Dynamic modeling and operability analysis of a dual-membrane fixed bed reactor to produce methanol considering catalyst deactivation

The goal of this research is dynamic operability analysis of dual-membrane reactor considering catalyst deactivation to produce methanol. A dynamic heterogeneous one-dimensional model is developed to predict the performance of this configuration. In this configuration, a conventional reactor has been supported by a Pd/Ag membrane tube for hydrogen permeation and alumina–silica composite membrane tube to remove water vapor from the reaction zone. To verify the accuracy of the considered model, the results of conventional reactor are compared with the plant data. The main advantages of the dual-membrane reactor are: higher catalyst activity and lifetime, higher CO₂ conversion and methanol production.     

Application of hydrogen-permselective Pd-based membrane in an industrial single-type methanol reactor in the presence of catalyst deactivation

This work presents application of palladium-based membranes in a conventional single-type methanol reactor. A novel reactor configuration with hydrogen-permselective Pd and Pd–Ag membrane are proposed. In this configuration the reacting synthesis gas is fed to the shell side of reactor while the high pressure product is routed from recycle stream through tubes of the reactor in a co-current mode with reacting gas. The reacting gas is cooled simultaneously with recycle gas in tube and saturated water in outer shell. The permselective palladium layer on inner tube allows hydrogen to penetrate from the tube side to the reaction side. In this work, the results of two types of novel membrane reactors are compared with a conventional methanol synthesis reactor at identical process conditions. Also the effect of key parameters such as membrane thickness, reaction and tube side pressure, ratio of tube side flow rate to reaction side flow rate on performance of reactor are investigated. The steady-state and quasi-steady-state simulations results show that there are favorable profiles of temperature and methanol mole fraction along the reactor in proposed reactor relative to conventional reactor system. Therefore using this novel configuration in industrial single-type methanol reactor improves methanol production rate.     

Application of water vapor and hydrogen-permselective membranes in an industrial fixed-bed reactor for large scale methanol production

Coupling reaction and separation in a membrane reactor improves the reactor efficiency and reduces purification cost in the next stages. In this work a novel reactor consisting two membrane layers has been proposed for simultaneous hydrogen permeation to reaction zone and water vapor removal from reaction zone in the methanol synthesis reactor. In this configuration conventional methanol reactor is supported by a Pd/Ag membrane layer for hydrogen permeation and alumina-silica composite membrane layer for water vapor removal from reaction zone. In this reactor syngas is fed to the reaction zone that is surrounded with hydrogen-permselective membrane tube. The water vapor-permselective membrane tube is placed in the reaction zone. A steady state heterogeneous one-dimensional mathematical model is developed for simulation of the proposed reactor. To verify the accuracy of the model, simulation results of the conventional reactor is compared with the available plant data. The membrane fixed bed reactor benefits are higher methanol production rate, higher quality of outlet product and consequently lower cost in product purification stage. This configuration has enhanced the methanol yield by 10.02% compared with industrial reactor. Experimental proof-of-concept is needed to establish the safe operation of the proposed configuration.     

A Novel Fluidized‐Bed Membrane Dual‐Type Reactor Concept for Methanol Synthesis

A novel fluidized‐bed membrane dual‐type methanol reactor (FBMDMR) concept is proposed in this paper. In this proposed reactor, the cold feed synthesis gas is fed to the tubes of the gas‐cooled reactor and flows in counter‐current mode with a reacting gas mixture in the shell side of the reactor, which is a novel membrane‐assisted fluidized bed. In this way, the synthesis gas is heated by heat of reaction which is produced in the reaction side. Hydrogen can penetrate from the feed synthesis gas side into the reaction side as a result of a hydrogen partial pressure difference between both sides. The outlet synthesis gas from this reactor is fed to tubes of the water‐cooled packed bed reactor and the chemical reaction is initiated by the catalyst. The partially converted gas leaving this reactor is directed into the shell of the gas‐cooled reactor and the reactions are completed in this fluidized‐bed side. This reactor configuration solves some drawbacks observed from the new conventional dual‐type methanol reactor, such as pressure drop, internal mass transfer limitations, radial gradient of concentration, and temperature in the gas‐cooled reactor. The two‐phase theory of fluidization is used to model and simulate the proposed reactor. An industrial dual‐type methanol reactor (IDMR) and a fluidized‐bed dual‐type methanol reactor (FBDMR) are used as a basis for comparison. This comparison shows enhancement in the yield of methanol production in the fluidized‐bed membrane dual‐type methanol reactor (FBMDMR).     

