since metals generally exhibit lower fatigue life relative to composites, understanding the failure mechanisms associated with embedded metal conductors is necessary for improving operational life. Specimens having 0.127 mm thick embedded copper strips were used to measure fatigue life as a function of copper strain amplitude. Fracture of the conductor was observed for loading below 75% of the composite ultimate strength, without failure of the composite. The fracture surface morphology was composed of a combination of fatigue crack growth and ductile fracture, with a higher percentage of the latter existing for greater load amplitude. Crack growth in the copper was found to be strongly coupled with debonding between the copper and composite. Prevention of debonding directly influences the fatigue life of the embedded copper strip, much in the same way as composite patches retard crack growth in repaired metal structures.     

Numerical simulation study of fatigue crack growth behavior of cracked aluminum panels repaired with a FRP composite patch using combined BEM/FEM

A combined boundary element method and finite element method (BEM/FEM) is employed to investigate the fatigue crack growth behavior of cracked aluminum panels repaired with an adhesively bonded fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite patch. Numerical simulation of crack growth process of a cracked aluminum panel repaired with a FRP composite patch under uniaxial cyclic loading has been carried out. The curve of crack length on unpatched side of the cracked panel versus the number of cyclic loading is determined by the numerical simulation, and it agrees well with experimental data. Furthermore, the crack front profiles of the cracked panel during fatigue crack growth and the distributions of stress intensity factors along crack fronts are also numerically simulated.     

Fatigue behaviour of glass bead filled epoxy

There is a relatively abundant literature on the mechanical properties of particle filled thermosets. Detailed experimental data are available on the effect of variables, such as the filler volume fraction, its surface treatment or shape factor, on the usual properties. In the case of epoxy matrix composites, data have been published on elastic properties. Kinetic studies on thermoplastics, as well as microscopic investigations clearly show that each particle acts as a crack initiation site. The present study deals with thermoset epoxy-glass bead composites. A noticeable advantage of the sphericity of the glass beads over the previously studied mineral fillers is that theoretical calculations, for instance of interparticle average distance, are easier. Some results are reported concerning the eventual role of the geometrical characteristics, including particle diameter, number of particles per volume unit, particle-matrix contact area, interparticle distance, on the fatigue characteristics of the composite as assessed from Paris or Wöhler plots. In addition, quasi-static crack propagation characteristics will be compared with dynamic ones. It is clearly shown that glass beads improved the fatigue crack propagation. Despite this fact, it is also shown that even a small amount of mineral filler, acting as crack initiator, can considerably reduce the fatigue life of epoxy composites.     

Fibre composite repair of cracked metallic aircraft components — practical and basic aspects

Crack patching, the use of advanced fibre composite patches (such as boron/epoxy or graphite/epoxy) bonded with structural film adhesives to repair cracks in metallic aircraft components, is a significant development in aircraft maintenance technology, offering many advantages over conventional repair procedures based on metallic patches and mechanical fasteners. This paper reviews selected theoretical and experimental aspects of Australian work on this topic and describes a preliminary design approach for estimating the minimum thickness patch that could be employed in a given repair situation. Finally, the paper provides a case study on our repair to the wing skin of Mirage III aircraft. Aspects discussed include evaluation of minimum cure and surface treatment conditions for adhesive bonding in repair situations, potential thermal and residual stress problems, resulting from patching, studies on overlap joints representing repairs and crack propagation behaviour in patched panels.     

Hybrid nanoreinforced carbon/epoxy composites for enhanced damage tolerance and fatigue life

Hybrid nano/microcomposites with a nanoparticle reinforced matrix were developed, manufactured, and tested showing significant enhancements in damage tolerance properties. A woven carbon fiber reinforced polymer composite, with the polymer (epoxy) matrix reinforced with well dispersed carbon nanotubes, was produced using dispersant-and-sonication based methods and a wet lay-up process. Various interlaminar damage tolerance properties of this composite, including static strength, fracture toughness, fatigue life, and crack growth rates were examined experimentally and compared with similarly-processed reference material produced without nanoreinforcement. Significant improvements were obtained in interlaminar shear strength (20%), fracture toughness (180%), shear fatigue life (order of magnitude), and fatigue crack growth rate (factor of 2). Observations by scanning electron microscopy of failed specimens showed significant differences in fracture surface morphology between the two materials, related to the differences in properties and providing context for understanding of the enhancement mechanisms.     

Characterization of fatigue crack growth in aluminium panels with a bonded composite patch

This study introduces an analytical procedure to characterize the fatigue crack growth behavior in an aluminium panel repaired with a bonded composite patch. This procedure involves the computation of the stress intensity factor from a two-dimensional finite element method consisting of three layers to model cracked plate, adhesive and composite patch. In this three layer finite element analysis, as recently introduced by the authors, two-dimensional Mindlin plate elements with transverse shear deformation capability are used. The computed stress intensity factor is then compared with the experimental counterpart. The latter was obtained from the measured fatigue crack growth rate of an aluminium panel with a bonded patch by using the power law relationship (Paris Law) of an unpatched aluminum panel. Both a completely bonded patch (with no debond) and a partially bonded patch (with debond) are investigated in this study. This procedure, thus, provides an effective and reliable technique to predict the fatigue life of a repaired structure with a bonded patch, or alternatively, it can be used to design the bonded composite patch configuration to enhance the fatigue life of cracked structure.     

Progressive edge cracked aluminium plate repaired with adhesively bonded composite patch under full width disbond

In this study, the crack growth behaviour of an aluminium plate cracked at the tip and repaired with a bonded boron/epoxy composite patch in the case of full-width disbond was investigated. This effect is the imperfection which could result during the bonded patch of the repaired structure. Disbonds of various sizes and situated at different positions with respect to the crack tip as well as the effect of adhesive and patch thickness on repair performance were examined. An analysis procedure involving the efficient finite element modelling applied to cracked plate, adhesive and composite patch was used to compute the stress intensity factors. The crack growth rate is dominated by the stress intensity factor near the location and size of the pre-existing disbonds. The cracked plate and disbond propagation result in an increase in the patch deformation. The patch does not have an influence on the crack growth when the ratio 2a/d_R exceeds 0.8.