Contribution to emission reduction of CO2 by a fluidized-bed membrane dual-type reactor in methanol synthesis process

In this work, a fluidized-bed membrane dual-type reactor was evaluated for CO₂ removal in methanol synthesis process. The feed synthesis gas is preheated in the tubes of the gas-cooled reactor and flowing in a counter-current mode with reacting gas mixture in the shell side. Due to the hydrogen partial pressure driving force, hydrogen can penetrate from feed synthesis gas into the reaction side through the membrane. The outlet synthesis gas from this reactor is fed to tubes of the water-cooled packed-bed reactor and the chemical reaction is initiated by the catalyst. The methanol-containing gas leaving this reactor is directed into the shell of the gas-cooled reactor and the reactions are completed in this fluidized-bed side. A two-phase dynamic model in bubbling regime of fluidization was developed in the presence of long-term catalyst deactivation. This model is used to compare the removal of CO₂ in a FBMDMR with a conventional dual-type methanol synthesis reactor (CDMR) and a membrane dual-type methanol synthesis reactor (MDMR). The simulation results show a considerable enhancement in the CO₂ conversion due to have a favourable profile of temperature and activity along the fluidized-bed membrane dual-type reactor relative to membrane and conventional dual-type reactor systems.     

Co‐current and Countercurrent Configurations for a Membrane Dual Type Methanol Reactor

A dynamic model for a membrane dual‐type methanol reactor was developed in the presence of catalyst deactivation. This reactor is a shell and tube type where the first reactor is cooled with cooling water and the second one with feed synthesis gas. In this reactor system, the wall of the tubes in the gas‐cooled reactor is covered with a palladium‐silver membrane which is only permeable to hydrogen. Hydrogen can penetrate from the feed synthesis gas side into the reaction side due to the hydrogen partial pressure driving force. Hydrogen permeation through the membrane shifts the reaction towards the product side according to the thermodynamic equilibrium. Moreover, the performance of the reactor was investigated when the reaction gas side and feed gas side streams are continuously either co‐current or countercurrent. Comparison between co‐current and countercurrent mode in terms of temperature, activity, methanol production rate as well as permeation rate of hydrogen through the membrane shows that the reactor in co‐current configuration operates with lower conversion and also lower permeation rate of hydrogen but with longer catalyst life than does the reactor in countercurrent configuration.     

A fluidized bed membrane reactor for the steam reforming of methane

In the present investigation a realistic two-phase model accounting for the change in the total number of moles accompanying the reaction is utilized to explore a novel reactor configuration suggested for the methane steam reforming process. The suggested design is basically a fluidized bed reactor equipped with a bundle of membrane tubes. These tubes remove the main product, hydrogen, from the reacting gas mixture and drive the reaction beyond its thermodynamic equilibrium. The proposed novel design is also equipped with sodium heat pipes which act as a thermal flux transformer to provide the large amount of heat needed by the endothermic reaction through a relatively small heat transfer surface, assuring better reactor compactness. Two options for fluid routing through the membrane tubes are proposed; each is suitable for a certain industrial application. The performance of this novel configuration is compared with that of an industrial fixed bed steam reformer and the comparison shows the potential advantages of the suggested configuration.     

Dynamic simulation of a cascade fluidized-bed membrane reactor in the presence of long-term catalyst deactivation for methanol synthesis

In this work, a dynamic model for a cascade fluidized-bed hydrogen permselective membrane methanol reactor (CFBMMR) has been developed in the presence of long-term catalyst deactivation. In the first catalyst bed, the synthesis gas is partly converted to methanol in a water-cooled reactor, which is a fluidized-bed. In the second bed, which is a membrane assisted fluidized-bed reactor, the reaction heat is used to preheat the feed gas to the first bed. This reactor configuration solves some observed drawbacks of new conventional dual type methanol reactor (CDMR) and even fluidized-bed membrane dual type methanol reactor (FBMDMR) such as pressure drop, internal mass transfer limitations, radial gradient of concentration and temperature in both reactors. A dynamic two-phase theory in bubbling regime of fluidization is used to model and simulate the proposed reactor. The proposed model has been used to compare the performance of a cascade fluidized-bed membrane methanol reactor with fluidized-bed membrane dual-type methanol reactor and conventional dual-type methanol reactor. The simulation results show a considerable enhancement in the methanol production due to the favorable profile of temperature and activity along the CFBMMR relative to FBMDMR and CDMR systems.     

Dynamic optimization of membrane dual-type methanol reactor in the presence of catalyst deactivation using genetic algorithm

This paper presents a study on optimization of a membrane dual-type methanol reactor in the presence of catalyst deactivation. A theoretical investigation has been performed in order to evaluate the optimal operating conditions and enhancement of methanol production in a membrane dual-type methanol reactor. A mathematical heterogeneous model has been used to simulate and compare the membrane dual-type methanol reactor with conventional methanol reactor. An auto-thermal dual-type methanol reactor is a shell and tube heat exchanger reactor which the first reactor is cooled with cooling water and the second one is cooled with synthesis gas. In a membrane dual-type reactor the wall of the tubes in the gas-cooled reactor is covered with a pd–Ag membrane, which is only hydrogen-permselective. The simulation results have been shown that there are optimum values of reacting gas and coolants temperatures to maximize the overall methanol production. Here, genetic algorithms have been used as powerful methods for optimization of complex problems. In this study, the optimization of the reactor has been investigated in two approaches. In the first approach, the optimal temperature profile along the reactor has been studied and then a stepwise approach has been followed to determine the optimal profiles for saturated water and gas temperatures in three steps during the time of operations to maximize the methanol production rate. The optimization methods have enhanced 5.14% and 5.95% additional yield throughout 4 years of catalyst lifetime for first and second optimization approaches, respectively.     

Enhancement of Methanol Production in a Membrane Dual‐Type Reactor

In this study, a dynamic model for a membrane dual‐type methanol reactor was developed in the presence of long term catalyst deactivation. The proposed model is used to compare the performance of a membrane dual‐type methanol reactor with a conventional dual‐type methanol reactor. A conventional dual‐type methanol reactor is a shell and tube heat exchanger reactor in which the first reactor is cooled with cooling water and the second one is cooled with synthesis gas. In a membrane dual‐type reactor, the wall of the tubes in the gas‐cooled conventional reactor is covered with a palladium‐silver membrane, which is only permeable to hydrogen. Hydrogen can penetrate from the feed synthesis gas side into the reaction side due to the hydrogen partial pressure driving force. Hydrogen permeation through the membrane shifts the reaction towards the product side according to the thermodynamic equilibrium. The proposed dynamic model was validated against measured daily process data of a methanol plant recorded for a period of four years and a good agreement was achieved. The simulation results show that there is a favorable profile of temperature and activity of the membrane dual‐type reactor relative to single and conventional dual‐type reactor systems. Therefore, the performance of methanol reactor systems improves when a membrane is used in a conventional dual‐type methanol reactor.     

Selective Oxidation of Methanol to Green Oxygenates – Feasibility Study of Fixed-Bed and Membrane Reactors

A feasibility study of a conventional fixed-bed reactor and a packed-bed membrane reactor (PBMR) in distributor configuration is carried out for the selective oxidation of methanol to the oxygenates dimethoxymethane and methyl formate on a VO_x/TiO₂ catalyst. Kinetic experiments provided the reaction network and a reliable kinetic model of six main reactions involved. The PBMR offers significant advantages and potential for the formation of both target products due to an effective kinetic coupling of the oxidative dehydrogenation of methanol and the consecutive reaction steps to dimethoxymethane and methyl formate in a broad range of operation conditions.     

Theoretical Investigation of a Pd‐membrane Reactor for Methanol Synthesis

A numerical study is performed in order to evaluate the performance and optimal operating conditions of a palladium membrane reactor for methanol synthesis. A novel reactor configuration with a Pd wall, which is perm‐selective to hydrogen, has been proposed. In this configuration the reactants are added to the tube side while pure hydrogen is added to the shell side, as a result, the hydrogen diffuses across the membrane from the shell side to the tube side. In this membrane reactor, hydrogen penetrates to the reaction side in order to maintain a suitable hydrogen level in the whole length of the reactor and shift the equilibrium reaction. The effects of different parameters on the methanol output mole fraction were investigated in the co‐current mode. These parameters were membrane thickness, reaction side flow rate, reaction side pressure, shell side pressure and H₂/CO₂ ratio in the feed.     

双膜组件及耦合工艺的研究与应用进展

气体膜分离技术受到工业化膜材料性能的限制，往往不能同时达到生产过程对选择性和渗透性的要求。双膜组件是将两种气体渗透性能不同甚至相反的膜材料集成到一个组件中，可以很好地弥补膜材料自身选择性差以及渗透速率低的缺陷。首先介绍了双膜组件的研究进展，回顾了双膜组件从产生到发展几个主要研究团队的贡献。随后，介绍了双膜组件强化传质和分离的特点，展示了双膜组件降低膜两侧浓差极化的基本原理，分析了流动形式对组件分离效率的影响。接着借助实例对基于双膜组件的双膜+吸收、双膜+反应和双膜+冷凝+精馏的3种耦合流程工艺进行了详细阐述。最后对双膜组件的研究和工业应用进行了展望，指出通过与其他分离方法进行耦合双膜组件在石油化工、天然气工业等领域已经显现出一定的潜力和独特的优越性，提出双膜组件的研究还处于发展阶段，需要加强膜组件分离序列及操作条件方面的实验研究。     

A comparison of co-current and counter-current modes of operation for a novel hydrogen-permselective membrane dual-type FTS reactor in GTL technology

In this work, a comparison of co-current and counter-current modes of operation for a novel hydrogen-permselective membrane reactor for Fischer-Tropsch Synthesis (FTS) has been carried out. In both modes of operations, a system with two-catalyst bed instead of one single catalyst bed is developed for FTS reactions. In the first catalytic reactor, the synthesis gas is partly converted to products in a conventional water-cooled fixed-bed reactor, while in the second reactor which is a membrane fixed-bed reactor, the FTS reactions are completed and heat of reaction is used to preheat the feed synthesis gas to the first reactor. In the co-current mode, feed gas is entered into the tubes of the second reactor in the same direction with the reacting gas stream in shell side while in the counter-current mode the gas streams are in the opposite direction. Simulation results for both co-current and counter-current modes have been compared in terms of temperature, gasoline and CO₂ yields, H₂ and CO conversion, selectivity of components as well as permeation rate of hydrogen through the membrane. The results showed that the reactor in the co-current configuration operates with lower conversion and lower permeation rate of hydrogen, but it has more favorable profile of temperature. The counter-current mode of operation decreases undesired products such as CO₂ and CH₄ and also produces more gasoline.     

Methanol synthesis in a novel axial-flow, spherical packed bed reactor in the presence of catalyst deactivation

Since in the foreseeable future liquid hydrocarbon fuels will play a significant role in the transportation sector, methanol might be used potentially as a cleaner and more reliable fuel than the petrochemical-based fuels in the future. Consequently, enhancement of methanol production technology attracts increasing attention and, therefore, several studies for developing new methanol synthesis reactors have been conducted worldwide. The purpose of this research is to reduce the pressure drop and recompression costs through the conventional single-stage methanol reactor. To reach this goal, a novel axial-flow spherical packed bed reactor (AF-SPBR) for methanol synthesis in the presence of catalyst deactivation is developed. In this configuration, the reactor is loaded with the same amount of catalyst in the conventional single-stage methanol reactor. The reactants are flowing axially through the reactor. The dynamic simulation of the spherical reactors has been studied in the presence of long-term catalyst deactivation for four reactor configurations and the results are compared with the achieved results of the conventional tubular packed bed reactor (CR). The results show that the three and four stages reactor setups can improve the methanol production rate by 4.4% and 7.7% for steady state condition. By utilizing the spherical reactors, some drawbacks of the conventional methanol synthesis reactors such as high pressure drop, would be solved. This research shows how this new configuration can be useful and beneficial in the methanol synthesis process.     

A comparative study of two different configurations for exothermic–endothermic heat exchanger reactor

The coupling of the energy intensive endothermic reaction systems with appropriate exothermic reactions reduces the size of the reactors and can improve the thermal efficiency of processes. One type of a suitable reactor for such a kind of coupling is the heat exchanger reactor. In this study, the catalytic methanol synthesis is coupled with the catalytic dehydrogenation of cyclohexane to benzene in an integrated reactor formed from two fixed beds separated by a wall where heat is transferred across the surface of the tube. A steady-state heterogeneous model of the two fixed beds predicts the performance of the two different configurations of the thermally coupled reactor. The co-current mode is investigated and the simulation results are compared with the corresponding predictions for the industrial methanol fixed bed reactor operating in the same feed conditions. The results of the study reveal that should the exothermic and endothermic reactions be located in the shell side and tube side, respectively, the methanol production rate will increase in comparison with the conventional methanol synthesis reactor as well as the case where the exothermic reaction is located in the tube side and endothermic reaction in the shell side.     

Economic feasibility of silica and palladium composite membranes for industrial dehydrogenation reactions

This article addresses the economic feasibility of silica and palladium composite membranes for gaseous dehydrogenation reaction schemes. Unlike other methodologies addressed so far, this work presents the economic assessment of dehydrogenation reaction schemes using a conceptual design based simulation methodology for the comparative economic assessment of membrane reactors with conventional reactors. The suggested methodology is applied to two industrially prominent reaction schemes namely styrene (from ethylbenzene) and propylene (from propane) production using silica and palladium composite membrane reactors. Various sub-cases studied in this work include the influence of membrane area per reaction zone volume, reaction zone temperature, reaction and permeation zone pressure, membrane thickness and sweep gas flow rate on process economics. Based on this work, the propylene production scheme is evaluated to provide 60–70% excess profits using membrane reactors when compared with the conventional reactor based technology. However, the gross profit profiles for both conventional reactor and membrane reactor configurations have been found to be similar for styrene production case. For all cases, the cost contribution of membranes and other auxiliary equipment is estimated not to exceed 20% of the total costs. In addition, similar economic performance has been observed for both silica and palladium membranes. Based on these studies, it has been concluded that the industrial applicability of membrane reactors is economically suitable for those dehydrogenation reactions that enable significant conversion enhancement with respect to the conventional reactor technologies.     

Sustainable Dimethyl Carbonate Production from Ethylene Oxide and Methanol

A large-scale dimethyl carbonate (DMC) production process from ethylene oxide (EO), CO₂, and methanol was simulated and optimized. Unlike most industrial processes of DMC production, the direct conversion of EO and CO₂ to ethylene carbonate (EC) and EC transesterification to DMC were performed in a single reactor. The reaction volume and the reactor operating pressure were selected as decision variables and evaluated. The key performance parameters, e.g., conversion per pass and CO₂ intensity, were compared with conventional commercialized routes or novel promising processes in the literature.     

Modeling of a novel membrane reactor to integrate dehydrogenation of ethylbenzene to styrene with hydrogenation of nitrobenzene to aniline

The catalytic dehydrogenation of ethylbenzene to styrene is coupled with the catalytic hydrogenation of nitrobenzene to aniline in a simulated integrated reactor formed of two fixed beds separated by a hydrogen-selective membrane, where both hydrogen and heat are transferred across the surface of membrane tubes. A pseudo-homogeneous model of the two fixed beds predicts the performance of this novel configuration first proposed by Moustafa and Elnashaie [Simultaneous production of styrene and cyclohexane in an integrated membrane reactor. Journal of Membrane Science 178 (1), 171-184]. Both co-current and counter-current operating modes are investigated and the simulation results are compared with corresponding predictions for an industrial adiabatic fixed bed reactor operated at the same feed conditions. The conversion of ethylbenzene and the yield of styrene in the membrane reactor are predicted to exceed by a wide margin those in the industrial adiabatic fixed bed reactor. Aniline is also produced as an additional valuable product in a favorable manner, and autothermality is achieved within the reactor. The results suggest that coupling of these reactions could be feasible and beneficial. Experimental proof-of-concept is needed to establish the validity and safe operation of the novel reactor.     

Dual-membrane reactor for methane oxidative coupling and dry methane reforming: Reactor integration and process intensification

A novel dual-membrane reactor concept was introduced for integrating the oxidative coupling of methane (OCM) and CO₂ methane reforming (dry reforming) reactors. The OCM reactions occur in a conventional porous packed bed membrane reactor structure and a portion of the undesired produced CO₂ and generated heat are transferred through a molten-carbonate perm-selective membrane and consumed in the adjacent dry methane reforming catalytic bed. This integrated reactor provides a very promising thermal performance by controlling the temperature peak to be below 50 °C in reference to the average operating temperature in the OCM section. This was achieved even for the low methane-to-oxygen ratio 2 by introducing 10% CO₂ as the diluent agent and reactant in this integrated reactor structure. This contributed to the improved selective performance of 32% methane conversion and 25% C₂-yield including 21% C₂H₄-yield in the OCM section which also enhances the performance of the downstream units consequently. Around half of the unconverted methane leaving the OCM section was converted to syngas in the DRM section.The dual-membrane reactor alone can utilize a significant amount of the carbon dioxide generated in the OCM catalytic bed. In combination with adsorption unit in the downstream of the integrated process, 90% of the produced CO₂ can be recovered and further converted to valuable syngas products. The experimental data, obtained from a mini-plant scale experimental facility, were exploited to verify the performance of the OCM reactor and the CO₂ separation section.